California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 24, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 40 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Dave Healey

executive
#1

Appreciate it, Jonathan. Greetings to all, and thanks for joining the California Water Service Group call where we'll discuss results for both the fourth quarter and the entire 2021 fiscal year. With me today are our President and CEO Martin Kropelnicki, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Thomas Smegal, and Paul Townsley, who serves as our Vice President of Business Development. You can find instructions for listening to a replay of this call in the yearend earnings release that was issued earlier today. Access to that replay will be available until April 27, 2022. One brief item before we begin: a slide deck accompanies this earnings call. It was provided with an 8-K this morning and is also available on the company's website, www.calwatergroup.com. Ahead of discussing the results for this quarter and the full year, we want to take a brief moment to address forward-looking statements. During this call, there may be occasions when the company issues certain forward-looking statements. Because such statements concern events yet to come, they carry a range of risks and uncertainties, and what actually happens could end up materially different from what the company presently expects. Given that, the company strongly urges every current shareholder, along with any interested parties, to thoroughly review and grasp the company's disclosures regarding risks and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports we file with the Securities and Exchange Commission from time to time. I'll now hand things over to Tom to get started.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#2

Dave, thanks, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to join you here to go over California Water Service Group's — Cal Water's — results and what we expect as we look toward 2022. Starting on slide 5 in the deck, I'll take you through the financial results for the full year, and then we'll continue on as the slides move forward. On this first slide, I'd like to spend somewhat more time than I usually do, because a handful of new items appear here, or at least items for the group that deserve mention. To start, our operating revenue was down a little for the year, and yet net income attributable to the company increased $4.3 million; that's certainly good news, and we're proud of that outcome. There's a point here that could leave you a bit puzzled. Why did revenue come down while net income went up? It comes down to how California's regulatory framework works: we're giving back to customers deferred income taxes that turned out to be excessive. That giveback flows through into the rates customers pay, which pulls revenue down, and it also reduces our income tax expense. So if you dig into the financial statements included with the press release, or into the 10-K, you'll see that our income tax for the year came in lower. Another item worth flagging: I referred to net income attributable to CWT. The reason for that is we're leaving out the effect of the minority interest tied to BVRT, the Texas entity we jointly own. So if you go through the 10K, you'll find quite a bit of disclosure and description about it; what you're looking at here is net income attributable to CWT, and that same wording will keep appearing going forward, both in the press release and in our SEC filings. Turning to earnings per share, we came in just a touch lower for the year, moving from $1.97 down to $1.96. And once more, what explains the gap — net income rising while earnings per share falls — is the 3.3 million new shares we issued back in 2021. Regarding our ATM program, we'll cover that in greater detail a bit later in the slide deck. Turning to slide 6, our fourth quarter financial results, we did experience a drop in net income and earnings for Q4. The main reason is the effect of lower unbilled revenue; we discussed this on both the second quarter and third quarter calls, when the company had a much higher than usual unbilled revenue accrual during Q2 and Q3. That has now returned to a normal level by year-end, and so that is really what's driving the fourth quarter results you're seeing. That's really the main factor there, and we'll dig into it using those bar charts a bit later. Now I'd like to hand things over to Martin for a recap.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#3

Appreciate it, Tom. Morning, everybody. Thank you for being with us on a morning that's extremely packed with news; we're grateful you carved out the time today. Like Tom said, we enjoyed a strong year overall while continuing to navigate the pandemic, the drought, and plenty of regulatory matters, especially in California, where our cost of capital proceeding and our 2021 general rate case are both underway. Infrastructure investment across the year came to $293 million; that figure is a bit lower than before, yet we felt good about where we landed considering COVID's persistence plus the supply chain challenges everyone has been hearing and reading about. Obviously those supply chain problems hit us too, affecting how much capital we can actually put in the ground. On top of that, we keep pursuing growth, having brought in our Texas subsidiary, and we'll get into more detail on that shortly. Naturally, we've also kept pushing forward on strengthening our ESG work, which included releasing our very first ESG report. Also, California allocated federal pandemic relief bill money designated for utilities' risk management, and in February a check arrived worth more than $20 million. Those dollars are meant to offset and assist our customers in lowering the debt tied to their water bills from the pandemic. We're currently working through distributing that money. So all told, from an EPS standpoint, we came in a penny per share lower. Yet, as Tom noted, we put out 3.3 million shares through the ATM program. That pushed net income above 100 million for the very first time in company history, closing the year at $101.1 million. That ultimately left us room to raise the dividend by $0.08, or 8.7%, moving from $0.92 per share to $0.01 per share for 2022. Alright, now let's turn to the fourth quarter highlights on slide 8. As I said, net income fell by 12 million, landing at 3.5 million for the quarter. The main reason behind that was a 9.2 million drop in accrued unbilled revenue. Just to give some perspective, across the full year unbilled revenue declined by $0.5 million, so essentially almost no change in unbilled revenue for the year. Still, we clearly saw plenty of fluctuation throughout the year — in the second quarter, the third quarter, and then again here at year's end. So the full-year outcome for unbilled revenue wasn't a surprise. The rate increases contributed 2.1 million, and we also faced higher depreciation and maintenance expenses, which pushed costs up by $3.7 million. Then there's another factor, somewhat beyond our control: unrealized gains tied to our non-qualified retirement plan assets dropped by $2 million versus the previous year. Those items are visible on the earnings bridges on slide 9, and we also have the bridge covering 20 to 21. Once again, the yearly results look quite similar — rate relief and the benefit of lower bad debt expense from receiving state funding for risk management, while other elements are essentially the company's routine operating costs working against that rate relief. Turning to the quarterly earnings bridge on slide 10, you'll notice the sizable effect there, including a shift in unbilled revenue along with mark-to-market. Now I want to turn to 2022, on slide 11, and go through a few points that analysts and those watching the stock ought to keep in mind. We discussed these a year ago too, but let me just cover some of the main factors. For 2022, our adopted rate base in California stands at 1.84 billion, which yields adopted net income in California of $90.5 million — that's what the commission expects us to earn under normal conditions. Our other states carry roughly 110 million in rebates, and you'd anticipate they earn consistent with their rebase. Since this marks the third year of the California GRC process, new rates from the new case wouldn't take effect until 2023. There's also everything that comes with the third year of the general rate case — expenses projected 5 years back that, under normal circumstances, shift over time, which typically creates some pressure on the company. That shows up when you examine earnings in the third year of the California rate case. This year especially, inflation is weighing on many parts of the business, and that could affect us in 2022 as well, so we need to stay cautious and monitor it. We did receive a significant step rate increase for 2020 to $21.7 million general rate increase, and part of that reflected their acknowledgment of inflation. So the Commission's process delivered a larger step increase because recorded inflation had come in higher. As for the reduction in cost of debt that we saw — which we proposed to the California Commission in the cost of capital case — the rate payer advocate didn't contest it, and on its own, bringing our cost of capital's cost of debt down from 5.51% to 4.23% would cut revenues by $11 million. Once our rates take effect in the cost of capital proceeding. As Marty brought up briefly before, the decrease in our bad debt reserve during this year — that amounted to a $4.6 million cut to the bad debt reserve tied to the $20 million obtained from the state of California; in our view, it isn't probable that further funding would become accessible and keep lowering that bad debt reserve. Therefore, it probably won't happen again in 2022; and as is always the case, a caution that mark-to-market is a variable we can't always predict, during 2021, it rose $3.8 million, while in 2020, it had gone up $4.3 million. Thus, in each of those years, mark-to-market helped the company, and regarding unbilled revenue, earnings declined by $1.3 million in 2021 and by $0.8 million in 2020. So that has remained a fairly neutral element. Yet it may shift at times. So please keep that in mind; and now I'll hand things over to Paul for an update on the California general rate.

Paul Townsley

executive
#4

Thanks, Tom. If you could move to slide 12 in your presentation. Our California general rate case, submitted on July 1 of last year, is moving along well. As a quick refresher, we're asking for $1.02 billion of capital investment across 2022 through 2024, and $913 million of that total is for new capital projects. Among the bigger investment categories in this filing are carrying on with our pipeline replacement program — something we've now taken through 3 rate case cycles — plus continuing our wildfire hardening effort, which reflects the fires California has gone through over the past few years. This filing also takes into account that we will lose our decoupling mechanism. In response, our application aims to offset that loss through better sales forecasts, an adjusted mix of relative production sources, and a redesigned rate structure that shifts more revenue into fixed monthly costs on customer bills. We got testimony earlier this year from the California Public Advocates in this case, and right now we're drafting a rebuttal addressing the points where we think they've gotten it wrong. The schedule for this rate case holds, and we expect a commission decision before this year ends, with new rates taking effect on January 1, 2023. With that, Tom, back to you for the cost of capital update.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#5

Thank you, Paul. Now, the second matter we're dealing with in California is our cost of capital application. We submitted that filing on May 1 of last year, seeking a review of the cost of capital that would apply for 2022, 2023, and 2024. In that request, we asked for a 10.35% ROE based on the same capital structure — 53.4% equity — along with a cost of debt that, as I noted before, came down to 4.23%. The Cal advocates' testimony was released in late January or early February, and it proposed a 7.81% ROE with a 49.44% equity capital structure, while agreeing with our analysis of the cost of debt. We'll be submitting our rebuttal in March, just a few weeks from now. We're expecting a final ruling in this case during the third quarter of 2022. Let me also mention that we've completed quite a few financing activities in recent years, especially in 2021, and those represent some major achievements for the company. We clearly issued 280 million in first mortgage bonds back in May, and we sold 197.9 million of stock through the ATM program over the course of the year. So there's been substantial financing activity, and as part of our rebuttal, we're making the point to the commission and to the rate payer advocate that this company has made significant investments and completed significant financing, and maintaining that equity capital structure is truly essential. The company has a well-defined plan to reach the equity capital structure that was proposed for the 2022 through 2024 period. That said, at the close of 2021, we find that Cal water sits at 48.5% equity, and clearly, through further financing across 2022 through 2024, we anticipate bringing that equity level up to match what we requested. Now I'll hand things over to Marty to discuss the drought.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#6

Alright, thank you, Tom. To put it mildly, this winter has been quite eventful along the West Coast. As some of you might remember, on October 19, 2021, Governor Newsom declared a drought emergency for California; two significant storms struck the west coast—more of what people refer to as a cyclone storm or bomb storm—delivering fairly heavy rain and snow to the area, but then they dissipated. These things tend to produce very intense bursts of storm activity before fading; so in spite of that most recent storm late in the year in Northern California, we've gotten no rain during January and February, and that makes this the driest January and February ever recorded in California; as a result, our drought plans remain unchanged. Every one of our districts is under a drought emergency. Keep in mind, the state now coordinates a 5 stage plan for drought emergencies. So our planning phases are the same as before; 6 districts sit at a stage 2 drought, while the remaining districts are at a stage 1 drought. We'll therefore keep concentrating on water supply resiliency across all districts, and our drought taskforce has kept meeting all winter long. Naturally, we're watching closely what unfolds over these final six weeks of winter, and we're hopeful for additional rain and snow during the March months. Still, we can't count on that or gamble on it. So we're staying the course with our drought emergency planning, and though we hope for the best, we always prepare for the worst, and that approach will continue as we move into spring of 2022. I'll now turn things over to Paul for a recap of our 2021 business development activities. Paul?

Paul Townsley

executive
#7

Yes, thanks Marty. If you look at slide 15, there's a summary of the deals we completed in 2021. That was a really active year for us — we got several acquisitions across the finish line while still hunting for new opportunities. Our Texas investments keep expanding, finishing the year with 2,500 customer connections in total. We also completed the purchase of a pair of water and sewer systems in Hawaii last year, which brought in 1000 new customers, and then earlier this year we wrapped up Valencia Mesa Water in New Mexico, which added yet another system in that state. During 2021, the California PUC gave the green light to our CCN for a brand-new service territory in Madera County, California. That territory goes by the name the Preserve at Millerton, and we anticipate the first customers will come on board at that Greenfield system at some point later this year. Turning to slide 16, you can review a few of the other deals we're actively pursuing. In New Mexico, just earlier this month, we got the nod from the New Mexico public Regulatory Commission to acquire the Animas Valley Water System, which will bring 2,000 new customers in that state; in Hawaii, we're waiting on the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission to sign off on two acquisitions, HOH utilities on the island of Hawaii and Keahou utility on the on the big island — once the Commission approves them, these systems will bring over 3,300 wastewater customers into our Hawaii operations. We have 2 small systems in California and Washington that we've announced and are now moving through due diligence, regulatory filings and the rest of the closing process. And in Texas, we've brought another new utility into our portfolio within our BVRT Partnership, known as the railyard utility, and that will create another new growth area for us in Texas. So that covers where things stand with our business development. And I'll hand this back over to Marty.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#8

Thank you, Paul. I'd like to discuss what we achieved in ESG during 2021, and there were quite a lot of accomplishments. As most of you are aware, over the past two years we've placed a great deal of emphasis on the ESG elements of our operations and on reshaping our corporate strategy so that ESG aims and targets are better woven in, especially when it comes to climate change, reducing its effects, and adjusting to it. To begin with, we issued our inaugural ESG report, which followed TCFD principles and was aligned with SASB, and we brought in four fresh ESG policies covering human rights, environmental sustainability, political involvement, and diversity, equality and inclusion. Our ESG framework was released, and you can find it in our proxy as well as our 10k, and it plainly demonstrates that board-level oversight of ESG work exists via the nominating Corporate Governance Committee of our board of directors; officer-level accountability comes through an officer ESG oversight committee, and we also have subject matter experts inside the company who formed the ESG working group, which assisted us in establishing our goals and objectives. During yesterday's session with our board, we brought them up to date on our climate change strategy, and in particular we had just finished a new climate change study; we have a 5.0 plan for how we fit into climate change, with five goals as follows. We aim to lower the contribution that we and our customers make to climate change. We aim to comprehend and prepare for how climate change will affect our business; so that means not only mitigation, but also adaptation to climate change. We aim to increase collaboration and advocacy, both at the consumer level and at the state and agency level, where our coordinated efforts can have a wider impact on lessening climate change's effects on the environment. We aim to establish time bound goals and report on them, and we aim to keep maturing our disclosures and the way we communicate these goals to our stockholders and to interested parties in California Water Service Group. In addition, we completed — recently finished a highly robust ESG goal setting process that establishes short-term and long-term objectives. I'm very proud to say that yesterday our board of directors, our compensation committee of our board of directors approved 5 ESG goals for our long term incentive plan. Our prior incentive plan contained 1 ESG goal, so we're moving from 1 to 5; this long term incentive plan will pay out 3 years from now, and it aligns all the officer and department head goals, keeping officers and department heads across the companies in all 5 states focused on the same goals. So there's plenty happening on the ESG front at Cal Water, and we received good accolades for the progress made in 2022. Our upcoming ESG report is going to be released soon, during April, so keep an eye out for it appearing before long, and we're eager to discuss it in the months ahead across 2022 and after.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#9

Appreciate it, Marty. Looking at slides 18 and 19, there's only a minor refresh here as we wrap up 2021, again showing $293 million in capital investment on the CapEx slide, and then moving over to slide 19, $1.95 billion is the presently adopted rate base for the entire company, and we're confirming that figure. Those yellow bars appearing on slides 18 and 19 capture what we're requesting in the California general rate case, along with what we anticipate in other states regarding capital investment and rate base growth. So bear in mind that outcomes could differ once we work through the regulatory process in California and elsewhere. Still, that's the projection we currently have. Now I'll hand things back to Marty to discuss our business priorities.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#10

Alright. On slide 20, we discussed what our business priorities are, but I'd like to take a moment to note a few management shifts the company implemented as of January 1, 2022, to assist us in reaching our goals and objectives. Above all, Ms. Sophie James was appointed Chief Water Quality Officer for California Water Service Group along with every one of our operating entities. Sophie had been serving as our lab manager, and she's being elevated to director of water quality. She's uniquely suited to head up our water quality efforts inside our company. She earned a master's degree in analytical chemistry, plus a BS in chemistry with a minor in Mathematics. She holds a number of certifications, including ones in lab management, treating water, and distributing water. In addition, as part of continuing our effort to bolster ESG sustainability, Ken Jenkins received a promotion to Chief Water Resource Sustainability Officer, and he will play a significant role in our sustainability work and in adapting to climate change. Ken came aboard the company 17 years back and worked in community and governmental affairs. From 2008 through 2020, he was promoted to head our drought response team along with our conservation team, and he performed wonderfully — during the most recent drought, as you might remember, we achieved our reduction goals of 25% throughout our service areas in California. In 2020, he was promoted to director of water resource sustainability. Ken plays a key role in steering our company's sustainability initiatives, along with our climate change planning and the way we'll adjust to those strategies. So I'd like to offer congratulations to Sophie and Ken alike on their advancement to Officer roles at California Water Service Group and California water service company. On top of that, we saw some shifts in management, and I want to bring up Elisa Wang. I moved up to Vice President Facilities Fleet and procurement, taking effect January 1, 2022. Elisa played a big role, clearly, in what we were doing with supply chain, and when the pandemic hit, well, a few of our third party suppliers had some difficulties, though this company has really performed pretty strongly. What mattered most over these past two years was simply ensuring we had the proper PP&E in place for every one of our employees, and at the very least it has done a wonderful job making certain that each of our workers has whatever they require to show up on the job throughout the pandemic, since we have never once closed our doors. Our people have been working around the clock — 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. On top of that, Paul Townsley picked up some cowboy boots and said yes to relocating to Texas on our behalf. So for the very first time, Paul isn't here with us in person — he's on the line from Austin, Texas. In the job he held before, Paul oversaw Business Development along with serving as our Chief Regulatory Affairs Officer. That said, since business development has kept us so busy, and since Paul's team has delivered such impressive results across the last two years, we asked him to focus entirely on business development, and we relocated him to Texas so that he could lead those efforts. Along those lines, Greg Millman — previously VP of Rates for California — has taken on the role of VP of Rates within Regulatory Affairs. In that capacity, he's responsible for our entire regulatory function spanning all 5 states, which you could also describe as the group level, or simply "group." That means Greg picked up the rest of what Paul had been doing: leading our regulatory efforts and rate case proceedings across those same 5 states. Separately, Michelle Mortensen has been elevated to Vice President, Corporate Secretary and Chief of Staff. In that position, she supports me in running the company, and she also helps me communicate with the board, organize board meetings, and manage all the other responsibilities that come along with operating as a public company. Starting from the first of January in 2022, her promotion took effect. I want to offer congratulations to Paul, Greg, Elisa, Michelle, Sophie, and Ken for their advancements, as we set our direction for 2022. With that being said, what do we see as our key priorities as we look toward 2022? Six areas have our strong attention. The first and most important one is the general rate case in California — we're aiming to keep it progressing and secure a favorable result in that proceeding. The second involves the cost of capital in California, which, as Tom noted, is already moving forward, and at this moment we're addressing comments from advocates, with the expectation of finishing that up around the middle of the year. Our plan is to keep putting money into capital projects, keep steering through the supply chain disruptions coming from certain vendors, and keep getting those dollars deployed. We also need to address the drought in California. Clearly, whatever unfolds over the coming six weeks will have a much bigger impact on how the drought situation shapes up for the year across the state, so we intend to monitor it closely and be prepared for whatever drought-related difficulties the company encounters in 2022. Finally, we aim to keep advancing our ESG efforts. As I noted earlier, we have revised our LTI so that it now includes five LTI goals tied to ESG. Our most recent climate change analysis, which gets shared with the board, has just been completed, and an updated ESG report is set to be released in April for stockholders. So 2022 holds plenty of priorities for us; nevertheless, these are the areas the company will concentrate on intently. To wrap up, reviewing 2021, it was a year of solid performance, since net income surpassed $100 million for the first time ever. That earnings result makes us very pleased, and despite pandemic and supply chain difficulties, CapEx came through nicely, along with another robust year of business development that in the end brought Paul to Texas. I'd bet he's giving his boots a good shine at this very moment while remaining on the call with us; thus we anticipate yet another robust year ahead from the folks in business development. And naturally, we anticipate bringing the regulatory proceedings to a close during 2022, while keeping our attention on the drought as well as our sustainability work aimed at adjusting to climate change. So, Jonathan, with that said, we'll now take questions.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#11

Hi everyone, appreciate you allowing me to ask. First off, regarding unbilled revenue, Tom, would you mind taking us through how we ought to approach it for ’22 in a bit more detail, and then perhaps explain how it actually works, so we can get a clearer picture.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#12

Absolutely; so unbilled revenue is an accounting exercise we carry out each quarter — in fact monthly, though for financial reporting it's quarterly; what we examine is those customers who've consumed water and received service from us yet haven't been invoiced; that's invariably an estimate, known as an accrual, so at period end we accrue the count of days not yet billed times the typical, the typical invoice the customer could have — could have received had they been billed for that day. What you observe is that across the year, unbilled revenue rises, since unbilled usage in June and in September far exceeds what it is in December and in March. Consequently you get this pattern running through the year, with a comparatively low figure for unbilled revenue at the start and the close of the year, then a comparatively elevated figure in the second and third quarter. Going back, and if you're able to check this in our presentations, in both the second quarter and the third quarter, we recorded an unusually large amount of unbilled revenue in June and in September, and there are a few distinct possible reasons behind that. First, you consider weather, and you consider customer usage happening at that moment. So you're assessing the average, the possibly average invoice during that month and attempting to establish an estimate for unbilled. What we observed in December was, clearly there'd been a fair amount of rain toward the end of December, the bills declined, and that's where you're seeing that figure decline and the unbilled revenue will decline. So it was — it was certainly something we flagged. Once more, if you revisit our earnings presentations from the second and third quarter, we were aware that was elevated and we were aware that that or we presumed, I suppose, that it would decline, since it invariably declines at year end. And so turning to ’22, you know, there's no way to predict what it'll be in June and in September. However I do know with a fair level of certainty that by the close of 2022, that won't be a significant factor in the company's earnings for the full year. The thing is, generally you're talking about the same kind of weather at the end of December each year, especially in California, and the same count of unbuild days. So really, the way to view it is that these could be variations from the fourth quarter. We definitely had pull into the second and third quarter of unbilled revenue this year. But in the end, by year-end, it wasn't a factor, so hopefully that clears it up.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#13

No, it does. Could we go a bit deeper on this, perhaps with Marty, Tom, or Paul, regarding the new rate structure aimed at reducing the impact from losing decoupling?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#14

Absolutely. Paul, do you want me to kick things off, or are we all equally ready to jump in on this? So Paul, go ahead.

Paul Townsley

executive
#15

Alright, let me go ahead. What we've tried to accomplish is capturing a larger share of the money coming in from customers — money that historically came through the variable usage component of a customer's bill — and shifting a bigger portion of it into the fixed side by means of what's known as the monthly service charge. Doing that would give us more steadiness in revenue when consumption fluctuates. And across time, we've worked to raise that figure within each of the service territories we operate. Also, in the current rate case, we've sought to lift it — not by a large degree, but to a greater level. That way, when sales diverge from the assumptions used in the rate case, the money we bring in stays more consistent than was true previously, and naturally, thanks to a decoupling mechanism, should consumption shift versus what the rate case assumed, that mechanism makes up for it — or offsets the shortfall and provides substantial compensation — or put differently, our aim has been to grow the portion of revenue tied to customers rather than to the service charge.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#16

Understood. That makes sense. And then, Tom, regarding the capital structure — could you just say a bit about it? So it appears that way. You can go, you're at 49.44% equity, you're permitted, or the larger?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#17

No, yeah, so keep in mind, at this stage we're only handling the rate, their advocates testimony.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#18

Alright, understood.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#19

Or a single party — in this instance, a single party — we had put forward a capital structure of 53.4% equity, which is what this company has used for a great many years, approved by the California Commission, and now they're stepping in to say, well, across the past couple of years, we've actually been below that level. Therefore the commissioners ought to go with a lower figure; and the point we'll make in our rebuttal testimony is that honestly, every bit of that debt financing was done to serve our customers' interests. We put out $280 million in debt at an extremely unusually low rate, bringing down the weighted average cost of debt across 30 or 40 years for those customers; and simply because during 1 year or 2 years, the capital structure carried somewhat more debt than was normal at the time, that ought not to lead the commission to conclude they should settle on a smaller capital structure. So we believe we'll prevail on that argument, though in the end it rests on what the Commission rules. Still, it's something — it's something worth keeping an eye on.

Paul Townsley

executive
#20

And Tom, the sole thing I'll mention, assuming my calculation is correct, is this. Your group brought the typical expense down by close to 130 basis points, which is a big deal. So when we sit down for the cost of capital settlement talks, debt costs simply flow through, meaning there's headroom plus an allowed return on equity, based on the approved capitalization structure, that adds up to a pretty meaningful giveback for ratepayers, since we aren't meant to earn a profit on the debt portion. So I offer Tom's team enormous credit for moving when they did in the market to seize those cheaper rates, and we did that for our customers. Therefore we don't think the commission ought to punish us for it.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#21

Great, thank you, guys.

Paul Townsley

executive
#22

All right. Thanks, Ben.

Ben Kallo

analyst
#23

Take care.

Paul Townsley

executive
#24

Thanks.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#25

Okay, thanks, Jonathan. So, our 10K should be filed later today — we're wrapping up the final steps and will sign everything off this morning right after we finish this call, so it will be submitted; keep an eye out for it. As I said, our ESG report is expected out in April, and we'll share it and post it on our site. Also, I'd like to pause briefly to express appreciation to all of you for the ongoing interest in and backing of California Water Service Group. With 2 years of the pandemic coming to a close, hopefully we're returning to something closer to a normal environment and, ideally, a normal operating environment. So we're grateful for your support and for considering us, and we can't wait to see all of you very soon. Thanks, and have a great day. Bye, everybody.

Operator

operator
#26

We appreciate you, ladies and gentlemen, for joining us on today's call. That brings the program to a close. You're welcome to disconnect at this time. Have a good day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.