British American Tobacco p.l.c. (BATS) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 8, 2024

London Stock Exchange GB Consumer Staples Tobacco earnings 71 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone. It's a pleasure to have you join us for our 2023 Preliminary Results Presentation. Joining me this morning are <<inaudible>>, our Finance Director, and Victoria Buxton, who serves as Group Head of Investor Relations. I'll start by covering the financial highlights and how we've progressed against our key areas of focus during this year. After that, Javed will walk you through our financial performance in greater depth. Then I'll come back to discuss our glidepath toward Building a Smokeless World in more detail, and following that we'll open things up for the Q&A session. Before that, please direct your attention to the disclaimers shown on Slides 2 and 3. So, let's turn to how we performed in 2023. Our reported results reflect the impact of the non-cash impairment charge, taken mainly against the U.S. brands we acquired. Unless otherwise stated, we'll be focusing on constant currency adjusted results. I'm pleased that BAT has turned in a resilient performance, in line with our guidance, reflecting the benefit of our global multi-category strategy. The breadth and scale of our global footprint allow us to consistently deliver balanced results. Our strong performances in AME and APMEA demonstrate this, delivering combined double-digit revenue growth that offset the U.S. Overall, we delivered organic revenue up 3.1%, which excludes Russia and Belarus from both periods.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#2

Operating profit rose 3.1%, or 3.9% on an organic basis, and diluted EPS climbed 4%, while organic growth came in at 5.2%. I'm especially happy with how we did in new categories, where revenue increased by almost 18%, and by 21% organically, as Vuse and Velo produced strong, volume-driven revenue growth. Our consumer count hit 23.9 million, which excludes 1.5 million consumers in Russia. We gained more than 3 million consumers year-on-year, including 1.1 million during Q4 by itself. At the half year, I laid out a clear set of objectives aimed at sharpening our execution and building a more modern and agile BAT. Working alongside our broader teams over the past six months, we've made solid progress on these six areas of focus. Let me now walk through some of the highlights. First, I'm delighted that we've achieved new category profitability two years ahead of our original target. We got there while still investing an incremental 300 million pounds in 2023 for future growth. Our new categories are contributing meaningfully to group results, since we're benefiting from greater scale, with strong profitability gains powered by Vuse and Velo. We've improved our new category contribution sequentially, moving from a peak loss of £1.1 billion in 2020 to a small profit position in 2023, which reflects a £400 million improvement last year.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#3

I should point out that although we anticipate further gains in new category profitability annually, the year-over-year contribution improvement won't follow a straight line because of how investments are phased. Our top 10 new category markets delivered strong progress, producing roughly three quarters of new category revenue in 2023, and category contribution margin there now exceeds 20%. What these markets show is that revenue keeps growing quickly. As scale builds, gross and contribution margins are expanding robustly, and absolute margin levels are approaching those of our Combustibles business. Profitability at that scale gives us confidence in the direction we're heading as we broaden our new category footprint. It also offers a clear line of sight toward profitability in less established markets going forward. Returning our U.S. Combustibles business to consistent value growth has been our second focus area. Early signs of volume and value share recovery are already emerging from our commercial plans. Volume share has risen 40 basis points since January, helped by a 160 basis points gain in the premium segment. Beyond that, we're seeing value share gains of 20 basis points since January, powered by a 60 basis point rise in our premium share that brings us to the highest level in three years, led by Newport and Natural American Spirit.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#4

I'd like to give you a bit more detail on what we're doing in the U.S. On premium, we've put investment behind Newport soft pack, building a laddered portfolio, and that has driven an acceleration in Newport's share of the premium segment. We're working through targeted execution of this state by state, with a broader roll out planned in 2024. Lucky Strike is the fastest growing cigarette brand in the market, and just three years after launch reached 4% national volume share at year-end. Beyond that, we're sharpening our execution, increasing the number of trade reps by around 10%, further strengthening and simplifying our route to market and upgrading our digital analytics. We're confident these actions will further strengthen our portfolio over the medium to long-term. Turning to my third area of focus, Heated Products, where I am determined to significantly strengthen our portfolio. Our recently announced global patent settlement is an important step forward, allow us to further develop improved products and innovations in the Heated Products space over the medium term. Meanwhile, I'm excited about our newest hyper launch, which delivers a total system upgrade. Our new device, glo Hyper pro, is a more premium offering with new heat technology and longer lasting sessions.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#5

Our new supertob consumables have been reworked so that both taste and flavour delivery are significantly better. We have also introduced veo, our first-to-market tobacco-free consumables featuring an herbal substrate, across 11 European markets. Although it remains early days, we are already seeing encouraging results, among them volume retention for our Heated Products in those markets. These launches represent the first examples of a stronger innovation pipeline. We are also stepping up our R&D, bringing in new capabilities like Device Engineering and fully integrating our global teams into a more collaborative network. Beyond that, we are teaming up with external industry leaders in complementary fields, including battery technologies and electronics manufacturing, so as to speed up our pipeline. With discipline, we keep applying our product lifecycle management model, which lets us bring stronger innovations to market at speed. Work remains to be done, yet I am confident that the right capabilities are now in place to deliver a faster and more meaningful innovation pipeline going forward. My next focus area is leading responsible development of new categories. We must secure broad acceptance of our Tobacco Harm Reduction agenda and promote a fact-based discussion about nicotine among key stakeholders.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#6

That is why I have rebuilt the corporate and regulatory affairs function and created an additional management board role. Our position is unambiguous: regulation ought to be shaped by science. That is the reason we hold the view that every smokeless product category deserves its own regulatory treatment, matched to the risk it carries and grounded in the available evidence. My commitment is to steer our transformation in a responsible and transparent manner, by stepping up how we engage with regulators, policy makers and other relevant stakeholders. Certain irresponsible marketing practices observed in some markets are entirely unacceptable, and we ask governments and regulators to back more effective distinction between responsible and irresponsible players. That will establish a level playing field, tackling important matters like underage access and environmental impacts. Encouraging progress on new category regulation is visible around the world, among it recognition of the role of Tobacco Harm Reduction in major markets such as the U.K. and New Zealand. New markets are opening up to make smokeless alternatives accessible for consumers. And a growing multi-category footprint, with 55 markets now regulating more than one new category. Our more front-footed engagement and advocacy actions in the U.K. make me proud, where we launched a multi-channel media campaign calling for better enforcement of regulation around vaping products, so that the vaping industry can help make smoke free Britain a reality.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#7

Moving forward, our plan is to introduce our refresh along with responsible marketing principles and code, which shows our dedication to a responsible approach for this new category. Strong enforcement matters greatly for building functional markets in new categories. We remain deeply worried about the ongoing spread of illicit single-use Vapour products across the U.S., and we estimate these account for more than 60% of the Vapour market. Government agencies, along with state and local authorities, have multiple levers at their disposal to make sure enforcement is properly carried out. In 2023, we observed a modest escalation in actions taken against illicit products, including almost 4 million units that were captured or refused entry into the U.S., plus roughly 5 million U.S. dollars in fines issued by the FDA. Even so, it is clear that far more work remains to be done. Our teams in the U.S. are actively engaging with government agencies and federal and state law authorities, drawing on every tool available to push for better enforcement and, importantly, a level playing field. One recent sign of progress is Louisiana, where a state law has passed that establishes a directory of Vapour products that either have received, or genuinely have pending, a PMTA. A number of other states have enacted similar laws, with additional bills still pending. I am also encouraged that the U.S.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#8

The International Trade Commission has taken up our complaint and is looking into imports of illegal single-use vapour products. Although no meaningful national impact has been seen from this so far, it is clear to us that the push for effective enforcement keeps growing. Now I'll turn to my fifth focus area, which is about improving our financial flexibility. Through the continuous improvement mindset we have established, we keep delivering efficiencies. We remain on track to produce at least £1 billion in additional savings by 2025, and nearly £500 million of that was already saved during 2023. That has been critical in offsetting inflationary pressures. We keep looking for and assessing every opportunity to strengthen balance sheet flexibility. As part of that, we review our stake in ITC on a regular basis. We acknowledge that our significant shareholding gives us a chance to release and reallocate some capital. Our shareholding in ITC has been in place in one form or another since the early 1900s, and it has been subject to numerous share capital changes and regulatory restrictions. For some time we have been actively working to finish the regulatory process needed so that we have the flexibility to monetize part of our shareholding and reallocate some capital. We will update you on this at the earliest opportunity.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#9

Beyond that, we’re continuing to refine where we operate geographically, and we’ve left approximately 35 markets. That aligns with our strategy of departing Combustibles markets that aren’t strategic, since we don’t foresee a near-term chance to carry out our new category strategy there. As a result, we’ll sell fewer cigarettes each year, with only a limited effect on our P&L, and resources get reallocated toward markets offering higher returns. Our free cashflow generation has risen substantially, with 4 years in a row of operating cash conversion of at least 100%. That has let us give shareholders a total of £26 billion across the past 5 years. We’ve made solid headway on de-leverage, finishing the year at 2.6x adjusted net debt to adjusted EBITDA, nearer the middle of our 2x to 3x target range. Across the coming 5 years, we expect to produce roughly £40 billion of free cash flow before dividends. As our transformation continues, our medium-term financial model is going to evolve. That will provide greater flexibility for allocating capital to drive returns and reward shareholders, and it includes carrying on our 20-year track record of progressive dividend growth. When the midpoint of our leverage target is achieved, we’ll assess every option for returning surplus cash to shareholders, among them launching a sustainable share buyback.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#10

Now to my final priority: fostering a culture that's more collaborative and inclusive. With our updated corporate values as our guide, it's clear to me that we'll build on the solid base we have in integrity, collaboration and inclusivity to create the culture required to transform BAT successfully. On that note, I'm very pleased to welcome the new members of our Executive and Non-Executive Senior Management teams. Each of them brings varied, top-caliber sector expertise and experience. Soraya Benchikh, who becomes our CFO, joins in May, and I want to use this moment to thank Javed for taking on the Interim Finance Director position while continuing as Director, Digital and Information. To sum up, we've achieved meaningful progress across every one of these priorities. Even so, more remains to be done. I have confidence that the decisions we've taken are laying solid groundwork for growth ahead and will produce sustainable value for all our stakeholders, as we keep rewarding shareholders through robust cash returns. With that, I'll pass things to Javed, who will walk you through the specifics of our results.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#11

Thanks, Tadeu, and good morning to everyone. The numbers we posted show how resilient this business is. We achieved organic revenue growth of 3.1%, with New Category revenue rising 21% and Combustibles price mix at 6%. Adjusted profit from operations rose 3.1%, and operating margin climbed 60 basis points, thanks to a big gain in New Category contribution and our ongoing push on efficiencies. Adjusted diluted EPS was up 4%, or 1.1% on a current currency basis. On an organic basis, taking Russia and Belarus out of both periods, adjusted profit from operations increased 3.9% and adjusted diluted EPS rose 5.2%. We got there even while absorbing a 2.5% transactional FX headwind. Organic New Category revenue growth remains strong. This clearly shows the strength of our multi-category portfolio, led by Vuse and Velo. So we keep transforming quickly, with smokeless now accounting for more than 30% of revenue across 24 markets. That is close to one-third of the 76 markets where we currently have a New Categories presence. In many markets our transformation has gone even further. Smokeless now makes up 16.5% of Group revenue, 1.7 percentage points higher than in 2022. Leaving aside our U.S.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#12

On the combustibles side, smokeless products now account for over a quarter of Group revenue. Next I'll walk through more detail on the drivers of our key categories; market share figures can be found in the appendix. Within Vapour, we grew our value share leadership with Vuse to 36.1% in tracked channels across the key Vapour markets. We're also continuing to make solid progress on profitability, with Vapour now delivering a positive contribution in four of the five key markets. The fundamentals of the Vapour category as a reduced-risk alternative for adult smokers are strongly positive. The overall number of Vapour consumers is accelerating, and Vapour is the biggest contributor to active New Category usage, driven by growth in both closed system and single-use Vapour. In the U.S., our PMTAs for Vuse Alto's two Tobacco flavour products remain under FDA review. These applications further build on the foundational science behind our successful tobacco flavour submissions for Vuse Solo, Ciro and Vibe. We are confident of a successful outcome for the Vuse Alto PMTAs still under FDA review, and consistent with the time frame the agency most recently communicated, we expect to hear in the coming months. We are challenging the FDA Market Denial Order for Vuse Alto Menthol flavour and have recently been granted a permanent stay by the court.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#13

Beyond the U.S., we keep tackling the expanding single-use Vapour segment responsibly, consistent with our International Marketing Principles and Underage Access Prevention guidelines, and we also take part in takeback programs for proper disposal. Within Heated Products, glo's reported revenue declined 2.5%, while on an organic basis it rose 4.1%. Although our organic volume climbed 12% and our share of the combined Combustibles and Heated Products category kept rising, glo's volume share of the Heated Product category fell 110 basis points to 18.2%. Ongoing category volume share momentum in key AME markets, such as Poland and the Czech Republic, was offset by highly competitive conditions in Japan and Italy. As Tadeu pointed out, more work remains, yet I'm glad to report that our latest innovations, glo Hyper pro and veo, show our capacity to deliver innovative products to the market. Our recent patent settlement will provide further support for this over the medium-term. Turning to Modern Oral, our portfolio kept expanding, with Modern Oral volume rising 33.6% and revenue climbing 39%, fueled by additional geographic expansion and innovation. We continue to increase our volume share of Total Oral, even as our Modern Oral category share declined, largely due to the U.S.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#14

The strong results from our recent Velo pilot in New York are encouraging, with a more premium brand expression and design, and we plan further roll-outs in 2024. We also remain confident about securing the PMTA for our Europe-leading Velo 2.0 platform, which supports our long-term competitiveness in the U.S. Beyond the U.S., we held clear leadership in the Modern Oral category. I'm delighted to report that in most markets Velo is helping drive higher category profitability, with a quick payback period under two years. We still see a significant opportunity for Modern Oral in emerging markets, with strong volume growth in Pakistan and Kenya. Turning now to Combustibles: our cigarette volume fell 5.3% on an organic basis. After adjusting for markets exited during the year, our volume was down 4.6%, versus an industry decline of 3.4%. That gap stems mainly from lower U.S. industry volume and share loss tied to our premium position, plus the impact of significant excise increases in Pakistan. Combustibles price mix stayed strong, rising 6%, with pricing largely offset by geographic mix. All together, that produced a 0.6% increase in organic revenues. Group volume share was flat, as gains in AME were offset by APMEA and the U.S.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#15

Our group value share slipped 40 basis points, which reflects how our commercial plans in the U.S. played out along with losses in APMEA, though in AME we maintained our share. Outside the U.S., we're doing really well in Combustibles, where organic revenue rose by almost 7%, thanks to re-invigorated portfolios, refreshed brands and sharper execution. That shows what our global footprint brings us and how we can deliver even in tough environments. Now let's move to the regions. In AME, 2023 was an outstanding delivery: total organic revenues climbed 13%, fueled by higher Combustibles revenue on the back of a resilient volume performance and pricing. On top of that, every New Category kept growing, with revenue up 39%. AME is genuinely a multi-category region, and smokeless products now account for 23% of regional revenue in the markets where we operate. Adjusted profit from operations rose 10%, helped by better financial performance in key markets. Over in APMEA, we had a strong financial delivery. Total revenue grew by more than 5%, with a robust Combustibles performance powered by pricing. Notably, in Pakistan pricing more than offset the hit from excise-led volume decline, while Bangladesh kept seeing volume growth. Vapour and Modern Oral revenue each rose by over 70%, partly offset by a decline in Heated Products, mainly in Japan, which left New Category growth for the region overall at 3%.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#16

In the markets where we operate, smokeless products are now accounting for roughly 20% of regional revenue. Adjusted profit from operations in APMEA rose 7%, thanks to strong pricing and ongoing efficiency gains. In the U.S., total revenue fell more than 4%, pressured by continued macro-economic pressures and the impact of illicit single-use vapes. Even so, Vuse grew its value leadership in tracked channels by 470 basis points, reaching 45.6%, with revenue up 14%. In Modern Oral, Velo revenue declined because of lower volume. Adjusted profit from operations came in marginally higher, up 0.4%, and our operating margin expanded by 280 basis points as Vuse profitability and efficiency gains offset Combustibles headwinds. U.S. Combustible industry volume was down 7.5%, or 8.6% on a sales-to-retail basis, excluding inventory movements. Beyond market secular decline, industry volume was mostly affected by a combination of macro-economic headwinds and the growth of illicit single-use vapes. On top of those industry factors, our volume performance was affected by lower volume share, reflecting our more premium skewed portfolio, and the California flavour ban. Consequently, our Combustible volumes declined 11.3% in the U.S., more in line with industry decline if you exclude the deep discount segment where we do not participate.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#17

If we zoom out and consider the larger U.S. picture, U.S. consumers did face powerful macro-economic headwinds across 2022 and 2023, but we're beginning to notice some very early recovery signals, with gas prices settling down and the space between wage growth and inflation getting smaller. That said, consumer confidence is coming back more gradually, and it remains well under pre-COVID levels, since consumers keep feeling the cumulative impact of inflation, along with higher interest rates on elevated debt loads, which leaves them with less discretionary income. Against that macro backdrop, the premium segment stayed under pressure throughout 2023. As Tadeu pointed out, our commercial plans are delivering, and we're beginning to produce recovery in both volume and value share within the Premium segment, led by Newport and Natural American Spirit. Beyond that, Lucky Strike keeps performing strongly in the value segment. Consequently, our volume share of the total U.S. market is beginning to level out. Getting our U.S. Combustible business back to consistent value growth will take time, but progress is happening, and throughout 2024 we'll keep executing our plans with care and thoroughness. It's worth remembering that, on the whole, elasticities remain steady versus pre-COVID levels at minus 0.4, and affordability stays high.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#18

Given our strategy across multiple categories and our robust brand portfolio, we're in a strong position to gain from macro-economic improvement and from a rebound in the legal Vapour market once illicit products are effectively enforced against. As we announced at our trading Update in December, we've taken a non-cash impairment charge mainly tied to our acquired U.S. brands. After completing our detailed year-end finalization process and adjusting for FX movements, the total charge recognized comes to £27.3 billion. This reflects the current macro-economic pressures bearing on the U.S. Combustibles industry and the shift in consumption patterns post COVID, together with growth in illicit single-use Vapour products and uncertainty surrounding the potential menthol ban. This approach also aligns with our vision of building a smokeless world. Going forward, our Combustibles brands will be amortized over a maximum of 30 years. Consequently, our annual non-cash amortization will rise by around £1.4 billion from 2024, which will be treated as an adjusting item consistent with our accounting policies. Our acquired U.S. brands account for most of the Group brands and trademarks on our balance sheet and, as such, we don't expect similar Combustible brand value revisions going forward. Importantly, these charges have no effect on our de-leverage, or on our dividend and capital allocation flexibility.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#19

Now looking at how the Group performed: our operating margin saw a robust increase of 60 basis points, even as we took on greater inflationary pressure and a 2.5% transactional FX headwind affecting profit. This came about through better profitability in new categories along with extra efficiency savings. Moving on to EPS, we achieved constant currency adjusted diluted EPS growth of 4%, and 5.2% on an organic basis. That mirrors our resilient operating results, sustained strong delivery from ITC, and a smaller share count. These gains were partially offset by higher net finance costs. The underlying tax rate stood at 24.5%, and given existing tax rates, we anticipate a rate of approximately 25% in 2024. Operating cash conversion came in strong at 100%, which reflects our ongoing emphasis on cash delivery. Just as in 2023, we expect gross capital expenditure for 2024 to fall below adjusted depreciation and amortization, at roughly £550 million, along with net finance costs of approximately £1.9 billion. We kept bringing leverage down toward our target, and we have a manageable maturity profile, with 98% of our net debt fixed, an average maturity of just over 10 years, and close currency matching. Going forward, we are making targeted investment choices to drive our medium-term sustainable growth algorithm. Alongside persistent macro-economic pressures in the U.S., these investments will affect our 2024 delivery.

Javed Iqbal

executive
#20

So because of that, we still anticipate delivering low-single digit organic revenue growth and adjusted profit from operations growth, and that includes a 2% transactional FX headwind. Our performance is second half weighted for revenue and for profit, largely because of the ongoing effect of macro pressure and illicit single-use vapes in the U.S. There is also continued investment in our U.S. commercial plans, mainly weighted to the first half, plus the phasing of investment in AME and APMEA. If we extrapolate current spot rates, we expect currency translation to be a 3% headwind on full-year adjusted profit from operations growth. Past 2024, we expect to progressively improve our delivery to 3% to 5% organic revenue growth and mid-single digit profit from operations growth on an organic basis, and at constant rate by 2026. Lastly, as we carry on our transformation journey, we are focused on how important disciplined capital allocation and strong shareholder returns are. We stay fully committed to a progressive dividend, and we have announced a 2% increase this year, and once the middle of our leverage range is reached, we will evaluate every opportunity to sustainably return excess cash to our shareholders. With that, I will hand back to Tadeu.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#21

Thank you, Javed. There are two key messages I'd like you to take away from what we've presented so far this morning. First, we've taken meaningful steps to sharpen how we execute, and the progress we're making is strong. Second, although we do face some challenges, our performance is holding up well, which reflects the advantages of our broad portfolio. I'd now like to take a few moments to lay out the opportunity and the path that lie ahead for BAT. And to explain why this will produce strong outcomes for our shareholders. First, the Nicotine market is expanding. According to our estimates, which draw on the latest industry data and trends, New Category revenue will add to Combustibles rather than replace it. And looking ahead, New Category volume will more than make up for the fall in Combustibles as smokers keep switching to smokeless products. As a result, the quality of our top-line growth will be far better, since that growth will come from volume. Our multi-category strategy is the correct route into this expanding market. Consumers are picking different alternatives to cigarettes. Markets and consumers are not all alike. And no single solution can satisfy every consumer preference. On top of that, the data shows that when you move into higher tar markets, such as Canada and the U.S., penetration with Vapour is much higher.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#22

Heated Products, meanwhile, are more likely to succeed in markets where cigarette strength is lower. Japan illustrates that point clearly. Delivering across multiple categories will fulfil our A Better Tomorrow purpose. Our new vision—to Build a Smokeless World and to turn into a business that is predominantly smokeless, with 50% of revenue coming from smokeless products by 2035—is one we are dedicated to. Through rolling out our multi-category portfolio around the world, we can actively motivate smokers to Switch to Better. To make that possible, we have sharpened our Group strategy. This gives a clear line of sight right across the organization. It rests on three strategic pillars: Quality Growth, Sustainable Future, and Dynamic Business, which underpin delivery of our goals. The six areas of focus for sharper execution that I set out earlier already line up fully with these wider strategic pillars. And the values we have just launched are a crucial enabler for the whole business, sitting at the heart of who we are as BAT. Performance will be assessed against every strategic pillar. We will keep working to hone these measures and targets, and to bring our proposals into closer alignment in this year's remuneration policy review. I look forward to sharing further details at a later date.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#23

I have confidence in how our financial performance is progressing. As new categories grow to represent a larger share of our business, the forces behind our growth will change over time. That range captures the CAGR growth we expect across the whole period, not targets set for each year. Growth in our adjusted profit from operations will come from larger scale benefits that lift New Category contribution margin, along with Combustibles cost efficiencies that create positive operational leverage. Thanks to this, Group margin will stay at a high level. Since our transformation keeps evolving, we will go on giving guidance annually. This growth algorithm underpins our ambition of 50% Smokeless revenue by 2035, and we expect Smokeless revenue to hit roughly one-third of Group revenue by 2030. To sum up, 2023 delivered resilient financial performance consistent with our guidance. There is no doubt. There is more to do. We are sharpening how we execute so we can handle near-term market challenges and position the business for a stronger future. The targeted investment choices we are making in 2024 are laying the foundations for long-term growth and value creation. A thrilling opportunity lies ahead, with growing nicotine industry value powered by New Categories. And evidence is now emerging that our multi-category strategy will deliver long-term profitable growth.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#24

We're committed to rewarding shareholders all through our transformation, and that's powered by greater financial flexibility, disciplined capital allocation, and strong returns for shareholders. So Victoria will now come up on stage with us for the Q&A session. Javed and I will be glad to take your questions.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#25

Thanks, Tadeu, and good morning, all. <<operator_script>>. We'll start by taking questions from the phone lines.

Operator

operator
#26

Thanks. Our next question comes from Richard Felton at Goldman Sachs. Richard, the floor is yours — your line is open.

Richard Felton

analyst
#27

Morning, and thank you. I have two questions, please. First, on the U.S. Vapour category: I realize pinning down an exact figure may be hard, but could you give us any color on the pace at which the total U.S. Vapour category is expanding, covering both illicit and tracked channels? My second question concerns U.S. Combustibles. Many thanks for the encouraging data points on how BAT is performing relative to the market. Still, the category overall remains under some pressure, and volume declines are coming in larger than has historically been the case. I understand there are many moving parts — illicit Vapour, tough macros, and some remaining COVID unwind. But when you look at the U.S. Combustible market over the medium term, what do you regard as the normalized rates of volume decline? And given BAT's commercial strategy, what is your outlook on pricing in that market — do you still view U.S. Combustibles as a source of EBIT growth? Thank you.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#28

All right, then—let me work through what you've asked. Starting with the first question, which falls under Vapour. In the U.S. market, Vapour is expanding considerably. Our estimate is that we currently have roughly 29 million <<inaudible>> Vapours across the U.S. That said, the bulk of the growth—and I'd put our expansion at approximately 20% over roughly the past year—has come primarily from this illegal modest product. As we see it, a revenue pool of about £10 billion currently exists in Vapour, and 60% of that ties to this illegal product. So over time we've built a very strong Vapour business in the U.S. As our disclosure shows, we've reached more than £1 billion in revenue. Our operating margin level today closely resembles that of cigarettes—I'm speaking of operating margin, not even gross margin. So it's a big business we've built in the U.S., and we're very proud of those efforts. At the same time, we're certainly frustrated that no level playing field currently exists in the U.S. We're aware the FDA is taking action to strengthen enforcement. Our view is that far more still needs to be done on that front.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#29

Once they wrap up the PMTA review process, that will mark an initial milestone, since at that point we'll be able to identify which illegal products never should have been on the market to begin with. Still, it's encouraging that certain states are tackling this issue themselves and passing legislation aimed at certifying PMTAs and tying that to the products they'll seek to enforce within their own local markets. As we disclosed in the presentation, we're doing everything we can to collaborate with authorities at the federal level and at state and local levels that we're involved with through ITC. We continue to expect that ITC could eventually reach a stage where we see enforcement at a meaningful level, which would be ideal, I have to say, though plenty of work remains. That's where things stand today on Vapour in the U.S. On the Combustible side, you're right. A great deal of change has occurred over the last four years, I'd say. As a reminder for everyone, what we started from was a decline of roughly 4% to 5%, essentially a secular decline in the U.S.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#30

Turning to the market: then out of nowhere, in 2020, we observed a rise of 1%, 1.5%, since consumers were under lockdowns and getting substantial support at the federal level and at the state level, and that entire process began to taper off over the next two years. On top of that, this whole process has been made worse by the conflict that began between Russia and Ukraine, along with the inflation that followed in its wake, and with considerable pressure on consumers' purchasing power. So what we see in the market today is a situation in which the macros are weighing heavily on it. Yet even though we are seeing early green shoots when it comes to unemployment levels, gas pricing moving in the right direction, and even inflation now easing, we still see a lot of pressure on consumers' purchasing power stemming from high levels of debt. The cost of debt remains very high — mortgages. And we think it will take some time for this whole process to unwind. It's hard to predict. We are not providing guidance for 2024, but it is easy to see that these macros account for at least 2.5%, 3% of the decline in the U.S.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#31

So my best guess, if you'd like one, is that this comes after we see some normalization — and we will see it, because economic cycles always work that way. Historically, there have been ups and downs. Nothing will be different this time. Our view is that the market could very well be stabilizing around a 5% to 6% decline, with the recognition that more and more smokers are migrating into poly user products. Of course, the unknown in this whole process is the level of enforcement the FDA needs to carry out in terms of modest that has impact — and not only in the Vapour business I just mentioned, but in the Combustible business as well.

Operator

operator
#32

UBS's Faham Baig — Faham, the floor is yours; your line is open.

Faham Baig

analyst
#33

Morning, Tadeu, Javed and Victoria. I've got a couple of questions too, if I may. First, on the ITC stake: could you remind us where things stand regarding the approvals needed to cut that stake, and what timeline you're expecting? And more importantly, what should we expect BAT to do with the net proceeds? In other words, might those proceeds come back to shareholders via a buyback? Second, on heated tobacco, do you have any early signals about how the market has reacted to the EU flavour ban? I believe you said BAT managed to hold on to its share. And later on, I think you pointed out that in the Czech Republic our share has in fact increased. So could you give us a bit more detail on how BAT's share is performing, given that glow has historically been over-indexed to flavours? Thank you.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#34

Alright, let me begin by addressing your question, ITC. I'll use it as a way to provide some context, since it matters that we remind everyone of our starting point. BAT generates a very large amount of cash. Each year, our free cash flow comes in above £80 million. That tells you that, when we think about our progressive dividend policy and absent any significant or material M&A, if you will — on a business-as-usual basis — we can bring the company's leverage down by roughly 0.2x to 0.3x, subject as we just noted to the FX rate at year end. We showed exactly that across 2023. And there are essentially two reasons we've stated that we want to get at least to the middle of the range. First, the world has changed, and starting in 2022 we witnessed an unprecedented rise in interest rates, which peaks at very elevated cost-of-capital levels relative to where things stood over the prior decade, if you will. And even if we anticipate rates beginning to decline, we've probably not — we have never returned to the point where we were before.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#35

Alright, so the world has changed. Capital now costs more than it did previously — that's the first thing, and it's obvious. The second thing is quite specific to BAT. We still face a headwind stemming from Canada and the CCAA, and I've been fully clear and transparent on that. At present, roughly £2.3 billion in cash is trapped in Canada. Once we — and if we at last — I can't share much detail about the process now under way with the plaintiffs in Canada. But we would expect that cash to be released if we ultimately reach an agreement with the plaintiffs, and also eventually to take some material headwind on our earnings going forward. To illustrate this in simpler terms, if you removed that element entirely from our figures, we would see the ratio improve by between 0.2x and 0.3x. That's the reason we need the buffer. And I believe we have a very solid plan to keep reducing the company's leverage organically, and I have no worries whatsoever on that front.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#36

So certainly, we're looking for ways to allow more flexibility when it comes to how we allocate capital. That financial flexibility stems from the challenge of trying to divest some of the assets held within the Group. One reason we've exited 30 or more than 35 markets, mostly over the last two years, is also a result of that. We bring in some proceeds from this, though not really that material. There's also the benefit that the Group is now refocused going forward when it comes to allocating resources toward the genuinely growth markets ahead. And this was a very good exercise. We keep doing that. But we can't ignore the fact that the biggest asset on our balance sheet is the association with ITC as an associate. So that's why we're discussing ITC in this release today. Today, we want to maintain a level of influence in ITC, which is transforming itself. Under local legislation, a minimum of 25% of shareholders need to retain their veto rights. That's what we'd like to do in the first phase.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#37

So that means, since we're above 29, there's room for us to bring our shareholding down. What we need to do now — and we've been at this for a while — is work with people on the ground, more closely with the authorities, mainly at the Central Bank, and with ITC's help, to reconstruct the entire history of BAT's shareholders going back 100 years. As you can imagine, over that stretch ITC has grown inorganically, which adds another layer of complexity. There have been bonus issues, share splits, subscriptions. The regulatory environment has also shifted, mainly where tobacco is concerned. So we've had to rebuild that whole history, and that's what we've been working on for some time now. It's very hard for me to give you a timeline, beyond saying that we're doing everything we can to create this flexibility so the board can make an assessment on capital allocation decisions going forward. In the meantime, we're very supportive of our stake in ITC. It's a fantastic company, well run, well managed, a very fast growing company in a very fast growing market with the most populous country in the world, and it's accretive for BAT in terms of earnings and also in terms of cash, because they have a very good dividend payout policy — and the share price has actually doubled over the last three years.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#38

That's the current position with regard to our ITC holding.

Faham Baig

analyst
#39

The second item was the HP ban.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#40

Yeah, the HP product. And yes, the EU flavour ban. So first off, in Europe, roughly 50% of the consumables in Heated Products are flavoured. For us, we're over-indexed there — more than 7% of what we sell in Heated Products in Europe is flavoured. That's why launching this new herbal product mattered so much, and we did it, first in the market, and we're very happy with how competitive this product is, and it resonates quite nicely with consumers. Setting their own timing is up to the European markets. Some markets haven't done it — Czech, as you mentioned, is one of them. Romania is another. In those markets where we've seen the flavour ban already happening, we managed to hold, and sometimes even grow, our overall share with veo, which is very pleasing to see. Some other important markets, like Poland and Italy, are still to come. So this is a process that, in terms of these flavour bans being introduced, we expect to wrap up by mid of this year, and we're very well pleased with that, because not only is it a great alternative, but at the same time we're rolling out this new device, the glo Hyper pro, which has enhancement capabilities, new to the wall display.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#41

Additionally, the heating delivers a higher temperature, which makes it more satisfying — satisfaction. The session length is also longer. So we're moving in the right direction.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#42

There's one more question coming in from the phone lines.

Operator

operator
#43

Thanks. We'll take the next question from Gaurav Jain at Barclays. Gaurav, your line is open — go ahead.

Gaurav Jain

analyst
#44

Good morning, and thanks. There are three things I want to ask about. The first one concerns pricing trends at Newport. You clearly have a stabilized share, and that share is growing, but it seems to be coming at the cost of pricing, and people are worried that what you're doing might cause pricing discipline in the U.S. cigarette market to break down. Could you comment on that? My second question concerns new product launches. You're emphasizing the new glo product launch — can you also discuss new product launches in the other two segments, meaning Modern Oral and e-cigarettes? And my third question concerns leverage. Your competitors are all now running at less than 2x leverage, and that's also where PM is guiding to. So is the right leverage for you also closer to 2x rather than the middle of 2x to 3x? Thank you.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#45

Alright, Gaurav. Regarding Newport, what we're doing is introducing laddering in the brand, which lines up with the commercial practice we've observed in the markets. So in that sense, we aren't really doing anything unique. It's simply a recognition that when an economic downturn hits, our consumers have absolutely no safeguard when it comes to continuing with the brand. So we introduced a soft pack. We piloted that in some states in 2023 very successfully, as you could see in the numbers we have demonstrated, and we expect to roll out this practice throughout 2024. And it's important, despite the fact that there is a mix impact on that, to keep consumers in the family, because we have seen from the past that when the economic cycle changed, the consumer uptrends. And so it's important that we keep them in the family, and that's exactly what we want to achieve with the introduction of the laddering, the Newport specifically. For sure, that's not just it, that we are doing. We are also assessing, reassessing some channels where we haven't really been present before as we should, like for example deeper discount channels, $1 channels that consumers start migrating to, and we are establishing some trade practice that can be competitive in those channels to support our brands as well.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#46

And beyond that, as I said in the presentation, we're adding trade reps, and all of that has a favorable effect in the market. So we're being very deliberate about how we do this, very measured in how we do this — which is why we've said from day one that this is a process that won't take months; it will take longer than that, and we're continuing to do what we need to do through 2024. The early signs in that space are very positive. It's important to make the point about the Combustible business just to see that the U.S. market — total nicotine in the U.S. market in terms of volume and revenue, without the issues we faced in 2023 — is going, I understand the focus on the Combustible because it's quite cash generative. But overall, the nicotine space in the U.S. is still very favorable. And now, for sure, a big chunk of that is going into the illegal products and modern disposals that we expect enforcement should come through on. And then once it comes through, open up this white space, and we'll be positioned better than anyone because we're the leading brand in Vapour as well.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#47

So, connecting that to your second set of questions about other products: in U.S. Modern Oral, we do have an improved product. We ran a pilot on this refreshed offer to consumers — covering the campaign, the communication, and how the product feels and looks — and it went very positively in New York. Our plan is to roll it out across the year. In Modern Oral we also have all the plans — very exciting ones — around new SKUs that we'll launch in different markets where we have the freedom to do so, though not in the U.S., and that will simply support our leading position, since basically we're the leader everywhere else apart from the U.S. On Vapour, a strong pipeline is coming starting from the second quarter of this year on the disposable side, and on the refillable side as well, along with new technologies, and those will hit the market very soon — we're very positive about the innovations coming through. And on leverage, as I said, 2.5x is basically our starting point — for us it's a starting point that gives a bit more flexibility than what we have currently.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#48

It's not that we intend to remain fixed at 2.5x. As I mentioned, leverage doesn't worry me much, since this company generates a great deal of cash, and in any given year we're capable of achieving improvements of roughly 0.2 or 0.3. So my view is that after reaching 2.5x, we'll enjoy greater flexibility than what we have now. That's really the crux of what I'm saying regarding the midpoint of the target.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#49

We have one more question coming in from the lines.

Operator

operator
#50

Thanks. We'll take the next question from Rashad Kawan at Morgan Stanley. Rashad, the floor is yours — your line is open.

Rashad Kawan

analyst
#51

Yes. Thanks, and good morning, Victoria, Tadeu and Javed. Appreciate you taking my questions. I have just a couple. First, going back to heated tobacco, regarding the settlement with PMI, could you explain whether those legal disputes hurt your capacity to innovate, and how you see this affecting your prospects in that category going forward over the medium term, if at all? Then my second question is just to dig a bit deeper on U.S. Combustibles. I know you'd rather not provide 2024 guidance on the U.S., but if I could frame it a little differently, given how you've given preliminary guidance for 2025, do you expect the current level of competitiveness in the marketplace and the down trading we're seeing to carry on into next year? Thank you.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#52

All right. Regarding the IP agreement with PMI, it was mainly about resolving every one of those outstanding disputes we had worldwide, and that is done — notably, as I should stress, with zero compensation, no monetary payment at all. For us, the effect shows up right away in that case we had against Vuse Alto in Virginia, in the U.S., plus quite a few disputes that were pending around glo in Europe and also Vuse in Germany, to name a few. Beyond that, this agreement gives both companies something: peace of mind, so we can concentrate on advancing and speeding up the Tobacco Harm Reduction agenda and innovating in line with it. That means greater freedom for us going forward, and it will be very positive not only for BAT but for the industry overall, because I believe everyone in the industry really wants a better outlook with the various stakeholders around just how important it is that Tobacco Harm Reduction moves faster across the many jurisdictions. So this was a strong step forward, I have to say. The Combustible business — yes, you're right, that one is difficult for me. But at the end of the day, I'm trying, and anybody could make this kind of analogy.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#53

A lot of the negative factors we're dealing with right now stem from macroeconomic conditions. And as for the macro picture, my expectation for next year is an improvement over this year, since discussions are already underway about interest rates eventually beginning to come down, and we know consumer confidence and cigarette sales are correlated. We've seen in the past that when interest rates begin to decline, sentiment shifts overall and confidence can eventually bounce back, which would have a favorable effect on cigarettes. So the assumption is that next year will be better. And of course, one big unknown, as I mentioned earlier, is enforcement regarding Modern disposal, which also has an impact on the Combustible side. But from a macro standpoint, we would expect business to improve starting in '25.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#54

I think there's another question coming in from the line.

Operator

operator
#55

Yes, we’ll take the next question from Jonathan Leinster at Societe Generale. Jonathan, the floor is yours — your line is open.

Jon Leinster

analyst
#56

Alright. Thanks, and good morning, gentlemen. Yes, I have a few questions if I may. First of all, regarding the launch of the glo Hyper Pro — I mean, you described it as a premium product. Does that mean it will actually be priced differently from earlier iterations, and are the consumables any different as well? So is this a sort of step up aimed at trying to avoid the sort of price discount we've seen in some of the key markets in terms of the sort of Mainline glo Hyper?

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#57

Yes, Jonathan, this device is already priced higher than the one before it. Obviously, it's a far better device, and we've got room for that. So that's one thing. The consumables are going to be improved consumables, and how that plays out depends heavily on each market's circumstances. It's really hard to offer anything like a single answer that fits every case. What we have in hand, we believe, is much improved for the consumer relative to what came before. And we always want to reassess — there's a great deal of activity in Tobacco Heating Products below WAP right now, as we speak today. So it isn't simply a matter of what we wish to do; it's how we read the competitive landscape, as is usual in this situation.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#58

Looks like we’ve run out of time. Jonathan, my apologies—go ahead and finish your questions.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#59

I believe there's another question over there. Yes, Jonathan.

Jon Leinster

analyst
#60

Yes. All right. Very briefly — well, maybe not so brief. Regarding vaping markets internationally, quite a few countries have moved to formalize the market after it had been something of a gray area before. Is that something — are there major markets out there where you expect vaping markets to be formalized in a way that would represent a genuine opportunity for you?

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#61

So, we're seeing — and it's encouraging — some markets treating Tobacco Harm Reduction as a really prominent foundation. Take New Zealand, for example, which we just saw being very supportive of vaping, and that's quite favorable. Even the U.K. wants to regulate further, but they keep in mind that this is a very important tool for reducing the incidence of smokers generally. Canada is the same. It comes down to how you finetune the regulation. More recently we're seeing accounts like Chile, where we expect them to open up the market for Vapour at any time. And we note there are discussions in big markets such as Brazil — they have a public consultation running as we speak about whether they will regulate Vapour or not. Turkey is another big market. Under our current assumptions, we aren't expecting any of those big markets to make big moves in the short term. But we expect this as we progress, and this is one focus area — like I said, the sustainable future is about that. We expect to have more and more evidence-based science and fact-based points to engage with all of those different authorities and governments so we can unlock the potential that could make a tremendous positive impact for the currency smokers in those markets.

Jon Leinster

analyst
#62

Alright, thank you.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#63

I appreciate it.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#64

As I mentioned, unfortunately we've gone past our allotted time, though I believe there's one final question remaining on the line, and we'll take that one.

Operator

operator
#65

Thank you. Our following question comes from Joffrey Bellicha Meller at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Joffrey, the floor is yours — your line is open.

Joffrey Bellicha Meller

analyst
#66

Thanks a lot, and I appreciate you making time for this. I've got two questions. First, regarding the demerger of ITC's hotel business, I'd like to hear how you're viewing your stake in that company going forward, and whether you'd look to exit it right away, assuming the regulatory approvals come through. Then, on U.S. Combustibles margins, when you talked about the laddering of products — for instance, the launch of soft packs with Newport — is the margin on those at the same level as what you get on your regular Newport products? Thanks so much.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#67

To answer your first question, Joffrey: I've told you before that BAT has no strategic intention to remain a minority shareholder in an Indian hotel. Keep in mind that they're floating 60% of the hotel business — that's 6% of their hotel business overall. It's early to pin down the exact timing; we expect it will land more toward the end of the year, and the board will decide what to do with the stake when the time comes. So I'll leave the hotel question there. On the second one, the laddering in Newport: we can't maintain the same margin levels at the very top price point. But more importantly, given the cannibalization we're seeing and, even more so, consumer retention, we view it as a very positive move — which is why we ran pilots, drew our conclusions, and are now beginning to roll out through 2024.

Victoria Buxton

executive
#68

Thanks so much, Tadeu and Javed. And thanks to all of you for your questions. I'm sorry we didn't get to the questions submitted online, but our IR team will be answering those later today. With that, I'll turn it back to Tadeu for closing remarks.

Tadeu Marroco

executive
#69

All right. Thanks, everyone, for tuning in today. In closing, although plenty of work remains ahead, I have no doubt that the investment decision we're making will demand crisp execution and lay the groundwork for growth over the long term along with value creation. Thanks once more for being with us today. I'm eager to keep you informed as we make progress and as we work together more closely.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete British American Tobacco p.l.c. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to British American Tobacco p.l.c. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in British American Tobacco p.l.c. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.