California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 29, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Dave Healey
executiveThanks, Lonnie. Greetings, everybody, and welcome to the first quarter 2021 earnings call for California Water Service Group. Joining us on this call are Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our President and CEO; Thomas Smegal, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Paul Townsley, our Vice President of Corporate Development and Chief Regulatory Officer. Details on the dial-in number for the replay can be located in the release covering our first quarter results, which came out earlier today. That replay is accessible through June 30, 2021. One thing to note before we get started: the company has prepared a slide deck that goes along with this quarter's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K this morning and can also be found on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Prior to reviewing the first quarter results, we want to spend a few moments addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since such statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly urges all current shareholders, along with interested parties, to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures regarding risk and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports filed from time to time with the securities and exchange commissions. I'll now hand things over to Tom to get us started.
Tom Smegal
executiveThank you, Dave, and good morning to all of you. It's great to have you join us for our call covering the first quarter results. My remarks will follow along with the slide deck, and I'll begin on Slide 5, the results table. This compares 2020 to 2021. Operating revenue during the quarter rose to $147.7 million, up from $125.6 million in the first quarter of 2020, and I'll explain what drove that shortly. Net loss shrank from $20.3 to $3 million, and earnings per share — or rather, loss per share — improved from a $0.42 loss to a $0.06 loss for the quarter. Capital investments, as I'll note on this slide, rose just a bit and were in line with our plan. Moving to Slide 6 on financial highlights: as I said a moment ago, the net loss fell by $17.3 million, driven mainly by the California General Rate case adoption late last year. Several factors played into that, but the first was clearly the rate increases tied to it, which contributed $6.4 million of revenue. Beyond that, if you remember back to the first quarter of 2020, we didn't recognize our balancing mechanisms — the WRAM and MCBA coupling mechanisms, plus our pension and health care balancing accounts. By recognizing them now in the first quarter of 2021, since they carried forward and were adopted in the rate case, we're adding $7.6 million of revenue from that. As you'd expect, we did see higher other operations, depreciation, and associated costs, which partly offset the revenue gains from the rate case and the recognition of those mechanisms. As we noted at year-end, our AFUDC equity — that's equity funds used during construction — is lower because less construction work in progress occurred during 2020. We had a major capital project tied to the Palos Verdes Peninsula Water Reliability project, and that boosted our AFUDC equity throughout the year. So we anticipate lower AFUDC equity for the full year, and in the quarter it declined roughly $1 million. Capital spending, as I mentioned, is slightly higher. We think we're on track with capital for the year. Then there are 2 other items beyond our general control, but I wanted to bring them up since they're fairly significant this quarter. The market value of certain retirement plan assets — well, that market value rose $0.3 million, versus a $4.7 million loss in the first quarter of 2020, so that item is sort of back to normal. It was essentially <<inaudible>> for now in the first quarter of 2020. And our unbilled revenue was very similar. There's a loss of $100,000 tied to unbilled revenue — quite minor, and honestly it looks more like what you'd normally expect, especially when you set it against the negative $3.7 million from 2020, which was an unusual kind of decline in that unbilled revenue accrual. So I'd characterize those 2 items as somewhat closer to normal, unlike the unusual figures we saw in the prior year. Moving over to Slide 7. I'm not going to go through this in any depth, but it's our waterfall EPS bridge chart, and it addresses the very same subjects. Then on Slide 8, I'll offer just a quick note regarding the tax rate. I'm aware that a number of the analysts examine the company's effective tax rate. I simply wanted to remind everybody that in 2021, we are giving back to customers through rates $19 million of excess deferreds tied to the tax rate change under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. That pushes the effective income tax rate down to 6%, so — revenue is lower and the tax rate is lower. As a result, we aren't earning anything from that. But when you simply look at the headline tax rate, it comes across as quite low. The second point, at the close of 2020 there was a sizable benefit connected to our mains and services repairs investments along with the state tax deduction we're permitted to claim there. And just to bring you up to date on the estimate. During 2020, we had $160 million of deductible mains and services repair investments. And our present estimate for 2021 is that $60 million will qualify for that tax treatment. So that's going to be a factor that comes in somewhat lower for the year 2021. Capital spending is still expected to land between $270 million and $300 million, that hasn't changed, but it's simply the timing of when certain projects close that is going to shift that tax qualification. Now, I'll hand things over to Paul Townsley for a regulatory update.
Paul Townsley
executiveThanks, Tom. There are a couple of regulatory matters in California I want to address this morning. The first concerns our cost of capital filing. As you may recall, that filing happens once every 3 years. Our most recent one came in 2017, since we received a 1-year extension. We're submitting that cost of capital application on Monday, May 3, and in the application going to the commission, we're asking for a return on equity of 10.35%, which is an increase over the 9.2% cost of equity currently approved. We'll also be making use of refinancings and new debt issuances, which brings our embedded cost of debt down 128 basis points, from the 5.51% cost of debt previously authorized to a new cost of debt of 4.23%. Putting those 2 together — the higher cost of equity and the lower cost of debt — means the rate of return we're requesting, the authorized rate of return, rises only slightly, from 7.48% to 7.5%. From a customer's standpoint, what that translates to is a median bill increase of roughly $0.34 a month, so it's really not a significant change to a customer's bill. Now, as you remember, the commission will review the cost of capital filing, and it would be approved to take effect in January 2022. I should also mention that our capital structure — roughly 53% equity and 47% debt — stays the same under this particular application. We're not just refinancing existing debt with new lower-cost debt; we've also been investing a great deal of capital and taking on new debt at a lower cost, and that is really what helps push our overall cost of debt down, which benefits our customers. The second item I'll discuss only briefly is our 3-year General Rate case filing. It will be submitted on July 1 — actually, July 3, because the 1st falls on a weekend. We're working on it at present, and we'll give you all more details when we reach our next quarterly conference call. With that, I'll hand things over to Marty.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAppreciate that, Paul. Morning, everybody. I'd like to give you a brief status report on what we're continuing to do in reaction to the COVID-19 pandemic. Above all else, let me say right at the start that across each of the 4 states where we do business, we keep witnessing the compounding advantages of vaccination among the population. Right now, more than 1/3 of the people who work for us have gotten their shots, and that's wonderful news. At the outset, the vaccine distribution process had some rough patches, yet those rough patches have largely evened out, and we're still seeing the count of our vaccinated workers rise every day, plus we've observed a sharp drop in COVID infections identified among the Cal Water family or coming from our staff — during the first quarter, we saw only 5 instances where workers fell ill and subsequently got better. As of today, we have not — we have endured no loss of life among Cal Water employees, something we feel deeply thankful about. When it comes to helping our customers, we've kept every collection activity suspended across all 4 states. You're beginning to notice that being rolled back in various states throughout the U.S., but within the 4 states where we operate, our freeze on collection activity remains completely in place. We have observed, and keep observing, growth in customer account aging resulting from that collection suspension, and the amount currently sitting over 90 is roughly $11.6 million, and we've bumped up our bad debt reserve by an extra $0.5 million, taking it from $5.2 million up to $5.7 million; and a bit later I'll share more about bigger things we're pursuing alongside the commission regarding collection activity. The added costs tied to our COVID response came to about $300,000, which lands in a memo account for possible recovery down the road in Hawaii and California. One fascinating point: water sales reached 105% of adopted, largely fueled by stronger residential demand, and that has been balanced out by weaker business and industrial usage. So once we begin to see business usage recover and conditions return to normal, we anticipate business and industrial sales will climb as well. Our liquidity has stayed robust; we held $84.4 million in cash along with roughly $115 million of extra capacity on lines of credit, contingent on certain borrowing conditions. So I believe we got through the toughest part of the COVID storm, and we're beginning to emerge from it. California, the biggest entity we operate in, is set to fully reopen for business on June 15. Moving to the following slide, I'd like to spend a moment discussing the ESG report we put out not long ago. That report came out a few weeks back, it's in line with SASB and makes reference to GRI, and it's now accessible. There's a link in the deck that will bring you to the report. Also, for anyone receiving the printed annual report and proxy, our annual report contains a summary ESG report. Producing our first ESG report required a great deal of effort. It's something we take a lot of pride in, and we're equally proud of what we're accomplishing on the ESG side here, and I'm eager to share more as we continue work on our ESG-related projects over the course of 2021. I'll now turn things back to Paul for a brief update on acquisitions. Paul?
Paul Townsley
executiveThanks, Marty. At Cal Water, our business development work has been quite busy and quite fruitful. You'll remember that during the prior year, we completed 2 transactions: the Rainier View Water System up in Washington, along with the Kaho system — sorry, I mean the Kalaeloa system over in Hawaii. On Slide 12, as you're able to see, there are 6 additional acquisitions we've announced and are currently pursuing. Regarding the first of these, the Kapalua Water and Wastewater System, we truly anticipate wrapping that up within the coming few days. Adding one more system to the Cal Water family — or, in this instance, the Hawaii Water family — is really thrilling. The remaining entries on that list include The Preserve at Millerton, Animas Valley, Keahou, Skylonda, and Stroh's. As you're able to see, we've got activity across every one of our operating states, and we're striving to bring all of them to close too. So we have a number of systems announced, plus a number of others still sitting in the pipeline. This is an exciting period for acquisitions at our company. With that said, Marty, I'll hand things back over to you.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveActually, it goes over to Tom.
Tom Smegal
executiveYes, I'm going to grab it.
Paul Townsley
executiveI'm sorry, Tom will take the next slide.
Tom Smegal
executiveAll right, all right. We're looking at Slide 13 now, which is the same capital investment chart we always show. During the prior quarter, we introduced a depreciation line. That way, you're able to observe how the CapEx we're putting in relates to the yearly depreciation happening across our systems. The takeaway is that over the past 5 years, we've typically been running at roughly 3x the depreciation we accrue annually. This chart, along with the projection, extends only through the current year, and the $285 million figure we're estimating sits at the midpoint of our $270 million to $300 million CapEx range for the year. And we — when the second quarter call happens, and we put out the details from our General Rate case in California. I'll refresh this slide, so that 2022 through 2024 will also appear here. Moving to Slide 14. Here's our rate base slide, and much the same thing applies, meaning we'll project rate base from 2023 through 2025 based on the rate case filing, and that will show up in the second quarter slide decks. So there isn't a great deal that's new regarding the rate base estimate on Slide 14 at this point. Marty, I'll hand things over to you for the summary.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAlright, thank you, Tom. There are just a few points to touch on as we wrap up this call and prepare for the Q&A portion. Above all, the first quarter is our slowest one, so it feels good to have that behind us. From an administrative standpoint, it's an extremely demanding quarter due to the year-end audit, completing the annual report, and this year we also finished the ESG report. That leads us into an exceptionally hectic second quarter on the administrative side, with the cost of capital filing Paul mentioned, where we're seeking a modest increase, along with submitting our 2021 General Rate case. Our 2021 General Rate case is massive. During this quarter, the commission receives tens of thousands of pages, and preparing that rate case takes tremendous work, so we're anxious to file it. Moving forward, as Tom said, on our second quarter earnings call we'll give everyone an update about where our request for the 2021 General Rate case ended up. Plus, this is kind of breaking news. Some of you may have seen in the media during the last 24 to 48 hours that drought emergencies have been issued in certain parts of California. To be specific, California Governor Gavin Newsom declared a drought emergency for Sonoma and Mendocino counties in Northern California. Because of the extremely mild winter we experienced this year, combined with our snowpack being just 25% of normal as of earlier this week, we anticipate additional drought declarations occurring at the local level throughout 2021. For those familiar with us, you'll recall we dedicate considerable time to emergency preparedness and planning. Similarly, through the rate case process, we're revising our water supply master plans, which encompass drought contingency master plans as well. What does this mean from a high-level perspective? California's reservoirs right now are in reasonable condition — I wouldn't call it excellent, but reasonable — as we head into the summer months. What really worries us on the drought front is the winter ahead of us, and if it turns out dry again, then what happens in 2022. That's a thing we'll need to keep watching as we head toward a fire season that could prove worse than usual, along with a public safety power shutdown period that could also be more severe, given how little rain we've had this winter. As for fire season and PSPS season, we point out in our ESG report that even with all the hurdles of running things through COVID, over 97% of our employees have wrapped up their emergency response this year, and we're well along in getting ready for a fire season that may arrive early and for the PSPS events that could take place in different parts of the state. As you might remember, in the prior year, even though there were quite a few PSPS occurrences across the state, some lasting 2, 3, 4 days, not a single one of our customers lost water service, thanks to effective contingency planning by the company and the capacity to shift resources throughout the state to keep our systems pressurized and our pumps operating. As we move into what is, hopefully, the last stage of COVID-19, we are seeing improvement. Also, to repeat what I mentioned earlier: the California government has officially designated June 15 as the date the state will reopen to some version of normal, though what that looks like hasn't been pinned down yet. We're continuing to collaborate with the commission on innovative approaches for customers who've been impacted by COVID—particularly through the low-income OIR Phase 2, where we put forward an arrearage management program similar to the one electric utilities got approved for recently. In that proposal, we recommended that customers carrying COVID-related past-due balances, as long as they keep up with their water payments, would get a credit amounting to one-twelfth of what they owe, provided they continue paying until the balance is cleared and their account is current. Also, that monthly credit would be deposited into an account balance and later counted toward recovery. Approval for this water industry program hasn't come through yet, though the electric industry version has been given the green light. As a result, we're watching to find out how the commission will handle it. Clearly, our hope is that those overdue balances will be reduced as operations move back toward a more typical state. With all of that said, finishing Q1 feels great. It's a welcome sight to glimpse what we hope is the end of the COVID tunnel, with staff receiving vaccinations and beginning to return to a normal environment. A portion of our workforce still hasn't returned to office-based work. Since these staff members operate in the field, 90% of them have shown up on the job daily. The folks in our corporate offices and our corporate staff have been the group doing the most remote work. We're close to locking in our return-to-office strategies, and we'll keep watching what local jurisdictions require before bringing employees back. That can differ from one county to the next across California, but our strategies are set, and we're prepared to move as soon as we're cleared to have people return. With that said, Lonnie, that brings our prepared remarks for the first quarter of 2021 to an official close, and now we'd like to take your questions.
Tom Smegal
executiveMarty, I actually heard something from one of our analysts — they pointed out that all the California utilities happen to be holding their earnings calls at precisely the same moment.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveYeah, I noticed that as well, Tom. I realize plenty of other companies are releasing their results right now, and that's what makes this period of quarterly announcements so tough.
Tom Smegal
executiveYes.
Ben Kallo
analystSo Marty, regarding that final topic, I hope everyone on your side is doing fine. It's reassuring to know your staff are in good health as well. That closing subject about the drought — I've also been following it, being someone born in California. May I ask what your take is, and what exactly are you all up to? I suppose this applies to you, Tom, and Paul — how are those conversations with the PUC going? Because I'm aware opinions have diverged on matters like this, correct?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveRight. I'll begin, and then Paul, I'll hand it to you for the commission perspective. Let me say upfront that at Cal Water, we've never formally exited a stage 1 drought. Actually, when the previous drought ended, the mandatory restrictions got lifted. We might have — we reached our goals, our conservation goals, which was a positive thing, and we advocated strongly that these restrictions ought to stay fairly strict since we were meeting targets and driving usage down. Two developments occurred. First, once the Governor declares a dried emergency, that's likely the simplest route for us to obtain a memo account for that region. In his remarks earlier this week, the Governor made it clear he anticipates the drought will be largely regional, tied to each area's water supply. So in our case, for Mendicino and Sonoma County, we don't run operations there. Were we operating there, we'd seek a drought memo account. That said, we're also observing certain water agencies, such as East Bay MUD or the North Marin Water District, announcing a stage 1 drought; and regarding the North Marin Water District, we actually have 2 systems in Northern California impacted by it. At that stage, Paul and his group will probably move to seek a memo account, citing the local agency's drought emergency declaration. So Ben, I think what this amounts to is that we must monitor the situation and see how it unfolds. What separates our current position from 2015 is that our snowpack stands at 25%. If you recall, back in 2015, Governor Brown held a well-known press conference in the meadow where snowpack readings typically take place — where we'd ordinarily be standing atop 7-feet of snow — and instead he stood on green pasture. So some snowpack does exist for us. The reservoirs remain in reasonable condition; that's why the key question ahead really concerns what unfolds in 2022. Even so, we do anticipate additional local drought conditions getting declared at the local level, though perhaps not statewide at this moment. Paul, I'm not sure — is there anything you'd like to add?
Paul Townsley
executiveRight. Where the commission is concerned, we're at an early stage still. Commission staff have been reaching out to us about how we're getting ready, so we've been answering a number of those requests for data. Naturally, another side of the drought is that the odds of PSPS go up, and there's been considerable continuing focus with the commission when it comes to public safety power shutdowns. We've kept participating in those discussions, though I'd say the commission hasn't genuinely started concentrating on the drought as of yet, and we'll be seeing more on that front as the year goes on.
Ben Kallo
analystGreat. Perhaps this one's for you, Tom. You folks sort of covered several items when it comes to those regulatory dates; and just so I'd — you're basically in the clear. Could you take me through it once more, sorry, just go around what we ought to be looking for?
Tom Smegal
executiveYes, certainly; so on this Monday, our cost of capital application is going to be filed. And that — we've laid out what the parameters of it are. That — so it gets filed near May 1 and is anticipated to be decided by the close of the year; that's the plan contained in the commissions model, if it doesn't get done...
Ben Kallo
analystThat applies to California, is that right?
Paul Townsley
executiveYes, that is correct for California. Beyond that, there is the General Rate case, which should be submitted near July 1. As Paul noted, weekends are involved, and my sense is that a small amount of load occasionally gets filed even one day past the 4th of July, simply due to the holidays and similar factors. So we will find out — it will land in early July, to phrase it that way — and it takes 18 months. Therefore, no outcome from the California General Rate case is anticipated before the effective date of January 1, 2023. And as we recently learned — or observed just last year — delays are possible, and such cases frequently have been delayed. More than 6 months of delay affected 2 of our most recent 3 general rate cases, so we will need to see when it actually takes effect. Interim rates apply to both California filings should a timely decision not be reached. Thus, the effective dates are essentially those dates. We also are submitting a rate case in Washington state in connection with the Rainier View acquisition. With the commission, we reached agreement to file a new rate case this year covering both our current group and the Rainier View group. So it will be completed this year, though it will be considerably smaller.
Ben Kallo
analystRight, understood. And regarding that 10 point — I believe it's the 10.35% figure compared to your previous one, how much does interest — is it simply that interest rates have risen slightly? Is that relevant? Or, put another way, how significant is it? Do you think so when you're putting that together?
Tom Smegal
executiveBen, the inputs for these company applications are quite technical. We have an econometric — an economist witness who examines many of the standard models, DCF models, capital asset pricing models, and so on, in order to derive those suggested rates for return on equity. So I'm not sure it's any single point that's pushing it upward. My recollection is that in the 2017 case we requested something above that, though I'd need to check. One item I wanted to mention, which we didn't include on the slide, is that in California it has been atypical for water utilities to carry noticeably lower ROE than electric utilities. And if you examine other states across the U.S., and you likely know this as well as we do, water utilities don't get a discount. In fact, in nearly every instance we're smaller organizations than the electrics. So you would expect greater financial risk there. Yet California has always had, for whatever reason, a discount applied to the ROE for waters; therefore the ROE we're proposing here, 10.35%, is actually closer to the electric ROEs in California. So we'll see how that plays out. I believe we have solid arguments for it. And I believe our witness is strong, and we're hoping to prevail on it.
Ben Kallo
analystYeah, on California and the scale, I'm with the front on that. Perhaps one final item. Marty, regarding infrastructure—does any portion of that, the infrastructure package, and I realize much remains to be settled—does any portion of it affect you? Or what's your thinking on how it might affect you folks?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAbsolutely. In fact, Ben, that's an excellent, excellent question, and it's a rather intricate matter with many moving pieces. Our National Association, led by Rob Powelson, a former FERC Commissioner and previously Head of the Pennsylvania PUC, has been deeply engaged in efforts on the Hill, clearly, regarding allocations to the state revolving funds. We need to ensure we advocate for access to those funds within the state once they're allocated; however, it can differ state-by-state as those funds are pushed down as required under Federal laws. The other major item that's been discussed is whether, as part of the Bailout Bill, any dollars will be made available for arrearage management, and we've been engaged in those efforts. In fact, this week we attended an event with one of the governors, where we stressed that any dollars from the Feds intended for COVID relief, for customers carrying outstanding balances, investor-owned water utilities—their customers are taxpayers too, and we should have equal access to those dollars; so nothing is set in stone yet. It's quite a gray area. The Department of Health Services has had dollars since the late fall, and they haven't pushed them down to the states yet. We're monitoring that; we're in discussions with them about what occurs when those dollars do get pushed out and trying to secure access to those dollars for our customers, but nothing has been finalized yet, Ben; but trust me when I say we are fully on top of it, we have our federal team working on it, we have our CWA teams, our California Water Association, teams working on it, and we have our local government affairs continuing to work, and that's to be determined. I anticipate some dollars flowing from the Feds down to the state, likely sometime here in the second quarter, but nothing has been determined about how the mechanics will actually work out, though discussions are underway.
Paul Townsley
executiveOkay. Lonnie, thanks, and thanks to all of you. I appreciate everyone spending part of your day with us here. As Tom said earlier, there are plenty of conference calls taking place at the same time. We'll be available if anybody has questions. Should you have a moment, please take a look at the ESG report — you'll see all the wonderful work we're doing on the ESG front. And we're eager to share updates on our progress with the General Rate case and our cost of capital at the close of the second quarter; so stay safe, everyone, be well, and we can't wait to speak with all of you at the end of the next quarter on our upcoming earnings call. Thank you, everyone. Have a wonderful day. Lonnie, over to you.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up the conference call for today. We appreciate everyone for joining in. You're free to disconnect at this time.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.