Bank of Queensland Limited (BOQ) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 10, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone being on the line, and we're glad to have you at the Bank of Queensland FY '23 Results Briefing. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn the call over to Jessica Smith, our General Manager of Investor Relations and ESG. Over to you.
Jessica Smith
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining Bank of Queensland's presentation of results for the full year that ended 31 August 2023. I'm Jessica Smith, General Manager of Investor Relations and ESG at BOQ. Before we start, I'd like to pay my respects to the traditional custodians of the land where we're meeting today, the Gadigal people, and to acknowledge elders past and present. Thank you for making the time to be with us this morning. Joining me is Patrick Allaway, our Managing Director and CEO; and Racheal Kellaway, Chief Financial Officer. BOQ's executive team and senior management are also here in the room with us. Today, we'll present an overview of our full year results. Patrick will outline the key features of the result and also provide an update on BOQ's strategy. Racheal will then speak to our financial results before Patrick closes with a summary and outlook. Following the briefing, there will be an opportunity for questions. I will now hand over to Patrick.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveThank you, Jess, and good morning to all of you, and I appreciate you making time to join us this morning. I would also like to extend a welcome to our Chairman and our executive team, who are here in the room with Racheal and me today. I'll begin on Slide 8 of the investor pack, where I'll share some key messages to leave with you. BOQ has a solid platform on which to build, supported by our 149-year heritage of serving customers and local communities. We have distinctive brands operating in niche segments, along with a quality, well-secured $81 billion lending portfolio with diversified revenue streams spanning retail and business banking. This year we delivered $450 million in after-tax cash earnings and $124 million in statutory profit after tax. Our cash earnings result reflects the industry margin and cost inflation headwinds that we called out at the half. Our statutory result reflects the cost of a business in transformation, addressing decade-long legacy issues stemming from underinvestment in technology and inadequate integration from multiple acquisitions over our history. We also have changes in the way we work, reducing our property footprint. We recognize this has been a difficult year for our shareholders, with changes in leadership, identified weaknesses in our operational resilience and risk maturity, and the subsequent voluntary and court enforceable undertakings with our regulators.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveLater in the presentation, I'll discuss how we've embraced accountability and consequence management regarding these results. Through the cycle, we keep investing in our business, and in FY '23 we accepted a temporary performance trade-off in exchange for medium- and long-term gains. We've sped up investment in our digital transformation so we can enhance the customer experience, broaden our funding sources on the new digital banking platform, and lower our cost to serve. We've put money into risk and restructuring to reinforce operational resilience, cut operational complexity, and secure productivity gains. Growth in mortgages has been tempered, with priority given to retaining customers and economic return. Our financial resilience has been bolstered by carrying larger capital and liquidity buffers throughout the economic downturn and the term funding facility repayment. We're taking the tough decisions needed to confront our challenges directly. Transformation is moving quickly, with key milestones delivered on plan and budget in FY '23. Our simplification program targets more than $200 million in productivity benefits between FY '24 and FY '26, with the goal of offsetting cost inflation. Through digital transformation we're building a scalable, simpler, digitally enabled bank that's future fit for growth and returns. Over this period, we'll stay focused on diversifying our revenue mix and lifting our margin by growing our Business Bank and capital-light revenues.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe hold strong confidence in the transformation plan we've set out, and there's a clear road map for building a bank that is stronger and simpler — one that works better for customers, better for our people, and delivers improved returns to shareholders. In the market conditions we face today, we're focused on managing the things within our control, and we're putting BOQ in position for recovery and growth once the cycle turns. If you'll turn to Slide 9, we'll walk through the financial overview. Statutory net profit for the full year came in at $124 million. That figure includes 4 below-the-line items, among them the goodwill impairment and the risk remediation provision we took in the first half. As we told you at the half, we would be moving ahead with a simplification program aimed at delivering future productivity benefits, and for that we recorded a $35 million after-tax restructuring charge in the second half. We also announced $44 million in after-tax additional ME integration costs, which stem from recent decisions to further consolidate our property footprint in Melbourne and to accelerate ME's digital transformation. Cash earnings for this year were $450 million, including income growth of 5%, which was offset by higher costs and by loan impairment expense rising to more normalized levels. At the half, we highlighted an initial margin tailwind, and as we noted, that had turned in October 2022.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveLooking ahead, we expect tougher competition in both mortgages and deposits during the second half. That is what we have seen, and we chose not to chase mortgage pricing that fell below our cost of capital, putting economic return, customer retention and prudent risk settings first. Persistently high inflation across the second half, together with greater investment, weighed on our cost base, which grew 8% for the year. At the half, we recognize that this could not continue and that our simplification program would deal with it, with benefits flowing from FY '24. I will come to that soon. We kept strong capital and liquidity buffers throughout FY '23. Our CET1 ratio of 10.91% sits above our target range, and it underpinned the Board's choice to declare a final dividend of $0.21 per share. That amounts to a full year 59.7% payout range on cash earnings and a 7.1% dividend yield on the year-end share price. Racheal will give more context on the financial results shortly. Turning to Slide 10 for a view of the Retail Bank. Total income for the retail bank was flat on the prior year, as gains from the rising cash rate were more than offset by competitive pressures in housing and the normalization of noninterest income.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAs I mentioned during my introduction, we kept economic return ahead of growth as our priority, and that led to our mortgage book shrinking over the period. We'll keep watching this closely, and we're well placed to get back to growth once our lower cost to serve lands in 2024 or once rational pricing comes back to the market. Execution of our digital strategy remains strong, with more customers deciding to bank with us. All 3 retail banks -- all 3 retail brands now sit on the new digital banking platform, which delivers a better customer experience. We've seen 267% growth on the platform, and that has supported the group's funding profile with $5.5 billion in digital retail deposits. Moving to Slide 11 for a review of the Business Bank. We hold a diversified portfolio of assets across retail and business banking. The Business Bank has had a strong year, delivering 55% of the group's cash profit. Our strategic approach of prudent, targeted lending, along with highly specialized bankers who serve niche industry sectors where we can differentiate and win, has produced income growth of 14% for the Business Bank in the year. We achieved improvements to our risk-adjusted returns and a 4.5% improvement to cost-to-income ratio.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWhat sets us apart is our focus on lending to small and medium-sized enterprises in health care, agriculture, unoccupied commercial property, and equipment finance. With 87% secured lending, the book is well collateralized and diversified across geography, channel, and asset class. Now if you turn to Slide 12, we'll review our customer experience. We know customers can pick who they bank with, so delivering an experience that is consistent, exceptional, and differentiated is what will drive our success. We have amended our vision to be the bank that customers choose. To this end, we've elevated the customer voice across the organization and amended our operating model to create a Chief People and Customer Officer. We're building a differentiated approach, focused on niche customer segments across both relationship and digital banking. We are structuring the organization to serve customers the way they wish to be served, simplifying the banking experience. Those customers requiring a fast and simple self-help digital experience will be served through our ME and VMA national digital brands, leveraging our target state, low cost to serve, end-to-end digital banking platform. Those customers with more complex needs, requiring a human touch will be served through our BOQ brand, leveraging our deep community relationships, specialist bankers and unique owner-manager network.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveOur owner-manager network is deeply rooted in the communities they serve, and each of them is well placed to meet our customers' relationship banking needs in both retail and SME. As we work through a stretch of persistently high inflation and steep rises in interest rates, we have been engaging with our customers proactively, and that includes assisting more than 3,500 customers who faced hardship over the year. We have sharpened our focus on shielding customers from growing industry fraud and scams by means of education, collaboration with industry partners and monitoring of suspicious activity. The scams landscape is shifting fast, and criminals are growing more sophisticated and more targeted. While it is regrettable that we cannot stop every instance of customer loss, our teams helped prevent customers from losing in excess of $6 million in FY '23. Rolling out our new digital banking platform across all 3 retail brands has produced better NPS and App Store ratings and fueled 10% customer growth in FY '23, giving BOQ a more diversified funding base. Turning to Slide 13 for an overview of the transformation: our 4 strategic pillars — strengthen, simplify, digitize and optimize — are driving bold decisions to lift performance and create shareholder value. As I said in my opening comments, we are confident we hold the right strategy to tackle our legacy issues and build a future fit bank for the long-term benefit of our customers, people and shareholders.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveThose strategic pillars are meant to tackle the drawbacks we face — among them a higher cost of funding, a higher cost to serve stemming from a historical technology deficit, and an operating structure that is complex and duplicative. Now I'll go through each of those pillars in more depth. Our strengthened strategic pillar is covered on Slides 14 and 15. Over the course of the year, we bolstered financial resilience — lifting CET1 and our liquidity coverage ratio — thanks to prudent capital and liquidity settings. Early in the second half we announced that we had entered into 2 enforceable undertakings, one with APRA and one with AUSTRAC. We recognize and accept that BOQ must build stronger foundations, and that means fixing deficiencies in operational resilience, risk culture and governance, and our AML/CTF compliance. Over the past 18 months we have applied accountability and consequence management for those weaknesses, through leadership changes and the remuneration consequences that went with them. Turning to Slide 15. The scope of the 2 remediation programs has been finalized and submitted to the respective regulators. These multiyear programs are set to deliver meaningful and sustainable change, meeting all requirements under the 2 EUs. Program RQ is designed to strengthen risk culture, governance and operational resilience. AML First, meanwhile, focuses on addressing the weaknesses and gaps across BOQ's AML/CTF compliance.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe have clear work streams, deliverables, and actions set up to track sustainable embedment and reporting for these 2 programs. An independent assurance provider has been appointed to report to the Board and regulators. As we carry out these programs, we'll produce a stronger bank with better operational resilience, risk maturity, and culture. Slide 16 addresses our Simplify strategic pillar. Across our 149-year history, we've acquired complementary businesses to build our successful multi-brand approach. What we haven't done so well is fully integrate those businesses into our group structure. We recognize we can't wait for digitization to deliver future state productivity gains, and there's plenty we can do right now to simplify and streamline our business. At the half, we called out that we were starting a program of work to simplify BOQ aimed at providing productivity benefits. Meanwhile, investment in the digital transformation and strength in the target future operating state continues. This work will also help lower operational risk and get us ready to take full advantage of our digitization. As already mentioned, we've recognized a $35 million after-tax restructuring charge in FY '23, being implemented across 4 key work streams.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveDuring FY '23, we started putting our new operating model into practice. That included cutting 4 positions from the senior executive leadership team and lowering FTE by roughly 100. In the first quarter of FY '24, we'll take FTE down by another 150. Our technology transformation and the decommissioning of legacy platforms have carried on, with tech assets down a further 12% since FY '21 and the count of core banking platforms falling from 8 to 6. We've carried out a focused set of measures aimed at cutting supply spend and shrinking our property footprint. We've pinpointed key processes for automation and are cutting down the manual handoff points in home loan origination. As we head toward FY '26, we have targets set across each of our 4 work streams to simplify further and finalize the future operating model and the pathway to a materially lower cost to serve. In FY '24, we shifted to a shared service operating structure. A further 35 technology assets will be decommissioned in FY '24, and by FY '26 we're aiming to bring core banking platforms down from 6 to 3. Under our new ways of working, we're cutting 16,000 square meters of corporate property space, and we're targeting automation of 80% of our processes, including 95% of home lending controls, which will cut home loan origination costs by 50% in FY '25.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAll of this feeds into the productivity initiative we've set up, which is aimed at achieving more than $200 million of savings across 3 years and is designed to counterbalance cost inflation, with the benefits starting to come through in FY '24. On Slide 17, we get into the digitized strategic pillar. From the time we unveiled our 2020 strategy, we've achieved a great deal and are still tracking as planned in constructing our end-to-end cloud-based digital banking platform. Among the things we accomplished in FY '23: we delivered the road map on schedule and within budget, we upgraded the technology behind our business banking, we moved every one of our people onto 1 platform, which supports better collaboration and operation as an enterprise-wide team, and we launched ME transaction and saving accounts on the new cloud-based digital banking platform. Across the coming 12 to 24 months, BOQ will keep pushing work forward on the digital road map. Key milestones will be delivering digital mortgages in 2024 and decommissioning the ME legacy banking platform by FY '25. That will give us additional proof points on delivering our end-to-end scalable digital bank, which lets BOQ compete at a lower cost, with a faster time to yes and a better customer experience in a mortgage market that has become highly commoditized. Now on Slide 18. With ME Go now launched, all 3 retail brands have been delivered onto the digital banking platform.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveThroughout the year, digital deposits rose 267% to reach $5.5 billion. Our customer base expanded 103%, reflecting a combination of acquisitions of new-to-bank customers and those who migrated themselves from legacy platforms. With myBOQ, the average customer age has fallen to 34, versus 49 on BOQ legacy platforms. Encouragingly, these customers transact actively and are helping diversify our low-cost funding base. Slide 19 addresses our optimized strategic pillar. Heightened competition demands a simple operating model that is low-cost and scalable, alongside prudent capital allocation centered on return on equity. Within our optimization strategic initiative, more work lies ahead, and it will center on enhancing risk-adjusted returns and diversifying our business to optimize margin and capital-light revenues. By FY '26, we remain committed to hitting our cost to income and return on equity targets. Our updated financial model captures both today's revenue headwinds and the productivity initiatives we announced today. Turning to Slide 20. At BOQ, our purpose and values guide everything we do. Building social capital, our purpose, is about what we stand for as an organization. That covers doing the right thing, backing our customers and communities, enriching our people, and committing to our environmental targets.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveBy 2025, we remain on course to meet all of our energy requirements from renewable sources. During FY '23, we backed 9 community partners as they delivered essential services to vulnerable Australians, with $2.2 million invested. This year, BOQ introduced its fresh financial literacy initiative, featuring an introduction to budgeting plus the fundamentals of money management. In 2023, we were proud to work alongside Head Start housing, helping single parents, First Nations peoples and families in community housing to purchase their own home. In an Australian market first, ME Go customers were given the choice of 5 charity linked debit cards, and each one provides a $0.01 donation per digital wallet transaction. All of these illustrate how we build social capital through banking. With that said, I'll pass things to Racheal, who will walk through the financial results in greater detail. Over to you, Racheal.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThanks, Patrick, and good morning, everybody. For financial year 2023, BOQ Group reported cash earnings of $450 million. Total income rose 5% compared with the prior year. Inside that, net interest income increased 6%, helped by 3% growth in average loans aimed at higher returning segments, while margin fell 2 basis points. Noninterest income declined 7%, which reflected one-off items we outlined last year. Expense growth of 8% partly offset the income gains, and that left underlying profit 2% higher. Loan impairment expense rose from a very low base to more normalized levels, and as a result cash earnings finished 8% lower than the prior financial year. Slide 23 sets out statutory net profit of $124 million, down 70%. We have made a number of key decisions to set BOQ up for the future. We recognize that this year has again brought significant adjustments to cash earnings. These adjustments let us give a clearer view of our underlying performance. They included ME integration costs of $44 million after tax. That integration program is now complete, and I will cover it further shortly. As Patrick outlined, our simplification program is well progressed, and we recorded $35 million after tax in restructuring costs to deliver the benefits outlined.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveFinally, we observed modest improvements in the amortization of acquisition fair value adjustments as well as in hedging ineffectiveness. Now moving to the main components of the result shown on Slide 24. Total income came in at $1.7 billion, up 5% versus the prior year and down 7% on a half-on-half basis. NIM declined 2 basis points across the year, but it reached its peak in October 2022 and then fell to 1.58% during the second half. I'll cover this in greater depth later in the presentation, and I'm certain it will draw attention today. As we highlighted at the half, we took a deliberate decision regarding how we allocate our capital. That led to a 1% reduction in our mortgage portfolio. We recorded 2% growth in business lending across the year within targeted segments, along with 6% growth in Asset Finance, which produced flat overall lending growth relative to FY '22 and a decrease in the second half. Total customer deposits rose $6.1 billion over the year, which reflects strong execution of our strategy as we keep seeing more customers opt to bank with us, giving BOQ a stable funding source. As Patrick mentioned, we bolstered our financial resilience throughout the period and maintained conservative settings on LCR at 154% and on our capital ratio CET1 at 10.91%.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThat has given BOQ flexibility and resilience through uncertain economic conditions and as the RBA's term funding facility begins to be repaid across the sector. BOQ drew down on the TFF early, among the first banks to do so, with $3 billion of funding. We've taken strategic steps to replace it when wholesale market conditions have been favorable, and through customer deposits, which lifted our deposit to loan ratio to 83%. We're well along in replacing the TFF, with 60% repaid. With that as background, I'll now take you through the main elements of NIM. NIM contracted to 1.58% over the half. In the detail, lending had an adverse impact on NIM of 10 basis points. Retention discounting accounted for a 6 basis point impact, a slight improvement versus the first half. Low acquisition margins in housing, driven by competition, produced a front-to-back book impact of 4 basis points. We saw a slight benefit as customers rolled from fixed to variable rates. Competition for business lending is also strong, but we are seeing more rational pricing decisions in the market, with a 1 basis point impact to margin. As anticipated, funding costs became a headwind, with a 10 basis point impact in the half.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveWe keep benefiting from a tailwind tied to savings and at-call deposits, which helps NIM by 1 basis point, but competition for term deposits has more than offset that. Through the cycle, our comparatively smaller share of transaction accounts has weighed on us, which makes our digitization strategy even more essential. For the industry, term deposits are a competitive funding source as they replace the TFF. They are also a solid option for customers when a higher cost of living and high interest rates make yields even more important. As we flagged at the half, we also experienced higher wholesale funding costs. A 5 basis point liquidity impact includes the full-period effect of the committed liquidity facility handbag. We also ran a higher LCR during the period as we refinance the TFF. A 4 basis point benefit from cash rate rises on capital and low-cost deposits partially offset this. And we saw margin improve by 2 basis points thanks to lower third-party costs. Lastly, we had a one-off weighted average life adjustment because customers are refinancing faster across the industry than historically. That has shortened the portfolio duration. This was a one-off impact to NIM of 3 basis points.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveIt has been an extraordinary stretch. As we highlighted when we reported first half results, our NIM reached its high point in October 2022 — a moment that carried tailwinds from the rising rate environment and favorable funding conditions. Since then, what we've faced is fierce competition in both mortgages and deposits. The pressure on NIM has been made worse because customers, quite reasonably, went looking for better returns on their savings in a market that is refinancing a substantial TFF funding pool. As for our NIM outlook, we anticipate mortgage competition will persist, and the move from fixed to variable lending will keep delivering a margin tailwind. Deposit competition is set to stay intense while the industry replaces the TFF. Our replicating portfolio will keep contributing benefits to NIM and will peak on the uninvested portion as we arrive at the top of the cash rate tightening cycle. Lastly, once the TFF is repaid, we'll look to optimize our liquids portfolio. Now to expenses on Slide 27, which rose 8% compared with FY '22. We felt the effects of high inflation. Technology spend grew by $22 million during the year — roughly speaking, half of that is tied to running and maintaining our legacy systems, with the other half made up of cloud licensing and costs connected to our future state.
Racheal Kellaway
executivePersonnel expenses rose as we wrap up negotiations on the enterprise agreement, and we also experienced a return to normal leave patterns following the pandemic. We interact with customers more during this year while they adapted to rising interest rates. Our continuing expenditure on risk, regulation and assurance — cyber included — went up as we made the bank stronger. Turning to the expense outlook, inflation is going to keep affecting our cost base. We will keep incurring the cost of running and maintaining legacy systems, even as we build the new digital bank. The gains from the simplification program that Patrick outlined partially offset those increases. We expect our underlying cost base to rise in the low single digits. Beyond that, investment spend will step up through the operating expense line as we keep strengthening the bank. We are moving the banking core to the cloud and starting migration of customer deposits to the digital bank. This marks the last year of the stand-alone ME integration program. We reached our goal of an annual run rate synergy benefit of $72 million within the timeframe we stated. Total costs came to $176 million, and $133 million of that consisted of the program integration costs. When closing down the program, we evaluated the observed ways of working in our Melbourne offices and the clear technology road map that accelerates us onto one core banking platform for retail.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThat led to 2 more assets being written down, which added another $43 million of impact. Integrations are complicated and difficult. Even so, that program has now been finished. Moving on to our investments, which are on Slide 29. We're at a pivotal moment in our transformation, with $167 million invested during the second half. Beyond integration and the costs tied to the remedial action plans, we put money into strengthening the bank and made progress on our digitization strategy, where we invested $103 million. That investment has let us speed up parts of our digital road map, delivering ME digital transaction and saving accounts in the period. We've now built digital mortgages for all of our brands and are testing them. The first phase will see ME Bank and Virgin Money launched to the market this financial year. As we invest, our software intangible balance keeps growing, and we expect amortization to rise into FY '24, largely depending on when assets under construction are completed. More notably, the mix of our investments is increasingly OpEx in nature, as I outlined when I described FY '24 operating expense considerations. Impairment expense for the year came to $71 million, or 9 basis points to GLA, as shown on Slide 30.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveIn the second half, total provisions rose by $19 million, reaching $332 million. That reflects forward-looking assumptions within the collective provision, which was up 25%. In our forward-looking models, we've kept a 45% weighting toward a downside or severe downside economic outcome. The provision also carries overlays for fixed rate mortgage roll-offs, construction and commercial property, and the effects of El Nino. Specific provisions and impaired assets stayed subdued in FY '23, helped by strong risk settings over recent years — things like reduced LVR and DTI in housing and a high proportion of well secured lending in the business portfolio. Strong underlying property values have supported this as well. As anticipated, we've seen housing arrears rise back to pre-COVID levels. On commercial arrears, a material commercial exposure was refinanced after balance date, which brought commercial arrears down. In housing, we've proactively engaged with and supported customers affected by sustained high inflation and rapid monetary policy tightening. Because of the environment, more hardship arrangements have been taken up. BOQ takes a conservative approach to hardship reporting, keeping these customers in arrears for a longer observation period.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYou can see that in the arrears figures. It's encouraging that cure rates are significant, which indicates the majority of our customers are fulfilling their obligations once hardship ends. Now, on funding and liquidity, turning to Slide 31 — a lot of this has been covered already. Our liquidity position is strong, and our funding approach is conservative, giving us an end-of-period LCR of 154%. During the second half of this year, we began repaying the TFF. Deposit competition was strong, and we were able to draw on our strong liquidity position to handle that period in an orderly and safe manner. We're proud of the 10% growth in customer deposits over the year, and especially pleased that these customers are engaging and transacting with us more on our digital platform. That gives us a stable and more diverse funding mix and shows early success of our digital strategy — the need for which is evident for BOQ in this part of the cycle. Moving to capital on Slide 32, we finished the year with a strong CET1 of 10.91%, including a 16 basis point impact from holding a capital overlay as part of our EU with APRA.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveDuring this half, capital improved by 47 basis points thanks to cash earnings, while cutting credit risk-weighted assets added another 20 basis points. The first half dividend, net of the dividend reinvestment plan, gave 25 basis points of capital back to shareholders. We know that in a stretch marked by weaker earnings and heavy investment, giving shareholders a dependable dividend matters. Our solid capital position let us do that, with a second half dividend of $0.21. We also dropped the discount on the DRP. Looking ahead to FY '24, we anticipate carrying on at or above the upper end of the $10.25 to $10.75 target range and keeping our targeted dividend payout ratio at 60% to 75% of cash earnings. To sum up, this year brought margin pressures, with heightened competition on both sides of the balance sheet throughout the industry. We strengthened our capital position and kept conservative liquidity settings as we repaid a substantial share of the TFF. We have confidence in the quality of our portfolio and keep conservative provisioning levels. The ME integration program is complete, yet we still have material investment underway to deliver the strategy, and we stay committed to our FY '26 targets.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveI'll hand things over to Patrick now, who will give his closing comments along with the outlook for FY '24.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveThanks for that, Racheal. Turning to Slide 34, I'll give an overview of the FY '24 outlook. Australia's economy has stayed resilient, helped along by low unemployment and solid cash savings. We see risks building as we go into FY '24, given the elevated cost of living along with the delayed effect of higher interest rates and rates staying higher for longer. We'll keep standing by our customers as they navigate this tough economic cycle. In FY '24, we expect revenue and margin pressure to persist, driven by slower credit growth and competition. At some point, mortgage pricing across the market will need to adjust so that returns come in above the bank's cost of capital, in our expectation. Deposit competition looks set to stay heightened as the term funding facility is refinanced. We'll keep investing to strengthen BOQ and make it more digital. Our simplification program will partly offset inflationary pressure, and we expect low single-digit cost growth in our underlying cost base, along with investment spend and amortization. Through better customer experiences and simpler, stronger operations, we're getting BOQ ready for recovery and growth once the cycle turns. Now to the summary slide, Slide 35. BOQ holds a strong financial position, which lets us keep supporting our customers and our people and deliver on our strategic transformation priorities.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe remain dedicated to the risk remediation efforts we have underway with APRA and AUSTRAC. Productivity gains are coming from our simplification initiative, which supports the move toward our future state digital and relationship operating model. All key milestones in our digital transformation are being delivered on schedule — digital mortgages in 2024 and retirement of the legacy ME core banking platform by FY '25. A future state with a lower cost to serve and a broader, cheaper funding base will strengthen our capacity to compete in the mortgage market, which is highly commoditized. We acknowledge that shareholders have had a disappointing year, and our historical operating model is under strain, especially in the current market cycle. What we can control today is being managed, and we are tackling our challenges head on. Our strategy is clear for addressing legacy issues and delivering a competitive, sustainable and attractive bank with better customer experiences, profitable growth and shareholder returns. This remains a work in progress, and we expect improved outcomes to be delivered over the next 3 years. I want to take this chance to thank our customers for choosing BOQ, our shareholders for your support, and our people for their commitment and hard work in building a stronger future fit bank.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveThanks. Now I’ll hand things over to Jess for questions. Thanks.
Jessica Smith
executiveThanks, Patrick. At this point we’ll open it up for some questions. Please keep it to 2 questions per person. Operator, could you please bring up the first question?
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Andrew Lyons of Goldman Sachs.
Andrew Lyons
analystIf I could, just 2 questions. First one is on margin and volumes. In mortgages you're a price taker, and you keep saying that more mortgage repricing is needed before returns can get above the cost of capital. That said, some recent commentary out of the major banks points to a bit of recent improvement in returns, back to levels at or slightly above their cost of capital, at least. Now, you're clearly in the middle of a big transformation and productivity program that's working, and that clearly closes the returns gap. But until it's done, could you just talk about how willing you'll be to keep watching the balance sheet go backwards if there's no further repricing of the mortgage book?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAppreciate the question, Andrew. Well, it's a tricky balancing act. We keep watching this continuously. Our position is firm: writing business beneath our cost of capital simply doesn't make sense for shareholders. We hold strong conviction about our future-state operating model, which will bring a far lower cost to serve. That clearly helps us compete in a very competitive market. Beyond that, we also expect our cost of funds to become more competitive relative to peers as we deliver the digital banking platform with a low cost of funds too. So we'll keep monitoring. As you noted, there have been some early indications of rates rising, but we'll track that through FY '24. Racheal, I'm not sure whether you'd like to add anything there.
Andrew Lyons
analystSo now I’ll move to a second question. It’s about your medium-term costs, and I think you made two points today. First, you restated the target of a CTI below 50% by FY ’26, and second, you said you’re aiming for $200 million in productivity benefits by FY ’26. If we look at where consensus currently puts FY ’26 revenues — roughly $1.75 billion — your CTI target of under 50% would seem to suggest that the entire $200 million of productivity benefits drops through to the bottom line, offset by underlying inflation of about 2% per annum relative to FY ’23 levels. Is that broadly the right way for us to think about the path toward that CTI ratio of less than 50%? Or are there other factors at play? And I’m especially keen to hear your thoughts on revenues, which, given today’s results, probably carry some downside risk to that FY ’24 forecast.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveRight. So I won't be giving any long-term revenue or cost base projections. We've gone back over our financial model. In our view, it's prudent and conservative. We've factored in the $200 million in productivity benefits. Those will come through across the period. We've also taken another look at the headwinds we're facing right now and at where margins stand today, and we've reset our revenue expectations accordingly. That said, we have high conviction in the investment we're making in the bank and that the cycle will turn, and we remain firm on both of those targets.
Andrew Lyons
analystPatrick, that's fair enough. But let me just confirm the $200 million in productivity benefits. Can I confirm that this would mean your FY '26 expense base is $200 million lower than in FY '23 because of those productivity benefits? Is that the correct way to look at it? Or is it more of a cumulative figure?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAndrew, as we've stated, we anticipate that the $200 million in productivity gains will counterbalance inflation. We're also continuing to put money into the business, and a good portion of those investment costs land in OpEx. So expenses will rise as a result of that investment. But I'll leave it to you to work through the details.
Operator
operatorAndrew Triggs of JPMorgan has the next question.
Andrew Triggs
analystPerhaps I could ask a follow-up regarding margin versus growth and capital settings. At 10.9%, although that sits above the upper bound of the range, it leaves only limited headroom to move up toward the top of the target range. What interests me is ongoing organic capital generation alongside a declining ROE and that starting point, which is modestly above the top end of the target range. Does that also shape your decisions about gross settings over the near term, please?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveOkay, so we are keeping capital above the target range, because we're putting a sizable investment into the business, and we're balancing that investment against where our growth settings stand for asset growth. And on top of that, paying dividends to our shareholders. We have a very clear 5-year model that gives us comfort around the balance that we've got and the return to growth generating organic capital through the cycle. So we're comfortable with the settings where they are. You would expect that we will not hold capital at that high level. We've got a target range of $10.25 million to $10.75 million. And in time, you would expect it to come within the middle of that range.
Andrew Triggs
analystNow, the second question concerns margin. When I examine the parameters tied to margin — specifically those involving the net stable funding ratio and the liquidity coverage ratio — I see that both measures sit quite high and have continued climbing. That's somewhat understandable while TFS repayment is underway, though 60% of it has already been repaid. And 128% would point to a funding approach — an extremely conservative one. So my interest is this: when do you expect that to normalize to normal levels over time? And what effect do you think that carries for the bank's net interest income — not so much NIM — along with enhanced revenue?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveI'll have Racheal handle the second part of that question, but Andrew, let me take the first part. Throughout this cycle we've been quite prudent. As we mentioned at the half, wholesale markets were difficult for much of the FY '23 year. During certain stretches neither we nor the industry could access wholesale markets. That's why we believed it was important to maintain high liquidity levels amid the volatility we've seen in markets. On top of that, as you pointed out, the industry has had to contend with the CLF and the TFF repayment. We're well ahead of peers on TFF since we drew down earlier. As Racheal said, we've repaid roughly 60% of our term funding facility. We considered it very prudent to hold elevated liquidity levels through that stretch. Competition in the deposit market has been fierce. You're seeing quite extreme competition as banks refinance that $180 billion over the period, and that will continue. For an organization like ours, we wanted to ensure we had prudent buffers, and we managed liquidity appropriately.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveMy expectation is that the liquidity coverage ratio will decline down the road. We feel quite at ease with the state of our financing as it stands today and with the choices available to us regarding our financing plan. So you should anticipate that we won't be quite as prudent moving forward. That said, I may ask Racheal to address the second part of your question.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYes. So look, there are a couple of — and you flagged this when you posed the question. Two elements make up how holding more liquidity affects us. One relates to NIM, and the other relates to NII. And so the 5 basis points of liquidity drag we experienced through NIM this period — roughly 4 basis points was actually the denominator effect, so essentially no impact, or very little, on NII. And then the other one has to do with the yield, sort of the cost, which flows through your revenue line. There is — the only other point I'd make is that there's a bit of timing when it comes to the numbers around LCR and the net stable funding ratio, as you pointed out. And so we actually had a significant TFF maturity coming into our window — into our funding plan in September. And so the spot LCR at the end of the period came in higher because the liquidity has moved into the 30-day window. So those numbers have a bit of timing in them as well.
Andrew Triggs
analystAlright. Racheal, just to clarify on the NSFR specifically — running an NSFR that high suggests that over time you could shift the mix of wholesale funding, or move out of expensive long-term wholesale funding into cheaper shorter-term wholesale funding. Is there any capacity for that kind of optimization over time?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYes, absolutely. I mean, we examine every possible source of funding. During this period, we made a decision to secure some solid long-term wholesale funding deals. So we now have that stability in place. The balance between long-term and short-term funding is something we review all the time. Ultimately, as Patrick has outlined, having more customer deposits is what we're after, since they're stable. We're bringing in more customers, and from an LCR and NSFR perspective, that's an advantage too.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes. So Andrew, to build on what Racheal said, there is a very favorable spread right now in the market between wholesale funding and deposits. And as you heard Racheal mention, we've seen substantial growth in our deposit base over the course of the year — roughly $6 billion. And the digital banking platform is letting us tap into that cheaper source of funding, and we'll keep working to get that mix where it should be.
Operator
operatorJeff Cai of Jarden has the next question.
Jeff Cai
analystStarting with your medium-term goals and that FY ’26 ROE target: I’d like to know how much of your thinking already includes margin expansion and a turn in the cycle. Could you also walk through the main building blocks and explain how ROE can rise from 6% to around 9% ahead?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveI believe I addressed that question before. We won't be providing a detailed forecast. What I'd say is truly essential for hitting those targets is the road map we have in place across our strategic pillars to deliver BOQ's transformation. That will generate meaningful benefits on the cost side as well as improve returns. On your margin question, our position is that FY '24 will remain a difficult year. We've built that into our financial model. We do expect the cycle to turn. Whether banks choose to price above their cost of capital is really a question of timing. But we also believe the economic cycle will turn. And we do see interest rates beginning to come down at the back end of this year and into FY '25. We'll pick up some benefits from that too.
Jeff Cai
analystUnderstood. Now, turning to SME lending — volume growth has been fairly weak during this half. What's the right way for us to view the growth outlook ahead? Do you have certain initiatives already underway that are working through and might substantially lift growth in '24 and '25?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveSME system growth is really quite flat—in fact, right now it is flat. So you should not expect any material expansion in our SME lending. We are highly targeted toward specific sectors, and we are intent on growing that book. That said, given the cycle we are in, I would not anticipate that you will see material growth. We are taking a prudent approach when it comes to the quality of the business we write. And we have no desire to move up the risk curve in order to grow the book. We are comfortable holding our capital through this cycle and searching for opportunities to grow when such an opportunity arises. But we have superb bankers who are specialists in particular sectors, and we will see continued growth—though we remain very focused on lending to targeted borrowers.
Operator
operatorJonathan Mott of Barrenjoey has the next question for you.
Jonathan Mott
analystI have two questions, if I may. I'd like to return to the first one — right back to Andrew Lyons' initial question, since I believe that's likely the most significant bet on something within your control, namely your cost in FY '26. So you're stating that you anticipate $200 million in productivity, but inflation will offset that. And then you mentioned there will be cost growth from investments. So I want to be really clear: your cost base is just over $1 billion at present. Does that mean from this point forward you'll see productivity and inflation essentially canceling each other out over 3 years, depending on your cost inflation at that time, yet the cost base will still be higher in FY '26? We can each have our own assumptions regarding volumes and margins, but cost is what you can control. I just want to make it very clear: what do you expect that cost growth to be in '26?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveJonathan, we won't be providing a cost forecast for 2026. What matters most, I believe, is that we flagged at the half year that our cost growth cannot be sustained. In the second half we launched the simplification program, which represents a substantial body of work. More remains to be done within that program, but we're stating with confidence our ability to deliver productivity benefits of $200 million. We're operating in an environment of very high inflation. That covers service costs, wages, and every area of the bank. I won't commit that the cost program will fully offset this over the period. Over time, we would expect our productivity gains to more than offset inflation, but we are not making that commitment to the market.
Jonathan Mott
analystAll right. So your point is that inflation's future path is unknown. That makes it difficult — I get that, and it's a fair point. But your view is that the $200 million in productivity ought to broadly cancel out inflation, more or less depending on where it comes out, and we won't be held to that. Beyond that, though, you'd anticipate costs rising because investment spending keeps increasing. Is that the right way to read what you're saying?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveRight. So, look — investment spending is going to peak. At present we're at the very top end of what we spend on investment, and over the coming couple of years we're seeing the tail end of the retail bank transformation come through. So you'd expect that investment spend to decline. You should also expect that we'll keep finding opportunities to simplify our bank and deliver cost benefits. The financial models we have today give us confidence that we can continue to hold the FY '26 CTI under 50% and the ROE target above 9.25%.
Jonathan Mott
analystAlright, may I follow up with another question? It refers back to something raised 6 months ago regarding the owner-manager branches and the franchisees. What we discussed then was the book contracting — motivating franchisees becomes extremely hard when their pricing is out of the market. Your response at the time was that the plan involved refocusing owner managers toward business banking, since they're deeply connected to their communities and should be able to grow. Yet now it appears the business book is contracting too. So could you tell us, within the Business Bank, how growth is trending through the owner-manager branch network? Or is that shrinking as well? And in this climate, I believe you're also indicating that on margins and payouts, owner managers of third parties — part of that would be owner managers declining too. So how do you retain and motivate owner managers when their personal outlook is so difficult?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes, Jonathan, that's an excellent question, and it matters a lot to us as we move ahead. Owner managers are central to the differentiated strategy we run. What you need to keep in mind is that the typical owner manager has been with BOQ for more than 10 years on average, and cycles do happen. At the moment, banking is moving through one of those cycles. So owner managers see good years, and at other times things are tougher. Still, they hold an annuity book. So even though mortgage origination is lower for the owner managers, the annuity book they hold gives them a share. Deposits have been a massive focus for us this year. And the owner managers have gained from the growth in our deposits. Our aim is to change the owner manager role so they play a far larger part going forward in our SME focus. Some owner managers already handle that extremely well and are gaining from it right now. But that is definitely where we're headed. Racheal, I'm not sure whether you'd like to add anything there.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveThis is likely just underscoring that owner-managers, given how deeply rooted they are in the community, stay very focused on lending to SMEs. A portion of the balance sheet movement on the business banking side has occurred at the upper end, meaning lower corporate lending. So the actual volume of lending we're doing at the SME level remains pretty strong, and that is also coming through owner-manager channels.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveTurning to the second half of what you asked, Jonathan, like I mentioned before, lending growth in the Business Bank system and SME lending throughout the industry is currently flat. Our SME book has grown really strongly over the last 2 years, which reflects a deliberate focus and a strategy for BOQ. I expect that to slow somewhat until the cycle turns again. The reason is really that we simply don't want to move up the risk curve. That business, though, is also well supported by our asset finance business, and you've seen strong growth in a very diversified asset finance book, which is likewise supporting growth of the Business Bank.
Operator
operatorThe next question is from John Storey with UBS.
John Storey
analystI think it's clear the market is very focused today on just trying to backfill that 9.25% ROE target around — and I suppose a lot of it comes down to NIM and costs. So I won't ask anything on that. I think you guys have addressed that now. Well, a lot of it on the call. I was actually just hoping to kind of get your views on some of the stuff that you're targeting around some of the capital-light parts of revenue. I mean, obviously, NII was down today. So maybe just get more detail on what initiatives you have to target noninterest revenue? That's the first one. And then just quickly, in terms of kind of how you're thinking over the next 2, 3 years out to FY '26, what are the views — what are the bank's views the trifecta effectively of kind of lower rates, how that plays through into margins your stuff that you called out today on more normalized competition, clearly, the impact that, that has on volume and margin. And then the assumption, I would imagine lower cash rates and lower credit impairments. Just I guess kind of back to some of the targets in FY '26.
John Storey
analystSo that's just those two on my end.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAppreciate that, John. I’ll likely have Racheal come in and supplement a few of my remarks. I think it makes sense to begin with the first part of your first question, on noninterest income. During the presentation I mentioned that this remains a work in progress, though we’re quite eager to broaden where our revenues come from. One advantage we hold is a very strong Business Bank, and that unit is carrying us through this stretch in which Business Bank growth has been offsetting, clearly, the stance we are taking in the mortgage market. That said, we also acknowledge a desire to lift our return on equity and to diversify beyond a highly commoditized market, even while remaining very focused on that same commoditized market. So we have several initiatives that could grow noninterest income. Through our VMA offering, you’ll notice we’re seeing strong growth in insurance commissions, and also in super commissions, where we’re building a good book in those areas. That income carries no capital weighting. It flows directly into the revenue line and supports ROE. Right now it’s fairly small, but we’re seeing very, very strong growth emerge from it.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe've likewise witnessed a very significant uplift in our financial markets segment. Our financial markets business has been redirected away from trading and risk so that it truly concentrates on serving customers and drawing on the BOQ network, and that too is generating quality returns without capital weightings attached to growth. Now it's very early days, yet we're highly focused on seeking to expand those earnings and on having them turn into a more material portion of our revenue base. And that is a central element of the strategy, though still a work in progress. Regarding the trifecta you mentioned, I'd say BOQ is more disadvantaged than our competitors when interest rates are rising. And that genuinely reflects our low base of low-cost funding transaction accounts. So as you see interest rates rise, we're paying a much larger spread than many of our peers. That benefit will help us once rates come down. So for most banks that's countercyclical, but the spread we pay on our funding will shrink as rates come down. So I think that's one. We also expect that once the cycle turns, we'll see system growth return. And with improved system growth, our feeling is that competition bullies.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveCompetition has intensified because the market is contending for a considerably smaller slice of it, and that does heighten competitive pressure. From that angle, we'd anticipate pricing to get better. We don't know when that inflection point arrives, though our projections suggest rates will likely remain elevated until close to the finish of FY '24 and then ease at the end of '24 going into '25. So we see that cycle beginning to turn. We're positioned well to get back to growth as the cycle recovers. That said, I might ask Racheal to address any further remarks she has.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveI'd say that covers it well. The one thing I'd add, John, is a point about long-term loan impairment expense. As of right now, LIE sits at 9 basis points over GLA. There's a great deal of uncertainty, I'd note, and definitely some pockets of stress in our portfolio. Still, when you look at our absolute provisioning levels, we're provisioned quite strongly. So over roughly a 3-year horizon, we wouldn't anticipate any material surprises coming through the loan impairment expense line during that stretch either.
John Storey
analystAnd Racheal, just to make that clear, that also factors in where the bank is expanding. So expanding more on the business side relative to retail and mortgages?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveAbsolutely. Yes. To be clear, the business mix is factored into how we view LIE going forward. We have mentioned this previously and disclosed it previously: for a bank like ours, we believe the long-run average is roughly 12 basis points in terms of the mix, and if we expand more in business lending, that could rise somewhat. But the reality is that, as we sit here today, we have 41 basis points of coverage from a provisioning standpoint. So we are entering the next 3 years from a very strong position.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveJohn, let me just build on that point. As Racheal mentioned earlier, we've raised our collective overlays. That really addresses the fixed rate maturities coming due across the upcoming period. We've also examined construction within the agricultural sector alongside our commercial property sector, taking a forward view of where the economic cycle is heading. We believe our coverage for those events is genuinely prudent. The key takeaway, though, is that our book is very well secured, with loan-to-value ratios that are relatively low. So we do expect customers will have a harder time during FY '24, and more of them will experience hardship. Still, the security coverage ratios in the book leave us comfortable that no material losses will hit us through this cycle.
Operator
operatorThe next question is from Josh Freiman at Macquarie.
Josh Freiman
analystI have just 2 questions. On the first one, I would describe the impact on margin as fairly disappointing when compared with what consensus had assessed. Still, it is clear the exit margin might be considerably lower than that. Given the significant move, can you give any color on the exit margin and on how margins are likely to track across the half? I will come back to the second question afterward.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAppreciate that, Josh. Let me see whether Racheal would like to add something here. We don't — and we discussed this back at the half year too. In our view, giving an exit margin could really be misleading, since it's fairly volatile, and we don't consider that appropriate. What we've provided does give you a solid sense of how margins have shifted since October 2022, when they reached their peak. Clearly, they came down significantly across the second half, and the outlook statement for FY '24 lines up with what Racheal said earlier. So I doubt there's much more we can offer beyond that. Thanks for asking.
Josh Freiman
analystAll right, got it. So then, turning to costs, you folks haven’t really been ready to give much visibility on where things land at the close of FY ’26. Still, looking at that $200 million in productivity benefits, can you offer any detail on how that phases in and which key drivers account for the amount?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes. So we mentioned — during my presentation, I noted that the main drivers related to the operating model. We've already made adjustments to that operating model. What that involves is making our processes simpler and cutting down on duplication within the organization. Unfortunately, that has an effect on people. So we've let a number of people go, and as I mentioned, we'll continue with that into the first quarter. The second component of that program concerns digitization, which is going to bring substantial productivity gains once we deliver the digital mortgage in 2024. As we've stated, we expect to lower our cost to serve by roughly 50% when we roll out the end-to-end digital banking platform and retire the legacy ME platform in FY '25. So significant product entity savings are going to flow through. But when you look at how the $200 million is spread, our strong focus is on countering inflation in FY '24. In the outlook, we've indicated that we anticipate low single-digit cost growth before investment and amortization. That applies to FY '24.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Richard Wiles of Morgan Stanley.
Richard Wiles
analystI've got a question about costs. Patrick, for FY '24 in particular, you said this earlier and I believe just restated it: you're expecting low single-digit cost growth, plus additional investment spending, plus greater amortization. Could you help us understand what that implies for total cost growth — is it mid-single digit? Or could you indicate what you think the dollar impact will be from the higher investment spend and the amortization expense?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes, and thanks for asking that, Richard. I'll bring in Racheal to speak about investment spend. Clearly, we're at the peak of our investment cycle right now. We do expect that investment spend will decline in FY '24 relative to what we spent this year, but I'll have Racheal give more detail on that. Look, we're highly focused on costs. I mean, we recognize it, and we said at the half that cost growth cannot be sustained, especially in an environment where revenue is under pressure. We've announced a program of work — a continuous improvement program of work. We'll keep focusing on what we can do to lower our cost base. But we don't want to overpromise, and we want to give the market clarity that inflation is a big issue for all companies and all industry, and it's a very difficult environment in which to give a clear forecast. And — but I might bring in Racheal to speak about the investment spend.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveAbsolutely. If you look at it purely in dollar terms, our overall investment spending will come down over the coming year. What we experienced during this period was the effect of the remedial action plan provision we booked in the first half, along with the last year of integration. Effectively, those items will drop out of the investment funding envelope. So the absolute dollars will decline. What I'm really trying to get across is that the composition of that investment spend is shifting quite markedly as we move into next year — which is exactly why this ties back to the operating expense guidance we're giving, in terms of higher prospects next year. As a result, amortization becomes less of a factor through FY '24, peaks in FY '25, and there's a bit of a step-up in prospects into FY '24.
Richard Wiles
analystRacheal, could you help us understand what kind of impact that's going to have?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveI'd characterize it as material. A great deal remains to be worked through regarding when things will actually be delivered. We do have a very clear plan in place. But the fact is, we'll be looking to revise that figure as the year goes on. So offering guidance probably isn't a sensible move at this point in time. As Patrick laid out, the summary really comes down to low single digits growth from what we refer to as the BAU operating expense position, and then there will be a step-up in OpEx tied to investments.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveI'd like to build on what Racheal said and offer something for you to think about too. Decisions about investment are genuinely, genuinely hard. What we're doing is choosing to put money in now so that we end up with a scalable bank at lower cost down the road. And in the current part of the cycle, where revenues are, obviously, under a lot of competitive pressure, those choices are truly, truly tough. Even so, we're confident they're the correct ones, and we're acting boldly since our conviction is very strong that what we're doing — and that our strategy — will produce a much more competitive and sustainable bank later on. So yes, it does weigh on FY '24, but we think these are the right calls we have to make so we can deliver a better bank and better outcomes for our customers.
Operator
operatorAzib Khan with E&P has the next question.
Azib Khan
analystTo pick up where Richard left off on FY '24 costs: it’s the low single-digit increase on underlying, plus the investment, plus the amortization. You’ve laid out your digital conformation program plans pretty clearly today, and you obviously have a highly visible roadmap in mind for the remedial steps you’ll take in dealing with the enforcer for undertaking. Could you give us the total cost growth for FY '24 — not FY '26, only FY '24? So overall, on that $1.01 billion you delivered in FY '23, how much does it rise in FY '24?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveRight. So that isn't a figure we normally provide guidance on. What we've done is give you the underlying information so you can work from it. Repeating the outlook statement we issued is really all I'd be doing here. So I'm sorry, there's nothing further I can share beyond that. I would just add that we're weighing a lot of competing considerations, and we'll be managing our cost base actively as we go through this cycle.
Azib Khan
analystPatrick, let me just check on that—clearly you referenced the 5-year financial model, which suggests to me you have some visibility across a 3- to 5-year horizon. So surely you have considerable visibility as you head into next year. Internally, are you confident about a cost figure you can achieve next year? Or is there a great deal of uncertainty around that?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe feel good about the cost number we've set for next year. There's a really clear plan in place. We have a clear road map for where the investment is going. And we also have a highly detailed road map for the simplification program — the one delivering the $200 million — including the timing of when that lands, so we know exactly what we're doing. What we can't predict is how inflation will behave, though our economic forecast does assume inflation begins to ease, since rate moves work with a lag and will start to take hold. So we have confidence in next year's budget, in our internal forecast for next year, and in the financial model we've built, which is what gives us high conviction in our FY '26 targets.
Azib Khan
analystPatrick, can I get your confirmation that you feel confident about hitting that $200 million in productivity savings without needing any additional restructuring charges?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveSo we have absorbed the restructuring charge related to that. What I’m unable to claim is that no restructuring charges will ever arise again in the future. As we move forward, we’ll keep evaluating the business. It is not our aim to return to the market with restructuring charges. That said, both the Board and management will keep assessing this. And should we identify material benefits available through investment in those areas that would serve our customers and our shareholders over the long term, that remains a possibility—though nothing is planned at present.
Azib Khan
analystSo should I interpret that as, Patrick, if more restructuring charges come, that $200 million productivity savings goal would grow? Or could it be that you need additional restructuring charges simply to reach the $200 million?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe're comfortable with the plan for that $200 million. Should other opportunities arise, we'll return to the market with us.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveI might just add something there: the outline Patrick provided gives you the kinds of cost benefits we’re seeing come through from the simplification program. So the restructuring charge we’ve just taken mostly relates to the operating model changes that we need to make now — and that we have now acted on — which delivers a benefit through FY '24. After that, the simplification program changes shape. If you think about some of the benefits we’ll be getting toward the back end of this period, there will be benefits tied to things like decommissioning technology platforms. And so there isn’t actually a cost — a restructuring cost — that we need to take in relation to those. So it varies in shape, with a lot of work being done on the shape of this benefit profile, and also the cost associated with it. The costs tied to decommissioning are already included in our investment portfolio, and we have a plan for that over the next few years as well. So from that perspective, no surprises.
Azib Khan
analystApologies, Racheal. So that $200 million figure takes in the savings that come from decommissioning and retiring not only ME — the ME platform — but the BOQ legacy platform as well?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveRight. So the slide Patrick walked through contained those cost categories. It addresses the simplification in terms of the number of core banking platforms we're moving from and moving to.
Azib Khan
analystThere's a slide mentioning that BOQ legacy systems will be retired past FY '25. So should I interpret that as everything being finished by FY '26?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveNo, that commitment isn't something we're making. So through FY '26 we have a clear plan — and that plan includes ME Bank and winding ME Bank down. Cutting the count of core banking platforms is a real priority for us, but at this stage we won't put that commitment out to the market. What we are saying is that it will take place after FY '25.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveRight, and one more thing worth clarifying: BOQ operates as both a business bank and a retail bank, and as things stand, the Business Bank's plans aren't part of that simplification program when it comes to decommissioning.
Azib Khan
analystOn decommissioning — does that $200 million cover only ME core banking decommissioning, or does it also include retirement of BOQ legacy systems?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveWe've mentioned that some of our older systems are being retired. During FY '24, we highlighted the retirement of certain systems. So there are BOQ systems that are likewise being phased out. However, what we're not committing to within that $200 million is moving the BOQ legacy banking platform over to the new digital platform and decommissioning it. And just to emphasize this point as well. As we noted throughout the presentation, we're really concentrating the BOQ brand on relationship banking and human touch banking. And we've sped up the digital banking platform for ME and VMA, where we'll serve customers who are after self-help and quick responses via digital banking. So the urgency around decommissioning BOQ will take a back seat to the acceleration of our digital banking platform for the other two brands.
Operator
operatorEd Henning of CLSA has the next question.
Ed Henning
analystI have just a quick follow-up regarding the '24 costs. On Slide 29, which you mentioned earlier, you noted there will be a significant rise in the expense line tied to investment spending. You show $24 million here for the second half of '23. So we should anticipate that figure rising above $24 million and continuing through both halves of '24. Then, on the amortization charge, looking at Slide 27, it came to $11 million this year. You are indicating an increase in '24 and '25. Could you provide a bit of guidance on the amount by which that will rise as well, please?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAppreciate the question. That one I'll probably hand over to Racheal. Thanks.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveRight, so amortization isn't going to be a major factor in opex going forward. It came in at $11 million this period. That figure will rise, but it wasn't a significant jump. On the first point, yes — as I mentioned, we're reducing our absolute investment spend, though there will be a shift in mix toward in-year operating expense. As a result, the $24 million we have in the second half will be higher next year.
Ed Henning
analystOkay. And on the material side, can you give us a rough sense — is it above 5%, above 10%, just some ballpark figure?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveIs that in millions or percent?
Ed Henning
analystIf you could share that in dollars, that would be useful, though a percentage is fine too—whatever is easier for you.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYou've basically posed that same question in several different forms. Unfortunately, I doubt we're going to give you that answer.
Operator
operatorThe next person to ask something is Brendan Sproules at Citi.
Brendan Sproules
analystMy question concerns how the simplification program will affect things, especially in the mortgage origination area. A lot of banks have taken this on, and clearly their capacity to handle mortgages was competitively strained for a while. What ought we to anticipate as you work through this effort and the automation component of your simplification initiative, and how will that affect your capacity to approve home loans relative to other peers in the market?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes. So look, our process, as we mentioned earlier, is quite manual, with a lot of handoffs along the way. And I went through in the presentation that we'll be delivering digital mortgages in 2024 — that program remains on track. It's currently in testing. We're confident we'll deliver it on time and on budget, and that will bring us material productivity benefits and a significantly improved customer experience with time to yes, as well as significantly cutting our handover — our handoff periods on mortgages. Racheal, I don't know whether you'd like to add anything. But yes, we can definitely provide you with more detail off-line, and I could ask Craig and Rod to share some of the benefits we're driving there. But we're very confident that we will materially improve our customer experience and lower our cost to serve, which will let us be more competitive in the mortgage market.
Brendan Sproules
analystAbsolutely. I may hold you to that offer. My second question also concerns your FY '26 objectives. There is a fairly sizable gap between the ROE and the cost-to-income figures you are giving us and, as I understand it, the consensus analyst expectation in the market, which I believe puts ROE at somewhere in the 5% to 7% range. What would you tell investors the consensus is overlooking here that you plan to convey to us today?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveAppreciate that question, and thanks for the chance to address it. We acknowledge there is a meaningful gap. The cost-to-income ratio and return on equity we have right now mirror the market cycle in which we are operating. It is our view that today's margin headwinds cannot persist across the marketplace. And we do expect the cycle to turn. It could, however, stretch into FY '24. The TFF has significantly distorted funding markets. That, in turn, has produced a temporary distortion when it comes to cost of funds. We have strong confidence that our new digital banking platform will bring down our funding costs and provide a far more diversified cost of funds. We have already seen evidence of this during FY '23, when deposits on the platform grew substantially, reaching $5.5 billion. So that will clearly be a help. The decommissioning program — especially our core banking platform, in my view — will generate considerable productivity gains. And as noted earlier, digital mortgages will deliver considerable benefits too. So we do believe we will end up with a very low cost to serve national brand that is scalable, that can compete in the market and produce higher returns through the cycle.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveEven as you assess the company right now against the current cycle—one in which margins face pressure and we are putting substantial investment into the business—we hold very strong conviction that what we are constructing is a bank delivering considerably greater returns from a far smaller cost foundation, which will pay off once the cycle turns.
Brendan Sproules
analystLet me try to sum that up, then. Based on what you just said, if I'm looking at my figures, I ought to focus on my total expenses, since your cost of services is going to come down materially in 2026. And I should also be watching the cost of funds, because this competition in funding markets isn't going to last, plus the structural changes you're making to your funding mix. Are those the 2 things I should take away from that?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes. Look, right now the cycle is hitting us harder. We’ve pointed out where we’re at a disadvantage. The two major disadvantages for us are a higher cost of funds, because our base of low-cost transaction accounts is relatively low, and also our cost to serve, which is very manual and high. I think another thing you should consider is our Business Bank. The Business Bank produces 55% of our profits. And when we discuss margins, the Business Bank has maintained its margin through this cycle. It has grown significantly. I think it’s approximately $3 billion in asset growth. I’ll check with Chris regarding the last couple of years as we’ve changed our strategy to grow our SME sector; we do see ourselves as really well positioned to grow the business bank as well. So that margin mix across retail and business is also a very important factor for you to consider.
Operator
operatorThe next question is from Nathan Zaia at Morningstar.
Nathan Zaia
analystHas the effect on margins from retention discounting and front-to-back book repricing differed materially between brands? And looking ahead to the FY '26 plan, does that hinge on one brand or channel delivering stronger loan growth than the others?
Patrick Newton Allaway
executivePerhaps I'll ask Racheal to weigh in on that.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYes. Regarding the question about brand difference, not really. I mean, the main distinction is really where growth is coming from. So we have continued to see growth through ME Bank. We have CCR and ME Bank, strong low LVR lending that's relatively simple. And so we've kept seeing strong settlements through that brand. The point about retention discounting I did want to make was that we are seeing that decline and become less of a feature of the margin walk. And going forward, particularly by sort of FY '24, we expect that it won't be called out in the walk at all. That's driven by a couple of things. A lot of the portfolio has now been discounted. But then secondly, the gap between your front to back book margins has narrowed. So retention discounting has been a big impact on the industry up to this point, but we're seeing it decrease going forward.
Nathan Zaia
analystAnd as we look ahead, to hit the kinds of targets you've mentioned, does that require additional growth in the direct channel compared with broker, or is that not necessarily the case?
Racheal Kellaway
executiveIn our view, every one of our channels matters a great deal. I mean, brokers — customers do like brokers. So we have a genuinely good blend of channels through which customers can reach us. Digital mortgages are more direct and more streamlined. As a result, we are seeing — and we expect to see — a greater share of our customers coming to us directly as well.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Matthew Wilson at Jefferies.
Matthew Wilson
analystWe're now at levels for interest rates that are closer to normal than what we saw previously. Term deposits made up 70% of your deposit book back then. At present, that figure stands at 50%. My assumption is that customers behave rationally and will shift toward higher bank yields as rates stay elevated for a longer stretch. Could you walk us through how NIM behaves as your deposit mix shifts toward a substantially larger share of TDs? And I have a second question as well.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveYes, thank you, Matthew. I’ll ask Racheal to answer that one. Thanks.
Racheal Kellaway
executiveYes, that's a wonderful question. Customers enjoy securing their yield when rates are at their peak, so we've witnessed a shift in our mix toward term deposits. We've observed the negative drag from that. I mentioned in the first half that we were pricing term deposits below swaps. That provided a really substantial boost to margin. That has now returned to what I'd describe as a more normal pricing level. The problem is the TFF as we look ahead to FY '24, and there will be considerable deposit competition throughout the industry. So we anticipate that margin erosion stemming from term deposits will persist, driven mainly by competition. That covers term deposits, then. I believe the other element, when you're speaking about a period as far back as that, is that in fact there's been significantly more activity when it comes to savings accounts. And so there are -- based on customer age, younger customers in fact favor placing their funds in some of the savings accounts with higher yields, and from a digital standpoint they're convenient, and they're also simpler to transact with. And so the dynamics surrounding term deposits have changed somewhat in the market where savings accounts are concerned too.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveSorry to cut in there, Matthew, just before we continue. Obviously, considering how long all of you have been with us on this call, we're aware that we've been at it for a while now. So my suggestion would be that we perhaps take 2 or 3 additional questions. Then we'll wrap up after that. Apologies, Matthew. Please go ahead.
Matthew Wilson
analystYes, just one more. I'm curious about your outlook remarks. Why do you believe banks ought to generate excess returns over the cost of equity on a home loan, which is a competitive commodity, and that cost of equity mirrors the required return driven off that product? Why should an excess return exist in this space? And with everyone shifting toward digital home loans and generating efficiencies, competition is surely going to intensify further.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveRight. So obviously this is a market where commoditization runs deep — no doubt about it. Still, when all is said and done, investors expect a return that exceeds the cost of capital. And any bank that writes business failing to deliver an economic return won't survive. So here's my answer: every one of us carries a cost of capital, and writing business beneath that level strikes me as neither rational nor sustainable.
Matthew Wilson
analystThat said, the ROE target you've set sits under your cost of capital, and every risk plus every required return a product needs is already baked into that cost of capital.
Patrick Newton Allaway
executiveExactly right. Our ROE growth is a major priority for us, and the money we're putting into the business is aimed at expanding that ROE down the road.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the Q&A. I'll turn things back over to Ms. Smith for some closing comments.
Jessica Smith
executiveI appreciate all of you being here today. Should you have additional questions, please reach out to the Investor Relations team, and we anticipate talking with many of you during the weeks ahead. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Bank of Queensland Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Bank of Queensland Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Bank of Queensland Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.