ACEA S.p.A. (ACE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 8, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Ira Angrisani
executiveThank you. Good afternoon, and thanks for joining us for the presentation of Acea Group’s results as of December 31st. Fabio Paris, the company’s CFO, and Stefano Songini, Director of Investor Relations and Sustainability, will now walk you through the results. After that, we’ll move on to the Q&A session. Fabio?
Fabio Paris
executiveThank you, Ira. Good afternoon, everyone. Let's move on to the presentation. We'll begin with slide at page two. Of course, the market situation and the market environment in 2022 is well-known to all of us. It has been characterized, especially, in the second part of the second semester, by a macroeconomic scenario, which was heavily affected by the price of energy and the inflation and the consequent increase of rates, which made for a very challenging environment in the second part of the year. Despite that, the group's performance is in line with the results we expected. Basically, we had excellent performance for the whole group. Let's switch over to page three. This slide summarizes the main dealings and the main highlights that have been carried out throughout the year. I would only like to point out the highlights of the last quarter because all the others have been already announced at the previous quarters. During the months of October, in particular, we completed the acquisition of Tecnoservizi. In November, we completed the acquisition of Italmacero, and in December, we completed the business combination and acquisition of a stake in ASM Terni. Of course, as we understand, the transactions are concentrated on the environment area in keeping with the strategy that the group adopted during previous periods.
Fabio Paris
executiveWe continue to stress how central ESG factors are to what the group focuses on. One more event worth noting from the fourth quarter was Mr. Fabrizio Palermo being named CEO of the group. From the moment he took the role, management as a whole redirected the company toward containing costs and strengthening the group's strategy. That produced solid results in delivering the quarter's performance, and it in fact offset the rise in certain extraordinary costs and events that came up late in the year, among them the higher profit taxation, the higher interest rates, and the greater credit impairments the group has set aside, given the scenario that could hurt credit quality. Special attention was also warranted for certain strategic items, among them getting Peschiera unblocked. Beyond the work itself being unlocked, we secured public funding for the plant, which has already been provided for in the 2023 stability law to the tune of roughly EUR 700 million. We also secured PNRR funds of approximately EUR 733 million. We received the authorization, and we began the process of building the fourth line at San Vittore. Lastly, we presented the project for the city of Rome.
Fabio Paris
executiveAlso worth noting, on February 17th Barbara Marinali was named chairperson of A2A. Let's move to page four. As I've mentioned, we take pride in what the group accomplished in 2022. Revenue came in at EUR 5,168 million, up 29%. That growth stems largely from higher energy prices. EBITDA reached EUR 1,305 million, +4%, consistent with the guidance we recently reviewed. EBIT was EUR 566 million, down slightly by 3% from last year. Here, the drop in EBIT reflects higher impairments, as I noted before, tied to the worsening we booked in the last quarter. On that point, I'd add that the performance the group now reports under the credit heading matches our expectations, and the situation has not deteriorated. Net profit came to EUR 208 million. That's -11% against last year. The biggest factor here is the windfall tax, which hits net profit by EUR 38 million. Absent that, net profit would have been EUR 318 million, an increase over last year's result.
Fabio Paris
executiveCapEx is at EUR 1 billion, up 8%. I'd like to note too that where CapEx is concerned, that figure includes a gross increase tied to Law Decree number 50 — the price review on public centers — amounting to roughly EUR 49 million. On that specific piece, the group has also begun some possible activities to account for it going forward. That's something that will show up in 2023 as a result of reimbursement requirements. Net financial position is EUR 4 billion, 440 million, +11%. I think when we announced the guidance review, we also mentioned that net debt is mostly impacted by the energy scenario we've seen across the year. That comes from greater absorption of working capital owing to the mix change in procuring energy through over-the-counter contracts and various over-the-counter markets, which brought a significant shortening of payment terms. GME now gets paid at eight days, much shorter than previously. The net debt EBITDA ratio is 3.4x, and we can confirm the group's robustness. EBITDA is 87% from the regulated market, and the CapEx we invested in 2022 is 88% in the regulated market.
Fabio Paris
executiveThose percentages also take in the environment business. From 2022 onward, in the first year this was put into practice, essentially every one of the group's plants has operated under the regulatory framework. Dividends are going to stay steady, even under the difficult scenario we've just outlined. The per-share dividend proposed at today's board of directors meetings comes to EUR 0.85 per share. Payout stands at 65%, and the dividend yield is 6.6%. Guidance for 2023 remains on the up, since EBITDA is projected to increase somewhere in the range of 2% to 4%. CapEx is roughly consistent with 2022. Net debt to EBITDA will come in under 3.8x. On that specific item, allow me to note that the net debt to EBITDA ratio in fact results from a fairly precise evaluation. In the scenario we've built around those metrics, we did factor in certain elements that continue to soak up working capital, given the energy situation and given how regulations affect our business. The baseline scenario — the energy price figure we used when developing our assumptions — is EUR 280 per kWh. Right now, as we speak, we can in fact see that the scenario shows a lower energy price.
Fabio Paris
executiveConversely, we're factoring in the water tariff cap being introduced alongside the chance to fully recoup energy costs for 2023. To give you a sense of scale on those figures, together they represent roughly EUR 320 million of deterioration in our accounts. That goes some way toward explaining the highly prudent assumptions we've adopted for the coming year. Turning to page five. Here we can examine some of the group's financials. EBITDA has risen by EUR 49 million. As mentioned, it now stands at EUR 1.305 billion. We're aware that 86% of the business is generated by the regulated market. The key effects—which we'll cover over the next few slides and which shaped how 2022 performed—are the regulatory impact, which caused a WACC decrease, translating into a reduction of roughly EUR 26 million compared with the prior year. The technical quality bonus for water services contributed + EUR 27 million, while freeing the Terni plant from its obligation to buy CO2 allowances delivered + EUR 18 million. Moving to page six. As noted before, EBIT is down by approximately 3%, landing at EUR 565.9 million for 2022.
Fabio Paris
executiveBeyond that, the biggest factor was higher depreciation, driven largely by the steady investment strategy the group has pursued over the past few years, 2022 included. Aside from depreciation, the unusual item affecting EBIT in 2022 was a rise in credit loss provisions, which now sit at EUR 113 million compared with EUR 86 million for 2021. We made that decision because we introduced the stress scenario used to gauge possible credit deterioration that could arise if payments contract going forward. Net profit stands at EUR 280 million, as I mentioned. Excluding the windfall tax, it could have been EUR 318 million. The tax rate, given this windfall tax effect, stands at EUR 37.6 million. Absent that, the tax rate would in fact be slightly below the prior year, since the normalized tax rate for 2022 would be 29.8%. Let's turn to page seven. Take a look at investment. CapEx is EUR 1 billion for 2022, up EUR 70 million from the year before. As I noted, the largest share of CapEx will go into energy infrastructure and water. Beginning this year, we also placed environment within regulated businesses.
Fabio Paris
executiveTaken together, they represent 88% of CapEx for this year. Investment and CapEx over the course of the year were influenced by certain scope variations amounting to roughly EUR 21 million. That figure takes in the effect of Law Decree number 50 concerning price reductions on regulated contracts. Page eight. Cash flow for this year appears on page eight. That's the cash flow for 2022. If working capital for 2022 were set against 2021, it looks quite comparable across both years. In fact, relative to the forecast we originally made, there is an extraordinary capital absorption stemming from the energy scenario situation. To give you some figures on how energy procurement versus GME played out — that had an effect in 2022 — it resulted in additional absorption of approximately EUR 70 million owing to this shift in the payment mix. One more factor that has marked cash flow during this period is the windfall tax, which in terms of economic weight across the years comes to EUR 39 million. Over 2022, the average paid amounts to EUR 26 million. Regarding the remaining changes in cash flow, CapEx is shown here. We've covered that earlier. Delta funds also captures the effect of losses on pension funds.
Fabio Paris
executiveOn taxes paid, we've already laid out what the windfall tax does. As for M&A transactions, those would in fact contribute positively. What we should really keep in mind is that this is a net figure combining the deals closed — or rather paid — over the year with the gain from cashing in on the sale of the photovoltaic business, and that added roughly EUR 150 million on the positive side. Last, I want to flag the IFRS 16 impact: an increase of EUR 36 million, and this effect stems from the group's postponement of its photovoltaic disposal strategy. You may recall that we now have a fairly substantial pipeline under development, and the group's strategy was to contribute to developing photovoltaic assets through a joint venture. During 2022, we did not pursue that disposal in order to manage, let's say — in fact, and the price increases posted across 2022. The strategy remains confirmed, and the IFRS 16 item I'm referring to is essentially tied to the use rights on the land structures where we are developing the new photovoltaic plants. That particular component will be deconsolidated as we proceed, in line with the strategy we have already announced.
Fabio Paris
executiveMoving along to page nine now. We’ve already provided a few items that really describe how the group’s finances are structured and the impact we saw on the rise in net financial position — that figure now stands at EUR 4.45 billion, up EUR 450 million compared with last year. The group’s structure is quite robust, including from a financial standpoint. When it comes to our debt, 92% matures after 2023, and 84% of what we hold is at a fixed rate. The average cost sits at 1.44%, while the average term comes to 4.4 years. The ratings back up the group’s robustness. Fitch has us at BBB+ with a stable outlook, and Moody’s assigns us Baa2 with a negative outlook. We should also note that in mid-January, early February, the group returned once more to the financial markets by issuing two bonds. In fact, it’s one bond plus one tap on that same instrument, for a grand total of EUR 700 million. We placed them successfully, also because they carry a very, very attractive rate given the market conditions at that time. Page 10 now offers some details on the individual business areas. On Water, we confirm 2.1% growth.
Fabio Paris
executiveEBITDA comes in at EUR 669 million. What characterizes growth during this period is the quality premium of EUR 27 million — the quality bonus. Acea Ato 2 adds roughly EUR 24 million, thanks to that quality bonus. The remaining water companies accounted for under equity contribute around EUR 9 million. Those equity-counted water companies likewise benefited from the quality bonus — the technical quality bonus. Another factor is Publiacqua, which in fact turned in a stronger performance than it did last year. The negative result we must flag is that of GORI, and two components mainly explain it. The most significant is the lack of tariff increases for social remuneration, a technical component inside GORI. From a regulatory standpoint, the company could not secure this for 2022. On water, there is another interesting item: growth of 6% in RAB, which now sits at EUR 3.886 billion. Moving to page 11, let's examine how the energy infrastructure business performed. In this area, results are affected by a decrease of roughly 5% in EBITDA, attributable mainly to the reduction of WACC, which, as you may recall, fell from 5.9% to 5.2% last year.
Fabio Paris
executiveThat reduction's economic effect comes to roughly EUR 26 million. Higher efficiency and improved profitable investments partially counterbalance it. The negative impact was not fully offset by us. Let me repeat that RAB rose 3%, with the value for 2022 now at EUR 2.539 billion. Altogether, distributed energy is up 9.3 GWh. Periods remain steady at EUR 1.6 million. Turning to page 12, you'll see detailed performance in generation. EBITDA there has risen 13%, and price is the most significant driver of that expansion, adding an average of EUR 298 per MWh in 2022. A decline in hydro electric volumes, which cost us 95 GWh, partly countered this. Taken together, those two metrics produced EBITDA of +EUR 21 million for the period. Regarding photovoltaic asset development, as I mentioned before, we reaffirm the group's strategy of expanding in that business. The pipeline is now 1,070MW under construction or ready to build. Among these, 211MW already hold consent and are either being built or ready to build, while 859 megawatts await consent and authorizations.
Fabio Paris
executiveThen there’s the effect of the Sostegni-ter law decree, which put a ceiling on electricity sale prices. At the Sant'Angelo hydroelectric power plant, that meant a decrease of roughly EUR 18.3 million for 2022. On Page 13 you can see commercial and trading performance. This business recorded a performance gain of around 12%. EBITDA went from EUR 8 million in 2021 to EUR 9 million in 2022. In this specific instance, energy sold fell to 7.7 TWh, consistent with a strategy of limiting risk, since the group is short on energy it produces. There was a dedicated effort to pinpoint those supplies carrying a lower level of risk. We tended to concentrate carefully on which clients to serve and on the performance to be delivered. Customers are declining a little. Owing to the disposal of certain protection market customers, we lost 18,000 customers in 2022. Let me remind you that in 2023, the group will gain access to 148,000 new customers thanks to the auction for small and micro enterprises in the enhanced protection market. Those customers will only be counted beginning in 2023. EBITDA growth for the financial year stems mainly from Acea Innovation, owing to the energy efficiency projects the organization undertook.
Fabio Paris
executiveThat comes from growth in value-added services at Acea Energia. On Page 14, you can see how the environment area — the Acea Ambiente business — performed. Once again, we report a substantial rise in margins. EBITDA comes in at EUR 101.6 million for 2022, an increase of almost 60%. This growth stems mainly from higher margins and from energy prices at the San Vittore and ASM Terni plants, which together contributed EUR 16 million of growth. The new scope of consolidation also lifted EBITDA by 12.4%. The MEC Group, the Deco Group, Serplast and Italmacero acquisitions altered that scope. We brought the new scope into account from the moment those companies were integrated into the group's results, as the slide shows. Consequently, the new scope of consolidation raised waste treatment and disposal, which went from 1.5 million tons to 1.7 million tons in 2022. Electricity sold is essentially flat — that is the electricity generated by waste-to-energy installations. Earlier, we mentioned that the Terni plant also added EUR 18 million when it was freed from the obligation to purchase CO2 allowances. With that said, I'll hand things over to Stefano for the remainder of the presentation.
Stefano Songini
executiveThanks, Fabio. Good afternoon, everybody. Let me walk you through a few quick ESG highlights. We'll start with how we performed on the environmental side. 2022 was another excellent year. We delivered some very solid results. We're on page 15 at this point. We reaffirm our position as Italy's leading water operator, with 8.6 million inhabitants served. Water loss reduction — something the group cares about a great deal — came in at -6% compared with the prior year, and that translates into savings of roughly 30 million cubic meters of water year on year. Another point we take a lot of pride in is ATO 2, where water losses were brought down to 27.8%. Back in 2019, losses stood at 34%, so that's a major achievement and a major step forward. Moving on to the energy infrastructure. We distributed 9,355 GW of electricity, and we continue to improve consumption efficiency while raising awareness around consumption, since we've now installed roughly 600,000 2G smart meters, which will help our consumers become more conscious of what they use. On the generation side, we produced 941 GWh, 68% of which came from renewable sources. Naturally, that 68% reflects very limited output this year from the hydroelectric plants, given the very dry conditions.
Stefano Songini
executiveThat figure is roughly -25% versus the prior year. One notable element is our base of prosumer customers. That group now stands 14% larger than a year earlier — around 18,000 — and 74% of the energy they generate and feed into the grid comes from photovoltaic sources. That's a highly significant evolution, particularly when you consider what's happening with energy communities. Acea Ambiente generated 36 GWh of energy. Roughly 20,000 cubic meters of biogas came from anaerobic digestion, up 16% from the previous year. Our composting plants also yielded 37,000 tons of high-quality compost, a 31% increase versus 2021. Commercial and trading — naturally, as Fabio mentioned, on the free market — we continue promoting green offers, meaning 100% green energy plus offset gas, and 42% of the electricity we sell in the free market is in fact green. One last point on ESG: our engineering and services division carried out 365,000 analytical determinations on drinking water at Acea alone. That represents a substantial quality commitment. Slide 16 presents our social governance and economic performance. Specifically, we engaged with the community — I mean in particular the vaccination hub we ran at Acea. We shut it down in January of this year, after administering more than 171,000 vaccine doses.
Stefano Songini
executiveWe continue to launch additional water kiosks. Right now, 166 of them exist in the regions where we operate. On the workforce side, we take real pride in remaining a top-quality employer. 99% of our employees hold permanent positions. In 2022, we brought on roughly 427 new hires, and 43% of them are 30 or younger. Naturally, we're pushing ahead with this workforce renewal, including in terms of upskilling those people. Turning to suppliers, we were certified as a top employer in 2023 as well, in January 2023. More recently, we set up an Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion committee, which we paired with an equality, diversity, and inclusion policy. A committee reporting directly to the CEO will manage their activities. We are the first listed Italian multi-utility to secure certification on gender equality. Now, suppliers. Here too, we're acting in light of the new directives we have implemented regarding ESG and sustainability. Naturally, 78% of our suppliers are qualified. They in fact completed a self-assessment questionnaire covering sustainability aspects. This year, we raised by 129% the number of suppliers rated through the EcoVadis platform. That figure now stands at 339, which reflects supplier quality. On supplier quality once more, we carried out more than 14,700 inspections at work sites this year.
Stefano Songini
executiveTo add to what Fabio mentioned earlier, in addition to the two green bonds we issued in January and February of this year, one more issuance worth highlighting is the additional credit line we negotiated with Cassa Depositi e Prestiti last year, for EUR 200 million. It's a revolving credit facility linked to a sustainability rating, and that facility is in fact tied to improvements in two specific ratings that we agreed upon with the counterparty. Now, let's turn to page 17, our ratings. As you can see, we improved on virtually all of our ratings, with CDP being the sole exception — there, unfortunately, since we haven't yet communicated science-related targets, we experienced a downgrade, and we're working on that, and we're confident that we can improve there as well. In 2022, Acea was included in the MIB ESG Index two, which of course means that our standing as an ESG-conscious company has been formally approved and certified. That's everything from us — if there are questions, we'll be glad to take them now.
Operator
operatorThanks, Fabio. Thanks, Stefano. At this point we're ready to take your questions. This is the Chorus Call operator, and the Q&A session is starting now. Should you have a question, please press star one on your phone. To leave the waiting list, press star two. Kindly ask your questions using your phone receiver. If you have questions, please press star one. The first question will come from Javier Suárez of Mediobanca, please.
Javier Suárez
executiveGood afternoon. I’ve got two or three questions. The first concerns 2023 guidance and debt. Net debt appears to be above EUR 5 billion. Given that the company’s operating cash flow generation and CapEx are essentially the same amount, the company’s credit should improve year-over-year in line with the debt payment of roughly EUR 200 million. The year-over-year increase in debt is around EUR 700. Seven hundred million euros. That looks similar to the prior situation, which was EUR 500 million. I’d like to understand the reasons why there was this EUR 500 million negative working capital absorption in 2023. In your presentation, you said working capital is worsening, and there’s also an assumption about the review of water tariffs, which would offset the recovery in energy costs. Could you please tell us how you expect the split between these two factors to play out? Do you expect any recovery in working capital absorption in the following years? As far as water regulation is concerned, is that something that’s going to happen again in the future or not? My second question is, what does it mean for Acea to have an EBITDA which is nearly 4 times the previous business plan?
Javier Suárez
executiveYou brought up 3x in the earlier forecast, and the company felt quite comfortable with that. From what we can see, debt to EBITDA stands at roughly 4x rather than 3x. What does that mean for the company when it comes to CapEx and the dividend as well? My third question concerns the 2023 guidance. I was hoping to understand whether you could give us guidance on the provisions level that you would view as fair for 2023. We are aware that credit loss provisions have been rising rather substantially. On credit loss provisions in particular, I would like to hear, from your perspective, what level of net income would be compatible with the guidance you have given for 2023, particularly given that market consensus sits at about EUR 310 million. Thank you.
Fabio Paris
executiveThank you, Javier. All right. I'll do my best to address your questions in the sequence you raised them. Let's begin, in fact, with the debt guidance. Javier, those figures are accurate. Naturally, the difference comes to roughly EUR 700 million. As I mentioned earlier, we have a tendency to be quite conservative when we give forecasts for 2023. Specifically, my remark regarding supplies concerns the ongoing shift of offers between fixed price and variable price. From the start of 2022, whenever offers to free market clients reached expiry, the group began offering existing customers only contracts with indexed prices. For the group, that means a change in how we purchase and procure energy, since within the group we cannot rely on sufficient generation to cover all the needs of our sales. Moving to that mode means that every contract we used to serve at a fixed price rested on procuring energy via bilateral agreements, which were over-the-counter arrangements with leading suppliers, with payment conditions spanning anywhere from 60 to 90 days in payment terms. Procuring energy for variable price offers is now handled by the group directly from GME, and GME's payment terms are eight days.
Fabio Paris
executiveWe're assuming, naturally, that the approach the group has taken here is to keep providing indexed price offers. Given our assumption that the average across every energy scenario for 2023 ought to be EUR 280 per MWh, the gradual shift of procurements toward GME means that out of the EUR 300 million I mentioned earlier, roughly EUR 150 million would go to GME. Naturally, certain measures could be taken to limit that impact. One is surely evaluating procurement options through bilateral contracts. We aren't looking at that right now, because the trade-off might be the ability to negotiate with counterparties, a financial effect that would stem from this delay in payments. The second effect rests on the energy scenario we have assumed, which is, naturally, the reduction of the energy scenario, and that would deliver a notable decrease in the possible absorption of working capital. As an order of magnitude, 30 days of payment terms on the stakes, boat from GME for the HGR group come to approximately, well, somewhere in the range of EUR 40 million-EUR 50 million of working capital absorbed. One more element we've cited to explain the cautious stance we've built into our assumption for 2023 concerns the water business.
Fabio Paris
executiveAt this moment, ARERA hasn't stated any stance regarding the adoption of price caps meant to recognize energy costs. For a potential cap being put in place during 2023, our assumption is that the cap could match in size the one we factored in for 2022. With no benchmarks available for alternative forecasts, we regard the 2022 cap as fairly prudent. Should ARERA proceed with it, that would hopefully represent a worst-case situation. Another point is that we view this as a time-bound measure. The cap might come in at a particular point, and within the two-year horizon we ought to return to normal conditions, which is our usual expectation. The honest answer is that everyone is awaiting a decision from ARERA and whatever measures it may issue on this matter. Regarding the plan scenario, that will be the new board of directors' top priority. Naturally, a business plan will be approved, containing a set of measures that typically prioritize strategies and programs for the group. Right now, we foresee no particular difficulty in handling this transition or in managing the debt position we currently hold.
Fabio Paris
executiveIn the forecast we gave for 2023, no strategic action aimed at containing net debt has been factored in — though that is definitely a step the group could choose to take. Regarding provisions for 2023, our assumption is that they will track fairly closely with the group's normal performance, roughly EUR 90 million per year. For 2022 we built in a deterioration, since we chose to apply a credit impairment system constructed on top of the model already in place. That existing model, as is true of any model, was created before we reached this juncture, and it carries a flaw: it captures no possibility of an abrupt shift in market conditions. It makes no allowance for a sudden decline in payment performance. Our view is that this is a one-off measure. We might have to handle a potential abrupt worsening of the situation. We don't anticipate that carrying over into 2023 as well. The reason is that two fundamental features define Acea's business: for regulated operations, defaults must be recovered through our tariffs, according to whichever scenario we end up facing. For customer service in the free market, risk management provisions will likewise mean that customers who remain in default will stop being served.
Fabio Paris
executiveOur approach was to flag a potential abrupt deterioration as a one-time adverse impact that could in fact be experienced during the interval after performance declines, and we recognize that in our financial statements. I'm not certain — have I addressed everything you asked?
Speaker
unknownSomeone also asked about the net financial position being 4x rather than 3x, and how that affects dividends?
Fabio Paris
executiveRight, thank you. And Sarah, thanks for the reminder. Yeah. Actually, in this debt scenario we don't see... Well, as I mentioned to you, the group has quite a lot of confidence regarding how net debt is managed. In our guidance we can indeed confirm both the ability and, well, to run CapEx, which lines up with the performance of the regulated business. In 2023 as well, the investment mix will match the group's standards and habits. We don't foresee any particular difficulty in actually delivering that performance, and we don't expect any negative effect on dividend distribution either.
Ira Angrisani
executiveThanks. I believe we’ve covered all the points.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a question from Davide Candela at Intesa Sanpaolo.
Davide Candela
analystGood afternoon, everyone, and thanks for your presentation. I have three questions as well. Could you help me square a few accounts? When I look at leverage and what you mentioned, RAB stands at roughly EUR 6.4 billion, EUR 6.5 billion at the close of 2022. Looking specifically at the RAB for water, are you also consolidating companies that are equity accounted for, apart from those consolidated line by line? If so, at EUR 3.9 billion, how does that compare with the EUR 4.9 billion target, which I believe I came across in some of the presentations recently uploaded to the website? Could you shed some light and reconcile some of those accounts? Related to that, given that you're examining CapEx for the waste business, are you in fact treating waste within regulated CapEx? So might the valuation of the RAB of those treatment plants also become part of the group's consolidated RAB going forward? My second question concerns possible prices and possible leverage on the 2023 targets. We're discussing EUR 280 per MWh. Given that cautious level of leverage and the year-end targets, I was wondering whether you're applying the same assumed prices to the operating part of the business?
Davide Candela
analystTo put it another way, for electrical generation, are you assuming the same price, and do you also assume the same price for the energy you're going to purchase? One last question is about — well, I think I understand that the company wants to become more geared towards fully regulated markets. So considering the possible sharp increase of debt, are you considering that you may want to dispose of some liberalized companies for energy supply in particular? Even though, as you said, the debt level of the company is just a phase of transition, so it's sustainable on your side? Thank you.
Fabio Paris
executiveThanks a lot. I’ll do my best to address every question as well. Now, regarding RAB, the figures you cited exclude the equity-accounted companies. Therefore, the water value stands at EUR 3 billion, 886 million, which includes Terna and GORI but not the equity-accounted water companies. For a sense of scale, Acea Ato 2 comes to EUR 2.66 billion in RAB terms. If the RAB of equity-accounted water companies were also included, the group’s total water RAB would reach EUR 5.42 billion. For electricity distribution, the RAB is EUR 2.539 billion, all of it belonging to Areti. On CapEx for the environmental area: this RAB covers only water and energy distribution, so environment is not part of it. Your question is well-pointed. What I mean is that regulatory evolution in the environmental area is tending to look more and more like the business we previously ran. What we can say today is that within the Acea Group there is just one plant, and a rather small one at that, which is not included among what we might term minimum plants. In the most extreme synthesis we can offer today on environmental regulation, that means WACC is still being remunerated over investment, so it is likewise a sort of RAB-based mechanism, WACC over CapEx.
Fabio Paris
executiveFor this type of accounting, 2022 is in fact the first year, so that's a piece we will need to evaluate as we move forward. Without question, the Acea Group installations, given their characteristics, are facilities that are inclined to complete the waste management cycle. The individual regions in which they sit have designated them as plants for total waste management and recycling. Their classification as so-called minimum plants gets reviewed every two years or four years. It is somewhat too soon to grasp how matters will develop over the longer term and how the rules will shift. Regarding the price scenarios for generation... Well, thank you for that question, actually. I had been neglecting to point this out. Allow me to remind everyone that a ceiling has been set on prices for producing energy without the use of gas: EUR 180 per MWh. The present limits, I believe, will stay in place until June. Across all of 2023, we have in fact assumed that this cap will persist without change. Our assumption is that the revenue recognition ceiling for generation will remain in force through the whole of 2023. To the extent possible, we take a prudent stance on generation two. Acea is, indeed, a multi-utility that is specializing in the regulated market, which is in fact demonstrated by the CapEx that we've carried out and the EBITDA position that we hold.
Fabio Paris
executiveRegarding the strategic assessments we'll be carrying out, that will be a priority for the new business plan and for the incoming board of directors, which will certainly proceed in line with these guidelines. We have consistently emphasized that this group operates as a multi-utility manager within the regulated business.
Operator
operatorWe'll take the next question from Stefano Gamberini at Equita SIM. Starting off, I'd like to ask about slide eight, specifically the cash flow.
Stefano Gamberini
analystYou mentioned that 2022 saw a significant cash flow absorption. You noted the GME impact is roughly negative EUR 180 million — EUR 170 million. But I believe the delta working capital is slower — sorry, lower — than 2021. There's another factor involved. Why did the guidance worsen? The working capital change occurred over the last nine months, and the delta is comparable to last year. My second question also concerns debt. Leverage stands at 3.8x, slight or similar. Keeping BBB. Well, Fitch hasn't actually placed anything under observation. To maintain investment grade, what level of leverage should you have? At what leverage level do you risk a downgrade? Another thing I'd like to understand relates to guidance again. For next year, you expect EBITDA to rise by EUR 40-EUR 50 million. Given that in water, you have EUR 29 million of quality premium for 2018, 2019. If we remove another EUR 12 million, which is the CO2 certificates no longer mandatory for the Terni plant and are helping, but they're one-off, that means another EUR 30 million less. EUR 80-EUR 90 million of EBITDA is going on a like-for-like basis.
Stefano Gamberini
analystIn 2023, where do you expect those to originate? What source scope are we talking about? Question three concerns electricity. If I follow you correctly, waste was meant to deliver EUR 16 million more EBITDA this year. From Terni, I believe that's 0.3 TWh of production. That's roughly 50 to 60 MWh extra. During 2023, the energy price will take a negative hit, since waste is capped. Will the same occur in power gen, where you had EUR 10 million more? ... EUR 50 per MWh, and the other portion did not. What should we expect next year? I'm trying to figure out whether, in year-on-year variations, the energy scenario will in fact negatively affect electrical energy sales. Thank you. Apologies, one last question if I may. The final question is about waste once more. Could you please tell us the type of investment you have in mind for San Vittore's fourth line? How much will be invested there? What EBITDA, and when will we have it? Which year? Once again, the WTE of Rome installation is a separate question. I know it's quite a sensitive issue at the moment, but I'm trying to understand it together with you.
Stefano Gamberini
analystSuppose I put EUR 600 million to EUR 700 million in over the coming 4 years, and EBITDA will only rise by the time those 4 years are up — with the debt structure we have now, how would I be able to finance that CapEx? Thank you.
Fabio Paris
executiveI hope I remember everything. Stefano, if I forget something, just let me know. Now, cash flow — I was mentioning the negative effect we posted. Without that, of course, we would expect our original forecast on working capital, which was more, let's say, optimistic. For operations, we have a cash flow improvement of about EUR 88 million. Which were in our pipeline already. Two more effects have been reported in this period. You've mentioned them as one-off, but let me try and explain this a bit better. Certainly, we did actually have an improvement from selling the CO2 stakes, which was an economic improvement and an improvement of the cash flow too. Also, we cashed in the technical quality bonus for this period, which was about EUR 26 million. That actually accounts for fluctuations in working capital in 2022. I had only talked about the negative side, but actually, there were factors that offset that scenario. As to the guidance on a day, well, actually, we're not considering in this guidance the effects of any possible technical quality bonus for 2023. Because of course, if you're familiar with the regulations, you may know that this technical quality mechanism does not allow us to provide any advanced forecast on the possibility to achieve that goal.
Fabio Paris
executiveThat's the reason we didn't account for it. Let me add, though, that during the fourth quarter the overall scope took a one-off reduction tied to two specific components — GORI, as we highlighted in the slides — amounting to a decrease of roughly EUR 8.5 million, and we're assuming that won't recur in 2023. There's also a separate impact of approximately EUR 13.2 million in Q2 related to end of year liabilities, since local regulators removed certain regulations that had been pending owing to implementation of the transitory tariff system. That dated back to 2018 and 2012, and it had remained pending ever since. Both of these components affected performance, and each was a one-off effect in 2022. They aren't expected to affect 2023. On the energy scenario, as we mentioned earlier, implementation of a tariff cap — which we assume for 2023 — will likely stay unchanged through the year. We assume that cap for the environment area as well. To give you a sense of magnitude for the impact of that gap in the energy scenario for environment, we're assuming a reduction of around EUR 15 million. On the rating impact, talks with the rating agencies are ongoing at present.
Fabio Paris
executiveRegarding Moody's, we actually talked with them about this some time back, and they told us they're comfortable with the rating they have on the group. The fourth line — yes. The fourth line at San Vittore, like we mentioned before, we've just gotten the authorization. At this moment, and with luck we'll wrap up by March, we're finishing the auctions and figuring out which company will construct it. Assuming all goes according to our initial plans, we ought to be in a position to begin construction around the end of the year. At this moment, the CapEx for San Vittore's fourth line ought to be EUR 46 million, and we assume we'll expense that in 2023. Our expectation is that it will take 12 to 18 months before the plant is finished. Per the auction, the entire plan ought to cost roughly EUR 200 million, correct? Yeah, EUR 200 million-EUR 230 million. That ought to be the total investment. The gentleman was asking about EBITDA and about the WTE in Rome. Well, Stefano, as you mentioned, the waste to energy plant of Rome, we did present our project. So far it's what's called a manifestation of interest. On timing, we're going to learn a bit more about it as the city continues working on it.
Fabio Paris
executiveThe schedule for this will hinge on the auction plan, assuming the city of Rome chooses to move forward with this project of ours. That probably won't occur until after the summer. At this moment, there's nothing further we can share with you about it.
Operator
operatorWe’ll go next to Emanuele Oggioni from Kepler Cheuvreux. Please go ahead.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystGood afternoon, and thank you for the presentation. I have a few questions as well. First, I'd like a recap of the moving parts you've assumed for net working capital in 2023. Could you give me a brief summary breaking down the EUR 700 million increase from EUR 4.4 billion to EUR 5.1 billion, or 3.8x? For that additional EUR 700 million in the worst case scenario, how do you break it down? Is this net working capital tied to past regulatory issues in water, or to diluted payments from end customers, or other moving parts, so I can reconcile it better? That's my first question. My second question is on water. At ATO 5 and Gori, EBITDA decreased in 2022. At Gori, this was explained by the absence of tariff increases. Beyond what happened in 2022, I'd like to understand what you expect for ATO 5 and Gori regarding growth of their EBITDA in 2023. On water again, the Terni Water Integrated System. It was supposed to deliver EUR 20 million of EBITDA per year. Here again, 2022 was lower. How much EBITDA do you expect from 2023? I have another question on working capital again. The portion of the EUR 700 million worsening of net working capital — is it due to the negative effect of the worsening of working capital for water?
Emanuele Oggioni
analystGiven energy costs sitting at EUR 280 per MWh, I think at some point you ought to set out a threshold no greater than EUR 180 for generation. If we bring that down by EUR 100, how sensitive would things be? What sort of delta improvement in net working capital might we see? Then, on the moving parts of EBITDA 2023, for organic growth in 2023, that's pretty clear for water and for regulated electricity infrastructures. I'd like some guidance on waste, since we have roughly a EUR 15 million negative impact from waste to energy in 2023 compared with 2022. All in all, I expect waste EBITDA to grow by around EUR 100 million in total in 2023. Could you give us some guidance there? And for retail, do you also expect positive EBITDA performance in 2023, following the very good showing in 2022? Then one last question: any idea when the new plan might come out? Thank you.
Fabio Paris
executiveLet me briefly cover the EUR 700 million figure. That EUR 700 million actually represents the worsening. Within that EUR 700 million, EUR 300 million would stem from e-extra absorption tied to the water supply. Of that EUR 300 million, roughly EUR 150 million — so 50% — comes from supply, and EUR 150 million comes from water. Regarding the other element that absorbs net financial position: between 2019 and 2022, the group's net financial position absorption runs at approximately EUR 460 million-EUR 470 million each year. That is mainly driven by how investments on RAB perform. It's the largest absorption factor. As I noted at the outset, under this assumption there is no space for any strategic measure the group might take, and any such measure would be carried out under the new business plan. On ATO 5 and GORI — I didn't mention this during the presentation — ATO 5 will actually go through a tariff review, a structural tariff review. For 2023, ATO 5's EBITDA should come in at around EUR thirty and a half million. For GORI, we assume approximately EUR 76 million. For ASM Terni, it should be EUR 15 million-EUR 16 million.
Fabio Paris
executiveHere's what we're actually expecting for 2023. On the environment business, we anticipate that performance will be confirmed, and EBITDA for 2023 should be confirmed as well. It now stands above EUR 100 million — that's the overall range we're working with. For commercial and trading, our assumption is that it will come in pretty much flat versus 2022, given the risk containment actions. Because this business can't meet all of demand on its own, there is some risk there, and we're putting actions in place to limit and manage it. When will the business plan be ready? As we speak, I can't give you a specific date, but of course this is the number one priority for the new board, which will take office anytime soon. I'm sure it will be at the top of their agenda. The current business plan is going to come to an end in 2023. Of course, that will be their top priority.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystThanks a lot for those really precise and helpful responses. Sorry, I’ve got a follow-up question on the sensitivity. If energy costs are EUR 280 per MWh and there’s a cap at EUR 180, what would happen to working capital? I think you should recover at least EUR 100 million.
Fabio Paris
executiveHonestly, I can't provide a sensitivity number today, since there are plenty of unknowns regarding where ARERA stands and what they'll decide as things develop. What I can say on behalf of the group is that the positioning shouldn't be worked out using a EUR 180 cap; instead, it ties to the average prices posted over the window ARERA is going to look at. We could definitely lay out plenty of assumptions, but we ought to have clearer visibility on the scenario coming our way shortly. Thank you.
Operator
operatorMs. Angrisani, that brings us to the end of the question queue.
Ira Angrisani
executiveAll right, thanks a lot for joining the call. As always, we’ll be around should you require any additional details. Thank you, Fabio, Stefano, and all of you. Thanks. Goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete ACEA S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to ACEA S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in ACEA S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.