Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings (ASIC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 19, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 27 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Justin Cohen

executive
#1

Good evening, everyone, and thanks for being on Ategrity's call for the fourth quarter. I'm Justin Cohen, and with me today are Chris Schenk, who serves as our President and Chief Underwriting Officer, and Neelam Patel, our CFO. Once again, Ategrity posted record results in Q4, showing strength on both the top and bottom line. Gross written premiums were up 30% compared with a year earlier, which beat our guidance of surpassing E&S industry growth by 20 percentage points. The 84.9% combined ratio we recorded in the quarter marks a new company record. We keep growing our market share profitably in the small and midsized E&S space, and that comes down to 3 key factors. First, within our core specialty verticals, we spotted gaps in the market and created targeted products to fill them, which generates structural growth while we hold to strict technical discipline. Second, our distribution network has expanded to nearly 600 partners. Thanks to tight alignment of product and execution, we've produced strong submission volume, including growth of nearly 90% year-over-year this quarter. Third, we've engineered our workflows and automation so we deliver speed with precision, responding quickly to brokers while upholding rigorous standards at scale. Taken together, these factors have produced both growth and margin expansion in a moderating E&S market. Now to additional dynamics from the quarter. In property, we were up 18% year-over-year, with strong sequential acceleration, which stands in stark contrast to the overall property market, which contracted as a whole. By concentrating on small- and medium-sized attritional risks where we hold an underwriting advantage, we positioned ourselves away from the more cyclical large account catastrophe-exposed market. Our 84.9% combined ratio reflects favorable loss experience, business mix and operating leverage. Net earned premiums rose 25 percentage points faster than operating expenses net of fees, which drove a 6.1 percentage point improvement in our overall expense ratio even as we keep investing in growth initiatives and technology. On technology, in recent weeks, the capital markets have focused on the risks of AI to the specialty insurance industry. Here at Ategrity, more than 2 years ago, we set out a clear road map for integrating AI and made critical investments in that direction. Those investments have now been operationalized, and we'll give some additional context later in the call. Finally, stepping back to broader E&S market dynamics, while industry growth has decelerated, that is less the case in our small and midsized segment. Competitive intensity increased marginally again this quarter, but we continue to stand out through our business model and execution, driving growth in our market share. With that, I'll turn it over to Neelam to discuss the financial results.

Neelam Patel

executive
#2

Thanks, Justin. We turned in another robust quarter, posting adjusted net income of $25.4 million versus $22.7 million during the same period a year earlier. That came from top line growth, better margins, and ongoing strength in investment income. Gross written premiums rose 30% for the quarter, and that growth was broad-based. Casualty premiums were up 38%, while property premiums climbed 18%. Net written premiums rose 44%, reflecting improved retention compared with a year ago. Net earned premiums increased 34%, a smaller gain than net written premiums because growth is recognized on a natural lag. Sequentially, net earned premium growth sped up thanks to our larger premium base and the effect of lowering our quota share reinsurance in 2025. Fee income reached $2.3 million, versus $0.4 million a year ago, reflecting standard policy fees put in place in 2025. Underwriting income for the quarter came to $15.5 million, a 160% increase year-over-year. That equates to a combined ratio of 84.9%, compared with 92.3% last year, on reductions in both the loss ratio and the expense ratio. The loss ratio was 57.1%, 1.2 points lower year-over-year, driven by strong underlying results in our property business. Once again, we had no prior year development. Catastrophe losses represented 3.2% of net earned premium, down from 3.7% last year, because the fourth quarter saw very few catastrophe events. On the expense side, the overall expense ratio improved 6.1 points to 27.8%. Operating expense equaled 10.5% of net earned premiums, down 2.4 points year-over-year and below Q2 and Q3 of 2025; that gain came from earned premiums growing faster than operating expenses, plus the benefit of higher fee income. Policy acquisition costs, as a percent of net earned premiums, fell to 17.3% from 21%. That improvement was mainly mix driven, since growth has been concentrated in lines of business that carry lower acquisition costs and higher ceding commissions. Now to investment results. Net investment income was $11.6 million, up from $6.3 million last year, reflecting a larger investment portfolio. Realized and unrealized gains totaled $6.7 million, supported by strong results in our utility and infrastructure portfolio. Our effective tax rate was 20.2%, bringing net income to $25.3 million. Adjusted net income was $25.4 million, or $0.51 per diluted share. Turning to the balance sheet. Cash and investments rose by $45 million from the third quarter to $1.1 billion, reflecting strong operating cash flow. Book value rose by $26 million, driven by retained earnings. Our book value per share ended the quarter at $12.78, up 21% since the IPO. Overall, the quarter reflects strong growth, underwriting discipline and operating leverage. With that, I'll turn it over to Chris to discuss underwriting and operating performance.

Chris Schenk

executive
#3

Thank you, Neelam. A 30% increase alongside an 84.9% combined ratio made this yet another record-setting quarter for Ategrity. Our key operating measurements — retention, hit ratios, submissions, and rate change — either matched or exceeded what we had planned. Additionally, our cost of product signals, such as frequency and severity indicators, keep moving in a favorable direction. What these outcomes demonstrate is how robust our productionized underwriting model has become, grounded in vertical specialization, deep expertise, and structured underwriting. I'd like to call out three factors that drove these results. To begin with, we've seized upon growth avenues that others in the industry have passed over; these represent distinctive routes to expansion that only we can spot, given our focus on particular verticals and micro segments. Roughly half our expansion during this quarter originated from strategic efforts such as Project Heartland, retail trade, and our multifamily developer product; within Property, we closed out 2025 with premium growth and renewal rate increases. We expanded 18%, even as numerous competitors shrank. This expansion stemmed from states frequently ignored, including North Dakota, Ohio, and Nebraska. On the property side, we additionally attained full year rate change in the high single digits. Now shifting to Casualty. In that area, we expanded 38% and secured low teens full year rate increases. Our management and professional liability lines proved to be a robust contributor, with premium more than tripling even amid broader softening conditions. Next, we secured larger wallet share among our partners. In particular, our 2023 and 2024 distribution cohorts generated over 100% same-store growth. These partners enjoyed solid renewals and boosted new business placement with Ategrity. At the same time, our 2025 cohort brought in 25% additional new partners to our distribution network, and we're witnessing encouraging early indicators of engagement. Our submissions rose approximately 90% year-over-year. We drove premium growth by quoting additional business from a wider opportunity set while upholding pricing discipline. Last, our underwriting platform is generating speed and operating leverage. We're providing rapid, dependable, and market-ready quotes without sacrificing technical rigor. Within our brokerage channel, policy count climbed 3.5x alongside record high transaction volumes. Our underwriting efficiency more than doubled; we generated record high quotes while cutting turnaround times. Standardizing processes and automating through technology enabled us to take on that growth while generating operating leverage. This played a part in a 2.4-point decrease in our operating expense ratio year-over-year. As we look toward 2026, we're carrying out initiatives aimed at the next wave of growth. This involves ramping up our regional strategies; in Florida, we introduced a brokerage package product backed by a dedicated underwriting team. It ranks among the few offerings of its type available in the market. In New England, we're rising to address a market gap with a playbook for older buildings and dense mixed-use exposures. And across the Midwest, we're intensifying our commitment to Project Heartland with a comprehensive branded product. These growth pathways are distinctive and ought to let us keep surpassing the market. Lastly, I want to expand upon Justin's earlier remarks regarding AI. We've been following a distinct road map for more than 2 years now. Artificial intelligence is already in place across our back office, where it sharpens risk qualification, gets data ready, and optimizes parameters. Come 2026, we're now putting AI functionality straight into underwriting workflows, using tools our own innovation lab developed. Our underwriting approach lends itself perfectly to AI adoption since it's structured and grounded in technical pricing, with risk selection criteria that are clearly defined. How we pick risk and move away from technical rates is highly prescriptive. That means we're able to bring AI in with disciplined guardrails and pull out genuine economic value. To us, this represents a step change for the company. A great deal of the heavy lifting is behind us, yet we're proceeding responsibly, testing and ramping deployment as this year unfolds. Once fully deployed this year, we anticipate this will push our expense ratio down. With that, I'll hand things back to Justin for closing comments.

Justin Cohen

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Chris — by every standard, this was a robust quarter. The top line moved higher, margins widened, and we kept strengthening our distribution ties, and we did all of it while holding firm on underwriting discipline as the market softened. What we delivered shows a model built deliberately for this purpose and run with real rigor. Against that backdrop, I'll shift to what we expect going forward. For Q1 '26, our guidance — the same as what we gave last quarter — calls for growth running 20 percentage points ahead of E&S market growth, which speaks to further share gains and the power of how we operate. On top of that, we expect a combined ratio slightly under 90%. There's one more thing to mention. We filed an 8-K today to announce a share repurchase program, and we'd be glad to take any questions about it during the Q&A. With that, thanks for spending your time with us. And operator, would you please open the line for questions?

Hristian Getsov

analyst
#5

For my first one, could you break down the pricing conditions you're observing, especially splitting casualty from property, and how each compares with loss trend? Also, with rates where they are now, is it fair to expect that your mix keeps moving more toward casualty in 2026?

Justin Cohen

executive
#6

Chris?

Chris Schenk

executive
#7

Sure. Let me begin with casualty. Across our verticals, the rating landscape remains robust. Demand is quite healthy. That shows up in the flow of submissions, and we are staying disciplined on price. Our technical rates are set prospectively. As a result, we've secured rates that exceed trend, and near term we don't expect that to ease. That said, because of market conditions and the competitive set we face, we've kept room to defend our renewals should the market move across any of our lines. So any easing in rates would come from that quarter; in property, we compete on a highly differentiated field in the Midwest. We don't encounter much competition chasing the kind of business we're writing. That lets us obtain the rates we need. Tariffs and other severity drivers are already reflected in our pricing; so on property too we're rate adequate; and we've achieved rates above trend.

Justin Cohen

executive
#8

Regarding the mix question—we've previously stated that for casualty, the target range we anticipate landing in is 60% to 70%. This quarter we came in at 67%, and we'll stay inside that range, so you shouldn't anticipate us moving away from it. Thus, roughly where we currently sit is a solid expectation for mix.

Hristian Getsov

analyst
#9

Understood. On Project Heartland, could you quantify the available runway for expanding distribution? And can you put any numbers on what this initiative contributed to premium growth during the year?

Chris Schenk

executive
#10

Yes, Project Heartland has 2 components. One is an appointment piece — bringing on additional partners — and that phase is almost complete. The focus shifts more toward capturing greater wallet share from partners, so that stage has only just begun. What we believe sets us apart is the money we've put into the Midwest — not only on the distribution side, but also when it comes to creating products and building a distinctive proposition within our verticals — and that gives us an enormous runway for growth. As I said in my remarks, we're bringing out a Heartland product that will make us stand out in the market. It's essentially a marketing tactic, but it also lets our coverage and our offering gain instant recognition, and that will be the next stage of these efforts. It offers us considerably more — a longer runway for growth.

Pablo Singzon

analyst
#11

A lot of other carriers, and a few of those are pretty big with mature platforms, have demonstrated a real appetite for small commercial E&S, and they've shared growth figures publicly that look really strong. So my question would be, are you noticing any signs of those companies appearing in the markets you operate in?

Justin Cohen

executive
#12

What you're getting at is whether new entrants have been arriving?

Pablo Singzon

analyst
#13

Understood. And what I have in mind, without mentioning any specific companies, is big businesses that care a great deal about small commercial E&S.

Justin Cohen

executive
#14

No pressure of that kind has come our way, and we haven't observed it either. A few of our metrics came out this quarter, as you noticed, and I believe that shows we're building momentum on our own, and that sort of competition isn't something we've run into.

Pablo Singzon

analyst
#15

All right. Moving to my next question, which concerns the outlook. When I last looked, the E&S market seemed to be growing at a high single-digit pace. Given that, doesn't your guidance of more than 20% imply roughly high-20s growth for the first quarter, Justin?

Justin Cohen

executive
#16

That's right. We've intentionally steered our outlook toward a rate of expansion that exceeds the market, and the reason is that we don't make projections about the market itself. That isn't where we direct our energy, and we don't believe it would serve us well to lay out our speculations on the subject. Still, considering our position — drawing on what we've picked up and observed regarding the market — a reasonable benchmark, in our view, might be somewhere in the mid- to high single-digit range.

Andrew Kligerman

analyst
#17

Andrew, asking about that 84.9% — you said it was our best-ever combined ratio. I'm curious, since you've posted some strong figures over the past few years. Could you — and I believe Neelam noted on this call that you also had no prior year development. Could you discuss your approach to reserving a bit? How much conservatism, if any, goes into those numbers? Maybe — could you touch on that a little.

Justin Cohen

executive
#18

Andrew, overall our reserves sit in a very strong spot, on both the property and casualty sides. You heard Chris say during the prepared remarks that early indicators for the recent years are coming in very strong; so our confidence in those reserves is high. And beyond that, we truly saw a low quarter of losses and frequency and severity in property, yet we have booked losses — we have booked reserves in anticipation of maybe late reporting. So we think that both property and casualty are in strong position.

Andrew Kligerman

analyst
#19

That's quite useful. I'd like to dig into something a bit — since I'm traveling, I haven't had a chance to look at the 8-K, so it's good to learn there's a buyback authorization. Could you share the size of it and how you intend to — the desire to manage it so it's genuinely put to use? And more broadly, could you assess how much capital is available to redeploy? I'm aware your leverage is de minimis. Does the balance sheet hold enough capital to support this very strong growth of 30% a quarter?

Justin Cohen

executive
#20

Yes. So Andrew, it comes to $50 million; and the reasoning is that we have a — we're a business whose book value per share has risen roughly 21% since the IPO. We're trading at 9x consensus forward, and we've produced surplus capital in exactly the quarters we've been discussing — across the last 3 quarters we've reported to you. So we think buying the stock here is the right move. I'll add that we're dedicated to growing the float over time. It'll simply happen at a different price. So when it comes to surplus capital, if you revisit the sums we've produced over just the past 3 quarters, that's actually a pretty substantial figure, and it leaves us well positioned to deploy capital into a buyback while also continuing to expand; so the capital picture and the growth path when it comes to deploying capital haven't shifted.

Matthew Heimermann

analyst
#21

I have a few things to ask. First, given that AI is already in place in the back office, I'm wondering about the claims team — has it provided any benefit there, sorry, for LAE costs, either allocated or unallocated?

Justin Cohen

executive
#22

Regarding AI, the opportunity we've identified is primarily on the underwriting side. So on the claims side, if that's what you mean, we haven't yet put it to use in any significant way. Was there something else you wanted to ask about that?

Matthew Heimermann

analyst
#23

Yeah, so, well, let's — I've got two follow-ups on that. The first one is just about the — what do you see as the use cases for your company when it comes to claims? And I'd be curious to hear about that; and part of it is maybe just my own confusion regarding what counts as more back office versus a front-of-the-house function. So maybe you could actually walk through what you'd consider to be back office, just so we can perhaps level set on that too?

Justin Cohen

executive
#24

Just on claims, one thing that's clear is that there's a processing element to incoming claims. And so deploying it there, as we do with our intake process in submissions, that is — that will ultimately be an easy win; but on this call, we're not going to describe how we're going to be deploying claims in AI. Chris, do you want to talk a little bit about where you're at?

Chris Schenk

executive
#25

Right. Regarding what I mean by back office in my remarks, we treat that as covering all the steps prior to an account arriving at an underwriter's desk. That means intake, then data prep, then prequalification. We've been applying AI to prequalification, which lets us filter out accounts that don't fit our appetite. The following stage involves risk assessment, once the account reaches the underwriter's desk. There, usage falls along a range. It might span anything from complete automation for straightforward accounts to automation in part when it comes to risk assessment. This is underwriting done at the level of an individual account, where we evaluate against particular criteria. Since our model is built in a structured way, we can spot use cases that add a great deal of value along several dimensions: first, producing a clearer and more quantitative assessment; second, generating a higher-quality decision when the assessment isn't purely quantitative and automated. When it moves into the underwriter's judgment, helping to steer that judgment is the second and third use case there.

Justin Cohen

executive
#26

Alright, we really appreciate everyone tuning in and for those questions, and we're eager to connect with you over the coming weeks and months. Thanks so much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings transcript — plus 133,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings earnings transcripts and 133,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.