ACEA S.p.A. (ACE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 10, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the conference call covering the nine-month 2023 results. Mr. Palermo, CEO, along with Mrs. Bartolomeo, CFO, will walk you through the key dynamics reported during the first nine months of 2023. Once the presentation wraps up, a Q&A session will follow. Now I'll pass things to the CEO, our chair, for the introductory remarks. So please, sir, the floor is yours.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveThanks a lot, and good afternoon. To begin with, I'd like to offer a brief remark about the especially difficult market conditions we've seen in Italy and across Europe more broadly. Within the target markets, we've observed certain shifts on the regulatory front. Where water is concerned, ARERA launched the consultation on revising the rules governing integrated water service tariffs for the fourth regulatory period, running from 2024 to 2029. Regarding networks and smart cities, the consultation on tariff regulation for electricity distribution for the sixth regulatory period, 2024 to 2027, is still underway. And when it comes to waste, new criteria have been drafted for regulating the waste sector, for non-integrated providers, and the timing of their application remains uncertain. Turning to our commercial activity, the auction for non-vulnerable customers is expected in December 2023, with service due to begin in 2024, and we are still awaiting a formal announcement on that. So across all the areas in which the group operates, we've seen an evolution on the regulatory side, and we don't yet know what impact that evolution will have, particularly with respect to the consultation on water service tariffs, which could have a substantial effect on the group.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveNow, regarding commodity prices and inflation—as you probably know, commodity prices went up again during the quarter. PUN in particular, which is the national electricity reference price, climbed to 116 EUR/MWh in September, a 3% increase over the prior month, while the PUN for Q3 2023 came to 113 EUR/MWh, up 7% compared with the previous two-month period. That said, the PUN fell considerably when you compare it with January through September 2023, a stretch in which it reached 129 EUR per MWh. Inflation for September was up 0.2% month over month and rose 5.3% overall. So inflation from January to September 2023 came in at 7% against 2022. Turning to interest rates—rates were especially difficult because, naturally, they have pushed financial costs higher, and those are up relative to 2022. Here you can see the figures for the four-year mid swap and how 2023 compares with 2022. There is a half percentage point difference between those two periods I just mentioned. So once more, as already noted, the market environment has been challenging when it comes to energy prices and interest rates. And on top of that, there are the upcoming regulatory changes. Even so, the group has held up very well.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveEBITDA increased. On a recurring basis, EBITDA now comes in at EUR 992 million, which is EUR 29 million higher than during the first nine months of 2022. I'm talking about the regulated business here. This result came about largely because we managed operating costs very carefully. Net profit came to EUR 209 million, and excluding one-off items, recurring net profit is up 3%, which shows that the rise in EBITDA allows us to counterbalance higher financial costs caused by increasing interest rates, as well as greater depreciation tied to investments we made over recent years. As I mentioned, the group is holding up very well, and so is net profit, even with interest rates climbing, which the group is offsetting thanks to the attention we give to operating cost. CapEx came to EUR 733 million, higher throughout the regulated business, consistent with the investment plan and with the 2022 average. Those were the key points for the first nine months of 2023, and at this stage I'd like to pass things to Mrs. Di Bartolomeo, who will give us further details.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveGood afternoon. As Mr. Palermo has already mentioned, the first nine months of 2023 were marked by a difficult market, yet the group still achieved growth. EBITDA's organic expansion came chiefly from the regulated business, which represents 87% of total EBITDA at H1 and 88% of our total CapEx. Accordingly, EBITDA in the regulated business rose by more than 6%. CapEx were stepped up again, especially in the regulated business — so Water Italy, Grids and Smart Cities — and net profit increased 3% like for like, thanks to an operating performance that offset higher depreciation and financial costs. Net debt rose to EUR 4,843 million, with a ratio of 3.7%, in line with our guidance. Regarding EBITDA, excluding non-recurring items, please keep in mind that last year we reported roughly EUR 20 million tied to the bonus for technical quality in the water segment, and then there was the exemption from the obligation to purchase CO2 allowances amounting to EUR 8 million. We then report an organic growth that is partly offset by higher energy prices. The decline in the PUN affects the energy sale, and thus it affects the environment business in particular.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveThat was marked by an EBITDA decline, though the regulated business's stronger operating performance made up for it. Now to the net profit slide. Once again, we succeeded in boosting efficiency and expanding the regulated business, which more than compensated for higher depreciation and interest rates—factors that, as you're aware, affected our results to the tune of EUR 54 million in total, yet our operating performance offset those. Kindly keep in mind that 2022 included non-recurring items of approximately EUR 55 million, among them the capital gain from selling our stake in the photovoltaic business known as Energy Box. And then, as I mentioned, the bonus for technical quality and the exemption from the requirement to buy CO2 allowances. Turning to CapEx, as already noted, the group has concentrated especially on the regulated business. Here you can observe how CapEx evolved, with about 88% coming from the regulated business—specifically water, electricity, and environment. That's because the group has faith in these activities, which represent the group's core business. Better grids, and upgrades to those grids, will prove to be an asset for the entire country, and will also mean improved service for our customers.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveOur investments have gone chiefly toward extraordinary upkeep of plants and networks. We're concentrating especially on the purification systems, along with repairing and widening the water and sewage pipes. That's the priority we've kept investing in. We're well on track and, when it comes to CapEx, actually aligned with last year, and we'll keep going down this road through year-end. Turning to cash flow, this time we're showing it in a different way. We're giving probably more detail than we did previously. As you can see here, the group succeeded in generating EUR 24 million of operating free cash flow. That bears witness to the group's capacity to absorb high CapEx levels, EUR 733 million, an improvement of EUR 112 million compared with 2022. Cash flow before M&A and IFRS 16 mostly mirrors the outflows for dividends and financial charges after the interest rise. Still, we're devoting the greatest attention to cash flow. Cash flow is a further priority. We'll keep concentrating on optimizing our cash flow so as to deliver better performance relative to earlier years.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveOn debt structure, we're reaffirming our guidance. Our average cost of debt comes in at approximately 2%. Beyond what we already announced on the prior conference call, we've made no further issuances. Fixed rate debt makes up the bulk of our borrowings, which is standard practice for companies in regulated sectors. And as you can see, our duration — the average duration — stands at 4.5 years, which means we'll be in a position to offset the rise in financial costs. Turning to the business units. For Water Italy, we posted organic EBITDA growth of 6%. That was driven almost entirely by tariff adjustments, along with some extra efficiency we were able to deliver across the group. On CapEx, we have favored investments in the regulated businesses, as I noted earlier. So in water, we see CapEx up 7% versus the prior year. Total RAB as of December 31, 2022, was EUR 3.8 billion. Now on to grids and smart cities. EBITDA rose 6%, so we reported meaningful EBITDA growth, powered by organic growth of about EUR 15 million. And that 15 million includes a couple of million in higher cost efficiency.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveTo reiterate what I said earlier, the group's current emphasis is on cost efficiency. Capital expenditures went up during the second half of the year. In the first half we had been running somewhat behind, though by now we've caught up nearly completely. Turning to RAB, it stood at EUR 2.5 billion as of the 31st of December, 2022. On the environment business, as holds true for all our competitors, environmental services constitute a segment under pressure, chiefly because of energy prices. Plainly, selling energy at a price far below the prior year's level inevitably affects the revenues of the environment business and, therefore, affects that business's EBITDA. In addition, compost disposal prices affect Acea's environment business revenue, since they fell over the first nine months of the year. Our hope is that during the final part of the year, those prices — the compost prices — can recover. On CapEx, we are aligned with the prior year. Regarding the environment business, in January, 35% of the stake in Deco, in Abruzzo, was acquired, and the group now holds 100% of Deco, while 70% of Tecnoservizi, a separate company, was acquired by the group.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveSo that's how this year differs from last year. On the production side, just like what happened in the environment business, the EBITDA decline comes almost entirely from the energy situation, once you strip out the effect of higher output. Put differently, we did manage to raise volumes, particularly in photovoltaic and hydroelectric energy. Sadly, energy prices were far lower this year, and that has inevitably pushed the EBITDA in this business down. On CapEx, it comes to EUR 31 million, basically in line with last year. In fact, it's EUR 5 million above this year versus 2022. That said, we've seen growth in authorized megawatts under construction and ready to build, which hit 280 megawatts, and installed capacity now stands at 101 megawatts. Turning to the commercial business, EBITDA rose 44%, driven largely by the LD scenario, but also by the strong focus on cutting costs, and by the policy we adopted of shifting the risk — the energy risk — onto the customer. So we swapped the fixed-tariff contract for contracts whose tariffs are driven by the price of energy, and that has let us lift our EBITDA while also shielding the group if price fluctuations occur.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveWe've also observed growth in our electricity customer count, and keeping the customers we have matters to us — which is why we'll watch the auctions very closely. Those auctions are set for December, though their effects will be felt in the months after. At this point, I'll hand things over to the CEO. I trust my presentation has covered everything, and I believe we're ready to begin the Q&A session now.
Operator
operatorThe operator here. The Q&A portion can begin at this point. Should you want to pose a question, dial star and then one on your phone. Pressing star and then two will remove you from the waiting queue. Kindly use your headsets when posing your questions. You may press star and then one at this time if you would like to pose a question. Our first question comes from Javier Suarez at Mediobanca.
Javier Suárez
analystGood evening, and thanks a lot for the presentation. I appreciate you taking my questions. Actually, I have three or four of them. The first one concerns the business plan update. When do you expect to update it? And why hasn't the business plan been disclosed yet? What issues must be resolved before you can disclose the new plan — setting aside the regulations and the consultations currently under way — is it all connected, or does that decision hinge on the waste-to-energy plant in Rome, or are there other reasons the business plan hasn't been disclosed so far? Then I'd like you to elaborate on the Rome project. We've seen the project's cost rise considerably. What about the cost of the Rome project, and how will the capital invested in it be remunerated? That was my first question. My second question is this: we heard the CEO mention the substantial investments you're making in the water business. So, is the group willing to become more nationwide in that business?
Javier Suárez
analystAnd if that's the case, what sort of changes would Acea need to make in order to become a nationwide player? Then the third question has to do with working capital. On page ten, could you expand a bit more on page ten? What steps is management taking so that the negative absorption of working capital can be gone by the end of the year, or at least next year? Thank you very much.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveAll right, and thanks so much for the questions. On the business plan, I think several factors need to be weighed. Our intention is to have a new plan finalized by the end of January. As has been reported in the press, the group has undergone major changes — and not just management turnover at every level — and at this point the new managerial team, myself included, is developing a business plan that obviously needs to be owned by this new management team. Beyond that, we are still awaiting certain decisions from the authority, since those decisions will have a major effect on our businesses. So, to produce a properly thought-through business plan, we chose to hold off until those decisions are adopted. This has nothing to do with the waste-to-energy plant, which is headed in an entirely separate direction, so to speak. Regarding the waste-to-energy plant, we submitted a bid on March 1. Ours was the sole bid, partly owing to significant time constraints. After our bid, however, a consultation took place with the municipality of Rome to pin down the various elements of the project, which a technical committee reviewed.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveAfter that, we fine-tuned the project, and as a result, costs came down too. So the final request for bids ought to launch soon—shortly, in fact. And once that happens, we'll see how things go. A second bidding round is scheduled for May, and following that the tender will be awarded. Our bid's quality gives us confidence that Acea is well placed and very likely to win the tender. On your second question, I'd say Acea already operates nationwide in the water business. We're in a great many Italian regions. By size, we rank first. Compared with any other player in Italy, we're considerably bigger. Acquedotto Pugliese holds the second spot. At present we serve nine million water customers, and we work across a great many Italian regions. Everywhere we operate, we've managed to enhance operations, and ARERA's assessments attest to this—assessments that have also rewarded us economically, so to speak. Water is certainly among the group's top businesses. Not the sole one, naturally, as you're aware.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveEnergy and smart cities and the environment make up the remaining two core businesses. So as we look ahead, the group intends to keep moving in this direction, just as we set out in the strategic guidelines we announced this past July. We therefore reaffirm the overall course we are on. Turning to your final question, during recent months especially, and following the arrival of a new management team, we have shown that we can, you know, handle cash flow more effectively, and we are confident this will produce solid results. That said, you know, this is certainly not a simple job, but we are taking action at every level available to us. So we are. Our approach to cash flow has changed, and we are rolling that approach out across all the group's various entities and all the businesses in the places where the group operates.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot. Emanuele Oggioni from Kepler Cheuvreux has the next question.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystGood evening, and thanks a lot for the presentation. I have a couple of questions. First, once more, on the guidance: if I recall correctly, the water bonuses aren't part of the guidance. So the bonus you got recently came to EUR 25 million. That was, I mean, awarded a few weeks back, and it will be factored in during Q4, so we thought this bonus would mean the guidance gets confirmed at the high end or even above the range. Then, a second point I'd like you to specify: how much working capital will you be able to recover in Q4? And so, is your guidance on debt lower than 3.8 conservative or not?
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveOkay, let me begin with what you asked at the end. Fabrizio mentioned this too — our attention stays fixed on how we manage cash flow. And as we've said before, that is not simple at all, given that ours is a regulated business. We truly hope we'll surprise you in a good way, and we will certainly give our utmost so that shareholders are rewarded. And so that our shareholders are pleased. So what we've been doing includes watching expenses closely as well. Whether we can beat our guidance — I can't say that today — but we will certainly give our utmost to hit our targets.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorMoving on to the next question, which comes from Stefano Gamberini at Equita.
Stefano Gamberini
analystThanks so much, and good evening. I’ve got a few questions as well regarding the full-year guidance. First, you reaffirmed the EBITDA guidance. We’re looking at EUR 25 million more than expected. But could you give us guidance on adjusted EBITDA, given that you’ve now also provided some adjusted figures—what might adjusted EBITDA be for 2022 and for the full year 2023? My second question—and I apologize for bringing this up again—is about the year-over-year worsening of leverage. Earlier this year, the issue was the energy scenario, so the previous management issued that guidance because the implied energy price was above 200 EUR per kWh, which is no longer the case now. So the EUR 400 million of worsening in working capital and other items that, if the guidance is confirmed, leads to that 3.8 debt-to-EBITDA—what are the causes? Is it water? Is it energy? If it’s sales or distribution, does that have any impact? And my third question: can you help us better understand the strong performance in the water business—if we exclude the equity-consolidated companies, you have 11% growth; why?
Stefano Gamberini
analystWhat was behind that growth? And regarding grids and smart cities, my impression is that in Q3 we reported double-digit growth. What are the reasons you posted such a strong growth number? And can we expect that growth to stay at that level going forward as well? And then one last question: it matters to us to understand whether the 2022 dividends could serve as a floor for 2023, or whether you are still, so to speak, discussing this point within the board. Thank you very much.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveTo start with, the bonuses — the water bonus for this year — come to between EUR 28 million and EUR 29 million, and they sit inside EBITDA. So the EBITDA serving as the guidance base was the budget, and that budget already baked in certain efficiencies — substantial ones, especially across all the P&L cost lines. Given that, issuing a different guidance today would be tough. That's the reason we're pushing to hit our budget targets. So far, let's put it this way: we've managed to keep our shareholders happy. Without question, we're on track — well on track with our budget — and we're delivering what we promised. We're moving forward along the lines already announced, and we've managed to improve quarter-on-quarter. On leverage: leverage was announced at below 3.8. Right now we're at 3.7. As I've already said to the other analysts, we'll keep improving it. So we're on track. The guidance stays the same. We're on track with the guidance as it stands. And as I mentioned, we may deliver a surprise by the end of the year. The water business and the grids as smart cities business are performing very well, and that's thanks to the tariff policies and the regulatory framework.
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveWe’ve also been able to take inflation pressure on costs into account by giving the closest possible attention to cost efficiency. And our focus is on those costs that we really could bring down, and that is why we’re seeing this improvement, which likely isn’t as evident with other players. As for dividends, well, that’s something I certainly can’t comment on, since this is a point that has not yet been discussed within the board of directors, so I cannot answer that question.
Stefano Gamberini
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, nothing is currently queued on the question list. As a matter of fact, Javier Suarez has sent in one more question. We also have a follow-up question.
Javier Suárez
analystI really do apologize—sorry about that. I have a couple of questions regarding the regulatory framework. We’ve heard that the consultation on water service tariffs still isn’t clear. So I’d like to find out whether you anticipate an upgrade for water services like the one seen for the grids in July. And then, could you please comment on the document that ARERA published and what effect it might have on your business?
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveOkay, regarding the water business, once again, I think that the ARERA consultation—which we took part in—allowed us to put together several proposals on how service tariffs, water service tariffs, ought to be updated, in our view. I think that document contains some interesting insight, and if it gets implemented, the outcome would be a far more modern system, but also one that would make investments easier and faster. So the consultations are still going on. We don't know what the final outcome will be, but certainly, several proposals for improvement have been put forward. And I really hope that some of those proposals will be taken into account. And the ARERA consultation is intended to improve the service tariffs, the water service tariffs, to improve the entire system of water tariffs. So I do expect this consultation to produce some improvement. The scope and size of that improvement, well, it's too early to say. But at least we are seeing serious and well-structured consultations with ARERA, and we have been among the leading parties in this, because we are one of the largest water players in Italy. And I do believe that the final outcome will be a system that will be able to meet the players', the market players', requirements.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveNow turning to Grids and Smart Cities. Regarding the ROSS — we think putting the ROSS to use could benefit businesses that place a priority on efficiency, and therefore it may represent a solid opportunity. Naturally, the rules are still in draft form and continue to be revised. So, I'd say that for efficient companies, the ROSS presents an opportunity.
Javier Suárez
analystThe last thing I wanted to ask about is the group's debt. Clearly, Acea has an investment opportunity here, though it does align with what the country requires, since the country needs significant investment in the water system. So at present we carry low debt as far as the water business goes, and that is bound to come down. But what would be the ideal debt level for Acea?
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveSure, that's accurate. There is a need for national investment in water and the water system, and significant opportunities exist in this area. The water business is regulated, and regulated businesses carry multiples that differ from ours, along with notably higher leverage. As was mentioned earlier, we continue to keep a close watch on our debt. We have no desire for our debt to rise past what we consider a sensible leverage level. Still, if we consider Acea's infrastructures, for example, we would want Acea to be viewed just like any other player that has infrastructures.
Javier Suárez
analystAll right, thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorDavide Candela from Intesa Sanpaolo has the next question.
Davide Candela
analystGood evening, and many thanks for taking my question. Actually, I have two questions here. The first one concerns the full year 2023, the full year financials, and net profit in particular. Assuming the EBITDA guidance is met, we know there are financial costs beneath the net profit line that can have an impact. So what about your net profit?
Sabrina Di Bartolomeo
executiveFrom what I understand, the consensus figure right now sits at roughly EUR 295 million, and in my view that's a bit on the high side, so it would help me to hear what you have to say about that net profit for the full year 2023 and how it stacks up against 2022. And after that, could you put a number on the regulatory working capital you expect to recover, whether that happens this year or in the years that follow? So on net profit, we do confirm the consensus. We're well on track, and we will do our utmost to hit that EUR 295 million target. Obviously, the rise in interest rates has driven a substantial increase in financial costs, so we'll do our best. That's what I can tell you on your first question. Regarding the regulatory net working capital, the tariff increase we're expecting ought to release some room — free up some room — for recovery. Right now we don't have the definitive figures, so I can't tell you how much we'll manage to recover. Our goal, then, is to recover a substantial amount over the coming three, four years. So clearly this is something we're monitoring with the greatest attention.
Operator
operatorIf you have additional questions, you can press star then one on your phone. Ladies and gentlemen, there are no questions — we have no further questions.
Fabrizio Palermo
executiveAll right, many thanks for joining our conference call. Should you have any additional requests, the investor relations team is available to help. Thanks again, and enjoy your evening.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete ACEA S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to ACEA S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in ACEA S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.