California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 25, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Healey
executiveThanks a lot, Victor. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us for California Water Service Group's call covering fourth-quarter and full-year 2020 results. With me on the line today are Marty Kropelnicki, President and CEO; Tom Smegal, Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; Paul Townsley, Vice President of Business Development and Chief Regulatory Officer; and Shannon Dean, Vice President of Customer Service and Chief Citizenship Officer. You can find the dial-in details for the replay in our year-end earnings release, which was issued earlier today. That replay will be available until April 26. Also, a quick note before we start: for this quarter and year-end call, the company has prepared a slide deck to go along with our remarks. This morning an 8-K went out with the slide deck, which you can also find on the company's site at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we get into the quarter and year-end results, we want to spend a few minutes on forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company may make some forward-looking statements. Since those statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results might differ materially from what the company currently expects. For that reason, the company urges anyone who currently holds shares—and any other interested parties—to thoroughly review and grasp what we disclose about risks and uncertainties in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and the other reports we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission periodically. I'll now hand things to Marty to get us started.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThanks, David. Morning, everyone. We're glad you could be with us today as we review what we accomplished in 2020 and report our results for the year. We thought we'd do things a bit differently this morning. I'll start with some short comments and a summary of the year, then hand it over to Tom, and after that we'll go through the deck we normally use. My reason for structuring it this way is that by just about any measure, 2020 stood apart from every other year; we started the year with a general rate case that had been delayed and was nearly a year behind schedule, which we were able to book in December, and we finished 2020 with record earnings. Capital spending also hit an all-time high, with roughly $300 million put toward our infrastructure improvement program — a 9.1% increase over 2019, which had held the previous record. Through that program, we swapped out 169,000 feet of main in 2020, the most ever, and we completed the biggest single capital project the company has ever undertaken: the Palos Verdes Peninsula Water Reliability Project, which began serving customers in the fourth quarter of 2020. We completed the purchase of Rainier View Water, and that deal made Washington Water twice as large as it had been. As a lot of you probably saw, back in January we lifted our dividend by 8.2%, reflecting the solid financial shape in which we finished the year. While plenty of businesses were trimming their budgets and coping with the downturn brought on by the pandemic, we understood how much our economic activity matters to the communities we serve. Along those lines, we gave away thousands of units of PPE to first responders in those communities. A good number of these communities, especially the rural ones, had not been adequately prepared. We gave a record $1.7 million to a range of community support organizations that helped our customers through a tough stretch during the pandemic. For all eligible customers in the communities we serve, we expanded the Cal Water philanthropic scholarship program, and we recorded a record $51.4 million in diverse spending with diverse suppliers that assist us in carrying out our mission across the service area. Overdue balances totaling more than $400,000 were forgiven for customers who were having trouble paying their bills; and of course, we suspended shutoffs very early in the pandemic so that our customers would have the water they needed to fight the pandemic at home. Regarding governance, we finished our inaugural ESG materiality assessment, which establishes the basis for our ongoing efforts concerning climate change, sustainability, conservation, and other significant ESG and company-wide risks that could impact how we operate. We closed out the year having recorded zero primary and secondary water quality violations. Moreover, even with California's most severe fire season on record and many public safety power shutoffs, not a single one of our customers faced any major outage throughout the hot, dry summer period and fire season. Our water professionals at Cal Water carried out their work safely around the clock — 7 days a week, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year — doing what they do best, and we pulled all of that off amid the worst pandemic to hit us in the last 100 years. This was genuinely a year filled with countless challenges and plenty of unknowns, and we're extremely proud to present our results to you today. That said, I want to pause for a special moment and thank every Cal Water employee for the hard work and dedication that produced the outstanding results we reported for 2020; and with that, I'll hand things over to Tom to kick us off as we walk through the deck. Tom?
Thomas Smegal
executiveThanks a lot, Marty. I'll begin with the slide deck, starting at Slide 5. If you'd like to follow along and you happen to have a copy of the deck in front of you. This is the results table we typically present, and I'll point out just a handful of the key figures. As Marty said, net income set a record at $96.8 million for 2020. That came in up slightly more than 50% for the year. Earnings per share were $1.97, which again rose more than 50% compared with earnings per share in 2019. And CapEx, which Marty referenced, was nearly $300 million, an increase of 9% over the prior year. Turning to the fourth quarter, which we'll touch on briefly as well. We saw earnings per share rise to $0.31 compared with $0.24 in the earlier period, along with net income of $15.5 million versus $11.3 million in the same period a year earlier. Now let me spend a little time on the financial highlights and what drove this outcome, on Slide 7. The gain was mostly attributable to adoption of the California General Rate Case. As those of you tracking us are aware, we spent the year awaiting a final decision on that rate case, and in the third quarter we did book what we had expected would be the final outcome of that case, which proved accurate. That rate case was adopted on December 3 with no changes, or no material changes, from what had been expected to be adopted at the close of our third quarter; so the rate case truly contributed to our revenue and net income. It also reduced the adopted purchase water and purchase power expense. And when those items ran somewhat higher over the course of 2020, we're permitted to record revenue tied to the balancing accounts we maintain, or the modified cost balancing account connected with purchase water and purchase power; and so what you'll observe is that the margin between revenue and water expense is what really — that is what really drove our earnings higher for the year. Another significant factor, one that operates both within the rate case and outside of it, involves lower effective income tax rates. So within the rate case, we are giving back to customers our excess deferred taxes tied to the lower federal tax rate under the Tax Cuts and Job Act. That is a planned program spanning roughly a 9-year period; so what you'll see in our Rate Cases is reduced income tax expense and reduced revenue flowing directly back to customers; and then the second item was that we surpassed our expectations for repairs and maintenance deductions. Now regarding how mainline replacements in our water systems are handled for taxes—we can expense those, and that came in above what the general rate case had estimated, which contributed to earnings both for the year and for the fourth quarter. Marty and I have already discussed capital investment quite a bit, but I want to emphasize it once more: $298.7 million went toward capital improvements, and that figure includes finishing the Palos Verdes Peninsula Water Supply Reliability Project. For the fourth quarter, several of the same drivers I described apply—the rate increases stemming from the general rate case and the higher repairs tax deductions—partly offset by rises in general and normal operating costs. Our usual bridges appear on Slide 9 and 10. I won't walk through them in detail, since I typically don't. Still, as you can see, the general rate increases together with regulatory mechanisms—that modified cost balancing account I mentioned earlier—account for most of the earnings difference between 2019 and 2020, with the repairs tax treatment coming next. You can follow the remaining factors through the bridge. So I wanted to pause, as I've done the past couple of quarters, to break down our earnings and give some context on how the company generates money; we'll go through this for 2020 and for 2021. For 2020, we estimated that the California rate case adopted net income of $76 million; and if you look—this is on Slide 11—down at the bottom, you'll see certain variances from the GRC-adopted earnings tied to our California regulated operations, some favorable and some unfavorable. In particular, expense was pushed up by recorded bad debt that ran higher because of COVID, and we'll discuss that in more detail later on the call. But we also saw, partly as a consequence of COVID, reduced travel costs, training costs, and outside services costs for the company, since we were in lockdown and employees simply weren't going out to other locations for travel and training. Depreciation and property taxes came in below what the rate case had adopted. That is really a timing difference, and as you'll see on the next slide, we expect it to return to normal next year. Finally, moving beyond the California Rate Case, our regulated activities outside California contributed $3.8 million of net income; and additional net income for the year came from what I'd describe as areas outside our core regulated earnings—recognition of AFUDC equity contributed $5 million, and mark-to-market on our Benefits Plans Investments added $3.4 million. Nonregulated activities contributed $1.4 million, and the repairs tax treatment added $3.3 million beyond what was permitted in the California general rate case. So now let's move to 2021. I'll give you a quick walk-through of what to expect and what to consider regarding the variables for 2021. In California, we've seen a step rate increase, and the Palos Verdes pipeline has also been included in our rates. As a result, we think our regulated rate base in California stands at $1.7 billion, which translates into an adopted net income of $83.5 million. Now, as I noted, depreciation and property taxes will probably come in higher because of the plant additions made in 2020. We start recording depreciation in the year after we install a new facility. Our bad debt expense is likely to persist through the majority of 2021. A moratorium on the collections process is in place at least through June in California and at least through the first quarter in the other states. One factor in 2020 was that, because of the rate case delay, we held off on hiring some of the authorized positions tied to that rate case, since we weren't certain how the Commission would ultimately rule on that matter. So in 2021 we have to bring on some of those authorized positions, and that will increase wages. In our other states, we expect performance similar to what they delivered previously. Then, outside of core regulated operations—just so the analysts are clear on this—we have the recognition of AFUDC, which will likely be lower in 2021 following the completion of major projects in 2020. What that means is that AFUDC is recognized on construction work in progress, and we expect a smaller balance of construction work in progress as time goes on in 2021, simply because we had some major projects that sat in progress for an extended period during 2020. The mark-to-market on those Benefits Plans Investments, along with our unbilled revenue, is always unpredictable for the company, and both do fluctuate quarter-to-quarter and year-to-year. Our nonregulated activities carry some variability as well. And then finally, the last item, which boosted earnings in 2020—the net income effect of the state tax repairs deduction—will be set by our construction completion in 2021. So that's one more variable for the company. That covers my brief outlook and explanation for 2020 earnings and the 2021 outlook. I'll now hand it over to Marty to discuss some details of our COVID-19 pandemic response.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThanks, Tom. So yes, when we think about COVID in hindsight and going forward, and try to gauge our current position, we'll continue running with stronger safety measures in place. That 5-stage COVID response plan was developed by Cal Water; we've been operating inside its stage 3, which involves keeping staff in pods, enforcing strict PPE rules, and sending workers out from remote sites instead of having them report to a central location. Throughout the pandemic, 90% of CAL Water employees have shown up to work daily. A portion of our corporate employees have been working remotely, yet the bulk of our assets sit out in the field, and throughout the year most of those field assets kept producing — that is what contributed to the record results we posted for 2020. We will keep suspending water shutoffs, at minimum until the close of the first quarter of 2020. Mandates differ from state to state. California operates under one, though we will navigate our way through it; and we have observed growth in customer receivables aged beyond 90 days. The figure stands at roughly $9.6 million, and in my view that reflects the economic shock and the fact that people are not at work. Because of that, our reserve for doubtful accounts went up from $2.7 million to $5.2 million during the fourth quarter. COVID-related costs in Q4 came to roughly $400,000. We see possible recovery in Hawaii and California, where memo accounts have been set up with both states for COVID-related expenses. Notably, aggregate water sales came in near the adopted figure — about 96% of adopted sales, which represents an increase of roughly 4.9% over 2019. It was notable that residential usage rose while business, industrial and public authority usages declined, offsetting that gain. With people staying home and companies still shut down, we saw increased usage on the residential side, and the two roughly offset each other. We closed the year with solid liquidity: $44.6 million in cash along with more than $180 million of available borrowing capacity under our credit line, subject to certain borrowing restrictions. All in all, Cal Water has come through the COVID crisis in good shape. Fortunately, we have not lost any employees to COVID. I believe everyone knows someone, or has worked with someone, whose life was taken by COVID. And thankfully, at Cal Water, every one of our employees has stayed safe. I give credit for that to a superb safety program and to how soon we put rigorous PPE rules in place, thanks to the safety team we have here at CAL Water. On a new topic—one we devoted considerable time to during 2020—I'll hand things over to Shannon Dean, who will discuss our ESG work. Shannon?
Shannon Dean
executiveAlright, thanks, Marty. Before I get into our ESG highlights for 2020, I want to begin with the strategic framework that we put together 8 years ago — it's there on Slide 14 if you're following along. The key point is that well before ESG became top of mind for so many investors, we were already building our strategy around it. On the map in the center, you'll see that we defined our purpose as enhancing the quality of life for customers, communities, employees and stockholders, and what drove us were our core values: integrity, service, value, and corporate citizenship. So doing the right thing has always been in our DNA. Now moving to 2020. One thing we recognized is that even though we were doing a lot of good in the ESG space, we weren't telling our story very well; so as Marty said at the outset, we completed a materiality assessment early in the year to help us pinpoint the most relevant ESG topics so we could sharpen our focus, and now we're working on an ESG report that aligns with SASB and references GRI, which will be available in early April. That covers the reporting side. On ESG performance, 2020 was a very good year despite all of its challenges. On the environmental side, we combined our water supply and demand management team to sharpen our focus on climate change, and we also finished Phase 1 of a new climate change study that's really going to help us going forward. We also continued our industry-leading conservation program, and the programs we implemented in 2020 will save an estimated 43 million gallons of water every year, which is pretty impressive when you consider that much of the year we were in lockdown mode. Marty mentioned the social side — all of the wonderful things we did against the backdrop of COVID, whether it was forgiving customer balances or keeping our employees safe or really supporting the charitable organizations that needed us so much; and then on governance, I'd like to highlight that we added a corporate citizenship and ESG practice section to our proxy to enhance our disclosure. We held our first virtual-only stockholder meeting, and we added guidelines to our corporate governance guidelines regarding Board diversity; so I think we had a very good year in 2020. And I'll say that in '21, we're really looking forward to progressing on our journey and doing even more. We look forward to reporting on that on a regular basis. With that, I'll hand it off to Paul.
Paul Townsley
executiveThank you, Shannon. As Marty mentioned earlier, during 2020 we wrapped up our California General Rate Case, and those new rates are taking effect — they have taken effect in 2021. So that has been a positive development. But as 2021 gets underway, we have a very full regulatory agenda ahead of us this year. On May 1, we will file a cost of capital application with the California Public Utilities Commission; that application comes up every three years, so it is due for filing this year. Also this year, on July 1, we will file our triennial California General Rate Case. And keep in mind those rates would be effective — expected to take effect on January 1, 2023; so that is in progress; we also have several other smaller rate cases in our other states that we will be working on this year. So it really is a very full slate of regulatory activity. In the California General Rate Case, we expect that we will file and request continued strong capital investment for our communities in California. We are also going to work on our rate design in this upcoming rate case, continuing to refine and improve our sales forecast and water cost forecast, and we are doing that because we keep getting better and better at it. And also, in this particular case, we expect that we will have a discontinuation of our RAM, or our revenue decoupling mechanism; so we are really focusing on how to adjust all of these things so that we can still continue to provide affordable and reliable water service and enhance conservation. So with that, I will turn the slide deck over to Tom.
Thomas Smegal
executiveThanks, Paul. To add a bit more detail on the capital investment update, as we've said before, we put $298.7 million into developer and company-funded capital investments during 2020. That went above our target range. Our target, I believe, was $260 million to $290 million, and the main reason was the favorable working conditions we enjoyed all year because of COVID. Traffic was much lower and contractors and subcontractors were far more available. As a result, we got more done than we had expected. For 2021, our target is $270 million to $300 million. Keep in mind, we're in year three of the California General Rate Case authorization that came from the 2018 General Rate Case. Altogether that came to about $830 million over three years, which means California expenditures combined with outlays in other states land us in that target range for 2021. After we submit the rate case that Paul referenced a moment ago, our intention is to put out capital plans covering 2022 through 2024, and that projection will rest on our rate case filing, and clearly that filing is going to be open to modification reflecting whatever the Commission does over the course of that case. Moving to Slide 18. I wanted to bring up the development taking place today. Today we are announcing that we have priced $280 million in first mortgage bonds by way of a private placement process. We issued $130 million in 30-year bonds carrying a 2.87% coupon, along with $150 million in 40-year bonds at a 3.02% coupon. The bonds will be funded on May 11, 2021. This presents exciting opportunities for us to keep advancing our capital investment program and to strike the right balance between debt and equity as we proceed with the significant capital upgrades already underway. I want to point out something that connects to Paul's earlier comment: this new issuance, along with the other debt we've issued over the past two years or so, is going to push our weighted average debt cost for the company — for California Water Service company — down below 4.3%, which benefits customers via the cost of capital process and application beginning in 2022. As I recall, the adopted weighted average cost of debt in the 2018 cost of capital was 5.51%. So overall debt cost has come down a lot, and we're able to share that and pass it back to our customers. You're all aware that we have an at-the-market stock issuance program running, which represents the flip side of our debt and equity position. Through stock sales under that at-the-market program, we brought in $82.6 million during 2020. Across the life of that program, we anticipate raising roughly $300 million in equity. Turning to Slide 19. If you've followed us for a while, this CapEx chart may look somewhat unfamiliar. I wanted to point out that depreciation now appears here as a line item. What you can see is that the bars on Slide 19's chart display the CapEx we incurred over that period, while the line shown represents our cumulative depreciation for each of those years. The takeaway we intend is that, quite clearly, during the 2015 through 2020 period the company has been deploying capital at a rate above three times depreciation. I believe I calculated it at 3.1x depreciation, but it's above 3.1% — or above 3% — sorry, let me restate that, above 3x depreciation, and we're hopeful this can continue as we head toward the next General Rate Case. Looking at the 2021 estimate, we gave a range of $270 million to $300 million, and $285 million sits right in the middle of it. Slide 20 shows our usual rate base chart, now refreshed with the adopted 2020 rate base and the adopted 2021 range. Right now, our adopted rate base stands at $1.81 billion, and in California we still have some advice letter projects pending approval. Those could get the green light this year or next, so for 2021 rate base we show that as a variable ranging from high to low. With that, I'll hand things off to Marty, who picks up on Slide 21.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThanks, Tom. Now, regarding what the business faces in 2021, there are a few things worth pointing out. First and most important, the California Public Utilities Commission has a new Commissioner, and we look forward to collaborating with Commissioner Houck in her new role as she starts at the commission. She comes from a legal background and worked for several years as an ALJ. She has also been a commission adviser, so she understands rate-making and the regulatory landscape well, and in our view she was a strong choice to join the California PUC after Liane Randolph, who termed out. In addition, Terence Shia has been appointed as the new Head of the Water Division. We're really looking forward to collaborating with Terence now that he's leading the Water Division at the California Public Utilities Commission, and honestly, only a few items will occupy us through the first half of the year. First, as Tom noted, we'll be filing the 2021 general rate case — especially the new rate design that eliminates decoupling. That matter is absorbing a lot of our attention. We're equally intent on the affordability consequences of operating without decoupling and on what those consequences mean for lower income customers. Our team is hard at work on that, developing a forward-looking rate structure that aims to serve every one of our customers well. Next, we'll be submitting our cost of capital filing. The PUC turned down our ask for a twelve-month extension on our cost of capital. Their reasoning, honestly, was quite sound — we hadn't gone through a cost of capital proceeding in four years, so it was simply time to file. The rates team is therefore busy with that work. To repeat what I said before, COVID isn’t disappearing any time soon. We’ll keep watching and following shifts in CDC guidance and what those shifts mean for our staff, making small changes and adjustments as we move through the pandemic’s ups and downs, its peaks and valleys. The same overall aim stays in place: keeping customers safe and keeping our employees safe. Then, as Shannon said, we will keep investing in ESG efforts. In 2020 we made a big quantum leap by completing that materiality assessment. As Shannon put it, it’s in our DNA. We've come to understand that we need to clarify matters more effectively and operate with greater openness. And I believe you'll witness us keep making significant progress on the ESG front to enhance how transparent we are with our investors; so to sum up, as we close out what proved to be a difficult year, we did extremely well throughout the pandemic. And with the General Rate Case having been delayed, we at last completed it. We closed the year posting record earnings alongside record capital spending. We made sure our employees and customers stayed safe, and we did everything possible to support both the people affected — our employees and our customers — to the fullest extent we could. We also have to thank our Board for letting us go over budget on contributions and for absorbing some of the bad debt. The Cal Water Board was wonderful to work with throughout the crisis and was quick to see the part we play in helping our communities. Business development had a strong year — likely our best in the last 20 years — and that team has kept at it, with a full pipeline of potential opportunities for the company to consider. Overall, we're simply looking forward to beginning the new year with a fresh set of challenges and to putting 2020 behind us. It really was a long year. Even though the results were great, don't kid yourself — those results required a lot of effort from a lot of people, and we're extremely grateful to the team that delivered these record results. So with that, Victor, we'll open it up for Q&A, please.
Ben Kallo
analystCongratulations on 2020. You steered through all of that. From where we sit, it's difficult to grasp everything your employees did; but thank you. On the numbers, just for '21, I believe consensus figures are edging lower. I think that's partly because the rate case may not be fully reflected yet. But maybe you could help us with that. And then second, well, how should we think about, like, longer-term growth as you move through the upcoming rate cases and beyond?
Thomas Smegal
executiveYes, Ben, I'll begin, and this takes us back to Slide 12 in the deck, and we can certainly discuss that more with other questioners as well as with you; so we do see — if you look — if you kind of compare Slide 11 and Slide 12, so to speak, we do see higher earnings in that core California regulated authorized earnings owing to the jump in rate base. And so we're looking at a rate base of $1.6 billion in 2020, $1.7 billion in 2021. And so that is a positive for earnings. And think about that over the longer term. When I showed the CapEx growth, we've got roughly $175 million of additional CapEx minus depreciation each year that's going to keep adding to the company's rate base, and that will continue to grow the company's earnings; these other factors we discussed on Slide 12, some of which added to earnings in 2020. They may or may not add as much in 2021. And so that's kind of the message there: there are a lot of variables outside that core regulated earnings potential. I mentioned a couple of things that were very favorable for us this year, particularly, I wanted to highlight the depreciation expense; and the depreciation was lower than was adopted. So we made more money on the California regulated operations than was adopted for us. And that's really a timing issue because as we complete plant projects, the depreciation comes in the next year; we had a lot of major project completions in 2020. That's going to hit us in increased depreciation in 2021. So that's a factor which will tend to pull our earnings back a little bit toward that regulated calculation. So some of the things like that would lead you to believe that 2021 is going to be a little bit more moderate, but as I say, we do have the increase in rate base, and you'd expect that would increase the earnings in a general way. Does that make sense, Ben?
Ben Kallo
analystIt does. Look, perhaps on — go ahead.
Thomas Smegal
executiveGo ahead. No, no. You go ahead.
Ben Kallo
analystNo, regarding business development, Marty, Paul, or Tom, that Washington transaction was solid. I mean, how should we think about your geographic focus? I realize you likely don't want to get into this on a live conference call, but where are you concentrating when it comes to acquiring assets? And then perhaps even how do you view any type of infrastructure, based on what you've observed, in terms of whether it could affect you or not?
Paul Townsley
executiveBen, Paul here. I'll address the business development angle; we have an extremely robust pipeline of opportunities that we're actively pursuing. It's an exciting period for us to be engaged in business development. And we do keep concentrating on the states where we operate and states located in the western portion of the U.S.; we consider that our sweet spot. You've seen quite a few other acquisitions that we've announced over the last couple of years, and you will continue to — should continue to — see that sort of activity from us. But I can't discuss anything in the pipeline until we're ready to announce it.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveYes. The one thing I'd tack on to Paul's remarks — Ben, it's Marty here — is that our nature is to buy for value. What appeals to us are acquisitions that may be undercapitalized, that perhaps carry operating difficulties requiring capital, and where we can lift them up to meet our operating standards. So we aren't pursuing M&A because core rate base growth is lacking. Plainly, with a 3x depreciation rate, we expand rate base simply by executing our capital improvement program, our investment improvement program inside the company. Yet, as Paul mentioned, we are searching pretty much every corner of the states where we operate, hunting for solid small to potentially midsized businesses that are prepared to sell and move on and that require a capital infusion and some assistance. Those are the ideal targets for us. So I believe we'll remain focused on the value side of the equation as we assess these deals.
Ben Kallo
analystAnd congrats on the ESG front.
Thomas Smegal
executiveThanks, Ben.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThanks, Ben. We appreciate that. Tom, there's just one thing I'd tack onto what you said regarding depreciation. In 2020 we made a record investment of nearly $300 million, but we also closed a record $391 million into plant. That's the big bubble that's going to flow through and appear in depreciation in 2021.
Thomas Smegal
executiveThanks, Marty. Yes, that's correct.
Agnieszka Storozynski
analystI've got a question about the cost of capital proceeding. As you both mentioned, the Commission wants you to come in since 4 years have passed since the last proceeding. They do mention lower interest rates. I'm just wondering whether it's mainly about the cost of debt or the cost of equity, I mean — and also how that change arriving in 2022 would affect your earnings, that is, are you currently meaningfully benefiting on the debt side from lower interest rates as far as your earnings go?
Thomas Smegal
executiveSure. Let's work through it, Paul. Paul, perhaps I should start with the second part of your question. Several factors have been at play that made 2020 challenging and are carrying over into 2021. Our weighted average cost basis reflects cheaper debt, yet we're carrying somewhat more debt than we'd typically expect. The reason is these collections—mainly the collections problem and also the RAM issue. And honestly, a third factor is the postponement of the California rate case. So there are quite a few dollars owed to us out there. That forces us to raise our financing cost so the company can keep its cash reserves intact. To answer whether falling interest rates leave us better off overall, I'd characterize the current situation as roughly neutral, and we anticipate improvement once we've gathered the cash tied to the '21 General Rate Case. Still, looking ahead, as those items settle into a normal pattern, it clearly matters that customers receive the benefit of cheaper debt. That, I believe, will weigh heavily in how we approach that cost of capital filing. From my perspective, the general rate adjustment tied to our cost of capital that we'll submit in May should be fairly modest, given how low debt costs currently are. So hopefully that provides some relief. Paul, I'm not sure—do you want to add anything else on that topic?
Paul Townsley
executiveYes. Regarding the equity side, to be candid, we're still in the midst of analyzing all of that. There are still more than 2 months remaining before our filing is made. We have our — right now we're conducting research on the appropriate cost of equity to include in that filing. So it's premature for us to genuinely be in a position to state what we anticipate filing for. And then, naturally, there's a process we go through, the consumer advocate will file their points of view. And naturally, we're also doing this together with 3 other water utilities. So what the Commission ultimately decides toward the end of this year is genuinely unknown at this point.
Agnieszka Storozynski
analystOkay. And separately, since you'll be getting ready to submit your upcoming GRC, and that one won't include full RAM. I realize you're referring to modifications in the rate design that will be part of this filing. But I'm curious whether there are lessons to be drawn from what San Jose Water has shown — 2 years of falling meaningfully short of their water production volumes? And do you believe that's a risk you're prepared to handle, and how do you intend to deal with it in that filing?
Paul Townsley
executiveLet me begin — Paul here. Obviously, with full decoupling gone, it matters enormously that we get things as precise as we can, both regarding water sales and regarding water production cost, the RAM and the MCBA, so to speak. And we've devoted an enormous amount of time to both of those matters as we prepare for this case. Ultimately, these are forecasts. What we actually observe in 2023, '24 and '25 is uncertain, and our projections reflect that, but we're working hard to foresee possible declines in water sales stemming from drought or economic conditions, and to ensure our risk exposure stays even. In effect, we've selected a cost of production and water sales where our downside risk and our upside risk are balanced. So it's an iterative process. We've been at this for months and months already. We expect that when we're set to make our filing in July, we'll have fairly solid numbers; but ultimately, we'll simply have to watch how it all unfolds.
Agnieszka Storozynski
analystAll right. One final thing from me about the systems outside California. My assumption is this: since Hawaii is in its — and since tourism has fallen off, you'd anticipate somewhat better realized ROEs on that rate base outside California as early as 2021, purely because, again, sales volumes are going to pick up. Would that be fair?
Thomas Smegal
executiveFrom a purely business standpoint, I believe the point Marty made is the crucial one. Namely, none of us knows where COVID is headed. At the moment it looks quite encouraging. If you extrapolate in a straight line from the trajectory of COVID cases, the pandemic, and the vaccinations, you would conclude, "Wow, by summer we'll be past this, and all will be wonderful." We can't be certain that's really how it plays out, correct? Another surge might occur; new variants might emerge. So my guess is that if you assume the COVID situation gets better enough that people want to visit Hawaii, that will be a benefit there. In Hawaii, I believe our rate designs are favorable. The drop in profitability was not as large as one might have anticipated, since we have substantial volumetric charges that recover the high costs of purchased electricity. So if you examine — as we do internally, we examine the margins in Hawaii. And honestly, given that the hotels had shut and travel there was minimal, we performed reasonably well in Hawaii this year; so an improvement would follow if COVID were dramatically reduced. Still, I doubt the improvement will be as large as one might anticipate.
Paul Townsley
executiveAnd then when you look at the rest of our states — Washington and New Mexico — nearly all of our customers there are residential, with just a little commercial business; so the downturn hasn't really had much of an impact in those places.
Agnieszka Storozynski
analystJust one more question about this. A number of these systems came on during the year. If you could provide the annualized effect — the earnings effect — from those systems, so we can make a cleaner year-over-year comparison, what incremental earnings would there be if you had owned all of them for a full year in 2020?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveYes, the largest one, and really the only one that would be material to the company in any respect, would be Rainier View; and I believe you can check the regulatory filing at the Washington UTC. Paul, the rate base there was roughly $13 million at the last adoption for that system. I'm aware that a rate case is coming that we will file this year, as required under the acquisition. So it is, once again, a return on that rate base that you can work out. But the remaining systems have been fairly small. The largest acquisition in Hawaii has not yet closed, and that is the Kapalua — the Kapalua system; we expect it to close quite soon, and hopefully in the first quarter; and that might contribute a little to Hawaii.
Martin Kropelnicki
executivePerfect. Thank you, Victor. On behalf of everyone on the Cal Water team, we appreciate your being with us today. If anything else comes up, don't hesitate to get in touch, and we'll be glad to share our Q1 results with all of you around late April or the start of May. So take care, enjoy the rest of your day, and thank you for standing with us through 2020. Thank you.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of today's conference call. Thanks for taking part. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.