Bank of Queensland Limited (BOQ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 20, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone holding on. You're welcome to the Bank of Queensland Group's 2023 half-year results call. Everyone joining is currently in listen-only mode. A presentation will be given, and after that we'll open things up for questions and answers. Should you wish to pose a question, please press the star key and then one on your phone's keypad. At this point I'd like to pass the conference to Ms. Tanya Aaskov, General Manager of Investor Relations. Over to you.
Tanya Aaskov
executiveGood morning, everyone, and welcome to BOQ's results presentation covering the half year that ended 28 February 2023. I'm Tanya Aaskov, General Manager of Investor Relations. Before we start, I'd like to acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land where we're meeting today, the Gadigal people, and to recognize elders past, present, and emerging. Thank you for joining us this morning. With me are Patrick Allaway, our Managing Director and CEO, and Racheal Kellaway, our Chief Financial Officer. BOQ's executive team and senior management are also here in the room with us. This morning, we'll give you an overview of our half year results. Patrick will update you on our strategy. Racheal will speak to our financial results, and then Patrick will close with a summary and outlook for the second half. After the briefing, there will be a chance for question and answers. I'll now hand over to Patrick.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThanks, Tanya. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us. As Tanya said, I'm here this morning alongside Racheal, other executive team members, and our senior leaders. On slide eight, the key messages I want to leave with you. BOQ sits in a strong financial position as we head into this more challenging economic environment. We're well-placed to keep investing in our transformation so we can deliver a stronger and simpler, low-cost, digitally enabled bank. Since announcing our strategy in 2020, we've made progress on digitization, improved our strategic position through the ME Bank acquisition, achieved growth across our brands, and strengthened our financial resilience. At the December AGM, we detailed that we would be prioritizing, strengthening, and simplifying BOQ while optimizing returns, providing stronger foundations for our target state, a digital and data-led bank. Our brands target specific customer segments across retail and business, providing differentiated value propositions in the market and diversification across our portfolio. We have high conviction that our transformation strategy will address our structural challenges as a smaller bank through our targeted customer value proposition, lowering cost of funding through a broader digital deposit base, and simplifying and automating our business to materially decrease our operating costs.
Patrick Allaway
executiveBOQ's asset quality is still solid, with a well-diversified, collateralized book and prudent risk settings. Our purpose and values will guide how we behave as we deliver this strategy and improve outcomes for customers, people, and shareholders. Turning to slide 9 for our financial performance in the half. Statutory net profit after tax for the half came in at AUD 4 million, and that included two one-off non-cash items: an AUD 60 million provision for the Integrated Risk Program and an AUD 200 million goodwill impairment, which we announced last Friday. We delivered AUD 256 million in cash earnings after tax. That was supported by a margin tailwind, which has materially reduced over the last two months of the half amid heightened mortgage and deposit competition. The margin uplift was offset by 7% growth in expenses. We know that is unsustainable, and we will tackle expense growth through our simplification program, which I will discuss shortly. CET1 at 10.71% is up 114 basis points from the prior half and includes the benefit received from implementation of Basel III. Our spot liquidity coverage ratio was 143%. We will retain the higher capital buffer, with our revised CET1 target range between 10.25% and 10.75%.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThe board has decided to issue an interim dividend of AUD 0.20 per share. Relative to the reported cash earnings result, the payout ratio came in at 51%. Once the one-off provision for the Risk Program is factored in, this dividend equates to a 61% payout. Racheal Kellaway, our CFO, will soon give further detail on our financial results. Moving to slide 10, which shows the retail bank. A focus of our retail transformation this half has been lifting our customer experience as we advance work on the digital bank. Housing lending stayed broadly flat, since we moderated growth while competition continues at heightened levels. Customer deposits have grown by AUD 2 billion, and we have 110,000 deposit customers on the new digital platform. Deposits on that new platform now total AUD 3.8 billion. Given the sharp rise in interest rates, we have been proactive in reaching out to customers. Many of these customers have never previously faced rising interest rates. For customers with fixed rates maturing within the next 12 months, we are making contact to offer support as they prepare for this change. Now to slide 11 for an overview of the business bank. A key strength of BOQ is the performance of our business bank and its associated high return on equity.
Patrick Allaway
executiveOur renewed emphasis on SME business is producing encouraging results and growth of good quality. Efficiency has been pushed forward by the business bank, and you can see that in a cost-to-income ratio of 40.2% for this half, which is low, along with better risk-adjusted returns. The business banking book carries solid collateral, with only limited lending against cash flow, and it is diversified across industries. As slide 12 sets out, we have achieved meaningful progress in our transformation, improving both our customer value proposition and the experience we offer. Our strategic position has been enhanced through the ME acquisition, and we are now in the last year of the standalone integration program for it. Results are coming through from our digital platform, with customer numbers rising and more of those customers naming BOQ as their main financial institution. More than 170,000 customers are now on the new platform. Group customer NPS and employee engagement scores have both improved against the prior comparative period, though we know there is more work ahead. Our financial resilience has been made stronger by solid capital and liquidity buffers. Given where we are in our transformation journey, and with the economic cycle becoming more challenging, we plan to hold on to our capital buffer. Turning to slide 14. We remain committed to our purpose, which we announced at the full year, of building social capital through banking. That purpose is our guiding principle and the reason we are in business.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThose principles at the heart of our purpose matter more than they ever have, and they shape the way we'll remake this bank as we deliver top-tier experiences for customers and staff alike. We've paused to consider the distance we've travelled and what matters most for success as our transformation enters its next phase. Our approach to the transformation program is becoming more holistic and integrated still, so that we build a bank that is stronger and more resilient, with a simpler structure, less duplication, and greater productivity. A digital bank able to expand at scale and tune itself for profits and returns that last. We hold a clear set of capabilities for reaching these outcomes. With a team that is now proven and experienced running the digital bank. Our community-anchored area managers and specialist bankers, through the strong relationships they already hold, will be complemented by our digital bank. I'll speak to strengthening BOQ on slide 15. As we said last week, following on from the 2022 results and the AGM in December last year, effort is needed to lift our operational resilience and risk culture. We have by now scoped, costed, and kicked off a defined program of work, backed by a robust governance structure and independent assurance, to achieve lasting embedment of this uplift throughout our three lines of defense.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThe Integrated Risk Program represents a $60 million commitment to making the bank stronger. Across our systems, processes, risk and compliance outcomes — AML included — this program will deliver improvements. Delivering on this program depends heavily on our risk culture. We hold the view that risk belongs to everyone, and that idea is being embedded further throughout the group, driven from the top. According to our latest engagement survey, our people feel increasingly comfortable speaking up. That measure improved to 78%, and it will remain an ongoing area of focus for the group. On Slide 16, we lay out how we are simplifying BOQ. Simplifying our complex operating model is no small task, yet the benefits are already visible — better processes, fewer products, and redundant technologies being decommissioned. The next phase of this simplification involves aligning our organizational structure with our target customer segments and business model, cutting duplication via an integrated model and taking advantage of process automation. We are consolidating suppliers and our property footprint, and we are making clear decisions regarding non-core activities, including the sale of our New Zealand asset finance business. This simplification work will tackle cost inflation, and in the second half we will give the market a more detailed update, including productivity targets.
Patrick Allaway
executiveWe expect that meaningful cost savings will begin to show up in FY 2024. Now I'll discuss digitizing the BOQ as laid out on slide 17. Our digitization roadmap remains on schedule. Data from around the world tells us that focused, straightforward digital models don't just create a more even competitive field — they also let smaller players beat the big banks. One effort we've sped up within our digitalization is building out the new digital platform and moving ME Bank customers onto it, which will give existing and new ME customers the best possible digital experience, from transaction accounts through to mortgages. It also lets us retire redundant systems sooner, giving an early proof point in FY 2025 of a digital, low-cost, scalable, national brand and operating model. Moving now to optimizing BOQ on slide 18. BOQ has solid foundations for further optimization, with a quality asset book, a strong 149 year heritage, and a portfolio of quality brands with deep customer relationships in targeted segments. We expect a material performance uplift from FY 2025. We stay committed to hitting the target cost-to-income ratio of below 50% along with an ROE of over 9.25% by FY 2026. A robust financial model and a clear transformation plan underpin these targets, and that plan assumes highly competitive market conditions will normalize.
Patrick Allaway
executiveMoving on to slide 19, I'll discuss how we're building a sustainable business. As our customers deal with a rising cost of living, higher costs in their own businesses, and increased interest rates, our purpose and values will let us stand behind them. These relationship-based customers benefit from owner managers who are deeply connected to their communities — that gives them the support of a national bank, local knowledge, and a banker who acts as a genuine partner. Some of Australia's most vulnerable people receive support from our community partners, and we're proud to carry on that important work. Our people sit at the heart of both our business and our customer proposition, and we're creating a future fit organization — one that is agile, with curious bankers. To create value for our people, our customers, and our shareholders, an engaged and diverse workforce with inclusive leaders is paramount. Clear environmental targets overlay our strategy, and we're committed to the transition toward a low carbon economy; we will cut scope one and scope two emissions by 90% and scope three by FY 2030. I'll now pass things to Racheal, who will give more detail on the financial results. Over to you, Racheal.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThank you, Patrick. Good morning, everyone. On the next slide, I'll go through the non-cash items in greater depth. I'll begin with cash earnings and take a close look at how the group performed financially, and we achieved a 10% lift in underlying profit versus the prior comparative period. The driver was 9% growth in total income, partly offset by operating expenses rising 7%. We met our commitment to positive jaws during a period of strong revenue growth, which was partly offset by cost pressures, among them the effects of inflation and what we are investing in technology. Cash earnings fell 4% to AUD 256 million relative to the prior comparative period, because a loan impairment credit occurred in the same period last year. Loan impairment expense for the half came to AUD 34 million, a return to a more normalized long-term level. Cash earnings were up 7% on the prior half, once again demonstrating positive jaws, with income growth of 6% and cost growth of 4%. As Patrick mentioned earlier and as detailed in our ASX release last week, we have impaired goodwill by AUD 200 million and raised a AUD 42 million after-tax provision in the half for our Integrated Risk Program.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveWe remain on schedule, and this is our last year of bringing ME Bank into the group, with AUD 13 million after tax of integration costs landing in the half. Those items left us with a statutory profit of AUD 4 million. Slide 23 sets out the main income components. Total income came to AUD 902 million, up 9% versus the prior corresponding period and 6% half on half. NIM rose to 1.79% for the half. Across the period, NIM did moderate. We have eased balance sheet growth during the half. In mortgages, competition heated up. We chose deliberately to curb our growth and concentrate on areas where returns were appropriate. In business lending, although we saw the system slow, our growth stayed positive and, pleasingly, was supported by our SME focus, which delivered 7% growth for the half. Total business lending rose AUD 509 million. As anticipated, NIM benefited from the rising cash rate environment, along with ongoing gains on our capital and low-cost deposits. The 4 basis point NIM improvement in the half included a 2 basis point decrease tied to a reclassification of ME Fee income. Earnings are unaffected by this.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveSetting that aside, the NIM gain we saw during the period on an underlying basis came to 6 basis points. Let me break down the main NIM components in greater depth. Pricing and mix on the asset side produced a drag of 12 basis points. Of that figure, 7 basis points came from retention discounting, since we concentrated on our current customer base while acquisition competition picked up throughout the industry. Front-to-back book compression cost us 6 basis points in the half — 5 basis points in housing and 1 basis point in business lending. That remains a weight on margin, though it is better than what we recorded in the prior half. On funding costs, NIM gained 24 basis points. That gain stemmed from how we managed at-call savings margins. We additionally recorded a 5 basis point gain from term deposits, which, as we mentioned at the full year, are priced off the BBSW and proved once more an appealing funding source during this period. As we signalled at the full year, wholesale funding costs have risen. That subtracted 3 basis points from margin. The replicating portfolio gained from the rising rate environment, adding 7 basis points to NIM through capital and low cost deposits.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveWe maintained elevated holdings of liquid assets as we returned the Committed Liquidity Facility and began substituting the Term Funding Facility. In the opening months of this calendar year, we deliberately capitalized on attractive investor demand. That choice trimmed NIM by 9 basis points across the half and was a sensible move given the strains in funding markets. Lastly, third-party costs produced a 3 basis point effect on NIM. Now, on the NIM outlook: although margins rose during the half, persistent sector-wide pressure in mortgages — especially retention discounting — plus the funding cost effects as banks move to replace the TFF mean we anticipate NIM will fall in the second half. Our focus will remain on expanding within higher-returning segments and refining the mix of our portfolio. Funding costs are set to weigh on margins. Competition for deposits is intense, and we expect wholesale funding costs to rise. The replicating portfolio will keep delivering a benefit. Liquidity will continue to be affected as we further build the bank's financial resilience and seize chances to pre-fund the TFF replacement as they emerge.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveBecause refinancing is running at elevated levels across the industry, portfolio duration could get shorter in the second half, and we'll begin to see customers shift away from fixed rate loans. That impact will mostly show up in FY 2024. Moving on to non-interest income, which is on slide 26. For the half, non-interest income came in at AUD 70 million, down AUD 20 million versus the prior comparative period and up slightly on 2H 2022, which reflects the fact that the large one-off items flagged in the first half of last year did not recur. Operating expenses rose 7% compared with the prior corresponding period, reaching AUD 495 million for the half. Inflation was the main driver of that increase, along with AUD 11 million of higher costs tied to technology and proactive customer contact. During the half we delivered AUD 13 million of annualized synergies, and we remain on track to hit our target of AUD 70 million-AUD 80 million by FY 2023. This marks the program's final year, and it's also the last year we'll report on it separately. As we look toward the second half, we anticipate continued inflation and ongoing costs associated with maintaining legacy systems as we build the digital bank.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveBeyond that, and so we can move our strategic digitization goals forward quickly, we expect higher expenses and growth in FTE tied to investment spending during the second half. As Patrick mentioned earlier, we have a strategic program running to make the bank simpler. We are not satisfied with our cost base, and that program will cut duplication, improve our operating model, and stays sharply focused on hitting our cost to income target. Moving to our continuing transformation investment on slide 28. Our investment spend this half includes the cost of the Integrated Risk Program. Integration costs have stepped down, as we noted at the full year. Our investment has concentrated on our re-retail digital transformation and on delivering our data capabilities. Later this month, we will launch the first phase of ME Digital Deposits on the same core platform used by the myBOQ and VMA brands. That is a major milestone in making our bank digital. Now to provisioning and loan impairment expense on slide 29. Although we have begun to see a modest rise in arrears in the housing and business portfolios, that comes off a very low base and is still below long-term historical averages.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveOur provisioning approach has been cautious, and total provisions stand at AUD 313 million. The portfolio is in a good position, since customers hold substantial household savings and repayment buffers. Loan impairment expense came to AUD 34 million for the half, which reflects a more normalized long-term level. Impaired assets fell once more during the half, ending at AUD 133 million. We feel confident about the quality of our portfolio, which has now recorded five consecutive halves of lower exposure in the high DTI and high LVR bands. Both measures beat industry averages, which means we hold more resilience against higher interest rates and lower house prices. Relative to the industry, our business lending portfolio carries significantly less unsecured lending and is well diversified across geography, size, and asset class. We also recognize that some customers are facing, or will face, difficult financial periods amid higher interest rates and greater cost of living pressures. We are supporting them through this and will keep doing so. Turning to funding and liquidity on slide 30. During the half, our CLF was returned, and we pre-funded the initial tranches of the TFF replacement. We acted strategically here, capitalizing on favorable wholesale spreads.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveOur liquidity portfolio holds a varied blend of high-quality liquid assets, and for the half our spot LCR came in at 143%, running above that level on average, especially during the second quarter. We maintain a varied set of long-term unsecured and secured debt programs, which lets us seize opportunities in a competitive wholesale market. Customer deposits are up 12.3% versus the prior corresponding period. During the half we brought in more than 76,000 new customers, and the count of those who treat BOQ as their main financial institution grew 4%. On the myBOQ platform, new-to-bank customers average 32 years of age, versus an average of 45 on BOQ legacy platforms. That speaks to our digital strategy, which offers an appealing customer proposition. Happily, our loans to deposit ratio strengthened to 80%, 6 basis points better than the prior comparative period. In addition to our new retail customers, we have further developed our platform arrangements, which underpin a stable funding position. Inside customer deposits, we observed a continuing shift as customers moved out of transaction accounts into savings and term deposit products, seeking yield in a higher interest rate environment. Although our total transaction balance declined, we saw strong growth in the number of customers who transact with us on that digital bank.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThis marks the first reporting period under Basel III, and we're glad that this framework produced a positive impact of 120 basis points for us, thanks to a reduction of AUD 5 billion in risk-weighted assets. Under this new framework, our target range is now 10.25%-10.75%. That's prudent given an uncertain economic climate, and we keep investing in strengthening and transforming the bank. At the end of the half, our capital position is strong, and with CET1 of 10.71% we sit at the top end of our new range. To sum up, BOQ has posted a half-year result featuring a 10% increase to underlying profit. We delivered on our commitment to positive jaws and stayed disciplined in how we deployed capital in an intensely competitive environment. We've recognized the need to invest in our financial and operational resilience, including raising a provision for our Integrated Risk Program. This is the final year of what was an ambitious integration. We are on track to deliver what we promised we would, with AUD 70 million-AUD 80 million in annual synergies to be delivered in the full year. We have bolstered our capital and liquidity position and are confident in the quality of our credit portfolio.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveI'll now hand things back to Patrick for closing comments and the full-year outlook.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThanks, Racheal. Turning to slide 34 for the outlook. Australia's economy remains resilient, backed by low unemployment, steady growth in order books, and strong terms of trade. The nation's banking system, together with a robust regulatory environment, supports stability after the recent U.S. bank failures and developments in Europe. Economic growth is set to slow in the second half and into 2024, reflecting elevated inflation and the recent rapid rise in interest rates. We expect industry headwinds to persist over the six months ahead, with the current intensity of mortgage competition likely to continue and deposit competition having escalated through Term Funding Facility refinancing. We anticipate margin pressure during this period, which reaffirms the need for disciplined execution of our strategic priorities so we can transform into a scalable, low-cost bank with strong foundations. As Racheal said, we strategically reduced high DTI and high LVR lending, which supports strong customer cash buffers and reduced our exposure to property price reductions. We're expecting increased impairment expense below the industry longer-term average as a result of sustained higher inflation and interest rate, and the interest rate environment. Our share price is trading at a material discount to book value and a relatively low price-to-earnings multiple, which does not reflect the material investment being made in the transformation of BOQ.
Patrick Allaway
executiveThe headwinds currently affecting the industry mean we need to take a medium-term perspective on the benefits. To sum up, BOQ finds itself in a robust position. Our capital and liquidity ratios have been reinforced, underpinned by solid asset quality and sensible risk settings. We've posted one more half of positive jaws and achieved better NIM across the period. Given intensified competition in mortgages and deposits, NIM faced pressure during the final two months of the half. We're happy to report a 10% rise in underlying profit across the period. Our digitalization efforts have advanced considerably. We've achieved a solid result in our digital deposits franchise and remain on schedule to launch digital mortgages in FY 2024 and complete a full ME migration onto the new digital platform in FY 2025. We recognize that a great many of our customers are experiencing the effects of elevated inflation and cash rates. We are engaging with them proactively and stand ready to give our customers and our staff support throughout this uncertain period. We're putting investment into lifting our operational resilience and risk culture, and into simplifying the bank. As these programs move forward, a stronger BOQ will emerge, positioned to seize opportunities that create lasting value for our shareholders. Our conviction in the strategy is high.
Patrick Allaway
executiveWhat we're investing to make BOQ stronger, more digital, and simpler is going to optimize earnings and deliver a substantial increase in enterprise value. Thanks for joining us this morning. At this point I'll turn things back to Tanya so we can begin the Q&A.
Tanya Aaskov
executiveThanks, Patrick. At this point we'll open the lines for phone questions. Please keep it to two questions each. Naturally, if you have more questions about the results, management will gladly address them later today. Thank you, operator.
Operator
operatorThank you. To ask a question, press star one on your phone and hold until your name is called. Should you wish to withdraw your request, press star two. Those using a speakerphone should lift the handset before asking a question. Once more, we kindly ask everyone to keep questions to two per person. Our first question is from Matt Dunger at Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Matt Dunger
analystYes. Thanks a lot for taking my question. To start off, you're pointing to more competition for deposits. Given this environment, why do you want to grow deposits rather than turn to funding markets? Are those markets open to BOQ at the moment?
Patrick Allaway
executiveAppreciate that, Matt. For us, deposit markets have come at lower cost. On top of that, we were in a blackout window before results came out, which meant no access to our wholesale markets. Going forward, we'll keep tapping both the wholesale markets and the deposit markets. As we've noted, building liquidity and optimizing how our funding is mixed have truly been aimed at supporting the hand-back of the CLF and the replacement of the TFF — and in April, you know, we had 23% payback of that. During this period, we believe it makes sense to run a higher ratio of deposits to loans to support those strong liquidity buffers.
Matt Dunger
analystThanks a lot. If I could just ask a quick follow-up here — can you put a number on it? You mentioned the effect of the move into term deposits compared with that call. Could you quantify that for us?
Patrick Allaway
executivePerhaps I'll simply ask Racheal about that.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveMatt, looking at the margin walk, you can see that we've continued to benefit from term deposits during this period. I noted that they remain priced relatively favorably because they're priced off the BBSW, so TDs are still an advantage. What we're observing in the market right now is that, given the heightened competition, TD pricing is rising. As Patrick laid out, we will always simply aim to optimize funding costs across a wide range of areas, including wholesale markets as well as retail deposits within, you know, savings, term deposits, and the developments through our digital assets, where we're seeing additional customers move over from a transaction perspective as well.
Matt Dunger
analystAll right, thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Andrew Lyons with Goldman Sachs. You have the floor.
Andrew Lyons
analystThanks. Morning, everyone. I have just 2 questions for you. First, on your NIM. At the FY 2022 result in October last year, management's remarks about the NIM back then were quite optimistic, referring to an exit NIM comfortably above the 1.81% posted in the fourth quarter. Even so, today you've reported a NIM averaging only 1.79% across the half, and you noted that NIMs peaked in October 2022, which mathematically implies the exit NIM for this half had to be meaningfully under the half NIM as reported. So, consistent with what was said last half, could you perhaps give some commentary on the second quarter 2023 NIM and on how far below the half average that exit NIM sat?
Patrick Allaway
executiveLet me offer a few remarks on the first part of your question, and then I'll address the second part. Headwinds for the industry have intensified throughout the sector, and obviously, you know, BOQ carries a higher cost of funding. Those two factors are both eating into the tailwind we enjoyed from them as we entered the half. As Racheal noted, that tailwind reached its peak in October. On the question of where NIM is headed, we won't speculate, and we don't provide an outlook for NIM. What we do know, and what we've stated, is that NIM compression will persist, with heightened competition in both mortgages and deposits weighing on NIM. There are quite a few moving parts involved there. It wouldn't be appropriate for us to say anything further at this stage about where NIM is.
Andrew Lyons
analystPatrick, I completely get why you’d prefer not to comment on the outlook, but would you be willing to discuss perhaps where the actual NIM for the second quarter of 2023 stood and where the exit NIM might have been relative to that actual second-quarter NIM?
Patrick Allaway
executiveNo, because like I mentioned, we said it's peaked. We said it compressed during the second quarter. Industry factors are affecting that, and you'll keep seeing NIM pressure through the second half.
Andrew Lyons
analystThanks for that. Now, a second question about expenses. On slide 28, it's noted that the AUD 60 million provision for the Integrated Risk Program sits inside your wider investment spend. Yet total investment spend for the half rose only roughly AUD 6 million, and that means underlying investment spend actually dropped by AUD 54 million half over half — close to a third. I realize several factors are at play there, so I suppose what I'm asking is why management would cut the business's underlying investment spend by that much, given the need to digitize more broadly, which you've discussed. If that isn't what's happening, then why was the AUD 60 million charge taken below the line rather than treated as ordinary OpEx?
Patrick Allaway
executiveYour question is going to be answered by Racheal.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThe first point I would make is that, leaving aside the Integrated Risk Program, a fairly significant factor behind the lower investment spend is that this is the last year of the ME Bank integration. Roughly AUD 30 million of that decrease is tied to the integration wrapping up. My second point is that a couple of sizable programs did finish during the period, and through that the team has reworked the transformation roadmap. We view this as a level of investment the business can sustain going forward, without jeopardizing any of our objectives for digitization, strengthening, and simplifying, and in particular without jeopardizing any financial targets we have set out, such as the ROE and CTI targets.
Richard Wiles
analystGood. Just to verify — when we think about investment spending, it should be the first-half level minus the AUD 60 million from the IRP.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThat's pretty much the level we expect to operate at across the coming two halves. Right.
Richard Wiles
analystAll right, thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from John Storey at UBS. Go right ahead.
John Storey
analystMany thanks. Morning, Racheal and Patrick. Excellent presentation. I have just a couple of questions. The first concerns asset quality. One thing we've noticed is that your 30 day plus arrears have risen rather sharply, certainly on a half-on-half basis. I just wanted to get a sense of how that trend looks in March and, I guess, the early parts of April, in terms of whether some of those arrears are converting or the backlog has cleared there. The second is really just about expectations for volume growth. We noted that new business app applications are down about 30%. I just wanted your sense of the trade-off between volume growth and pricing.
Patrick Allaway
executiveJohn, perhaps I could take the second part of your question, and then I'll turn to Racheal for the first part. As we mentioned in the presentation, we're highly focused on putting our capital to work appropriately so that we earn appropriate returns. As we've also noted, the mortgage market specifically is extremely competitive right now. We don't want the right business priced below our cost of capital. Quality growth is a major focus for us. We're retaining capital and directing it toward business bank opportunities, where we've seen growth during the first half. We've also kept our capital position because we do expect the market to rationalize, and we anticipate earning appropriate returns from that. We will sit this out. System growth has obviously declined as well, we've seen. The market is clearly more and more competitive for a much smaller market share than we previously held. Our view is that we won't participate in an irrational market.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveJohn, to respond to the question about arrears: we are definitely very watchful of the fact that arrears are rising, but at this stage we are not alarmed. They have carried on creeping up somewhat again after the end of February. The first point is that they are coming off a very low base and remain well under historical averages. When I consider the level of provisioning we hold, we are confident that this provision level accounts for a number of forward-looking scenarios spanning a wide range of potential outcomes. The connection between arrears and the suitability of the provision level we have, we believe, remains quite strong.
John Storey
analystPerfect, I appreciate that a lot.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Richard Wiles of Morgan Stanley. You have the floor.
Richard Wiles
analystGood morning, everyone. Two questions from me. First, on expenses: Patrick Allaway, at what point will you actually bring the cost base down? When you say you expect material cost benefits in FY 2024, does that mean costs will decline during that year, or is reducing costs more of a medium-term objective? Second, I'd like some clarity on your outlook commentary and guidance. I understand you aren't commenting on run rate margins right now, but the margin certainly appears to have been close to 1.7% at the end of the quarter, and you flagged additional pressure ahead. Given that pressure on margins, are you still on track for positive jaws in the full year 2023, which was the guidance given at the start of the year? Can you hit your FY 2026 ROE and cost to income targets if margins don't expand from where they are now?
Patrick Allaway
executiveThanks for that question, Richard. Let me start with expenses. While we're constructing the new bank, we're still running the old one, and that means dual system costs until legacy is decommissioned. That's what's driving the cost escalation right now. As we've mentioned, the bulk of that expense growth comes from running dual systems, along with inflation, investment and amortization. Those pressures have been partly offset by productivity and synergies. The expense growth we saw in the first half is not something we're comfortable with, and we're taking action on it. As we've said, we're tackling it through a simplification program. A considerable amount of work has already gone into that program. We'll return to the market in the second half with an update on the target productivity benefits from it. As I noted in the commentary, we don't expect that to materially reduce costs in the second half. We see cost escalation continuing in the second half, and we're driving for the material productivity benefits to begin from FY 2024. Just to clarify that point. You asked about the outlook for positive jaws in the second half. Clearly, given those statements, achieving positive jaws will be difficult.
Patrick Allaway
executiveI'll stop there. On how confident we are about bringing down our CTI targets and hitting the return on equity targets we've laid out for FY 2026 — we hold strong conviction in the transformation program we're pursuing and the simplification program we've kicked off, which adds further support to that transformation effort. To reach those targets, we're now taking considerably bigger steps on simplification productivity than we had before. And yes, those targets do assume — and we made that qualification clear, as you'd have seen in the presentation pack — that they assume market competition becomes more rational and that NIM normalizes.
Richard Wiles
analystThanks, Patrick.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Jonathan Mott at Barrenjoey. Go right ahead.
Jonathan Mott
analystThank you, Patrick. I have a question that also concerns volumes. As you know, we witnessed a steep decline across every channel during the last half, and you mentioned wanting to stay rational rather than compete in these conditions. I can see where you're coming from. My real worry is what happens next to the owner-managed branches, since those are franchisees. Franchisees are essentially compensated for expanding their business and building a book as time goes on, and truly growing their operation. Granted, there is some payout when margins improve over a stretch, but that will disappear in the coming period or two. If rivalry persists for a long stretch and the market is able to stay irrational for a long stretch, how do you retain the franchisees? How do you keep them motivated when they see so few chances to grow their own business over a stretch of time?
Patrick Allaway
executiveAppreciate that, Jonathan. This is something we've considered carefully, and the business has other dimensions that matter a great deal to them. Clearly, deposits are expanding, and our owner-manager branches are a key contributor to that deposit growth and share in the upside. As our attention increasingly shifts toward small to medium-sized enterprises, in the core centers where our own managers sit, we're seeing a growing chance to draw on the strong community relationships they hold in order to expand O&SME business. You'll have noticed the very strong growth in the first half across O&SME business. That's delivering strong returns for us. The owner-manager network also has further opportunities to gain from the products and services we offer.
Jonathan Mott
analystThe OMBs need to shift in a real way — from a focus that's mostly mortgage-based over to an SME focus, and that is genuinely a very, very different kind of business. So the question is whether they possess the capability and the skill set required to serve as business bankers.
Patrick Allaway
executiveAbsolutely. We have some outstanding bankers who’ve spent 20 years in their communities working with local businesses, and 15 to 20 years in the business itself. We’re looking to draw on that strength more effectively. Our specialist business bankers give them strong backing. In fact, we’re even considering whether to place business bankers in some of those owner-manager branches. That’s a central element of our plan to grow our relationship bank and to back the communities, and the businesses within those communities, where we operate.
Jonathan Mott
analystThanks. One more question, if I may — and this is likely directed at you, Racheal. You mentioned that retention discounting cost 7 basis points during the period. For many of the banks, that's probably going to be a larger drag than the front book, back book. Could you give us a sense of how far along you are in the repricing? I realize this is a dynamic situation, not a static one where you begin from a single point, but are there still a substantial number of customers on old pricing? That's going to be a continuing drag for a stretch of time. Even if mortgage competition lets up, you still have that ongoing amortization of high margin mortgages rolling off. How far through that process are you?
Patrick Allaway
executiveI'll hand that over to Racheal. Thanks.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThanks, John. That's a fair question. We do anticipate that this will keep weighing on us over the coming period, at a minimum. 70% of our portfolio is variable, and of that portion, roughly one-third has accessed a discount. We know we're likely about a third of the way through. It's unlikely that every customer will reach a discounted position, but, you know, I think we do have a little bit further to go, particularly through the second half.
Jonathan Mott
analystI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Josh Freiman at Macquarie. You have the floor.
Josh Freiman
analystHi folks, I appreciate the chance to pose a few questions. Perhaps the first one relates to that mortgage competition, picking up where Marty left off. I'm aware that, you know, major banks have recently been trying to lift their front book variable rates, and I'm fairly sure that's likely because they've witnessed competition across both sides of the balance sheet, and all of us have seen sub-economic front book rates on mortgages. I just want to ask, have you actually observed any meaningful shift in how intense front book mortgage competition is there as a result of that?
Patrick Allaway
executiveRacheal, would you take that one? Thanks, Josh.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYeah. Look, Josh, we're seeing a few very early hints of softening when it comes to front-to-back book pricing, I'd say, but it's so early and probably so immaterial at this point that we aren't forecasting any material shift in that right now.
Josh Freiman
analystThanks. My second question is about how myBOQ and deposits in the new system are growing. I'm aware that the cost of deposits for savings and at call accounts on the legacy system differs quite a lot from what applies on myBOQ, which is clearly much higher. Looking at your deposit base, it seems to be divided with 95% of deposits sitting in the legacy systems against 5% in the new myBOQ and equivalent. I suppose, as you move customers across, I'd expect the push to shift accounts into considerably more attractive deposit accounts to be materially weaker than it is today. So what plans do you have to offset this deposit shift margin impact over the medium term? Or is that margin impact something already factored into your budgets and plans?
Patrick Allaway
executiveWe are definitely giving our customers an appealing deposit rate on new banking apps, and we view that as a highly important service for our customer base. As we kind of move customers onto the platform, we are really seeking more sticky transactional accounts, which matters a great deal to us. This isn't merely a deposit base. Clearly, in today's higher interest rate environment, we are observing customers shifting away from transaction accounts into deposit products with higher yields. Our belief is that we will in fact have a solid mix across both. We're going to have a far lower cost platform when it comes to servicing customers, and we believe the net benefits will actually deliver improved returns for BOQ.
Josh Freiman
analystAll right, just to pick up on that point — as those legacy deposits move over to the new platform, you don't see any danger of them turning into meaningfully more expensive ones, do you?
Patrick Allaway
executiveActually, that isn’t the case for us.
Josh Freiman
analystGot it.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Andrew Triggs at JPMorgan. Go ahead, please.
Andrew Triggs
analystThanks, and good morning to Patrick and Racheal. I have a couple of questions as well, please. Starting with the first one: can you help break down that 9 basis point liquidity headwind to NIM between the CLF replacement and TFF pre-funding? My assumption is that the NIM pressure coming from CLF replacement is roughly revenue-neutral, whereas TFF pre-funding is not. And just on that pre-funding piece, how much of the TFF have you pre-funded so far? The TFF rolls over over the coming few halves, so do you expect to stay fully pre-funded across the next three halves? Then maybe there's a tailwind at the end of that stretch, when you allow LCR and NSFRs to run down after TFF maturity.
Patrick Allaway
executiveI’ll pass it to Racheal for that. After Racheal, I may have a few remarks.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveAbsolutely, and thank you, Patrick. The effect on liquidity is going to remain a headwind across the second half, and as you know, a substantial share of our TFF matures in FY 2024. Regarding how much we have already funded, right now roughly AUD 1.2 billion of the TFF is rolling off in FY 2023. We have gotten through approximately AUD 1 billion of that amount. From where we sit, that is a genuine positive. You are correct. Out of the 9 basis points, the bulk of that effect is tied to what it costs to replace the TFF, along with holding liquidity as the TFF shifts into our LCR window. A minor piece of it is connected to the CLF.
Patrick Allaway
executiveI'll add a few other remarks on that. We believe it makes sense to keep larger liquidity buffers in place during this period. That does put pressure on NIM, but it's the right call given how big the task is for the market right now, with both the CLF run-off and the TFF run-off happening. To put some figures on it, CLF stood at AUD 243 billion. Across the industry, the TFF is AUD 188 billion. The funding task facing the industry is very large, and we think it's appropriate to accept some compromise on NIM in the interim so that we can be sure our liquidity buffers stay really strong through this period.
Andrew Triggs
analystThanks. My second question concerns the possibility of reducing the typical duration of mortgage loans. What I'd like to know is how advanced that review currently is, and perhaps you could offer some form of sensitivity analysis regarding what could happen to NIM should that duration be cut.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveSure. What I mean is that we are observing something like steady declines from one month to the next, which is what you'd anticipate, especially considering the elevated volumes of fixed rate mortgages that, as you know, were originated throughout the industry. There might be an effect of a couple of basis points on margin at. Should we be required to, if circumstances put us in a spot where reducing that weighted average life becomes necessary and we need to pull forward a portion of the acquisition costs tied to those customers.
Andrew Triggs
analystRacheal, thank you for that. Could you say anything about the retention rates you're seeing across your book, especially regarding the fixed rate maturities, please?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveWe aren't truly yet at a stage where lots of fixed rate customers are rolling off; the great bulk of those customers on fixed rates will begin rolling in FY 2024.
Patrick Allaway
executiveWhat I'd emphasize is that our priority right now is holding on to the customers we already have and helping them through this intensely competitive period, rather than chasing growth in new customers.
Andrew Triggs
analystI mean, if you read between the lines there, retention rates really haven't shifted so far, but obviously most of the fixed rate rolls are still ahead.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveRight, yeah. The shortening, I mean, has been occurring across several periods. You’d want to watch, well, several halves in which you’re observing a shortening before making any adjustments to your weighted average life. It isn’t solely driven by the fixed rate maturities.
Andrew Triggs
analystI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. The next question is from Brett Le Mesurier at Velocity.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystMuch appreciated. In terms of working out ROE for mortgages, what is your approach to establishing the cost figures?
Patrick Allaway
executiveBrett, I missed what you asked — could you say it again? My apologies.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystWhat's the method you use for calculating mortgages?
Patrick Allaway
executiveYou're breaking up again. The connection is pretty poor. Let's give that another try.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystWhat method do you use to figure out the cost of funding when you're working out the ROE on mortgages?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThere's an internal FTP process we use that lets us see, at any point in time, what the acquisition cost would be — meaning the funding cost for any new loan. That's the basis on which we figure out the ROE. We take a portfolio view of returns on a portfolio, on a mortgage portfolio, and we also examine acquisition returns.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystIs that a blend of retail — the retail you have now — along with funding costs?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThat's right. Yeah. Yeah.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystWhen you’re calculating this, do you apply the bankwide average cost-to-income ratio?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveSo there are several approaches we use when examining cost allocations, if that’s what you’re getting at. As part of that, we consider the marginal cost involved in bringing on a new customer, and we also examine the average cost across our customer count, along with what it takes to keep that base going and serve the customers we already have.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystIs it reasonable to say that your cost-to-income ratio sits below the bank-wide average?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveWhen we go through that analysis, every cost gets allocated, so in aggregate we aren’t working with a reduced cost-to-income figure — no.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystWith that target for FY 2026, will that let you cover your cost of capital?
Patrick Allaway
executiveYeah. We're losing quite a bit of your audio, so hearing you is pretty difficult.
Brett Le Mesurier
analystSince your return on equity right now sits at roughly 8.5%, could you identify for us the products that are genuinely clearing your cost of capital?
Patrick Allaway
executiveThat level of detail probably isn't something we'll get into on this call. For sure, we can follow up with you on it when we reconnect.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Ed Henning at CLSA. You have the floor.
Ed Henning
analystHi, I have a couple of questions. First, could you clarify something? You mentioned that positive jaws are going to be difficult in the second half, but have you moved away from your full-year guidance for positive jaws?
Patrick Allaway
executiveGiven the headwinds the industry is facing right now, and considering where we're trading at present, we're not sticking with that positive jaws guidance.
Ed Henning
analystAll right, I appreciate the clarification. I have a few questions. In the past, the BOQ teams mentioned that the home loan brands aim at various market segments. Could you discuss how competition looks across those segments? Is one brand experiencing heavier competition and greater margin pressure compared with the others, or is the margin pressure roughly the same for all of them on the mortgage side?
Patrick Allaway
executiveRight. Our brands and the segments we serve each offer value propositions that are quite distinct. Across the entire industry, it would be reasonable to say we are all encountering headwinds of a very similar kind.
Ed Henning
analystAll right, just one more. You know, you've provided certain specifics — the cost simplification program, a digital strategy, and an operating model — and these have come up previously. Is it that you don't currently know what this will cost, or are you simply looking at possibly getting more costs out, or, you know, is inflationary pressure sort of preventing you from releasing some cost targets at this point? I'm just attempting to work out why, given that the plans are in place, you aren't providing us with additional detail at this stage until the second half?
Patrick Allaway
executiveWe have a clear investment roadmap, and we understand its costs very well. Our future investment program has not been disclosed to the market. We don't believe that would be appropriate. As for the simplification program, that's a newer initiative. Over the last couple of years, we have had ongoing productivity benefits of about AUD 30 million. Given where our cost pressure is at the moment, we've told you that it's unacceptable and that we are not comfortable with the expense growth in the business. At the beginning of this calendar year, we initiated a material program of work to look at how we could more simplify the bank and get more productivity benefits. That work is not complete. We know where we will be targeting those expenses. We've, we have more work to do. We'll come back, in the second half, as we've said, to give a very clear outlook as to those productivity benefits. The reason we're not disclosing today is we're not ready. We certainly are giving you a very strong heads-up that we are addressing our expense inflation, we're not comfortable with it, and we're gonna take material measures to drive productivity benefits.
Ed Henning
analystUnderstood—that's clear. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Nathan Lead at Morgans Financial. Go right ahead.
Nathan Lead
analystAppreciate the presentation. My first question: regarding that New Zealand asset sale you're aiming to finish, what are your plans for the capital from it, and how will it affect earnings as well as regulatory ratios?
Patrick Allaway
executiveRight now, we don't have any plans for those funds. It's going to help our capital position. That sale hasn't closed yet. We're kind of in the last phases of working toward completing the sale process, but that isn't capital we're counting on today. Down the road, it's definitely something we'll factor in. Like we've said, we want to maintain larger capital buffers. We're putting our capital to work in the right places — across portfolio growth, but also the investment in our digital transformation, and making sure we've got sufficient capital buffers to get through this cycle.
Nathan Lead
analystI have a second question. Could you talk about how long your investment securities portfolio runs, and remind us of your approach to managing interest rate risk on it?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveEvery one of those securities carries a full hedge. Interest rate exposure is hedged across the board. Credit risk makes up only a minor piece, yet as far as rate risk goes, everything is completely hedged and marked to market. Those securities get marked to market by us. Our duration stance on that book is mixed, so a portion of those securities you will find placed out past 5 years, while others get placed at shorter maturities, driven mainly by what returns are available to us.
Nathan Lead
analystYes. I appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. The following question is from Azib Khan at Morgans Financial. You have the floor.
Azib Khan
analystThanks a lot. I’ll start with a question about margins, then follow with one about costs. On margin, when I look at deposit tailwinds outside the replicating portfolio, there was a 25 basis point benefit from savings in TDs in first half 2023. There was an 11 basis point benefit from savings in TDs in second half 2022. That’s a 36 basis point benefit in total across the two halves, which came from savings and TD rates, with rate rises lagging cash rate rises. With them calling that out, or you’ve mentioned that deposit competition escalated in the second quarter and is likely to continue, you know, if I look at your savings deposit rates and carded TD rates in the market, they’re very attractive and sitting above the cash rate. Can we expect that 36 basis points of NIM benefits that came across the last 2 halves to now start dissipating?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYes, Azib — our projection is that this becomes a headwind.
Azib Khan
analystYeah. Racheal, is that 36 going to vanish and then some? Is that the way we should be thinking about it?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveNo, the 36 stays. It'll simply become a headwind during the second half. We anticipate some benefits coming through, especially on the savings front. We are observing certain headwinds where term deposits are concerned. You can look at the graph included at the back of the pack showing where the BBSW has moved. Also, and more significantly, there's currently a great deal of competition for term deposits throughout the industry. Term deposits are experiencing margin compression. The final factor is really that we've witnessed customers shifting funds out of lower yielding products and up into those higher yielding accounts. That mix shift will act as a drag through the second half too.
Azib Khan
analystRacheal, on the savings deposits point you raised, am I right to read it as meaning that, on average, the increases in your savings deposit rate are still trailing the rises in the cash rate?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveRight, yes. That advantage is still showing up, isn't it.
Azib Khan
analystAll right, thanks. My second question is about costs. I realize you'll be giving more information on the simplification program during the next half, but is there a good chance that program will involve restructuring provisions?
Patrick Allaway
executiveAt this point, we won't be making any comment on that. As you remove material productivity, naturally you'd anticipate restructuring costs coming along with it. Like I mentioned, we'll get back to you on this. We won't proceed with this or put money into it unless it delivers productivity gains that hold up over the long term. Should restructuring costs arise, the investment case built on long-term benefits for BOQ will certainly justify them.
Azib Khan
analystI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. We'll take our next question from Brendan Sproules at Citi. Go ahead, please.
Brendan Sproules
analystMorning. I have a few questions. First, regarding asset quality. On Slide 29, it shows that the major shift in asset quality during this period was an increase in 90 days past due within your asset finance division. Was that actually caused by some of the problems we are observing in construction, or is there a wider trend you could identify for us?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveHi, Brendan. A few things come to mind. First, I'd note that the asset finance portfolio is fairly small — AUD 6.7 billion. Within it, we've got some construction exposure, and we've seen a bit of stress driven by supply chain problems. That has produced a modest rise in arrears, and we're watching it very closely. In asset finance, we're quite well diversified across both customer size and geography. None of the large companies that have recently gone into liquidation represent direct exposure for us, though we're definitely keeping a close eye on how that portfolio is performing.
Brendan Sproules
analystAll right, thanks. My second question concerns the anti-money-laundering procedures you are in the process of improving. I noticed the materials say you could potentially face fines or penalties — that is a possibility. Did that possibility prompt the disclosure you made today, and is it essentially your way of signaling that at some point further along there will have been some kind of breach of your systems during the recent period?
Patrick Allaway
executiveThanks for asking that. As you’re aware, we’ve kept showing that our disclosure practices are quite robust. If there were anything to disclose regarding fines, enforceable undertakings, or action in the future, we would make that known—and doing so would in fact be obligatory for us. Over the last six months, we’ve communicated with considerable transparency and clarity about the need to bolster our operational risk and resilience. In our financial accounts, it is appropriate to highlight the risks tied to failing to meet regulatory requirements. And that has been highlighted appropriately.
Brendan Sproules
analystAlright, thanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. Since no more questions have come in, I'll turn things back over to Ms. Aaskov now for any closing remarks.
Tanya Aaskov
executiveWe appreciate everyone being here today. Naturally, the management team will gladly address any additional questions you might have regarding the results at a later point today. Thanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Bank of Queensland Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Bank of Queensland Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Bank of Queensland Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.