California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 6, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 46 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Dave Healey

executive
#1

Thanks, Bridgette. Good morning, everybody, and thanks for joining us for California Water Service Group's 2020 Third Quarter Earnings Results Call. With me on the line today are Martin Kropelnicki, who serves as our President and CEO; Thomas Smegal, our Vice President and Chief — and Chief Financial Officer; and Paul Townsley, our Vice President of Business Development and Chief Regulatory Officer. Information about the replay dial-in for today's call appears in our third quarter earnings release, which was issued earlier today. You'll be able to access that replay through February 5, 2021. One quick note before we get started: the company has prepared a slide deck that goes along with this quarter's earnings call. Earlier today, an 8-K filing included the presentation slides, which you can also find on CalWater Group's site, www.calwatergroup.com. Prior to reviewing the numbers for this quarter, we want to spend a short while addressing forward-looking statements. At various points in this call, the company might express certain forward-looking statements. Since such statements concern events yet to come, they carry a range of risks and uncertainties, and the company's actual outcomes may end up substantially different from what it currently anticipates. For that reason, we urge everyone who owns stock in the company right now, along with anyone who might be considering an investment, to review closely and make sure they grasp what we've shared about risks and uncertainties in our Form 10-K, our Form 10-Q, our press releases, and the other documents we periodically submit to the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll now hand things off to Tom so he can get us started.

Tom Smegal

executive
#2

Thanks, Dave, and good morning to all of you; this quarter has been quite an exciting one for those of us at California Water Service Group. We have the chance to discuss at some length our California General Rate Case, along with several other developments taking place during the quarter. As Dave mentioned, I will walk through the slide deck, and I will point out slide numbers as we move through the presentation, just as the other speakers will; my starting point is Slide 6, a slide concerning recognition of the 2018 California General Rate Case; so as nearly everyone is aware by now, on October 14, the California Public Utilities Commission issued a proposed decision in our California GRC. That GRC was delayed and ought to have taken effect on January 1, 2020; the proposed decision approved the settlement we had announced back in October of 2019. It further proposed to adopt Cal Water's positions regarding the disputed financial matters in the case. During the first 2 quarters of the year, we had been hesitant to record regulatory assets for certain of our continuing balancing account mechanisms, including the WRAM and the MCBA decoupling mechanism, as well as our pension and medical cost balancing accounts, since we did not know whether recovery of those accounts was probable. Based on the proposed decision and a couple of things that came after it, we have concluded that the GRC decision is very probable to award us those accounts on a continuing basis; therefore we are recognizing the regulatory assets tied to the water revenue adjustment mechanism, modified cost balancing account and the pension medical cost balancing account regulatory assets; those will — those contribute significantly to our revenue for the quarter and for the year-to-date; on top of that, the commission will grant us interim rate recovery. And because we now know what the proposed decision says about the revenue requirement, we can calculate what is in the interim rate memorandum accounted. So we have also booked a regulatory asset for the interim rate memorandum account. I wanted to speak briefly about the subsequent event that is giving us additional confidence in the General Rate Case; that is that on Tuesday, among other things that took place on Tuesday in the United States, the Cal PA, the Public Advocates Office, issued their comments on the proposed decision. And although they provided extensive comments across a variety of areas, they did not comment on the 3 major areas that we are recovering here. In other words, their comments do not challenge the proposed decision's granting of a continued water revenue adjustment mechanism, modified cost balancing count or pension and medical cost balancing account. And so we feel very strongly that the final decision, which the commission can render no earlier than November 19, is going to allow those balancing accounts for us. And so that is very good news for the company. Beyond those three points, I should note that through this rate case we're giving back to customers the surplus deferred tax tied to the reduction in the federal income tax rate under the Tax Cut Job Act. That refund is being put into effect; it flows into customer rates, and on our income statement it appears as a decrease to our effective tax rate. Consequently, going forward you will observe a reduced effective tax rate for the company as those surplus deferred taxes get refunded. I want to stress that these probability assessments carry some risk; everything depends on the CPUC approving the proposed decision without material changes. Still, as I said, based on the evidence in hand today, we believe that outcome is probable, which is why we have already folded these into our third quarter estimates — or actually, our third quarter earnings results, not estimates. Now moving to Slide 7. What that determination produces is a very substantial rise in our net income for the third quarter. It climbs from $42.4 million to $96.4 million versus 2019. Earnings per share came to $1.94 for the third quarter, compared with $0.88 in the third quarter of 2019. Looking at the year-to-date picture on Slide 8, net income has risen. It's higher by roughly $30 million. That puts it at $81.3 million, an increase from $51.8 million during the same year-to-date stretch of 2019; this translates to earnings per share of $1.66 year-to-date versus $1.08 year-to-date in 2019. Then working through Slide 9 and Slide 10, I'll move quickly. The remaining items affecting earnings, revenues and expenses are fairly typical for us, the same matters discussed in earlier quarters. We've had higher operating expenses for wages and other items that simply rise, along with depreciation and amortization. From time to time we get fluctuations in our unbilled revenue accruals, which you'll spot on a few of these slides, plus the mark-to-market adjustment on certain retirement plan assets. So nothing significant in either the quarter or the year-to-date period in those areas, though they do ultimately impact earnings. Let me spend just a moment on Slide 11, the earnings bridge, to drive home the point regarding third quarter earnings. If you're looking at Slide 11, the first bar change is $0.80, labeled delayed recording of Q1 and Q2 regulatory assets; since we're capturing the General Rate Case effect through the third quarter, that $0.80 in the first bar reflects net earnings that would have been realized during the first 2 quarters of the year if the rate case had been adopted on schedule. I want to call your attention to this point so that as we approach Q3 of 2021, everyone understands we likely won't see earnings of $1.94 per share again in that quarter of 2021. Of course, it would be great if that happened. Now let me direct you to Slide 13, because I'd like to walk through it once more as a framework for analysts and anyone else evaluating our stock. When it comes to the company's earnings power — and remember, we operate as a mainly regulated utility across all 4 states, which generates the bulk of our revenues and net income — the California rate case, should the proposed decision be adopted, permits a specified net income of roughly $76 million for test year 2020, and that figure mirrors the authorized equity return applied to the equity component of $1.5 billion in rate base. Beyond California, roughly $110 million of rate base sits in other states, and it ought to produce a comparable equity return, once more on a normalized test year sort of basis. Keep in mind, though, that equity returns from our regulated operations hinge on our costs aligning with the adopted costs. Furthermore, in the remaining 3 states — New Mexico, Washington and Hawaii — our returns are likewise influenced by water sales. As Paul will explain shortly, starting in 2023, we anticipate that California earnings will similarly feel the impact of water sales. One more thing regarding the quarter and year-to-date: everyone should recognize that on an annual basis, we don't expect any net income effect stemming from shifts in our unbilled revenue accruals or unrealized movements in retirement asset value — the mark-to-market we occasionally mention. Through Q3, those items are contributing approximately $9.6 million to our year-to-date net income. So keep that in mind as we move toward year-end, since we anticipate that the unbilled portion in particular will fall back to its end-of-2019 level. Lastly, a handful of additional items push our earnings somewhat above what core regulated earnings would otherwise be: our unregulated activities, operational maintenance contracts, antenna leases for various purposes — various cellular antennas situated on our facilities, the regulatory asset we record in connection with the equity portion of construction, funding the AFUDC so to speak, and state tax timing differences can also come into play. I simply wanted everyone to have that awareness. I'm glad to field questions on any of it too. Marty, I'll hand it over to you to discuss COVID-19.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#3

Okay, thank you, Tom. I'd like to provide a brief update on operations, keeping the COVID-19 situation in mind. Yet despite COVID-19, California experienced its most devastating wildfire season on record. So on top of the pandemic, we were contending with multiple fires, plus the public safety power shutoffs that occurred across the state at different points, along with a few earthquakes. Operations-wise, it has been an extremely hectic year; our emergency operations center has been activated 18 times so far this year. That, I believe, sets a new record for us. At the EOC — our emergency operations centers — we essentially adhere to a FEMA-style framework for handling emergency situations. And I'm pleased to report that although we faced numerous possible emergencies over the course of the year, the company's operations performed extremely well, and we managed to prevent any significant interruptions to water service or shortages of water service, particularly during wildfire season. That said, we're still operating under heightened safety measures to shield customers and staff from infection. Safeguarding employees, customers, and public health continues to be our top priority. I'm delighted to tell everyone, and you might have seen this already, that we were honored with the Stevie Award — the Silver Stevie Award — recognizing us as the most valuable employer for a COVID response. That was among more than 700 companies vying for a Stevie Award. So we're thrilled to receive that recognition for our efforts on the COVID response and for keeping our workforce safe. Amid the pandemic, we've observed a rise in customer accounts becoming overdue because collection activities were suspended. As you may remember, Cal Water halted our collections and shutoffs early in the process, and the government later mandated it, but we had already taken that step before any government orders came down, since we understood how essential water is for our customers in fighting the virus. Consequently, our over-90 balances have grown to roughly $5.4 million. Typically, only a fraction of those amounts ends up being uncollectible. We're watching that very, very carefully. We believe it reflects the tough financial circumstances, as the pandemic has affected people, who've been told to stay at home and may be relying on some form of assistance program, unable to manage paying their bills; we've boosted our reserve for doubtful accounts by approximately $1.6 million, bringing it to $2.7 million. So about 50% of that balance is reserved for, and we'll keep monitoring it as we head into the fourth quarter. Our added costs related to COVID came to under $100,000 in the third quarter, which we consider positive; we do maintain a memo account in California as well as a memo-type account in Hawaii. As I think many of you are aware, with a memo account you record the expense during the period when it is incurred, yet it's tracked in a manner that sits outside the books; and once it reaches a particular threshold, you may have the option to return to the commission and pursue recovery of those costs, since they exceed what the business model had planned. So in our operations we keep accumulating costs tied to COVID within our memo accounts. Overall water sales came in near the adopted level — roughly 95% of adopted sales in California — helped by greater customer usage as people stayed home and consumed more water, which was then offset by reduced business and industrial use across the quarter. On liquidity, we continue to be in a solid position. At September 30, cash stood at $113 million, plus another $170 million of current capacity available under our line of credit. So throughout the pandemic the company's liquidity has stayed strong, and we head into the fourth quarter from a very good position. I'll now hand things to Paul Townsley for an update on California regulation.

Paul Townsley

executive
#4

Thanks, Marty. If you go to Slide 15, that's where we cover what's happening on the California regulatory side. It's been an extremely busy stretch for Cal Water when it comes to regulation. Like Tom said, a proposed decision came through in October, and through that PD, the commission set a fresh revenue requirement for Cal Water of $698.7 million for test year 2020. That same proposed decision also gave the green light to $828 million in new capital expenditures, or new capital investments, spread over the 3 years of the rate case cycle. We had filed a settlement agreement as part of this rate case, and that agreement took care of most of the issues in the general rate case. That said, 11 items — 11 litigated items, litigated financial items — fell outside the settlement agreement we submitted to the commission. When the proposed decision came down, the judge sided with Cal Water's position across all 11 of those litigated financial items. The administrative law judge ruled in our favor on each one, and those included keeping the water revenue adjustment mechanism, WRAM/MCBA, in place; keeping the sales reconciliation mechanism, or SRM; keeping the pension and health care balancing accounts; adding an equity component into our AFUDC calculation; securing approval for capital projects for AMI, or advanced meter infrastructure; and for certain water quality or water treatment projects down in the Los Angeles area. The commission is scheduled to rule on the proposed decision no sooner than its November 19 open meeting. I'd also point out on Slide 15 that Cal Water, together with the other parties, has filed a request for rehearing on the commission's August 27 decision, which stops Cal Water and others from continuing to use the WRAM/MCBA starting, in our situation, with our 2021 rate case filing, which takes effect in 2023. 2021, like I said — or rather 2020 has been a busy year. 2021 is going to be busy too, since, as I just noted, we'll file our 2021 rate case next spring, and we'll file our cost of capital case next spring as well; so our regulatory team is going to be very busy next year pulling all of that together. With that, I'll hand it back to Marty.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#5

Okay, thank you, Paul. Now I'll provide a brief update regarding the 2020 capital investment program. During the third quarter, capital investments reached $84.7 million, which is a 16% increase compared with the same quarter a year earlier. On a year-to-date basis, capital investments total $221.3 million, representing a 13.5% rise year-to-date versus 2019. Earlier, the company projected spending somewhere between $260 million and $290 million. As we head into the fourth quarter, we believe we are well positioned to meet our capital investment program targets for this year, even though the operating environment has truly been difficult. Additionally, on October 13 we announced completion and placement into service of our Palos Verdes Water Reliability Project. That stands as the biggest project ever undertaken by the company—a project just under $100 million designed to deliver redundancy to the PV peninsula in Southern California. So it's great to have that finished. Once again, the team performed tremendously, laboring under tough operating conditions, to complete that project within this year. Fresh off the presses: yesterday, the CPUC adopted a decision that grants Cal Water's request for an extra $700 million in additional financing authority. That authority is anticipated to be used to assist in financing the company's capital program through 2025 or beyond. Consequently, this permits us to go out and secure an additional $700 million in debt or equity in order to fund our capital growth program over the next 5 years. So that was welcome news too. One area where we've been extremely active—and honestly, we are likely at our busiest in business development in roughly the last 20 years when it comes to BD. So Paul will now update us on what's been taking place on the business development front. Paul?

Paul Townsley

executive
#6

Sure. If you look at Slide 17, I can give you an update on what we're doing in business development. Cal Water keeps running a really solid process for bringing in new business, and it's paid off a lot this year. Year-to-date, the work we've done on new development has gotten more than 25,000 new customer connections signed up, which works out to more than a 5% increase in new customer connections throughout the company's subsidiaries. In 2020 so far, we've completed 2 acquisitions: the Rainier View water system, located in Washington, and the Kalaeloa water and sewer system, located in Hawaii. Beyond that, we've signed contracts to acquire the Animas Valley Water Company in New Mexico and the Gunner Ranch sewer system in California, and both of those still need regulatory approval; when it comes to regulatory approval, 2 other acquisitions remain under review — the Kapalua Water and Sewer Company in Hawaii and The Preserve at Millerton water and sewer in California. Now if you go to Slide 18, you'll find some specifics on the projects I just described. To sum up, as this matrix shows, our business development work is strong, and we have a robust pipeline of potential deals. With that, I'll hand things back to Tom.

Tom Smegal

executive
#7

Appreciate that, Paul. I'll take just a moment or two to walk through the following 2 slides, which are our standard bar charts for CapEx and rate base. There's a bit more confidence behind these 2 charts than we've had previously. As Marty and Paul both noted, the CapEx that the commission has authorized is moving nearer to actually happening. We've got the midpoint of our $275 million CapEx target. That is quite attainable in 2020 given what we've already completed. If you move to the estimated regulated rate base, this chart has been revised by us to capture the proposed decision rate base in California. It then incorporates the rate base from the other states that I brought up earlier during this call. So once the CPUC adopts — assuming adoption of the proposed decision and the settlement — we project our 2020 rate base for California and the other state-regulated jurisdictions at roughly $1.6 billion. The Palos Verdes pipeline project is excluded from that figure. As Marty noted, it came in at close to $100 million. It falls among these advice letter projects. We anticipate having it reflected in rates quite near the beginning of 2021, or possibly slightly ahead of that, based on how the timing works through the rate case process in California. So on this chart, that represents nearly 2/3 of the advice letter rate base. I should stress, however, that the 2021 and 2022 rate bases in California are tied to the earnings test. We haven't discussed — there was no earnings test this year given the rate case test year, but in 2 of every 3 years, an earnings test applies that examines our progress on capital investments and the effective rate of return before additional rates are granted in the California districts; so by the year-end call, I believe we'll have an update on that and on what the increment will contribute to 2021. What you see for 2021 here is the authorized rate base assuming we pass every one of those earnings tests. That's the reason it appears as it does. Marty, over to you for the wrap-up.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#8

Okay, thank you, Tom. To start, I’d like to pause and express appreciation to Tom and Dave. Things have been extremely hectic over the past couple of weeks ever since we received the PD, working through all the details, getting everything booked, and coordinating with our independent registered certified public accountants, Deloitte & Touche. So I simply want to recognize that the two of you, along with your team, have performed exceptionally well. I’m aware you’ve put in many hours to get all of this booked. It’s wonderful that the 2018 general rate case is nearly finished and that we’re getting it done. The fact that it came so late was a letdown for us. Still, it feels good to have it completed and to be able to move ahead. And as Paul noted, we are already at work on our 2021 general rate case. As we head into the final 6 weeks of what has genuinely been a disruptive year — possibly the most disruptive year anyone of our generation has lived through — Cal Water remains well positioned through the execution of our business plan, including our business development growth plans, our dividend growth plans, and our capital investment programs, and most importantly our safety program, which has enabled us to keep our operations going. 91% of our employees have shown up to work each and every day. The majority of our employees and our assets are out in the field, and they have been doing the job daily throughout COVID, which meant we had to put in place many very strict COVID protocols to keep them safe. So we believe we’re executing well. We’re in a really strong position. And I thought, in a year that simply hasn’t brought much really good news, I’d like to end with something I consider fairly significant. In late September, California’s legislature approved a bill we had been working on to help us deal with some of our concerns about wildfire liability. Senate Bill 1386 — that’s the bill, now law after Governor Newsom signed it — states that fire hydrants connected to public water systems are generally not designed or installed to provide water service to aid in extinguishing fires that threaten property not served by a water service provider or wildfires. Our government affairs team worked extremely hard with California lawmakers to get this law enacted. And we think this is another important milestone that further sets our risk profile apart from those of the electric and gas utilities in California. So it’s a major step in the right direction. Credit goes to the team for making that happen. And now — Bridgette, with that, we’ll open it up for Q&A, please.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#9

I appreciate the thorough update on the quarter — it gave us most of what we were looking for. Still, I have a few broader, quick-picture questions. First, regarding how COVID-19 might shape the regulatory climate in California — from what you describe, there seems to be no effect thus far. You mention the approved CapEx plan and the green light for greater financing capacity. Yet is there any indication — whether around cost of capital and ROEs, or around the prudence of investments — that given all the economic strain, regulators might prefer to see things decelerate? I'm aware that many municipal systems are pushing off certain investments at this point. Any sign that this sort of thinking could gradually appear and you could be requested to delay some items? Or does everything appear to be full speed ahead?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#10

I'll begin, then Paul and Tom can chime in too. As things stand at this moment, everything appears to be full speed ahead. That's a strong question you're raising, because with COVID, hotel occupancy rates have fallen. Tourism has vanished. Nobody is heading to Disneyland or Southern California. So a multiplier effect will emerge that definitely hits municipal systems. However, for those of us who are rate-regulated investors in water systems, everything appears to be full speed ahead at present. What we're monitoring most closely is really customer accounts receivable and how those receivables age; and during the recession of '08 and '09, the sub-prime crisis, something interesting happened. Our bad debt rose, I believe, by 10 basis points. So obviously, the governor's order suspending collections has nudged our receivable balances upward somewhat, though that's really confined to roughly 60,000 customers so far. So we're keeping an eye on that. Another point I'd make, Ryan, is that for us — and it has been a tough operating year — we have not halted our outreach programs. We have not halted our philanthropic programs. You might have noticed we doubled our firefighter grants this year; we recently held a community EOC exercise, with 43 government officials from the local and municipal areas we serve taking part in a jointly run emergency operations center. So we basically put it together. They might lack the funding for such exercises, so we'll organize it, and they'll join us. So we believe all of that feeds into the ESG aspect of being a utility. And so I think we all need to keep watching and see how things unfold. From my perspective, now that the rate case is beginning to conclude, we're in a strong position as we head into 2021; and I'm quite pleased with the business development efforts we've managed to keep pursuing even with COVID around. Tom, what do you think?

Tom Smegal

executive
#11

Perhaps I'll have Paul start us off. I've got a few things on my mind, but since Paul is more involved with the regulatory aspect, I'll hand it over to him to begin.

Paul Townsley

executive
#12

Absolutely. I'm very much in agreement with what Marty expressed. The commission has concerns, and they've posed inquiries to every one of the utilities they oversee regarding our efforts to assist customers throughout the COVID period. We've managed to give them solid responses, a lot of which Marty just described. Still, I haven't observed any indication of a shift in tone from the California Commission, nor from the other commissions where we operate, when it comes to modifications to how we run our business or how the commission views us as a utility.

Tom Smegal

executive
#13

What I intended to contribute was a bit additional optimism, so to speak. Yet I observe patterns, and these could simply be temporary patterns, but we've discussed somewhat how individuals are relocating — truly desiring to relocate away from high-density locations toward medium-density locations where they're able to possess their own spaces, this working from home along with the COVID circumstance we find ourselves in. Many of the locations that Cal Water specifically serves and a portion of the — I suppose, all 4 of our utilities serve, are mostly suburban-style locations instead of urban locations featuring lots of apartment buildings and condos and such. I believe we've in fact witnessed considerable interest among people relocating into those communities; and therefore if you examine the differing economic effect, I believe there's in fact probably going to be a rise in interest regarding residing in many of the communities we serve. And definitely, we must be capable of supplying the infrastructure along with the operational abilities in those locations to satisfy those expanding demands. So I merely wanted to include that.

Ryan Connors

analyst
#14

All right. All right. That's extremely useful. I'm grateful to each of the three of you for sharing your thoughts. So, my next question concerns the matter of decoupling, correct? As you're aware, our take on it differs somewhat. Our view is that although earnings could become somewhat more volatile, we expect that to be contained, and we see a possible upside where ROE is concerned. What I'd like to ask is this: your nearest — you're — presumably your nearest comparable company in California offered some remarks earlier in the week that appeared to back the notion that even though earnings might swing around more, the overall message was something like, "Look, this is quite manageable. We'll make it through. And even in the absence of it, it isn't a huge problem." I'm loosely restating, but it certainly wasn't what you'd call a harshly severe take. So my question: how do you answer that, in terms of how significant an issue this is when it comes to earnings volatility? And particularly — can you quantify it somehow? Since clearly, when you're valuing the equity, how large that possible rise in earnings volatility might be matters a great deal. So whatever measurable figures you could provide on that would be useful.

Tom Smegal

executive
#15

Let me stress a few points, to start with, and these relate to regulation. Paul, go ahead and jump in too; but throughout the summer, ever since the proposed decision came down in the low-income rule making, I've been examining this. What matters most for us, should decoupling be eliminated, is keeping in mind our situation prior to decoupling being put in place. Consider the rate structures we used to have: we could recover roughly 50% of our fixed costs through service charges, while approximately 50% of those fixed costs came back to us via quantity rates. In lots of our districts — and this differs somewhat from the peer utility you mentioned, Ryan — in lots of our districts, water is inexpensive. Keep in mind, roughly half our water comes from pumped groundwater. Where pumped groundwater dominates, incremental water costs are minimal. So once we adopted this decoupling mechanism, our aim was really to shift the cost into the quantity rate as a way of encouraging conservation. What we ended up doing in those areas especially is bending our cost recovery much further toward quantity rates. Consequently, the worry about volatility shows up mainly in places we serve such as a Bakersfield, such as a Chico, where we've pushed rates largely into a quantity format — where, if you simply billed people according to where costs landed, they'd be paying a $40 monthly base rate plus $0.10 per unit for water, or along those lines. So nobody is going to save water that way, and that isn't what the state asked us to accomplish. Because of that, the rates have been distorted. In the upcoming rate case, and in ones after that, we'll need to push those rates back toward where they normally belong, and that could change the conservation incentives our customers face. But the biggest thing, in my view, is that the volatility we keep discussing has to be symmetrical. That means it falls on us to do the work within the rate case process to come up with a forecast that the Raker advocate — or at minimum the commission — will accept, one that gives us the same shot at earning above or below the authorized return in any year, and in a typical year lets us hit that authorized return. That's really what the rate case is about, those 2 items: changing the rate design, especially in the areas with low water costs, and getting the sales forecasts accurate; and if we succeed at both, we'll cap the volatility and make it symmetrical too; and I'm certain Paul has a few additional remarks.

Paul Townsley

executive
#16

Absolutely, and thanks, Tom. I believe you captured that nicely, and I simply want to highlight a few things once more. Before decoupling existed, we were a thriving utility. Throughout the time we operated under decoupling, we have remained thriving, and once decoupling ends, we will continue to be financially thriving. Among the matters that have troubled us the most was the ruling issued by the commission; the reason we regard that ruling as mistaken is that it removes a crucial instrument for setting prices to encourage water conservation, which is the policy objective in the state. Should we lack the ability to impose substantially greater cost per unit of water on heavy users, then a highly valuable instrument for conserving water is gone. Another concern is our belief that customers using less water, many of whom have lower incomes, will suffer because of this ruling, since it forces us to shift a larger portion of our expenses into fixed charges and to lower the thresholds separating the first tier, second tier, and third tier once more; as a result, someone using little water — possibly with a low income — will face a bill that is comparatively larger than the bill that same person would have received under a decoupled system; and our genuine view is that this ruling was mistaken for state policy and mistaken for our customers, which is the reason we have requested a rehearing on it.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#17

Yeah, thanks for those slide specifics. Could you walk through the way that $0.80 tied to Q1 and Q2 splits across those 2 quarters? As I attempted to reconcile it, my figure came out nearer to $0.85 or $0.86; so I'm not sure whether something moved somewhat relative to your earlier quarterly reports.

Tom Smegal

executive
#18

Jonathan, I believe our 10-Q, which we will file later today, contains somewhat more detail, and perhaps we can turn to it and assist in walking you through it once you've read it. Yet a portion of what separates the estimates for the first 2 quarters that we were producing from what we're now concluding is that only at this point do we possess the precise rate design the commission will adopt; and we sort of plug — we plug that into our billing system; and thus there could be, say, a few differences between interim rates and WRAM/MCBA purely because of extremely minor shifts in how the rates get calculated; and so that could be one of the factors at play there. The other item is somewhat esoteric, but — and I'm sorry for anyone who would rather not wade into the weeds here, but one thing we ultimately do with the WRAM is assess what portion of it can be collected over the next 12 months and what portion can be collected in periods after that; and there's a degree of discounting applied to WRAM balances not collectible within 12 months because of the accounting rules involved. And so that might be exerting a slight influence; so please be patient with us, Jonathan, and we'll aim to obtain that information and show you where it appears in the Q.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#19

All right, that's helpful. Now, turning to the earnings power slide — if I've run the numbers right, those 2 regulated businesses bring you to roughly $1.60 in EPS, provided you hit the permitted returns. Does that check out? And after that, where would you expect your achieved ROEs to land versus what's allowed?

Tom Smegal

executive
#20

Broadly speaking, during year one following a rate case, we tend to perform quite strongly in California when you look at earned ROE on a regulated basis. So my sense is we're approaching that mark — we're approaching that mark in California and honestly, in the remaining states too. I'd say that's weighed on us across the years, especially while we were scaling up what we've invested in Hawaii. In fact, on the Hawaii earned rate of return we've begun to close much of that gap, and that represents a meaningful share of the assets we hold outside California; therefore, on the core regulated portion of our operations, things look — clearly, only 3 quarters have elapsed, but things look fairly solid on revenue and expense when measured against the rate case. After that, the additional elements I mentioned are what would likely push net income above that level for the year.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#21

Correct, correct. No, what I'm getting at is this: if you strip away the impact that the unbilled sales and the unrealized gains have had so far this year, and you also leave out other income, then just the core — I suppose the utility rate base — that brings you to roughly $1.60, does that sound — does that sound accurate?

Tom Smegal

executive
#22

Yeah, I don't have that precise figure sitting in front of me, though it's roughly in that neighborhood. We could nitpick the arithmetic. But for the benefit of everyone else, rather than just having a discussion with Jonathan, since I'm sure all of you — the rest of you are on the line too — it's simply the rate base times the weighted capital structure in California, and well, in California the allowed equity is 53.4%, and the return on that is 9.2%. So essentially, anyone can run those numbers on about $1.5 billion of rate base. And then when it comes to the other states, it's likely nearer to a 50-50 split between debt and equity. But generally, on the equity portion we're earning that same authorized return of roughly 9.2%; and so whatever figure that works out to, that's what it is.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#23

All right. And regarding the equity program within that $300 million initiative of yours, what amount would you anticipate drawing down during 2020? My understanding is you're roughly at $50 million at the midpoint of the year.

Tom Smegal

executive
#24

Yeah. I believe that we — Dave, do you — apologies, Dave, do you happen to have that figure? I'm aware it appears in the Q, and we didn't discuss on the slide deck the additional amount that existed in the third quarter related to the equity program. We may need to — we may need to circle back on that or point folks to the location in the Q where it's disclosed.

Dave Healey

executive
#25

Yes. I can't remember it right now.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#26

But do you have a sense of the overall figure you're anticipating for 2020, or...

Tom Smegal

executive
#27

We'd expect it to come in just a bit below $100 million. What we've seen with the program is that, in particular, the market has had periods of volatility here and there, and on certain days we weren't able to trade, or weren't able to trade in any significant volume; honestly, we're quite new to this ATM program. So as far as our goal of $300 million across 3 years goes, looking at it right now, on a 12-month basis we're likely somewhat under that. That said, it doesn't mean we can't beat the target in year 2 and year 3 of the program; across that period we're still aiming for roughly $300 million of equity.

Dave Healey

executive
#28

Tom, I happened to be reviewing the Q line a moment ago. For the first nine months, that figure stands at $58.6 million.

Tom Smegal

executive
#29

Okay. And there's a little bit more to go in the fourth quarter.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#30

Okay, thank you. Bridgette, I appreciate it. Naturally, our 10-Q will contain quite a few specifics when it gets submitted later on today, and we'll be available to address whatever questions anybody might have. Until then, I want to express our gratitude for the ongoing interest you've shown in California Water Service Group. We value your backing, particularly through this COVID period, and we wish for everyone to remain well as the Thanksgiving holiday approaches. We're eager to speak with all of you around late February or the beginning of March when we close out 2020 and share our financial results covering the entire year. So, thanks again. Stay safe. We'll be in touch with everybody soon. Thank you. Goodbye.

Operator

operator
#31

That brings our session to a close, ladies and gentlemen. We appreciate your taking part. Have a wonderful weekend, everybody.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.