Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust (APUN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 30, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello everyone, and thank you for joining the Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust conference call covering our first quarter 2020 earnings. Please be aware that this call is being recorded today. At this point, I'll hand things over to your host, Mr. Michael Emory. Go right ahead, sir.
Michael Emory
executiveThanks, Elaine. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to our conference call. Joining me on the line are Tom, Cecilia, and Hugh, and we'll be discussing Allied's results for the first quarter ended March 31, 2020. During this conference call, we might make forward-looking statements regarding future events or future performance. By their nature, such statements carry risks and uncertainties that could cause actual events or results to differ materially, including the risks outlined under the heading Risks and Uncertainties in our most recently filed annual information form and in our latest quarterly report. Material assumptions underlying any forward-looking statements we make include those set out under Forward-Looking Disclaimer in our most recent quarterly report. As you know, a global pandemic overshadowed the first quarter of 2020, forcing people around the world to confront a sudden and severe public health crisis. Governments, businesses, and citizens have put in place extreme physical distancing measures in an effort to mitigate the spread of a novel virus, COVID-19. The physical distancing measures necessary to mitigate the spread of the virus have caused severe economic disruption. Governments and central banks worldwide have provided massive economic stimulus to counter the disruption and are likely to provide additional stimulus going forward.
Michael Emory
executiveAlthough that’s a favorable sign for recovery, we simply cannot forecast right now how long the present economic slump will last or how severe it will be. The global pandemic and the economic disruption that followed did not affect Allied’s first quarter results. During the quarter we drove robust growth both internally and externally, with a mid-single-digit percentage rise in same-asset NOI, FFO per unit, and AFFO per unit, plus an 11.7% gain in NAV per unit. Cecilia will go into more detail on our financial results and will also cover our balance sheet and our near-term outlook. Tom will then give an overview of leasing and operations. Hugh will provide a development update. I’ll wrap up with a few remarks about our long-term outlook. I’ll now hand things over to Cecilia.
Cecilia Williams
executiveGood morning. I'll walk you through our financial results, our balance sheet, and the internal forecast for 2020 that we've revised. Let me start with the financial results. This quarter ranked among the strongest we've ever had. We delivered CAD 0.58 of FFO per unit, and that figure even includes CAD 587,000 in non-recurring condo marketing costs at King Toronto. Our annualized quarterly EBITDA hit a record CAD 343 million. Thanks to rent growth in Montreal along with gains in both rent and occupancy in Toronto, same asset NOI for the first quarter rose 4.3% versus the same quarter a year earlier, which drove 5.2% growth in normalized AFFO per unit. Now turning to the balance sheet. With development, NOI growth, and strength in our core markets behind it, NAV per unit as of March 31st came in 11.7% higher than a year ago. At the end of the quarter, net debt to EBITDA stood at 6.8x, and total debt was 27% of IFRS value. Both metrics sit inside our targeted range. Interest coverage was 3.3x, moving toward our goal of 4x. Our ratio of unsecured to secured debt was 2.1x at quarter end, with unsecured debt making up 67% of total debt. At quarter end, unencumbered assets totaled CAD 6 billion, which is 73% of our investment properties.
Cecilia Williams
executiveWith The Landing closed as of last week, the pool stands at CAD 6.2 billion, making up 74% of our investment properties. As mortgages mature, we plan to keep prepaying or repaying them, aiming to leave most of our asset base unencumbered. Our view is that this gives us the strongest and most flexible balance sheet, both defensively and offensively — whether responding to shifting market conditions, acting on acquisition opportunities, or financing development activity. Finally, turning to the short-term outlook. Our first quarter results cannot be viewed in isolation when framing an outlook for the rest of 2020. We expect some downward pressure on rental revenue in the near term stemming from the global pandemic and the economic disruption it has caused. The best indicator of what to expect in the second quarter is April rent collection, the first full month with physical distancing measures in place across Canada. Gross monthly rent due in April came to CAD 54 million. Of that, 74.4% is from office use, 15.4% from urban data center use, 7% from retail use, and 3.2% from parking use. Given the current economic disruption, we have granted a one-month rent deferral to users in genuine financial need, which for us includes a significant portion of our retail users and a very small portion of our office users in early stages of business development.
Cecilia Williams
executiveFor May, we anticipate offering those users yet another deferral of rent covering one month. As of now, 90% of the total amount due in April has been collected, and we have provided one-month deferrals amounting to CAD 4.2 million, equal to 8% of the total amount due. That leaves 2% of April's total amount due still to be collected. We are actively working to collect these amounts and anticipate succeeding in most cases. Activity among users of our UDC space jumped in late March and continued at elevated levels through April. Usage of our meet-me rooms and cross-connection capability is climbing in step, along with demand for extra power, which we are able to supply profitably in meaningful quantities. We anticipate this surge will deliver a boost to our 2020 earnings and an even more material boost to earnings over the longer term. We expect we will be able to quantify this more fully at the time we report second quarter results. From all of the above, it is clear that we will see some erosion in rental revenue over the remainder of 2020, mainly through turnover vacancy in space we had originally expected to remain productive for all of 2020. We do not think the near-term erosion will be material, particularly given probable positive offsets arising from our UDC space and other parts of our operations.
Cecilia Williams
executiveOriginally, our internal forecast for 2020 anticipated mid-single digit percentage growth in same-asset NOI, FFO per unit, and AFFO per unit, each of them. Given the global pandemic and the economic disruption that followed, our revised internal forecast for 2020 now anticipates flat to mid-single digit percentage growth in each of same-asset NOI, FFO per unit, and AFFO per unit. In 2020, we expect to deploy a substantial amount of capital, with the same strategic coherence and discipline that we showed in 2019. Over the course of 2020, we're committed to allocating CAD 335 million toward development and value-add activity, and we expect to put additional capital toward accretive acquisitions. There are significant areas of uncertainty surrounding our revised internal forecast. The biggest one is that we cannot predict how long the physical distancing measures currently in place across Canada will last. We also cannot predict how consumers will respond in the near term once physical distancing measures are lifted or relaxed. I'll now hand the call over to Tom, who will discuss our leasing and operating activities.
Tom Burns
executiveThank you, Cecilia. The leasing momentum we saw in 2019 carried over into Q1, and activity stayed strong through mid-March, when it started to taper off, although a lot of lease negotiations are still ongoing. All told, leased area across our workspace portfolio stands at 95%. Average rents on space that was renewed or replaced rose considerably in Q1, reflecting a 24% increase on the affected area. During the quarter and into April, we finished a number of significant renewals and made leasing headway on our development projects. I'll give you brief highlights on leasing activity across our major markets, but I wanted to devote most of this call to how the Allied team has been operating through this unprecedented period. Here are a few leasing highlights, workspace first, then UDC. Beginning in Montreal, we signed a 15,000 sq ft lease with Beanfield at 3575 Saint-Laurent. After the quarter ended, Unity committed to a 35,000 sq ft expansion at Le Nordelec. We're continuing to work with Mulafachy & Gensler on plans for the repositioning of 700 DLG. At quarter end, our Montreal portfolio was 93% leased. In Toronto, we kept up discussions with one of our major tenants regarding an additional pre-leasing commitment of 60,000 square feet at The Well. Our rental portfolio in Toronto is 99% leased.
Tom Burns
executiveIn Calgary, we achieved solid progress and are currently wrapping up a renewal of 45,000 square feet, while also nearing the finish line on three leases totaling 12,000 square feet at Telus Sky. Leasing across our Calgary portfolio stands at 90%, which is considerably higher than typical levels. Over in Vancouver, two tenants that had committed to pre-leasing at 400 West Georgia have now exercised their options to take more space, bringing that project to 95% pre-leased. Our Vancouver rental portfolio is likewise 95% leased. With the balance of office demand and supply in Toronto and Vancouver, we anticipate rental rates will keep facing upward pressure through the rest of 2020. In Montreal, we foresee demand staying robust, although the demand-supply situation there creates less upward pressure on our rates. Moving to our UDC portfolio, we signed a renewal shortly after the quarter ended with our biggest single tenant at 250 Front. That 60,000 sq ft lease now runs until August 31st, 2022. As Cecilia noted earlier, our data center space has seen greater usage throughout the pandemic. Every bit of available space at 151 Front is currently being negotiated. Now on to the team. Even while navigating the countless challenges brought about by the global pandemic, the Allied team has risen to the occasion in numerous ways.
Tom Burns
executiveDespite the fact that we've been apart physically, we've stayed in constant contact. Here are just a few remarks on how every one of our departments keeps pitching in. The technology team has ensured we possess every tool needed for communication. Answering questions—chiefly regarding security—while rents are being collected is something our property managers have handled remarkably well. Our accounting team has delivered in a major way, finishing 2019 year-end adjustments and putting together all the figures for our Q1 report in under 30 days from quarter end. Our UDC team hasn't skipped a beat in rolling out new protocols for building access within a strictly controlled setting that must stay fully operational under any circumstances. A weekly newsletter for building users has been produced by our experience team. They've additionally readied a thorough package cataloguing every avenue of government assistance to distribute to their building users. Tracking our performance internally remains a focus for our asset management team, which also monitors our accounts receivable on a daily basis. Daily updates on the virus in every one of our operating regions are supplied by our talent team. That team has, in fact, brought on three new employees amid the shutdown. Virtual tours of vacant space are being developed by our leasing team to keep connections alive with the brokerage community and prospective tenants.
Tom Burns
executiveThere are dozens of deals currently under discussion throughout the portfolio. Every single day, our operations supervisors and building operators are on-site at the properties. Finally, we promoted Doug Riches to Senior Vice President, National Operations. As many of you are aware, Doug has handled our UDC operations with great skill since 2009. Doug will keep overseeing our urban data centers, but he will now also focus on our workspace portfolio. In time, the best practices and policies across our UDC and workspace portfolios will be completely integrated. I'll now hand the call over to Hugh for an update on development activities.
Hugh Clark
executiveThanks, Tom. COVID-19 has certainly had an effect on our construction activity, but we've still managed to move several projects forward during this quarter. I'll start with a quick look at how physical distancing has impacted our construction projects, and then I'll give a brief overview of other preparatory work we've kicked off. Construction activity. How much progress we've been able to make on construction projects has differed across the country. In Montreal, all construction activity had to be halted temporarily, though it looks now like it will get going again in May. In Toronto, Calgary, and Vancouver, certain projects have carried on with minimal impact, while others have continued with a more material impact. A few of the smaller projects have come to a complete stop. In Montreal, for both 425 Viger and Le Nordelec, our base building work had been finished before the construction moratorium came into force. That has considerably lessened the impact on Allied. Some small-scale landlord work projects and relocation projects have had to be put off. Our team has been working proactively alongside our consultants and contractors to get ready for the pending recommencements. In Toronto and Kitchener, most of our projects fall within the permitted activities of the Ontario government.
Hugh Clark
executiveThe Well, 19 Duncan, and College and Manning are mixed-use developments, and all of them keep moving forward, albeit somewhat more slowly. When physical distancing rules first came in, we saw a short-term decrease in workers, but things have bounced back over the last two weeks or so. At present, we anticipate a potential delay of two to three weeks to the timelines on those projects. Both our King and Spadina project and Breithaupt Block phase three have taken a hit. Neither one falls clearly within the province's exemptions. As a result, construction work at those sites has been scaled back. Once the moratorium ends, we'll evaluate how these project schedules are affected. Down in Calgary and Vancouver, building work carries on for the residential levels of Telus Sky. Manpower has fallen substantially, and that has pushed back occupancy for the building's upper portion. We did manage to secure occupancy for the office levels. That upper-floor occupancy delay will impact our residential rental timeline. We've moved the expected launch of that program to late summer. Meanwhile, work continues without slowdown at 400 West Georgia, the WAHI building, and the Sun Tower restoration.
Hugh Clark
executiveOn the planning side, although construction has been affected by the pandemic, we've still managed to move forward with planning for future development. In Montreal, work continues on the early planning for the multi-phased intensification of Lenoir West. In Toronto, we're in the final design stages for King and Brant as well as Adelaide and Spadina. COVID-19 has affected progress on our construction projects, but fortunately the impact has been minimal. The third-party contractors working on our projects have done a great job moving things forward while making sure workers follow protocols for their safety. I'll now hand the call back to Michael.
Michael Emory
executiveThank you, Hugh. From where I sit, the valuation that equity markets are assigning to publicly traded real estate companies has become, to a substantial degree, untethered from the actual worth of the properties underneath. During Allied's 17 years of operating as a public real estate entity, I have witnessed this pattern on multiple occasions. Each time, property values refused to track the equity markets downward; instead, within a fairly brief stretch, the equity markets realigned upward with the value of the underlying real estate — and that is precisely the outcome I anticipate on this occasion. Our conviction in, and dedication to, the plan of consolidating and intensifying unique urban workspace and network-led UDCs across Canada's major cities remains deep. It is our strong view that the most significant secular trends shaping Canadian and global real estate form the foundation of that strategy, and that neither the global pandemic nor what follows it will change those trends in any meaningful respect. We are equally firm in our belief that the properties, financial strength, people, and platform we possess are what is required to carry out our strategy for the continued benefit of our unitholders. In closing, no element of Allied's vision or mission has been, nor will it be, weakened by the global pandemic and its aftermath, in my view.
Michael Emory
executiveCities aren't going to empty out, and people won't grow any less social. Social creatures are what we are, and that won't change. Awareness of wellness and sustainability is going to be sharper than it has ever been, though for those who build cities it is in no way a new development. And maybe the biggest point for our vision and mission: the men and women who make up knowledge-based organizations are not about to flee en masse to home offices outfitted with technology. In fact, as one insightful Canadian observed, COVID-19 has forever shattered the dream of working from home. Working from home was never a dream of mine, and it never will be, yet I believe that Canadian is completely right. I hope this update has served you well and given you a thorough picture during this extraordinary period. At this point we would be glad to take whatever questions you might have.
Operator
operatorThank you. Ladies and gentlemen, should you wish to pose a question, kindly press the star or asterisk key and then the digit 1 on your phone. Please make sure the mute function on your telephone is turned off so that your signal can reach our equipment. Should you discover that your question has already been answered, you are welcome to remove yourself from the queue by pressing star two. Once again, please press star one to ask a question. Our first question today comes from Jonathan Kelcher of TD Securities. Please go ahead.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAppreciate it, and good morning, everyone.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystStarting with the data centers — my first question. Am I right in thinking you expect the higher power and interconnection fees to largely cover whatever softness shows up in the rental portfolio? Is that the whole story, or do you also see some leasing gains pitching in on that front?
Michael Emory
executiveWhat we're mainly expecting is that the UDC revenue we hadn't counted on for 2020 will make up for part of the turnover vacancy we believe we could see during 2020. That would be the main offset.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystIs it reasonable to characterize the interconnection revenue as being mostly 250 Front and power, and that the power increase would come from both 250 Front and 151?
Michael Emory
executiveThose interconnection fees would come from 250 Front and 905 King. We also expect increases in rack revenue and conduit revenue from 151 Front. So it's those three elements combined, along with the fact that a number of the users we anticipate will need more power, and we're able to supply that. Naturally, the rent they pay is determined by power rather than square footage. We convert it into square footage just because that's the terminology we're most used to employing. In reality, it's how much power is available that determines the rent paid, and as we raise that, existing users pay more rent.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right. So with the time-of-use savings Ontario currently has, are you actually getting any benefit from those, or does that get passed along?
Michael Emory
executiveThere could be an advantage for us from the hydro reduction. We're examining that, though the majority of it would flow through — perhaps not the entirety, yet most would flow through to benefit the users.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAlright. And then second, the lease extension you completed at quarter-end — that seems fairly short. Could you perhaps shed some light on the reason it was only an 18-month extension?
Michael Emory
executiveThe actual count is two, and Tom—who led that effort together with Ben Richards—is well positioned to address it.
Tom Burns
executiveJonathan, that is exactly how the option was drafted. They exercised it at 2 years. They still had 3 years remaining. They moved forward for 2 years.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right. Are you still going to be doing more work with them on another extension?
Tom Burns
executiveWe will be. Well, not at this moment, but we will be.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right, thank you very much.
Michael Emory
executiveJonathan, my read is that this specific tenant intends to raise its demands regarding the facility, and it managed to carry out a 2-year extension without needing to negotiate that with us. We absolutely anticipate that this tenant will keep occupying the space considerably past that 2-year extension, but as part of that it will be raising what it expects from us and from how the facility operates across the coming 2 years. We are completely ready for that and thoroughly familiar with it. Because of that, the tenant did not wish to take more than 2 years of renewal, and 2 years was the sole basis on which renewal could be exercised. Under its lease it had flexibility, and for those reasons it selected that flexibility, which is not a bad thing whatsoever. In fact, it was structured to assist us and to help us move toward a stricter facilities management protocol going forward, which I believe will keep them there for a very lengthy period of time.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right, many thanks. I’ll hand it back over.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question comes from Mario Saric at Scotiabank. Go ahead, please.
Mario Saric
analystMorning, Mario.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, Mario. Have the odds been adjusted by you?
Mario Saric
analystClearly, I haven't. That's something we'll need to address once more. Turning to operations, there's 1 million square feet still set to expire between now and the end of 2020, and that figure includes 320,000 square feet across Montreal and Toronto. My understanding is that Allied reported mark-to-market had closed at 17% against 24% as of the close of Q1. Could you describe what the renewal conversations are looking like and maybe what typical lease terms tenants are considering? In the current environment, are you noticing any interest in extending leases for shorter periods? And on a net effective rent basis, what caused the 17% to decline?
Michael Emory
executiveMario, apologies—there's a bit of an echo on your line, and the question didn't come through clearly to me. I caught only portions of it. Would you mind saying it again? Sorry about that.
Mario Saric
analystLet me give it another shot. Does that work better?
Michael Emory
executiveRight, that's somewhat improved. If you could raise your voice slightly, that would help.
Mario Saric
analystYour question related to that million square feet coming up for expiry by the end of 2020. I'm just wondering what appetite tenants are showing — perhaps for shorter lease terms when they renew — and given the 17% mark-to-market you've disclosed year-over-year, how that might appear on a net effective rent basis.
Michael Emory
executiveAt this point, we see nothing suggesting that individuals or users facing renewal are looking to shorten the terms of their renewals. Actually, it's the reverse. At present, we have zero signals that net effective rates upon renewal will land under what we expect. All of what we negotiated during the shutdown has aligned with our own internal forecast. We still see no sign of users seeking better renewal terms because of the global pandemic situation and the economic disruption that followed. Given how supply and demand work in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver, that strikes me as quite logical. In Toronto, there's still nearly a sense of desperation among those needing bigger office spaces. By bigger, I mean 50,000 square feet or more. Such spaces are extremely scarce. Plenty of people require them. Because of that, we anticipate no meaningful change in how people are willing to commit to new space or renew space they already have. Over the past two or three years, we have never encountered pushback regarding the rising rental rates or the timeframe we sought for a renewal.
Michael Emory
executiveWe haven't seen any sign of that so far. That isn't to say those kinds of demands won't come up, but right now, there's nothing pointing to it whatsoever.
Mario Saric
analystYeah. Okay. My next question concerns capital deployment. Looking back, roughly almost 10 years have passed since the GFC, and around that period, I believe Allied as an entity was considering external growth opportunities and weighing international expansion into what were then typically termed Class I buildings against broadening the opportunity set within market nodes. The path chosen back then was to stick with the market nodes. I just wanted to dig a little more into what you said about the gap between public and private market valuations and your expectation for closing acquisitions during the year. Could you perhaps give some context or color on those remarks, and on whether you think Allied as an organization might be able to use the crisis you're seeing today to perhaps expand internationally sooner than you otherwise would have expected?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a fair question. We definitely recognize the economic climate we're currently in, and we anticipate it staying negative for a while, which gives us chances we wouldn't have had in a more typical economic setting. I think those will mostly be infill opportunities in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver. Maybe Calgary too, though there they'll be quite small, just as they've been historically. I don't view this as a springboard for Allied to move into other markets. It very well could generate opportunities in those other markets that Allied would be suited to chase, but our sense is that we have such an abundance of opportunity in the major Canadian cities we're concentrated on that looking beyond those cities—and certainly beyond Canada—for growth prospects in the near term, which I'd roughly describe as three to five years, would be a misallocation of capital. I simply don't consider that appropriate for a company with such strength in Canada's major cities, and I believe we'll keep having meaningful opportunities to grow. Perhaps because of the economic downturn, those opportunities could be more financially attractive than they'd be in a normal market.
Michael Emory
executiveNo — to put it plainly, that's not how we're viewing this. We don't regard it as a springboard for broadening where we operate geographically.
Mario Saric
analystGot it. Alright, so perhaps a brief follow-up regarding the public versus private discussion. Would you see this, then, as a chance to maybe buy back units somewhat more aggressively than you've done previously?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a great question, and the short answer is no. Our NCIB has only ever been used for our long-term incentive compensation program — nothing else — and to my mind, that isn't a suitable way for a company like ours to allocate capital. I believe we'll be fairly valued within a reasonable timeframe. That's been the pattern historically. Buying back our units isn't something we believe in, even when they're trading at a discount in the market right now. Our view is that we can put capital to work building the business and augmenting the portfolio, which will be far more productive over time. I don't see us going down that road.
Mario Saric
analystAlright, my final question returns to the data centers and ties in with what Jonathan asked before. There's a comment or expectation about a material boost for 2021, but maybe an even bigger longer-term effect on the company's cash flows arising from this. Do you believe this crisis, in some ways, makes it easier for you to take on the remaining roughly 56,000 square feet of availability at 250 Front, or are those two things independent of each other?
Michael Emory
executiveActually, I do think it does. In my view, demand for space and power will go up, and those two things are intertwined, as you know. I genuinely believe it will let us expand the ecosystem at 250 Front. As Tom said, the turnover vacancy at 151 Front that we have — which, I believe, we flagged when we set out our 2020 forecast on February 5th — is in fact being negotiated with tenants who will strengthen the 151 Front ecosystem in a very, very meaningful way. Over time, we would expect the same thing to happen at 250 Front. So I suppose the answer is yes and yes.
Mario Saric
analystAll right, thanks, Michael.
Michael Emory
executiveAppreciate that, Mario.
Operator
operatorThanks. Thanks. Our following question comes from Jenny Ma at BMO Capital Markets. Go right ahead.
Jenny Ma
analystHello, and good morning to all of you. To build on what we discussed regarding the data centers, that near-term additional lift you anticipate from this sub-segment — how much of that would you view as variable, for example power usage? As you consider how you expect it to counter a portion of turnover vacancy within the office portfolio, what sort of — I suppose — present circumstances, work from home, shelter in place, are you assuming when it comes to that variable component?
Michael Emory
executiveThe encouraging part, Jenny, is that none of this is variable. If there is a revenue surge, that surge isn't variable either. It happens either because rack space or conduit space costs have risen, so to speak, on a permanent basis, or because interconnections have been set up, at least in theory, on a permanent basis. A reduction in interconnections is always conceivable, though I'm not aware of that ever occurring. Our assumption is that once an interconnection exists, it represents a more or less permanent piece of the revenue stream. That is the reason we intend to be extremely cautious when assessing this, both regarding how it affects 2020 and regarding its longer-term effect on the business, and the reason we are holding off until the second quarter, which I believe we report on January 29th, before offering more granular disclosure on that front.
Jenny Ma
analystSo my guess is that with a jump in power demand, you're figuring it either gets billed at the peak rate, or you don't see that consumption declining—even if people gradually drift back to the office and the share of employees working from home shrinks. I'm simply trying to grasp how those two things connect.
Michael Emory
executiveNo, I don't see that declining once people return to their usual working setup.
Jenny Ma
analystAll right. I’d like to clear up something Tom said earlier. You noted that every bit of the space available at 151 is in negotiations right now. Given occupancy stands at 90%, does that apply to the 10% that is vacant at present?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's right.
Jenny Ma
analystAll right, if the talks proceed as expected, what sort of timeline do you anticipate for that becoming available?
Michael Emory
executiveAdoption will roll out in stages, beginning around spring 2021 and continuing across the rest of that year.
Jenny Ma
analystAlright, thanks a lot. So Michael, I'd like to hear what you think about the CECRA program. How does Allied stand on that government-offered program, and given what we know about it at this point, what share of your tenants do you figure would be eligible for it?
Michael Emory
executiveRight, no, that's a fair question. We didn't bring it up in any of yesterday's disclosures, since the program's details aren't clear at the moment. That said, I believe the program's core aim is well thought out. It makes sense for the federal and provincial governments to help small and medium-sized users whose revenue was crushed to zero overnight. The idea of the government carrying 50% of the cost, the landlord carrying 25%, and the tenant carrying 25% strikes me as inherently equitable. A significant number of the users we've given deferrals to would likely qualify, in that they're small or medium-sized enterprises and their revenues have dropped by 70% or more. Unfortunately, clarity is lacking right now, and I believe that will get addressed. There's currently a lack of clarity on several things regarding eligibility for this assistance, regarding how the program will be administered, and regarding provincial involvement, which so far has added to the confusion rather than reduced it. Being the optimist I am, I think the governments mean well.
Michael Emory
executiveMy view is that a workable program is going to get put in place. And assuming that happens, and that it proves useful to the users we've given deferrals to, then we'll take part.
Jenny Ma
analystAll right, thank you. With the May collection happening tomorrow, based on the conversations you've had, what sort of color could you give us on what you may be expecting?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a fair question. As I believe we said, we completely anticipate carrying those deferrals over into May. In May we'll be aiming for outcomes comparable to what we delivered in April, and we see no reason to anticipate anything materially different on that front. For the most part, our office tenants have fulfilled what they owe. The sole office tenants to whom we've granted an extension of deferral are quite small, early-stage businesses, largely located in 2 Montreal properties, El-Pro and the RCA Building — buildings we intend to reposition 2 or 3 years from now. We're entirely ready to cooperate with those tenants at this point and to keep those properties running as they are, since they serve a great many very small occupants. We'll reposition them in good time, once we've formed a vision for transforming both properties, which together total almost 500,000 feet.
Jenny Ma
analystThat’s excellent.
Michael Emory
executiveThat's roughly how I view it. May is tricky, I think. Some folks attempt to hold us back, but in the end they don't succeed. There are 1 or 2 really small cases — again, baked into the figures we've given — where we could in fact reclaim the space, since we can more profitably deliver it to office users. That would be second-story space that quasi-retail tenants occupy right now, which we might flip around and use to meet some of the tremendous demand for space that exists across the next 2 or 3 years, space over the coming period. May, we are working hard to match what we did in April. I suppose looking ahead to June is a bit difficult, because I believe we might see some shifts when it comes to the physical distancing rules all of us are living under during May. We definitely will in Montreal and in Quebec, clearly. I think we might even in Ontario and Vancouver and British Columbia too. May, we are working hard to match what we did in April.
Jenny Ma
analystPerfect, thanks so much. I'll hand it back over.
Michael Emory
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. We'll take our next question from Chris Couprie at CIBC. Go right ahead.
Chris Couprie
analystMorning. I wanted to follow up about the rent deferral. How do you plan to collect those deferred amounts? Does it happen across some set period, or are you extending the lease term — what's the actual method for deferring the rents?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a fair question, Chris. All we've done is give them a deferral. Nothing has been arranged with the user regarding repayment method, repayment timing, or the conditions involved. That will be handled individually, user by user, or case by case, once everyone has greater clarity about what the slowdown or shutdown really means for those businesses. It's going to differ across users, I believe. Take our retail tenant base as it stands today: roughly 13% of it, which of course accounts for 7% of our revenue. Around 13% of that retail tenant base consists of what we term early-stage retail outlets — ones that haven't occupied our space for very long. The following group, 49%, are established yet mostly independent operators who have occupied our space for an extended period and have operated there at a profit. Last, roughly 37% of our retail users are what I'd describe as national or international tenants, who have managed to sustain themselves through this particular crisis. Our dealings will mainly involve retailers in the early-stage group and the established independent group — 13% of the total and 49% of the total, respectively.
Michael Emory
executiveWith the first category, that 13%, we'll likely take a more flexible stance — we may even reach a point where the deferral turns into something beyond a deferral. For established operators, our approach will probably look different. Over time, we'll set up a repayment mechanism, since we recognize they'll be running very profitably out of that space once again. Those are the kinds of considerations we'll bring to bear as we work through the specific deferrals to date. We haven't demanded anything from anyone. We've essentially provided a blank deferral. In theory, we could require that payment on the 1st of May. Naturally, we won't do that, but the option exists. That's the way we intend to handle it. As we get closer to June, what we do with these deferrals should become clearer. Ideally, the government program will make things easy for a significant portion of our users. Even if the government program, for some technical reason — which would actually make no sense, but nonetheless, for some technical reason — doesn't apply to our users, we'll work alongside them to help them get through the difficulty they're facing through no fault of their own.
Chris Couprie
analystThat seems quite fair and responsible. Just shifting topics, regarding acquisitions, I believe you said the plan is probably to concentrate on infill opportunities. Would you guess that if these happen, they will most likely be weighted toward the back half? Second, about the partial asset sale in Montreal, is that still proceeding as expected? And is this something you intend to do more of?
Michael Emory
executiveTaking your second question first, on the 24th we signed a formal purchase and sale agreement with a subsidiary of the Canadian Pension Fund. It stays conditional through June 15, and following that, Competition Act approval will be a mutual condition for both sides. We do anticipate that deal will close, and we expect closing in early July. We actually confirmed that in the press release. I don't anticipate that this will set off a flood of comparable deals across Allied's portfolio. It fit very well in the context of buying The Landing, and it also fit very well for building a relationship with this particular Canadian Pension Fund. That said, I doubt we'll see a sudden wave of transactions like this from Allied. Still, we do recognize that there are situations in which that kind of capital redeployment, if you will, could benefit Allied. When such a situation arises, we'll certainly consider it, and I believe we have the ability to execute. On your first question, or the first part of it, we had been seeing modest infill opportunities even prior to the onset of the global pandemic. The acquisition we completed on the Esplanade essentially finishes a spectacular assembly that we hold between Front Street and the Esplanade.
Michael Emory
executiveI expect additional situations of that kind to reach us in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver. I wouldn't say that in the second quarter we'll rush out and purchase everything in sight. Should genuinely attractive opportunities present themselves, and should their pricing be more favorable than would normally be the case, we will definitely give them consideration.
Chris Couprie
analystUnderstood. All right. Many thanks.
Michael Emory
executiveSure thing.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question comes from Mike Markidis at Desjardins. Go ahead, please.
Mike Markidis
analystGood morning, everyone. My first question concerns the possible pace of the decline in your outlook. I realize there is considerable uncertainty, but I am simply curious whether you expect the largest effect in Q2, with a ramp beginning in the third and fourth quarter and acceleration into 2021, or whether the direction is meant to be the reverse?
Michael Emory
executiveMike, my view is that Q2 probably won't show much of that decline, since I believe the decline will come in the form of us having to give space back. I don't expect us to do that in Q2. I'd see it happening more in Q3, if it happens at all. I expect Q2 will be largely a standstill quarter in the sense that we won't see much erosion. Clearly our receivables will go up because of the deferral we've made. We also may be in a position — and by the way, we, like everyone else, will report on that very precisely so that our constituents can see through the deferral numbers well and correlate them appropriately to the receivable increase that they represent. I sort of see that as a transitional quarter, and then the impact really affecting us in Q3 and Q4. That's kind of how I expect it to play out.
Mike Markidis
analystAll right, that clears things up. Thanks. Regarding the CAD 335 million in capital commitments tied to development value add — does that figure cover the entire year, or is it what's left for 2020?
Michael Emory
executiveThanks. That's a fair question, and maybe the disclosure isn't ideal, but the figure really covers the whole year. A sizable portion of it has already been funded. We did mention throughout the year, so it's a full-year figure rather than what's left for the rest of the year.
Mike Markidis
analystAny idea, approximately, what the balance still owed on that comes to?
Cecilia Williams
executiveOut of that CAD 335, Mike, we've put in CAD 70 so far.
Mike Markidis
analystPerfect. Okay. Thanks, Cecilia. Regarding that step change in your power revenue, could you remind us what the power capacity is at your three UDCs and how much room you have to grow it with the existing infrastructure?
Michael Emory
executiveCecilia, can you pull up those figures? We’ve actually had a request for them, and we do have those figures. Are they handy for you, Cecilia?
Cecilia Williams
executiveSure.
Michael Emory
executiveApologies for catching you off guard there. I don't have that. I ought to, but I don't. It matters a great deal, yet I'd need to go dig those figures out, Mike. They aren't among the documents sitting in front of me. Yeah, my apologies for that. I should have had them.
Mike Markidis
analystIf you don’t have that handy right now, we can pick it up afterward outside this call.
Michael Emory
executiveSure.
Mike Markidis
analystMichael, my final question is really more theoretical in nature. I was just reflecting on what you said regarding real estate values or equity values not aligning with property values, and your remark that you might potentially act more aggressively should prices decline a bit rather than otherwise. In the near term, how does Allied view its cost of capital? Given that the stock price is down, does that affect how you think about funding? Would you lean on your balance sheet strength to seize opportunities, expecting the equity price to bounce back very quickly? I'm simply attempting to reconcile your thinking on that point.
Michael Emory
executiveSure, that's a fair question too. The way we see it right now is that the bond market has, in fact — or at least seems to have — settled down; I don't want to sound like some kind of authority on this. I'm estimating more than speaking as an expert. It looks like the bond market has steadied, even though spreads have widened, and the terms available for issuing unsecured debentures are really quite appealing. So right there we've got a funding route whose pricing works in our favor at the moment. The equity capital markets, on the other hand, aren't valuing Allied at a level that would make sense for us today. I don't think we've ever sold equity beneath our NAV per unit — I believe I've mentioned this before and I'll say it again — we'd be extremely reluctant to issue equity under our NAV per unit. If equity were the right kind of capital, and securing it meant issuing beneath our NAV per unit, I believe we'd walk away from that chance. I doubt we'd ever find ourselves in such a spot, but should it happen, we'd let the opportunity go rather than raise equity under the NAV per unit. Of course, it's tricky to talk about these things in hypothetical terms, and you can never truly predict how you'll act until a real situation is in front of you.
Michael Emory
executiveIf we’re speaking hypothetically, at least, we wouldn’t be prepared to tap the equity capital markets right now given the conditions. It would only be if our cost of capital came down and landed below the issuance level relative to our NAV per unit that we’d be inclined to make use of those equity capital markets.
Mike Markidis
analystAll right. Before I hand it back, when you mention your NAV, do you mean the book value per unit, or your own internal estimate of what NAV per unit is?
Michael Emory
executiveOh, no. Our official NAV per unit. If we had to comply with my internal thoughts, we may never issue equity. My internal thoughts don't govern our decisions in that regard. No, absolutely, our NAV per unit, as expressed in our financial statements and perhaps also as evaluated by the analysts who coverage our stock, and we take cognizance of that as well.
Mike Markidis
analystAppreciate that, and thanks for giving me the chance to ask a couple of things.
Michael Emory
executiveHappy to do that. We'll pull those figures. Hopefully we'll have them in hand prior to the call.
Cecilia Williams
executiveGot it — glad to do that.
Michael Emory
executiveAlright.
Cecilia Williams
executiveI've got it.
Michael Emory
executiveGreat, Cecilia. Appreciate it. Please go ahead.
Cecilia Williams
executiveSo at 151 Front, the capacity comes to 40 MW, and 15 MW of that has been allocated so far. Moving to 250 Front, capacity there is 20, with eight of that allocated. Then at 905 King, capacity stands at 10, and four and a half of it is allocated.
Michael Emory
executiveGreat, thank you, Cecilia. I believe it would be good to take the next question now.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take our next question from Howard Leung at Veritas Investment Research. You may proceed. Your line is open.
Howard Leung
analystThanks. Good morning. Leora, I hope you'll pardon me for spending some time on Q1. I simply wanted to connect it with COVID, perhaps. For leases already in place, the renewal rate came in at 61. I believe that's lower than what we saw in Q1 of last year and in Q1 two years back, assuming those figures are right. To what extent was COVID responsible for that, or is it merely a coincidence?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a fair question, and the timing is purely by chance. At 1050 Homer in Vancouver, we had a non-renewal. That was the MINI dealership. Much like the MINI dealership we have in Toronto on King West, it expanded until it required a more traditional dealership format, so COVID played no part in it. A small tenant departed QRC East — again, that was unrelated, or rather not a new development. Then the Gap shut its store at 375 Queen. That formed part of our redevelopment of QRC West, phase II. We have now de-leased that whole property and will begin developing phase II of QRC West. Another interesting aspect of the handful of non-renewals we saw was that at the two Montreal buildings I mentioned, the RCA Building and Belgo Building, a number of the smaller users chose not to renew because they were unwilling to pay the somewhat higher net rent levels that we believed were suitable given market conditions. I think we'll replace them fairly easily, particularly now that we're able to offer short-term occupancy to those who might want that flexibility. It genuinely was coincidental, and none of the non-renewals we experienced in the first quarter had any COVID-19 impetus whatsoever.
Howard Leung
analystRight, that's exactly my point. Yes, in Q1 there is really no COVID impact. So, going through the leases you announced — the new ones signed plus renewals and extensions — are you seeing any sort of shift in the way tenants intend to lay out those spaces? Perhaps square footage per employee, is it greater or smaller than previously? No difference, or nothing of that kind that you're observing?
Michael Emory
executiveRight now, there's nothing on that front. We haven't observed that. People are seeking additional room for a variety of reasons, though those reasons relate more to growing their operations than to any need to create a six-by-six grid inside the space. We haven't seen anything indicating that COVID-19 is pushing people to shrink their space because staff can work from home, or to grow it because they want additional square footage per person to achieve physical distancing — and to do so on a permanent basis. We've seen no sign of either one. Looking ahead, my expectation is that we might see both. Some people may feel able to reduce their space somewhat, and some may need to increase their space requirements somewhat. I don't anticipate that either trend will be material, though only time will establish that with certainty.
Howard Leung
analystOkay, yes, absolutely. There's certainly no shortage of uncertainty right now. I suppose this leads nicely into my final question, which takes a broader perspective and considers tail risk. In your opinion, what would it take for bigger users—particularly those requiring space, such as large tech companies—to genuinely change their preferences and how they utilize office space?
Michael Emory
executiveMy view is this. Ultimately, as a provider of workspace, we serve the men and women who make up knowledge-based organizations—the people who are, technically speaking, our tenants. What those men and women want is, I believe, what will determine how workspace develops. And I believe their desires are what have shaped the way workspace has changed over the past decade or two, as the real estate sector grew more attuned to what was actually going on with its users. For a mass departure from the type of workspace we offer the market to occur, the highly educated, highly motivated men and women who have chosen to reside in inner cities would have to conclude that going forward they wish to work in a cocoon-like setting at home, which technology makes possible. That, I don't see happening. In fact, I believe the reverse could occur, but I certainly don't see the end users of our space wanting to pull back from it. Employers, in my view, will always do whatever is needed to draw in, keep, and inspire their invaluable staff. It would take those employees deciding en masse, or to a very substantial degree, that they want to work from home.
Michael Emory
executiveI think if that were to occur, or should it occur, employers would make an effort to accommodate those people, and demand for the type of space we offer would, in theory, decline. That's what it would take, in my view. It wouldn't be a handful of accountants, thankfully, thinking, "I can cut costs by shrinking my space and cramming all my creative staff into home offices." That's not going to be the outcome. When it comes to our workspace, accountants no longer run the world. That's the reason our workspace has developed in the manner it has. In the end, it's the users who run it — the men and women with the abilities to drive the businesses of our tenants. They are the ones making the choice. They are the ones who will decide what comes next. My very firm conviction, grounded in many years of experience — not simply because I'm an older, aging baby boomer — is that they are not choosing to work from home to any appreciable degree.
Howard Leung
analystRight, yeah, that was genuinely insightful. Thanks. Since I'm a former accountant and someone who's getting a bit tired of working from home, I get that. Appreciate the answer, and I'll let you.
Michael Emory
executiveSure. I don’t mean any offense to accountants, but this matters. It isn’t a decision driven by economics. Economics always matter, naturally. This is not an economic call. At this point it’s a people and, really, a leadership choice, which is excellent, and in my opinion that makes me confident there won’t be a significant shift in the way people utilize workspace down the road because of the pandemic. Change will keep happening, simply because that’s a very human fact, and our task is to stay abreast of it—or better yet, ahead of it.
Howard Leung
analystOkay, that's clear.
Michael Emory
executiveAlright.
Howard Leung
analystI appreciate that.
Michael Emory
executiveHappy to do it.
Operator
operatorI appreciate it.
Michael Emory
executiveMoving on to the next question.
Operator
operatorThanks a lot, sir. Our following question comes from Matt Kornack at National Bank Financial. The line is yours.
Matt Kornack
analystMorning, everyone.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Matt Kornack
analystTurning to your retail leasing: do these deferrals inevitably start conversations about those leases? Is there a way to restructure them going forward? And perhaps build in some kind of percentage rent possibilities so you could share in the upside as those places reopen?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a fair question in theory. I'd likely lay out a couple of principles we'd apply there. First, no one's rent is getting cut. We don't see that as the right move given the situation. If a tenant comes to us wanting a lower rental rate from here on, the answer is no. We'll take the space back instead. That probably won't be a frequent outcome, but when it happens, that's the outcome. And honestly, we're not interested in percentage rent either. We never have been, mainly since that kind of entitlement is very hard to monitor. Rather than land ourselves in that spot, we've consistently preferred to set a fixed rental rate and let the tenant keep the upside if their business develops that way — rather than, so to speak, forming a business partnership with our tenants. I don't see us going down that road. As I said, I think it'll be handled case by case between us and each individual user. What matters most is whether the user is viable. Obviously, we can't carry someone who lacks the ability to stay viable going forward. I doubt many situations like that exist in our portfolio. For users who've benefited very substantially from our space across a very long stretch, we'll expect them to support their own businesses and their own space, in the end.
Michael Emory
executiveThat said, we're ready to assist them where cash flow is concerned. Those are the sorts of principles, Matt, that will guide us as these conversations take place. Luckily, thanks to Tom and the excellent operations groups we have nationwide, our knowledge of our tenants is very deep, each conversation is personal, and each one, I suppose, honors the conditions that exist within the relationship.
Matt Kornack
analystSo I suppose, by extension, many of these retail locations have seen market rents climb, and presumably some of them are paying rents that sit below market. You're going to work with those tenants, and I guess the question is whether there's the ability to capture a portion of that upside going forward, if you're going to supply cash flow in the meantime?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's possible. That's perhaps among the trade-offs we'd seek in return for the backing we've given. It may be in play — either we'd want to be repaid earlier, or we might raise the rent charged so it aligns more closely with what the market currently bears. I believe that's the sort of conversation that will take place. As I mentioned, Tom and the operations team are simply exceptional when it comes to the strength of the ties they've built with our users, who, as you can imagine, are under real stress. I can't even picture what it would feel like for your revenue to drop to zero overnight. We'll deal with these people equitably, trying to weigh what's best for our customers against what's best for our unit holders. In the end, our unit holders benefit from having tenants who can pay rent and stay viable once the pressure from this pandemic starts to ease. We see it as enlightened self-interest that steers us in these talks with these users, many of whom we've shared a relationship with for years and years and years, and we know we can rely on them to run a good business if they're permitted to do so.
Matt Kornack
analystThat's reasonable. As for the Montreal disposition, would IFRS fair value capture what that asset was worth at this stage in Q1?
Michael Emory
executiveI’m not entirely certain what the question is asking.
Matt Kornack
analystSo, I guess there would have been a mark to market from that, and it would have shown up in the Q1 results?
Michael Emory
executive<<inaudible>>
Matt Kornack
analystDid that happen at market?
Michael Emory
executiveActually, that asset, I believe, did go up. In Q1, the IFRS value of one of those two assets did rise. That increase will be more than validated by the ultimate distribution price.
Matt Kornack
analystAll right, that's fair. Cecilia, regarding straight-line rents, does that include anything tied to some of the near-term assets you're delivering through the development pipeline? And would you say that figure is a solid run rate for the remainder of the year?
Cecilia Williams
executiveI’ll need to verify that, and… I can’t recall it right now without checking. I’ll follow up with you on it.
Matt Kornack
analystAlright, no problem at all. That covers everything on my end, I believe. The kids are out of the house now, and my home office is a bit more chaotic today than it's been over the past couple of weeks. I'm looking forward to being back in my actual office.
Michael Emory
executiveAll right, Matt, thank you.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question comes from Brad Sturges at iA Securities. Go ahead, please.
Brad Sturges
analystHello. Regarding the UDC portfolio and how we should think about capital investment strategies moving forward — with the positive trends you're seeing in the space, does that shift your near-term and long-term view on capital investment in new opportunities, whether that's at the DLG in Montreal or other opportunities in existing markets?
Michael Emory
executiveBrad, sadly there's a lot of echo coming from you on the moderator phones, at minimum. My understanding of your question is whether we anticipate chances to grow our urban data center footprint into additional cities?
Brad Sturges
analystSo within that — aside from the three assets you already hold — how do the trends you're seeing right now look to you when it comes to new capital investments for new opportunities in Montreal, Vancouver, or perhaps going after something else in Toronto?
Michael Emory
executiveIt likely heightens the attention we'd give to urban data center capacity opportunities similar to what exists in Toronto. Suppose, for instance, we could build network-dense urban data center capability in Montreal, say, or Vancouver—given what we're going through in Toronto, we'd probably be more inclined to consider that today than we were before. And indeed we are inclined toward that, and have been for a while. It isn't a top priority in the sense that we're upending everything and examining every possibility in pursuit of such an opportunity. Capital allocation and human resource allocation give us other priorities. It's something we've been considering and are assessing, and 700 DLG stands as a very, very good illustration of where that might be achievable. Once more, I wouldn't rank it at the top of our priority list now, just as I hadn't ranked it at the top before the global pandemic arrived. It's a longer-term opportunity we've observed for some time, and certainly what this experience has taught us probably makes us more favorably disposed toward these opportunities.
Michael Emory
executiveOnce more, there's a lot of other transformational work in progress, so in the very near term our capital and resources will likely be concentrated on those efforts. I hope that answers your question.
Brad Sturges
analystYeah. No, that helps a lot. Regarding de la Gauchetière or Growth Guide there — parking revenue makes up a fairly small segment — have you noticed many cancellations of monthly passes, say, from tenants inside the building, or effects along those lines, and do you think that cancellation trend could grow over the coming months?
Michael Emory
executiveThe good news is that a lease covers the majority of our parking. This isn't something the tenant can choose — it's both a right and a duty. I haven't heard of anybody attempting to walk away from their parking commitments. Clearly, traffic in and out will decline during April, May, and June. Most of the parking income comes essentially from obligations written into the office leases for users. Those obligations aren't voluntary. They're essentially compulsory, just like the remainder of the space. As far as I know, no one has sought to escape those obligations, whether temporarily or in any other way.
Brad Sturges
analystAll right, that's useful. I appreciate it.
Michael Emory
executiveI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. At this point, there are no more questions from our side.
Michael Emory
executiveOkay, thanks so much for joining our conference call. We really value the time you've taken, along with your questions and comments. Going forward through this unusual period, we'll definitely keep you updated on how we're progressing. Thanks once more — take care, stay safe, and have a great day. Thank you, operator.
Operator
operatorThank you. That brings us to the end of today's conference call, ladies and gentlemen. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.