ACEA S.p.A. (ACE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 9, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. I'm the conference operator from Chorus Call. Welcome, and thank you for being with us for the 2019 results of the ACEA Group. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'd like to hand the conference over to Ms. Angrisani, who serves as IR manager of ACEA.
Elvira Angrisani
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thank you so much for joining the conference call where we present the ACEA Group's results as at 31 December 2019. Mr. Donnarumma and Mr. Gola will give the presentation, after which we'll have a Q&A session. Stefano, the floor is yours.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveGood afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you so much for joining the conference call. As you know, we held the Board of Directors meeting this morning. This is essentially the final Board of Directors meeting of this mandate. So until the shareholders' meeting on the 28th of April, no meetings will take place unless extraordinary board meetings are called, which we do not anticipate at this point. We approved the 2019 figures, and we summarized the trend and the performance of the past 3 years, which were very satisfactory and very positive for all of us. So I'll begin with the stock price on Page 2 of the presentation, and here you can see the share price, which has reached historically unprecedented levels. I mean, we have to go back 20 years ago to see such a price, but we were not listed back then. And in 2019, this share price rose by 53.5%. And over the past 3 years, we went up by 38.6%. The EBITDA is above EUR 1 billion, EUR 1.42 billion. This is the objective that we achieved and that we set for ourselves. So we're very happy with this result because the results are very sound.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveFor the entire period, growth has stayed in double digits. As you can see, it moved from EUR 840 million up to EUR 1.42 billion. CapEx is rising by roughly EUR 800 million. Right now, among the utilities putting more money into Italy, we are one of them. Our focus is strongly on regulated business infrastructures. A lot of these investments relate to water and to the energy or electricity sector. In addition, we hold some investments in the waste treatment business. The debt/EBITDA ratio sits below 3. That, as you can see, was one of the targets in our business plan. And we feel very satisfied about it, because when we compare it with the investments we made, well, the debt/EBITDA ratio shows the company is well managed. As you can also see, net working capital is very, very satisfactory. Between 2019 and 2017 there is a difference of some EUR 100 million. That comes from very strong financial control. Let's move to Page 3 now, and we'll carry on with the presentation. On the 2nd of April 2019, we presented the new business plan 2019-2022. And if you consider that the business plan set the following target, which was EUR 900 million of -- EUR 972 million of EBITDA, and we reached EUR 1.42 billion, that means we succeeded in hitting our goals.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveWe also went back over our targets 1 year ago, and that was for this reason—because performance has been good. At this point, though, we need to evaluate the company's fundamentals, and those are very sound. We also chose to tie practical, sustainable goals to those fundamentals. I've said many times that this company is in fact sustainable. We run the water business and water resources with special care for where the water comes from. Take energy—the power distribution at, for instance, the Roman plant: we've worked to cut dispersion, the loss of power, and we put the emphasis on resilience. On waste management, we're concentrating more and more on this killer economy. So all of our businesses line up with the sustainable goals. Those sustainable goals are also part of our managers' bonuses. As for the evolving business mix, well, that has improved. The company's management team decided to review the composition, or the weight, of the different businesses, and we've moved increasingly and progressively into gas distribution, and then we've grown the waste management capability. When we began, we had some—little capability to manage 800,000, 900,000 tonnes a year.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveAt this point, we exceed 2 million tonnes per year in waste management. That means our growth is organic. We're putting money into our plants, and as a result, our company ranks among the top 3, 4 utilities in Italy. We also invested in photovoltaic plants within renewable energies, and that is definitely ensuring our company stands among those favoring the so-called energy transition process, favoring renewable sources of energy, which will carry on over the next few years. Turning to Page 4, you'll find the financial highlights. Revenues are rising, as you can see. That's also because tariffs in the regulated business have increased. EBITDA is up 11.7%, and the group net profit is quite substantial with no one-offs in there. There's just one fee that the antitrust authority canceled. But as you can see, group net profit now stands at EUR 284 million, up 4.7% against the prior year. And we consolidated Gori. So you have to keep in mind that, with Gori consolidated, the gap between this year and last year — or 2018 (sic) 2019 versus 2018 — is definitely larger.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveCapital expenditures rose 25.7%, driven primarily by our regulated operations — segments that are expanding — while net debt to EBITDA sits under 3, which tells you the company is financially solid and in very good shape. At the bottom of the page you'll find our 2020 guidance. We expect EBITDA to increase 6% to 8% compared with 2019, consistent with the CAGR in the 2019-2022 business plan. CapEx should come in broadly at the same level as 2019. Investment peaked in 2019, and we'll likely repeat that in 2020, though it remains consistent with the business plan's CapEx. Net debt, meanwhile, will land somewhere between EUR 3.45 billion and EUR 3.55 billion. With that said, I'd now like to hand things over to Mr. Gola, our CFO, who will begin walking through the data starting on Page 5 and will also help me out during the Q&A session.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveThanks, Stefano, and good afternoon, everyone — welcome. Now let’s go through the details of how we performed. EBITDA for 2019 was EUR 1.42 billion, with 82% of that coming from regulated businesses — so water and energy infrastructure — and 19% from nonregulated business, meaning commercial and trading plus the environmental businesses. The water business makes up 48% of total EBITDA; energy infrastructure, 37%; commercial and trading, 7%; environment, 5%. Now, looking at how the different businesses grew, starting from 2018 EBITDA: water grew by EUR 72 million — not just from organic growth of the business, but from full consolidation of Gori and the partial consolidation at the end of 2018 of del Fiora — and then energy infrastructure by EUR 31 million. That reflects the regulated business, but also the development of the photovoltaic business, which had some effects in 2019. Commercial and trading is down by EUR 7 million because of the decrease here over the regulated tariffs. Environment, minus EUR 13.6 million because of the end of the CIP6 incentive, and the other businesses have limited effect. Other here also includes the fine that was paid.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveAnd — sorry, we — apologies, that item was cancelled, and it ended up benefiting our P&L. So here you can see another EUR 24 million. On this slide, the table on the right shows the 2018 and 2019 impact. Gori: EUR 14.7 million in 2018 and EUR 68 million in 2019. After that came the Pescara Distribuzione Gas acquisition, the Fotovoltaico acquisition, and then Demap plus the Berg — the 2 waste management plants. Now let's go through the different businesses. Water business, Page 6. EBITDA of EUR 505 million, up by almost 17% compared with 2018. That growth, as you can see, comes not just from consolidating companies and from the growth of ATO5. ATO2 has stayed almost flat. We had some nonrecurrent positive one-offs that we consolidated in 2018. And on the key highlights here, we have the line-by-line consolidation of Acquedotto del Fiora, and in March 2019, the acquisition of Pescara Distribuzione Gas. CapEx is rising from EUR 380 million thanks to the consolidation of Gori and partly of the Fiora Acquedotto. As for the companies consolidated at net profit, here you have Gori and del Fiora exiting that consolidation — they weren't there in 2018; del Fiora is only partly present in 2019, and Gori is no longer included.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveMoving on to energy infrastructure, EBITDA came in at EUR 392 million, compared with EUR 360 million in 2018 — an increase of nearly 9%. That is almost entirely driven by expansion in distribution, meaning the regulated side of the business, which posted EUR 345.4 million against EUR 317 million. On generation: that segment contributed positively thanks to the photovoltaic business, which delivered EUR 3.6 million. Generation is therefore declining somewhat, since in 2018 we recorded EUR 5 million tied to a one-off item. Now let's turn to commercial and trading on the next page. EBITDA was just under EUR 70 million, a drop of 9.2% from the prior year. The main reason is margin compression resulting from the revision of the RCV component tariff. Even so, as the key highlights show, this business is expanding. Its customer count is rising year over year. You can see that from 1,185 (sic) 1,177 customers, the figure rose to 1,177 (sic) 1,185. Total gas customers are up as well, by close to 11%. What matters here is how credit management is performing, which we should see later when we look at net working capital.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveCredit performance has improved. Unpaid credit rose 1.6% compared with the prior year. Then, moving along, there's the environment business, which is closing EBITDA with — an EBITDA of EUR 52 million against EUR 65 million in 2018. That decrease stems from the reduction or the ending of CIP6 incentives, which from August 2019 we no longer have, minus EUR 16.7 million, but we do have the impact of the Demap and Berg acquisitions. Regarding waste treatment, we surpassed 1.2 million tonnes in 2019, with 327 gigawatt-hour of electricity sold. On Page 10, you can see the items below EBITDA. EBIT came to EUR 518 million, up 8.3% versus 2018, and net profit reached EUR 284 million, up roughly 5% on the previous year. As for net profit, as Stefano already pointed out, it's worth bearing in mind that this figure has been normalized. If you take into account that in 2018 and in 2019, this item is net of — because we had a net of certain nonrecurring items. In 2018, to be precise, we had the provision for Gori that was released, amounting to EUR 44.2 million, then we had roughly EUR 9 million for the TWS gain, and then we added the negative impact of the antitrust fine of roughly EUR 16 million.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveNormalized 2018 results came in at EUR 234 million, compared with EUR 271 million. Then in 2019 we again had 2 nonrecurring items: the cancellation of the antitrust fine, roughly EUR 16 million, and the release of the provision tied to Gala, since the resolution ARERA adopted in December let us release a provision of approximately EUR 12 million, which has a net impact, after tax, of about EUR 9 million. That makes normalized net-net profit for 2019 approximately EUR 258 million, 10% higher than the normalized figure for 2018. Turning to the dividend history and the dividend we will propose to the general shareholders' meeting, we are submitting EUR 0.78 per share, for a total of EUR 166 million, with a dividend yield of 4.7% based on the average stock value in 2019 and a dividend payout, excluding minorities, of 59%, which is fully consistent with the guidance we gave when we presented the business plan, the new business plan. We had announced EUR 0.75 as a minimum dividend, and it is EUR 0.78 that we are submitting to this year's general shareholders' meeting, thanks to the good performance we were able to report in 2019.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveLooking at Page 11, capital expenditures rose significantly compared with the prior year, hitting EUR 793 million. Several items drove that increase. On water, CapEx came in EUR 50 million higher, largely because of consolidating Gori assets, which accounted for EUR 44 million — that's the difference we had to factor in — plus EUR 11 million from consolidating del Fiora Acquedotto. We also made sizable investments in repairing and widening water and sewage pipes, in extraordinary maintenance of water centers, and in work on treatment plants. Turning to energy infrastructure, investments were up by about EUR 50 million — 5-0 — again, chiefly to upgrade, improve and expand the grid. We then put money into the resilience plan, concentrating on secondary substations and the mid-voltage and low-voltage network. Funding also went to revamping the Mandela hydroelectric plant along with the Tor di Valle and Montemartini thermoelectric plants. On the commercial and trading side, investment increased to upgrade our system and bring in new customers. On environment, we opened the Monterotondo Marittimo plant in October 2019 and expanded the Orvieto landfill. The remaining investments relate to a corporate IT project of approximately EUR 23.5 million.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveThe next page shows how cash flow changed in 2019 versus 2018. EBITDA for 2019 came to EUR 1.042 billion. Working capital rose by EUR 16 million, against EUR 35 million in 2018, as Stefano already noted, and against EUR 115 million in 2017 — which offers some evidence that we succeeded in bettering how we manage receivables. So cash-ins stayed flat this year, yet we did manage to better the cash-ins at Acea Energia, which lifted cash-ins by about EUR 50 million, 5-0. Regarding the absorption of working capital, it deserves a mention that, because of regulation — meaning both water and electricity — revenues that get cashed in during the following year or the following 2 years produced a negative impact of EUR 41 million. Net of that effect, we can state that net working capital generated cash of roughly EUR 25 million this year, and that is the first time, at least in ACEA's recent history. But returning to the cash flow: our free cash flow net of CapEx generated cash of EUR 233 million, net finance charges came to EUR 90 million, and the change in provisions was EUR 107 million.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveAnd here, obviously, the gain at Acea Energia is being offset by the broad business scope that comes with consolidations; income tax paid came to EUR 134 million, far above the prior year, reflecting greater net profit in 2018, and we made tax payments during 2019. Dividends totaling EUR 151 million were paid in 2019 against the 2018 results. Next comes M&A and consolidation activity. And there the effect is considerably larger owing to the change in the IFRS accounting principle. We then have EUR 50 million, which is a noncash effect arising from consolidating Acquedotto del Fiora. So roughly EUR 80 million relates to M&A activity, while the IFRS 16 impact is noncash and comes to EUR 64 million, as already noted. Taken together, this produces a rise in net debt of EUR 495 million. On the next page you can see the complete picture. Net debt therefore stands at EUR 3.62 billion, but excluding noncash items and the M&A activity that had not been included in our guidance, as we have consistently noted, we have EUR 2.826 billion of adjusted net debt, which sits below the minimum range -- the level of the range we disclosed last year.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveOn net debt/EBITDA, Stefano mentioned it earlier — it stands at 2.9x. Turning to how our debt is structured, 81% carries a fixed rate. Back in May 2019, we issued a bond of EUR 500 million. Then in 2020, we brought another bond of EUR 500 million, with a 9-year maturity and a fixed rate of 1.75%. That puts the total cost at 2.19% across a 3-year period. On ratings: Fitch Ratings gives us BBB+ with a stable outlook, and Moody's has us at Baa2, stable outlook. That covers what I wanted to say. And I'm — we're ready to take your questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Javier Suarez at Mediobanca.
Javier Suárez Hernández
analystI have 3 questions. The first one has to do with working capital. The company's efforts to strengthen working capital across the last couple of years genuinely impressed me. Could you walk us through what you determined to be the problem during the past 3 years regarding the management of working capital? So which issues did you pinpoint, and which steps were taken that delivered this kind of working capital improvement? I'd also like to hear if that working capital improvement is expected to hold in the next year as well? So could you again describe how you succeeded in enhancing working capital over the past 3 years and which issues you encountered? My second question is about the company's net debt -- sorry, the dividend, the dividend that you submitted is -- or that you're going to submit is EUR 0.78 per share; in the -- when the business plan was disclosed, you said EUR 0.75 per share. So may we treat EUR 0.78 as the minimum dividend through 2022? Or should we return to the earlier target that you announced? And then one more question that I never thought I'd be able to ask.
Javier Suárez Hernández
analystThat said, given what's going on with the coronavirus, I'm curious whether the company is now viewing with different eyes the amount of debt it's prepared to take on through 2022? The situation in Italy is certainly very tough. So I'd like to know whether you're looking at your debt differently in light of the coronavirus crisis, and whether you need to think about other ways of preserving your financial soundness. Then one more question about the commercial side. EBITDA went up by 9%. I heard what you said regarding tariff changes in the regulated market. But I'd like a better understanding of how that affected the free market, or nonregulated market, and your EBITDA?
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveOn the debt question, Mr. Gola will take that.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveWell, I'll attempt to recap what has been accomplished over the last few years. We've consistently discussed this on each conference call. Given that working capital isn't composed solely of receivables, let's say that during the past 3 years, we altered the procedures and processes for managing credit, in both the energy business and the water business. And the 2 businesses responded differently, since the water business responded promptly in 2018. And in 2018, if my memory serves me, we succeeded in cashing in approximately EUR 70 million, EUR 80 million more than 2017. And that result became achievable because of the new procedures for credit management or receivables management that are, in a sense, standard procedures, but we lacked them previously. Such procedures also entail cutting off water supply to delinquent clients. Previously, we tended to slow the process down because it was handled entirely in-house, and this clearly affected our results. Regarding energy, revisiting the processes and procedures required somewhat more time. We had to begin bottom up, and that is why performance picked up only in 2019. As I mentioned, unpaid at 6 months in Acea Energia fell from 4.9% to 3.3%, which means long-term unpaid invoices have improved considerably, we ought to be at around 2% when it comes to long-term unpaid invoices.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveThis is also a market benchmark. Put differently, when it comes to Acea Energia, we match best-in-class standards as well. That said, it doesn't mean we can rest on our laurels. We need to work hard to push this performance even higher. To be sure, we can't count on reporting the same kind of cash-in improvement that we saw over the past 2 years.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveAnd if I could just add a point, Giuseppe is completely correct. He talked about processes and procedures, but I'd also like to bring up the organization. We might have had the chance to discuss this when we met with investors in Milan. So I think what truly made the difference was the shift in focus from administration to the business. Giuseppe Gola and I succeeded in getting the heads of the various businesses involved in managing working capital for receivables and cash-ins, and we set these as objectives and targets for them. Management typically concentrated on business KPIs, but not on targets of this kind. So today, we've made these targets part of the incentive plans for top managers and middle managers. And I think this has made a genuine difference. Then there was your question about dividends. I believe that, as we indicated when we disclosed the business plan — the new business plan — EUR 0.75 was the low end of the range. So in a sense, it was the minimum. We did better this year, and we're pleased because performance was very strong in 2019. But as we indicated when we disclosed our business plan, we're confident that we'll be on an upward trend going forward unless unexpected events occur.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveAt this point, I'd like to address the question about the coronavirus, and then I'll invite Giuseppe to add a few words if he would like to do so. Obviously, we are facing a crisis that nobody could have expected or foreseen. And naturally, it does bring difficulties. We've put protocols in place. As things stand, 50% of our staff is working, thanks to smart working. Our IT system makes this possible. Plainly, we hope it won't persist for a long time, since over the long term this could clearly slow down activity. We don't anticipate that the coronavirus crisis will have a substantial impact on our business, because, I mean, water and energy distribution are, of course, essential and will become even more essential going forward. At the same time, as I said, energy distribution won't be impacted, because we must keep supplying energy as we always have, and the same holds for waste, waste disposal and waste treatment. Our group is seen as a player that can really bridge the gap existing in some Italian regions. So we'll keep investing in this. As for our -- let's say, for the commodity business, despite this crisis, we don't expect any substantial impact.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveThe sole issue we might foresee is a lag in invoice settlement among small and medium-sized enterprises, even though local clients make up the majority of our customer base. Therefore, I don't anticipate any significant effect on that front either. With that, I'd like to pass things over to Giuseppe.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveOn your debt question: the gap between the dividend we're proposing of EUR 0.78 and the minimum of EUR 0.75 works out to a negligible effect, though we do believe our dividends need to keep rising over the long term — definitely not at 10% a year, but rise they must. On debt, we succeeded in holding at 2.9x EBITDA in spite of the impact we reported this year, which came from M&A activity, growth in CapEx, and adoption of the new accounting standard, IFRS 16 — that produced a modest EBITDA lift of EUR 10 million but added EUR 60 million to our debt. Consolidating del Fiora Acquedotto brought EUR 90 million into our debt while contributing only EUR 14 million to EBITDA, since that contribution covers just the final 2 months of the year. So in spite of every one of these items, we succeeded in constraining how much our gearing grew. Across the coming few years, we'd like to maintain this kind of trajectory. Accordingly, the guidance we gave for next year aligns with that approach — namely, preserving some of the working capital and debt management drivers that match what we've delivered up to now.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveRegarding our guidance, we anticipate capital absorption in 2020 to be somewhat above 2019, since, as I mentioned, it's not possible for us to keep converting receivables into cash indefinitely, and additionally because a new regulation named REMSI—if my memory serves me—will allow building managers or facility managers to postpone payments. Even so, we anticipate that our debt and working capital will stay consistent with the guidance we've given. And the final question concerning performance—commercial performance. As I've already noted, the decline in our EBITDA stems entirely from the regulated tariff being reduced. Consequently, there's also a decrease in the cashing in of delinquencies. In spite of that, we've succeeded in improving on the prior—on 2018, since we signed 270,000 new contracts compared with 135,000 in 2018. Put differently, we've doubled what you might call our commercial capacity, which has raised the count of clients on the free market by 20%. And as far as margins go, the effect up to now has been negligible, because the new clients do not—are not counted for the entire year. And we've likewise seen a modest decline in margins and prices within the free market, or the unregulated market.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveBut let's just say our commercial performance has definitely gotten better.
Operator
operatorEnrico Bartoli from MainFirst has the next question.
Enrico Bartoli
analystI've got a few things I want to ask about myself. First, I'd like to begin with the regulatory review that took place in the business, and we already — or rather, you went over how it hits your accounts. Could you tell me what the effect is on OpEx and on quality bonuses as a result of that regulation review? Are you anticipating anything additional in 2020? Are there actions you can take to boost efficiency within the company? Then — and after that, a question on your guidance. From the calculation, you expected EBITDA to increase by EUR 60 million, EUR 80 million in 2020. EUR 40 million ought to come from full-year consolidation of the del Fiora Acquedotto, and then taking into account the CapEx of 2019, roughly EUR 600 million may come from the RAB, and then per my calculation, I end up with a final result somewhat above your guidance. Is there something I'm missing, or does my calculation contain some errors? And then a third question regarding waste. What evolution do you expect for this business in 2020? The CIP6 were terminated in August, so you should face an unfavorable comparison in 2020 versus 2019. Do you have any new plants starting up in 2020 that could offset this shortfall?
Enrico Bartoli
analystThen there's another question regarding M&A. Should we anticipate any new deals in 2020 on the M&A front? And could you give me a sense of which business might be affected? We saw something in the newspapers, but it wasn't clear. Can you share anything with me about that — or tell me something on this?
Giuseppe Gola
executiveAll right, I’ll do my best to address your questions. Regarding the water regulation, on the whole, there are impacts that generally get offset within the new water regulation. At this moment, we are evaluating every effect of the new regulation. Still, it’s highly probable that the quality bonus will decrease, and that will be partly balanced through investments made by — sorry, through operating costs, OpEx. We are currently developing an internal efficiency plan so we can compensate for those negative effects and thereby achieve an overall neutralization of the quality premium impact resulting from the regulation. I now follow your calculation. As for your question — you moved on to the next question — it is correct that an impact comes from the del Fiora consolidation, and there is an impact from the regulated business, and there is a negative CIP6 impact that will have a full-year effect in 2020. And that brings you to the guidance we provided. So our expectations are fairly stable in terms of EBITDA performance where corporate customers are concerned. Then, regarding CIP6, given the plan we put together in 2019 and given the acquisitions we intend to carry out in 2020, even so, those will not fully offset the CIP6 loss in 2020.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveStefano is going to share some details with you now regarding waste as well as M&A in 2020.
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveOn the waste side, if we keep our business plan targets in mind, the plan was put together this way: via organic growth plus acquisitions, we anticipate compensating for the CIP6 loss over the plan period. CIP comes to roughly EUR 30 million, which isn't peanuts given this business's overall EBITDA. Then there are the acquisitions we completed in 2019, along with repowering of new plants, and in 2020 we'll keep going down that road — we have some files under consideration and assessment on the M&A front. And here I'll address your last question. M&A activity will move in 2 directions: first, concentrating on the photovoltaic business, but we're also concentrating on primary energy plans. After that we'll keep assessing them, and we're looking at the waste management business, Unieco. We are certainly interested in that transaction. We're working alongside A2A, and we should see what the timing and the modalities are. But this is certainly an interesting transaction for us, and I'm referring to Unieco.
Operator
operatorMoving on, we have the next question coming from Emanuele Oggioni at Banca Akros.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystI have a couple of questions. The first one, again, concerns how the coronavirus crisis is affecting things. What sort of effect do you anticipate on the process of bringing in new clients and on clients moving from the regulated market to the unregulated one? So I understand it is too early to tell, and we still need to see how long this crisis will go on. But can we expect an impact going forward on this business as well? My second question is about the debt guarantee for 2020, which matches my calculations and my estimates. Even though the debt is much higher than what I calculated, and also taking into account what the consensus figure is, could you explain to us why there is such a difference of hundreds of millions, given that the EBITDA growth is in line with our expectations?
Stefano Donnarumma
executiveTo address your question about the panic coming from the coronavirus crisis and how it affects market behavior, I'd say first that it's too soon to tell, since the panic is spreading right now — or rather, more than panic, I'd call it deep concern. Honestly, I don't anticipate this concern hitting the market right away. You might smile at this, but we talked about it today at the executive committee meeting with our managers. Consumers will probably focus more on what the various players — the market players — are offering, because they'll be spending more time at home. That may sound trivial, but it's what we picked up from the calls we got. So people who normally aren't very interested when something is offered to them are calling us because they're rethinking the offers we made. And they say this crisis could benefit us commercially, because, again, our offers are very interesting and our brand is a strong brand. So I think we shouldn't expect any substantial impact from the crisis. As for our debt, I'll hand you over to Giuseppe once more.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveWhen you look at cash absorption for 2020, as I mentioned earlier, we projected a modest working capital rise in 2020 as a result of the REMSI regulation, that new rule. And bearing in mind that CapEx, let's say, stays -- is going to stay flat, you're aware that a CapEx increase would affect working capital. If CapEx stays flat, naturally there's no working capital impact in the quarter. Turning to financial charges, we anticipate those staying flat. We foresee a modest rise in tax -- in taxes, reflecting better performance, and then dividend growth, as we said before. So we're looking at roughly EUR 100 million of M&A activity, which is already included. So overall, we anticipate our debt rising in line with -- our net debt in line with the guidance we gave. Given that we always publish a range and we generally say we'd rather stay at the low end of that range, we think that going forward we may be able to move below this minimum level. But in any case, let's say we stick with our guidance.
Operator
operatorEnrico Bartoli from MainFirst has a follow-up question next.
Enrico Bartoli
analystI’m sorry about that. I’d like to ask for a bit more detail. First, provisions and write-downs came in at EUR 115 million in 2019 — will 2020 and the following few years look similar? Next, public lighting is now posting positive EBITDA; can we take that as a positive trend for 2020 and later years? On the tax rate, it was roughly 29%, a little below the guidance you provided — is that sustainable? Then there’s the matter of the gas tenders. We’ve seen in the press that, given the coronavirus crisis, the government may consider accelerating the process through suitable rules and regulations. How do you see this? Do you have contacts with the government, or is that expectation realistic?
Executive
executiveOn write-downs and provisions, we showed just one item: write-downs of EUR 66 million, which is net of the EUR 12 million in provisions we were able to release for the Gala business. Apart from that, things are stable. Once you exclude that EUR 12 million, it will be stable. On the tax rate, here's a very quick answer. It might look like the 2 tax rates differ, but in fact they are very similar. Last year we had provisions, and the AGM sanction wasn't subject to taxes. This year we released it without taking the tax impact into account, net of the EUR 16 million tax impact. In any case, the tax rates for the 2 years are very similar.
Executive
executiveOn public lighting, I want to offer a comment — actually, I have a reply for you here. Your point is very appropriate. Last year, we had to fund maintenance plans, and that spending was fairly sizable. By the end of the year, the number came out quite negative. This year, we are seeing the beneficial effect of those investments. Investment rose last year, and in 2019 as well, and in 2018 too. Together with the technical offices of the Rome municipalities, we are evaluating whether to repower — and so to put money into plants. And I believe that will be positive. Let me address your questions on the gas tenders. We have not had any — or rather, the government's view at this moment. We have not talked this over with the government, but I think it will be discussed in the coming few weeks, since the government may consider accelerating the process and — with the aim of ensuring the proper and suitable execution of the investment plans, which is certainly going to matter a great deal.
Operator
operatorMoving on to the following question, from Stefano Gamberini at Equita.
Stefano Gamberini
analystI have a few questions. First, regarding the EBITDA guidance: given EUR 100 million of additional debt from M&As, I'm wondering if you're including those acquisitions in the EBITDA figure too, since they involve substantial investment. I'd like to know whether these are processes that are already at an advanced stage in the waste business. And is there anything similar for the other renewable energy sources? Then, you mentioned EUR 800 million of CapEx. Where is that CapEx going to be spent? I'm curious whether, when you update the business plan, we can expect more investment in the water network and in electric energy distribution as well. And when can we expect an update of the business plan? And then, don't you think the government might ask for a delay in the payment of utility bills, at least for consumers, given the difficult times we are going through, and could this have an impact on your business going forward? So are there any negotiations ongoing with the government about this?
Giuseppe Gola
executiveOkay, regarding our guidance: once more, the M&A activity we carried out in 2019 had a full-year effect that's larger than what we anticipate for 2020. And these M&As can only be announced one at a time, once they're completed. As we said, our main focus will be the photovoltaic business. In the secondary market, we'll get to the 50 megawatts that we had planned for in our business plan. Right now we've reached 20 megawatts, but our pipeline is quite full, let's say. So we'll reach 50 megawatts soon. And as Stefano already noted, we'll also be focusing on the primary market. Because, as I mentioned, in the secondary market, even though the returns for us are high, given that we take a very selective approach to the targets we're going to acquire, the impact on our debt is substantial. That's why we're considering stopping once we hit 50 megawatts, while we'll be putting more focus on the primary market going forward. And then we'll certainly be making acquisitions in the environment business. At present, we have some targets, but no negotiation has been completed yet, as well as some opportunities in the gas business.
Giuseppe Gola
executiveOn CapEx—and I think you actually asked two things there—our 2019 investment came to EUR 800 million, with EUR 700 million of that going mainly toward water, so essentially we're concentrating on regulated infrastructure. That emphasis has stayed the same across the 3 years of our mandate, and it won't shift over the next 3 years either, as we already laid out when we presented the new business plan. Beyond that, naturally, we'll also be putting money into electricity infrastructure and into the environment business. You raised the possibility that we might revisit the business plan. Well, following the general shareholders' meeting, we could indeed be revisiting it. That ought to take place before the summer, and work on it is still ongoing.
Stefano Gamberini
analystSo no risk at all in your view stems from the delay in utility bill payments?
Giuseppe Gola
executiveOh, right — I overlooked that question. Well, to be honest, we have no idea if this will actually happen. If it does, if the government chooses to request that energy bill payments be postponed, my expectation is that it would apply only to particular groups within the population. And naturally, when that moment comes, we would need to do the same.
Stefano Gamberini
analystAnd do you not anticipate that this is going to affect your M&A plans?
Giuseppe Gola
executiveNo, definitely not. At least not right now.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take the next question, a follow-up from Javier Suarez at Mediobanca.
Javier Suárez Hernández
analystI've got a couple of questions. The first one is on synergies. When you put out the latest business plan, you mentioned roughly EUR 50 million of efficiencies across 2018 and 2019. So, going by your own figures, how much in synergies did you capture in 2019, and where did they come from? Second, picking up on the follow-ups Enrico and Stefano raised on CapEx: given the economic slowdown, my sense is the government is keen on companies that are willing to invest in the country. So what conditions would need to be in place for you to raise your CapEx capacity? Under what circumstances would you deploy more capital to generate a virtuous cycle? We're aware the gas tenders aren't ideal, but that isn't the only factor. So what do you think would push you to put your capital to better use? Then one more question on the photovoltaic business: could you give us a sense of the IRR you target, after taxes, when investing in primary and secondary plants?
Executive
executiveOkay, Javier, regarding synergies — that’s a recurring item for us. As we’ve mentioned previously, we’re speeding things up. We’re pressing ahead with our efforts to try to enhance the efficiency gains across our operations. And in 2020, we’d like to offset — neutralize — the effect of the new regulation. In 2019, we had roughly EUR 15 million to EUR 20 million of synergies compared with the actual data from 2017. As for the other question on CapEx. Well, I share your observation. Naturally, we need to relaunch the economy, at least in the regions where we operate, and new investments can definitely be a key factor for that. We’ve discussed this matter quite often with central and local authorities, and they are certainly interested in it. For example, the Acquedotto del Pescara is a major investment. It’s a project we keep working on, and we hope it will receive the authorizations soon. If your question was this: what do you need in order to be supported in making greater investments, or to have to make greater investments? Well, authorizations are the big problem for us. So perhaps red tape should be streamlined, because it slows investments down, so reducing red tape could matter for accelerating investments.
Executive
executiveSure — ACEA has every tool it needs, whether financial or engineering expertise. We possess the full set. There are quite a few opportunities open to us. On top of that, depending on how efficient a given period turns out to be, we're able to either decelerate or speed up our multiannual plans, and that effectively turns us into a rather compelling machine, so to speak, across the central and southern regions of the country — the territory where we conduct our operations. Turning now to your second question, the one on photovoltaic, we continue to share our views on that subject with all of you. For investments in photovoltaic and secondary plants, our floor target for IRR stands at 7%. Holding to that number is extremely challenging. A great deal of effort sits behind our ability to keep delivering a return of that kind. Regarding the primary business, we apply the identical target on an unlevered basis. What I mean is, bearing in mind, though, that within the primary business the energy cost is conservative absent, though, a PPA — a long-term PPA in Italy can only be secured when energy prices are low, and for us those prices aren't advantageous. At present, as a group, we purchase energy net.
Executive
executiveI'll add one more point. We're also looking at another thing—which means that in the near term, we might take minority positions in photovoltaic companies, and those could deliver a return—not really IRR, not unlevered IRR, but possibly a return on EBITDA above 7%, given how much debt these companies carry. That could give us critical mass in terms of the megawatts we manage. However, this would expose the company—our company—through a reduced level of indebtedness when it comes to these companies.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a follow-up from Stefano Gamberini at Equita.
Stefano Gamberini
analystApologies — just one quick thing. Could you give us the distribution tariffs for electricity and those for the water business for 2020?
Executive
executiveApologies, Stefano—your question didn’t come through for us. Could you say it again?
Stefano Gamberini
analystYeah, I’d like to ask if you can give us the RAB for electricity in 2020, and also the same figure for water — for the different companies in the group?
Executive
executiveHonestly, those numbers aren't in front of me at the moment. We'll reach out to you afterward to give you the exact figures, but since you already have the investment total, you can do the calculation yourself without much trouble.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the question-and-answer session, everyone. Thank you so much.
Elvira Angrisani
executiveAnd as usual, we're open to taking your questions now. If you'd like, feel free to email them to us. Thanks so much. Thanks for joining us.
Operator
operatorThe Chorus Call operator here. That brings the conference call to a close. You may hang up at this point. Thank you so much.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete ACEA S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to ACEA S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in ACEA S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.