American Homes 4 Rent (AMH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 24, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Nicholas Fromm
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to the conference call covering our 2022 fourth-quarter earnings. Joining me on this call are David Singelyn, our Chief Executive Officer; Bryan Smith, our Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Lau, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements may be part of today's discussion. Any statement in this call that isn't a statement of historical fact counts as a forward-looking statement, and such statements carry various risks and uncertainties that might make actual results diverge materially from what those statements project. The risks and other factors that might negatively impact our business and results down the road are laid out in our press releases and in the documents we file with the SEC. Every forward-looking statement is made only as of today, February 24th, 2023, and we take on no duty to update or revise any forward-looking statement, whether because of new information, future events, or anything else, unless the law requires it. A reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures appears in our earnings press release and supplemental information package. Also note that our operating and financial results, which include GAAP and non-GAAP measures, are laid out in full in our earnings release and supplemental information package. Those documents, along with SEC reports and the audio webcast replay of this conference call, are available on our website at www.amh.com. With that, I'll hand the call over to our CEO, David Singelyn.
David Singelyn
executiveAppreciate that, Nick. Hello, everybody, and thanks for being with us today. First off, I want to draw attention to the company-wide rebranding we announced last month. Making it easy to lease a high-quality home has always been our aim, which lets our residents concentrate on what truly matters to them in life. A simplified, modern look is what our rebranding brings, reflecting how committed we are to ongoing innovation, and it includes a refreshed website plus an improved mobile experience. That said, this is only one piece of the puzzle. The single-family rental space keeps changing, and this year we intend to strengthen our position as market leader even further by maintaining our spending on customer service and maintenance delivery through an effort we've called the Resident 360 program. Added resources for our property management platform, ongoing system innovation, and reinforcing our various supporting functions will all be part of this year's investments. Shortly, Bryan and Chris will walk you through our operational plan and the financial effects of this highly significant initiative. Now, on to the quarter and the full year; we finished 2022 on a strong note, delivering 13% core FFO growth per share for the year. That marks the second year in a row of double-digit growth, which speaks to the AMH team, platform, and portfolio. Looking toward 2023, we know the landscape is shifting as the economy cools and inflation keeps squeezing consumers and businesses alike; keeping that in mind, our 2023 outlook assumes our top line stays resilient, with growth above historical norms, even if it moderates somewhat from 2022; long-term fundamental tailwinds in our industry are what drive this strength and resiliency. To begin with, housing is undersupplied, and current building permits point to a major drop in new housing inventory. Next, affordability strongly favors renting. Based on the most recent John Burns data, renting is more than 20% more affordable than owning across our top 20 markets. And lastly, our portfolio is focused on high quality of life markets, where most of our households have dual incomes and work in resilient sectors, with nurses, firefighters, and other first responders among the most common professions for our residents. Switching to the investment side, our AMH Development program, which is the foundation of our growth, keeps paying off for us. Right now, our traditional and national builder channels are mostly paused. As things stand, buying properties in an accretive and responsible way remains hard, since expected returns at today's pricing are still too low to meet our required return thresholds. Someday those channels will reopen, but no crystal ball tells us exactly when. Because of that, our investment guidance assumes no material activity in these two channels during 2023. We'll share updates if market conditions shift. One major advantage of our three-pronged growth strategy is that, unlike others, we don't depend only on open market acquisitions for growth. During 2022, our AMH Development program kept producing steady, forecastable expansion, handing over 2,183 homes, which matched what we had planned for that year. During 2023, we anticipate yet another year of steady delivery growth. Much like what we mentioned on the previous earnings call, across numerous markets we operate in, we're noticing indications that development labor and input costs are coming down. Deliveries during the fourth quarter do show peak pricing, but at present, we're watching those prices come down. To illustrate, lumber right now costs one-third of what it did at its peak in May of 2022. For the remainder of this year, we anticipate additional price decreases in vertical input costs. Do remember that the vertical development phase takes six to nine months, so the cost savings we're seeing today will appear in yields during late 2023 or 2024. When it comes to asset management, our focus remains on getting the most out of the asset base we already hold. To be specific, we expect another busy year for dispositions, seizing on present market pricing chances by selling homes that don't fit with our long-term goals. You can already observe this in the fourth quarter, when we sold roughly $130 million worth of homes, pushing the full year figure to almost $300 million. Individuals purchased the overwhelming majority of those homes. To wrap up, as we move into 2023, our resilient asset class, solid tenant base, and unique development program put us in a good position amid these uncertain economic times. Our Resident 360 program, along with favorable long-term rental demand tailwinds, sets the stage for steady value creation over many years ahead. I'll now hand the call to Bryan for an operations update. Bryan?
Bryan Smith
executiveThanks, Dave. AMH had yet another excellent year in 2022. Strong operating results were delivered by our team, along with an impressive 9.1% same-home core NOI growth across the full year. Before diving into our results, I want to acknowledge the team for executing on key technology initiatives that paved the way for our Resident 360 program. First, last month we rolled out our upgraded website, a critical milestone in delivering the modern resident experience. With mobile as a priority, our new site makes leasing more convenient than it has ever been. Simplified home searches, streamlined map functions, and an even easier showing process are among the new features; this new website serves as the key platform for future improvements to the resident experience. Second, significant progress has been made on our next-generation maintenance services platform, which includes system enhancements across our logistics, scheduling, and communications functions; we anticipate delivering another round of improvements later this year. Most importantly, these initiatives enable us to capture even more data on prospects and residents, which is already powering our analytics engine. Now to operating results. Fourth quarter demand matched our expectations. While some seasonality was present, demand metrics remain above pre-pandemic levels. Same-home average occupied days came in at 97%. Growth in new, renewal, and blended rental rates was 8.5%, 7.9%, and 8.1%, respectively, which produced 7.3% same-home core revenue growth for the quarter. Core operating expense growth reached 10.5%, mainly due to the Texas property tax true-up we talked about last quarter. As a result of all this, same-home core NOI growth was 5.7% for the quarter. Now looking at the current year, 2023 has begun very well, with robust demand for our homes persisting through January and February. Thus far this year, we have observed higher website traffic and inbound leasing inquiries, fueling a 20% rise in distinct showings per ready property versus our long-term averages for the same period. During January, same-home average occupied days was 97%, while new and renewal spreads were 7.2% and 7.6%, respectively. Blended rate growth for the month came to 7.5% as a result. On a full year basis, our same-home core revenues growth outlook sits at 6% at the midpoint; this is mainly driven by forecasted growth in average monthly realized rent in the 6.5% area, which includes a low 4% earnings from last year's leasing activity and the partial year contribution from 2023 blended rate growth expectations. Small year-over-year movements in occupancy and fees, along with our expectation for a modest 35 basis point increase in our bad debt percentage, partially offset this. This expected increase can be attributed to a small cohort of lingering COVID-impacted accounts taking longer to resolve than expected. Turning to what we expect for core property operating expenses, the same-home growth forecast for next year sits at 9.75% at the midpoint, and that captures yet another year of higher property taxes and insurance, which Chris is going to address shortly; when it comes to all remaining expenses, our guidance factors in broad inflationary pressure along with deliberate investments in our Resident 360 program. As things stand today, our platform delivers the finest customer service anywhere in the industry, and that has let us set ourselves apart from rivals. Resident 360 broadens what our platform can do, and it will help with resident retention, allow for tighter cost control and bolster our standing as the customer service leader in the market over the long haul. I'm eager to watch Resident 360 become a reality. A strong operational platform and team are already in place with us, and our industry-leading customer service will simply improve now that this program has been completely rolled out. With that, I'll hand the call over to Chris.
Christopher Lau
executiveThank you, Bryan, and good morning, everybody. There are three topics I plan to address in my remarks today. To start, I'll give a quick rundown of how we finished the year; after that, an update concerning our balance sheet and the capital activity we've recently undertaken; and finally, I'll wrap up by walking through our 2023 guidance. Turning first to operating results, we wrapped up 2022 with one more robust quarter of steady execution, posting net income attributable to common shareholders of $87.5 million, equal to $0.25 per diluted share, along with $0.40 of core FFO per share in unit, which amounts to 6.7% growth versus the prior year. For the entirety of 2022, net income attributable to common shareholders came to $250.8 million, or $0.71 per diluted share, plus $1.54 of core FFO per share and unit, a figure matching the midpoint from our latest 2022 guidance. On top of that, because taxable income kept climbing strongly, following the close of the year our Board of Trustees signed off on raising our quarterly distribution by 22%, bringing it to $0.22 per share. Keep in mind that our distribution hikes have been unusually large in recent years while we worked off what remained of our net operating losses. Now that those net operating losses are largely exhausted, we anticipate that going forward, distribution increases will track earnings growth more closely as time passes. Looking at investment activity, we handed over 701 total homes from our AMH Development program during the quarter, a result that came in slightly ahead of what we had anticipated. Breaking down those deliveries, 415 homes went to our wholly-owned portfolio and 286 homes went to our joint venture portfolios; as for acquisitions, our programs are still mostly paused as we wait patiently for additional stabilization in both home values and the capital markets. We picked up just 74 homes during the quarter, mostly made up of pre-existing national homebuilder contract closings. I'd now like to shift to our balance sheet and the capital activity we've recently completed. When the year ended, our net debt, including preferred shares to adjusted EBITDA, stood at six times; cash available on the balance sheet totaled $69 million, and against our $1.25 billion revolving credit facility, we had a drawn balance of $130 million. After the year closed, we settled the remaining 8 million Class A common shares tied to last year's forward equity sale agreement, generating net proceeds of $298.4 million, part of which went toward paying down our credit facility, while what remained helped fund a portion of our 2023 capital plan, which I'll get into further in a couple of minutes. Also, given the ongoing uncertainty we see in the public capital markets, we recently reached an agreement to expand the total capital capacity of our existing joint venture with institutional investors advised by JPMorgan Asset Management to roughly $900 million. That gives us close to $300 million in extra joint venture capital capacity, which will be directed toward incremental land and development opportunities. Importantly, this larger JV capital capacity lets us stay opportunistic while making sure our wholly-owned development pipeline stays strategically sized so it can be funded without needing to issue additional common equity. Now I want to give everyone a look at what we're initially expecting for 2023. Across the whole of 2023, our projection for core FFO per share comes in at $1.58 to $1.64, and the midpoint of that range works out to 4.5% growth compared with the prior year. To add a bit more detail, that midpoint assumes same-home core revenues rising 6%, which Bryan went over a few minutes back, together with same-home core property operating expenses climbing 9.75%, pushed by property taxes growing around 9%, since our year-end forecasting work on those taxes is now finished and we think 2023 property tax growth will probably stay at last year's peak levels, reflecting how states with multi-year revaluations keep picking up backward-looking home price appreciation; on a brighter note, a few of our annual revaluation states are starting to show slight deceleration, which backs up our belief that property tax moderation is still ahead of us in future years. On top of that, we're anticipating 10% to 11% combined growth across all other expense line items, which mirrors the broader inflationary backdrop, a tough property insurance market, and the added costs tied to the Resident 360 program. When we combine our same-home portfolio revenue and expense growth assumptions, we arrive at expected 2023 same-home core NOI growth of 4% at the midpoint. Turning to investment, because of the market conditions we're seeing, our 2023 investment plans include no material acquisitions through either our traditional or national builder channels. And while we think those channels will reopen at some point, the timing isn't something we can forecast, which, as a reminder, highlights the steady and dependable value that comes from our AMH Development program. Even with acquisitions currently constrained, we still anticipate deploying $1 billion to $1.2 billion of total capital this year in an attractive way, adding between 2,200 and 2,400 newly constructed AMH Development homes across our wholly-owned and joint venture portfolios. To be specific about our wholly-owned portfolio, at the midpoint of our ranges, we look to invest roughly $900 million of AMH Capital, made up of $650 million, or 1,850 homes, added through our development program, plus $250 million of combined investment into our wholly-owned development pipeline, our pro rata share of JV investments, and property enhancing CapEx programs. On the funding side, we expect this year's $900 million AMH Capital plan to be covered by a mix of retained cash flow, $200 million to $300 million of recycled capital from dispositions, net proceeds from our forward equity shares settled last month, and modest leverage capacity utilization from our balance sheet, which leaves a couple of hundred million dollars of dry capital capacity available to pursue additional growth opportunities if market conditions shift. That wraps up our prepared remarks. But before we take your questions, I want to remind everyone that our asset class, diversified portfolio footprint, and investment-grade balance sheet leave us positioned for resiliency through these uncertain economic times. On top of that, Resident 360 gives our operating platform extra strength, and our unique AMH Development program also puts us in a strong spot for creating value over the long term. With that said, I appreciate you spending your time with us once more, and now we'll take your questions. Operator?
Nick Joseph
analystThanks. I get the capital allocation strategy completely, yet what would make you keener on buying properties moving forward? And also, perhaps, what's your view on cap rates right now?
David Singelyn
executiveYeah. Nick, this is Dave. Good afternoon. The capital plan and the investment plan are connected, and really it comes down to your cost of capital at present and where growth chances exist. Right now, what we're observing is the acquisition market plus the national builder market. Yields at today's pricing sit in the mid-5s. And at the mid-5s, they don't appeal to us. We view our acquisition program, or our investment program, as having three channels. And the development program provides us the best assets and, over the long term, the best yields within the acquisition channels are the opportunistic ones. At present, we'd need to witness an additional 50 basis points or more of an increase before we'd step into that market. Nick, as you can see or heard from the prepared remarks, we have no material acquisitions planned, but that's — should the market shift, we'll be prepared to acquire opportunistically.
Nick Joseph
analystThank you; that's quite useful. Then perhaps regarding the outlook for expense increases, clearly, property taxes are still having an effect. Should we see that as a 2023 catch-up stemming from all the appreciation in home prices? Or is that something we ought to kind of anticipate in the coming — across the coming two or three years, simply given how various municipalities deal with real estate tax assessments?
Christopher Lau
executiveYeah. Nick, this is Chris speaking. Great question; and listen, I'd really link back to a few of our remarks from the prior quarter. And as everyone is aware, appreciation in home prices, which ranks among the main drivers behind property taxes, reached a turning point, at some point around the midpoint of last year or thereabouts. Consequently, as we've conveyed previously, we expect that property taxes will reach a turning point too; yet since property taxes look backward and also because roughly a third or so of the property taxes we pay are in states that reassess every several years, which means they're still catching multiple years of record home price appreciation that looks backward at this point. What we anticipate is that growth in 2023 property taxes will continue to be comparable to 2022, in that vicinity of 9%. Yet as I noted during my prepared remarks, we're starting to observe a few green shoots across a couple of our markets that reassess annually. In particular, we discussed a fair amount during the prior quarter and the prior year; in Florida and Georgia, instead of the mid-teens gains we witnessed a year ago, we're watching those moderate into the low teens or thereabouts this year. And then in particular, in Texas, we still anticipate 2023 running above the average. Yet since appreciation in home prices there has eased as well and now probably sits under the Homestead Exemption cap, we don't anticipate a repeat of the disproportionate treatment last year, if that's what you'd call it, toward properties not occupied by homeowners. But as I said, these represent solid leading indicators regarding the probable path of property taxes going forward. They simply aren't significant enough at this point to alter the character of this year's property tax growth, which is being held in place by those states with multi-year reassessments that look backward.
Juan Sanabria
analystHi there. Morning. I was hoping you might take a few minutes to discuss the Resident 360 program — what effect it could have on the operating cost expense guidance, plus what it means for G&A? And how should we view the return on those investments down the road?
David Singelyn
executiveMorning Juan, this is Dave. Let me walk through and sort of lay out what the Resident 360 program actually is, and then Chris may take over and cover some of the figures. To be specific, Resident 360 is an upgrade to the platform we have now; it's an upgrade to that platform focused on resident communications and on additional improvements and upgrades to how we deliver maintenance. At present, we take pride in being a leader in customer service and maintenance programs, which is shown by third-party surveys you've seen in some cases and by others we've commissioned. The ones we've commissioned also provide us with feedback about what residents want improved from residential, institutional landlords — whether single-family, whether American homes, whether multifamily. And that really centers on those two things: communications and maintenance delivery. So, we pay attention to our residents, and being a leader doesn't mean we can't get better. So, that's the initiative. What do we get from it? Well, similar to other investments we've made and that others make, there's somewhat of an investment window and then a window where you get the benefit. That benefit window will arrive — what we'll observe, and we know this since we piloted this program across 2022, is that we'll observe gains in customer satisfaction and, where we tested it, it produced stronger retention. That produces better turnover, or lower turnover cost. And we've also observed stronger execution in the maintenance platform, stronger execution, letting us perform more internal work, which — raises the quality of the work, but it also holds the cost down. So, there will be somewhat of an investment in 2023. Those benefits will begin to show up near the end of the year, but probably more significantly, in 2024. When it comes to the components of expenses, I'll hand it to Chris.
Christopher Lau
executiveRight, Juan — the main area where you'll notice spending going up during this year is going to be within the property management segment; as a point of reference, the guidance we've laid out includes roughly a 12% rise for property management this year, and that figure comes from a few separate factors. First, obviously, there's simply the broader inflationary backdrop. Second, we experienced somewhat limited staffing during the opening quarter of last year, which will create a somewhat unfavorable comparison on a year-over-year basis as we move through this year. After that, the remainder of this year is going to reflect the money we're putting into Resident 360.
Juan Sanabria
analystGreat, and then could I shift topics over to bad debt? It went up from one period to the next. You mentioned it near the beginning. I'm just wondering whether specific geographies, areas of the country, or customer types are driving that? And when do you expect we'll move beyond that COVID-related distortion, so to speak?
Christopher Lau
executiveYes. Juan, this is Chris once more. That's a good question. Let me begin, I'll provide a bit of context, and then Bryan likely can add a few more perspectives too. Broadly, we'd describe collections as still remaining robust. For the entire 2022 fiscal year, our bad debt came in at roughly the low 1% range, and that aligned quite closely with what we had anticipated when we put our guidance together. There's one piece that has unfolded a bit differently from how we first thought it would, and Bryan touched on this earlier. A modest group of our residents is requiring somewhat more time to get through their COVID-related situations, since certain court systems continue to operate at a slower pace than usual. On top of that, we've identified additional households that had seemed to be financially recovered once their rental assistance ended — something we were genuinely pleased to see — but regrettably, they turned out to be unable to remain stable over the long run without that support. That's what pushed our bad debt for the fourth quarter to roughly 1.4%. Since some of these final resolutions are taking a while, we've taken the conservative route for now and assumed that same 1.4% bad debt level will hold through 2023. We're hoping we can outperform that. But because parts of that timeline aren't ours to control, we wanted to begin the year with a cautious view on how much improvement we'd see.
Bryan Smith
executiveAnd Juan, it's Bryan here. Regarding the latter portion of what you asked, what we're observing is that this can really be split into two distinct groups among the affected accounts. First, certain procedural mandates in Washington are creating substantial holdups. That's likely where things are most concentrated. And second, like Chris said, there are simply fundamental backlogs, and in certain other states — Georgia and North Carolina, for instance — the process has been drawn out considerably. We're pushing through it as fast as we're able. My hope had been that we could get it — that by this point it would be settled, but we're still processing; and it's the state of Washington, not Washington, D.C., just to clarify.
Joshua Dennerlein
analystYeah, hi everyone. Appreciate you making the time. I suppose what I wanted to do was sort of check in on a few of the assumptions sitting underneath the same-store expense guidance. I was just hoping you could walk us through what you're anticipating for turnover across the portfolio? And then what sort of turnover cost is baked in there?
Christopher Lau
executiveYes. Morning Josh. This is Chris. Let me break down the individual pieces so everything is properly framed, and I'm certain Bryan will add his perspective on a few of the other assumptions we're working with. When it comes to the big building blocks of the expense guide, keep in mind, at the midpoint we're looking at 9% for property taxes, which we covered a few minutes back. After that, that brings you to roughly 10% to 11% on all the remaining items, and that's coming from a handful of important drivers. First, insurance is running around 20%. Our renewal for insurance is still being worked through and finalized. We aren't done with it just yet; but as everyone is aware; the market for property insurance is extremely difficult at the moment; and we want that reflected in what we expect for the year. Second, like I said a moment ago, 12% on property management. As I noted, that captures the pressure from inflation, the fact that we're lapping some of last year's understaffing shortfall from early in the year on a year-over-year basis, plus the money we've put into our Resident 360 program; and then increases of an inflationary nature on R&M and turn costs as well as HOAs in, let's say, the 7% area or thereabouts, and all of that lands you at a midpoint of 9.75%. But before Bryan offers any additional detail, I did want to remind everybody, as we consider expenses for 2023, keep in mind that since our Texas property taxes were under accrued during the first nine months of 2022, and those got trued up in last year's fourth quarter, our expense growth for 2023 will be uneven this year, with larger growth across the first nine months, which then settles back into our expected guidance range come the fourth quarter.
Bryan Smith
executiveAlso, Josh, when it comes to what we're anticipating for turnover expenses and turnover rates in 2023, our expectation is that occupancy will look a lot like it did in 2022. We have several initiatives underway that Dave brought up, plus some on the operational side, to try to see whether we can do better on that turnover rate. Even so, as we move forward, what we're expecting is something comparable to 2022 in that regard. As for turnover costs, we continue to face certain cost pressures when it comes to CapEx, and a few of those accounts tied to COVID may cost more to turn than the typical turns we see across the portfolio. So those factors are incorporated into our expectations too.
Joshua Dennerlein
analystI appreciate that. And maybe if we take a step back and look at this year, when I consider it, it appears that margins for the same-store pool are going to contract. Do you believe we've essentially reached peak margins? Or is there still more room to grow margins down the road throughout the portfolio?
David Singelyn
executiveYes. So, Sam, this is Dave. If you examine 2022 and 2023 along with margins, a reduction in a figure — a decent portion of that is due to timing, the timing of property taxes, since we've observed considerable increases in revenues and HPA in earlier years, and property taxes, as we're aware, is a lagging measurement tool. So, that's somewhat of a catchup mechanism. If you look at margins moving forward — well, and another thing I would mention regarding 2022 and 2023 is what you just raised, and what we've already discussed, which is the temporary adjustment to our expectations on bad debt. Going forward, I would anticipate bad debts to return in line with 2019 levels. The initiatives that we are starting today, in line with all other initiatives we have undertaken throughout our history, have involved a cost upfront and benefits afterward, whether it's been earlier enhancements in the early days of our operating platform, whether it is in our development program, there is an investment cost upfront. And then the benefits will accumulate to us in the future. So, I view our margins — what you are seeing in 2022 and 2023 — shouldn't be trended down for future years. I would expect that we will see going back to 2018, 2019, those trendlines from there, removing the COVID years being a much more consistent way of looking at life.
David Singelyn
executiveHey Sam. Are you there? Are you on mute?
Sam Choe
analystMy apologies. I had myself muted. Is my voice coming through at this point?
Christopher Lau
executiveIndeed, we hear you.
Sam Choe
analystAll right. My apologies for that. I have to commend the dedication your team shows toward technology, and Resident is essentially proof of it. I suppose that whenever you're mapping out tech projects, I recognize that your team takes a long view. So, with a situation such as 2023, when inflation was in the picture, I wonder, did any worries come up regarding launching Resident 360, since it costs quite a bit, despite all the enthusiasm about what it could achieve for the business? I'm simply curious whether the timing gave you any hesitation.
Bryan Smith
executiveHello Sam. Thanks. Bryan here. Our Resident 360 initiative truly reflects how we think for the long haul. And like Dave said before on this call, we piloted this program. We piloted it across markets. The results pleased us greatly; and waiting to introduce it nationwide wasn't something we wanted to do. The sooner we launch it, the sooner we can refine it and ensure those advantages begin appearing in expense control and retention; regarding technology, we possess a strong feedback loop inside our system, inside our company. We pay attention to what residents tell us, and we aim to align those needs and those requests with upgrades we can bring to our platform. And often, the chances sit in technical enhancements. One instance is the upgrades we're doing in the logistics program, which connect to the way we convey that to the resident, which connects to our communications initiative. So, we never stop innovating. That technology component matters greatly. Resident 360 directly answers what our residents want. So, waiting on it wasn't something we desired. There truly is no better moment to begin than right now.
Sam Choe
analystUnderstood. That's genuinely useful context. Then, examining the January figures you gave us, it really demonstrates quite a bit of resilience. When I consider the same-store revenue outlook, what sort of economic presumptions went into arriving at the top and bottom of that range?
Christopher Lau
executiveSam, this is Chris. Regarding what moves us toward the top versus the bottom of the range, well, I'd say — allow me to pull back a bit and restate and break down a few of the elements behind the revenue guidance. Bryan mentioned some of this, but for this year we anticipate average monthly realized rent rising roughly 6.5%. Keep in mind, that comes from last year's earn-in plus a partial-year effect of this year's leasing spreads, which on a full year basis we anticipate landing in the 5% to 6% zone. Then for occupancy, we foresee full year 2023 landing in the 97% zone, which remains extremely, extremely solid, only slightly under last year's 97.2%. That converts to rent revenue growth in the low 6% zone, and adding roughly 20 basis points of contribution from our expanding ancillary income programs plus about 40 basis points of bad debt drag that we discussed a few minutes back, that brings you to our midpoint of 6%. When I consider what could push us higher from there, well, 97% occupancy is quite full. That's quite near structurally full occupancy. So from our perspective, the upside opportunity sits in spreads, obviously, as we've discussed, uncertainty lies ahead this year. 2023 will differ from 2022. So we want to begin the year with a sensible degree of conservatism in what we expect, and acknowledge there will likely be some moderation this year, and ideally we can outperform where we're beginning the year. And should we encounter less moderation, that would obviously be a lever toward the upper end of the range. Then, as I mentioned a few minutes back too, we're adopting a cautious stance on bad debt. At the beginning of the year as well. So if we can push through some of those outstanding resolutions and outperform that roughly 1.4% that's baked into guidance at the start of the year, that would serve as an additional lever toward the upper end too.
Sam Choe
analystGot it. Thank you.
David Singelyn
executiveThanks Sam.
Steve Sakwa
analystSteve, thanks. I suppose, Bryan, might you discuss what you're anticipating for leasing spreads during this year — sort of a blend of new and renewal — and how that could move across the year? Then Dave, might you just clarify again that margin gain — are you indicating it will happen in 2024? Or might there still be cost pressures in the coming year that sort of prevent that margin from potentially getting better until 2025 and later?
Bryan Smith
executiveSteve, thank you. I'll begin with the rate part. What we expect for the entire year is that re-leasing spreads and renewal spreads will increase within a 5% to 6% range, quite near to moving together. January got off to a great start, and there we went beyond that. The guidance assumes some moderation as the year goes on; we'll keep pushing those rates as hard as we can, yet we're also taking a cautious stance given today's economic conditions. So, 5% to 6% for the year, with the blend of new and renewals staying consistent.
David Singelyn
executiveAbsolutely. And Steve, regarding your next question about the Resident 360 program, along with margins and cost pressures — from what the pilot program showed us, roughly 12 months is needed to roll the program out, train the people involved, and move past some of the duplication that inevitably arises when you launch initiatives like this. So my expectation is that benefits will perhaps begin to appear in Q4, though we would see them in 2024. As for 2024, I don't anticipate any material incremental cost tied to this program — possibly a small amount of trailing cost early in the year, depending on how quickly the rollout happens; however, judging by the pilot program, it took approximately 12 months before we started realizing or observing the initiative's benefits.
Steve Sakwa
analystAll right. One more item regarding CapEx, Chris — perhaps I overlooked it, but was there any discussion from you about what the figure for maintenance CapEx might be? I realize that number has been climbing for your company and for several competitors. So I'm curious what you're anticipating for maintenance CapEx during 2023.
Christopher Lau
executiveSure. That's a fair question, Steve. I'll offer my perspective, and Bryan is welcome to chime in with anything further; we didn't address it — as part of guidance. Broadly, though, inflation is what mainly drives CapEx. As we've mentioned previously, deploying our in-house workforce on maintenance and turn work delivers the greatest value, rather than doing whole-system replacement projects, which show up more heavily in CapEx — meaning that particular line item tends to be somewhat more exposed to inflationary pressure from third-party labor along with full material costs. That explains why 2022 landed in the 20% area; 2023 will likely look similar, since we still anticipate yet another year of significant inflation affecting third-party labor and materials. Even so, we're taking every step available to hold it steady and reduce the impact; Bryan may also have thoughts, especially as Resident 360 keeps rolling out, with growing emphasis on maintenance delivery capabilities and bandwidth. A possible upside in that regard involves handling a greater share of the CapEx side too.
David Singelyn
executiveSteve, Dave here. I want to tack on a few points. First, there's our asset management program, and that covers the deliveries from development. As you noticed, roughly 1,000 homes were sold by us during this year. A great many variables sit at the center of all of it. Still, one variable that comes out of your development program is holding your portfolio's average age lower. Keeping expenses and capital expenditures in check benefits from that too. Looking backward across roughly the past 5 years, our AFFO as a percent of FFO, I believe, has come in at 88%, 89%, remarkably steady each and every year; and with inflationary impacts hitting our CapEx, I would anticipate that being materially the same this year.
Haendel St. Juste
analystHello everyone, hope your morning is going well. A few fast questions from my end. Chris, during your discussion of possible uses of capital for this year, you brought up the preferreds, and I believe their yield sits above 6%. What's your thinking there? Is there any situation where you'd consider purchasing those during this year? Thanks.
Christopher Lau
executiveYes. That's a fair question, Haendel. Well, this is a matter we monitor quite carefully and one we kept an eye on all through the prior year; and indeed, your point is accurate. A few of our series are either callable now or will reach callability. It comes down purely to how the relative math works out against our present cost of capital. With the turbulence we're seeing in capital markets right now and the levels where new issuance is being priced, my sense is the odds are somewhat on the lower side that we'd call those in. Still, remember that this is among the best features of preferreds — they represent genuinely perpetual capital, carrying one-way optionality to redeem once we're beyond the call dates. So we'll monitor it carefully. That optionality remains in place; and once the right moment arrives in the market, measured against prevailing capital market pricing and the relevant considerations, we'll pursue the most favorable chance to retire those.
Haendel St. Juste
analystUnderstood. Understood. That's helpful. I had a follow-up question regarding development. You all referred to reduced lumber expenses, anticipated yield gains, and the schedule for later this year and next year. As of right now, what yield assumptions are you using for new starts, compared with that 6% bog you've referenced previously? Thank you.
David Singelyn
executiveYeah, so right now, whenever we're evaluating new acquisitions and new developments, you consider our current cost of capital. Therefore, our underwriting would fall in the high 6%s or 7% range. Remember, looking at 2022's fourth quarter, you'll notice we're remaining patient and disciplined — I think we bought a single lot or a single tract of land, I think it's 180 lots; the reason is that right now, with our underwriting, we require land cost, land development cost, and vertical costs to align. We've extended a great many land contracts. We've tried to renegotiate a great many land contracts. Clearly, we succeeded on one to bring it within an acceptable price range. Just to make these figures clear. So, this isn't something we anticipate. The land we're developing now that will be delivered in 2023 — that land was bought in earlier years, and the land development occurred in earlier years. Those costs are already spent. What we're observing in vertical costs for lumber is among the things you brought up, along with every other vertical cost. During the past few months, we've seen improvements, particularly relative to peak pricing from the second quarter. Lumber hit peak pricing in May. Lumber's price stood at $1,250. Currently, it sits in the low $400s per 1,000 board feet. As for the future, Random Lengths anticipates this will persist through the year. But development's mechanics mean it takes roughly a six-month — five to six-month period for vertical construction, yet you sign contracts for supplies, labor, and so forth beforehand. Consequently, it's roughly a six to nine-month period. Therefore, what we delivered during this year's fourth quarter would reflect peak pricing. That's the material contracted back in May of this year. What we'll observe as we move into 2023 is vertical cost benefits phasing in across the year. Land and land development costs are already locked in. Those occurred in earlier years. Thus, delivery this year won't land in the high 6%s, low 7%s, or 7%. Instead, they'll be 5.5%, scaling up to 6% across the year. Over time, they'll capture the advantage of vertical development pricing improvements, though incorporating those takes time. So the ones we deliver toward year-end will be considerably higher. Okay, one thing I want to clarify: we shouldn’t assume that the deliveries happening tomorrow are tied to what we’re underwriting right now. What we’re underwriting right now reflects the capital we’re using right now, and those will likely be delivered in 2025. And one final thing on your question, Haendel: for the deliveries we’re making now, the ones at 5.5% to 6%, that capital is already secured. So when we made those investment decisions, we raised that capital — at least the equity portion of it — so there’s some match funding that took place.
Adam Kramer
analystHey everyone, thanks for taking the question. I wanted to ask about where loss to lease currently stands — obviously, I realize it likely isn't anywhere near as strong as it was at certain moments during 2022. So I'm curious where it sits now? A related thing I'd like to know about, I suppose, is the sequential movement in market rents tied to new lease growth, whether that's the fourth quarter into January, or the fourth quarter into January and then into February — but given the usual seasonal effects, which I believe came back during the fourth quarter, what sequential patterns in market rent growth are you observing?
Bryan Smith
executiveHi Adam, thanks for asking. This is Bryan. Our estimate for loss to lease right now falls in the 5% to 6% bracket. As for what we expect on new lease growth, the year got off to a strong start for us. We're seeing — we had considerable pricing power, we're at full occupancy, and demand is great. My hope is that this keeps up. What we've built into our guide is a slowdown from the 7%s we began with, ending the first quarter on re-leasing at roughly 7%. After that, a gradual easing toward the latter half of the year; we'll try our hardest to keep pushing those new lease rates higher. I hope demand remains as robust as it is now. So I'd welcome outperforming that, but from a conservative standpoint, that's where expectations sit at the moment.
Adam Kramer
analystThanks, that's a big help. Bryan, appreciate it. I want to ask about the JV aspect of this. I realize you've broadened the relationship with JPMorgan in that group. But I'm curious, on the whole, about how much appetite or capacity there is to move even further along the JV route. Is that something you're considering exploring? Do opportunities exist there, or is it perhaps not as much?
Christopher Lau
executiveYes. Adam, this is Chris. The short answer is yes. Opportunities are plentiful. But allow me to pull back and speak from a more strategic, higher-level perspective. As we've told you on many occasions, when the right opportunities are attractive and accretive, our priority is to push as much growth onto the balance sheet as we can; that said, we also think having a blend of joint venture capital matters a great deal strategically, since it gives us another way to apply our platform and fixed costs across a bigger asset base while earning fees as compensation. Through our promoted interests, JVs open up truly distinctive chances for appealing longer-term economics. And, crucially, when public capital markets are uncertain and volatile, as they are at present, they offer a strategic route to high-quality, long-term capital — which is precisely the thinking and approach behind the recent deal to upsize our joint venture with JPMorgan Asset Management, which, as a reminder, delivers close to $300 million in added JV capital capacity, letting us stay opportunistic on incremental land and development opportunities that may not make sense at the moment given our current on-balance sheet cost of capital.
Adam Kramer
analystI appreciate you making room for us. Thank you, Chris.
Christopher Lau
executiveThank you as well, Adam.
Keegan Carl
analystAppreciate you making room for us. I realize this came up briefly already, but with the busiest leasing period upon us, I'm just wondering how demand stacks up against both the prior year and the pre-pandemic baseline. You mentioned web traffic and tours, but perhaps you could speak to where applications stand and how those figures look versus earlier periods?
Bryan Smith
executiveThanks, Keegan. We examined the year-to-date picture, and I brought this up during the prepared remarks — one of our key metrics is check-ins per rent ready; these represent individual shoppers touring our homes; and as I noted, that figure rose roughly 20% measured against a rolling historical average. That's one piece of it; then converting those check-ins into applications is the following step. So, thus far this year, application activity and leasing activity have been outstanding. We're quite happy with how it began and carried through February; we've seen solid absorption of homes in the portfolio. I'm hopeful that this will keep going. And should it do so, we'll enjoy strong pricing power heading into the spring leasing season. Something I'd anticipate seeing this year possibly is a shift back toward a more typical pattern in which, during peak leasing season, we're able to raise re-leasing rates; and then in the first and fourth quarter of the year, you tend to find greater strength perhaps on the renewal side, just to align with how things historically appeared. But as things stand at present, demand remains very strong across every metric. The new website has made navigation simpler, particularly on mobile. So, we're receiving very favorable feedback from our prospects on that front; they're arriving at the website and remaining there longer and reaching the pertinent check-in and application pages faster than they managed to under the previous website. So, that's been quite encouraging. And we're going to hope to keep seeing those advantages as we move into the busier season.
David Singelyn
executiveDave here, Keegan. I’d like to add a few thoughts that are perhaps more macro regarding the marketplace. As of today, nothing is different versus earlier periods: there are still a great many households seeking high-quality housing in this country, and supply remains insufficient. That said, a few developments have occurred. First, among homebuilders, the speed and rate at which they were putting up new homes has decelerated; as a result, the capacity to satisfy that demand has diminished somewhat too. Second, consider the affordability of a newly built house — the mortgage, plus the other ancillary expenses tied to owning a home — compared with what a rental costs. For a long stretch, those two were roughly at equilibrium. Now, based on some figures available, chiefly the John Burns data we have reviewed, you will find renting is substantially more affordable at present. Specifically, it is greater than 20% more affordable, a very, very major shift relative to where we stood. All of this is creating considerable — maintain considerable demand for rental product in the marketplace; bear in mind, we are also in volatile and uncertain times, with some pricing pressures on households, yet the demand exists. Therefore, it falls to us simply to seize that demand.
Keegan Carl
analystSo, switching topics now. I realize it feels like this comes up on every single call, but there appears to be an increasing amount of discussion regarding regulation in the single-family rental sector, with the latest example being North Carolina. I'm just wondering how you all are approaching not only the wider regulatory landscape, but perhaps also on a state-by-state level, and how that shapes the choices you make?
David Singelyn
executiveYeah. Well, Kean, I believe you're likely correct that there is a bit more awareness, at minimum, regarding the political dimension. And I'd say North Carolina is among those states, though it isn't the sole one; we're seeing this in Georgia. We're seeing it in California. We're seeing it in Washington state. We've taken a very proactive stance on the government affairs front; we launched roughly 18 months ago a government affairs division. We have government affairs personnel among our team; we dedicate time at the executive level to speak with government officials across federal, state, and local levels; and when you examine much of the rhetoric that has emerged from government officials or even in newspapers, you'll notice that we might be mentioned in the piece as another participant in the single-family rental business, yet not a great deal has been aimed at us specifically. And that truly stems from maintaining those solid relationships out there. So, we will keep pursuing and holding those conversations annually. A portion of Resident 360 will tackle some of that too, not the main emphasis, but perhaps a secondary, ancillary advantage of that initiative. So yeah, at least the rhetoric exists. At the federal level, that's the most prominent, it's more spectacle than at local levels where it's more actual action; so yeah, we possess a ground operation as well as being highly concentrated at the federal level too.
Alan Peterson
analystHey everybody, I appreciate you making the time. Chris, could you walk us through how the appeals process works, given those assessments that came in late last year? At this point, when we look at your current expense guidance, is it built on the assumption that you come out ahead on any of the appeals you've got going right now?
Christopher Lau
executiveYeah. Alan, Chris, that's a great question. This is something we've discussed for years. Across the entire country, when it comes to property tax values, we're one of the most aggressive filers of appeals, if not the most aggressive. Every single year, we are extremely active on that front. A few things to update you on. During last year, the count of individual property tax value appeals we filed came in somewhere between 12,000 and 13,000 and 14,000. It turned out to be a fairly strong year for us. My recollection is that roughly 70% of the time we succeeded last year. On the appeals we did win, we realized a value reduction in the range of 4% to 5%. Rolling out of last year and into this one, there remain what I'd describe as a couple of hundred or so appeals that haven't closed yet. Where those will end up, I believe we have a reasonably solid sense. And for the most part, our actuals already reflect all of it. Then, as we move toward 2023, leaning into the appeals machine again is definitely our expectation. With any luck, we'll post another year of solid results on that front. As for how we treat it in guidance, it's the same as in any other year. At the start of every year, we begin from a conservative expectation, or a conservative read, of how likely success is. Ending up on the wrong side of that is not something we want. So, as I mentioned, a conservative estimate is baked into 2023. It would be great if we outperform that. That said, word on it typically doesn't come our way until the back half of the year, so updates will have to come as the process moves along.
Alan Peterson
analystThanks for that. Let me pick up where you left off on Adam's question about the development pipeline. Jack said a couple of years back that the development program might scale up to 3,000 or 4,000 new deliveries each year. Is the guidance right now 2,300 homes? Is that a capital allocation issue at this point? Or do other factors hold back your capacity to grow construction toward that new delivery target?
David Singelyn
executiveYes, good question. Several factors are at play. To start, 3,000 to 4,000 homes is quite achievable when you look at infrastructure and demand. As for actually carrying out those deliveries, what we've seen across the last three years is a slowdown during the COVID period in getting inspectors out and in securing permits at the municipal level for horizontal or land delivery, or the land development process. You have to develop the land before you can put up vertical buildings. So we've fallen a bit behind on the 2023 to 2024 delivery plan, and the cause isn't what's occurring in 2023 and 2024 but what occurred in 2020, 2021 and 2022 regarding land development and completing those inspections. Moving into 2025. Again, this isn't really COVID — it's more the economic and interest rate shifts we witnessed in late 2022, which has slowed our land acquisition pipeline. We'll grow in a disciplined, controlled manner. We can wait if we must. There's no need to grow merely to add numbers to an infrastructure line; so in 2022, as I said earlier, we acquired only one parcel in the fourth quarter, given the pricing and what we're seeing in the shifting environment. So what we're going through now is likely one of the biggest economic adjustments over a short span. To me, that doesn't speak to long-term viability or long-term benefits. It's a short-term effect. But in development, short-term means multiple years, not one day, one month or even one year. And so, I believe the opportunity exists. I know the opportunity exists to reach 3,000 and 4,000 homes and perhaps even a bit beyond. In the near term, a few things have come up along the way.
Brad Heffern
analystOkay, thank you. So what's the situation on supply when it comes to build-to-rent? And as things stand right now, are you noticing more competition, whether that shows up as more listings or through other metrics you monitor?
David Singelyn
executiveSure. Regarding construction of build-to-rent specifically, the count of parties interested in pursuing build-to-rent is clearly declining, and that includes certain national builders who had been moving into build-to-rent and have eased off somewhat. A great deal of build-to-rent activity came from private equity, involving smaller efforts in which just one or two projects would be undertaken. For one thing, I believe their early assumptions were somewhat too hopeful; beyond that, there's the matter of the economics we've discussed and already addressed. Meanwhile, we enjoy economies of scale. We receive vendor rebates, and so on. Our position differs from theirs, and they took a hit; as a result, they've pulled back. We've observed that slowdown on their end. Some of those engaged in build-to-rent have approached us asking whether we'd be interested in partnering on or buying those build-to-rent projects, sometimes while they're still underway. That opportunity exists, provided we can land on a price that makes it appealing for us. And then, my apologies, the other — I believe your question had another component that's slipped my mind.
Brad Heffern
analystYeah. Regarding supply at present, are you noticing signs such as a rise in listings that might indicate the competition has gotten fiercer at this moment?
David Singelyn
executiveWell, when I hear a rise in listings, Brad, my mind goes to the market; and in the MLS market, what we're not seeing — compared with a couple of months back, listings have gone up; however, those listings remain below the levels that are normal historically. What I believe you're observing is that right now, quite a few individuals and households over the past couple of years obtained extremely advantageous mortgage notes — loans, perhaps around 2%. Consequently, when it comes to their ability to relocate, a homeowner wanting to move and put their home on the list has faced difficulties. As a result, there's reduced inventory available in the market at this time. Prices are still somewhat elevated beyond what would align with our yield and investment goals; yet we are noticing some downward shift in those prices, though they still have a distance to travel before becoming viable opportunities for us.
Brad Heffern
analystOkay. Thank you.
David Singelyn
executiveThanks Brad.
Linda Tsai
analystHello. When you say renting is 20% more affordable than owning, how much does that differ from one market to another?
David Singelyn
executiveIt absolutely differs from one market to another. The 20% figure we cite is in fact slightly above that. As I recall, across our top 20 markets, the average comes to 24%, though clearly there is variation. Every one of them is more affordable, yet they do differ. And I don't have the range in front of me, Linda.
Linda Tsai
analystUnderstood. So how many of the people living in your properties have two incomes? Also, given where things stand right now, might you make your credit criteria stricter?
Bryan Smith
executiveLinda, dual-income households make up most of our residents — the precise figure I can't give you, but it's well above 50%. As for making credit requirements stricter, our collections have us quite happy, particularly if you set aside those residents affected by COVID, since they match up with what we've historically seen. Because of that, I don't expect we'd make any tweaks on that front. Those who moved in during the past 2 years are paying, and their bad debt lines up very closely with what we observed before COVID. So no changes strike me as needed there.
Linda Tsai
analystThank you; and finally, regarding those new lease rates being pushed, what occupancy level would you ideally want, given that you're sitting at 97%?
Bryan Smith
executiveFor how we're turning homes and how quickly we can get them re-leased, 97% strikes us as quite healthy; demand lines up with it in our view, and that level feels comfortable. As a reminder on terms as well, we consider the revenue line as a whole. Our management approach aims at maximum revenue overall, and rate versus occupancy involves some give and take; still, for this year, 97% occupancy seems like a solid goal for us.
Austin Wurschmidt
analystThanks, and hello everybody. Compared with the prior year, our development blend this year leans considerably more heavily on projects we own entirely — that's a fairly significant shift, along with a larger jump in the capital we're putting up. That said, should the capital markets remain choppy and your cost of capital fall short of your target, my guess is you probably won't enjoy the upside of drawing on equity proceeds, which luckily worked out for you a year ago; so going forward, how are you approaching funding so that your portion of development funding commitments keeps climbing in the years ahead, bringing you nearer to that goal of 3,000 to 5,000 homes you referenced earlier?
Christopher Lau
executiveYes, good morning Austin, this is Chris. Great question. This is an area I really enjoy discussing. There are a few things worth noting. First, part of the story involves why we decided to grow our joint venture alongside JPMorgan Asset Management, adding more JV capital capacity so we can stay ready to seize new land and development chances as they come up. At the same time, when we look at the pipeline we own outright today, as we've discussed on many occasions, we deliberately built it to a size we can finance without issuing equity. When you look at how the pipeline we already own will be developed over this year, the next one, and beyond, the money for constructing on properties already in our portfolio can come from a few places: cash the business keeps, some capital we recycle by selling assets, and a limited amount of borrowing against our balance sheet. Once again, we don't have to issue stock to complete everything in the wholly-owned pipeline currently on our books. As for growth beyond that, we'll weigh it against where our cost of capital stands at the time and seek the appropriate funding source, whether that's our own balance sheet or through joint ventures.
Austin Wurschmidt
analystThat's useful, Chris. Then, Dave, you brought up cap rates sitting in the mid-5% range, or 50 basis points within the point where they start looking more appealing to you. Still, I'm simply wondering who the busiest purchasers are right now at that mid-5% mark, whether you're noticing any deals being re-traded, and what you believe would need to shift to move pricing your way. Since at present, I believe you're on a spot basis at or slightly within that mid-5% mark, but yes, I'm just wondering what your thinking is there. Thanks.
David Singelyn
executiveRight; so, the real institutional-level purchasers these days have largely moved to the sidelines, most of them — a handful of private SFR firms have begun buying again at a much lower volume than what they used to acquire. Regarding pricing, we're finally beginning to see some of it decline. Asset values are declining; now, that's a curious thing to say, given how unpredictable this market is. We've also observed that pricing for national builder programs has been declining. Then, over the past week or two, it appears they've either leveled off, stayed flat, or possibly even reversed direction. So it keeps fluctuating; this is when patience matters; this is when you must keep underwriting — across every one of our markets. This is a diversified portfolio, given how many markets we operate in. Being in over 30 markets provides us with far more opportunity. Yet we don't have to push ourselves to buy; therefore, we must remain patient, and we must stay disciplined. Those opportunities are nearer now than during our prior call, 30 or 90 days back, or perhaps slightly longer than that, yet they still aren't available. Plus, the cost of capital is another factor that isn't steady either. It fluctuates and shifts constantly too. So you have to keep aligning the two and weigh them against each other each month; we're nearer, but we aren't that near right now.
Daniel Tricarico
analystThanks. Good afternoon. I've got a question about the development platform, picking up where Haendel left off. So your guidance points to roughly 1,850 wholly-owned deliveries this year at an average of 350,000 per home. That rests on the $650 million capital investment guidance. Dave, how much of that vertical cost softening you brought up does that number imply compared with what's being delivered right now?
David Singelyn
executiveYes; so with what's delivered right now — and by right now I mean the fourth quarter — wrong — the vertical — the total cost on those deliveries comes to roughly $350,000, and roughly $250,000 of that sits in vertical. I can't give you the exact specific figures, but that's directionally correct. On the vertical cost reductions from peak, what we're seeing today is we're probably at that 10% to 15% on vertical alone, and we expect to reach maybe 20%. But bear in mind, that doesn't mean a 20% reduction is what you'll see, because two things have to be factored in. You have to factor in that there's land and land development. So you're going to see about 20 — I'm sorry, about $40,000 of benefit coming through; we already are seeing, in our acquisition of lumber today, about $17,000 to $18,000 of benefit just on the lumber line compared with what we were contracting nine months ago; and then on other lines across the entire development platform, we have some savings now, and we expect more savings in a number of those lines. Overall, we'll expect to probably see a 10% reduction on home costs between the fourth quarter of last year and what we deliver in the fourth quarter of next year. As long as you comp — and make sure you're looking at comparable markets. So market mix will have an impact. Land costs more in the West than in the Southeast; and so as long as we look at it market-by-market rather than at the average of our entire company, it's about — going to be about a 10% reduction fourth quarter to fourth quarter.
Analyst
analystThat's genuinely useful, Dave. Thanks. Chris, one short follow-up from me. What amount of rental assistance came in during the prior year? And I suppose, what remains, if there's anything at all, for 2023?
Christopher Lau
executiveIt is certainly winding down over the prior year — let me run a bit of fast arithmetic here — let's see, a live figure, roughly $16 million to $18 million for that prior year, and that has declined from, say, $5 million to $6 million each quarter during the first half of the prior year, falling to, I believe, around $3 million in the fourth quarter. It's tough to say precisely how far it will shrink as we move into the first couple of quarters of 2023; my expectation is that we'll keep getting a portion, though it will slope downward as the year goes on.
Daniel Tricarico
analystGreat. Thank you.
Christopher Lau
executiveThanks Dan.
David Singelyn
executiveAppreciate it, operator. Thanks to everyone for the attention you've shown this quarter — it's been a bit of a marathon call on our end; we'll talk with you again in the next quarter. Have a wonderful day. Take care. Bye, bye.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call. At this point, you're free to hang up. We appreciate you joining us.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete American Homes 4 Rent transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to American Homes 4 Rent earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in American Homes 4 Rent or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.