Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust (APUN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 27, 2023

Toronto Stock Exchange CA Real Estate Office REITs earnings 27 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thank you for joining us on the Allied Properties REIT Second Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. To keep out any background noise, every line has been muted. Following the speaker's remarks, we will hold a question and answer session. Should you wish to ask a question at that point, please press star and then the number 1 on your telephone keypad. And if you'd like to take your question back, just press star 1 once more. Thank you. At this time, I'd like to hand things over to Cecilia Williams, President and CEO. Please go ahead with the conference.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#2

Thanks, Josh. Good morning, and welcome to our conference call. I'll give a brief presentation on the second quarter, and Nan and JP are with me to take questions. Michael is here as well. During this conference call, we may make forward-looking statements regarding future events or future performance. By their nature, these statements carry risks and uncertainties that could cause actual events or results to differ materially, including the risks described under the heading Risks and Uncertainties in our 2022 annual report and our most recent quarterly report. Material assumptions that underpin any forward-looking statements we make include those described under Forward-Looking Statements in our most recent quarterly report. Operationally, our second quarter was positive. Demand for our space remains strong, as tour activity indicates. We also leased considerably more space than in the prior quarter, and net rent per occupied sq ft keeps rising, increasing from last quarter to CAD 23.51. Higher interest expense and longer lease-up time frames produced Same-Asset and NOI, FFO, and AFFO per unit for the first half of the year that fell short of budget. Though this is temporary, since interest expense will drop materially going forward with the pay down of CAD 1 billion of debt, our results for the year have been affected, which has moderated our outlook.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#3

On the positive side, we're still seeing demand for our space products, and tour activity keeps rising. There are many ways in which completing the UDC transaction will be freeing. From an operations standpoint, the whole team will be devoted to operating the Workspace portfolio. On the financial side, we can cover our obligations while hardly drawing on our lines through 2027. As our development completions become economically productive, our debt metrics will keep improving too. We published our Fourth Annual ESG Report on June 26th. I'm happy with how our plan to reach net zero carbon is progressing, which includes setting an internal cost of carbon to aid internal decision making and forecasting. Additional details about our progress will come out in next year's report. My confidence in our long-term outlook is still strong. Through the last three and a half years of upheaval, our portfolio has held up well, and it will keep doing so amid the current headwinds, because in the end, we have the space that people want. Even more importantly, our team has never been stronger, more focused, or better integrated. I hope that update was helpful. We would now be glad to take any questions.

Operator

operator
#4

We'll now open the floor to questions — if you'd like to ask one, just hit star and then 1 on your phone's keypad. Our first question is from Jonathan Kelcher at TD Cowen. Your line is open.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#5

Thanks, and good morning to everyone.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#6

Morning, everyone.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#7

Starting with the tours, Cecilia — you mentioned that they were higher both year over year and quarter over quarter. As for the sequential move, how much of it, if any, reflects normal seasonal patterns in Q2 compared with Q1?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#8

That's a difficult one to call, since Q1 actually came in fairly strong for us. I can't say for certain. Honestly, Jonathan, from a tours standpoint we haven't really detected what would necessarily amount to a big seasonal effect.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#9

All right. So on a year-over-year basis, how would the tour count stack up against, say, a stronger office market like the one we had before COVID?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#10

In my view, what we saw this quarter reflects what a stronger office market would have looked like. Over the past three and a half years, our average was roughly 219 tours each quarter. We recorded 292 this quarter. Tour activity rose in each market, so Toronto, Vancouver, and Calgary all came in above that quarterly average, while Montreal matched it.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#11

All right, that helps. Moving on—you mentioned the Castle as a non-renewal behind the vacancy increase this quarter. My sense is that this property intensifies over time. Could you give us a bit more detail on that? Did you expect this vacancy, or will you be seeking a short-term tenant? How should we think about how that will play out?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#12

If an opportunity were available right away, we would have, you know, gone ahead and filled it. That isn't an intensification happening at present, but rather something for the medium to longer term.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#13

All right, so I assume your plan is to bring in a tenant on a short-term basis to occupy that space?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#14

Fair enough.

Jonathan Kelcher

analyst
#15

All right, I'll hand it back to you. Appreciate it.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#16

I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#17

Lorne Kalmar from Desjardins has the next question. Your line is open.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#18

Appreciate it, and good morning, everyone.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#19

Morning, everyone.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#20

Regarding that guidance, you mentioned a few factors behind the update and the guidance itself. Has anything in your outlook shifted between when you first gave that guidance and now?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#21

When we first put out that guidance at the end of January, it rested on a different outlook for interest expense, or the cost of debt, than what actually took shape during the first half of the quarter. We'll deal with that in the second half as we retire CAD 1 billion of debt. That's really the key difference.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#22

Right, so paying down CAD 1 billion in debt is certainly going to be beneficial. I think in the prior quarter you brought up the aim of reaching roughly 90% committed occupancy by the end of the year. Do you still see that as something you can hit?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#23

Our aim is to close out the year with a larger leased footprint than we had at the start. That has consistently been the objective. We remain committed to that target.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#24

All right, that's reasonable. Here's another somewhat minor item. I saw that the Telus Sky loan got a one-year extension. Could you perhaps shed some light on the reasons behind that?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#25

We're just wrapping up the upgrade — sorry, I mean the development — along with the residential component.

Michael Emory

executive
#26

Yes. In fact, that loan goes to our partner. We are not the borrower on it.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#27

Yes.

Michael Emory

executive
#28

Accordingly, the facility has been extended by our partner. Where Telus Sky is concerned, Allied carries no debt, and Telus itself likewise holds no debt tied to Telus Sky. That debt pertains exclusively to Westbank, our development partner.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#29

That doesn’t really point to anything else, perhaps, that might be going on more broadly at Westbank. It is specific to that site.

Michael Emory

executive
#30

No, that’s not the case.

Lorne Kalmar

analyst
#31

Oh, all right, that's excellent. I really appreciate the detail.

Operator

operator
#32

Matt Kornack from National Bank Financial has the next question. Your line is open.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#33

Hi, everyone. I’ll return briefly to the occupancy topic. In the press release, you gave a fairly large list of leasing velocity that you’ve achieved, and Montreal appears quite prominently. I know there was some vacancy there, but is that a market where you still expect to gain some incremental occupancy? As for maybe the Tannery, is there any update on that space?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#34

Yeah, regarding Montreal, we definitely expect occupancy to rise there. As for Tannery, we're in talks right now with the user, aiming to take a substantial amount of space.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#35

Alright, thanks. About leasing costs — TIs and leasing costs specifically — it seems like renewal space, more than new leasing, has edged up somewhat across the past two quarters. Is there something behind that, or is it simply down to the particular space being leased right now?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#36

That really depends on the space, Matt. When someone has occupied a given space for a while, then more work is due, so to speak — so it's very much a space-by-space matter.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#37

Alright, one final question from me. In your remarks, you pointed out something most of us are aware of — that you hold one of the biggest urban land banks anywhere. It's economically productive, but you brought up the density potential for mixed use. Could you give us some sense of whether your thinking has shifted regarding the office piece versus the residential piece within that mixed-use density potential, and then perhaps on the opportunity to monetize any of it over the near to medium term, or whether you intend to build it out yourselves.

Michael Emory

executive
#38

Matt, it's Michael. No, our focus on distinctive urban workspace hasn't shifted or changed, particularly regarding our intensification potential. As you're aware, we've always been ready, and we've consistently held the view that mixed-use intensification on very costly inner-city land is the finest method of realizing value. The Well is likely the most remarkable illustration of that in our company's history. Looking ahead, we anticipate the same. We won't be developing condominium residential space on our land in the future the way we did at King-Toronto. That was an exception rather than the rule, but we're quite prepared to include mixed use, retail, office, and rental residential on suitable inner-city sites, and nobody owns more suitable sites for that in the inner city than Allied. This doesn't represent a change in our emphasis. It will always be on distinctive urban workspace. We've long understood, dating back to roughly 2012, that the optimal approach for intensifying high-value urban land in Toronto and other places is through a mixed-use format. We'll receive greater backing from municipal authorities, we'll receive greater backing from the market, and we'll be capable of creating something more durable over time, which is the reason we want it to be rental residential to whatever extent there is a residential component.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#39

On the residential rental side, is that a thing — and again, this probably isn't imminent — that you'd hold and operate yourselves, or would you prefer bringing in a partner for it?

Michael Emory

executive
#40

No, we would. There might be a partner involved in managing it, but we would absolutely own our proportionate share or the whole interest in rental rents. The rental portion of Telus Sky pleases us greatly, and we're glad to hold that indefinitely. The rental piece of 19 Duncan, which will begin to fill up either late this year or early next year, is going to be an astounding asset. We'll hold 50% of it forever. I think it's a very good asset for us to have in a mixed use urban development. We won't go out—I can't imagine it—and simply develop rental residential buildings. We're very happy to hold rental residential components of mixed use urban development.

Matt Kornack

analyst
#41

That makes sense. Thanks, everyone.

Operator

operator
#42

Gaurav Mathur from iA Capital Markets has the next question. Your line is open.

Gaurav Mathur

analyst
#43

Thanks. Morning, everyone. Turning to leasing — do you foresee any non-renewals coming across the portfolio in the next few months?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#44

Nothing major there, Gaurav. Talks are already underway regarding the leases that come due over the next 18 months. The majority of those are going to be renewed.

Gaurav Mathur

analyst
#45

All right, thanks — that's helpful. To build on it a little: regarding the positive leasing spread on renewals for this quarter, could you give us a bit of detail on what's behind that, and how you expect that trend to play out going forward?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#46

We anticipate that renewals will stay at an elevated level going forward. As you're aware, 2022 saw us at a low point, mainly because of that single non-renewal in Kitchener, but this year we're looking for something nearer our historical 75%-80% renewal rate.

Gaurav Mathur

analyst
#47

All right, great. And finally, a wider macro question about the reduction to your guidance. When you made that cut, how much of it reflected the persistent work-from-home pattern you're observing across the M-T-V cities, as opposed to an economic downturn?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#48

Gaurav, the way we looked at it involved a pair of forces pulling in opposite directions, I'd say. The first is the short-term effect of elevated interest rates during the first half of the year, and we'll more than make up for that in the second half by paying down debt, along with the longer lease-up time frames. That, alongside the strong level of touring activity we have — which we see as the key metric, the metric that signals what's ahead — leaves us quite confident that lease deals will still materialize. It's simply a question of timing. Work from home hasn't really been a factor, since what we observe is growing, or rather, rising levels of people physically returning to offices throughout our portfolio, throughout the country, and not only in our portfolio but in every one of the higher-quality properties nationwide.

Gaurav Mathur

analyst
#49

All right, that's helpful — thanks, Cecilia, for the detail. I'll hand things back over to the operator.

Operator

operator
#50

Pammi Bir from RBC Capital Markets has the next question. Your line is open.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#51

Thanks. Good morning. Perhaps I could pick up where the previous question and those remarks left off — once more, in light of the resilience we've observed across the economy and in labor markets, are you seeing any change in tone among your tenants when it comes to leasing discussions? Is there still, perhaps, some worry about a recession that is affecting space requirements, or possibly the timelines involved in committing to space?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#52

What we're seeing is really driven more by macro-level uncertainty, which I think is stretching out how long it takes for decisions to get made. But there's no worry that people have stopped believing they still need office space — they do still need it. The real question is whether it's the same amount, or, you know, a modest bit more or a modest bit less. We continue to see, you know, strong demand coming from tech, from educational uses, and from medical services. That behavior fits with where we are in this part of the cycle.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#53

Alright, regarding that Shopify sublease space — is there anything new on where things stand, or how far along things are with Shopify in terms of getting it released?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#54

Tommy, I would say that we are happy with the progress being made there, and beyond that I really can't say anything more right now.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#55

Suppose a tenant of real significance came along—say someone interested in a large portion of the space. In a situation like that, would you deal with that tenant directly, or is it simply too soon to tell right now?

Michael Emory

executive
#56

Tommy, I don't mean to cut in where I shouldn't, but... Over a really long stretch, we've learned that big occupants never take a sublease. Dealing straight with the landlord is what they always insist on, and that's surely going to hold true in this situation. A large occupant subleasing from Shopify is close to impossible. A direct contract with the owner is what they'll demand, and the owner is more than ready to sign a direct contract with solid replacement occupants, and over time that benefits both the owner and Shopify. That's the way I see this playing out. With large space especially, which we've handled many times through the years, that's how it almost always plays out. How this unfolds isn't in doubt. Only the timing and the counterparty are. Together with Shopify, we'll work to reach an outcome that serves both the owner and the original tenant well, and we will get that done.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#57

Understood. Just one final question from me. Regarding the intensification pipeline you set out in your MD&A — I believe it's on page 68 — you've disclosed a value of approximately CAD 700 million. What level of NOI are those properties producing? I recall that at some point early last year, you ceased disclosing the annualized NOI. I'm not certain what the reason for that was, but any update you could provide would be helpful.

Michael Emory

executive
#58

I believe the reason we halted back then, Pammi, came down to market uncertainty—about what demand for office space would look like going forward, about construction costs, about essentially every aspect of development. It was likely more speculative than it had been before. I think we'd be hesitant to do anything beyond providing that quite broad orders of magnitude in the future, if we do so at all. What I think matters more in that comment is that there's remarkable potential for intensification in what already exists. How valuable that ends up being and how much value we can drive into it, you know, five, 10 years out—I don't think that's worth speculating about at this point.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#59

Oh, yeah. Sorry, Michael, I think... What I was asking about was more the NOI that’s currently in place on those assets. That’s the piece that was no longer disclosed. Is that what you meant, or?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#60

That figure isn't right in front of me, Pammi. It's probably fair to assume it's a comparable portfolio-wide cap rate and use that for the calculation. I simply don't have that figure available at the moment. Our decision was to keep it undisclosed since we don't see it as useful information, so.

Pammi Bir

analyst
#61

All right, I’ll hand it back over. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#62

Dean Wilkinson from CIBC is our next questioner. Your line is open.

Dean Wilkinson

analyst
#63

Thanks. Good morning, everyone. I have a quick question for you, Cecilia. Regarding those new leases, are you relying more on third-party brokers? I just saw a significant increase in leasing commissions there, and I'm curious whether that's coming from outside or inside sources.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#64

Yes, there are certain situations where we’re relying on more third-party brokers.

Dean Wilkinson

analyst
#65

If you look at it from the landlord's side of the work, would that simply involve taking some older space comparable to the upgrades you had to carry out for the renewals, so that it's specific to the site? Or did that also signal, in a sense, broader requirements across the market?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#66

Definitely, it's entirely tied to the specific site.

Dean Wilkinson

analyst
#67

Perfect — that covers everything. Appreciate it.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#68

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#69

The following question is from Jenny Ma at BMO Capital Markets. Your line is now open.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#70

Morning to all of you, and thanks for joining.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#71

Hello there, Jenny.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#72

I wanted to circle back to the sublease space involving Shopify. With a space of this size, how exactly does Shopify participate in the process? Is it a situation where each side has a representative, and you bring every — you know, there are three parties at the table in the discussions? And if you do find a user to take the entire space, is it possible that at some point Shopify could exit the whole lease and no longer be part of it going forward?

Michael Emory

executive
#73

It always comes down to, so to speak, the three parties that you mentioned. They might not have representation, though typically they do. Yes, ultimately, when the deal turns out in the way that best serves everyone's interests, the original tenant gets released from the obligation and can put that liability behind them. Naturally, the owner will only agree to that once it receives a comparable covenant, or one of comparable quality. We've completed this in a great many cases where it turned out very favorably for us as the owner and very favorably for the original tenant or user, whom we've permitted to, so to speak, escape that liability. A party's ability to establish direct privity of contract with the owner depends on the original tenant being effectively freed from its responsibility. Naturally, economics play a role in every bit of that. It's an arrangement that works quite well, and it always serves everyone's interests. The original tenant sheds a contingent — well, a very real and contingent — obligation. The new tenant is quite pleased to make a commitment on the space with the owner, and the owner is quite pleased with the covenant provided by the new tenant.

Michael Emory

executive
#74

That's the way it's going to develop. And yes, in answer to what you asked, when all is said and done, Shopify will be in a position to move past this, and the owner will end up at least as well off as it was with the tenant that was there originally.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#75

Okay, so whether Shopify gets off the hook really comes down to your discretion, right? But however those discussions turn out, it's up to your satisfaction.

Michael Emory

executive
#76

Sure. There’s no requirement on our side to sign a direct lease with a new tenant. None at all. We’ll take that step because we want to assist the tenants we already have and build a relationship with the incoming one. That decision rests completely with us, and that’s exactly why we’ve consistently noted that when quality space shows up on the sublease market, we hold the upper hand — and I say that without being smug, conceited, or domineering.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#77

All right, thanks. One quick housekeeping item on G&A. It seems there was some capitalization this quarter tied to the urban-data-centre portfolio sale. I'm just curious whether the change between Q2 and Q1 is the urban-data-centre piece. Will any additional amount of that flow through in Q3?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#78

The difference is—and there will be a minimal amount—past Q2.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#79

All right. So most of that gets expensed during the current quarter, is that right?

Cecilia Williams

executive
#80

Absolutely.

Jenny Ma

analyst
#81

All right, that's great. Thanks so much. I'm finished.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#82

Appreciate that, Jenny.

Operator

operator
#83

Just a quick note before we continue — to ask a question, hit star and then 1 on your phone's keypad. We'll take a brief pause to collect whatever questions are still coming in. Should nothing else come up, I'll hand things back to Cecilia Williams for her closing remarks.

Cecilia Williams

executive
#84

We appreciate you being on this conference call. Moving forward, we'll make sure you're kept informed about how we're progressing.

Operator

operator
#85

That brings us to the end of the call for today. We appreciate your participation. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Allied Properties Real Estate Investment Trust or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.