California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 27, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 24 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Dave Healey

executive
#1

Thanks, Tiffany. I'd like to welcome all of you to the earnings call for California Water Service Group covering the fourth quarter and full year of 2019. Joining me on this call are Martin Kropelnicki, who serves as our President and CEO; Thomas Smegal, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Paul Townsley, our Vice President of Business Development and Chief Regulatory Officer. Details on the dial-in number to access a replay of this call are included in the earnings release for the fourth quarter and year-end that came out earlier today. That replay can be accessed through April 27, 2020. Just a note before we get started — there's a slide deck the company has prepared to go along with this earnings call. That deck was provided with an 8-K this morning, and you can also find it on the company's website, www.calwatergroup.com. Prior to reviewing the results for the year-end and fourth quarter, we want to spend a brief moment addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, certain forward-looking statements may be made by the company. Since such statements involve events in the future, they carry a variety of risks and uncertainties, and what actually happens may differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages every current shareholder, along with any interested parties, to thoroughly read and understand the disclosures regarding risk and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports we file periodically with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll now turn things over to Tom to get us started.

Tom Smegal

executive
#2

Thanks, Dave, and good morning to all of you. Welcome to the earnings call we hold each year. I'll begin by going through the slide deck, and I want to apologize — I've realized there are no page numbers on it this time — but my plan is to begin with the table showing financial results, which you'll find on the deck's sixth page. That covers our results for the full year. Beginning with earnings per share: we posted $1.31 per share, which represents a decline of $0.05, or 3.7%, compared with last year's full-year earnings per share. Net income came in at $63.1 million, a drop of $2.5 million, or 3.8%, versus last year's earnings. Turning to the quarter — the fourth quarter — our per-share earnings were $0.24, which is $0.08 below the fourth quarter of 2018, and net income reached $11.3 million, $4.1 million lower than the earnings recorded in the fourth quarter of 2018. I should point out that, on both of these slides, capital investments for the year totaled $273.8 million. That figure stands as the largest CapEx ever recorded by our company, and it stems from a significant fourth quarter for CapEx. So, at the bottom of that fourth-quarter chart, we recorded $78.8 million of CapEx during the fourth quarter, a substantial increase over the fourth quarter of 2018. We'll get into some of that later on in the deck. Moving to the general description of our financial highlights for the year, keep in mind this marks the third year of our California General Rate Case cycle — the 2015 rate case in California — and this is when our rate relief is at its most limited. The rate relief we did see failed to cover the increases we experienced in asset-related costs, wages, and other operations costs. So that, unfortunately, is pretty typical of how things unfold in California under this cycle. Paul Townsley will speak shortly about our General Rate Case and next year's test year, but that pattern is generally what we encounter in year three of the California General Rate Case cycle at our company. We did record a $4.4 million reduction in business development expenses, which was offset by the non-recurrence of $3.3 million that we had received in 2018 as drought cost recovery. The third item here concerns our public safety power shutoffs along with wildfire risk reduction activities. That amounted to $2.1 million for the year. We've identified that throughout the year. The change in value of our benefit plan investments actually contributed $7.4 million this year, and that was partly offset by a modest reduction to unbilled revenue of $2.2 million and $1.6 million, once again, of a nonrecurring benefit that had arisen in 2018 from our company-owned life insurance. The fourth point here is that our final effective tax rate came in at 22%, which was above the 20% tax rate we had in 2018. The reason for that is a lower state tax deduction tied to repairs, which cut net income by roughly $2.3 million; and I brought up the CapEx. So let's move fairly swiftly to the fourth quarter financial highlights; and once more, what's different here is mainly tied to the items I discussed a moment ago, the drought program costs that didn't repeat, the recovery there, $3.3 million. The General Rate Case increases we had that weren't fully offsetting our higher wages, operating expenses and asset-related costs, the PSPS cost in the quarter and the various other items that were typical of the year. So now, I'll turn things over to Paul and have him speak a bit about our 2018 General Rate Case.

Paul Townsley

executive
#3

Yes. Thanks, Tom. So, back on October 8, we submitted a settlement to the California Public Utilities Commission, and that agreement was worked out with the California Public Advocates Office; through it, we resolved the large majority of matters that were at stake in our rate case, and included within that settlement were roughly $609 million in new capital investments that both sides agreed to, plus approximately $200 million of capital that had been authorized either in 2018 or earlier years. A small number of items remained unresolved through the settlement. Among those were keeping our Water Revenue Adjustment Mechanism, or WRAM, in place; retaining our Sales Reconciliation Mechanism; certain balancing accounts tied to pension and medical costs; and then additional matters, such as depreciation, working capital and financing during construction. We're waiting on a proposed decision from the administrative law judge. Interim rates were approved by the judge to take effect as of January 1, yet we still haven't gotten a PD, or proposed decision, from the judge, whether on the settled items or the disputed ones. And the commission has said it intends to issue a decision within the first half of 2020. Tom?

Tom Smegal

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Paul. Given the postponement in the rate case, we felt it was worth flagging that our first-quarter 2020 reporting could look somewhat out of the ordinary. What's behind that is management still isn't at ease with the contested matters in the rate case, and we might choose — when we put out the first quarter earnings report, should no proposed decision come through confirming approval of those items, we might choose against reflecting our balancing account along with regulatory assets and liabilities in that first quarter earnings report. My sense is we'll give you color, so we'll offer a range showing what would have been recorded had we prevailed on those issues, or had we known for certain that we'd prevailed. That said, the actual first quarter results, absent a proposed decision, might not include these balancing accounts. As a result, it could come across differently from the kind of first quarter we normally post for the company. Keep in mind, though, that we do have interim rates, plus rates dating back to January 1; so once a decision comes out — and the commission has said at this point that it anticipates issuing one during the first half of the year — we'd be in a position to retroactively receive credit for those items in the first quarter. So I simply want to ensure nobody is caught off guard in late April should a decision or proposed decision not arrive by that point. Just keep that possibility in mind. And Marty, would you like to cover CapEx?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#5

Right. Thank you, Tom. So I'd like to give a quick update on where things stand with the capital program. Tom walked through a few of the financial highlights moments ago; across the full year, the money we invested ourselves plus what developers put in totaled slightly under $274 million, and that marks a record high for the company. Compared with '18, that represents a 0.8% gain; the figure that matters more, though, is the quarter-over-quarter comparison. Looking at Q4 2019 versus Q4 2018, capital spending rose 33.9%. During the fourth quarter, $78.8 million was invested. Two factors really explain the higher fourth-quarter investment. First, the Palos Verdes water supply reliability project is now underway, and it stands as the biggest project this company has ever taken on. We made genuinely strong headway on it during the fourth quarter, and it should finish up in the back half of 2020; second, the fire season turned out quite mild. If you track our story and our presence across California, our footprint is quite wide and plenty of those areas face possible fire dangers. So having a light fire season in 2019 was welcome, and it let us keep our attention on the capital program and deliver those results from the fourth quarter — again, a 33.9% increase. Beyond that, the company rolled out its at-the-market equity program, which was — has been created and put in place to support our capital needs over the coming 3 years. We expect to raise roughly $300 million through 2020. And by year-end, $19.3 million of new capital had been raised to fund our capital acquisition program. So we're quite pleased with how the ATM program has performed and how it's functioning in the market. On business development activity, Paul, would you bring us up to date on that?

Paul Townsley

executive
#6

Yes, definitely. Our company's efforts to grow the business keep speeding up, and during 2019 we closed multiple agreements that, after receiving approval from the different regulatory bodies, will expand our customer base by roughly 4.5% — a fairly significant gain in the number of customers. Only a handful of these appear on this slide. On November 6, we shared news of a deal to purchase Rainier View Water Company, located in Washington State. That company adds 18,000 customer connections to us. Once it gains approval and is finalized, it should roughly double how large our Washington operations are. We submitted a change of control application to the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission, and our expectation is that this deal will get the commission's green light in the first half — rather, in the second half of 2020. On December 23 of last year, we reached an agreement to buy Kapalua Water Company along with Kapalua Waste Treatment Company; both are situated on Maui, and together they provide service to 1,000 connections at the Kapalua Resort; after that, in January of 2020, we lodged an application with the California Public Utilities Commission so we could begin serving what we had announced earlier, namely the Preserve at Millerton, a greenfield development located in Central California; so there's plenty happening on that front.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#7

I want to return to the topic of wildfire and Public Safety Power Shutoffs, which people call PSPS for short. Like I said before, having a gentle fire season this year was a real gift, and because of that we were able to perform really well on the capital side. Even so, staying alert with our program is essential. You may remember that back in 2019, a number of PSPS events occurred, particularly up in Northern California. At one point, 64 locations were left without water — sorry, I mean without power. During that long stretch with no electricity, not a single one of our customers lost water service. Our total costs came to roughly $2.1 million, split between PSPS and wildfire prevention work: $1.5 million went toward PSPS readiness, and about $600,000 went toward wildfire prevention. We're already at work on the 2020 program. We brought the team together and went through our lessons learned, asking what needs to get better as we head into this year. Those plans are moving along well, and we expect to take on additional costs in 2020 as we prepare for wildfire season and get more ready for power outages across the state. We'll pursue regulatory recovery and make future filings for the expenses tied to these 2 events. All in all, I believe the company's planning and the way it executed its business plans surrounding these events was quite strong in 2019, and I'm eager to carry that momentum into 2020 and take care of our customers when these events happen. Now I'd like to say a few words about perfluorinated compounds, which are also known as PFOA and PFOS; over the past several months this has been a hot topic in the media. PFOA and PFOS are man-made substances commonly found in industrial processes and consumer products. Things like firefighting foam, shampoo, clothing, food wrappers — anyone at home using baking sheets or baking paper when you bake cookies so the bottoms don't burn too much — all of them contain these compounds called PFOA and PFOSs. Within this class of families, there are usually about 5,000 of these compounds in total. PFOA and PFOS are 2 of the compounds found in these. These compounds also go by the name forever chemicals; up to now, no regulatory maximum levels have been set by either the Environmental Protection Agency or by state regulators in the states we serve. We've observed MCLs taking effect at the state level in New Jersey and New Hampshire, and we expect other states to do the same. We also expect the EPA might accelerate its process to issue an MCL in the states we serve, and we believe the regulation will change quickly. On top of that, in February of this year, 2020, California's Division of Drinking Water lowered its response level for PFOA to 10 parts per trillion and for PFOS to 40 parts per trillion. A response level isn't a health standard, but it essentially tells you that once a well reaches that level, DDW advises pulling it from service. Under their rules, a risk assessment gets done, and testing of your wells must follow their testing guidelines. That testing has been finished in California. Roughly 11 wells sat at or near that response level, and we're removing them from service. That said, we chose to move forward and test every one of our water sources across all 4 states for PFOA and PFOS, simply to make sure we hold a full data set and thorough information about our water supply. For context, that amounts to 11 wells out of about 1,100. So for the remainder of 2020, we'll keep testing all of our water sources, even where they fail to meet the selection criteria set by DDW or the EPA, just to learn what else might be present. Public health is always our aim, along with limiting any exposure our customers face, and we'll keep cooperating with the state toward that end so we maintain the highest water quality possible; we also expect to recover a portion of these costs via regulatory filings as the process moves further along. Then, finally on this subject, the company has joined the consolidated product liability litigation brought against the makers of firefighting foams, which in our view is the primary source of contamination entering the water supply. So expect further developments regarding PFOA and PFOS; this is a fairly complex matter. We're glad to discuss it in greater depth should people have questions. But watch the MCLs, and know that we're ahead of the program and doing the right thing.

Tom Smegal

executive
#8

Okay, moving to the following slide. I'll discuss the decoupling balancing accounts now. During 2019, in California—where the WRAM and MCBA apply to us—our sales came in at 86% of what had been adopted in estimates. As a result, our net WRAM receivable climbed to $62.6 million. At the close of 2018, that figure stood at $56.1 million. The adopted sales figures were revised downward because the sales reconciliation mechanism was triggered, which lets us modify our sales when they fall short of the target during the second and third year of a rate case cycle. If the SRM hadn't existed, the WRAM balance would have been substantially larger—roughly $14.9 million more than the current amount. So having that mechanism in place makes us quite pleased. Let me skip ahead a few pages to our CapEx. The CapEx table shows few alterations, though we are now reflecting the complete CapEx for 2019. Our 2020 and 2021 projections look much like what we presented at the close of the third quarter, and they stem from the rate case settlement that we anticipate the commission will sign off on at some point during the first half of 2020. Turning to the following page, the regulated rate base. One modification deserves mention: we've refreshed 2019, and it now shows the year-end rate base. Previously, what appeared there was a depiction of the advice letter projects we managed to secure under the regulatory framework from the 2015 rate case. The majority of those advice letter projects hadn't been submitted by the close of the year and will be submitted in the years ahead, especially the Palos Verdes Water Supply Reliability Project. That explains why that particular data point has dipped somewhat. However, the projected rate base for 2020 through 2022 remains unchanged. Those stay exactly as we laid out in the third-quarter slide deck. So, Marty, would you like to close things out for us?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#9

Absolutely. Thank you, Tom. So I hope everybody is getting the impression that we're really intent on getting our 2018 General Rate Case behind us. Like Tom said a bit earlier, there could be some choppiness if we begin drifting into the second quarter with no proposed decision in hand, and our hope is that the CPUC will bring our General Rate Case to a close, which would let us steer clear of a great deal of wasted effort that, honestly, is simply costly and delivers very little in the way of added benefit. And that's simply the way we arrived at stating the figure. So our attention is going to remain sharply fixed on that. We're eager to bring the Rainier View employees into our company. As Paul noted, we've made our filing with the UTC and are hopeful the transaction can be completed at some point in the middle to latter portion of 2020. The people at Rainier View have impressed us greatly, as have the methods they use to operate their business; we feel there is a solid cultural alignment with our own culture, and they will be a warmly welcomed addition to our family. And finally, our focus will remain on operations. The shifting PFOA and PFOS matters, getting ready for wildfire season along with additional PSPS outages over the course of the year, and ensuring we've kept our water at a high quality while serving our customers as well as we possibly can. So as 2019 comes to an end, I'd call it a highly successful year; it's somewhat disappointing that the rate case is being pushed back, since the company did, in my view, a terrific job attempting to keep it on schedule. But now we must wait on the regulators. And we'll continue doing what we do, which is put money into capital and grow our company in order to serve our customers. So with that, Tiffany, I'll turn it over — open it up for questions and answers, please. Thanks, Tiffany. I'm aware that our good friends at Aqua are holding their Analyst Day today and our call falls during their Analyst Day. So we'll be in the office the entire day. Should anybody have follow-up questions, don't hesitate to contact Tom, and all of us will be around and happy to take any one-on-one questions anyone might have. And thank you for the support you showed during 2019. And we look forward to speaking with everybody over the course of 2020. Thank you, and have a good day.

Operator

operator
#10

Everyone, that wraps up the conference call for today. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.