American Homes 4 Rent (AMH) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 23, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Residential REITs earnings 68 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Nick Fromm

executive
#1

Hello, everyone, and welcome to the conference call covering our earnings for the fourth quarter of 2023. Joining me on this call are David Singelyn, who serves as Chief Executive Officer; Bryan Smith, our Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Lau, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements may be part of this call. Any statements made during this conference call that are not statements of historical fact qualify as forward-looking statements, and they carry a number of risks and uncertainties that might lead actual results to differ materially from what those statements project. Details about these risks and other factors that could negatively impact our business and future results appear in our press releases and in the filings we make with the SEC. Every forward-looking statement is made only as of today, February 23, 2024; we take on no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statement, whether because of new information, future events or otherwise, except as the law requires. A reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP financial measures can be found in our earnings release and supplemental information package. Also, please note that our operating and financial results, including GAAP and non-GAAP measures, are fully detailed in our earnings release and supplemental information package. These documents, along with SEC reports and the audio webcast replay of this conference call, are available on our website at www.amh.com. With that, I'll hand the call over to our CEO, David Singelyn.

Dave Singelyn

executive
#2

Thanks, Nick. Morning, everybody, and thanks for being with us today. You probably saw last night's press release — I stated my plan to step down when this year ends. Leading this organization for 12 years has been an honor. I couldn't be prouder of the leadership group now in place, who are prepared to assume control. I'd like to congratulate Bryan Smith, our Chief Operating Officer, who is slated to become our next Chief Executive Officer when I retire. Bryan brings talent and experience and has propelled our business strategy and operations right from the start. In addition, we've promoted Chris Lau into the position of Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. With such a highly capable management team, I'm confident AMH is ready to grab the opportunities that lie ahead. I'll make a few quick remarks now, then hand things over to Bryan and Chris. At AMH, 2023 represented yet another year of resilient and durable growth. Across the full year, core FFO per share rose almost 8%, powered by lasting long-term rental demand, excellent operational execution backed by our strategic initiatives, and steady output from our development program. Both the single-family rental sector and the AMH platform kept gaining from supply-demand imbalances. The nationwide housing shortage, caused by a constrained supply of homes available for purchase on the open market, has produced difficult home affordability conditions for buyers. AMH is contributing to fixing this housing shortage. We're bringing new supply to market and providing high-quality assets and appealing family-friendly locations at a substantial discount to what ownership costs. We're positioned well to produce steady results for many years ahead. Turning to growth, our main channel is homes we develop internally that are well situated, high quality, and carry better maintenance CapEx profiles than our legacy portfolio. Holding complete control over the growth program lets us raise or lower our delivery pace in particular markets so we can properly manage our capital plan. Given our present cost of capital, our traditional and national builder acquisition channels remain mostly paused. Once those acquisition opportunities turn more attractive, we'll be prepared to move quickly to capitalize and complement our in-house development deliveries. Although the acquisition and capital market environments don't support accretive growth through the MLS or national builder channels, this continues to be an excellent moment to lean into dispositions. The single-family rental asset class has a distinctive capacity to be managed on an asset-by-asset level, which gives us the ability to recycle capital at appealing economics. On a personal level, leaving AMH is bittersweet, since I cofounded the company and helped build the SFR industry and team from top to bottom. I take pride that AMH is positioned well to keep up our success in delivering high-quality housing to our residents and superior returns to our investors. Over the coming 10 months, I'll be seeing a lot of you; still, once I step away from my role, I know I'll feel the absence of the colleagues I've worked alongside both inside and beyond the AMH community. For the connections that have come into being, my gratitude will never fade. With that, I'll hand things over to Bryan, who will share news about how our operations are doing.

Bryan Smith

executive
#3

I appreciate that, Dave. Taking on the role of AMH's next CEO is something I'm genuinely thrilled about. Dave, Chris, and I are going to collaborate over the coming 10 months to make sure the handover happens smoothly and without disruption. There's no change to our strategy — stability, consistency, and predictability stay at its core. On a more personal level, I'd like to offer Dave my congratulations on his upcoming retirement. Dave, I'm grateful for the way you've led, the guidance you've given me, and your friendship. It means a lot to me to step into the role you've held. At AMH, 2023 was yet another excellent year, defined by solid execution across our teams and seasonality coming back in full. As we get ready for the spring leasing season, demand is still robust. And while certain metrics have come back to normal levels, we keep seeing gains in important areas — website traffic, for instance, rose 11% year-over-year during the fourth quarter. Now to the fourth quarter operating results. Same-Home average occupied days came in at 96.2%, which reflects typical seasonal patterns along with somewhat higher turnover. Strong fourth quarter growth in new, renewal, and blended rates — 4.5%, 6.2%, and 5.7%, respectively — offset this slight occupancy decrease. Together, these factors produced 5.5% Same-Home core revenue growth in the quarter, landing at the midpoint of our full year revenue guidance of 6.5%. Now for expenses. Core operating expense growth in the fourth quarter reached 4.5%, largely because of negative property tax growth tied to a true-up during the same period a year earlier. Across the full year, core operating expense growth came to 9.1%, a bit under the midpoint of what we had expected, thanks to controllable expenses performing better than anticipated. The upshot was Same-Home core NOI growth of 6% for the fourth quarter and 5.1% for the full year. Now let's look at our 2024 outlook. We're entering spring leasing season with a steady start; during January, Same-Home average occupied days reached 96%, while new and renewal spreads came in at 4.3% and 5.7%, respectively. That produced blended rate growth of 5.3% for the month. For the full year, our Same-Home core revenue growth outlook sits at 4.75% at the midpoint. The main driver is projected growth in average monthly realized rent of 5% to 5.5%, which consists of an earn-in of roughly 3% from leasing activity last year plus the partial year contribution from an expected 2024 spread in the high 4% area; when it comes to occupancy, we anticipate that sector demand drivers will keep occupancy levels sustained in the low 96% area, still above our long-term average. Turning to core property operating expenses, our 2024 Same-Home expense growth outlook of 6.25% at the midpoint reflects one more year of elevated property taxes and inflationary pressures particular to our business. Chris will walk through the expense components in more detail shortly, but I want to stress that expenses overall are continuing to moderate, and our teams deserve credit for doing a great job holding controllable expenses in check. If we use the midpoints from our guidance for Same-Home revenue and core operating expenses, then Same-Home core NOI growth for 2024 should come in at 4%. To wrap up, I feel really good about where we stand as we begin this year. Our attention will stay on running the core operationally, on staying dedicated to delivering the strongest resident experience we can, and on growing responsibly through the investment programs we have. With that, I'll hand things over to Chris.

Chris Lau

executive
#4

Thank you, Bryan, and good morning to all of you. Prior to diving into my usual updates, I'd like to express my gratitude to Dave. Dave, I truly value the vision and mentorship you've provided over many years, and I'm eager to help continue the AMH legacy. I also want to congratulate Bryan, and I'm excited about the next chapter ahead of us. Now, returning to my standard updates, there are 3 topics I'll address this morning. First, a quick recap of our year-end results; second, a status report on our balance sheet along with recent capital markets activity; and third, I'll wrap up with a look at our 2024 guidance. Starting with operating results, we finished 2023 with yet another quarter of steady execution, posting net income attributable to common shareholders of $76.6 million, or $0.21 per diluted share, along with $0.43 of core FFO per share and unit, which marks 8.8% growth compared to the prior year; and across all of 2023, net income attributable to common shareholders came to $366.2 million, or $1.01 per diluted share, plus $1.66 of core FFO per share and unit, landing at the top end of the 2023 guidance range we most recently provided. On the investment side, we delivered 503 total homes from our AMH Development program during the quarter. That figure breaks down into 456 homes delivered to our wholly owned portfolio and 47 homes delivered to our joint venture portfolio; for the full year, we delivered 2,317 AMH development properties in total, which came in modestly above the midpoint of what we had expected. Beyond development, our traditional and national builder acquisition programs are still largely paused, with only 25 homes acquired in the quarter; regarding dispositions, we enjoyed another quarter of strong activity, selling 241 homes at an average disposition cap rate in the mid-3% area and bringing in $72.5 million of net proceeds. Now I'd like to shift to our balance sheet and recent capital activity. As of year-end, our net debt, including preferred shares, to adjusted EBITDA stood at 5.4x. We held $59 million of cash on the balance sheet, and against our $1.25 billion revolving credit facility, we had a $90 million drawn balance. What's more, during the fourth quarter and into early January, we sold roughly 3.7 million Class A common shares through our ATM program at an average sales price of $36.36. Those sales brought in total net proceeds of approximately $133 million, which will go toward funding part of our 2024 capital plan that I'll discuss further in a couple of minutes. Also, last month, we seized an appealing market window and were proud to become the first single-family rental REIT to issue unsecured green bonds; beyond serving as a significant capital raise, this green bond issuance underscores our dedication to responsible business practices and sustainable building standards. On the execution side, investor demand meant the deal was considerably oversubscribed, and that let us achieve appealing terms — a 5.5% all-in interest rate — while increasing the size to $600 million, the proceeds of which will fund part of our 2024 capital plan. I want to thank the team for getting this done and for helping us reach yet another milestone for the industry. Now I'd like to walk through a summary of what we're initially guiding for 2024. Across the full year 2024, our expectation for core FFO per share and unit is $1.70 to $1.76, and the midpoint of that range works out to 4.2% growth versus the prior year; on the Same-Home portfolio side, at the midpoint, what we're contemplating is core revenue growth of 4.75%, which Bryan covered a few minutes back, together with core property operating expense growth of 6.25%, with property taxes climbing in the low 7% area, which, as anticipated, is starting to show moderation relative to the past few years; plus 5.25% growth across all other expenses, which mirrors the broader inflationary backdrop; and insurance expense growth in the high single digits, reflecting a renewal campaign that succeeded and takes effect at the conclusion of this month. In assembling our Same-Home portfolio revenue and expense growth assumptions, we're looking for 2024 Same-Home core NOI growth of 4% at the midpoint. On the investment side, as we said last quarter, with capital markets behaving as they currently are, growing responsibly and under control stays a leading priority for 2024. Keeping that in mind, we've deliberately calibrated our 2024 investment programs so they stay in line with last year, and we anticipate deploying total capital of between $1.1 billion and $1.3 billion during 2024, which adds between 2,200 and 2,400 newly built AMH Development homes across our wholly owned and joint venture portfolios. To be specific about the wholly owned portfolio, at the midpoint of our ranges, we anticipate investing roughly $1 billion of AMH capital, made up of $750 million, or 1,900 homes, added through our development program, plus $250 million of combined investment in our wholly owned development pipeline, our pro rata share of JV investments, and property enhancing CapEx programs. Separately, as we mentioned last year, there are 2 legacy securitization loans coming due in the fourth quarter of this year. As a reminder, those 2 securitizations carry a combined principal balance of roughly $940 million, an average interest rate of 4.4%, and can now be prepaid freely with no penalty. Following the success of our January green bond offering, we recently issued notice to retire one of our upcoming maturities by the close of the first quarter. Beyond responsibly handling part of this year's maturity schedule, that payoff will free up roughly 4,500 properties, which our asset management and disposition teams can now review in full. As for the remaining 2024 maturity, we plan to watch the market opportunistically for refinancing windows and have built a midyear payoff into guidance. That being said, patience is something we can afford, and should it become necessary, we are in a position to comfortably cover what remains of our 2024 maturity by drawing on our $1.25 billion revolving credit facility. When we look at the capital plan as a whole, and factor in both our investment programs and securitization maturities, our expectation is that total 2024 AMH capital needs will come to roughly $1.9 billion, which we intend to fund from a mix of sources: retained cash flow; somewhere between approximately $400 million and $500 million in recycled capital generated by dispositions; equity capital, which includes the roughly $130 million in net proceeds from the ATM equity I mentioned earlier; $600 million raised through last month's green bond issuance; and approximately $500 million in further capital we intend to raise via the unsecured bond market during 2024, or else warehouse on our revolving credit facility should that be required. Last of all, as was also announced this week, in light of continuing growth in both our business and our taxable income, our Board of trustees gave recent approval to an 18% bump in our quarterly distribution, bringing it to $0.26 per share. It goes without saying that this stands as one more testament to how strong and consistent our platform is, as we keep creating value for our shareholders into this next chapter for AMH; and with that, I thank you once more for your time, and we'll now open the call to your questions. Operator?

Juan Sanabria

analyst
#5

I'm just wondering whether you might share some thoughts on what leasing trends you've baked into the 2024 guidance. Looking back over history, Q4 usually comes in somewhat under the average for the year that follows, because of seasonality. So I'm wondering about the pluses and minuses you've built in as the year begins within your full-year outlook for 2024.

Bryan Smith

executive
#6

Juan, it's Bryan. Thanks for asking. Like we've said previously, what we aimed for as we came out of '23 was to hold a strong occupancy position, carrying solid momentum into January so we could take advantage of the really growing demand that normally shows up from late January through February. The start of the year is unfolding mostly the way we anticipated. We've witnessed strong acceleration as February arrived, and we reported solid rate growth figures for January, with a modest step up, I believe, coming in February. For the whole year, though, we expect new lease rate growth to land in the low 4s, while renewal rate growth should be around the 5% mark, combining to a high 4 for 2024.

Juan Sanabria

analyst
#7

Great. And then perhaps you could just discuss bad debt a bit. How much of the COVID noncompliant remains? And what was the run rate before COVID, just to gauge any possible conservatism in the bad debt assumptions built into guidance for '24?

Chris Lau

executive
#8

Yes, sure. Juan, this is Chris. Let me begin, and then Bryan can add other details if that would help. But stepping back, I'd say bad debt is really still tracking quite consistent with what we expected. Q4 serves as a solid example, since it landed in the same low-1% range once more. As we've mentioned previously on these calls, our collections and the processes behind them have essentially returned to normal — the one exception being that various cities and court systems nationwide continue to operate at a somewhat slower pace than they traditionally have. That factor is what holds bad debt slightly above our long-term run rate of roughly 80 to 100 basis points. Beyond that, honestly, we haven't observed much movement on the local court system front since the last time we updated you. Because that's entirely beyond our control, we simply aren't able to rely on it in guidance at this stage. Consequently, when we look ahead for this year, we're assuming bad debt will stay around the low 1% range. That said, we'd be happy if that turned out to be too pessimistic and we ended up getting some favorable movement on bad debt during the year—we simply can't bank on it. To give you some numbers for perspective, if bad debt were to come back to typical levels across a full calendar year, you'd be looking at roughly 30 to 40 basis points more in Same-Home revenue contribution.

Bryan Smith

executive
#9

So Juan, to address what you asked about those COVID-era residents who remain in our properties: we've achieved quite strong results when it comes to resolving that delinquency. A small portion is still outstanding, and my sense is that it's concentrated in a few specific markets. Seattle is one that stands out, along with certain sections of Atlanta. That said, it genuinely comes down to the individual local governments and the courts in those places.

Jeff Spector

analyst
#10

To start, congratulations to Dave and Bryan. For my first question, could we turn our attention to the January update? In comparison with your peer, the new rate you recorded in January was significantly stronger. Could you elaborate on that a bit further? Is it confined to particular markets? For instance, what exactly are you observing? What might you tell us?

Bryan Smith

executive
#11

Certainly. Thanks, Jeff; Bryan here. Our strategy for pricing, and for how we oversee the whole revenue line, is quite balanced. January's results make us very happy. As I mentioned, a really strong rebound in demand was what we anticipated. A portion of the seasonality we experienced in Q4 carried over into the start of January. Even so, we still managed to report some very solid new lease rate growth. And no single market accounts for it. Part of this reflects our diversified portfolio, which is showing fairly strong performance compared with, I believe, certain other figures from other residential peers; it demonstrates fairly strong performance across the board.

Jeff Spector

analyst
#12

Perhaps this one's for Dave. Dave, if you could — maybe discuss an initiative or something that makes you proudest and that you're eager to really concentrate on during the months ahead, before you formally retire, that perhaps investors aren't fully valuing?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#13

Well, to start, Jeff, I appreciate your nice remarks at the outset. When I reflect on the past decade, it's been extremely, extremely fulfilling to look back and witness what's been achieved in creating a company, creating an industry. Yet I believe ultimately, the — likely the greatest achievement and the greatest payoff is the team you assemble, the individuals surrounding you, having time and observing their development and being able to guide them and watch them thrive. And stepping down isn't simple. It is — and I'm not sure there's a correct moment. It's — you always wish to keep doing what you're doing. You can't truly step away when things aren't going well; but this simply appears to be the correct moment. We've devoted a lot of effort to ensuring we place the right people in the right roles; we've discussed, far more internally than externally, probably, our succession initiatives, and that truly is leadership development at every level across the organization; and today appears to be the correct moment. We are very, very well positioned. I mean we — our growth potential ahead or the steadiness of this company, everything is functioning extremely, extremely well; and the team is — I mean, Bryan is prepared and Chris is prepared. It's simply the correct moment. And so — and look, I've been doing what I've been doing for a very long stretch. 12 years, 13 years here. Prior to this, I ran, was the CEO of a publicly traded company up in Canada for 10 years. So it's simply the correct moment, Jeff. So I appreciate your remarks.

Steve Sakwa

analyst
#14

Congrats once more, Dave and Bryan. I'd like to know if you could share any February figures? I understand we're not at month's end yet, but I'm just attempting to get a sense of the new and the renewals. Bryan, I believe you mentioned around 5% on renewals for the year. Clearly, Q1 has begun well. And I'm unsure what that suggests as an exit rate. I'm just attempting to work out your degree of conservatism when it comes to pricing.

Bryan Smith

executive
#15

Sure. Thanks, Steve. Like I mentioned previously, demand accelerated quite nicely late in January, and that has carried over into February. There's somewhat of a delay before that shows up in new leases, but February has started tremendously well. My expectation is that new and renewal leases will be slightly stronger on rate growth than January. And the impact of that stronger demand will likely become clearer in the March occupancy figures, for instance. Still, we've begun very well. Rate growth held steady and edged up a little. Regarding renewals, the expectation will be a return to more typical seasonality, in which renewal strength compared with new leases is high in Q1 and Q4, while new leases surpass renewals through the spring leasing season, and that's what we anticipate this year.

Steve Sakwa

analyst
#16

All right. Then perhaps shifting over to development, Dave. I was curious whether you might kind of lay out how the '23 development looks and what yields you expect on the '23 deliveries. And then I realize those ran into certain supply chain difficulties, and perhaps the cost structures on those homes weren't ideal. But what do you anticipate for '24? And in what way are you viewing new development yields going ahead, simply considering the sort of higher rate environment and where your stock happens to be trading?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#17

Yeah. Well, to begin with, I'm taking a look — let's simply examine the development program as a whole. If you rewind 3, 4, 5 years to when we initially launched development, one point we made is that it permits us to be in charge of our own fate, and we're able to expand through every kind of economic cycle. And that has genuinely been demonstrated now, when our other avenues for growth, the acquisition growth avenues, national builder, MLS, are basically shut, given the opportunity set that exists out there. When you examine 2023, the initial point I believe all of us need to keep in mind is that these homes being delivered right now, that land was purchased 4, 5 years back, perhaps 6 years back in certain instances, and that's the moment they were underwritten; and every yield we're delivering is substantially above what we underwrote at the time we bought them. Over the past couple of years, Steve, you're entirely correct; it has been difficult. We've witnessed the input cost of homebuilding throughout all homebuilders, it has increased beyond what we've truly ever seen historically; along with that, we've been extremely lucky. We've enjoyed very robust rental rate growth alongside it, and our yields are in fact, as I mentioned, substantially above. 2023, we discussed the hope of getting a small amount of benefit, a tailwind as we reached the latter half of the year, possibly a 5% decrease in certain input costs. We observed a small amount of it, yet not to the degree we anticipated. Homebuilding at the start of 2023 coming out of 2022 was rather sluggish. But the homebuilders did gain some momentum via incentives and other means; and the demand for supplies, demand for labor returned to normal. And the benefits failed to appear to the degree we anticipated. We received the most — the largest benefit still occurred, and that was in lumber. So at present, we — last year, we delivered in the high 5s. As we underwrite, that's still 100 basis points above anything we're seeing at present from national builders or MLS and our consistent underwriting between the 2 channels. So — and as we head into 2024, once more, bear in mind that many of these were underwritten and purchased many years ago. A lot of the product is already there, including land and land improvements, so those will remain quite accretive, and I'm extremely pleased to have them in our portfolio. But to address your question directly, we'll likely be at high 5s, perhaps slightly at 6. Still, for 2024 deliveries, let's keep ourselves in the high 5s at this point.

Keegan Carl

analyst
#18

So perhaps to start off, regarding your CapEx for property enhancement, it dropped significantly on a year-over-year basis as well as quarter to quarter. I'm just curious whether any portion of that ties back to the Resident 360 program, or if something different caused it? And after that, what figure would make sense as a solid run rate moving ahead?

Bryan Smith

executive
#19

Keegan, it's Bryan here. What I believe you're observing with CapEx for property enhancement reflects the outcome of our ongoing program for LVP hard surface flooring, through which we swap out carpet; we've achieved considerable advancement on that front, and at this point homes are entering turns that feature hard surface flooring. As a result, you'll notice somewhat of a decrease there. Another piece of that involves what we refer to as CapEx for revenue enhancement, meaning particular upgrade initiatives that we assess one unit at a time; those aren't anywhere near as substantial, yet they deliver solid returns when looked at per project. So indeed, a decrease has occurred. My sense is that will likely persist. Even so, we'll keep that initiative going until no carpet remains in our business.

Keegan Carl

analyst
#20

Understood. Then switching topics, perhaps one directed at Chris. Just looking at how your real estate taxes are growing. I suppose, is your approach to forecasting any different because of what took place over the past 2 years? And clearly, with the legislation passed in Texas, I'm just wondering what kind of benefit you anticipate?

Chris Lau

executive
#21

Absolutely, Keegan. Well, I'd simply point out that for 2023, our projections ended up essentially spot on, and likewise 2022 apart from that Texas surprise. Well, on the whole, nothing has changed relative to what we discussed a year ago, property taxes keep trending along quite in line with what we had anticipated. 2023 landed in that 9% territory we had at the outset of the year when it came to our projections. And then the trajectory and outlook going into this year, once again, closely mirror a few of the initial ideas we laid out a year ago. What we anticipate is that we will start to observe a degree of moderation since the pace of home price appreciation has retreated from the record peaks seen over the past couple of years; however, having said that, we also passed this along to you a year ago, we do not anticipate property taxes reverting to the long-term average instantly. As we're aware, property taxes are by nature backward looking; and even though conditions have softened, sizable swaths of the housing market have stayed quite resilient, correct? Markets such as Florida and Georgia keep holding up well, where we might still witness property tax growth across those states in the high single-digit to low double-digit range, every bit of which has fed into this year's outlook in the low 7s, which once more captures moderation versus the past couple of years, yet will probably still exceed our long-term run rate of 4% to 5%. But I'd wrap up by noting that everything is unfolding very much the way we had anticipated.

Cooper Clark

analyst
#22

Cooper Clark here, filling in for Jamie. We've been hearing from others in your space that build-to-rent supply keeps growing in places such as Las Vegas and Phoenix. We're grateful for the faster absorption you're seeing, and you do encounter pockets of supply. That said, which markets in 2024 would you flag as having more supply, where a bit of softness might show up in a particular quarter?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#23

Dave here. I'll handle part of that, then perhaps Bryan can chime in. Honestly, I'd push back somewhat on that view. More build is ramping up, yes, but it isn't really in the city's core. It's — it's way out in secondary and tertiary areas. As for build to rent, plenty of it entered the market 3, 4 years back, whether from national builders or from some form of equity. A lot of those projects have been listed. We've looked at many of them to take over midstream; but given their location and quality, we chose to pass. In the same way, lots of build-to-rent product is being pitched to buyers like us. And for most build to rent, the plan was to build it, rent it, stabilize it and sell it and monetize it. Again, these assets are — quite a few of them exist out there and they want to trade. But looking at their pricing, they sit in the 4s. During the last quarter — during the last year, really, each quarter we've seen thousands and thousands of tape — properties on tapes — not thousands of tapes, but thousands of properties on tapes from national and local builders. And when you examine their quality and examine their pricing, they're in the 4s and are underwriting, and they simply aren't an appealing opportunity. With the national homebuilders, the trend you notice now is that many of these homes labeled "built to rent" or identified as build to rent are being reclassified by the national homebuilders as for sale or for retail sale. That alone shows how very, very hard it is to move these homes unless they're well located or the builder takes a deep discount. And that's occasionally what they must do in secondary and tertiary markets; so I don't see as much build to rent actually trading as people might suggest. Anything you'd like to add, Bryan?

Bryan Smith

executive
#24

Absolutely. Cooper, when we zero in on what's happening with supply in particular markets, you're right that Phoenix stands out as one of the places getting more units — and that's true not just for build to rent but for ordinary scattered-site product too. It shows up clearly, and I think occupancy figures make it plain: over the last 5 years Phoenix has ranked among the strongest markets, on both rate and occupancy. Even so, a bit more supply is coming in. According to John Barnes, Q1 supply rose roughly 25% compared with a year earlier. What works in our favor is our belief that absorption will happen fairly fast; our Phoenix portfolio enjoys terrific locations, and we view this as short-lived supply pressure. Our expectation is that Phoenix gets back to something like its historical results quite soon. Turning to Las Vegas, supply there has grown, with build to rent driving that specifically, yet our portfolio continues to do very well in that market. Occupancy, in fact, remains in the 96s. The remaining market that deserves mention, from my standpoint, is San Antonio, which has likewise experienced added supply. Still, as we mentioned before, this illustrates why holding a well-diversified portfolio helps — we own markets where supply has actually fallen, particularly across the Midwest. So the position we find ourselves in right now is one we're genuinely pleased with.

Nick Joseph

analyst
#25

Well done, Dave, and congratulations to the whole team. Looking back at 2023, you wound up surpassing your guidance by roughly $0.05, and approximately $0.02 of that came from stronger same-store NOI; so I'm simply wondering what turned out to be a positive surprise that produced that additional $0.03, and how you're viewing certain of those line items as we move through 2024.

Chris Lau

executive
#26

Yeah. Absolutely. I believe it sounds like, Nick. Nick, this is Chris speaking. Yeah, when we reflect on 2023, I believe we're genuinely happy with the way the year ultimately unfolded and also, especially, the momentum we're bringing from '23 into '24. I'd point to notable areas when we consider the outperformance from a Same-Home standpoint, I believe we performed very well on the rate side, leaning into and driving rate throughout the year. I think we witnessed that particularly during the spring leasing season and some of our updates at the close of the second quarter. I'd say that was sort of the theme for the first half of the year. And then the other element, we discussed this frequently in the second half of last year, is what a terrific job the team did regarding controlling controllables, controlling controllable expenses. To a large degree, as Resident 360 began to be rolled out across the portfolio, we observed solid expense controls regarding R&M and turn in the third and the fourth quarter. And so I believe it was truly rate growth through the spring, solid top line trajectory, paired with disciplined expense controls, particularly in the back half of the year and through turn season that genuinely converted into the outperformance last year. And when we consider this year, just taking a step back, I'd remind us all that, look, it's early, correct? It's early in the year. It's not lost on us that there's still some economic uncertainty out there in the environment that we're contemplating this year. There's still some question marks out there throughout the environment, and we're going to make sure that we come out of the gate prudently at the start of this year; but I believe it's very important again, we truly like the position that we're in. We exited '23 nicely. We had a fantastic fourth quarter, and we're seeing really solid trend lines into January and February, like Bryan was mentioning.

Nick Joseph

analyst
#27

That helps. Now my second question concerns the disposition guidance of $400 million to $500 million. What cap rate is baked into that assumption? And yes, I suspect those are likely lower than the cap rate implied by your share price. So I was wondering how ATM issuance factors into your capital plan too.

Chris Lau

executive
#28

Oh, certainly. Let me connect those two points. My best estimate for dispositions is that conditions will likely look quite a bit like what we saw in 2023. Somewhere between $400 million and $500 million in sales, with disposition cap rates likely in the 3s once more. But look, to link this to the bigger capital plan, let me pull back for a moment; as you're aware, we face a substantial $1.9 billion capital requirement this year once you factor in both our growth initiatives and securitization refinancings. And while the main funding sources planned for this year are retained cash flow, and importantly, capital recycled from dispositions plus debt, we continuously assess every option. And when the stock was trading at a slight discount to consensus NAV, for instance, with everything taken into account, including our relative borrowing cost in the mid-5s and the full scope of this year's capital needs, issuing a modest amount of equity was reasonable; but once more, I'd point out, we're discussing only $130 million; that isn't material to the company's capitalization, yet we view it as a quite good supplement to help complete this year's bigger overall capital requirement.

Haendel St. Juste

analyst
#29

Congrats to Bryan and Dave as well. Dave, I'd like to revisit what you said about development for a second. I'm trying to get a handle on the chance that you could perhaps push development deliveries higher this year versus the $750 million you're currently guiding to. My recollection is that a year ago, you began with a $650 million initial guide and finished up at $850 million for the full year '23. So I'm wondering about that kind of opportunity and what you'd perhaps need to see; and is it possible we could see you flex up to a level comparable to last year?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#30

Yes. So let's discuss the opportunity set. First off, our position is extremely strong — not just for ramping things up, but for keeping a steady expansion plan going well into the future. At the moment, we hold somewhere between 12,000 and 13,000 lots, each at a different point in the development process; a portion remain raw land while others can immediately move to vertical construction. That gives us an exceptionally dependable multiyear growth trajectory. There are a small number of gaps in that plan, though they're quite minor — just an individual market or two where we might need to fill a gap in the 26 or 27 unit delivery outlook. Those adjustments will be handled by us. Being able to scale upward is available, Haendel. What matters most is examining the funds at your disposal. You need to track precisely where the money being spent annually ends up; during 2023, a portion of those funds went toward land development rather than deliveries, getting things ready for handovers in either the current or following year; therefore, you must consider both the quantity of houses and the monetary figures. The correlation isn't exact—land development activity and deliveries can get slightly out of sync timing-wise. We can scale up, and not only in development. As we mentioned earlier, we're currently staying out of the National Builder and MLS spaces. That's not because we've ruled out expanding there—it's that the opportunities just aren't available right now. Everything depends on conditions in the capital markets and what acquisition prospects are out there. Yet it also comes down to keeping your expansion efforts steady and foreseeable. We have room to ramp up, though we must be cautious about how far we push it. Ramping up too much might mean pulling forward from the following year, since the land needs to be ready first. So I realize that was a lengthy reply. It's a bit roundabout, but hopefully it addresses the concern you raised.

Haendel St. Juste

analyst
#31

That's helpful, and I appreciate it. Could you perhaps share some thoughts on how the land itself is being backfilled? I'm curious what you're observing in the market right now. Are there any notable shifts of any kind? And beyond that, are there potentially new regions or markets you'd like to enter, or where you'd want more exposure?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#32

I'm not sure — let's begin with markets. As far as I can tell, there aren't any additional markets we're looking to enter at this point. Something important about the stage our development program is at: when the chance existed 2 years back, 2.5 years back, to acquire land at very appealing prices during the COVID period, we seized it. I think within 1 year, we purchased close to 8,000 to 7,000 lots, or 8,000 lots. Looking ahead, we're positioned extremely well. Land can be found today. However, the cost of that land — just like MLS pricing at the moment — leans a bit toward the expensive side. So we're in a very, very — we're in a fortunate situation in that we do hold a land pipeline. As I recall, during 2023 we did acquire land, though the quantity was quite small. It was filling in some of those gaps I mentioned regarding the future years delivery program, '26, '27 and '28. Still, land will open up. We're extremely selective about the locations where we purchase land; we acquire parcels next to national homebuilders where they're buying retail product rather than build-to-rent product. Over the long run, that will yield dividends. But patience is something we can afford. We can certainly be patient; that's the advantage of possessing the pipeline we have. So I'm genuinely pleased that our development program stands in very good shape for many years; and there will be moments when we're able to accelerate land acquisitions at a faster rate than we currently are. But we're filling those gaps, and regardless, it will remain a very steady program for many years.

Adam Kramer

analyst
#33

Congratulations to Dave and Bryan. I'd like to begin with what might be a two-part question. First, what is the loss to lease at present? Then, Bryan, you touched on this briefly before, but approximately where are renewals being sent for March and April right now?

Bryan Smith

executive
#34

Adam, thank you. Currently, our loss to lease falls within the low 3% range. Regarding renewals, we are sending them out — for February and March, a lot of results have already come back to us, and they are performing a bit above January's level. For April, renewals are going out at 5% to 6%. And as previously mentioned, over the 12 months, we anticipate renewals will land around 5%.

Adam Kramer

analyst
#35

Great. And perhaps shifting topics here, and this is admittedly somewhat more of a conceptual one. I was just curious about acquisitions. It appears as though that isn't really being factored into guidance. My sense is you picked up a few things here and there across 2023. And I suppose the conceptual question would be, look, if the market for acquisitions, be it MLS or builder partners, were to recover and become more appealing, would you think about that? Or is the focus essentially entirely on developments, given the — given all the benefits that, that program offers, and you'd likely remain committed to development even if the acquisition market recovered? And then I guess if the market improved and you decided to lean into acquisitions again, do you have the overhead and the team in place to turn that acquisition tap back on?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#36

Yeah. Adam, it's Dave. For sure — we're not against national builder and MLS. We see them as a great addition to what we do in development. With development, as we've said many times, we can expand through any kind of economy, and that's the situation right now. That said, it doesn't mean we're against national builder and MLS. We still have an acquisitions team today. Every day, they keep writing policies on homes, whether those come through national builders or via the MLS. As everyone knows, far less inventory is listed on the MLS these days. Even so, we do write coverage on those properties, and each month and quarter we're insuring thousands of homes. It's simply that we don't find the current terms appealing. Looking ahead as things move through cycles — if you examine where we stand right now, it's likely quite similar to what history shows. Still, you'd have to look back quite far, most likely to the 1980s, when interest rates climbed extremely fast and so on. Yet those cycles keep recurring. Eventually, there will come a moment when purchasing any kind of product relative to your cost of capital becomes extremely, extremely appealing. And indeed, all the necessary infrastructure is already established for us. That readiness exists not just on the buying side but equally within Bryan's area of running the business. As a result, whatever opportunities might arise, whether large or small, we are capable of acting on them.

Michael Goldsmith

analyst
#37

When you consider what it takes to bring in as much revenue as possible — lease spreads are still pretty solid, but occupancy has slipped somewhat both versus the prior quarter and compared with the same time last year. Could you give us additional color on how you weigh occupancy against raising rates? And does that let you increase rates more aggressively than you might have done in earlier years?

Bryan Smith

executive
#38

Absolutely. Thanks, Michael. Let me begin by noting that our goal is to get the most out of the whole revenue line, and rate clearly plays a role in shaping occupancy. Our approach for this year was to come in from a strong position. 96% occupancy is a solid figure under any historical measure you could apply. And as we head into the spring leasing season, we anticipate having some ability to set prices. We're eager to take on some homes in what may be a somewhat improved rate setting. Still, we saw very good rate increases on new leases and renewals during Q4, and that carried into January. And remember, that's happening before demand truly picks back up. So we're sitting in a great spot going into that period; however, we aren't evaluating any single piece on its own; we're focused on keeping a highly balanced and steady pricing approach for residents that drives the greatest revenue over the long run.

Michael Goldsmith

analyst
#39

And on a similar note, turnover has been climbing slightly. My guess is that this is closely tied to the rate. Are residents pushing back at all when it comes to renewal rents?

Bryan Smith

executive
#40

Yes. Michael, there are a few pieces to that. You pointed to one. The other piece was the seasonal pattern returning, which we mentioned during Q4. At present, we are observing a modest amount of haggling between the rates we send out and those that get executed. The negotiation range can be thought of as roughly 30 basis points. So it is not significant. But we are having — with truly high-quality properties in strong locations, and we are discovering solid value that residents appreciate.

Brad Heffern

analyst
#41

Could you share some figures about residents leaving to purchase a home? What's been happening with that lately? And how does it compare to what we've seen historically?

Bryan Smith

executive
#42

Absolutely. Thanks, Brad. Bryan here. We've observed, as anticipated, a drop in the share of our residents moving out for the purpose of buying. During Q4, it came in below 30% for the first time in my memory. Then it kept drifting down slightly as we moved into January, landing in the 28% range. Looking back historically, the figure tends to be around the mid-30s. So there has been a decline, yet it remains the primary reason for — a top destination among those of our residents who do move out.

Brad Heffern

analyst
#43

All right. And on a somewhat connected note, could you describe what the guidance assumes regarding the direction turnover will take in 2024?

Chris Lau

executive
#44

Sure. What you should keep in mind, Brad, is that this feeds into occupancy. Another way to look at it is that for the full year, recall really represents seasonality coming back, which we began observing as we moved through the latter part of Q2, Q3, and the second half. So as we compare on a full year-over-year basis, there will likely be a modest increase in turnover for the full year, though this mostly reflects a return to normal seasonality—the post-COVID conditions that had stabilized during the later portion of 2023—and all of that is baked into the occupancy guidance for this year in the low 96s.

Linda Tsai

analyst
#45

I'm not certain whether you already addressed this, but could you give us a bit more detail about the occupancy guidance? What I'm trying to understand is why it would remain roughly flat compared with where things stand right now, given that overall demand looks fairly strong and new supply wasn't really affecting you.

Bryan Smith

executive
#46

Linda, it's Bryan here; in January we reported occupancy at 96%, and for the full year we're looking at the low 96s; so some absorption is what we anticipate. The way to think about it is really through what Chris mentioned a moment ago — that we observed seasonality coming back. And we expect that seasonality to continue through this year. So once the busy spring leasing period wraps up, there could be a slight rebalancing toward the end of the year.

Linda Tsai

analyst
#47

My next question concerns that 30 bps negotiating band, which really isn't very wide — what's the typical pattern for it? Does it shift significantly based on which portion of the year we're in?

Bryan Smith

executive
#48

Seasonal swings aren't particularly large in this area. Much of it comes down to the reality that the offers we make are fair, and they perform well given what's available for release in the market at any given moment. If you look back historically, to the pre-COVID era, things were likely somewhat narrower — around the 10 basis point mark. We've widened it somewhat, simply because of all the developments taking place globally. That said, it remains quite tight, and that band is something we're comfortable with.

Jesse Lederman

analyst
#49

Congratulations on your retirement, Dave. Also, congratulations to Bryan and Chris regarding their new positions. My first question concerns February, and it's wonderful to learn that conditions have gotten somewhat better during January. How would you characterize that improvement in terms of pricing power, particularly for February, and perhaps what do you anticipate for March relative to the typical seasonal increase — maybe back when seasonality mattered more before COVID at the start of the year?

Bryan Smith

executive
#50

Thank you, Jesse. Things are unfolding pretty much the way we anticipated. Demand speeding up at the end of January is truly producing outstanding outcomes in February. We're not through February yet. Even so, we anticipated beginning the year in a strong spot. 96% occupancy definitely qualifies. Thus we're able to raise pricing as we move faster into the spring leasing season.

Jesse Lederman

analyst
#51

Thanks. For my follow-up, I'd like to ask about the development pipeline. Over the past few years, and especially more recently, it appears the pipeline has been creeping up as a share of gross assets — likely because other routes to acquisition and growth have become less available. If things keep going the way they are, it seems like it could hit the 10% goal you've mentioned. What's your thinking on that moving forward? Have you revisited that target at all? Or is there anything you can do to hold it within a range you're at ease with?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#52

No — that's a really sharp point, and it's one of several factors we weigh when determining how big the whole program should be. So our goal is to keep this company's risk profile exactly as it has been since day one — we're not going to alter it. Essentially, we are entirely a rental business, and that's the way we want the balance sheet to stay. We also need sufficient scale. It's a matter of balancing things: we need a pipeline that's big enough to support expansion through every kind of economic cycle, which we've discussed before, and I believe we've struck that balance. My sense is that our current position aligns with where we ought to be. That said, whenever distinctive chances arise, we'll scale things up. As things stand, the initiative involves how hard it is to acquire both land and already-built properties. So although we're sitting in a really strong spot, we do take the balance sheet into account. We also weigh the capital markets, along with how our pipeline is shaped and what it looks like, while putting together our development schedule from one period to the next.

Austin Wurschmidt

analyst
#53

Understood. In what way does that low 3% loss to lease stack up against what's typical at this point on the calendar? Also, regarding the renewals you mentioned getting done for Feb and March, it sounds like those months are pretty much locked in for you. How has that acceptance rates — how has the acceptance rate moved compared with what you've observed, I suppose, during roughly this same period of the year?

Bryan Smith

executive
#54

Yeah. Appreciate it, Austin. That low 3% loss to lease we're seeing right now, clearly, things have been somewhat different across the last couple of years given the enormous acceleration in new lease rate growth. Where we stand today, though, speaks to the work of our revenue management team and the capability we've demonstrated in recapturing a portion of that. Low 3% at this point in the year, I'd call a really healthy spot. Bear in mind, you'll get seasonal variability in that as we move into the spring leasing season, new leases have a tendency to speed up quite significantly then, which would shift that loss to lease figure along with the remainder of the portfolio; and then turning to how February and March are shaping up. Those aren't finished yet, but retention has come in as we anticipated. We likely have clearer visibility on February than on March, yet it's genuinely unfolding the way we expected.

Austin Wurschmidt

analyst
#55

Then, is there anything to share regarding the rent-to-income ratio? As you possibly encounter somewhat more resistance at the margin compared to what you've typically experienced, is there any point on that rent-to-income ratio stretching beyond levels that would cause you to reduce rent increases?

Bryan Smith

executive
#56

No. Actually, we've felt quite good about the reality that incomes have matched rent movements, definitely among the applicants we draw; that's something we've observed over the last 3, 4 years, while rents have risen sharply. The wellness of the new residents we bring in is quite robust.

Omotayo Okusanya

analyst
#57

Once more, congratulations to Dave and Bryan, and Chris too. What I want to ask about is the SFR legislation floating around out there, the anti-SFR bills. Could you give us a sense of what you're picking up regarding these proposals, how likely it is that they advance in Congress at the federal level, or even what's going on in any states where you operate?

Dave Singelyn

executive
#58

Sure. Tayo, Dave here, and I appreciate that opening remark. Legislation and regulation — hasn't that been the tale for 12 years that we've been navigating? Its shape just keeps shifting annually. Let's remember our situation. An election year is upon us, and plenty of rhetoric will be flying around. What we've observed previously is that lots of talk emerges about various regulations, yet hardly any of them cross the finish line, particularly at the federal level. That said, all that rhetoric does get picked up, and it gets picked up locally. That's precisely where having a strong government affairs operation, getting ahead of things, and holding relationships at both the federal and local levels matters tremendously; and we've put substantial resources into that effort. Rhetoric about us will always, always exist. Ultimately, the one thing I believe you'll notice with American Homes is that we've always been fair, we've always been considerate in the way we've treated people. In the end, that's what matters. And we're part of the housing solution here. We're constructing homes; and the issue around — the reason so much rhetoric surrounds regulations is the reality that housing costs a great deal. Housing today accounts for more than — it's nearing 40% of many households' income, which is up from the low 30s. Yet the providers of housing aren't the problem. The real problem is that we lack sufficient housing. A housing shortage exists, and it must be addressed. And addressing it requires actually loosening some regulations and giving people incentives to build the housing needed to shelter Americans across this country. So yes, it's out there. I don't view it any differently. I do believe the rhetoric side has ramped up somewhat, but that truly connects to the fact that we're in an election year; and let's remember where we stand in the cycle.

Dave Singelyn

executive
#59

Well, I appreciate everyone joining us today. But speaking for myself, I'm grateful for the backing you've given throughout these 12 years. During the coming 10 months, I'll be on the road alongside Bryan and Chris, hopefully, getting together with a lot of you. I'm looking forward to that as we hand the CEO position over to Bryan. So, enjoy the rest of your day, and we'll be seeing you at various points during the year. Take care. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#60

Thank you. This concludes today's conference. All parties may disconnect. Have a good day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete American Homes 4 Rent transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to American Homes 4 Rent earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in American Homes 4 Rent or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.