American Homes 4 Rent (AMH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 4, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Nick Fromm
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to the conference call covering our earnings for the third quarter of 2022. Joining me on this call are David Singelyn, who serves as Chief Executive Officer; Bryan Smith, our Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Lau, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements may be part of this call. Any statement in this conference call that is not a statement of historical fact is a forward-looking statement, and such statements carry various risks and uncertainties that might lead actual results to differ materially from what those statements project. Our press releases and our SEC filings describe these risks and other factors that could negatively impact our business and future results. Every forward-looking statement is made only as of today, November 4, 2022; we take on no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statement, whether because of new information, future events or otherwise, except as required by law. Our earnings press release and supplemental information package contain a reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures. As a note, our operating and financial results, including GAAP and non-GAAP measures, are fully detailed in our earnings release and supplemental information package. These documents, along with SEC reports and the audio webcast replay of this conference call, are available on our website at www.americanhomes4rent.com. With that, I will turn the call over to our CEO, David Singelyn.
Dave Singelyn
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Prior to getting started, I'd like to pause and express appreciation to our team members for what they did around Hurricane Ian. Keeping our residents and team members safe comes first, and our disaster response team was positioned and prepared to move at a moment's notice. Chris will walk through the figures later on this call, but we came out fortunate regarding where the hurricane ultimately went. Even so, we know that a great many other people are enduring difficult circumstances because of the storm, and to do our part, American Homes 4 Rent has made donations to a range of Hurricane Ian relief efforts. Our employees are likewise helping their communities, partnering with shelters, giving to charitable organizations and supplying needed food and supplies. Our thoughts are with all those impacted, and we wish them a speedy recovery. Now, onto the quarter. We posted yet another set of steady results, with core FFO per share of $0.39, which equals 11.6% growth year over year. Bryan and Chris will share further specifics about how we operated in a moment. But before that, let me cover the macro backdrop; this nation finds itself in an economic period marked by uncertainty. Persistent, elevated inflation has compelled the Fed to lift interest rates substantially. At present, the housing market is displaying disruption similar to what occurred in the 1980s and during the global financial crisis. Against that backdrop, the resilience of the single-family rental asset class could not be clearer. With our national platform and a strong balance sheet, we are positioned to seize whatever opportunities emerge. Cyclical durability has sat at the heart of the American Homes 4 Rent thesis since day 1. Shelter is a fundamental need, and single-family rental fundamentals rest on favorable long-term supply and demand dynamics. Where supply is concerned, this country faces a housing shortage. That situation is only worsening, since projections for single-family housing permits keep falling; where demand is concerned, our business keeps gaining as more people come to value the proposition of high-quality housing minus the headaches that come with homeownership. Lately, that demand trend has gotten an additional boost from the fact that renting is currently far more affordable than owning a home. Based on recent John Burns data, renting costs roughly 15% less than owning across our top 20 markets. When it comes to investment, we keep producing high-quality homes through our development program. It's exciting to witness the headway we've achieved in several of our recently opened development markets in the West. Do bear in mind that costs for initial deliveries in newly opened markets are usually higher, and this quarter's deliveries show that. As time passes, our pipeline in these markets will keep maturing, and we will achieve economies of scale. Additionally, as laid out in yesterday's press release, our 2022 delivery guidance came down slightly due to modest construction delays in Florida. This is strictly a timing matter brought about by the hurricane. Now, let's look ahead. The current volatility in the housing sector brings back memories of 2011, the year American Homes launched and started expanding its portfolio in a major way. At present, our strategy for buying homes and land parcels is patient and disciplined. Price discovery is still underway, and more adjustments need to happen before returning to the open market in a meaningful way makes sense for us. As borrowing rates stay elevated, private portfolios, homebuilders and landowners may face difficult times ahead. That should create considerable opportunities for American Homes 4 Rent. Right now, builder homes number in the tens of thousands, and a growing backlog of MLS listings exists as days on market keep stretching longer. Although most of those homes sit in secondary and tertiary markets or fail to meet our quality standards, we are starting to notice price cuts on the ones that do qualify. Currently, such homes don't satisfy our yield requirements; however, I believe opportunities to buy high-quality, well-located homes will emerge over time. Even as we're enthusiastic about those opportunities, our development program continues to be the strongest path to steady growth. We currently observe 2 encouraging signs. First, high-quality, well-located land is coming onto the market, including vacant developed lots ready for vertical building. We keep witnessing price adjustments and stay patient and disciplined in our land acquisition program. Second, as homebuilders reduce their development programs, we're observing favorable price movements in construction materials and labor. So far, prices have fallen on most early-stage homebuilding input costs through the drywall phase. As homebuilding slows, I expect continued favorable movement in our cost to build homes; combined with favorable operating trends, that should produce higher yields for future development deliveries. At quarter end, we had options on over 15,000 lots, which represents a long runway of built-in growth. We will keep taking a prudent and disciplined approach with investments as we execute on our long-term growth plans. On the sustainability front, great progress continues. So far, we have installed solar systems on amenity centers and started pioneering solar build-to-rent communities. Our sustainability department keeps working hard, evaluating science-based targets focused on energy-efficient solutions and creating action plans to achieve net 0 carbon emissions over time. In closing, we all must acknowledge that these are uncertain times. I remind you that our asset class was born out of an opportunity created by a housing disruption. Though these uncertain times may bring some short-term issues and noise, the big picture is that long-term opportunities will present themselves and separate the players in our industry. We are prepared for those opportunities today, with a diversified portfolio and scalable platform supported by a strong balance sheet; now I'll turn the call over to Bryan for an update on our operations.
Bryan Smith
executiveThanks, Dave. Before getting into our operating results, I want to echo Dave in thanking our team for how they cared for and supported our residents throughout Hurricane Ian. They didn't just protect every vacant property ahead of the storm — they also ensured operations came back online right away once it had passed. Our teams carried out wellness checks in the areas that were hit hardest, had emergency supplies ready, provided resident support around the clock, and kept lines of communication open with those impacted by the storm; that really underscores one of the biggest benefits of our internal services platform, since it lets us redirect essential field staff and resources toward helping our residents. Now on to operations. Single-family rental demand remained robust. In Q3, we received almost 250,000 inbound leasing inquiries. Our website traffic was up 21% compared to the same period last year. And most significantly, the number of distinct showings for each rent-ready property is still 60% above what we saw on average before the pandemic. Same-Home average occupied days reached 97.1%; rental rate growth for new leases was 12.5%, for renewals 8.3%, and blended 9.5%, which produced 8.1% Same-Home core revenue growth in the quarter. Core operating expenses were 6.1%, leading to 9.3% same-home core NOI growth; this marks yet another excellent quarter. However, as we anticipated, seasonality is returning to the current operating environment, something that was a normal aspect of our business before the pandemic. During October, average occupied days on a Same-Home basis came in at 96.9%. New lease spreads were 9.1%, while renewal spreads reached 8.2%, producing blended rate growth of 8.5% for that month. We'll share additional detail regarding next year's outlook on our fourth quarter call. However, when we look ahead to 2023, two significant areas stand out. The first concerns revenue: earn-in from leases executed this year, anticipated recapture of loss to lease, demand that remains strong, and more deliveries stemming from our development program together position us well going into 2023. Next, since it appears inflation won't ease anytime soon, a key operational focus for us in the coming year is holding down costs by streamlining our services platform. All told, we delivered a strong quarter operationally, and we stay positive about what's ahead. We expect to close out 2022 on a high note, setting us up nicely to expand in 2023. On that note, I'll hand things over to Chris for the financial update.
Chris Lau
executiveThank you, Bryan, and good morning to all of you. There are 3 topics I'll address in my remarks today. To begin, a quick rundown of the quarter's results, which will include an overview of what we estimate Hurricane Ian cost us financially; next, the most recent information regarding our balance sheet and capital plan; and third, I'll close with an update covering our 2022 guidance along with the newest outlook on property taxes. To kick things off on results, we turned in yet another solid quarter, with net income attributable to common shareholders coming in at $50.7 million, or $0.14 per diluted share, a figure that absorbed an estimated net loss of $6.1 million tied to Hurricane Ian. As Dave mentioned, the storm's eventual track worked in our favor. Even though Hurricane Ian ranks among the strongest storms seen in recent memory, what we incurred was mostly cleanup and repair expenses throughout Florida and the Carolinas, plus our insurance deductible, chiefly connected to a modest group of flooded homes in the Orlando area. Please remember that these figures remain preliminary estimates and could keep shifting as we move forward. Leaving aside the estimated net loss from Hurricane Ian, in the third quarter we produced $0.39 of core FFO per share in unit, which equates to 11.6% growth year over year, and $0.33 of adjusted FFO per share in unit, equating to 9.8% growth year over year. Driving these results was yet another robust operational quarter, in which we achieved 9.3% Same-Home core NOI growth along with consistently steady deliveries from our AMH Development program. Over the quarter, 501 homes came through our AMH Development program, matching what we had anticipated. Breaking down those deliveries, 265 homes went to our wholly owned portfolio and 236 homes went to our joint venture portfolios. On top of that, we kept executing our acquisition plan, which we moderated recently, purchasing 145 homes in total during the quarter. All told, for our wholly owned portfolio, we added 410 homes over the quarter, at an estimated total investment cost of roughly $155 million. That's especially notable when you consider how tough it is to acquire things right now, and it highlights even more how valuable our AMH Development program is, along with a land pipeline of more than 15,000 lots. It's not just that we already have years of development growth built in; as we've said many times, we also have the balance sheet strength and cash flow characteristics to fund our existing development pipeline every year going forward, without needing to raise additional equity. Finally, regarding dispositions, we disposed of 164 homes during the quarter, generating roughly $49 million in total net proceeds. Turning to the next topic, I want to share a few updates about our balance sheet and recent capital markets activity. At the end of the quarter, net debt including preferred shares to adjusted EBITDA came in at 5.9x. We had zero draws on our $1.25 billion revolving credit facility, and cash on the balance sheet was about $97 million. In addition, during the quarter we drew $186 million from forward equity shares that had been raised in our January equity offering. As the quarter came to a close, about $300 million of forward equity shares were still available to us, and we intend to deploy those around the end of this calendar year or in early 2023. Last, I want to wrap up by offering a bit more detail regarding the 2022 guidance we revised in yesterday's press release, reflecting our newest property tax view along with several tweaks tied to our moderated capital plan. Broadly speaking, I want to point out that aside from property taxes in the state of Texas — where we just got some news that was both surprising and disappointing — every element of our full year Same-Home operating outlook is holding steady. You might remember that back in 2019, Texas enacted the Property Tax Reform and Transparency Act, which put a 3.5% ceiling on the growth of overall property tax revenue for cities, counties and certain special districts. Since its passage in 2019, that Property Tax Reform Act has acted as a meaningful check on property tax growth across all asset classes. Yet according to preliminary information, we recently found out that for 2022, nonowner-occupied single-family homes are on track to see a year-over-year increase that is disproportionately large. And although we continue to actively appeal assessed values in the state of Texas, it now looks probable that our 2022 Texas property taxes will rise by more than 20%. Beyond Texas, though, the rest of our 2022 property tax estimates — which assumed elevated increases in Florida and Georgia — are still tracking consistent with what we previously expected. Remember, our projections are still based on preliminary data. When the actual property tax bills come in, a true-up for full-year 2022 Texas property taxes will be reflected in our Q4 results. Even with that, after including our latest estimates, we've increased the midpoint for full-year 2022 Same-Home core operating expense growth by 200 basis points, bringing it to 7.75%. At the midpoint, that translates to a revised full-year Same-Home core NOI growth forecast of 9%, and full-year core FFO per share of $1.54, which still represents 13.2% growth—the highest in the SFR industry. Before we open the floor to your questions, I want to close with three main points from what we've shared today. First, Dave is correct; the economy right now is unpredictable. Still, keep in mind that housing is a basic necessity, and it remains undersupplied while demand keeps rising throughout our varied geographic markets. Second, our operating platform is efficient, scalable and prepared to withstand the challenges of today's inflation-heavy conditions. Third, when it comes to growth initiatives, the strength of our investment-grade balance sheet sets us apart — no one else can reliably supply inventory the way our development program's core does, and at the same time our flexible acquisition avenues are positioned to generate distinctive shareholder value from the growth chances we expect down the road. With that said, let's take your questions. Operator?
Nick Joseph
analystI appreciate those early 2023 building blocks, but could you put a number on the earnings you expect next year, and then the loss to lease both at present and what you'd anticipate it being at the close of this year, based on 2022 guidance and rent trends?
Bryan Smith
executiveThanks, Nick. Bryan here. Sure — the earn-in we anticipate from this year falls between 4% and 5% for 2023. That's a reflection of our in-place leases. As for the loss to lease, at this point we estimate it landing in the high-single digits. And regarding our expectations for the remainder of this year on rate growth, looking at the re-leasing side, it should continue in the 8% range, with renewals in line with what we posted in October for November and December.
Nick Joseph
analystThat's useful. Then regarding real estate taxes, I get what Texas did. However, when we look ahead to '23, might other states face the danger of higher village or property taxes generally? Also, do you foresee more of a split between owner-occupied and owner consideration when it comes to taxes?
Chris Lau
executiveThank you, Nick. This is Chris speaking. Excellent question, and I'm glad you brought up how this ties to other states, since I believe that matters a great deal. Well, when it comes to property taxes as a whole, let me begin by noting that our Property Tax team performed extremely well this year apart from the Texas surprise, which, incidentally, as I noted during my prepared remarks, caught the whole property tax consulting sector off guard; yet setting that aside, our total property taxes for this year are arriving quite close to the 5% growth we anticipated when the year began, which, as I said, accounted for fairly substantial rises in states such as Florida and Georgia, which are partly countered by other states having caps in place, plus the portfolio diversification advantage from other multi-year revaluation states that did not revalue this year. So right now, we still have a few things in motion; however, for the most part, we now hold almost all of our assessed values. Our teams have a solid sense of where appeals will probably end up. And at present we simply await our leftover tax rates being published near the balance of — or the close of this year. And on the whole, as I said, aside from the surprise in Texas, our other states are turning out mostly as we anticipated. Then regarding your '23 point, well, it's somewhat too soon to guess with figures, particularly considering the things in motion in Texas. Yet as we've discussed repeatedly in the past, eventually, we typically anticipate property taxes to move in line with HPA, frequently on a somewhat delayed basis. However, since home price appreciation has obviously reached a turning point, we believe it's fair to presume that property tax growth will also reach a turning point eventually. Even so, it's simply too soon for us to say whether we think that turning point will arrive in '23 or afterward. Still, we certainly know it lies ahead on the horizon.
Dave Singelyn
executiveNick, Dave here. I'll take on the latter portion of what you asked — whether this might be a sign of things to come in other states. Honestly, I don't have an answer. Up to now, what we've observed is that ownership and rental figures move in parallel. What I can share is that this news is extremely fresh, we're examining it, we've got a government affairs team, and we're talking with those people. Still, it's premature to come back with what we're learning there. One point I'd make is that we've witnessed in other situations where either rent control policies or other things affecting housing exist, over time those rules frequently end up being revisited, and in many instances modified or struck down. The latest example we can point to is November 2021 — quite recent — when St. Paul, Minnesota, approved a rent control ordinance capping rents at 3%, and 8% upon re-leasing. And now, they're watching their housing inventory and their capacity to expand their economy take a hit. That measure is under review as we speak. So actions of this kind do carry a negative long-term effect. Through our channels, we're working to hold conversations with the right people. But I'd say it's premature to give a definitive answer.
Juan Sanabria
analystCould we take a bit of time to discuss the for-sale developer segment, along with the impact that rising mortgage rates have had on that business? Also, when the for-sale market softens, does that create any kind of disruption — say, if those homes end up being converted into rentals, would that lead to issues with occupancy or leasing transfer for new homes, or anything along those lines?
Dave Singelyn
executiveYes. Good morning, Juan. There's quite a bit to address in what you've raised. To start, I'd point out that our focus is forward-looking, and what we see are tremendous opportunities for growth. The thing you're bringing up doesn't just shape whether we can make purchases from the building or how many opportunities we get there — the biggest impact, right off the bat, lands on our development pipeline in a good way. Builders are pulling back on new projects right now, and that's happening as we speak. They're still putting up and finishing the units they'd already begun. Even so, as that pullback unfolds, our development side is coming out ahead, and the price tag for putting up homes is dropping — everything from the dirt itself through to the vertical build. Looking at what construction savings have amounted to so far, I'd put that figure at roughly 10%. But the gains we expect ahead are considerably larger than that. On your specific question about whether builder inventories can be bought: there's a lot of builder inventory out there in the market. We've observed it amounting to tens of thousands of homes. So far, most of it fails to satisfy our standards for either location or quality. Still, a good number of them do qualify. The problem is that right now those homes aren't priced at levels we'd consider appealing enough to justify a purchase. At present, builders keep shielding their backlogs. Once those backlogs get worked through, prices will start coming down. That might happen toward the end of this year, or it might not occur until early next year. And when those chances do eventually arise, we'll be ready to make the most of them.
Juan Sanabria
analystNo worries, Dave. What I was really asking is whether that inventory currently being delivered—the stuff they can't move to homebuilders—is spilling over into the rental market. Is there any effect on your core business, as opposed to the development side, in terms of what you can lease up and/or what you can charge tenants?
Dave Singelyn
executiveYes. My apologies if I got the wrong end of it; but on that specific point, you've got it right. Quite a few of the homes sitting with builders—they're exploring other options for clearing their backlog, and some of those properties are being converted into rentals. Keep in mind that most of these homes sit in secondary and tertiary markets, and they aren't where our homes are. So they don't—they aren't competitors to us in any direct sense. Also worth remembering: across the past 10 years, single-family rental inventory has grown by 4 million homes, going from 13 million to 17 million homes. That works out to 400,000 homes on average each year. And the backlog we're talking about is 20,000 to 30,000 homes. Those 400,000 per year got absorbed just fine. Occupancies are still very, very strong. Demand for single-family rentals is higher today than we've ever seen; so while they may have a very short-term impact on absorption, they will be absorbed, and they will not have an impact to the long-term viability of single-family rentals.
Juan Sanabria
analystThanks; and then, when you look at the development platform overall, I'm just wondering about yield expectations there. With the rate moves we've seen, are those keeping pace with much higher capital cost? Or, given that capital is pricier today, how do you think about allocating additional dollars toward a pipeline?
Dave Singelyn
executiveRight. Juan, that's accurate. I mean, you have to consider the capital being raised alongside the investment opportunities, and the two must be aligned. When capital costs more, the yields you can get need to improve. What we're observing in development is meaningful decreases in what it costs to build homes. As I mentioned, with homebuilders reducing their output, we're seeing land come available that wasn't before, and that includes some very important land. We refer to these as VDLs, vacant developed lots. That's land we can buy and immediately start vertical construction on, with no land infrastructure work required. These land opportunities are currently being offered to us at discounts versus what we saw 6 months ago. They go from modest discounts all the way to 40% discounts. Over time, we anticipate they'll become even more appealing and move closer to what we historically saw before the pandemic. On construction cost, it's the same story. Looking at pre-pandemic trends, we're heading back toward those. A couple of examples: lumber has dropped from $1,600 a 1,000 board feet to $500; that's a 2/3 decline; that's over $20,000 in savings when building a home. We've seen the same in the trades, throughout drywall; so we've seen it in products and trades in framing, electrical, et cetera. Post drywall, we expect to see it. We haven't seen it yet. The homebuilders are still completing the homes they're building, and after that they'll slow the post drywall phase too. So we expect we'll see 20% to 25% reductions in input costs. The yields remain very, very strong. No change to the yield. All of that produces significant increases to the ultimate yield on our invested dollar. So we — I'll just repeat, in our development program I see tremendous opportunities; and this is the advantage of a diversified portfolio where we can build in many locations, while also having multiple channels through which we can acquire. So yes, the development program is very, very healthy so far. The existing program as well as opportunities on the horizon.
Steve Sakwa
analystDave, I get that this Texas situation is fairly recent, and there's no way for you to know exactly how it will shake out. But if it does look like the state has put some kind of target on the SFR back, would that, I suppose, eventually cause you to reconsider your long-term commitment to owning in Texas?
Dave Singelyn
executiveYes. Steve, I believe it's a bit early to reach any conclusion. So we have not yet had discussions with the taxing authorities, though our government affairs department will. I think part of this is also educating many parties, perhaps including us, but certainly the state parties too, and sort of showing them what has occurred in other cases where regulations have been hostile to rentals and what the impact over the long term is. So at this stage I'm not willing to say that we are adjusting any programs. I think it's simply far too early to make those calls.
Steve Sakwa
analystUnderstood. Chris, can you remind us what assumptions around bad debt are baked into the Q4 guidance? Also, give us the overall net bad debt number for '22, and perhaps your view on how that pattern carries into '23.
Chris Lau
executiveThat's a good one, Steve. When it comes to collections, speaking more generally, I'd say the trends have kept holding up well, with third quarter bad debt, as you noticed, coming in around the low 1% mark, which matched what we had anticipated pretty closely. Breaking that down a little, as we expected, rental assistance payments have kept declining; alongside that, collections have been improving more broadly. One more detail there: I'd say the broader bad debt picture is bolstered by the fact that for any remaining households we might have that COVID affected and that are still working their way through the process, if you remember, we adopted a highly conservative and prudent approach to accruing for bad debt during the pandemic's earlier stages. So those kinds of households have mostly been accounted for already in our bad debt from prior periods; thus, as we move into the fourth quarter now, things remain very much in line with what we expected before. We anticipate collections staying strong and expect that this debt will probably keep running around the low 1% mark, which is what we factored into guidance.
Steve Sakwa
analystApologies. So if you were to just sum up the gross, the net, and the rental assistance bad debt, what does that leave you at for the entire 2022 year?
Chris Lau
executiveRoughly 1% to the low 1s zone. Unpacking all the components is tough since there are so many shifting layers right now, but on a full year basis, 1% to low 1s.
Steve Sakwa
analystAnd on a broad level, do you expect that to stay roughly the same? Or, considering where the economy stands, do you figure that figure might rise in the coming year absent rental help? Or could it possibly decline and work in our favor?
Chris Lau
executiveWell, at this stage, rental assistance has fulfilled its purpose. It has been quite effective at supporting households in need. But for a while now, it has been phasing out, just for some background. During this year's third quarter, rental assistance came in around the $3 million mark; and as you may remember, that's versus $7 million to $9 million each quarter in the latter part of '21. So that reduction is already visible to us. We've also already observed that, once more, matched by better collections across the board. It's premature for me to speak in detail about how all of that takes shape going into '23. Still, up to now, we've experienced and witnessed — we've seen encouraging signs, felt optimistic regarding the better collections picture as rental assistance continues to diminish.
Steve Sakwa
analystAll right. And then, Bryan, one final thing. If you were to break down the metrics around tours or collections, the capacity to raise rents or to renew leases — can you pick out anything from the makeup of the renter pool regarding typical earnings or the sorts of occupations? I suppose I'm hunting for any anecdotal detail pointing to something regional or tied to a particular kind of consumer that could prove useful.
Bryan Smith
executiveYes. Appreciate it, Steve. I'd like to raise a handful of separate data points; we discussed rent coverage — the income-to-rent coverage our resident base has, which sits in the 5x range — and the reality that the typical household includes more than one earner, which provides us with considerable confidence as we head into these sorts of uncertain times. As for where our residents work and which industries employ them, to begin with, it's broadly marked by professional, knowledge-based sectors. According to our surveys, nearly 90% of our residents hold college degrees; they work in essential industries — health care, education, government, military — in professional-side roles, such as tech support, for instance. So we believe they're positioned really well. Should any economic pressures arise in individual cases, we remain quite pleased with the demand backdrop. That means we can turn homes quickly if any sort of stress hits our resident base; yet when it comes to their industries, where they work, their existing in-place income and their sort of excess capacity, we believe they're positioned really well.
Adam Kramer
analystI want to build a bit on what Steve asked; the detail you gave on bad debt early on is genuinely helpful; but I just want to nail down that 1% number, I believe, that you mentioned for bad debt — that is after subtracting the rental assistance, and I think you said $3 million in rental assistance?
Chris Lau
executiveRight; that is bad debt booked to the P&L, and it is net of that. And once more, there are many moving parts involved, but that is 1 piece.
Adam Kramer
analystUnderstood. That's completely logical. And when considering certain expense line items, property tax tends to be what draws attention as folks think about Q4 of 2023; yet when considering other property tax entries or additional expense categories, I suppose there are various pluses and minuses regarding whether turnover could rise and how that would flow through the P&L. Are there additional inflationary effects, certainly, and acknowledging that you folks are definitely taking steps to reduce costs through technological enhancements and greater portfolio density. But I'd really like to hear perhaps a few pluses and minuses on certain other expense categories?
Chris Lau
executiveYes. Absolutely. Adam, this is Chris once more. Allow me to take you through Q4 and what guidance includes; after that, I'm certain Bryan would be happy to discuss several excellent programs we're pursuing regarding efficiency. However, when you calculate it, the guidance midpoint in fact suggests a slowing in our Q4 nonproperty tax expense increase, mostly driven by when certain prior-year quarterly comparisons landed. As you might remember, near the close of 2021, we started noticing some of the present inflationary strains. And you might likewise remember that we chose to move up the schedule for certain calendar year-end salary bumps to improve talent retention entering Q4 of the previous year; thus all of that together produced a simpler nonproperty tax expense comparison in Q4 of 2021, which is what guidance reflects. So I simply wanted to explain that for you, and I'm certain Bryan would be happy to discuss all the positive developments we're pursuing regarding efficiency programs.
Bryan Smith
executiveAbsolutely, Adam — I'd say the most logical spot to begin there is with repairs and maintenance. It's clear that those increases sit significantly under what inflation would suggest. Plus, our team has simply excelled at boosting self performance. There are particular things within our control that let us offset inflation, and that comes from handling more tasks in-house, getting ahead of any supply chain problems we might have encountered during this year, and genuinely adopting a proactive stance toward self-performance work. So that's what shows up in the R&M line. Turning to property management, the shifts there show that we now have all positions filled. From a staffing standpoint, we're in an extremely strong spot to close out this year on a high note and get ready for a robust 2023.
Adam Kramer
analystGreat. And just one final item, a brief one here. Regarding Florida and Georgia — Chris, I know you mentioned them earlier, that the initial guide had sizable increases baked in there. I just wanted to, and again, only to the extent you're able to comment, sort of confirm that, I suppose, a settlement amount was already on the way for you folks. Put differently, you've essentially already seen how it all shakes out when it comes to those increases, and that's basically what was assumed?
Chris Lau
executiveThat's right. I think your line may have cut out for a moment. But I believe the question was whether Florida and Georgia were fully taken into account and what we had anticipated before; and yes is the answer. And for both of those, we've witnessed some fairly significant increases, with market values landing in the 20% to 30% range across those 2 states. But simply put, yes, those were factored into our prior expectations.
Haendel St. Juste
analystDave, I'd like to revisit what you said about development, specifically regarding cost and yields, to make sure I understand it clearly. What I'm wondering is how the yields on homes being started right now stack up against that 6% figure you've historically seen; and at what point do you anticipate the lower input costs you described will start helping those yields? Should we be thinking about that landing more in '24, '25? I'm simply trying to gauge what yield might look like across the coming couple of years.
Dave Singelyn
executiveYes. That's a fair question, Haendel. When it comes to development, we describe it as moving in cycles. So for the homes we'd acquire at present, we'd capture the land benefit, plus we'd capture the later benefit from declines in commodity costs and input costs; as for homes delivered during this period, and those we'll deliver in the next quarter, those homes weren't just started earlier this year, back when commodity pricing hit its peak. Many of those commodities had been contracted a few months prior to that. Consequently, the home center being delivered in the third quarter, fourth quarter, possibly even the very first quarters of next year, will reflect commodity costs incurred in the early part of 2022. That means they'll be more elevated. The yields will land in the 5s, which is what we underwrote them on. And the capital being utilized for those was raised early in 2022; and those acquisitions, despite being in the 5s, if you match them against the capital being utilized, remain accretive; but a time lag exists between when commodity prices shift and when those deliveries occur that benefit from those commodities.
Haendel St. Juste
analystPerhaps a quick follow-up regarding development, thinking about how the near-term items break down proportionally. I'm just wondering whether we ought to anticipate additional starts happening through the JV rather than on balance sheet? And then, given the fee opportunity there, would you — or should we — anticipate a progressively stronger yield from that?
Chris Lau
executiveCertainly. Haendel, this is Chris. I can begin with how we expect starts to land, and Dave can come back in regarding that second point; but broadly, and this has come up between us previously, with our development pipeline continuing to expand, a bigger and bigger share of those should get underway on balance sheet. Right now, our JVs remain quite busy and are performing well. Roughly 60% of their capital has been developed and deployed, and they likely need another 12 to 24 months to wrap up; however, with the program continuing to grow and with us increasing starts and deliveries, the anticipation is that a bigger and bigger share of those will sit on balance sheet.
Brad Heffern
analystRegarding the deals that got done during this quarter, could you provide the cap rate? Also, was there anything distinctive about those? Did you find opportunities that simply happened to be priced better, giving a higher cap rate? Was the share of newly built homes larger, or anything along those lines?
Dave Singelyn
executiveSure. Brad, this is Dave speaking. The acquisitions we disclosed for the third quarter were actually signed back in this year's second quarter. They closed during the beginning portion of Q3. Those deals sit in the 5s. So those — but once more, the timing of when they were signed was somewhat different. We keep reviewing every acquisition and growth opportunity out there. We are largely watching from the sidelines at present, since on pricing — we're in the middle of price discovery, and you're trying to figure out where those new prices will bottom out, or at least reach a point where they align with our cost of capital. As a result, nothing has been added to the growth program on MLS over the past couple of months. What we closed came from '20 — contracts from the second quarter that closed in the early part of the third quarter.
Brad Heffern
analystAll right, understood. Now circling back to those Texas property taxes — I have to admit, it caught me off guard a bit to hear that a distinction is emerging between single-family homes that are renter-occupied and those that are owner-occupied, particularly since these matters usually get handled locally. So has this been codified somehow on the regulatory side? And also, I'm wondering whether the higher assessed values, specifically on renter-occupied homes, could be successfully challenged on appeal?
Chris Lau
executiveAbsolutely. Brad, here's the thing — this surprised us, and it surprised the industry too. That said, I'd frame it as somewhat broader than simply owner-occupied against nonowner-occupied, and how everything functions under that 3.5% cap established by the Texas Property Tax Reform and Transparency Act. Commercial has to be factored in too. What we witnessed this year was really an unmatched, disproportionate approach spanning every asset class, with our read being that commercial is coming in extremely low — or even flat, in some instances. Meanwhile, owner-occupied residences sit at roughly 10%. That consequently means the remainder, or the sizable resulting hikes for nonowner-occupied single-family — which is what permits total property tax revenue to stay inside that 3.5% cap, held in place by commercial and owner-occupied homes. And once more, just to give some context, this runs quite counter to how Texas has historically handled things — the state had never experienced that degree of unequal treatment among the asset classes.
Dennis McGill
analystChris, I need to ask you about property taxes again, but first let me get a few figures straight. I believe you mentioned that you'd already factored in Florida and Georgia accruals rising somewhere around 20%-plus. And my guess is, if Texas is added to that group and those three states make up 40% of the assets, it suggests no other place saw any increase. I just want to confirm I'm reading those remarks the right way.
Chris Lau
executiveThere are a few separate points in there. Regarding Florida and Georgia, what I was referring to is the market portion — where those values drift to. Georgia landed in the 20% range. Florida has a few separate pieces, and this is getting quite detailed. But there are 2 parts. One is a market floating piece, and then there's what they refer to as a cap-assessed value piece, which is limited to a 10% increase and made up roughly 60% of property taxes in Florida, while the remaining 40% is the portion that floats to market — and that's the piece that rose roughly 30%. So Florida's net ends up somewhat lower. I believe it's in the high teens or thereabouts. As for everything else — it's not flat. But remember, quite a few other states have caps in place, and there are also jurisdictions throughout our portfolio, given how broadly diversified we are, that only get reassessed every few years. And a substantial number of those didn't get reassessed this year, which brings everything outside Texas down to 5%.
Dennis McGill
analystAll right, that's useful. Following up on something you said, Dave, about what it costs to build — I'm not sure I heard it correctly. Were you saying outright decreases in construction costs are beginning to show up? I'd probably leave lumber out of that, since we all know it gets passed through. But when it comes to categories other than lumber, are you already seeing labor and/or construction bids decline on phases underway or on bids yet to come?
Dave Singelyn
executiveYes, Dennis, that's right. However, it applies to the construction phases running up through drywall. In what comes after drywall — the finished trades, cabinetry, and so on — we haven't observed it. Those trades are still very much in demand among the builders. The trades before drywall, though, are calling us looking for work; and now we can pit multiple vendors, or a larger number of vendors, against each other, and reductions are the result. So right now it ranges from single digits to low double digits. Still, my expectation is that it keeps climbing. If you look back at historical trend lines, trend them, and strip out the pandemic anomaly, you'd need 20%, 25% reductions to return to the trend line of what construction has historically been.
John Pawlowski
analystChris or Bryan, can you help us understand the reason behind the 24% rise in recurring CapEx per home on a year-to-date basis?
Bryan Smith
executiveJohn, Bryan here. Sure — a few separate elements are at play, and a portion of them we expected when the year started. We discussed the workout involving certain distressed COVID residents, so that accounts for a small piece of it. What matters more, though, is purely inflationary pressure tied to third-party labor and materials, which we don't really control — and where our ability to offset is limited. That sets up a clear contrast with how we handle the R&M line versus what we spend on CapEx. As a result, we're simply more exposed to third-party cost hikes, particularly with something like HVAC, where at an owner occupied home we have to complete the job fast. And as the Q3 numbers show, we're just more vulnerable.
John Pawlowski
analystAll right. Could you help us understand what you'd consider a typical total maintenance cost at present? What I mean is, turnover has declined over the past few years, yet CapEx, R&M, and turnover expenses have been rising; so it seems that if turnover leveled off or even rose, those figures would appear considerably worse. So is roughly $3,000 as a total cost to maintain a sensible ongoing run rate, and we simply grow from there at whatever CPI is? Or do you have any sense of what an actual normalized cost number looks like? Any thoughts on that would be great.
Bryan Smith
executiveYes. Thank you, John. I won't accept that retention will do anything other than get better. However, as an estimate for a longer-term run rate, I believe you're fairly close. My expectation would be somewhat lower than that. Yet in the long run, we would anticipate that line item likely rising with inflationary levels.
Neil Malkin
analystTo start, David, you spent quite a bit of time during the call discussing additional opportunities, land, and builder inventories. Could you perhaps share a few thoughts about the owners of land banks? On the previous call, I believe you mentioned that a number of the big players had seen well-positioned deals come back to them or drop out because borrowing costs have risen. Could you update us on that? Could you describe what you're seeing when it comes to land bank opportunities? And then, does this differ by region? Take Phoenix or Florida, for instance, or any markets where there might be greater upside, where more properties appear favorably priced and therefore more appealing to you right now.
Dave Singelyn
executiveSure, Neil. Over the past few weeks, quite a few properties have come back to land bankers. If you follow the homebuilders, you've probably heard several of the big national homebuilders mention that they're handing back large quantities of homes to the land bankers. Right now, the gap between bids and asks is extremely wide. As a result, essentially nothing is happening — no transactions are taking place at this moment. As for the homes, the most appealing opportunities as of today — and this is highly dynamic, shifting every single day — the largest opportunities are entirely in the West. That means every Western market. It's the Northwest; it's down in the Phoenix and Las Vegas areas, it's Denver. That's where we're currently seeing most of the opportunities. In the Southeast, there are some opportunities, but they aren't as abundant as what we're finding in the West. Also — and this is the other point I raised during the prepared remarks, or perhaps in an earlier question — for the first time in several years, we're seeing vacant developed land, meaning land that, if we can buy it, lets us produce homes far faster than the raw land this business was built on. So opportunities are still emerging, though there remains somewhat of a gap between bids and asks relative to where we'd like to transact. In fact, nothing at all is trading. Nobody is taking the ask, and a bit more price discovery still needs to happen.
Neil Malkin
analystAll right. One more thing regarding that point. So I want to make sure — whenever you mentioned builders handing properties back, or stock that exists in the tens of thousands — you mean stock totaling tens of thousands, meaning actual houses, whereas the builders handing things back refers to the lots themselves, right? I just want clarity — those aren't houses.
Dave Singelyn
executiveRight, Neil. In the case of land bankers, they've put land up for auction, and builders have put land up for auction through those land banking companies. And what happens is — those auctions get called off, deposits are kept, and control of the land shifts to the land bankers. That's the land I mean.
Chandni Luthra
analystHey everyone, I'd like to raise a question regarding supply. On the MLS channel, what's showing up? With home buying having turned extremely cost-prohibitive for so many folks, are you noticing additional properties being listed for rent, and from where you sit, is that putting any downward force on prices?
Bryan Smith
executiveChandni, Bryan here. Appreciate you asking. On the supply side — within a number of our MSAs, we are encountering certain supply-related pressure, though it truly isn't a source of head-to-head rivalry for the properties we own. Typically, our properties sit in better locations and, in certain instances, feature newer construction, making them genuinely stronger assets. It comes down to the fact that rental houses aren't all alike. As for the impact of that supply, it has honestly been tiny when it comes to our occupancy as well as our rate growth. We continue to hold occupancy at very elevated levels, along with solid rate growth. And there's one more thing I'd like to highlight: we can achieve all of this without relying on any concessions. In certain markets we operate in, concessions are indeed being offered — just not from us. Let me be clear on that point.
Chandni Luthra
analystUnderstood — that helps. Now, looking at the other side of that same issue, what's the trend for residents moving out in order to buy houses? How far have those numbers dropped since the start of this year? And what are you observing on that front?
Bryan Smith
executiveYeah, they've declined a bit. There is somewhat of a delay. My expectation is that they'll keep falling. We observed a drop from August through the most recent 2 months, though it's likely a comparable share to the decline in total home sales, which is in the low double digits.
Hyung Jun Choe
analystLet me return to what you said about not relying heavily on concessions, Bryan. That makes sense to me, I think. I realize that in-bound leasings come to 250,000. Still, speaking broadly, should the macro backdrop deteriorate, what would your guidance be — how do you view deploying that lever within your broader rental approach?
Bryan Smith
executiveRight. Appreciate it, Sam; it's a tool. It's been something we've turned to before, though not for a number of years; yet right now, demand for our particular product is incredibly strong. I believe several different factors play into that. Our homes sit in excellent locations within growing markets, in desirable neighborhoods, and our leasing platform is efficient enough to seize this demand and harness it throughout the whole marketplace for the good of our portfolio. Inbounding inquiries count as 1 piece. Compared with record levels a year ago, website traffic has risen year-over-year. For our rent-ready properties, distinct showings remain far above the averages seen before the pandemic. So when it comes to demand for our particular product, it is exceptionally high. Right now, we simply don't perceive any reason to alter the concession policy in any way.
Hyung Jun Choe
analystUnderstood. Understood. Then one brief question; regarding ancillary revenue, is there anything being introduced soon? Or would it simply be normal operations with whatever you currently offer?
Bryan Smith
executiveYes. I'd likely call it normal operations; our pet program rollout keeps moving forward, as we've mentioned previously, though honestly there are no significant updates to share right now.
Linda Tsai
analystDo you continue to observe the advantages of people moving into your markets? Or has that pattern begun to ease?
Bryan Smith
executiveYeah. Thanks, Linda; Bryan here. No, we still see it happening. To be specific, a key factor is people relocating into our portfolio from California. And measured against the same period a year earlier, that figure remains 30% higher. So it hasn't halted. There's been no slowdown whatsoever. And it strongly affects our Western markets; so that keeps going. Then, consider another measure we track carefully, which is how many residents arrive in our homes from another state. That number is still far above both the prior-year level and prepandemic levels; so it remains a meaningful share of our application volume.
Linda Tsai
analystAnd on the other side of that, when people do move out, what reasons are they giving?
Bryan Smith
executiveThe explanations match what we've seen before, though the mix may have shifted somewhat. Buying a home remains the top cause for leaving. Everything else is smaller stuff — life changes and similar things. Renewal rates are ticking up slightly. So that particular reason has risen as well. But honestly, there's no significant shift in the breakdown of why residents depart; we're just very pleased that retention keeps getting better, and I believe that speaks to the strength of the value proposition our platform offers overall.
Jade Rahmani
analystMaybe this one's for Bryan, on the demand side. When you look at single-family rental versus multifamily, how do you see it? Do they act as substitutes for each other? Put differently, do the additional tenants mostly arrive from apartments and decide to set up a household in a single-family rental house, or are they people who would be owners but pick single-family rental instead? Could you offer a bit of insight into which tenants make up the bulk of what you're seeing?
Bryan Smith
executiveSure. Yes. Thanks for asking, Jade. A valuable source of our residents is multifamily. We track and survey their origin. No major shift has shown up. At the start of the pandemic, remember, applications from multifamily jumped sharply. That has settled back to roughly where things stood before the pandemic. My sense is it sits in the low 20% range; a valuable piece, yes, though not the bulk. I tend to frame it this way: as residents get older, marry, and begin families, moving into single-family homes is a natural progression. It doesn't have to come straight out of multifamily. The bulk of our residents arrive from single family, having either owned or rented before.
Jade Rahmani
analystSo when it comes to the slowdown in demand for new leases that's showing up in multifamily, what's causing it, in your view? And do you think that will ultimately spill over into the single-family for rent sector?
Bryan Smith
executiveI'd say the resident mix differs, and the demographics differ. For quite a while now, our demographic has stayed fairly steady. The typical age sits around 37, incomes are high, and these are folks picking a somewhat better quality of life. Some of the migration patterns would suggest that; plus our product isn't the same as multi-family. You get yards and space with single-family homes, and great neighborhoods. Into our communities we're bringing Class A multifamily style amenities; so a lot of genuinely, genuinely nice features are being added that I don't believe were around before, definitely not on the rental side; and when you pair that with our services platform, I think the value proposition we offer is really beginning to be understood. And that, I believe, will be the primary thing pushing it.
Anthony Powell
analystI'd like to pose the supply issue from another angle. What investors tell us worries them is this: should rates stay elevated for an extended period — that is, mortgage rates such that anyone who has to move out of their house for any reason decides it's better to lease it out rather than sell, even in certain of those better neighborhoods you referenced — that might mean more supply over the coming 2 years. Does that concern you or do you keep tabs on it? And how do you see that possible risk?
Dave Singelyn
executiveAnthony, indeed, that's something we track; every day we watch supply across our market. That situation could indeed unfold; so far we aren't observing much of it. However, let me also point out that the mom-and-pop offering and our residences differ, whether in the services platform or the upgrades we perform on these homes during turns. That product distinction, in my view, places us well and gives us a competitive edge. Still, as of today, we aren't experiencing much pressure from owner homes being converted to rentals.
Anthony Powell
analystOne more thing about Phoenix. People always bring it up as a place where home values have dropped quite a bit, but your lease spreads in that market are extremely robust. How do you see Phoenix as a whole? And is it possible for the gap between rising home prices and your solid rents to persist?
Dave Singelyn
executivePhoenix has consistently ranked among our best-loved and highest-performing markets. From many angles, it's wonderful. The occupancy figures are out there. The rate growth is out there. Collections are quite robust too, so that marketplace makes us extremely pleased. As I've mentioned on earlier calls, it has gained from California migration, and it's also a market with considerable investment activity. And among the MSAs I brought up before where supply has risen, it's one of them. However, I'd like to point out that the additional supply we're observing in Phoenix involves product that doesn't compete directly with what we offer. These homes sit in poor locations; often, we discussed the horizontal apartment surge that Phoenix experienced. So our offering stands apart there. Still, Phoenix stays among our leading markets, and we keep witnessing strength.
Austin Wurschmidt
analystDave, I want to return to something you mentioned regarding the stock of houses listed for sale that fit your standards for quality and roughly for location, yet whose pricing isn't really where it needs to be. Can you put a number on the size of that gap between what buyers will bid and what sellers will ask? Also, what's your sense of how much time the people who own those properties can sit tight before they might have to make a move?
Dave Singelyn
executiveSure. To start, what we had been referring to, as I recall, during that part of the conversation was the inventory held by the national builders; and as of now, we've observed some modest price adjustment, perhaps 5%. Another 15%, 20% of movement is what we're going to need to see, so.
Austin Wurschmidt
analystUnderstood. And then, when you consider that alongside development, could you remind us of the gap between those market cap rates—or where you believe values ought to be—and what you aim for on development?
Dave Singelyn
executiveSure. Historically, the difference in yield between acquisitions and development has come to roughly 100 basis points. And when we look at opportunities now, we're still in that very same neighborhood.
Dave Singelyn
executiveThanks, operator. To wrap things up, I want to restate that the SFR sector is demonstrating considerable resilience right now; we're positioned extremely strongly heading into 2023 and are starting to notice promising signs of quite appealing chances for both incremental development and acquisitions. So I appreciate all of you following us this quarter. We're eager to reconnect with you in the next quarter. Have a great day.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings an end to today's teleconference. At this point you're free to hang up your lines. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete American Homes 4 Rent transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to American Homes 4 Rent earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in American Homes 4 Rent or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.