Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust (APUN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 4, 2021

Toronto Stock Exchange CA Real Estate Office REITs earnings 87 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Thanks for joining us this morning, everyone, and welcome to the call. With me today are Tom, Cecilia and Hugh, and we're here to go over Allied's results for the Fourth Quarter and Year Ended December 31, 2020. During this conference call, we might make forward-looking statements regarding future events or future performance. By their very nature, such statements carry risks and uncertainties that could cause actual events or results to differ materially, including the risks outlined under the heading risks and uncertainties in our most recently filed Annual Information Form and in our latest quarterly report. The material assumptions underlying any forward-looking statements we make include those set out under forward-looking disclaimer in our most recent quarterly report.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#2

Good morning. To begin with, our financial performance, our property portfolio and our customer base proved resilient all through 2020. Even though rental income was down for a time, same asset NOI, FFO per unit and AFFO per unit all rose in the fourth quarter compared with the same quarter a year earlier. In each of those measures, the fourth quarter also came in stronger than the third quarter. The same holds true for our full year results, even after including $10 million of non-recurring items during the period. Those non-recurring items were made up of $5.1 million of abatements under the CECRA program, $2.8 million in provisions on deferrals, and a temporary decline in our parking revenue. Second, on our balance sheet, NAV per unit at December 31 rose 4.3% versus the same time a year ago. Our IFRS value increment for the fourth quarter increased by $15 million, mainly driven by rent growth in Toronto, partly offset by continued weakness in Calgary. We completed our Green Financing Framework. Sustainalytics has certified it, and it is posted on our website. Our plan is for our next bond issuance to be our inaugural Green bond. That reflects our continued commitment and attention to ESG matters.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#3

Closing out the fourth quarter, net debt to EBITDA stood at 7.4x. Total debt came to 29.2% of IFRS value, while interest coverage was 3.4x. We figure our developments — carrying a 13.5-year weighted average lease term — will add roughly $70 million to annual EBITDA across the coming 3 years. This will not only boost earnings per unit substantially, together with expected organic growth, but also meaningfully bring down our net debt to EBITDA ratio and meaningfully raise our interest coverage ratio — the two debt metrics we regard as most important. Our unencumbered asset pool totals $6.5 billion, which is 73% of our investment properties. As mortgages mature, we plan to keep prepaying or repaying them, aiming for most of our asset base to be unencumbered. In our view, this will leave us with the strongest and most flexible balance sheet, both defensively and offensively.

Tom Burns

executive
#4

I appreciate that, Cecilia. In Montreal, Toronto, Calgary, and Vancouver, our leasing teams did a great job in Q4, and they also did a great job throughout 2020. Altogether, across the year they closed 258 transactions, and 105 of those were new deals. That means 105 new tenants added to the portfolio. During the year, on space that was renewed or replaced, we recorded a healthy 17.2% increase in year one base rent. On the whole, leased area dipped a little to just under 93%, though the pandemic was not the cause of that dip. There were four distinct reasons. First, we bought some buildings early in the year that had vacancy. Second, a few non-renewals occurred, and we had known about them. Third, we were partially de-leasing two buildings in Montreal and two in Vancouver to get ready for repositioning in 2021. And fourth, TELUS Sky joined the rental portfolio in Q4, and that building is 68% leased. Had we made an apples-to-apples comparison, our leased area would in fact have risen in 2020. I will give an update on leasing activity in our major markets, including an update on our UDC portfolio, then finish with some remarks about the sublease market. Montreal was once again our most active market in Q4, with that team completing 38 deals in the quarter and a very impressive 130 deals for the year.

Tom Burns

executive
#5

Although Q4 didn't include any transactions that stood out by size, the team right now is handling an 89,000 square foot extension and expansion involving a tenant already in place, plus a new lease covering 50,000 square feet of currently vacant space. Updates on both of those deals will come at our next conference call. In Toronto we sit at 96% leased, and we closed the 61,000 square foot lease extension that was flagged as conditional during the Q3 call. During the quarter we also moved and grew a fin-tech tenant by 37,000 square feet, and did the same for a tech tenant at 26,000 square feet. Right after year end, the team signed a 25,000 square foot lease with a law firm covering two floors in the high rise portion of the tower at The Well, which lifts our leased area in that project's office component to 86%. That latest deal came in at rents above pro forma. Worth noting is that this significant transaction brings in the Toronto leasing team along with our most senior leadership.

Hugh Clark

executive
#6

Thanks, Tom. A number of construction projects saw solid progress this quarter. The second wave of COVID did affect manpower at our construction sites, but we've been working with our construction teams to keep the impact on the overall schedule as small as possible. I'll start with an overview of our major projects, then follow up with an update on planning activity for our development pipeline. Construction activity. Starting in Montreal, our team has been focusing on upgrades to vacant suites as well as the upgrade of 400 Atlantic and 700 DLG. We've made progress on both properties. We expect those projects to be finished by the end of the year and in the first quarter of 2022, respectively. In Toronto and Kitchener, our projects have moved along well despite government restrictions on construction. Fortunately, every one of our projects — all of our major construction projects qualify for the exemptions that allow work to continue. The Well has reached the 36th floor of the main office building and will be topped off in early Q1. We've completed the handover of 2 of the 6 transfer slabs, which has allowed us to close on those two air right sales.

Hugh Clark

executive
#7

We expect to finalize the rest of those sales during 2021. By collaborating with our construction managers, we've managed to reduce the effect of workforce cutbacks caused by COVID. We remain dedicated to keeping our sites safe and fulfilling our leasing commitments. Out in Western Canada, we've achieved meaningful headway on restoring the Lougheed Building, and our work on the Boardwalk Revlon Building in Edmonton is now progressing well. Over in Vancouver, our partners at Westbank are finishing up the envelope installation at 400 West Georgia. Fit-up work by tenants is set to start in late Q2 and carry into 2022. Turning to planning activity. This quarter, our emphasis has been on getting ready for formal submissions on a number of intensification projects in Toronto and Montreal. We expect to file those submissions in late Q1 and early Q2 for our Bathurst Street assembly, the Castle and Liberty Village, and Nordelec's first expansion. Once approved, these potential projects would add roughly 500,000 square feet of office space to our pipeline of future intensifications. Despite COVID's effects, this quarter has brought progress across every area of our development activity. Although we don't currently expect material changes to the construction schedule for our major projects, we're actively working with our various teams to tackle the manpower effects we've observed over the last 3 months.

Michael Emory

executive
#8

Thanks, Hugh. The strength of our platform, along with steady demand for unique urban workspace, let us raise our annual distribution in the late part of the fourth quarter — marking the ninth year in a row. Speculation keeps swirling about how disruptive working from home will be, but everything our users have told us points to one thing: once the pandemic ends, they intend to bring their workforce back to the office. For most knowledge-based organizations, an extended stretch of working from home seems materially suboptimal when it comes to culture, engagement and productivity. Our task is to keep anticipating how urban workspace will evolve, which is exactly what we have been doing for decades now. Given what we have experienced since returning to the office in early July of last year, I remain deeply confident in — and committed to — Allied’s strategy of consolidating and intensifying distinctive urban workspace and network dense UDCs in Canada’s major cities. I am firmly convinced that the most important secular trends in Canadian and global real estate underpin our strategy. I am equally convinced that we possess the properties, the financial strength, the people and the platform needed to carry out our strategy for the ongoing benefit of our unitholders.

Michael Emory

executive
#9

For Allied, buying properties has never been a goal in itself—it's always been a way to give knowledge-based organizations distinctive urban workspace more effectively and more profitably. That's equally true of what we do in development, redevelopment and upgrades. We're still focused on growing our urban workspace portfolio continuously, along with our UDC portfolio, over a 3 to 5-year timeframe. Canadian urban workspace is starting to trade again after a pause during the shutdown and the early part of the reopening, and the most notable deals have been in downtown Toronto and downtown Vancouver at low capitalization rates. I anticipate that meaningful acquisition opportunities will come up for Allied in 2021, and we'll be ready, willing and able to seize them if, as and when they arise. For the type of workspace we're after, capitalization rates should be largely in line with those seen before the shutdown. One last comment, or note, on ESG. As you know, we committed to formally submitting to independent scrutiny regarding our ESG performance by 2020. The single most important step for us was obtaining a GRESB Assessment and providing an annual ESG report.

Michael Emory

executive
#10

As you’re aware, these reports pinpoint Allied’s strengths as well as areas where improvement is possible. To my mind, what matters most is that they’ll help the board and management set sensible priorities moving ahead and will supply benchmarks against which progress can be measured going forward. On December 2 of last year, we released our first Environmental, Social and Governance report. As we disclosed, we completed that GRESB Assessment and got a score of 64, which isn’t heroic, yet GRESB recognized it as “a strong first year showing.” Going forward, we plan to obtain a GRESB Assessment and issue an ESG report annually.

Operator

operator
#11

Our first question comes from Caitlin Burrows at Goldman Sachs.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#12

Hello, and good morning to all of you. Perhaps we might begin by discussing leasing activity: renewals and replacements both rose considerably during the quarter, yet on a trailing 12-month basis the trend has been downward, and occupancy has declined as well—though naturally it remains off the very high levels you all experienced, and you covered some of the factors behind that. That said, I'd like to ask whether you can see any path to occupancy bottoming out, and if so, when that might happen and how much further it could fall?

Tom Burns

executive
#13

Our occupancy levels, we believe, are going to rise as the year goes on. As I said earlier on this call, occupancy was really tied to our de-leasing some space and bringing in some buildings that hadn't been part of the prior year — in the earlier quarter. So we're confident we can keep leasing and hold occupancy where it is. On the increase in rents for space that gets replaced or renewed, we hit 17.2%, which came in very near what we'd been delivering in prior quarters for a good long stretch. This quarter we did have some unusual circumstances, largely in our Calgary portfolio, and that affected those numbers, making a very modest difference to the rents we achieved in the quarter. We don't expect that to happen at all going forward; we think we'll be able to sustain large rental increases, mainly because a lot of the space being renewed happens to sit in Toronto, our strongest market, where we're confident we'll keep getting big upticks.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#14

That's useful, thanks. Michael, toward the end there you said you saw potentially meaningful acquisition opportunities coming up in 2021. So I wanted to ask — you noted cap rates might be similar to what they were before, but bearing in mind that your cost of equity has gone up and your leverage is comparatively higher? How would you go about financing those potential acquisitions, and what decision — what kinds of decisions would you weigh when determining whether those acquisitions make financial sense for Allied right now?

Michael Emory

executive
#15

We have quite a bit of flexibility when it comes to funding acquisitions over the near term. Our debt metrics have always been the primary constraint for us. And as you know, fit with our mission has always been another one. So the first thing we'll ask ourselves is whether this opportunity lets us deliver distinctive urban workspace more successfully and more profitably. If we answer yes, then we'll be strongly inclined to go after the acquisition, and we'll decide on the best funding approach in light of the deal itself and what it could mean for short-term accretion. One thing available to us in 2021 is the ability to lean on our balance sheet somewhat more aggressively than we have historically, and we can do so because we're highly confident in the $70 million that would be coming into our EBITDA beginning in 2022 and ramping up significantly in 2023. So we have plenty of flexibility, Caitlin, and we'll make every decision according to the circumstances at the relevant time. If our cost of equity were to improve, we might look at pursuing that path.

Michael Emory

executive
#16

If it didn't, and we found the opportunity really compelling, then we could look at letting our debt metrics run somewhat above the usual level for a short period. So I believe that's a call we'll need to make when the moment arrives, based on all the circumstances. But here's what I can promise you: we won't hold back from moving and taking action when the right opportunities come along. And there's another point I wanted to flag and to stress again — those opportunities aren't going to come cheap. Everything we're after carries a high price tag, and that's the end of it. Back in late 2020, we did succeed in picking up a few highly attractive small in-fill acquisitions — not at distressed pricing, but at what I'd describe as pricing we probably couldn't have obtained under other conditions. As for larger acquisitions, I don't believe that avenue is available to us; we'll be required to pay full value. And should they match our focus, as I said earlier, we have the means to pursue them and the willingness to make whatever decision is needed regarding which type of funding we'll use.

Caitlin Burrows

analyst
#17

All right, that’s really useful. Thanks.

Michael Emory

executive
#18

I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#19

Our next question comes from Fred Blondeau at AI Securities.

Fred Blondeau

analyst
#20

Thanks, and good morning. I have one quick question, I suppose, for Tom: it seems that Allied’s portfolio beats the market when it comes to sublet space, following up on what you said about that topic. For Toronto CBD, or the Toronto core, and likewise for Allied’s portfolio, what base scenario would you have regarding sublet space in 2021?

Tom Burns

executive
#21

In Toronto, that actually makes up 56% of the total sublease space we have, and we're under market by roughly 25% on those spaces being offered for sublease. So if we're approached about subleases, we expect to be in a strong position. Most of those subleases, Fred, are fairly short-term, and most tenants interested in those spaces will come to us seeking an extension of the term, which gives us a chance to bring the rents to market.

Fred Blondeau

analyst
#22

Okay, and so — in your view, have we kind of hit a high point when it comes to sublet space, or is it going to level off?

Tom Burns

executive
#23

That's a fair question. Actually, I think we might see a decline as the year goes on, since tenants—some of them, anyway—have already realized they'll need the space and have pulled it off the market. So whether we'll see an uptick, I'm not sure, but a decrease is probably what we'll get. Keep in mind that roughly 75% of the space being offered for sublease consists of units smaller than 10,000 square feet. So you have small tenants who've been at home working remotely, wanting to put their space on the sublease market just to see what happens. Nobody's taking it. They're going to come back and use that space.

Fred Blondeau

analyst
#24

Excellent. That’s all I have. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#25

Our next question comes from Jonathan Kelcher at TD Securities.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#26

Thanks. Good morning. And I guess just staying on that subleased square footage — roughly how much term is left, do you think, on the bulk of it?

Tom Burns

executive
#27

My understanding is that the weighted average lease term comes to 4 years.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#28

Okay, sorry about that. So is it basically just about how that works in the near term — I mean, the tenants handle the subleasing, then they have to get your approval, and after that you try to sign a longer-term lease? Would that be a fair way to think about it?

Tom Burns

executive
#29

Typically, the situation is that incoming tenants or sub-tenants tend not to be fond of the lease already in place, and they'll want certain modifications made. They'll want to leave their own mark on the transaction. So they'll approach us and say they'd like to sublease the space, but they require 5 additional years and they don't want a particular provision included in the deal. That hands us some leverage to respond, fine, we'll grant you the longer term and we may adjust the provision you're requesting, but in exchange, we need rents to go up immediately. That's generally the way it plays out.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#30

Alright, that’s useful. And Cecilia, when we look at the same-asset NOI growth outlook for next year, how much will come from the UDC portfolio, and how much from the rest of the portfolio?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#31

In 2021, the core urban workspace portfolio and UDC are genuinely the ones powering that identical asset NOI.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#32

Okay, but in Q4 I believe that figure was around 13% compared with roughly 0.5% between the two — is that the kind of pattern we should anticipate going ahead, or do you think it will even out more?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#33

That isn't the pattern we'd expect as we move ahead. In 2021, things would definitely be more even.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#34

All right, and then one final thing about that $450 million in development capital — roughly how does that break down across the coming two years?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#35

The spending is heavily concentrated up front. We expect somewhere in the range of $250 million to $280 million in 2021, and then the bulk of what remains falls in 2022, with only a small amount after that.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#36

All right, I’m finished. Thank you.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#37

Sure thing.

Operator

operator
#38

Our next question comes from Jenny Ma at BMO Capital Markets.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#39

Thanks, and good morning. I’d like to go back to the acquisitions you mentioned, Michael, and make sure I’ve got this right. Is it accurate that many of the opportunities you’re anticipating come from smaller properties rather than bigger ones such as 700 DLGs in 2019? Have I understood that correctly?

Michael Emory

executive
#40

Let me clarify what I was trying to say — perhaps I didn't put it clearly. In the latter part of 2020, we actually succeeded in completing several small infill acquisitions, and I believe those carry very meaningful potential over the long term for the business. Looking ahead to 2021, I would anticipate perhaps a few more of that type going forward, but what I expect on a more meaningful scale is larger transactions in the Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver markets — deals closer to the landing in terms of scale. If such transactions do arise, we will be very motivated to pursue them, and we expect we would have to pay for them as we did in 2019. So what I meant to suggest, or telegraph, is our expectation that larger opportunities will be available to us in 2021, and should they be, we will certainly be willing, motivated and able to pursue them.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#41

All right, so if those do end up happening, it seems like the timing would lean more toward the middle to end of 2021 — would that be a fair way to put it?

Michael Emory

executive
#42

The thing about acquisitions is that you can honestly never forecast the timing of when they will come along. It might happen tomorrow. As we sit here today, we have nothing in our sights. But honestly, based on our experience across 18 years now, an opportunity could come up tomorrow, or we could be staring at nothing at all well into December. So there is simply no way for us to predict it. I just have a strong feeling, from what I am hearing from others in the marketplace, that deals of some consequence are likely to reach the market at some point during 2021. I hope that proves to be the case. There is no assurance it will happen, but I am — my sense is that it will, and if it does and those opportunities align with our investment and operating focus, we will be all over them.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#43

Okay, great. And here's another question that's separate but related: I'm wondering whether you're noticing any distress in the market, perhaps among the smaller players, or whether you really haven't seen much of that, given what's happened less?

Michael Emory

executive
#44

Unfortunately, that isn’t the case. To me, it resembles the global financial crisis very closely. I recall telling investors back then that the positive aspect was the absence of distress, while the negative aspect was also the absence of distress—and that assessment was fairly accurate at the time and remains accurate today. That said, I would note that the smaller acquisitions we completed during 2020, and which we anticipate completing during 2021, involve purchases from sellers who are not under distress but who feel more motivated to sell than usual. Typically, these are sellers holding assets with a substantial accrued gain; they are not real estate professionals, though they are clearly very astute businesspeople, and they determine that the disruption occurring around them makes monetizing their gain more advantageous than waiting for additional gain on a contingent basis. That is how I would describe the smaller transactions we carried out in 2020. So, these are strong parties, not in distress, but more motivated because of the pandemic-driven disruption than they would have been before the pandemic; the clearest illustration in my view is the three outstanding assets we purchased on John Street.

Michael Emory

executive
#45

For many years we watched that row and showed interest repeatedly, yet nobody ever took us up on it. Around late 2020, those same individuals—or at least a handful of them—turned far more open, and they started the process that led to transactions: not large capital commitments, but long-term assets we never thought we could obtain before the pandemic. We would be delighted to have those, and that is perhaps the single upside for the acquisition side of the business stemming from the pandemic, though in total capital deployed they are fairly modest—still, I believe they matter significantly going forward. With luck, more such deals will come, but no one is over-levered. No one owes more than the mortgage. No one is in any form of distress, at least as far as we can tell, or at least among those owning the sort of assets that interest us. There simply is no distress there. Even in Calgary, there is no distress.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#46

All right, let's turn to the renewal and re-leasing rates. So, you noted it came down somewhat in 2020 compared with 2019. I'm just curious whether there was a bias toward a lower retention rate on renewals, or simply reduced re-leasing activity — was it really driven mostly by one or the other?

Michael Emory

executive
#47

I just want to make sure I follow your question, Jenny — what is it that went down, or which figure are you asking about when you say ticked down? Is it the…

Jenny Ma

analyst
#48

That figure of 78%.

Michael Emory

executive
#49

Absolutely.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#50

That figure has fallen from roughly the mid-80% range where Allied had been running over the past few years. So I'm curious: did the dip in 2020 come from lower retention on renewals, or was it simply less activity on the re-leasing side?

Michael Emory

executive
#51

Tom may have a sharper read on the specifics than I do, but from where I sit, our non-renewals in 2020 exceeded those in 2019 that we were aware of before the pandemic, and those non-renewals stemmed from tenants having outgrown the space, which we couldn't accommodate. We dislike that. Yet it's the one thing we have no defense against. So there are two specifically, Tom, that come to mind where the tenant loved the building, had a good relationship with Allied, but required more space and we just couldn't provide it either in that building or anywhere else in the portfolio. Is that right?

Tom Burns

executive
#52

That's exactly right. And one major factor was that 6 renewals in Calgary occurred on properties exiting long-term agreements. So those rents would have been pretty elevated, and the Calgary market shifted considerably. As a result, we wound up accepting lower rent. So that significantly affected those figures.

Michael Emory

executive
#53

Yeah, so that would be the Q4 rent growth number. The 7.3%, or whatever the exact figure is, came in low compared with Q3, Q2, and Q1, and that was mostly because of those Calgary transactions, plus the softer renewal rate — basically the Toronto non-renewals, which happened simply because we couldn't accommodate those tenants' growth. And like I said, that's the thing we dislike more than anything, and it's one reason growth in our asset base matters so much to us: we really hate being unable to accommodate a tenant who's growing and who's well disposed toward our kind of space and toward us as an operator. But that's what pulled the renewal rate down slightly in 2020, and it does have.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#54

Alright, thanks. I've got a few questions about modeling, specifically around capitalized interest. It seems there was a $1 million sequential increase. I'm curious what caused that—was it a higher borrowing base, or something different—and should we expect that to continue over the next couple of quarters?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#55

Hi, Jenny. This is Cecilia. When you go to recalculate capitalized interest, the residential inventory has to be part of that. I can take you through it offline, but the details are in Note 6 of the financial statement. So if you add that to the PUD balance and apply our weighted average cost of debt, you'll land within the range for the quarter.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#56

Thank you, that's quite useful. Just one final item regarding the Quebec subsidy for CECRA: did that represent the make-up payment on the 50% share of the landlord's portion that they were covering, and how much did that add? Understood, fine. And what amount of that was tied to same-store?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#57

In Q4, we got $700,000 from the Quebec government. So we offset the 5.8 we had avoided in Q2 and Q3 against that $700,000 subsidy in Q4, giving a net abatement of 5.1 for the year.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#58

All right. So that covers the whole thing, correct — it won’t return in future quarters?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#59

You're right. There aren't any additional costs. That's correct.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#60

All right, thanks to all of you. I’ll hand it back over.

Operator

operator
#61

Our next question comes from Brad Sturges at Raymond James. Your line is now open — you might be on mute.

Michael Emory

executive
#62

Brad, I believe your line is muted.

Brad Sturges

analyst
#63

Hi there, is my voice coming through okay?

Michael Emory

executive
#64

Absolutely.

Brad Sturges

analyst
#65

Thanks. Apologies for that. So, drawing on the conversations you’ve had with your tenants up to now, what base case are they assuming for a fuller return to the office — is it roughly the back half of 2021, contingent on how the vaccine rollout goes, or how are those talks progressing at the moment?

Michael Emory

executive
#66

Okay, here's how I'd put it. During the fourth quarter, there was a lot of uncertainty about when the pandemic would end, and with the vaccine arriving, people were also quite unsure about what "over" would actually look like. And I think that as distribution has moved along slowly but steadily — and I suppose as the vaccine has been introduced to populations worldwide — that confidence has been building. So our users still aren't certain about when they'll feel at ease coming back. A lot of them, I think, are imagining summer or perhaps later than that. But I wouldn't say that a large share of the office users in our portfolio who have stayed away have truly made a firm decision on that front. Still, quite a few users never left, so to speak — to some extent ourselves among them. But as for those who did leave in a very big and emphatic way, I think they're still watching and haven't yet committed to themselves, much less to anyone else, on when they'll come back. We've kept up constant communication — not so much to push people into returning. That choice is entirely theirs, but so that we're ready for them once they do come back.

Michael Emory

executive
#67

So if we were sizing things up right now, my expectation is that we won’t see a big influx into the buildings beyond those already on site, at minimum through the second quarter. And in the first quarter, I definitely don’t anticipate anything meaningful.

Brad Sturges

analyst
#68

Before we get to that, if there's a plan to come back or make choices about office requirements around Q2 or Q3, would you anticipate leasing or touring activity picking up beforehand — perhaps in late Q1 and on into Q2?

Michael Emory

executive
#69

Since the tail end of Q2 2020, leasing has been climbing sharply, and for Allied it hasn’t eased at all, as Tom noted. We closed 258 deals in 2020 — a truly remarkable volume — with 105 of them bringing new tenants into the portfolio. So within our portfolio, leasing has picked up noticeably and consistently from around June 2020, and for us it hasn’t let up in the slightest.

Brad Sturges

analyst
#70

Perhaps as a final question, I want to return briefly to what we discussed regarding subleasing. On your exposure, is it still primarily media advertising firms? And have you noticed any shift when it comes to financial services companies offering space to the sublease market?

Michael Emory

executive
#71

We haven't observed any shift at all. And, as you're aware, our exposure to the financial services sector is quite minimal.

Brad Sturges

analyst
#72

Thanks a lot, that’s helpful.

Michael Emory

executive
#73

Sure thing.

Operator

operator
#74

Our next question comes from Mike Markidis at Desjardins.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#75

Hello, everyone, and thanks. Apologies for rehashing this—likely more of the same questions—but regarding the sublease space, I believe you said The Wall is 4 year, and you mentioned that for Toronto it stands at 25% mark-to-market; by any chance do you know what the mark-to-market would be across the entire pool?

Tom Burns

executive
#76

My guess would be 18.8%.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#77

All right, thanks. And then just a…

Michael Emory

executive
#78

That's a fairly exact guess.

Tom Burns

executive
#79

It could be 18.7%, or possibly 18.9%.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#80

Also, have you closed any direct deals over the last two or three quarters, or were you just saying that in the past you'd expect them to return…

Tom Burns

executive
#81

Could you repeat that, Mike?

Mike Markidis

analyst
#82

I'm just curious — over the last couple of quarters, you've actually completed some direct deals on this basis that has been listed, so is that expansion purely on top of the sublease space, or is there a net effect in terms of the leases that have been done to…

Tom Burns

executive
#83

A large number of direct deals have been completed by us.

Michael Emory

executive
#84

I want to make sure I've got this right, Mike — is your question whether we've completed any direct deals involving sublease space? Is that what you're asking?

Mike Markidis

analyst
#85

Over the last two quarters or so — yes, that would be in your leasing activity?

Michael Emory

executive
#86

Nope. That’s not something we’ve done. We have not.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#87

That's reasonable. All right, I'll let that topic go. I believe we observed 400 Atlantic move into the development pool. And Michael, if my memory serves, you referenced 2 properties in Montreal — possibly 1 more on top of that — plus another 2 in Vancouver. Could you provide us with some additional detail regarding how much leasing will carry on at those sites and when, if ever, they might shift over to private?

Michael Emory

executive
#88

Tom brought up the de-leasing, I believe, so I’ll let him name the properties that we are quite familiar with.

Tom Burns

executive
#89

Those aren't the same situation — 700 DLG is one of them, and there we're repositioning that building, while the other is El Pro in Montreal, where we're clearing space so that larger floor plates can be offered to the marketplace. In a similar way, Vancouver has two buildings, 342 and 375 Water, and we're carrying out the same work there. We're clearing space in those buildings to accommodate larger tenants.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#90

All right. So will those projects' scope match what we saw with Boardwalk, Lougheed, and 400 Atlantic in terms of requiring public transfer, or will it be something that's…

Tom Burns

executive
#91

No, no, those are just small physical changes to the buildings, while at 400 there's a great deal of work underway, but these amount to minor physical leasing matters.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#92

All right, thanks. Michael, regarding the acquisition opportunity you might see developing in 2021, I believe you mentioned that the quantum and scale of the transactions would be comparable to the landing from a characteristic standpoint — is it more of a difficult class AI type of opportunity set, or do you expect it could be more of the conventional 700 DLG type of transaction?

Michael Emory

executive
#93

I really believe either scenario could happen. You might see a deal similar to the 700 DLG, yet there could equally be transactions closer in nature to the landing. So my expectation is that they will land somewhere inside that spectrum. And as I mentioned, I cannot tell which one will come along first or with greater certainty, though my sense is that it would sit within that whole range, or that full opportunity set, which we now view as suitable for Allied.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#94

Alright. And speaking of that kind of 700 DLG deal, would Toronto be a market that appeals to you on that basis, or is it more of a Montreal-type situation, where the supply is similar?

Michael Emory

executive
#95

Yes, that's a great question, and really it comes down to Montreal being a different case. The way we see things, Montreal functions as the upgrade market, while Toronto serves as the development market. So I don't know of any assets in Toronto that we'd view the same way we viewed 700 DLG in Montreal. And beyond its base building attributes, one factor that made 700 DLG so attractive to us was that no new supply is being built in that market—or at minimum nothing of consequence in terms of new supply—and in Toronto that clearly isn't the situation. So when it comes to trying to compete with new building technology, I'd be somewhat more hesitant in Toronto than I am in Montreal.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#96

Much appreciated—that clears things up. A handful of quick administrative items for Cecilia: I simply want to confirm I have this right. As Jenny, I believe, mentioned, Q4 included a $700,000 net favorable adjustment tied to the Quebec government's backing of CECRA—is that accurate?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#97

That is right.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#98

Okay, and against that you’d be setting the new $500,000 provision, so that basically leaves $200,000 for this quarter?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#99

Yeah, I suppose so — if that's the way you want to frame it, then sure.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#100

Alright, I’ll accept that. Thank you. Then I believe you highlighted that the financing side had about $5 million in deferrals during this quarter, and if that serves as a signal, roughly $2 million of it gets repaid in Q1. Is that the initial start of repayments? I ask because I don’t think you’ve provided that detail previously — and have any of the remaining deferrals come back to you yet?

Michael Emory

executive
#101

Mike, the reason we brought that up is that the money for that repayment is actually arriving straight from the Emergency Rent Subsidy. So we haven't said anything about what you might call a regular repayment, but we do know that $2 million will come to us in early 2021 through the Emergency Rent Subsidy, and in fact at least half of that is already in our pocket. I believe Cecilia says all of it is in our pocket as of today. So when something is as certain as the government paying, we're ready to essentially net it against the deferral. So in our view, I think the net deferral for Q4 came to roughly $3.5 million.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#102

That's right.

Michael Emory

executive
#103

And we — but we didn't, we believed it mattered to disclose the real deferral, since we genuinely did postpone receiving that amount, yet I believe $2 million of that deferred sum has already been settled and those funds sit in our bank account. And to be fair to the government, we ought to recognize that although the paperwork is burdensome, we have collaborated closely with our tenants to help them, as doing so is very much in our own interest. And once the documentation is finished and filed, the government has paid remarkably quickly. We observed that with CECRA, payment came astonishingly fast for a government, and the same holds true for the rent subsidies. So, I think it deserves noting that the government truly has been determined to give support to these businesses, and I think it should be praised for having done so.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#104

Alright, thanks. It seems to be producing a favorable impact. And then finally, Cecilia, regarding the FFO add-back for TELUS Sky, I believe it has stayed unchanged over the past couple of quarters, and you essentially moved it into the rental pool. And I realize there’s still some spending and activity that needs to occur there. How should that line develop in your internal forecast for 2021? Should it differ from gradually, or do you anticipate this changing at some point?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#105

Apologies — which page do you have in front of you?

Mike Markidis

analyst
#106

Well, if you look at your FFO reconciliation, there's that notional interest capitalization tied to the JV — roughly 600…

Cecilia Williams

executive
#107

As occupancy occurs throughout 2021 and we finish those projects, that capitalized interest is going to fall away entirely.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#108

My guess is that it'll look more like a gradual slope than a waterfall.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#109

Absolutely. That’s right.

Mike Markidis

analyst
#110

Alright, I appreciate that a lot.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#111

Sure thing.

Operator

operator
#112

Our next question comes from Matt Kornack at National Bank Financial.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#113

Hey, everyone. I just want to follow up quickly on what Mike asked about, regarding how COVID affected us this quarter. So, on the $500,000 provision you took — there weren't any rent abatements during the quarter, were there?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#114

Nope, there weren't any abatements during Q4.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#115

I realize you'd given us some details, and obviously I believe this ties to the $2 million you've now received, but my understanding is that when Q3 was reported, you had gathered 70% of October rent from tenants covered by CECRA — did that taper off, and then ultimately the money comes back to you in Q1? Should we be thinking about it that way?

Michael Emory

executive
#116

To answer your question, CECRA essentially concluded on September 30. So any effects on us from CECRA were reflected in our results during the second and third quarters. There may be a few tenants who moved from what we'd call CECRA tenants over to deferral tenants, but that number is small. The majority of our deferral tenants have remained on deferral throughout this disruption, so to speak, and the positive side is that nearly all CECRA tenants qualified for the Emergency Rent Subsidy, and even those who didn't qualify for CECRA seem to qualify to some degree for the rent subsidy. As a result, any deferral we are reporting in aggregate would represent the entire deferral we have extended during the year, and any provision we have recorded related to that — which I believe is $2.7 million or $2.8 million — would pertain to those deferrals going forward. But there is no situation where — it's not as though the CECRA tenants suddenly went into default when the CECRA program ended. As a matter of fact, I don't believe any of them did. We might have assisted some of them a bit further in Q4, and we may be ready to assist them in Q1 and Q2 of this year.

Michael Emory

executive
#117

Yet arguably what matters more is that the Emergency Rent Subsidy has genuinely stepped in for the spot CECRA vacated, and it stepped in without demanding that we forgive any rent, which naturally benefits us a great deal, though for the CECRA tenants, that group of CECRA renters certainly did not drop off a cliff once the CECRA program wrapped up, that much is certain.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#118

All right, that's reasonable. I was only aware that, where the government is concerned, there was some lag when it came to people getting those funds, so covering rent for Q4 might have been a problem, but it seems that's not really a problem…

Michael Emory

executive
#119

Right, and effectively we would have bridged them through that, Matt. So that's the reason $2 million of it we bridged rather than bringing in another tenant. Yes, we bridged them across the quarter end, and we're ready to keep bridging people against known Emergency Rent Subsidy receipts, since what we've seen is that the government really does pay, and it does so fairly promptly.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#120

All right, that's clear. Then looking at parking on a sequential basis, it got better, though I'd guess either something unusual happened in December 19 or Q4 typically brings a seasonal lift in parking revenue. Even so, it appears parking was still lower by $1.5 million year-over-year — not a shock given where the pandemic stood. Could you speak to parking? Once we're open again, presumably it recovers, and people might avoid public transit, which could offset some of the pressure — but what are your thoughts on forecasting parking for 2021?

Michael Emory

executive
#121

We're seeing a recovery in Q3 and also in Q4. So I think at that point, if I can call it the second shutdown, it has likely placed some pressure on that recovery. And I'd expect that to persist through the first couple of quarters in 2021 and start recovering in Q3 and Q4, and we would have built that into our internal forecasting.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#122

Alright, that’s clear. And I think it was Cecilia who brought up TELUS Sky and the residential portion there — could you talk about how leasing is progressing? Obviously, you’ve got a stunning product, so I’m just curious how it’s doing compared with pro forma.

Michael Emory

executive
#123

Absolutely, let me take that one. It is matching the updated expectations we set out last summer, at the point when we began leasing it up. So we continue to expect that roughly a couple of years will be needed before it gets to what I would call stabilized NOI.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#124

Alright. And the final question is about leasing — I realize we'll have a bit more clarity next quarter in Montreal — but do either of those two tenants in Cité Multimédia know that some turnover was expected there?

Michael Emory

executive
#125

Yeah, that turnover is factored into our internal forecast again, and Tim Low, Tom, and the Montreal team are really on top of it. And Tom has been encouraged by the activity level. Well ahead of the actual expiry dates, our listing brokers have already generated activity. So, Tom, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I think we're pretty comfortable with that.

Tom Burns

executive
#126

Activity levels have been unexpectedly strong, so that leaves us feeling quite positive.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#127

All right, that's encouraging, and it's encouraging to observe that in Montreal they appear to be somewhat more proactive about getting back to the office. Appreciate it, everyone. That's all from me.

Operator

operator
#128

Our next question comes from Howard Leung at Veritas Investment Research.

Howard Leung

analyst
#129

Appreciate it, and good morning, everyone.

Michael Emory

executive
#130

Morning, everyone.

Howard Leung

analyst
#131

I just wanted to follow up on a few of the questions about the 2021 forecast for same-asset NOI. I guess, apart from the economic occupancies at 425 VJ and the completed buildings, are you projecting an occupancy increase for those buildings in the portfolio, or is it mostly coming from rent growth on renewals?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#132

Rent growth would be the main thing behind that.

Howard Leung

analyst
#133

Alright, that helps. I keep picking up on what seems like a pattern involving smaller spaces — those below 10,000 square feet — where either tenants appear to be outgrowing them, or current tenants may be — perhaps some of them are subleasing those spaces? Are you noticing that the profile of demand across the pandemic has moved toward larger spaces, maybe? Has there been — have prospective tenants shifted in that direction more? I'm just sort of curious what your thinking is on that.

Michael Emory

executive
#134

I'd say the mix is pretty much unchanged. I really don't see any shift when it comes to size requirements. Over in Montreal, we wound up completing 130 transactions during the year — that market has been extremely active, and it covered a range of sizes, with plenty of smaller deals. Going forward, I don't anticipate any change in size requirements.

Howard Leung

analyst
#135

Yes, yes. My apologies — please continue.

Michael Emory

executive
#136

No problem, Howard. One trend we might be observing—and I really want to stress might—is that the range of tenants or users who show interest in the sort of space we run seems to be widening, and I have to say that was already apparent before the pandemic, but it looks like it's carrying on. The most striking example of that, in our view, is the transaction with the law firm that Tom brought up at The Well, covering roughly 25,000 square feet. I don't think we've ever had a requirement from a big law firm anywhere across the country in our portfolio. I definitely can't recall one if we did. And I consider that meaningful and in line with what we've been witnessing from professional services firms, among them firms as prestigious as Deloitte, who are now considering the type of space we offer, when maybe 5 years ago it would have been inconceivable for them to do that. So that shift clearly doesn't look like the pandemic has halted it. And I can't say for certain whether the pandemic has sped it up, but it's still taking place.

Tom Burns

executive
#137

Something worth noting. A law firm we have on John Street in Toronto doubled its footprint in 2020 — it went from 9,000 square feet up to 18,000 square feet. So I can't say for certain that points to a trend, but that gives us two examples of professional services firms showing real commitment to the type of product we offer.

Michael Emory

executive
#138

And that, naturally…

Howard Leung

analyst
#139

Right, right.

Michael Emory

executive
#140

That gives us encouragement, and it explains why, for us, these deals carry much greater significance than just the square footage involved.

Howard Leung

analyst
#141

Right. Yes, that sounds like demand shifting away from certain tenant classes as well. So that's good to know. Thanks very much. I'll hand the line over.

Operator

operator
#142

Our next question comes from Jane Wilkinson at CIBC.

Jane Wilkinson

unknown
#143

Thank you. Morning, all. Sorry that this ran more than sixty minutes.

Michael Emory

executive
#144

Sure thing.

Jane Wilkinson

unknown
#145

Michael, you said that whatever Allied wants to acquire will come at a high price, and that is of course a given. The other side of that, though, is that debt has probably never been cheaper, so could you say a bit about what you're seeing in the debt markets relative to the cost of the debt rolling over over the next couple of years, and even in the context of those green bonds — that even though those may be expensive, given that your debt has never been cheaper, that is more than the countervailing force against that, and it might not affect the coverage ratios from that perspective?

Michael Emory

executive
#146

My inclination is to reply with an affirmative across the board — yes, yes, yes, and yes. The debt market has been astonishing to us for quite a while now, and plainly to our industry peers and the sector too. One of your fellow industry analysts produced a rather fascinating piece of analysis contrasting the way the debt markets have dealt with Allied Paper against the way the equity capital markets have dealt with Allied units. And my sense is that the disparity is wider for Allied than for any other entity — any other publicly traded real estate issuer in the country. On one hand, that strikes me as appalling, and shame on the equity capital markets. On the other hand, it points to opportunity in the plainest meaning of the word. And obviously we intend to take advantage of the highly favorable valuation of our paper that seems to be prevailing in the debt capital markets. We will — we have been working hard at that for a while and we will keep working hard at it. And one more thing I would add: we are ready, on a temporary basis, to let our debt to EBITDA rise above where it currently stands, first, because debt costs are so appealing, and second, because we know our debt-to-EBITDA ratios will be subject to terrific downward pressure in 2022 and 2023 — so, yes, yes, yes, yes, and yes.

Jane Wilkinson

unknown
#147

Eventually, the equity markets are going to figure this out correctly. That is all I have to say. Thank you.

Michael Emory

executive
#148

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#149

Our next question comes from Pammi Bir at RBC Capital Markets.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#150

Thanks, and good morning. I'll aim to keep this brief. On the leasing comments, could you give us a bit of color on what tenants might be looking for when it comes to changes in lease terms — whether that's renewals, the length of new leases, or greater flexibility within those leases? Are you seeing any of that at this point, or not?

Tom Burns

executive
#151

They aren't doing that at all. What they keep chasing is long-term arrangements.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#152

Understood. And finally, returning to that law firm lease at The Well, I'm just wondering what factors attracted them to the property compared with, I believe, the space they already occupy that you mentioned they held a renewal option on?

Tom Burns

executive
#153

My sense is that what drew them in was the amenities that will be in place at The Well. It lets them update their space without doing internal renovations. Still, I believe the appeal for them was a completely new building that will offer what is likely the strongest amenity package anywhere in the city.

Michael Emory

executive
#154

Yes, particularly when you look at it from a neighborhood standpoint. And Pammi, there’s no doubt that this tenant reached the conclusion they did because they felt it would assist them in drawing in, inspiring, and keeping the sort of gifted young men and women they require moving forward. So what appealed to us about the deal was, first, it’s a law firm, which is an uncommon use for us within our portfolio. Second, they had clearly determined that operating out of collective workspace was necessary for their success. And third, they became convinced in the end that their capacity to draw in, inspire, and keep talent would be improved by taking space at The Well. In my mind there’s no doubt whatsoever that this is what drove them when all was said and done.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#155

That’s really useful. I suppose—sorry, please continue.

Michael Emory

executive
#156

Nope, nope, apologies — there's nothing there.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#157

No. Actually, I believe you may be steering me toward my next question — just on the point of whether you have any idea how the rents would have compared between what they're giving up and what they're receiving at The Well?

Michael Emory

executive
#158

My guess is that gross rents at The Well come in slightly lower, since they get the IMIT grant during the first 10 years of their lease there. Apart from that, I'd expect the rents at their current location and what they'll pay at The Well to be roughly on par.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#159

Understood, and thank you very much. I'll hand it back now.

Operator

operator
#160

Our next question comes from Mario Saric at Scotiabank.

Mario Saric

analyst
#161

Hey, thanks. Looking at the clock, I'd guess just the 6 of us remain on this call at this point. So I'll keep it to two very quick questions here, mostly clarifications regarding the sublet space and the impressions that both Tom and Michael mentioned. First, on sublets — Tom, I won't be asking for any figure or investment number in your answer. So no need to stress, nothing with decimals. Is it fair to say that internally, Allied feels somewhat more at ease about the wider sublet market now than it did back on the Q3 call? And is the straightforward reason for that simply that today we're nearer to tenants returning to the office than we were 3 months ago, or does something else explain that greater confidence, if that's the best-case read?

Tom Burns

executive
#162

My apologies — I wasn’t able to catch the question.

Michael Emory

executive
#163

I think the real question is: what explains the gap between total space and sublease space in Q4 versus Q3, back when we were somewhat more uncertain? I'm not sure we came across as more worried in Q3, Mario. We likely just didn't articulate it well. I mean, sublet space looks bad on the surface in any office market, as you know, but in our portfolio it has consistently worked to our advantage over time. And I think recognizing that most of it is actually located in Toronto makes us probably more confident than ever that no matter how this plays out, it will play out in our favor over time and with a high degree of certainty. So, I don't believe anything has shifted, though Tom's point that some sublease space was withdrawn from the market in the meantime—I think that's worth noting—people reflexively put it on the market and probably figured hey, if someone comes along and takes it, hallelujah. And then, so it could be those folks, or they might have thought, hey, we're going to work from home forever. And as reality set in either way, they may have pulled it off the market.

Michael Emory

executive
#164

As I believe I said during Q3, we do feel the same way now: for every space in our Toronto portfolio, we know which tenants are subleasing and why they are doing it—not because they intend to work from home in the future, but because their revenue has been squeezed and has stayed squeezed for some time. One of them is a media company, which is not a good sector to be in at present, particularly print media; a couple of others are advertising agencies, which remain viable businesses, but conventional ad agencies have seen their revenue squeezed for quite a while now. So regarding our sublease space, I don’t think our confidence is any higher or lower than before. And we have watched it decline in Calgary and Vancouver, which to me is actually far more significant. Toronto sublease space has never concerned us, and the results we have gotten from it have been good without exception.

Tom Burns

executive
#165

My view was that we wouldn't voice any worry regarding subleases in Q3. That has never posed a danger to us previously, and we don't anticipate it will, yet the overall mood hasn't shifted at all.

Mario Saric

analyst
#166

Yes. All right, that clears things up. So, just to make sure I understand the 250,000 square feet you mentioned — that figure covers the wider Toronto market, correct, rather than Allied's own portfolio in Toronto?

Tom Burns

executive
#167

Correct, Mario — that’s right.

Mario Saric

analyst
#168

Alright. My second question to clarify would go back to Michael, regarding a remark you made that in conversations with tenants, they feel — you feel they're fully committed to coming back into the office. Is that remark based on the expectation that tenants will return to the office, or on the expectation that tenants will keep the footprints they currently have, and is it still too early to draw a conclusion on that?

Michael Emory

executive
#169

The working assumption, I believe, would be that folks will keep the footprints they currently have—neither shrinking nor growing them—though it's too soon to say that with certainty. A great many users are weighing their requirements against what they've discovered and against what they anticipate happening down the road. And from our actual users, we don't yet have sufficient data to draw even a provisional conclusion about where things might head across the coming 12 to 24 months. That said, we feel quite confident, grounded in ongoing conversations that have really carried on from Q3 through into 2021, that the users we've spoken with will bring their workforces back into the office once the pandemic ends. The manner, the speed, the long-term degree—we still lack enough data to reach any sort of meaningful conclusion, even though it does look to us that the majority of users we serve aren't considering having sizable portions of their workforce operating from home. Yet once more, in the end, it's how reality plays out and how people actually behave that will reveal where the market is headed. Talk is cheap—whether that's my talk advocating for people coming back or some other clown's proposition regarding working from home.

Michael Emory

executive
#170

What truly counts is how people behave. That is the thing we are attempting to measure, and at this point we lack sufficient data to draw firm conclusions about what will occur over the longer term regarding the way our tenant base will utilize their space. I feel reasonably confident about it, though my confidence will rise considerably once tenants start coming back and once they start using their space full-time once more.

Tom Burns

executive
#171

Just to give you a bit of color on that, Mario, I brought up a tenant in our Montreal portfolio that's exploring expansion and is considering taking roughly another 20,000 square feet. What they've told us is that they had an office where people were packed in tightly, and they want to make it available, with additional meeting room space going forward, so people can spread out just a little bit. So this is a tenant that has been extremely successful throughout the pandemic, and they're telling us they want more space for their employees and won't have them crammed into the same space. We may see some of that — it's early days.

Mario Saric

analyst
#172

Yeah. That’s a really good point, Tom. But my final question is this: we’ve now been dealing with this pandemic for roughly a year. One of the uncertainties Allied faced going into it was how a smaller tenant, size-wise, would hold up in an economic crisis. So on that subject, I’d like to hear the full picture — since the pandemic began, how many office tenant business failures have the portfolios experienced?

Michael Emory

executive
#173

Honestly, Mario, it's been pretty much a non-issue. Our office tenant base has proven remarkably resilient — small, medium, and large organizations alike, with small, medium, and large space needs — much like what we saw through the global financial crisis. Nearly all the pressure has been felt, quite understandably, on the retail side of our tenant base. And failures there have been very few so far — partly, certainly, because we've been willing to work with some of the users we believe in and have relationships with. But on that front — I mean, I can think of just one instance within the office tenant base, and it involved a smaller co-working operator — not Spaces; Spaces has performed wonderfully the whole way through — but a very small co-working operator in our portfolio, where we essentially let them hand back 8 small locations totaling…

Tom Burns

executive
#174

Fifteen thousand?

Michael Emory

executive
#175

Yes, that was 15,000 square feet, and we kept two other tenants, and without that action they would have gone under. That’s the only case I can recall where a meaningful chunk of space was, so to speak, handed back to us with our cooperation. And I don’t think there have been any bankruptcies among the office tenants—certainly none involving anyone of any real significance. So it has tracked precisely the course we followed, or went down, during the global financial crisis; back then as well, our office tenant base saw very little pressure, and the retail portion absorbed all of it. The pressure they went through at that time was far less severe than what our tenants are facing today, but interestingly, the tenants back then were far less entrenched in their space and in our portfolio than they are now. So up to this point, there has been negligible failure among our tenants because of the pandemic—and I do mean negligible.

Mario Saric

analyst
#176

Perfect, I appreciate the context there. That covers everything on my end.

Michael Emory

executive
#177

Not a problem at all.

Operator

operator
#178

And with that, we have no more questions at this point.

Michael Emory

executive
#179

Thank you, Jennifer, and I appreciate all of you joining us on this conference call. We're eager to keep you updated on how things are progressing from here on out. Should any questions come up in the meantime, every one of us is available by phone. We're at the office and working diligently. Many thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#180

That brings today’s conference to a close. Thank you all for joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.