Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust (APUN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 29, 2020

Toronto Stock Exchange CA Real Estate Office REITs earnings 70 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Right now, I'd like to hand the conference call over to Mr. Michael Emory, our President and Chief Executive Officer. Mr. Emory, the floor is yours.

Michael Emory

executive
#2

Thanks a lot, and good morning to all of you. Welcome to our conference call. Tom, Cecilia, and Hugh have joined me here to talk through Allied's results for the third quarter, which ended September 30, 2020. During this conference call, we might make forward-looking statements regarding future events or future performance. By their very nature, such statements carry risks and uncertainties that could lead actual events or results to differ materially, including the risks outlined under the heading "Risks and Uncertainties" in our most recently filed annual information form and in our latest quarterly report. Material assumptions underlying any forward-looking statements we make include those set out under "Forward-Looking Disclaimer" in our most recent quarterly report. Allied's urban workspace right across the country keeps getting stronger. As our rent deferral program starts to scale down and the variable portion of our parking revenue starts to recover, our third quarter came in stronger than our second, with same asset NOI and FFO per unit largely in line with the comparable quarter last year. We anticipate even stronger results in the fourth quarter, as rental revenue returns to more normal levels. This once again confirms that our team, our properties, and our user base are truly resilient.

Michael Emory

executive
#3

Cecilia is going to walk us through the financial results and also cover the balance sheet plus what we expect near term. After that, Tom will give an overview of leasing and operations. Hugh will bring a development update, and then I'll wrap up with how we're currently viewing what lies ahead. So, Cecilia, over to you.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#4

Good morning, everyone. Let me start with the financial results. Rental revenue was temporarily depressed, but same-asset NOI and FFO per unit for the third quarter came in largely in line with the comparable quarter a year earlier. On the whole, the third quarter outpaced our second quarter, especially on same-asset NOI, which rose 2.9%, and FFO per unit, which gained 1.8%. We look for another stronger showing in the fourth quarter, with rental revenue coming back to more normal levels. Now to the balance sheet. NAV per unit as of September 30th was 8.6% higher than at the same point last year. Our IFRS value increment for the third quarter came to CAD 9 million, driven mainly by rent growth in Toronto and cap rate compression at 905 King West, partly offset by a decline in the value of our Calgary and Edmonton properties. Last month we closed a private placement of equity that raised proceeds of CAD 153 million. As intended, this bolstered our debt metrics. We now hold sufficient liquidity to meet our obligations through 2021 without any need to access the capital markets. We ended the third quarter with CAD 142 million in cash and no draws on our CAD 600 million unsecured facilities, the accordion feature included.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#5

Closing out the third quarter, net debt to EBITDA stood at 7.2x. Total debt came to 28.8% of IFRS value, while interest coverage was 3.3x. We figure our developments will add roughly CAD 70 million to annual EBITDA across the coming four years. Beyond boosting earnings per unit considerably, together with expected organic growth, this should bring down our net debt to EBITDA ratio materially and lift our interest coverage ratio materially as well — those being our two most important debt metrics. Our unencumbered asset pool sits at CAD 6.4 billion, which is 74% of our investment properties. Our plan is to keep prepaying or repaying mortgages as they mature, aiming to have most of our asset base unencumbered. In our view, that gives us the strongest and most flexible balance sheet, whether playing defense or offense. Third, the short-term outlook. Our initial internal forecast for 2020 had projected mid-single-digit percentage growth in same-asset NOI, FFO per unit, and AFFO per unit, each one. Given our second and third-quarter results, the recent private placement of equity, and how we see the fourth quarter, we've updated our internal forecast to flat to low single-digit % growth in same-asset NOI, FFO per unit, and AFFO per unit, each one.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#6

Although we don’t provide forecasts for NAV per unit growth, we still anticipate that it will grow during 2020. At this point I’ll hand the call over to Tom, who will discuss our leasing and operating activities.

Tom Burns

executive
#7

Thank you, Cecilia. In the quarter, our leasing teams across Toronto, Montreal, Calgary, and Vancouver delivered strong results, closing 80 transactions that came to 529,000 sq ft in total. Rental rates stayed firm, and on space that was renewed and replaced during the quarter we recorded a healthy 19.3% increase. By quarter end, our workspace portfolio stood at 93.4% leased. The modest decline in leased area stemmed mainly from non-renewals that we had already identified prior to the pandemic. We have every expectation of re-leasing that space quickly and at the rental levels we anticipate. I'll give a leasing update covering our major markets, with an update on our UDC portfolio as well, and then close with a few comments about our leasing staff and some brief observations on the marketplace overall. Montreal proved our busiest market, with the team completing 45 deals during the quarter. Both of our properties on de Gaspé are fully leased at 100%. Cité Multimédia stands at 97.5% leased. Nordelec is 94% leased. We are currently putting the finishing touches on our plans to transform 700 DLG, which will let us kick off our leasing program early next year. The downtown Toronto office market continues to be solid, with very little vacancy across the board. We ended the quarter at 96.5% leased. In Q3, the team completed 12 smaller lease transactions, averaging roughly 3,500 sq ft apiece.

Tom Burns

executive
#8

Right after the quarter closed, we agreed on three sizable lease deals worth noting. First, at 80, 82 Spadina, we signed a long-term agreement covering 37,000 sq ft with a fintech tenant that takes over from Shopify, which had been in that space on an interim basis. Second, we leased 26,000 sq ft at the Beardmore building, backfilling a vacancy created by a known non-renewal in Q2. Third, a 61,000-square-foot lease renewal on Queen East is now in the conditional period. On all three of these transactions, we secured rents above the in-place levels. In Calgary, we closed 10 deals during the quarter and held a respectable 87% leased area in that market. We anticipate completing a 16,000-square-foot deal at TELUS Sky, which will bring us past 70% leased in the office component. It's interesting that Calgary is the hardest leasing market in the country, yet it ranks second behind Montréal for the number of tours we ran in the quarter. Small spaces that are move-in ready are leasing in Calgary, and we've done a very good job getting our vacant units prepared for lease-up under these conditions. In Vancouver, we held leased area at 95%, completing 10 deals in the quarter.

Tom Burns

executive
#9

We have just finalized a renewal covering 45,000 square feet, and it came with meaningful increases in rent. Our UDC portfolio is still 89.4% leased, and ancillary revenues continue to grow. We have seen more sublease space become available within our portfolio, and we view that as an opportunity. In Toronto and Montréal, most of the sublease space on offer is Tier 1, Class I space, and it is leased at rents well below what the market currently commands. Since space of that kind is scarce, we expect to gain from the sublease process, just as we have before. To give these remarks some context, we looked at the four biggest sublease spaces in our Toronto portfolio and compared in-place rents against market. Without naming tenants or giving exact locations, the gap between in-place rents and market rents falls somewhere between 16% and 90%. In our Vancouver and Calgary portfolios, the volume of sublease space actually went down over the quarter. During our previous call, I noted the excellent work our operations teams did getting our buildings ready to reopen. On this call, I want to draw attention to what our leasing teams have accomplished. The Allied leasing team, led by Tim Low, has 22 people working on leasing and lease documentation throughout our portfolio. Our leasing results are no coincidence.

Tom Burns

executive
#10

The team has performed exceptionally well at remaining connected to the market, which has given us every chance to pitch and compete for tenants. Whenever a tenant is active in the market, we hear about it. Through regular Zoom calls, our leasing teams have been showcasing Allied's available space to the brokerage community, ensuring our portfolio's space stays top of mind. By the time our leasing team wraps up its outreach next week, it will have reached out to more than 600 individual leasing agents. Since these presentations began, we've seen a corresponding rise in tour activity. From March to September, we completed an impressive 385 physical tours of our available space. Interestingly, we conducted more tours in September than we did in January or February, before COVID. October's tour activity is even stronger than September's. We've experienced very few failures stemming from the pandemic, and those have been confined to smaller users. Following case-by-case discussions with our storefront retail users, most of which are exceptionally well located in downtown Toronto, we're confident that the vast majority of our retail and restaurant users will pull through. On the office side, tight supply means rents are actually rising on renewal or replacement.

Tom Burns

executive
#11

Tours are taking place, and every market shows substantial demand for additional space. Our responsibility is to ensure the market stays fully informed about what our portfolio offers. We also need to stay in close touch with our tenants and keep our buildings maintained to a high standard. The Allied leasing team is in the office and prepared to go the extra mile on each and every deal. At this point I'll hand the call to Hugh for an update on our development activities.

Hugh Clark

executive
#12

Thanks, Tom. For most of our projects, this quarter has brought productivity back to a more normal level. Even with the second wave of COVID, we've managed to keep our construction projects moving forward. I'll start with a quick overview of the construction projects currently active, and after that I'll briefly cover the other work that has moved ahead during the past three months. Construction activity. Nationwide, our major construction projects have seen a steadier pace of progress. Starting in Montreal, the team there has concentrated on upgrading two properties along with assorted stake and suite upgrades, which we expect will let Allied raise occupancy in the Eastern portfolio. On our 700 DLG repositioning project, we expect construction to begin in the fourth quarter, with roughly a year needed to finish most of the common area work. We've begun transforming the base building on several of the upper floors, giving the leasing team a template for what we can bring to the market. In Toronto and Kitchener, our projects are moving along nicely. Together with our construction managers, we've reached productivity levels matching those seen prior to COVID.

Hugh Clark

executive
#13

Out in Western Canada, the work on TELUS Sky is now finished. Restoration has begun at our Boardwalk Revillon building in Edmonton. Once transformed, this property will rank among the finest brick-and-beam buildings anywhere in the country. Completion of the restoration work is expected by the end of 2021. Down in Vancouver, our partners have topped off steel construction at 400 West Georgia, and they are pushing to wrap up that project by Q3 of next year. Turning to planning activity: this quarter, our focus has been on continuing to advance development approvals for upcoming projects in Montreal and Toronto. There is no urgency here, but we need to push harder than normal because of the reduced productivity of municipal planning departments. This quarter has seen the benefits of the Allied team working in unison to deliver space that serves our workspace users' needs. Despite the challenges of the second wave of COVID-19, the team understands our strategy and is seamlessly executing upon it. I will now turn the call back to Michael.

Michael Emory

executive
#14

Thank you, Hugh. As Tom said, renewals and new leasing are still going strong, and we've started having detailed conversations with workspace users about how they see their space requirements changing down the road. Early signals suggest that our customers nationwide plan to bring their full workforce back to the office once the pandemic fades, though we'll need additional data before offering a firm forecast on that point. I'd also say that anyone attempting to forecast future demand for urban workspace should bear the following firmly in mind. First, urban workspace isn't a fixed reality — it has been a changing one for decades, and it will keep developing ahead in reaction to every relevant force, most of them human rather than technological. Second, workspace has lately changed in response to what knowledge workers need and aspire to regarding human wellness, creativity, connectivity, and diversity — which, interestingly, line up with the environmental, social, and governance matters that public entities must tackle continually. At Allied, our task is to keep anticipating how urban workspace will develop, exactly as we have done for decades.

Michael Emory

executive
#15

Taking into account everything I've just outlined and what we've learned from working with knowledge-based organizations, my confidence remains strong, and so does my dedication, when it comes to Allied's approach of consolidating and intensifying distinctive urban workspace along with network-dense UDCs across Canada's major cities. It is my firm belief that the most important secular trends in Canadian and global real estate underpin our strategy, and I equally firmly believe we possess the properties, the financial strength, the people, and the platform required to carry out that strategy for the continuing benefit of our unit holders. A few remarks now regarding acquisition and development. For Allied, acquisition activity has never constituted an end in itself; instead it has always served as a means of delivering distinctive urban workspace to knowledge-based organizations both more effectively and more profitably. Our development, redevelopment, and upgrade activity follows the same principle. So far in 2020, we have allocated CAD 570 million toward acquiring distinctive urban workspace in Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver. We stay intent on augmenting our urban workspace portfolio on a continuing basis, and our UDC portfolio within a three to five-year timeframe. Urban workspace in Canada is starting to trade once more following a hiatus through the shutdown and the early stages of the reopening.

Michael Emory

executive
#16

The standout transaction was one in downtown Vancouver that closed at an extremely low cap rate. I don't anticipate chances coming our way for the rest of 2020, though I believe they'll start showing up in 2021. Cap rates for the type of workspace we're after should stay broadly in line with the levels seen prior to the shutdown. Anyone expecting distressed assets of the kind we target to hit the market will turn out to be mistaken. We've pledged CAD 500 million toward finishing our current developments across the coming four years. On very attractive terms, we recently put in place conventional construction financing covering CAD 250 million of that total, and we raised CAD 150 million of the remainder via a private placement of equity, as Cecilia noted. The last CAD 100 million is expected to be funded in 2022. Neither the global pandemic nor the economic upheaval it caused has damaged our return expectations, and construction completion has been pushed back only a few months. We project these developments will add roughly CAD 70 million to annual EBITDA over the coming four years. Beyond lifting earnings per unit substantially, together with expected organic growth, this will meaningfully lower our net debt to annualized EBITDA ratio and meaningfully raise our interest coverage ratio — two of the debt metrics we watch most closely.

Michael Emory

executive
#17

Last, ESG. Environmental, social, and governance matters are now a more deliberate and clearly articulated component of commercial activity, particularly for publicly traded companies such as Allied. That's a positive development, and Allied has an obligation to open itself up to examination on this front, much as we have opened ourselves up to thorough financial and operational examination since our listing. Roughly eighteen months back, Allied pledged to formally undergo independent ESG review by 2020. The single most significant move on that front was securing a GRESB assessment and producing an ESG report each year. We remain on track to accomplish precisely that. The GRESB assessment reaches completion on November 16, and our inaugural annual ESG report will come out ahead of year-end. I'm certain these reports will surface certain strengths as well as areas where Allied can do better. The crucial thing is that they will help the board and management set sensible priorities moving ahead and will supply yardsticks against which to gauge progress. Allied's board and management are dedicated to rendering our built-in ESG approach more visible, intentional, and quantifiable. We have long held that exposure to well-informed examination improves us as a business, and formally opening ourselves to ESG examination is no different in that respect.

Michael Emory

executive
#18

As we move forward in this part of our operations, we're eager to hear what you think. My hope is that this has given you a thorough and helpful picture of where things stand. At this point, we'd be glad to take whatever questions you might have.

Operator

operator
#19

Thank you. If you'd like to pose a question, please indicate so by pressing star one on your phone's keypad. Should you be on a speakerphone, kindly verify that your mute is disabled so that your signal can get through to our equipment. Once more, press star one in order to ask a question. Our first question will come from Frederic Blondeau of iA Securities.

Frédéric Blondeau

analyst
#20

Good morning, and thanks for joining.

Michael Emory

executive
#21

Good morning, everyone.

Frédéric Blondeau

analyst
#22

Tom, I wanted to circle back to what you said about subleasing. I've got just one brief question. Can you share some detail on what you're seeing right now in the GTA regarding the subleasing market as a whole, and what your outlook is at this point looking ahead — both for the overall subleasing market and for the subleasing space in your own portfolio?

Tom Burns

executive
#23

As you can see, Fred, a considerable amount of sublease space came onto the market during Q3, and Allied has followed the same pattern. The bulk of what's being offered comes from TAMI-type tenants — technology, advertising, media, and information. Our view is that subleasing gives us a chance to gain from swapping in a new tenancy without any downtime. The tenant already in place winds up subsidizing whoever replaces them, which works in our favor, and frequently we capture rent increases immediately. What we have yet to observe is downtown core financial services tenants stepping forward to sublease, and we anticipate that will occur over the next few months.

Frédéric Blondeau

analyst
#24

No, that's great. Maybe a quick one for Michael. I get that you'd rather not speculate on demand here, but would it be fair to say your base case for demand hasn't shifted much since April, I guess?

Michael Emory

executive
#25

You're right, Fred. Nothing has changed on that front. Luckily for Allied, we are back in offices nationwide, working with our tenants continuously. They are telling us very plainly that once the pandemic ends, they plan to bring their whole workforce back to the office. What's really at issue is the timing of the pandemic's end and what "over" actually means. Even with those open questions and that uncertainty, it's evident to us that the overwhelming majority of our tenants want their full workforce back in the office — both because their employees wish to be there and because the employer wants them there too. Now, as I said before, in an effort to avoid being dogmatic and to avoid ignoring reality, we still lack sufficient data to reach definitive conclusions. In response to your question, I'd say my view on ongoing demand for the kind of distinctive urban workspace we offer is as favorable today as it was back in March. Fortunately, it now rests on more data than it did in March, since back then we were all functioning in a surreal environment where nothing was taking place and where speculation and conjecture had largely run wild.

Michael Emory

executive
#26

At this point we're working from data, and that is, naturally, always the strongest foundation for making forecasts.

Frédéric Blondeau

analyst
#27

No, that's fantastic. Thanks. I'll stop right there.

Operator

operator
#28

Our following question comes from Mark Rothschild at Canaccord.

Mark Rothschild

analyst
#29

Thanks, and good morning to everyone.

Michael Emory

executive
#30

Morning, everyone.

Mark Rothschild

analyst
#31

Michael, it's obvious you've placed real emphasis on maintaining a solid balance sheet, and you raised equity to finance developments even though the unit price was plainly beneath what you consider its worth. Could you perhaps say a bit more about how far you'd keep doing that if the unit price stayed at its current level? When do you figure the balance sheet has become strong enough that you might deploy some of that strength toward potentially buying back units, even though I realize that's not something you've typically done? How are you viewing the unit price at this point?

Michael Emory

executive
#32

Mark, in complete honesty, our balance sheet is now precisely in the position we want it to be. For the coming 12 to 18 months—or even longer, should we require it—we have no need to tap the capital markets. I don't foresee us issuing equity or raising debt over the next 12 to 18 months. Regarding our unit price, our cost of capital has clearly worsened compared with where it stood in 2019. Thankfully, back in 2019 we made extraordinary use of the exceptional cost of capital available to us, which benefited both the balance sheet and the business. In my clear view, our present unit price is severely disconnected from the underlying value of our asset base. I also know from long experience that there is absolutely nothing we, as a management team, can do about that. The capital markets are beyond our control. The equity capital markets certainly are too. What we can do is keep running our business and stay focused on operations and leasing, as Tom described. I can honestly tell you—and I don't want to sound too promotional—that when it comes to leasing space, Allied is in a league of its own, both before the pandemic and certainly throughout it.

Michael Emory

executive
#33

What gives us confidence looking ahead is really the experience we've gained since we came back to the office, starting as early as May 18 and most recently on July 6. There's a huge gap between our unit price and what our business is actually worth. I think that has more to do with the equity capital markets than with our business itself. It falls to us to work through that. Another point I feel very strongly about is that we shouldn't take any action today or in the near term that hinges on our unit price reconnecting with the underlying value of our asset base. That will happen, I have no doubt, but I can't say when it will happen, and I can't say what the catalyst for it happening will be. It will happen. As I say, I won't even attempt to predict when, and I won't let any decision made by the Allied management team and board be predicated on that cost of equity recovering. In my opinion, that would be a foolish thing to do. That's a bit of a rambling answer, Mark, but those are my thoughts.

Mark Rothschild

analyst
#34

All right, thank you. Tom, regarding those 2021 expirations out in Western Canada, could you break down for us — since I see them listed as Calgary and Vancouver — which specific market each one falls in, and whether there are any sizable leases we ought to be aware of or keeping our focus on?

Tom Burns

executive
#35

Most of those, I'd say, are located in Calgary, and they consist of quite small tenants. No particularly big tenant is set to expire in 2021.

Operator

operator
#36

Our following question comes from Caitlin Burrows at Goldman Sachs.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#37

Hello, everyone, and good morning.

Michael Emory

executive
#38

Morning, everyone.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#39

I realize that predicting occupancy isn't easy, but on that front, both occupancy and the lease rate fell during the quarter, and you mentioned that part of this was anticipated. We observed decreases in Edmonton — which I believe may have stemmed from de-leasing ahead of development — as well as in Calgary, Montréal, and Toronto. So I was hoping you might offer some insight into how you see occupancy trending, particularly in the bigger markets such as Montréal and Toronto, and when a bottom might arrive and how much further it could drop.

Tom Burns

executive
#40

Sure, we did give up some ground during the quarter, but our occupancy is actually climbing. We have closed several transactions that hopefully will show that in the next quarter and beyond. As for the deals we lost, we have known about them for quite a while. They were anticipated, and we are working to replace them. A few of them have already been replaced. We expect our occupancy figures to improve over the quarters ahead.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#41

All right, that's good to hear. Regarding leasing spreads, it seems you saw solid spreads during the third quarter, which makes sense based on what history has shown. When we turn to what's currently expected for mark-to-markets in the coming year, those figures have been adjusted downward to some degree — though admittedly they started from a very elevated point — and at this stage they might be described as merely, to use the word, high. Could you shed some light on what the market anticipates for rent, and on why the three key spreads have stayed strong while projections for next year's mark-to-market appear to have softened a bit?

Tom Burns

executive
#42

So yes, we moderated the market rents. Each quarter we reviewed them. They did decline slightly. We are observing genuinely strong positive growth. I should note as well that the 19.3% rise applies to year one of the renewal. That is not the average rent across the renewal, it is only year one. We feel bullish regarding what lies ahead. Our spaces are distinctive, and people want them.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#43

All right, I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#44

Our next question comes from Jonathan Kelcher at TD Securities.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#45

Appreciate it, and good morning, everyone.

Michael Emory

executive
#46

Morning, everyone.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#47

To return to that capital raise Mark inquired about: has the team thought about divesting at least a partial stake in certain assets already held in order to bring in that equity? And, I suppose tied to that — I know this has been examined before — might you weigh doing so down the road? Since it would clearly help show what the portfolio is worth.

Michael Emory

executive
#48

We’ve looked at that, Jonathan, and chances to pursue it have come our way. We’ve chosen not to pursue it. Our confidence is very high in the cap rates we apply across our asset base, and we don’t believe selling an undivided half interest in anything would accomplish anything, since we’d never sell everything, just to validate that fact. We know the level at which the market is going to start trading, and that level will validate the underlying value of our asset base. Again, without being dogmatic, of that we are certain. I see absolutely no value in doing a trade merely to try to show the market that the underlying value of our assets is as we represent it to be, in our IFRS values. We have declined to do that. We’re aware of a U.S. office issuer having done that, on a rather large scale with Blackstone. It was, if you will, I won’t say a dud, but it accomplished nothing and did nothing to address the concern some people may have about cap rates, going forward. In my opinion, it would be one of those actions designed to, if you will, cater to the equity capital markets, and number one, it wouldn’t achieve the desired objective, and in my opinion, it wouldn’t be a good decision for the business.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#49

All right, that's fair. Second, looking at the UDC portfolio, we had another solid quarter there. Did any one-time items show up in NOI this quarter?

Michael Emory

executive
#50

I believe — and Cecilia can correct me if I'm wrong — regarding that CAD 800+ thousand we mentioned in the press release, I think 68% of it is recurring. By implication, the remainder would be more one-time items. What we're trying to do is identify the unexpected growth there that's recurring, and then the unexpected growth that's one-time. What we provided was an aggregate figure for the second and third quarters. As I said, if my memory serves, Cecilia, 68% was recurring and will continue to recur, so to speak, indefinitely. The remainder is non-recurring, or one-time. That's a fairly solid ratio. Obviously, we'd like it to be 100%, but we'll gladly take the non-recurring any day.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#51

All right. As for the non-recurring piece — I suppose the question is whether you'd anticipate that kind of thing showing up each quarter, just with varying non-recurring revenue?

Michael Emory

executive
#52

We've seen consecutive quarters with non-recurring revenue, but I don't believe it would be wise for us to assume that will keep going indefinitely. These are, so to speak, exceptional circumstances, and in them we're certainly getting what we earned or what we deserve. It would be unwise for us to view that as recurring. That doesn't mean we won't have other isolated items, but I would hate to describe that as something we depend on going forward, because there will certainly be months or quarters when there's nothing in that regard.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#53

All right, and one final item — this hasn’t come up between us for a few quarters, I believe. At 250 Front, how has leasing interest looked lately? It appears somewhat stalled around the low 70% range.

Tom Burns

executive
#54

We're continuing discussions with multiple prospective tenants for that building, and we're also exploring expansions with the ones already there. It's just that over the past few quarters, we haven't managed to close anything. That effort is still underway. Progress in that area has been slow.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#55

All right, thank you. I’ll hand it back over.

Operator

operator
#56

Thanks. Our next question comes from Mike Markidis at Desjardins.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#57

Hello there, and good morning to all of you.

Michael Emory

executive
#58

Good morning, everyone.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#59

I suppose I'd just add that, given your expectation of a stronger 4Q and knowing CECRA is no longer available, do you have any sense of how many of your tenants who had been depending on CECRA would be applying for CERS and would qualify for it?

Michael Emory

executive
#60

Regarding that new program?

Mike Markidis

analyst
#61

Absolutely.

Michael Emory

executive
#62

We don't have that answer yet, Mike, and honestly it's a bit frustrating. The eligibility criteria for the new program remain unknown to us. One could presume they'll mirror CECRA's, but that's pure guesswork at this point. My hope is that eligibility will be broadened somewhat. Consider the CAD 50,000 cap that existed under CECRA — I get why a clear threshold matters. Yet CAD 50,000 goes a very different distance in downtown Toronto compared with Barrie or elsewhere. I'm hopeful they will make an effort to widen eligibility so that it covers tenants we've had to look after through our deferral program. How exactly that will play out is still unclear. My impression is that the government genuinely wants to back small and medium-sized enterprise. That strikes me as sound economic policy, since taken together, small and medium-sized enterprises are essential to our economy and to our well-being. The answer to that question just isn't available to me yet. What I can say — and this is very encouraging for us regarding Q4 earnings, or more precisely Q4 rental revenue — is that as we sit here today, 70% of our users, or is it 75%?

Tom Burns

executive
#63

Seventy percent.

Michael Emory

executive
#64

Seventy percent of the users we had qualified under CECRA paid us their rent in October. For us, that is a highly encouraging indicator regarding how well those tenants can support themselves without subsidy. Three other factors give us encouragement about rental revenue in Q4: the highly visible rebound in our variable parking revenue, the fact that no rent abatement was needed at all, and lastly, the winding down of our deferral program, which is real, and which Tom has done an extraordinary job leading. There is really no tenant whose circumstances we are not fully conversant with and whose ability to survive we lack confidence in. Those are, in effect, the four reasons we expect more normal levels of rental revenue in Q4. Regarding the new rent relief program, we are eagerly awaiting the details, as are retail users throughout the country.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#65

Thanks, that's quite useful. So, just to pick up on the deferral program, which is getting smaller — I believe you had CAD 5.9 million in Q2 and CAD 5.4 million in Q3. Should we expect that to keep declining at a comparable rate, or will the tapering become faster in 4Q and 1Q?

Michael Emory

executive
#66

I realize this is risky ground for me to venture onto, but my expectation is that the reduction will happen faster in Q4 than was the case from Q2 to Q3.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#67

All right, thanks. Regarding the higher tour activity you’ve been seeing, that’s clearly an encouraging indicator. Tom, I’m curious whether you could share a few more details about where that demand is originating. At least near term, it appears the market has experienced a pullback in demand. My guess is it reflects more people who aren’t seeking expansion space but perhaps simply want to upgrade the premises they already occupy. The second question is how your conversion rate today would stack up against the pre-COVID levels.

Tom Burns

executive
#68

Our conversion rate remains quite strong, I'd say. It compares favorably. Regarding growth, a lot of it is actually coming from existing tenants who need more space. Many deals completed in Q3 came from our current tenant base wanting to expand. A couple of the deals I mentioned that happened after quarter end in Toronto — two of them involved tenants already in our portfolio who needed substantially more space. One went from 6,000 to 26,000, and the other went from about 18,000 or 20,000 to 37,000. Our existing tenant base keeps supporting us.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#69

All right, that's my final question before I hand things back. I was hoping you might briefly walk us through how 400 Georgia works. My understanding is that, as I think you mentioned, it will be finished in the third quarter of 2021. I'm simply trying to work out when your obligation kicks in to buy the 50% interest, plus how we ought to view the capital you've put out through the loan receivable, and what impact the recap could have on sources and uses down the road.

Michael Emory

executive
#70

Right, Mike. We absolutely anticipate that this transaction happens during Q3 of 2021. What it involves, naturally, is repayment to us of the advance we extended, followed by our acquisition of an undivided 50% stake in the property at what I believe is a 5% cap rate. That should take place in Q3, in our expectation. The flow ought to be roughly simultaneous, and it will line up as well with putting a conventional first mortgage in place on the property. As you're aware, Allied typically wouldn't go in for first-mortgage financing. Here, though, since we have a private partner, we're willing to make use of conventional first-mortgage financing, exactly as we'll do alongside our partner Perimeter in Kitchener once we finish the Google building. My expectation, Mike, is that this happens in Q3 of 2021, and I'd say the likelihood is extremely high at this point, considering where construction stands and considering that the building is basically entirely leased to remarkable tenants.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#71

Okay, so just on that — when the loan gets repaid and, sorry, not construction, but the takeout permanent financing goes in, does that mean you guys would actually receive some cash proceeds back once that closes?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#72

Exactly. That's correct. Once our loan gets repaid, the construction financing then goes in place.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#73

All right, I appreciate the clarification there. I'll hand it back over now.

Michael Emory

executive
#74

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#75

Our following question comes from Mario Saric at Scotiabank.

Mario Saric

analyst
#76

Morning, everyone — thanks for joining.

Michael Emory

executive
#77

Morning, everyone.

Mario Saric

analyst
#78

On the capital allocation front for 2021 and really thinking about external growth — Michael, you mentioned the expectation for acquisition opportunities in 2021 with pricing basically unchanged versus pre-COVID levels. Depending on whose estimates you use, Allied's implied cap rate likely rose 160 basis points-plus during the COVID crisis, which produced a large 34% discount to your IFRS NAV. The balance sheet is more or less where you want it, and it doesn't sound like asset sales will be material in the near term. So how are you thinking about growing the company's size and the portfolio while trading at a wider discount to NAV — something that has been relatively rare over Allied's history?

Michael Emory

executive
#79

That's a fair question, and we hear it often, and we have been giving it a lot of thought. I think the best way I can answer that is as follows. With respect to development, the interesting difference is we're committed now to it. There's no discretion. We have made those commitments. We need to complete those construction projects. That's why we took, if I can put it politely, the conservative or careful approach to funding our obligations in that regard. I think the private placement we did was very much putting discretion ahead of valor in an effort to be certain that we could meet those commitments with respect to which we have no discretion. When it comes to acquisitions, it's a much more interesting dynamic for us as a management team because it's an entirely discretionary act on our part. We can choose to do it or not to do it, depending on what we think is best for our business. As I mentioned, if we think it will make us a better provider of distinctive urban workspace in major Canadian cities, we're going to want to do it. Because it's discretionary, that may be a circumstance where we'll use our balance sheet strength to fund the acquisition, at least initially.

Michael Emory

executive
#80

Doing so would make sense and be suitable for us, even if — or perhaps particularly if — our cost of capital has not yet come back to a level we regard as appropriate. I've mentioned before, and our team has talked about, the option of drawing on that unused balance sheet strength to finance acquisitions, in the event that our cost of equity isn't appealing to us for that purpose. That isn't a commitment that we will do so. Nor am I saying we'd do it to an unusual extent. What I am saying is that we would lean toward acting that way on a discretionary basis, provided we're persuaded it would make us a stronger supplier of distinctive urban workspace in this country, or in this country's major cities. To be sure, our cost of equity at present stands as an obstacle to pursuing significant acquisitions. It poses no obstacle to small infill acquisitions, which we keep on making. Taken together, those don't amount to a large quantity of capital. When it comes to larger acquisitions, our cost of equity is presently an obstacle. Our cost of debt is, as it happens, exceptionally appealing, and we might, under the right circumstances, opt to use our balance sheet and put our balance sheet to work. We are not ready to put our balance sheet to work in order to satisfy fixed obligations over time.

Michael Emory

executive
#81

That would be dangerous. We could be ready, since development’s fixed commitments do deliver meaningful deferred returns to us—yet they generate no return at present. That is the key distinction. If we pursue acquisitions, they will produce a current return while also improving how we serve the distinctive urban workspace market. That is the way we would think about it, Mario. I cannot state with certainty what we would do if a wonderful acquisition appeared during the first quarter of 2021 and was sizable, but honestly, we would try as hard as we could to find a suitable and effective route to complete such an acquisition. In that case, we might rely on more debt than equity. We might even divest an asset, since there is no question about our capacity to do so. Frankly, we keep turning away people who tell us, “Please sell us half of this, so you can show the market a good price and your unit price will rebound.” It will not rebound. It would amount to a resounding nothing. If the purpose were to enable a major acquisition, that is an entirely different situation, and we might well consider that opportunity at that point. Again, this is somewhat scattered, but I hope it is useful.

Mario Saric

analyst
#82

No, I appreciate that added detail. Have you given any thought to what kind of balance sheet capacity might be available, perhaps for funding transactions or acquisitions in 2021?

Michael Emory

executive
#83

The urge to go down that road has been something I've held back from, though the impact of doing so would hardly be trivial.

Mario Saric

analyst
#84

All right.

Michael Emory

executive
#85

Our balance sheet can stay quite conservative, we can remain near our targets, and a meaningful portion of an acquisition can be financed with debt. I've pretty much intentionally avoided putting a number on that, because my colleagues would give me grief about it.

Mario Saric

analyst
#86

All right, I won't create any problems for you with the people you work with, so I'll move along to the following question.

Michael Emory

executive
#87

Go on, I beg you. I'm hardly keeping my head above water as things stand.

Mario Saric

analyst
#88

The following question concerns sublet space, and specifically your remark that the very early talks you're holding with tenants point to their returning at full workforce strength. That struck me as interesting. Sublet space in your portfolio is also rising around the same time, going from 2.2% of the portfolio to 4.7%. Could you perhaps square those two statements for me? The first is an expectation that people will return in full force, and the second is that you're seeing TAMI tenants place a portion of their space on the sublet market inside your portfolio.

Michael Emory

executive
#89

Mario, the way I see it, the fair way to square that is this: the TAMI tenants who are listing their space for sublease are feeling some top-line pressure. They have to cut costs. What's interesting to us is that in our portfolio, it isn't really tech tenants doing this. I can't speak for others. It's advertising and media — I believe their top lines are under a bit of strain, and I think they want to bring down their ongoing expenses. They're probably advised well enough to realize they hold something highly marketable. If you've got 25,000 sq ft of Allied space at, say, CAD 18 net, you'll exit that very successfully and at minimal cost. In fact, what often happens is the tenant comes to us and says, "We need your approval — A. B, the subtenant wants a longer term. Would you sign a direct lease with our subtenant?" What we typically do then is say, "We have a good opportunity for you. We'll enter into the direct lease from day one. We'll release you from your obligation, as long as the subtenant is suitably strong, and we'll handle the subtenant." That's where we've gained on virtually every sublease any of our tenants have completed.

Michael Emory

executive
#90

I think the way to square that is this, Tom: as far as I know, all of our major sublease tenants — and again, these are spaces of the 20,000-foot kind — want to keep their expenses in check going forward, since there's some pressure on their top line. In advertising, as you're aware, the traditional ad agencies remain viable businesses, but for several years now their top lines have been squeezed, and every one of them is focused on controlling costs. My belief is that the reason for subleasing space in our portfolio is almost entirely cost management, not any reluctance to bring employees back to the office. It's just that they likely have fewer employees, period, and therefore need less space, period. They are working to control the cost.

Mario Saric

analyst
#91

All right, just a couple more quick items from me, and one of them is for Tom. Regarding that roughly 120,000 sq ft you mentioned after Q3 — those three leases — how does the mark to market on them stack up against the 19% you achieved in Q3?

Tom Burns

executive
#92

I'd say roughly 20%, Mario. For those three deals, I haven't run the precise math. And here's another interesting detail about those transactions: in each of the three, the allowance we set aside was minimal. We also saw a rent increase.

Mario Saric

analyst
#93

All right, that's excellent. One final item from me: the LQA NOI at 250 Front declined somewhat compared with the prior quarter. I believe it went from roughly CAD 1.6 million to CAD 12.4 million. Occupancy, as mentioned earlier, was roughly flat versus the previous quarter. Could you shed some light on what caused that dip?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#94

Yeah. Hey, Mario. A recovery cap did hit us during Q3, though it was confined to that quarter, and it’s not going to show up again. The amount was CAD 400,000, which was annualized, but nothing like that will occur from October 1 onward.

Mario Saric

analyst
#95

Understood. So does that mean, if nothing else changes, from that point on it will rise by CAD 0.4 million?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#96

Sure thing.

Mario Saric

analyst
#97

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#98

Our next question comes from Howard Leung at Veritas Investment Research.

Howard Leung

analyst
#99

Appreciate it, and good morning, everyone.

Michael Emory

executive
#100

Morning, everyone.

Howard Leung

analyst
#101

Let me go back to that question about the pandemic being behind us and what you’ve been hearing from these tenants. You said that all of them have indicated, up to this point, that they’ll come back with their full workforce. Has there been any conversation about every employee coming back, but on hybrid schedules — meaning they’d be in the office just some of the time?

Michael Emory

executive
#102

Tom has handled the majority of those conversations, so I'll let him take that one.

Tom Burns

executive
#103

I decided to personally reach out to pretty much every major tenant we have in the portfolio, just to hear how they're feeling about coming back to the office and what lies ahead regarding flexibility for their employees. Every single one of them tells me they need their office space. They're eager to return. Most likely they'll offer employees some form of flexibility in the work week, but as far as I know, nobody has defined or established exactly what that looks like yet.

Howard Leung

analyst
#104

Right — I’d say it’s probably too soon for that.

Tom Burns

executive
#105

That’s correct.

Howard Leung

analyst
#106

So going forward, I suppose demand will be lower as a result of that.

Tom Burns

executive
#107

That's right.

Howard Leung

analyst
#108

To be more precise about the vacancies that emerged in Q3 compared with the prior quarter — I believe your remark was that the REIT had largely anticipated them. Just to clarify, were those expected before the pandemic hit? Had most of those vacancies been identified in advance, or did they only come to light during the pandemic?

Tom Burns

executive
#109

My take is that every one of those was already on our radar before the pandemic hit. We speak with the tenants routinely, well ahead of the date their leases run out, so we saw this coming. Nothing caught us off guard.

Michael Emory

executive
#110

Yes. And just to build on that point, Tom — unless I'm wrong about this, in each and every case, the tenant chose not to renew, and those tenants are, every single one of them, genuinely excellent tenants. What led them to not renew comes down to needing additional space, and we weren't in a position to provide it to them. Losing tenants for that reason is something we really dislike. We simply hate it. The pandemic played no part in it whatsoever.

Tom Burns

executive
#111

You're right about that.

Howard Leung

analyst
#112

That seems reasonable to me. Many of the vacant units listed in your table, I believe, come in at less than 10,000 sq ft, so presumably they were after something bigger. My next question, I suppose, concerns the leasing activity. Regarding the table included in the report, for this quarter, I guess, is any portion of it tied to leasing done through subleases? Take the 80 to 82 Spadina deal you mentioned, for instance—does that appear within the lease activity table, or does it stand as a separate transaction?

Tom Burns

executive
#113

That happened after the quarter ended, and it was not a sublease.

Howard Leung

analyst
#114

All right, understood. Then let me ask just one more about the development activity. Regarding TELUS Sky, I believe the table shows its transfer into rental properties has been moved to Q4. Could you go over once more what the criteria are for moving a property into the rental portfolio?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#115

Hey Howard — it’s at the point when every occupancy permit we need is in hand, and we anticipate having those in Q4.

Howard Leung

analyst
#116

Right, understood. Okay then. Appreciate it. That's all I had. Back to you.

Operator

operator
#117

Thanks. Just a quick reminder — if you'd like to ask a question, go ahead and press star one to signal us. Our next question comes from Matt Kornack at National Bank Financial.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#118

Morning, everyone — I'll do my best to be brief here.

Tom Burns

executive
#119

Good morning, everyone.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#120

On the sublet space, could you say whether any portion of that is presently included in your deferral program? You provided certain benchmarks regarding rent spreads, but do you have any indication of the weighted average rent spread and the term to maturity for those leases?

Tom Burns

executive
#121

Right. To begin with, none of those tenants belong to the deferral program. Every one of them is a highly credible tenant. We have meaningful upside available between the rents currently in place and market levels.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#122

Alright.

Tom Burns

executive
#123

Three and a half years.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#124

A period of 3.5 years.

Tom Burns

executive
#125

The average term on a weighted basis comes to 3.5 years.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#126

I believe you brought this up before — your leases don't permit them to make a profit on a sublet. If they managed to charge rent above market rate, they'd need to split that with you, right?

Tom Burns

executive
#127

You've got that right.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#128

Regarding 425 Viger and TELUS Sky, has 425 Viger reached full cash rent at this point, and is TELUS Sky recognizing any straight-line rent at all right now?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#129

TELUS Sky is still being accounted for on a straight-line rent basis, and 425 Viger has not yet moved fully into cash rent.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#130

Cecilia, at this stage do you have any sense of what share it would sit in?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#131

That would represent only a small share.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#132

Is that right? Yeah. Okay.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#133

Only a small piece of that 425 would be cash rent. The majority of it starts in Q1 of next year.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#134

Alright, perfect. This is my final question. Regarding changes in market rent, it appears the majority occurred in Toronto during 2022 and afterward. I take it that reflects both new supply entering the market and some anticipation of financial institutions returning space. You didn’t record any fair value adjustments on the portfolio. Were you using different rent figures in your projections? How should we interpret that? Perhaps you lowered cap rates on certain of those rent assumptions.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#135

Let me be clear about the market rents we report for space that's maturing — we aren't attempting to predict what market rents will look like down the road. We make no adjustment for any supply we anticipate arriving on the market in 2022. What we use is the current market rent for that particular space that's maturing. Each quarter, together with the brokerage community, we evaluate what today's market rate is for all the space coming up for maturity across the next five years. Those adjustments were made according to the nature of the space.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#136

All right, that's quite interesting. So in your DCF, I suppose you'd use a market rent as of the moment it comes due. Would that be fair?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#137

Right. About the DCF — I believe what you were asking had to do with the overall increase across the portfolio?

Matt Kornack

analyst
#138

I suppose that's really about whether we'd adjust any of our rent assumptions as we move forward.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#139

Cushman, the appraiser, would have adjusted the assumption. Our IFRS value rose during the quarter, mainly thanks to lease deals that came in above what the appraisers had modeled. No matter what they modeled, we ultimately did somewhat better than that in the quarter.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#140

Alright, perfect. Appreciate it, everyone, and it seems like a fairly steady quarter given everything.

Tom Burns

executive
#141

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#142

Our following question comes from Mike Markidis at Desjardins. Mr. Markidis, your line is open.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#143

Apologies — I had myself on mute. Thank you. That happens to me quite often lately, it seems. Regarding TELUS Sky, I simply wanted to ask a follow-up. I believe during the previous call you noted that occupancy permits were in hand and that the initial residents had moved in during August. What I'm hoping to understand more clearly is whether the transfer will happen across all of Q, meaning will the full decapitalization occur in the fourth quarter? And beyond that, if you could share where residential leasing stands at TELUS Sky, that would be quite useful.

Hugh Clark

executive
#144

Okay. When Q2 wrapped up, we had secured occupancy permits through a particular stage of the residential levels. We just managed, as Q4 got underway, to obtain the remaining occupancy permits. So at this point the entire building is able to be converted into PUD. On the residential floors, the transactions taking place align with our pro forma. Traction there looks solid. Westbank is engaged in efforts to lease out the remaining space in the building.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#145

All right — I don’t mean to press you on this at all, but what would the lease rate be right now?

Hugh Clark

executive
#146

If we look at it per square foot?

Mike Markidis

analyst
#147

Actually, I meant occupancy—not rent. My mistake.

Hugh Clark

executive
#148

That matches what we had projected regarding leasing activity for the residential floors.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#149

Alright.

Hugh Clark

executive
#150

At the very start.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#151

Right. Perhaps, provided that aligns with your assumptions, what did the initial pro forma assume regarding the time needed to lease?

Hugh Clark

executive
#152

Oh, roughly twelve months.

Michael Emory

executive
#153

A full year.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#154

Over a 12-month period. All right. When you look at those pro formas you're putting up, does that factor in any possible incentives, or is there no incentive activity at all?

Hugh Clark

executive
#155

Yes, that includes the incentive program. It was factored into our pro forma, and we assumed it as part of the project cost and the lease-up.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#156

All right, that's really great news. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#157

Right now, there aren’t any more questions waiting in the queue.

Michael Emory

executive
#158

Thank you, operator. I appreciate everyone joining us on this call. I hope our presentation and responses proved useful to you. We’re eager to keep you updated on how we’re progressing. Until then, take care, stay safe, and have a good day. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#159

Thanks, everyone, and that brings today's call to a close. You're free to hang up now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.