Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust (APUN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 28, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello, and welcome to the Allied Properties REIT conference call covering first-quarter 2022 earnings. This call is being recorded today. Right now, I'll hand things over to the President and Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Michael Emory. Mr. Emory, the floor is yours.
Michael Emory
executiveThanks, Justin, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to our conference call. Tom, Cecilia, and Hugh are with me to discuss Allied's results for the first quarter ended March 31, 2022. During this conference call, we might make forward-looking statements regarding future events or future performance. By their nature, these statements carry risks and uncertainties that could cause actual events or results to differ materially, including the risks described under the heading Risks and Uncertainties in our most recently filed annual information form and in our most recent quarterly report. Material assumptions underpinning any forward-looking statements we make include those described under the forward-looking disclaimer in our most recent quarterly report. Allied's first quarter results met or exceeded expectations, with AFFO per unit and average in-place net rent per occupied square foot rising to record levels. Cecilia will summarize our financial results. Tom will follow with an overview of leasing and operations. Hugh will provide a development update, and I will finish with our thinking on capital allocation. So, now over to Cecilia.
Cecilia Williams
executiveGood morning. I'll walk you through the improvements we made to our Q1 results disclosure, along with the balance sheet and our ESG program. Starting with Q1, FFO per unit was $0.61 and same asset NOI was 2%, both in line with what we expected for the quarter. AFFO per unit beat expectations, reaching a record high of $0.56. Our 2022 forecast of low to mid percent growth in each of these three metrics is still intact. The space we have occupied keeps getting more productive. Average in-place net rent per occupied square foot rose 4% versus a year ago, to $25.13. We anticipate that trend will carry on as our occupied space grows through the year. We made enhancements to our disclosure this quarter. With our latest acquisition, our Vancouver portfolio hit 1 million square feet, which gives us early-stage critical mass there. As a result, we now report on Vancouver separately from Calgary and Edmonton. We also added disclosure on the timing of NOI contribution from development completions before decapitalization takes effect, and that appears on Page 66 of the MD&A. Turning to the balance sheet, the acquisition from Choice Properties will strengthen our debt-to-EBITDA ratio going forward. On liquidity, we currently can access $475 million on our operating lines before we exercise the $100 million accordion.
Cecilia Williams
executiveWith our lines, we’re positioned to fulfill what we’ve promised well into 2023. Turning to ESG, we’re in the process of building out our plan for a net zero carbon pathway. That plan is going to be laid out in our third annual ESG report, coming out in July. To sum up, our dedication to the strategy and to our balance sheet does not waver. Our team’s execution through the operating framework has been unwavering as well. As a matter of fact, the business hasn’t merely shown resilience during this period of uncertainty — it has grown and kept evolving as we chase our strategy in ways that keep expanding. I’ll hand things over now to Tom, who will discuss our operating and leasing results.
Tom Burns
executiveThank you, Cecilia. Even with Montreal under a full lockdown in January, the year got off to a very good start for us, with 94 transactions completed totaling 440,000 square feet. On renewals or replacements in Q1, the average net rents we achieved came in 16.6% above the average rents in the expiry term. Our leasing teams are motivated. We just brought on an experienced leasing manager in Vancouver. Wherever possible, we have upgraded available space to speed up the leasing process. At 1001 Robert-Bourassa in Montreal, we have finished a show suite. With our listing brokers across the portfolio, we have made a few adjustments to ensure the best possible teams are on every assignment, and we are determined to move our leased area stats up meaningfully. At present, there is good action in all markets, which I will describe shortly. Looking at some information CBRE provided on the Canadian office market as of March 31, I note that Allied is doing well relative to the market. In every one of the cities in which we operate, except Vancouver, our vacancy rates are lower than the downtown markets. In Vancouver, we are higher than the market by only 1.5%, and that’s likely to change soon.
Tom Burns
executiveBefore we move into a broader leasing update across our key markets, I figured it would be useful to give you a quick rundown on the first 30 days after the Choice portfolio closed. Our operations and leasing groups had been deeply involved throughout the weeks before closing, so we were positioned to move immediately and fold these properties into our platforms without friction. Along with these acquisitions, we brought on board 14 new staff members. Since closing, we signed a 3-year extension with Ontario Health — formerly Cancer Care — at 525 University Avenue covering 74,000 square feet. We also wrapped up a short-term extension with NRC at 1185 West Georgia for 5,900 square feet. At 1508 Broadway, we finalized a 4-year agreement for the final remaining office vacancy. Right now we are in negotiations on a short-term arrangement with a fitness club at 1185 West Georgia covering 25,000 square feet, and we anticipate closing that in early May. We've had early-stage conversations with a medical-related user for 60,000 square feet at 175 Bloor, and we've opened talks on renewal rental rates with Omni Hotels for 20,000 square feet at 1010 Sherbrooke. We've held numerous meetings with a major brokerage firm and are still in the process of awarding listing assignments across 4 of the 6 projects.
Tom Burns
executiveNow I'll give you a general rundown on leasing across Montreal, Toronto, Calgary, and Vancouver, and then I'll finish with an update on our urban datacenters. Beginning with Montreal, the team closed 38 transactions and leased roughly half of the space leased during the quarter. After a very sluggish beginning to the year, momentum has been building month by month. We closed two transactions totaling 77,000 square feet at 111 Robert-Bourassa, and we closed a transaction with an existing film industry tenant for 15,000 square feet at 740 Saint-Maurice. Shortly after the quarter ended, we leased 30,000 square feet to a marketing company, taking a freestanding building at our RCA project in full. We have also just reached terms with a tech company for 40,000 square feet at 3575 Saint-Laurent, with room to expand to 60,000 square feet. As for what comes next in Montreal, an existing tenant at Citi Multimedia has just re-entered discussions regarding 60,000 square feet of expansion at 111 Robert-Bourassa. We are additionally working with a life science tenant for 30,000 square feet at RCA, and we are in talks with two companies for a combined 35,000 square feet at 400 Atlantic. Turning to Toronto, at The Well we closed a transaction with a tech company for 62,000 square feet and also with a prominent music industry tenant for 26,000 square feet.
Tom Burns
executiveOn our previous call, we said we were working on a transaction with a tenant already in place — one that occupies 55,000 square feet at 185 Spadina, in King-Spadina. During those talks, that tenant chose to bring more of its staff together in Toronto, and it now needs 120,000 square feet. We are currently in active negotiations with this tenant at The Well. Three additional tenants are interested, at varying sizes, in the final remaining space in that project. Either way, we anticipate reaching 100% leased in the office portion of The Well before long. In Calgary, we are holding 86% leased area, which is solid given conditions in that market. We closed 10 deals during the quarter and have seen healthy activity at Telesky on the final build-type suite still available, and we are working with an existing tenant there on an expansion of 18,000 square feet. Should those deals close, we would stand at 75% leased in that office component. Progress at Vintage Towers in the Beltline has been strong, and we are now 94.5% leased. In Vancouver, we sit at 91% leased, with solid activity on the space that is available. To give a bit more detail on the leasing picture across our workspace portfolio, beyond the negotiations I just mentioned, we presently have 600,000 square feet of interest at an early stage.
Tom Burns
executiveAnd last, our urban datacenter portfolio in Toronto stands at 95% leased. Right now we're working on a deal with a tenant already in place to build out all the remaining vacancy at 250 Front, and we expect to be able to announce that transaction on our next call. At this point I'll hand the call over to Hugh.
Hugh Clark
executiveThank you, Tom. During this quarter, the team achieved a key milestone on one intensification project, along with meaningful progress across several other active and upcoming development efforts. I'll start with a summary of our biggest projects, and afterward we'll come back with news about what we've accomplished in our development pipeline. Construction activity. To start in Toronto, the Building Inspector has approved partial occupancy for the office tower at The Well. Once the tenants have obtained their own occupancy, this approval lets them move into the tower's spaces. That marked a significant milestone and represented the payoff of 10 years of effort on this project for several key individuals. The other buildings are aiming for occupancy across the coming couple of quarters. Retail tenants will kick off their fit-up work beginning in Q2. Activity at our remaining projects in Toronto and Kitchener carries on without slowdown. Grading has been completed at King-Toronto and at the QRC West expansion, and we will soon begin to observe work advancing above grade. At Adelaide & Duncan, the team keeps driving toward partial occupancy in Q3. At the Breithaupt, our partners are finishing most of the base building work and will turn the space over to Google so their fixturing can begin in early Q2.
Hugh Clark
executiveIn Montreal, upgrading work is still underway at 400 Atlantic, 1001 Robert-Bourassa and RCA. To meet demand in the Montreal market, we've chosen to broaden the scope at 400 Atlantic so that it includes turnkey options for tenants. As a result, we've pushed back the date on which 400 Atlantic gets transferred out of the box. Over at 1001 Robert-Bourassa, the team has finished the model suite on the second floor. That work makes clear just what we're able to accomplish with this building, and it gives the leasing team a useful tool for drawing potential tenants. In Western Canada, work is continuing on Boardwalk-Revillon. As with 400 Atlantic, we've decided to offer turnkey options for tenants. That choice has already led to 1 week build being completed, and a number of other potential tenants are showing that they prefer our building to other spaces in the markets. Planning metrics. This quarter has brought a number of significant events for our future intensification projects. First, in Toronto, we've finished buying Great Gulf's half interest in our King & Brant project. With full control of the projects, we're moving the plans forward to improve the offering so it better suits the knowledge-based users we intend to serve.
Hugh Clark
executiveThe plan also involves design adjustments aimed at lowering the carbon footprint and possibly securing net zero carbon certification, looking into hybrid wood-and-steel construction, and converting the condominium portion of the project into rental residential. We're enthusiastic about what this project can deliver and plan to launch it to the market in the fall. In Vancouver, we've formed a joint venture with West Bank for phase four of their main alley installment. That JV covers a 200,000 square foot office development in the Mount Pleasant neighborhood. A major tech tenant has already leased 50% of the project. We're excited about the potential here, since it fits our transition plan for adopting low carbon design, our capacity to serve users and life sciences, and our expansion in Vancouver. From the start of this year, we expect roughly 2.5 years to complete this project. I'll keep you updated on its progress going forward. The team has also moved forward on approvals for additional future intensification projects in Toronto. We had hoped to secure approval for our by fall, but because of the fall municipal election, it now appears likely to be granted in the new year.
Hugh Clark
executiveWe expect to receive approval for The Castle earlier in the new year as well. Work on securing approval for our project at King & Spadina has moved forward, with a formal commission committed just after the quarter ended. The team is enthusiastic about progress on the active construction projects and about future intensification opportunities. Following the acquisition of the Choice Properties portfolio, the team is now working on establishing plans for a number of those buildings. Our work at 1001 Robert-Bourassa will be instrumental in understanding the potential some of these buildings hold and how we can transform the user's experience. I'll now hand the call back to Michael.
Michael Emory
executiveThanks, Hugh. As others have mentioned, Allied wrapped up its biggest acquisition ever at the close of Q1, and paired it with its largest equity issuance ever — priced at $50.30 per unit, which was our NAV per unit at the end of 2021. We put out our preliminary vision for how these 6 properties will be folded into our large, focused, and distinctive rental portfolio. That vision document is up on our website, and if you haven't taken a look yet, I'd encourage you to spend a few minutes going through it. In my view, a key industry theme this year is going to be the large-scale rebalancing of diversified portfolios across Canada among strong, experienced real estate entities. Allied's acquisition at the end of the first quarter was a prime example of exactly that. It marked an important and compelling strategic refinement for Choice Properties and a significant, well-conceived expansion of operating capability for Allied. This year, Allied plans to stay within two capital allocation guide rails. The first: we won't raise our ratio of net debt to annualized EBITDA when funding discretionary acquisitions. As Cecilia pointed out, the acquisition from Choice Properties actually improves that ratio. The second: we won't issue large amounts of equity significantly below NAV per unit to fund such acquisitions.
Michael Emory
executiveTo reiterate, roughly 75% of the purchase price was paid to Choice Properties through equity issued at our year-end 2021 NAV per unit. So it's clear that sizable discretionary acquisitions fit inside the guide rails we've laid out. During the first quarter of 2022, Allied made no use of its ATM program. At present, more than $475 million sits available under our revolving credit facility, plus a further $100 million accessible via the accordion feature. That liquidity comfortably covers every commitment we currently have for the rest of 2022 and well into 2023. Allied's aim is to grow the business rather than shrink it, all so that knowledge-based organizations can be served more comprehensively and more profitably as time goes on. With our proven strategy and our capacity to execute, we'll keep allocating capital toward consolidating ownership and operation of distinctive urban office and storefront retail space — what we group under the term urban workspace — in Canada's major cities. Our strategy, we believe, rests on the most important secular trends shaping Canadian and global real estate. We further believe we hold the properties, the financial strength, the people and the platform required to carry out that strategy for the continuing benefit of our unitholders and our many other constituents.
Michael Emory
executiveI trust this update has given you a thorough and helpful picture. At this point, we'd be glad to take whatever questions you might have.
Operator
operatorThanks. Today’s opening question is going to be from Scott Fromson at CIBC.
Scott Fromson
analystMorning everyone, and hello.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Scott Fromson
analystThat was a pretty thorough summary. So I only have a few very small questions. I'm just wondering how TIs have been trending? Are there any changes with leases that are currently under negotiation? And how does that compare with similar periods, such as early in the pandemic and before the pandemic?
Tom Burns
executiveMy take is that tenant improvements have stayed steady the whole way through. The sole distinction is that, in certain instances—as the speaking notes hinted—we've chosen to offer some build-out suites, and that actually brings with it a matching rent increase on our side. Still, by and large, TIs have remained pretty much unchanged.
Scott Fromson
analystAlright, thank you. And regarding those leases that come due during 2022 and on into 2023, has any portion of the GLA been set aside for that transitional portfolio?
Michael Emory
executiveScott, that's a fair question. I doubt any one of us is able to respond to it — keep reminding me to do that — there's a substantial area of returning that requires an upgrade.
Cecilia Williams
executiveNothing significant is due to mature, in my view.
Michael Emory
executiveYes. Of course, I can’t think of anything right now, though that’s a matter we ought to examine closely so we can respond to the question with greater confidence.
Scott Fromson
analystAlright, and one last quick item. Has anybody using The Well, or anyone who might use it down the road, offered up any committed space for sublease?
Hugh Clark
executiveI doubt it. At one point, I think someone mentioned that one might do so, but as far as I know, none exist.
Tom Burns
executiveMy understanding is that the architects were considering it — adding a single floor — but whether they’re actually ready to bring that space to market isn’t clear at this point. That tenant is fairly small, and a solid one. Still, I’m aware they were looking at listing half of their square footage. Whether that step has been taken, I can’t say. What I can tell you is that we have definitely not found ourselves competing against it — that much I know for certain.
Scott Fromson
analystPerfect, thank you so much — I'll hand things over now.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Jonathan Kelcher at TD Securities.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystThanks. Good morning. For my first question, I just want to make sure, Tom — in what you said, were you saying that right now you're talking about 600,000 square feet of space?
Tom Burns
executiveRight. That remark appeared at the close of the further work space comment, and it was simply meant to point out that a great many discussions are underway, with roughly 600,000-odd square feet in total across the portfolio sitting at very early stages. There's considerable interest right now.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right, I simply wanted to make that clear. Regarding The Well, clearly there’s been solid leasing activity for you folks, and my guess is that the space Shopify returned will be leased up fairly soon. Could you perhaps give us some idea of how the rate you expect on that space would differ from what Shopify had under contract?
Tom Burns
executiveJonathan, I’m really glad you raised that question. On the 90,000 square feet that Shopify did not occupy, we should see rent increase by $15 per square foot.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystOkay. And how large a percentage gain does that represent?
Tom Burns
executiveThat's nearly 50%.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystJust about 50%. Alright.
Michael Emory
executiveSo it's around 15% of that 35%, which works out to roughly 40%. And Jonathan, to make clear what Tom meant about The Well: about 120,000 square feet is still left to lease, and that figure includes the 90 that Shopify chose not to exercise its option on. We're in a very lucky spot, because one tenant is seriously looking at that 120,000 square feet at about $15 more than what Shopify was required to pay. Beyond that, three tenants together hold 120,000 square feet and are in the same situation, as I understand it, where we'd capture the change. So that's why, just so you know, we're talking with a lot of confidence: first, the rest of The Well is essentially leased for all practical purposes; and second, we'll see a $15 increase compared with what Shopify owed under its lease.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAlright, that all sounds quite positive. Then as a final point, looking at the balance sheet, you do carry a fairly sizable amount of floating rate debt. Perhaps could you share how you’re thinking about accessing the unsecured market? And if you were to move on it at present, what kind of term would you be considering?
Michael Emory
executiveOkay, Jonathan — the sole floating-rate piece we’ve got is the facility we set up not long ago in order to pay down the line. The reason it carries a floating rate is that this gives us full optionality as we move forward. It’s got a 3.5-year term, if my memory serves me right, and we can lock in the rate at any point if we judge that to be wise. That said, we intend to keep it floating, since that leaves us able to prepay at no cost. Should the bond market get better, we might look at repaying it using proceeds from a bond market issuance. In the same way, if our cost of equity improved, we might look at repaying it through an equity issuance. So what I appreciate about the floating rate here specifically is that it hands us genuine optionality across the coming 6 to 12 months regarding how we permanently finance — so to speak — that $300 million or $400 million facility. Normally we wouldn’t have interest in variable rate, as you’re aware. And as you probably note, in this case we were quite interested in the variable rate, mainly since it provided us full optionality going forward, whether by fixing the rate on the facility we already have or by repaying it with debt raised in the bond market or with equity raised in the equity capital markets.
Michael Emory
executiveNaturally, at this point we haven't determined which among those 3 options we may choose, yet being able to pick one as circumstances keep shifting is genuinely valuable for us.
Jonathan Kelcher
analystAll right, that clears things up. I’ll hand it back over. Thank you.
Operator
operatorMario Saric from Scotiabank has our next question.
Mario Saric
analystGood morning, and thanks for joining us.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Mario Saric
analystI'm curious—what took place in the quarter that made AFFO come in above what you had expected internally?
Michael Emory
executiveI'd say there are two factors. First, NOI growth came in solid and in line with expectations, and our parking revenue got better — not quite back to where it stood before COVID, but near it. And last, our regular leasing CapEx was likely on the lighter side this quarter, since the bulk of our leasing costs from 2022 onward are going to be tied to income-enhancing items rather than routine leasing expenses. So 2022 will bring sizable leasing expenses, yet a very large share of those will be connected to boosting the revenue-generating capacity of properties undergoing active upgrades, especially the ones in Montreal. And just so it's on the record, the three Montreal assets I'm referring to on that front are the RCA, El Pro and the 1001 Robert-Bourassa.
Mario Saric
analystAlright. So perhaps pivoting to market rent and occupancy. On the occupancy front, I understand the anticipation of a significant pickup, as Tom mentioned in the commentary. Looking at the near term, does the company believe internally that Q1 economic occupancy on leased basis marked the bottom?
Michael Emory
executiveAre you asking whether I believe the low point came in the first quarter of 2022?
Mario Saric
analystCorrect, that covers it.
Michael Emory
executiveYes, that's right — with a single possible caveat, which is that at 1001 we're going to take back space on the upper floors. Once more, this falls under our repositioning program, and I'm not sure how we'll describe it, Mario; we simply haven't had time yet to figure that out. But that could — it only could — hurt our occupancy for the rest of 2022. There's nothing else I know of that can or will. And certainly, week by week and month by month, we grow more confident in our capacity to hit our leasing goals for 2022. But we will be taking back four or five floors at 1001 Robert-Bourassa. Still, I don't view that as vacancy, so to speak; it's genuinely part of a repositioning program. And it's one that will take the shape we've already described at some length at 1001 with Robert-Bourassa, where those floors are transformed magnificently from chalked up, ugly, light-entrapped space into open, very well eliminated, very spacious space, cubically and otherwise. And we have to complete that transformation before we can re-lease the space on the terms we know we can now achieve in the market. So that is the only item that might hit numerically in 2022.
Michael Emory
executiveYet, as I mentioned, that belongs to a repositioning initiative we have long awaited and are now, happily, able to carry out extremely effectively. And we are aware that demand exists. Still, we must complete the transition before we can lease the space.
Mario Saric
analystUnderstood. And regarding those 4 or 5 floors specifically, are you aiming at a particular return on capital? Or does that become hard to answer given that this sits within the larger redevelopment of the property as a whole? How should we think about the return tied to repositioning that space?
Michael Emory
executiveIt's a bit hard to explain that in a vacuum, but here's something useful I can tell you: on that project, we do expect to hit the same kind of spread we'd get on a development. And Mario, as you know from talking with us and with others over a long period, we won't move forward with anything unless we believe we can get a spread of at least 150 basis points to the cap rates. And honestly, I'm quite confident in our ability to reach at least that level with 1001. Most likely it will be achievable at the end. I don't know whether some portion of about four or five floors will get us there. But our target is that we're essentially treating this as if it should perform like a development for us. Our total cost will bring us to a point where there's a spread of at least 150 to 200 basis points between the unlevered yield and the actual cap rates at which we could sell once the building is built out in the market. And we're certainly encouraged by the cap rate side of that equation in the Montreal market. It has traded more strongly and more rapidly than I would have expected in Montreal; Vancouver has traded rapidly and strongly, but that was no surprise at all.
Michael Emory
executiveAnd Toronto won't catch anyone off guard, I think. But what really amazed me was how quickly demand for purchasing urban office space came back in Montreal — and that's far from finished. It's only just beginning.
Mario Saric
analystAlright, just two more quick items. The first is about market rent, and then the final one concerns the remarks you made in the letter to unitholders. On market rents, some of the brokerage data from CBRE — they publish quarterly statistics — actually indicated that market rents had risen slightly in Toronto, though that may be affected by shifts in composition as new supply enters the market and so forth. Your estimated market rent appears to have declined somewhat relative to Q4, but it seems the bulk of that relates to Calgary. So if we take a step back and ask: three or six months ago, if you had space on the market — say, 25 net in your core portfolio in Toronto — what are you asking for that space today? Has it moved materially or significantly in either direction?
Tom Burns
executiveLet me make sure I've got your question right, Mario — you're asking if we feel confident that rental uplift will keep showing up in this strong market, since...
Mario Saric
analystSo it's less about those positive lease spreads and more about what the actual underlying market rent is for your assets, or for your portfolio. Has that moved in either direction on a quarter-over-quarter basis across the last 6 months?
Tom Burns
executiveMy view is that they held up extremely well. For many of the products we offer, supply is constrained.
Michael Emory
executiveFrom my perspective—and Tom, you're certainly more hands-on day to day than I am—the rent level that our core Toronto portfolio commands hasn't been eroded at all, and it has really kept growing throughout the pandemic, perhaps a bit more modestly than it would have under different circumstances. But it looks to me like it has continued to rise. We simply aren't letting anything go at a low rate. We're just not doing it. And that isn't because we're so tough or so clever—we just don't have to. There's always somebody ready to take the space. And we will always hold out for the rent level that we believe our portfolio can command. That's why I think our average in-place net rent per square foot keeps rising quarter after quarter after quarter. Because fundamentally, there isn't a huge gap between what we expect for our space and what the market is willing to pay.
Tom Burns
executiveThere's no lowballing happening from anyone. We aren't seeing tenants approach us with genuinely lowball figures whatsoever.
Michael Emory
executiveSomething worth understanding about the leasing business—and it's genuinely fascinating, and all of us have been through it for about 5 or 6 years now—is that price is never the thing we negotiate. And to be clear, that isn't due to any confidence on our part, since the intermediaries understand the market quite well. What truly matters to us, always, is whether our space satisfies the needs and ambitions of the employer. When it does, the market does a pretty efficient job of establishing the value of our space. And we simply never lose a deal because of price. In fact, one example comes to mind that I'm happy to share: a major marketing firm on Bloor Street evaluated The Well for a fairly large requirement—perhaps 200,000 square feet, possibly more. And it was obvious that this deal was being handled from New York by folks with no knowledge of the market whatsoever. Price was the sole thing they cared about. So we essentially directed them to the innovation center on the waterfront, where cheap, decent space was available. I'm joking—we didn't direct them there, but that's where they ended up going. Still, that was exactly what they wanted.
Michael Emory
executivePrice was the only thing they cared about, and having them in The Well isn’t something we want, nor did we need to. As a result, our rental rates haven’t eroded—if anything, they keep rising. And as we’ve mentioned, at The Well, they keep exceeding our expectations.
Tom Burns
executiveThe main topic in that discussion was the capacity to expand. These are mostly technology firms, and they want to know how they can grow, and what works in our favor is that we can expand those tenants inside our portfolio — perhaps not in the building they currently occupy, but definitely somewhere else in the portfolio. And a great illustration is the case I mentioned, where we have a tenant with 25,000 square feet at King-Spadina that wanted to grow. On top of that, they required 55,000. We were interested in 185 Spadina, very keen, extremely interested. Then suddenly they told us that won't be large enough for them. We need additional space. Fine. We know about that space Shopify aren't taking. Let's discuss that, and we're nearing a deal. So really, a tenant is more focused on the building or anything else.
Michael Emory
executiveThe Toronto market is highly efficient, honestly. It's like no one poaches space from anyone else, and nobody charges wildly excessive rates for space. The sophisticated established tenants get excellent advice, and the brokers in Toronto are extremely strong. It's an efficient market. In high-quality urban office space, there are extremely few price SKUs. Retail is a bit more subjective, sure, but for office, so to speak, the buyers receive very solid advice and the sellers understand precisely what they're doing and precisely what has to be done. For us, historically, the question used to be whether our mixed-use, amenity-rich urban neighborhood mattered more to the tenant than access to the underground path. And there are very rational grounds for favoring either one. Cost was never the issue — it was about whether the environment fit the building's users better. When it did, tenants came to us. When it didn't, they went to the conventional towers. And again, that's entirely rational. It hinges on what the user requires and desires for its people. We even lost Apple, I believe, to — they came out of Mississauga, and we figured, no question, they'd join our portfolio.
Michael Emory
executiveWe do have a relationship with that company in Vancouver. And they chose the South Core because of the connection to the path system, which in my view is fairly imperfect in the South Core, but it does exist regardless. For Apple, that mattered more than locating in a mixed-use, amenity-rich urban neighborhood, which is where our concentration and strength lie. So that ends up being more decisive for where people land than pricing does. As I say, nobody — I should say very few projects manage to succeed by being cheaper. That simply doesn't work that way these days. They succeed by serving the needs of the user better. And the user will pay the price, because it's an efficient market. That's probably more of an answer to last quarter, Mario, but it is interesting, and you can see we're living this. And I just know our rents aren't eroding. They're actually increasing. And Toronto is where — well, Vancouver, they're increasing at a crazy level too. So some — but Toronto is super strong. In Montreal the increases are much more temperate. It's a different market. The demand velocity is different. But fortunately, also, no new supply is being created in any meaningful sense.
Michael Emory
executiveFrom that angle, then, it works differently.
Mario Saric
analystYeah, that conviction and enthusiasm really comes through clearly, and I appreciate it. This is my final question, and I just want to turn to Michael's remark about the large-scale rebalancing of diversified portfolios in Canada being a major theme for this year. You completed the Choice deal. Does that suggest that other larger-scale opportunities to build the portfolio and your market might be on the horizon?
Michael Emory
executiveI want to be careful here not to make anyone listening anxious, but I know a lot of rebalancing is going to happen in 2022 and probably in 2023 as well. As I look at the market, I see basically two categories of rebalancing. First, there are the weak aggregators that have had to break themselves apart and rationalize back to something sustainable going forward. I don't see that offering Allied any opportunity at all. There's nothing of interest there for us. But I think it will make up a significant portion of trading volume in 2022. And I think real estate is going to end up in stronger hands — or to put it differently, more appropriate hands. I think that's good for the market generally, and it's good for trading volumes too. And I think it also reflects the reality of ongoing demand from different investors for different assets. I think pension fund interests are also going to rebalance from a position of very considerable strength, not from weakness, because they probably view themselves as overweight Canada. That is definitely going to create opportunity for buyers — whether it creates opportunity for Allied remains to be seen.
Michael Emory
executiveMy inclination is to say yes. That said, as I mentioned, we'll have to wait and see. In my mind, Choice is a comparable kind of transaction, and that's part of why I anticipated seeing what I referenced during the first quarter conference call. What I can't know, though, is whether the opportunities that emerge will align with Allied's focus or not. Should they align with Allied's focus, we'll definitely examine them and figure out whether allocating capital to them makes sense for us at that moment, given those circumstances. I could envision that being the case, and I could just as easily envision it not being the case. And as I've told investors repeatedly throughout 2022, investors know full well what we did on the acquisition front. Investors have no knowledge whatsoever of what we didn't do or which opportunities we chose not to chase across the last 20 years. And take it from me, when an opportunity doesn't suit us at the moment it comes before us, we'll walk away without hesitation—we already have plenty on our plate. And we're committed to that work and enthusiastic about carrying it out.
Michael Emory
executiveWe will never do acquisitions merely for the purpose of doing acquisitions. That has never been our approach, and I believe that is part of why our portfolio ranks among the most coherent in all of Canadian public real estate. And we plan to keep it that way. That said, if something would help us become a stronger provider of distinctive urban workspace in Canada's major cities, we will take a look at it. If allocating capital to it is opportune for us, we will proceed. If it is a chance for us to put capital to work, we will decline, knowing another deal will come along 2, 3, 4 months later that is as interesting or more interesting. So our aim is to consolidate and to keep consolidating. Our aim is not to shrink — as I said, shrinking holds no interest for me. But we will consolidate only if it amounts to appropriate capital allocation for Allied, given its history as a pretty good allocator of capital, in my opinion. Again, that is a little more than you asked for, Mario, but what the heck, I figured I would give you an answer.
Mario Saric
analystOnce more, the excitement and belief come through loud and clear, so I appreciate how detailed you were on every question. Thank you.
Operator
operatorAnd moving on, our following question is from Gaurav Mathur at IA Capital Markets.
Gaurav Mathur
analystThank you, and good morning, everyone. So given how quickly demand is moving for higher-class brick-and-beam space across the MTV cities, and the natural flight to quality, in your view, is there any potential upside in the current environment to the 94% targeted occupancy?
Michael Emory
executiveGaurav, is that question really about whether we're aiming to go past 95% occupancy — or are you asking about 94% occupancy once things stabilize?
Gaurav Mathur
analystAbsolutely.
Michael Emory
executiveI want to give a careful answer here, since I have a habit of promising too much and landing myself in trouble. Avoiding that is genuinely important to me. Still, I believe that once things are fully stabilized, expecting our portfolio to sit above 94% occupancy is not an unreasonable aim. That said, I see no realistic path to pushing past 95% occupancy during 2022. I wish there were one. Even so, that target alone is — well, it isn't a stretch goal, but it isn't a low bar either. It's an ambitious objective we've set for ourselves and are dedicated to, but we can't count on it simply happening. Reaching it will demand very hard work and some favorable results along the way.
Gaurav Mathur
analystAlright, thanks for that, Michael. For my last question, I’ll shift topics here. The Choice Properties transaction looks like a win-win for both parties. And considering what you said about rebalancing within the Canadian REIT landscape, do you expect to rely much more on the LP units mechanism for acquisitions going forward, simply to remain inside your capital allocation guardrails?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a good question, and a fair one. Before the Choice transaction, we had never thought of that mechanism as something we could use on a large scale. But I think the Choice transaction has shown us that we can actually carry out that kind of deal at scale. And it genuinely benefits a seller by deferring substantial capital gains and recapture tax, provided you have faith in Allied's units and Allied's business. So I don't want to imply that we'll see a flood of deals like this, but it's a possibility we now recognize more fully. And if an owner of assets that match our investment and operating focus came to us prepared to transact on this basis, we would now view it more favorably and with greater confidence and be better positioned to take advantage of that opportunity. So — and honestly, there are aspects of that kind of transaction I really like when it comes to allocating capital and building Allied's operating capability. So I'm not signaling to the world, please come talk to us. But it wouldn't surprise me.
Michael Emory
executiveTo be clear, no one has done so as of yet. That said, it wouldn’t shock me at all if, over the rest of this year and heading into the next one, people came to us on that basis—or if we went to others on the same basis. So once that possibility comes into view, it just turns into part of the lens through which you look at the opportunities your business has. And without question, we regard this as a really strong model for doing deals between sophisticated parties—parties capable of grasping the implications and capturing the benefits from this sort of use, so to speak, of units as currency.
Gaurav Mathur
analystThanks, Michael. I'll hand things back over to the operator now.
Michael Emory
executiveI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Jenny Ma at BMO Capital Markets.
Jenny Ma
analystThanks, and good morning, everyone.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Jenny Ma
analystThanks for the conversation about the capital allocation guardrails. And I'm curious, with this new context, how are we supposed to think about the ATM? Given that it's fairly small in quantum, does it sit outside those guardrails, or do you set it aside because the Choice portfolio transaction, I guess, lets you use up your equity, and so for now the ATM isn't necessarily a tool you need to use?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a good question, and a fair one. And our consistent answer has been that this doesn't fall outside the guardrails. It isn't an exception. We would — we will raise very considerable and very substantial amounts of equity through our ATM. But we won't do so at prices significantly below NAV per unit. So it doesn't fall outside the guardrails. It falls squarely within them. The dry run in the fourth quarter, I could argue, fell outside those guardrails, because we simply wanted to see how that system worked, and we were very encouraged with the results. But we didn't even consider using the ATM in the first quarter, because it — certainly before the announcement of the Choice transaction, we were nowhere near NAV per unit. And even as we began to rise toward NAV per unit after announcing the Choice transaction, the whole market then got distracted, understandably, with all kinds of uncertainties and anxieties, which I fully understand. So, just to be clear, it does not fall outside the guardrails.
Jenny Ma
analystAll right, that's quite useful. Now, on the IFRS cap rate specifically, for the UDC portfolio, that cap rate has stayed fairly level for close to two years. This quarter, we observed a decline of more than 40 basis points. I'd just like to ask whether you could shed some light on what caused that — was it being re-marked against certain other transactions? So is it somewhat of a catch-up, given it hadn't shifted in some time? Any detail would be helpful there.
Cecilia Williams
executiveAbsolutely. A QTS deal was announced late last year and completed earlier this year, which gave the appraisers one more data point. For our UDC assets, they consistently use 1 Wilshire and 60 Hudson as comparables, despite the fact that those aren't directly comparable — they're simply just as unique, so to speak, as our UDC assets. That transaction, therefore, made both them and us more at ease about lowering cap rates across the board.
Jenny Ma
analystAll right, so that was the main thing behind it?
Cecilia Williams
executiveAbsolutely.
Jenny Ma
analystThanks. And finally, on the previous call you mentioned the possibility that the CBC building could trade — any update there, especially as it relates to Allied and the options you have?
Michael Emory
executiveNo. There's honestly nothing new to report at all, but let me offer three points that might help. First, regarding the purchase of 250 Front, we haven't come to an agreement with CBC, and whether we ever will is uncertain to me. Second, should a deal happen, it wouldn't close before late 2022 or early 2023. And third, assuming we proceed, there are several ways we could finance an acquisition of that kind, and we won't step beyond the guardrails in pursuing it. But there's no fresh information on that transaction, Jenny. And honestly, I'm rather pleased that the public process CBC and CBRE believed they needed to undertake has concluded, and whether it ends with Allied completing a deal on that building, I genuinely don't know.
Jenny Ma
analystOkay. Actually, let me ask one more thing along those lines. If you do go ahead with some of these moves, would bringing on a partner be something you'd think about?
Michael Emory
executiveCorrect.
Jenny Ma
analystExcellent. Many thanks.
Michael Emory
executiveTo be clear, that is a thing we have thought about, so yes, definitely. And that isn’t the sole other option available to us.
Jenny Ma
analystPerfect, thanks. I'll hand it back over.
Operator
operatorAnd the following question comes from Mark Rothschild at Canaccord.
Mark Rothschild
analystThank you. And a good morning to all of you.
Michael Emory
executiveMorning, everyone.
Mark Rothschild
analystMichael, you mentioned the reasons you favor this transaction with Choice, since you could issue equity there. Looking ahead, how much would you weigh someone's intent to hold the units over the long term versus the short term whenever you do a deal of this kind? And to put it even more directly, how much has Choice signaled to you about how long they intend to hold those units?
Michael Emory
executiveThat's a reasonable question, Mark, though I really don't want to be put in a position of speaking on behalf of Choice or the corporate group, since it's an integral part of that group. I do believe that group places genuine value on the units beyond the fact that they make deferral of taxation possible. Still, I don't consider myself competent or authorised to express views for either Choice or the corporate group, of which it forms a part. Is it relevant to Allied? Yes. So, on that aspect of the question: if I believed they intended to dump the units at the first available opportunity in the fastest possible manner, I'd be less inclined to enter into such a transaction. But can anyone assure me in advance that they won't do that? No. Can I depend on the perceived integrity of the counterparty? Yes. Am I willing to do so in this situation? Clearly, yes — and in other situations too. But I must concede, on Allied's behalf, that there's no guarantee the holder of those units will do anything other than sell them once the contractual hold period ends. But — yes. I think that's likely the fairest and most helpful answer I can give.
Michael Emory
executiveDoes it matter to us? Absolutely. Have we spent a lot of time on it? Absolutely. Did we get counsel from Goldman and Scotia on this? Yes. But we also recognize that nobody holding about $600 million of Allied’s equity is going to box themselves in. That simply won’t happen. And I wouldn’t do that either.
Mark Rothschild
analystThanks for that. I appreciate it. Perhaps just one additional question. For understandable reasons, you're clearly bullish on the fundamentals in your core markets. And that's partly what gives you the confidence to pursue a big acquisition. How much do you consider the effect of increasing interest rates on potential value when you're evaluating acquisitions right now, or do you think there's sufficient capital out there seeking properties and that fundamentals will strengthen enough that you don't really feel worried about it?
Michael Emory
executiveMy expectation is that higher interest rates won't really move cap rates much for top-tier urban office properties. I could be mistaken. Still, I don't anticipate that outcome. In my view, demand versus supply is such that temporary shifts in rates won't change what people are willing to pay for assets that are nearly impossible to replicate. I might be wrong, but that's what I expect. That doesn't — we take a long-term view as a buyer. It barely affects our sense of value at all, since, first, we employ a fairly modest level of leverage. What truly matters to us is the cost of equity, naturally, and that is the largest factor in our willingness to pay. And once more, we're willing to pay because we operate assets rather than trade them. And I believe most buyers of the types of assets we target aren't really engaged in any form of financial arbitrage. They purchase assets in order to operate them, to create value, in some instances, to sell on the strength of that added value, and in Allied's case to hold indefinitely and to serve users ever better. So, Mark, I don't believe that will occur.
Michael Emory
executiveYet once more, this might grow in scope—and nearly every day the newspapers suggest it could become larger, with rates perhaps rising more quickly as a way to cool things down. Eventually, that will have an effect. Still, the majority of real estate purchasers aren’t doing any sort of arbitrage against debt. Years ago, that was precisely what all of us did. These days, though, we aren’t truly arbitraging against the cost of debt. The game is entirely different now.
Mark Rothschild
analystGot it. All right, thank you. That is useful.
Operator
operatorAnd moving on, our next question is from Irina Pulyakhina at Precima.
Analyst
analystAbsolutely.
Michael Emory
executiveYes, we can hear you perfectly.
Analyst
analystThanks for taking the question, and I'm sorry about that. I'd like to hear your view on the ducted market, considering how well we did in Q1. Also, which kinds of tenants are showing interest in leasing space, and what are your expectations for the remainder of the year?
Tom Burns
executiveOnce more, your question wasn’t fully clear to me—it concerns the Calgary market, how we view developments there, and whether we expect continued improvement in that market. And in fact, we are now physically witnessing the changes in Calgary. I don’t know whether you’ve been Downtown there recently, but people are back on the streets, people are out and about, and there is rush hour in Calgary again in the morning and the evening. Calgary is coming back to life. And we are seeing a corresponding increase in traffic through our buildings. So we are confident that Calgary is going to come back, and we are seeing some really good activity in that marketplace. I hope that answers your question.
Irina Prokopyeva
analystRight, and what about leasing activity — which types of tenants are showing the most interest?
Tom Burns
executiveMore and more, tech tenants are appearing in Calgary. The City of Calgary has been working very aggressively to attract tech companies there, and as a place for young families, the city holds strong appeal. I believe tech will keep growing in that market. And we are definitely getting our share of it.
Analyst
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings the question-and-answer portion to a close. At this point I'll hand the conference back to you in case you have any further remarks or closing comments.
Michael Emory
executiveThanks once more, Justin, and I appreciate everyone joining this conference call. Those were excellent questions, and I hope the answers we gave were useful. We’re eager to keep you updated on how we’re progressing from here until we talk again. Take care, and once more, thank you for being with us today.
Operator
operatorWell, thanks. That brings today’s conference to a close. We really appreciate you taking part. Have a great day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.