California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 30, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Healey

executive
#1

Thanks, Lisa. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the second quarter 2020 earnings call for California Water Service Group. Joining me on this call are Martin Kropelnicki, who serves as our President and CEO, and Thomas Smegal, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Details on the dial-in number for the replay are included in the second quarter results release that came out earlier today. That replay can be accessed through September 30, 2020. Also, a quick reminder before we get started: for this quarter's earnings call, the company has prepared a slide deck. That deck was submitted with an 8-K this morning, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Prior to reviewing the second quarter results, we'd like to spend a few moments addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, certain forward-looking statements may be made by the company. Since these statements involve future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results might differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages all current shareholders, along with interested parties, to thoroughly read and understand the company's disclosures regarding risk and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports filed from time-to-time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll now hand things over to Tom to get us started.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#2

Thanks, Dave, and hello everyone, welcome to the earnings call for our second quarter. As a quick note before we start, I believe most people joining us already know that the key issue affecting the company this quarter is really identical to what we saw in the first quarter: we still have not gotten a proposed decision or an actual decision regarding our California General Rate Case, which had been anticipated before January 1, 2020. I'll kick off the discussion of results on slide eight of the deck, covering the quarter briefly, then the year-to-date picture, and continue from there. Starting with slide eight for Q2, net income fell by $11.7 million, landing at $5.3 million, which takes us from a $0.35 gain in the second quarter of 2019 down to an $0.11 gain in the second quarter of 2020. The dominant issue is the absence of rate relief from the California Commission, and our estimate is that if that rate relief were granted, there are two main components, the same pair we discussed during the first quarter call. Altogether, $29.1 million is what we believe would have been realized as additional pre-tax income had the Commission issued a decision favorable to the company. Within that, for the second quarter, $10.9 million reflects the straightforward delay tied to the settlement agreement the company submitted with the consumer advocate back in October of 2019, and that amount is being tracked in an interim rate memorandum account for recovery later. Then there's $18.2 million, representing income from our disputed cost recovery regulatory mechanisms. Keep in mind these are mechanisms we've relied on for many years — first, to decouple our sales from revenue, which we'll discuss considerably more later on the call, and second, our regulatory mechanism covering the pension and healthcare balancing accounts. Since those are disputed in the case, we didn't record them the way we ordinarily would, and if we had recorded them this quarter, we estimate additional revenue would have been $18.2 million. Those regulatory mechanisms correspond to certain cost increases we experienced in the quarter. We saw $6.5 million in higher water production expenses, $5.7 million of which those regulatory mechanisms would have offset, plus $2.1 million in higher pension benefit expenses, which likewise would have been offset by those regulatory mechanisms if they had been in place. On other fronts for the quarter, we experienced a rebound in our unrealized benefit plan investment performance, coming in $3 million above the second quarter of 2019. Also, there were other developments you'd expect from a utility in our position. Our depreciation expense rose quite similarly to what we saw in the first quarter — it was $2.2 million higher in the second quarter — and that ties back to more plant investments during 2019. We also saw maintenance costs climb by roughly $1 million. If you look at slide nine, the year-to-date picture tells much the same tale with much the same reasoning; the figures differ, yet the reasoning doesn't change. Net income fell by $24.4 million, landing at a loss of $15 million for the year-to-date period. On earnings per share, we show a loss of $0.31 year-to-date versus a gain of $0.19 in 2019. Once again, the two drivers trace back to the rate case, and we think that if a rate case had been approved and it came out in the company's favor on these items — the $19.8 million standing for the postponed settlement agreement amounts, plus $26 million tied to those regulatory balancing accounts we've been talking about. Year-to-date, our unrealized benefit plan investment performance came in $4 million below the first half of 2019, and that's really because market conditions were comparatively strong during the first quarter of 2019. Other year-to-date impacts follow the same pattern: depreciation expense is up $4.3 million and maintenance expense is up $1.6 million. Slide 10 looks a lot like the one we showed you in the first quarter earnings deck. Our view of the estimated full-year benefit from the California GRC hasn't shifted. As the table on that chart shows, we put the benefit at somewhere between $38.9 million and $42.2 million on an annual basis, and we still expect that once a decision comes down in the case, that will be the benefit to the company. Our 2020 sales forecast, as we noted last quarter, sits roughly 7% under the 2019 adopted sales. So when we discuss the WRAM and the MCBA, we think we're far more likely to land closer to adopted sales than was the case in 2019. And as I said before, had the settlement been adopted, we would have been permitted to record extra revenue of $5.6 million to $10.9 million in the second quarter, with the bottom of that revenue range tied to a $5.2 million decrease in depreciation expense. Now, getting somewhat more granular on slide 11 regarding the disputed GRC items, I just want to highlight that the two things — the WRAM and the MCBA — we believe for the second quarter amount to about $14.9 million that would have gone into those balancing accounts, and the pension and medical cost balancing accounts, we believe, would have come to $3.3 million. Also, once more, we have strong assurance that sums previously logged in those accounts can be recovered no matter what the Commission decides moving forward in the General Rate Case we currently have underway. And as for the remaining contested matters in that rate case, we don't see them playing a significant role in either the second quarter or the results for the year to date. The pages have quit functioning, so I'll pass over the EPS bridges we have, since those get covered in the narrative. And I'll hand things over to Marty for a COVID-19 update.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#3

Morning, everybody. Thank you, Tommy. This second quarter has definitely been eventful, what with coping with the COVID-19 pandemic, and as I believe most folks are aware, utility staff count as essential personnel, so the bulk of our workforce — more than 90% — has reported to the field daily. Because of that, safeguarding those workers, and safeguarding our customers too, is extremely, extremely critical. We follow every local rule across the regions we serve, and we were among the earliest to require masks and other protective gear for the entire workforce. As you've likely read in news reports, California — and in particular Southern California, LA County and Kern County — has experienced a spike in infections, and over the last several weeks we've watched caseloads and hospitalizations climb, plus a small number of staff members have caught the virus away from the job. When that happens, we've managed to keep service interruptions to a minimum. Naturally, we quarantine any worker with any kind of exposure so they don't infect fellow employees, and that approach has worked. Our Customer Centers across all 4 states have stayed shut and will stay shut until we say otherwise. We've also halted every collection action, trying to keep water flowing to people. Beyond that, we've provided extra assistance via a direct grant initiative. You might remember that the company set aside $0.5 million for charitable giving — part of it supported local food banks and food pantries across the areas we serve. Another portion of that grant funded what we termed direct aid, or a direct grant, for customers having trouble paying their bills; and that has turned out, in my view, to be helpful, and even more significantly, I've gotten many letters from customers thanking us for giving them a hand. To date, we've had zero service interruptions despite COVID-19, on top of some of the rioting and other troubles we witnessed in Southern California late in May and at the start of June, and so we've stayed on course doing what we do best, which is delivering clean drinking water to our customers. Tommy, would you like to walk through how the pandemic has affected the business?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#4

Absolutely. Thank you, Marty. So what we're seeing is that customer accounts are aging more, and keep in mind this stems partly from the higher unemployment rate and partly from regulators instructing us that collections cannot proceed. As Marty might have mentioned in the prior quarter, this company chose on its own to pause collections earlier. Our state regulators then mandated that step. Even so, there is currently a regulatory requirement to halt collection efforts, and for California that requirement currently extends through April 2021. So this suspension of collections is going to last a long while. Bills that remain unpaid beyond 90 days — the ones that under normal circumstances would have gone to collections — have climbed to $3.4 million. Historically, whenever those bills were routed to collections, only some portion of the amounts tends to be uncollectible. Because of that, we increased our balance sheet estimate — the bad debt reserve for doubtful accounts — moving it from $0.8 million up to $1.6 million at the close of the second quarter. Water sales remain robust, especially among residential customers. That is helping counter a pullback in sales to business, industrial and public authority customers. That latter piece, I believe, reflected things like schools shutting down in the late spring. In resort areas, notably Hawaii, we are seeing a sales decrease that we're tracking. At the California utility, Cal Water, as we discussed during the first quarter, we turned on the catastrophic event memorandum account, which lets us track costs tied to COVID. During the second quarter, we put roughly $600,000 of added operating expenses into that memorandum account. Those are sums we will pursue recovery of through a later filing with the Commission. As you'll remember, a memorandum account isn't something where we normally record revenue until an authorization to recover that revenue exists; on top of that $600,000 of added operating expenses, once we do incur bad debts and those proceed to collection at the conclusion of this period, that too will be part of our request to the Commission for recovery. Hawaii has a quite similar mechanism that we're working to establish. A filing has also been made with the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission there. Our liquidity position is solid. At the end of June, at the close of the quarter, we held $114 million in cash along with additional current borrowing capacity on our credit lines exceeding $170 million. Marty, would you like to walk us through all the fun stuff in California?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#5

Well, California has a tremendous amount happening right now. To begin with, a number of you might be aware that the CPUC — that's the California Public Utilities Commission — pushed back the date by which it will examine and wrap up our 2018 General Rate Case, moving it to September 30th. What that means is that for the deadline to be met, a proposed decision has to come from the Commission by no later than August 25th. So we're keeping an eye on that and are hopeful we can get it finished. As Tom mentioned before, the absence of rate relief is hitting us financially, and it becomes quite muddled every quarter when we discuss our numbers both with and without rate relief. So we're hoping to have it concluded during the third quarter. Maybe even more significantly, from a policy standpoint, on June — pardon me, July 3rd — the CPUC put out a surprise proposal in a case that's unrelated, and I'd like to read the entire title of this OIR to you, then I'll return to discuss it. The complete title is: Evaluating the Commission’s 2010 Water Action Plan Objective of Achieving Consistency between Class A Water Utilities’ Low Income Rate Assistance Programs, Providing Rate Assistance to All Low Income Customers of Investor Owned Water Utilities, and Affordability. So this OIR was examining consistency along with the objectives of reaching consistency for low income rate assistance programs. So this proposed decision from July 3rd, which sort of emerged from left field, would — if it gets adopted — obligate Cal Water and other CPUC-regulated water utilities to put forward eliminating its decoupling mechanism in the upcoming General Rate Case. This decision troubles us for several reasons. Above all, it reaches conclusions based on an extremely narrow body of data and evidence; as a matter of fact, we aren't even aware of what went into building the data tables the Commission relied on to reach those conclusions. Only 2 hours of workshops were offered alongside this rule-making; and in our view it's simply a poor decision, and it also works against the state's objectives of making conservation a way of life; and we went after decoupling and conservation aggressively from early on, as the Water Action Plan directed. So we're deeply engaged, speaking with the Commission last week and this week regarding this proposed decision, and we see it heading the wrong way relative to the state's policy favoring conservation and the state's conservation goals. Just as a reminder to everybody, California's Ag business exceeds $60 billion. It's the biggest Ag state in the union, and our population is expanding from nearly 40 million to 45 million across the next decade. So the notion of doing away with decoupling and essentially carrying out what this OIR contains effectively raises rates for the majority of customers, low income customers included, so we are absolutely opposed to it and we are lobbying against it. There's still uncertainty around how this policy choice might impact the proposed decision we're currently waiting on; from a legal standpoint, it ought to move things into the following rate case cycle. That said, we're examining it and investigating it as we speak. So expect further updates regarding this PD that came out in early August. A great deal of our effort is going toward essentially requesting a pause so that additional evidence can be entered into the record, along with a thorough review of every piece of data available covering the past 12 years of decoupling, and our view is that the Commission would arrive at a different outcome if all the evidence were before them. Turning to capital investments for the quarter, this honestly stood out as a bright spot amid all the somewhat negative developments, and it's encouraging to see our capital program rose 9.5% versus the equivalent period a year ago. So $133.5 million was invested by us during the first half of 2020. Earlier, the company had projected spending in the range of $260 million to $290 million on capital across 2020. Although a few individual projects have slowed down, other areas, such as our main replacement program, have been able to speed up; as a result, we've stayed on track, at least as of this midpoint of 2020. Naturally, that might shift based on how the virus plays out and whether additional shutdowns arise that could hurt our overall capacity to invest capital and get it into the ground. Beyond that, we've tacked on an extra $5 million of capital investment tied to our Rainier View acquisition, which was completed in the second quarter, and if you flip the page, I'd like to discuss business development, Rainier View included. Our acquisition received approval from the Washington Water Service Company and the Washington UTC, the Commission in Washington, and we finalized that deal in June, which means Washington Water Service Company is now the biggest investor-owned rate-regulated utility overseen by the UTC in Washington state. We've also submitted applications in Hawaii to regulators seeking approval for the change in control of our Kalaeloa system on O'ahu and our Kapalua system on Maui, and we expect those to close, hopefully, by the end of the first quarter of 2021. You'll notice — you can see on the slides that roughly 18,500 customers were added through Rainier View, the Kalaeloa system is set to bring in about 200 customers, and historically for us that's the former Barbers Point air base on O'ahu, which will be redeveloped into residential and commercial properties. And then there's the Kapalua Water & Wastewater System, located just north of our Ka'anapali system on Maui, featuring a couple of large hotels, golf courses and developments. If you tally those together, wrapping up the 2 in Hawaii, that contributes slightly below 4% to the overall number of customer connections we had for 2020, which strikes us as quite robust considering everything we've contended with regarding the pandemic and all the rest. Our business development team, meanwhile, has stayed occupied and kept delivering solid results. Tom, would you mind walking us through the following few slides?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#6

Okay, thank you, Marty. Now regarding the slide showing our capital investment history — that's slide number 19 — we've revised what we expect for 2021 so that it reflects an extra $5 million put toward the former Rainier View Water. That's why you'll notice a slight increase in that area. Then, moving over to slide 20, the one covering our regulated rate base, we've incorporated the projected higher rate base for 2020 along with the 2021 capital investments tied to Rainier View, so those figures have risen somewhat. Clearly, this remains far smaller than what our California operations represent, and the overall shape of those curves stays the same, but the numbers themselves have been refreshed. As you're able to see, we remain on track, just as Marty said, and we expect these figures to hold, provided the settlement is adopted by the Commission. One more thing — and I apologize this isn't shown in the deck — but on slide 20 you'll find that the third row, labeled advice letters included in the settlement, comes to roughly $150 million, and that pertains to the California settlement. Yesterday, our company submitted an advice letter to the Commission to kick off the recovery process for the Palos Verdes Water Reliability Project. That's a 96 point — I believe it's a $96 million authorized advice letter covering that enormous project — the biggest one in this company's history — and we did complete those advice letter filings. It's now subject to a review process, and we don't expect that advice letter to be approved anytime soon; we're aiming for early 2021 to get it approved. But for those among you examining the rate base and that light green section, if you will, on the chart, the good news is that the bulk of it has already been filed for at this point. So, Marty, I'll hand things back to you for the wrap-up.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#7

Appreciate it, Tom. So, you ought to have a feeling that in Q3 there are likely three or four key items drawing our attention. Number one, the PD — that's the proposed decision regarding Affordability and Low Income Assistance — keeping our attention there, plus the work to bring our 2018 General Rate Case to a close. I believe this ranks among the rate cases with the longest delays that we've likely seen across at minimum the past decades. So we're eager to finish it up with the Commission and put it behind us. On top of that, the COVID response — it appears to shift daily, CDC requirements keep changing, and we still must report to work each day. We aren't a company with a large share of staff sheltering in place; we have to be there and keep producing and supplying water to our customers. So we make certain we keep taking every possible step to safeguard our employees and our customers while we handle COVID and head into the fall season, which means entering flu season too. And finally — this could grow into one of the bigger matters as we progress deeper into the third quarter — we're entering wildfire season, along with the genuine chance of ongoing public safety power shut offs. As we all know, the power might go out, yet people still require water, so the operations team has prepared extremely well for wildfire and the PSPS season and we stand fully ready to meet whatever challenges arise; thus Q3 is shaping up to be quite a busy quarter for us, and we're eager to share our results with you once we close out the quarter and report at the end of October; so with that, Lisa, let's open it up for questions, please.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#8

Hi, everyone. It's a good morning, and I appreciate you answering my question.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#9

Morning to you, Durgesh.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#10

Morning.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#11

Before I get into my question, I want to tell you that I genuinely value everything being done here and how open you've been. These are obviously extremely difficult days for you folks, yet you've more or less kept those of us in the investment community informed about each development, so credit to you for that. Now, about the proposed decision, I was hoping for one quick point of clarity. Turning back to slide 11, does that proposed decision apply to the WRAM and MCBA decoupling mechanism — that's the second bullet — or does it cover the WRAM/MCBA decoupling plus the pension and medical costs? I was just looking for a bit of clarity there.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#12

Certainly. This low income docket, the Commission's proposed policy decision, centers solely on the WRAM and MCBA mechanisms. And once more, as Marty mentioned, given how that proposed decision has been drafted, the company would feel the effects during its next rate case cycle. That means the 2021 filing, assuming that proposed decision were adopted with no modifications, and therefore neither of those items would be touched during the interim period; even so, you ought to be aware that the ratepayer advocate clearly fought that issue, along with the WRAM issue, against us in this rate case, and they've filed comments with the Commission in the rule making arguing why wait, let's get this finished for Cal Water. So this is definitely something we must stay wary of; we must keep pushing back and ensure the Commission grasps that moving from a decoupled water utility to one without decoupling isn't simply flipping a switch. Some significant rate design changes are required. To remind everybody, what decoupling accomplished back in 2008 was permit the company to embrace an exceptionally risky rate design. You've witnessed that in the WRAM balances we've carried across the years. The rate design, though, works so that a greater share of our costs get recovered via quantity rates instead of fixed charges, and a greater share of those quantity rates get recovered via the top tier; thus it's an accelerating cost recovery. It concentrates our fixed cost recovery on the customers consuming large amounts of water. And when you examine the companies lacking decoupling — those with the MRAM price adjustment mechanism — you'll notice they recover considerably more of their revenues via fixed costs and their rate designs are far flatter, so it would be premature and genuinely disheartening if the Commission removed the WRAM from play for us in the present rate case without altering the rate design. So essentially, within that proposed decision, you have one positive element — the rest of it is overwhelmingly negative, but that single favorable piece acknowledges that a substantial amount of work will be required around modifying the rate design along with other elements in order to eliminate a WRAM mechanism. Because of that, our expectation is that this particular wording will carry some persuasive weight with the Commission as it considers the case we currently have before it. Hopefully that answers your question, Durgesh.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#13

Got it, Tom. That's really useful. Okay, and then regarding the EPS bridge, Tom, on slide 12 — am I looking at this the right way? The effect of that $14.9 million appearing in the water production cost bar chart — is that how I should be thinking about it? So basically, you're not receiving recovery for those water production costs that went above what was allowed — is that the correct interpretation?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#14

Yes; so looking at the bar chart, the water production costs are shown there. That won't match the $14.9 million precisely, since a portion of that $14.9 million comes from revenue that was lower and never earned; as I said, water sales came in roughly where we expected. I believe they're at approximately 96% of adopted. So a smaller piece of that $14.9 million is in fact the revenue shortfall from lacking decoupling, as opposed to only the water sales piece.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#15

Got it, that's clear. So then, last thing — whatever detail you're able to give us. From what you said earlier, it sounds like you've had a few meetings with the Commission over these last two weeks. So heading toward August 6th, what are you expecting — do you believe the Commission will actually issue a ruling, or do you figure this gets taken up in some later proceeding? Any detail at all would be helpful.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#16

Sure. So we split the meetings up — I handled the first few, and Tom will take one or two of them this week too. We — we believe it's reasonable to keep asking about low income and underserved communities. That said, going from examining how consistent low income ratepayer assistance programs are to eliminating decoupling strikes us as quite a leap. That's essentially what we've told the Commission. And it differs from one commissioner to the next. One commissioner asked me, why not simply do away with it, and said we ought to eliminate the increasing block rates and reduce how many tiers there are. The trouble with that is it runs directly against what they're trying to achieve — equity among underserved communities and low income ratepayers. It raises rates for nearly every customer class, and honestly, doing so ends up benefiting the heavy water users while hurting those who use less. So our argument has been straightforward: at the very least, pause it, let there be a proper review of all the data and facts — not merely that very narrow, limited set of data we think the Cal advocates assembled — and then have a thorough conversation about it. This is a major policy change. Meanwhile, the State Water Resources Control Board has put all this effort into making conservation a way of life. How do you keep growing the economy, handle the expanding Ag business, handle population growth, and make conservation a way of life, when now a PD comes out saying they want to reverse all of that? So there's a disconnect there that matters a great deal when it comes to state policy versus what the CPUC is proposing to put in place. So we're highlighting those inconsistencies, since we consider them very significant. As all of you may recall, at the time we put a WRAM in place, we initially absorbed some criticism from the Wall Street side, since we were surrendering the chance to earn more as water sales increased, and our statement at that time was simply that this was the correct policy call for the state and for the company, given our desire to push conservation hard. So we are presenting the case. When you speak with the commissioner’s staff, they keep things quite close to the vest. The policy advisors keep things quite close to the vest as well. They pose many solid questions regarding our positions and regarding the data on which we depend. So what we seek is at minimum a hold, or perhaps a — an alternative, essentially more or less throwing out the proposed decision. And discussion of it is set for August 6th, and we will simply have to see how it plays out. A hold or a stay could be placed on it by any commissioner. In the same way, an alternate could be written by another Commission.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#17

Got it. Thanks, and I’ll squeeze in one final quick item — I’m grateful that you took the time for every question I had. Whether or not things move forward on this, will you put out some kind of release on August 6th, or file an 8-K, since for you this counts as a fairly material event — or are you not able to comment on that yet?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#18

Everyone will continue to receive updates from us. My sense is that a hold — simply an ordinary hold dated August 6th — might not lead to an 8-K, yet should any real decision come down, or should there be a signal that a final proposed decision has been made public, that would trigger a formal communication; so, I believe, if nothing shows up...

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#19

Got it. Thank you very much.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#20

I believe that if you aren't seeing anything, then — yes. My view is that when nothing shows up, that indicates it was held, since in every other scenario you would see something.

Durgesh Chopra

analyst
#21

All right, that's great, thank you everyone.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#22

Excellent, appreciate it, and hello there.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#23

Hello, Ryan.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#24

Morning.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#25

Let’s keep going on decoupling, and I’ll push back a bit on your position that this — that the new proposal amounts to bad policy. You brought up getting criticized by the street. I suspect some of those jabs came from us. What drives that is our belief that a key reason ROEs in California sit near the bottom nationally is that, despite what you said, Tom, regarding how risky the rate structure is, they’ve contended the decoupling mechanism lowers the business’s inherent risk, and it appears they’ve made that case successfully and sort of forced ROEs downward. So my question is this: suppose for a moment you don’t get what you want and this moves forward — could there be a silver lining, in that it removes their ability to make that argument, or at least means they can’t make the reverse argument they’ve been making all along, and might we then see some easing on the ROE front over the next few years if that happened?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#26

Ryan, those are excellent points. Still, the fact pattern to remember is that our cost of capital is handled as a group effort involving four companies, three of which have the WRAM mechanism, with San Jose Water being the fourth. And they have — looking back at all those proceedings, no difference in the allowed ROE has ever been recognized between the three WRAM companies and San Jose Water when it comes to the cost of capital and the riskiness involved; therefore, I’m not sure we can place much confidence in the notion that eliminating a WRAM mechanism would lead to a higher ROE for us. So I hope you’re correct, but even so, I’m somewhat skeptical that it would actually occur. I’ll just leave it at that, we’ll have to wait and see, and of course, for anyone who doesn’t remember, we’ll file for a new cost of capital next March, which would theoretically take effect on January 1, 2022, and that’s the Commission’s standard process. Marty, anything you’d like to add there?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#27

No. I believe that's correct. If decoupling lowered the risk, we'd definitely be achieving our ROE annually, and that clearly hasn't happened over the past 10 years. It does help by taking away the disincentive to push water sales, since it secures the margin. But as you said, Ryan, should things move in the opposite direction, that turns into a point for cost of capital. We'd absolutely assess that alongside the economists who assist in drafting our testimony, examining it both qualitatively and quantitatively. Still, it comes down — for me it returns to basic arithmetic and the policy choice facing the state: California is an enormous, enormous state, and there are no, as they say, no new water sources. You could turn to Desal, which carries a big carbon footprint and is extremely pricey. So your least-cost option remains conservation, and there are 40 years of case studies involving electric and gas in California showing decoupling works. So I truly believe this is a shortsighted move coming from a very narrow band within the commission attempting this. Their reasoning is simply poor. But as you mentioned, if — should they flip it, might we possibly raise that point on cost of capital? Yes, possibly, and it's likely a valid point. I'm not sure it would draw much interest; they're quite difficult to dispute on cost of capital, but we could definitely give it a shot.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#28

Got it. Okay. I think you've already covered a lot of the wider context — sorry, I mean the tactical side of things — pretty thoroughly. So my last question is really more of a macro one, a very macro one at that. When you look at how COVID has played out, at first glance it seems like regulated utilities haven't gotten especially favorable treatment when it comes to policy and stimulus. I mean, on the one side, you're classified as essential, so you have no choice but to keep running — and that simply means spending money. Yet if your customers say they require the product, you must provide it at no charge, despite the fact that significant federal government stimulus is arriving for households through unemployment benefits and stimulus checks. So I suppose what I'm really asking is: what's the path to get there? And is there any kind of industry-wide push right now to advocate for being treated better when the next stimulus package comes around — basically saying, if these checks are going to go out, could we demand some level of verification, so we know folks are covering essentials like water and electricity and so on, rather than spending on optional things first? It feels like utilities end up stuck in a rough position with the way this is unfolding. Any perspective on that?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#29

Tom, I'll start us off here, and then, Tom, you're welcome to add whatever you'd like. Regarding NAWC, you're probably aware that we brought Rob Powelson on board. On the government affairs side, he's been quite occupied following the legislation, keeping an eye on it, and working to weigh in on those bills. With any stimulus package at this moment — and we all saw the GDP numbers shrink today — the difficulty is that for folks who've been out of work, what we're really discussing now is bare survival. That makes it somewhat tougher to gain traction. We consider ourselves quite lucky, since we have a catastrophic COVID memo account set up, which lets us monitor additional expenses we take on because of the pandemic, and there's a chance we could recover those costs later, after we've gathered everything, submitted the claims, and had them reviewed. So the thing I find more compelling is that, among the customers we've applied that direct grant program to, half a dozen letters arrived this week from individuals, customers, whom I've never encountered, expressing gratitude for the grant program; and most of those letters essentially conveyed, thanks, we truly value the assistance. I realize I got behind on things, but there's a payment plan in place and my intention is to give the company its money back. So my wish is to hand that credit back over to you, and I'd ask that you steer it toward some other segment of the community where the need is greater, and what has been a really — for Tom and me, this quarter has been a sort of hellish stretch, with — our auditors are present, we have Board meetings scheduled. When those letters arrived, I have to admit I smiled and said that despite everything happening around the world, there are still people who care and do the right thing; and so my feeling is that we don't yet know how this will turn out. I think I attempted to go for a stroll during my lunch break. On the West Coast, things remain firmly closed, eateries are not operating, lodging establishments have not reopened, and the economic fallout from this slump will keep being enormous. So as a utility, I think it's somewhat difficult to advance that policy point at the federal level right now, while they're reviewing assistance measures. What interests me more is whether they establish a capital improvement initiative or a capital expenditure initiative, and ensuring water utilities receive fair and equal consideration regarding any funds that could be set aside for capital endeavors, and what is under discussion at this moment, Michael and Rob Powelson have been extremely, extremely engaged in that. Tom, is there anything you'd like to add regarding that.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#30

Nope. I'd say that's excellent, Marty.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#31

Excellent. Well, hey, I appreciate you spending part of your morning with us.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#32

Thank you, Ryan.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#33

Thanks.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#34

Appreciate it.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#35

Good morning, Jonathan

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#36

Good morning, Jonathan.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#37

Morning. Given the uncertainty around WRAM, do you figure the low income ratepayer docket PD needs some sort of resolution before a GRC proposed decision comes your way?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#38

That one I can't answer, Jonathan. My sense is that this could turn into a point of contention in the GRC. Whether it actually is or isn't, I honestly don't know. The way the PD and the low income piece is drafted, in my view it has no bearing on our GRC, but I'm not able to peer into the heads of the people handling our current GRC case. It's definitely something that could happen.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#39

From where I sit, it appears that — unless the CPUC completely drops the WRAM MCBA matter and then launches a distinct probe into it — the GRC proposed decision ought to wait for how this docket turns out?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#40

Yes; however, what I see as the key distinction, Jonathan, is that within the GRC a proposed settlement has existed since October. And looking at it through case law, these are two distinct proceedings, while ours was meant to wrap up by 12/31/2019. So I have not witnessed — and I was searching my memory, reflecting on every year I have spent at Cal Water plus at Pacific Gas and Electric — have I ever witnessed something like a retroactive ratemaking-style ruling issued by the PUC. I cannot recall a single one, so I believe the merits, viewed through case law, favor us. Yet like Tom mentioned, it is genuinely tough, you examine what this PD is labeled and where it landed plus the reality that it involved a very, very, very narrow data set and you do sort of scratch your head; and so we are attempting to figure out what on earth is happening with it; so I would say, never say never, yet I believe the arguments favor us and case law favors us. Still, I would say never say never, since you simply never know.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#41

Sure. Jonathan, here are two additional pieces of information on that. To start with, state law prevents the commissioners from discussing these matters with each other, and keep in mind that Commissioner Randolph is handling our General Rate Case. As we understand it, she is not permitted to have spoken with Commissioner Guzman Aceves regarding her policy decision. So any holdup affecting our rate case, at minimum through July 3rd, was unrelated to the policy decision Guzman Aceves was developing, at least from a theoretical legal perspective. Commissioner Randolph is also a strong government lawyer, which is to say she is an attorney who has faith in good government; therefore, I don't think that barrier has been crossed; so any postponement of our rate case, at least through July 3rd, had no connection to the policy decision. I should also mention that I realize this probably isn't a company many of you track; however, Liberty Water Utilities in California has a proposed decision, and that decision deals with some of the very same issues involving the WRAM and other balancing accounts. That proposed decision was issued, I believe, just on Monday of this week — or perhaps it was Friday of last week — and it does not align with the policy proposal. It states that the WRAM is performing well, that Park Water and Apple Valley ought to keep their WRAM mechanisms. They ought to keep their pension balancing accounts. So there doesn't appear to be any coordination of efforts there; but, once again, we will simply have to wait and see what ultimately comes out.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#42

Sure. What I'm attempting to work through here is whether there's a situation in which the proposed decision in the low income ratepayer docket, which now involves a separate investigation, and then the proposed decision in the rate case both come out and the rate case says no, you can keep the WRAM/MCBA. It doesn't seem logical that it gets taken away in one docket while the broader policy conversation is still underway, or on the flip side, if the PD is adopted as it currently stands in the low income ratepayer docket and it says fine, it will be eliminated in the next rate case, so not in this one. You'd think then that this current GRC proposed decision ought to include keeping it, as opposed to Public Advocates' stance that it should be eliminated immediately. I mean, I view it differently. This decision is intertwined, and I understand the idea that one shouldn't affect the other, or under land the proposed decision on your General Rate Case, but now they are intertwined, it seems.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#43

Yeah. No. I follow what you're saying, Jonathan. I believe that if the PD and the low income case were adopted as originally drafted, there would be a — it would be very hard for the Commission to simultaneously come out and say Cal Water ought to eliminate their WRAM mechanisms in the case they filed in 2018. I completely agree with you on that, and so I suppose that's a possible silver lining. I mentioned earlier the comments, clearly from the Ratepayer Advocate, that amount to let's get this finished kind of comments; so that might lead to a change in that proposed decision in the policy gate. We are very hopeful that isn't what happens, but you're correct from that perspective, I think, they wouldn't want two decisions that conflict with each other.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#44

Yeah. No. I appreciate you bringing up that point regarding Liberty Utilities. That was news to me as well. That's quite interesting. So, taking all that into account, how would you assess the odds that the CPUC rules on the low income ratepayer docket at the meeting on August 6th? From what I last saw, I believe it was placed on the consent agenda for approval?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#45

That's usually how it begins, Jonathan. So unless someone removes it from consent or places a hold on it, the standard approach is that it starts as an agenda decision, then it begins on consent; it truly hinges on the commissioners and their offices determining that the comments we have submitted and the work we have been doing to inform people about this matter are worthy enough to postpone the proposed decision or possibly to draft an alternate decision. As of right now, there has been no specific reply from any commissioner to hold the PD or to propose altering the PD, and it may not be customary for them to make that sort of announcement. These things are generally very last minute; so regrettably, I believe we will be waiting even as meetings keep occurring and not only Cal Water, but the other parties in the case and other interested parties keep meeting. I doubt you will learn about a hold or a possible alternate until very near to that next — to next Thursday's meeting.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#46

Alright. I genuinely appreciate the extra detail, and best of luck navigating all of these issues.

Thomas Smecal

executive
#47

Yes. Thank you, Jonathan.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#48

Thanks, Jonathan.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#49

Hi, Angie.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#50

Hello. How are you doing? Regarding the WRAM, I won't pose any inquiries, since, well, it's obvious that none of us really has clarity on it. But I do have another thing to ask you: what's the situation with the catastrophic memorandum accounts for costs tied to COVID? I simply want confirmation that this implies those expenses don't pass through the P&L when you disclose earnings — adjusted earnings — since you're postponing them into that memorandum account. Is that right?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#51

Well, that isn't right, actually. The catastrophic event account functions as a memorandum account, and under our accounting policy, regulatory assets and liabilities get recognized from balancing accounts. A memorandum account includes a reasonableness check, which happens when the filing process concludes. So, as I noted, the $600,000 for the quarter that gets recorded to the memorandum account — it appears in the P&L as an expense. Later, we'd seek recovery by filing with the Commission, and once the Commission grants approval, we would record revenue tied to that.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#52

All right. Since, among the California utilities I can bring to mind — and my coverage spans electric, gas, and water — you're essentially the sole one that continues putting those costs through the P&L.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#53

All right.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#54

My impression is that everyone else operates under the belief that a recovery is expected, and because of that, these amounts don't count as an expense.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#55

All right. Well, I'll connect you with the people who audit our books, and we'll have them look into it; this has simply been the company's — this has been the company's approach to recognizing revenue for quite a while. So we're at ease with that line drawn between balancing accounts and memorandum accounts. And once more, what sets things off is the Commission issuing us an order to recover something, and at that point we'll move forward and record it as a reg asset and record it as revenue.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#56

So in the same way, will any kinds of backup power costs tied to PSPS events also be running through the P&L?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#57

That's right. And as you may remember, I think we had some expense amount during the prior year. I don't have it with me right now. But for PSPS we maintain a separate memorandum account, and we do anticipate filing to recover those costs; it appears in our financial statements from the previous year. I can't provide the figure since it isn't in front of me. But those costs did run through the P&L, and once we submit that filing, future recovery is expected.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#58

Okay. Thank you.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#59

Thanks.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#60

Great.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#61

Great. Well…

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#62

Thomas, go ahead. Thank you, everyone. As Tom mentioned, the third quarter is clearly going to be busy. We'll be dealing with the proposed decision on affordability, and should anything significant come out of that, we'd respond with a filing. On top of that, we're continuing work on the rate case and navigating our way through COVID. So we're eager to reconnect with all of you once Q3 wraps up. We appreciate the questions you brought today and your attendance, we wish everyone well and stays safe, and we'll be in touch before long. Thanks, all.

Operator

operator
#63

This concludes today’s conference. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.