California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 28, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Dave Healey
executiveThanks, Polly. Hello, everyone, and welcome to California Water Service Group's 2022 Second Quarter Earnings Call. Joining me is our President and CEO, Marty Kropelnicki, along with our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Tom Smegal. You can find the replay dial-in details in our second quarter earnings release, which came out earlier today. Also, a quick note: the company has a slide deck that goes with this quarter's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K this morning, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we get into this quarter's results, we want to spend a few moments on forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company may make certain forward-looking statements. Since these statements involve future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly advises all current shareholders as well as interested parties to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures on risk and uncertainty found in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases and other reports filed from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll hand things over to Tom to get started.
Tom Smegal
executiveThanks, Dave, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to have you join our call for the second quarter earnings release. I'd like to begin with the financial summary found on Slide 5, and I'll dig into certain specifics shortly. However, to provide everyone with the headline figures, net income attributable to the group came in at $19.5 million, or $0.36 per share, which represents a significant decline from $38.2 million, or $0.75 per share, in the second quarter of 2021; when looking at the year-to-date period, the outcome is fairly comparable, with net income of $20.6 million, or $0.38 per share, versus $35.2 million, or $0.69 per share, during the equivalent year-to-date stretch of 2021. Turning to Slide 7, we can explore some specifics behind this. The main driver behind the earnings shift relates to our unbilled revenue accrual. I've now spent 25 years with the company, and I've been part of management discussing financials with all of you, I believe, for roughly 12 years. And our unbilled revenue accrual is something we frequently address. What's important to keep in mind is that this represents our calculation of the value of water consumed by our customers, yet not billed, and thus, it falls outside our regulatory mechanisms. And there is some fluctuation in this throughout the year. We bring it up each quarter. If you've been following us for a while, during the second quarter of 2021, our unbilled revenue accrual rose substantially, but it eventually returned to a normal range by the end of that year. This year, in — sort of mirroring the large increase from last year, we experienced a large decrease in our unbilled revenue accrual; that amounted to a $15.2 million change in revenue tied to it, along with a major effect on earnings per share for the quarter as well. But as a reminder, the company's unbilled revenue accrual tends to be very stable at year-end. And management holds the belief that we are very likely to see a year-end result for the unbilled revenue accrual that falls within plus or minus $2 million of the prior year. So even though there's a big swing here in the quarter and certainly a big swing compared to last year, we want to stress that by year-end, we expect all that volatility to disappear and for us to have a fairly normal unbilled revenue accrual. Another factor affecting the quarter that lies beyond our control is a change in the measured valuation of our nonqualified plan assets; this stems purely from market conditions, and the value of those assets dropped $6.2 million compared with the first — the second quarter of 2021. When it comes to our general rate increases — the step rate increase in California plus rate changes elsewhere — those contributed $6.9 million, which is a really favorable item for the year. That gain is partly offset by shifts in wages, depreciation, interest, and other operating and maintenance expenses, which are the kinds of things we'd typically anticipate as time passes and inflation kicks in. Both our CapEx for the quarter and our CapEx year-to-date are on plan and somewhat above what they were in the earlier period. The bar charts I'll skip, since for the most part they cover what I just described — unbilled being the main factor, together with the mark-to-market; and at this point I'll hand things over to Marty so he can discuss the California general rate case.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAlright, thank you, Tom. Morning to all of you. We appreciate you being with us for this discussion of our second quarter results. Our largest operating entity is California, and the 2021 California general rate case there has moved forward. Our hearings are finished, and briefs have been submitted to the administrative law judge. Our expectation remains that the GRC will take effect on January 1, 2023. Among the parties, nothing has shifted regarding the contested items. That said, when it comes to sales and water mix production as included in the general rate case, there is still no significant dispute among the parties. So we have notified the administrative law judge that a partial settlement might be submitted sometime in August. Tom, would you like to address the cost of capital? I believe that one is yours.
Tom Smegal
executiveAbsolutely. Appreciate it, Marty. So the procedural situation is quite comparable when it comes to the cost of capital proceeding we have in California. The hearings are finished. Briefs have been submitted, and the cost of capital case is now being reviewed by the ALJ. I did want to remind those investing in the public markets that when we filed for cost of capital, we sought a lower cost of debt than what was adopted most recently in the prior case. And were that to be adopted with nothing else changing on cost of capital, we'd anticipate an $11 million decrease to revenue out of California because of that reduced cost of debt. That reflects our financing and refinancing program, which lowered our cost of debt to 4.23% on a weighted average basis in this case, down from 5.51% in the last case. So we haven't taken a reserve for that amount, partly since we don't know the timing and effective date of the cost of capital case; and partly due to 2 other elements of the cost of capital case that remain unknown right now, those elements being the cost of equity, return on equity, so the capital structure for the company; and so investors should be aware that, that's out there and the commission could make that retroactive but we have not yet booked that into our results here in 2022. Marty, I'll turn it back to you for a throughout update.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAlright, several developments related to the drought. Above all, it’s still with us. As witnessed during the heat wave—not only across the United States but truly globally—this underscores how much we must keep prioritizing resilient supply and sustainability. In California, as noted during the prior quarter, deliveries from the California State Water project got reduced to 5%, which affected certain areas depending entirely on state-supplied water. On our side, customer usage declined 5% during Q2 relative to 2021. Yet the wider pattern matters most, in my view. Looking at the year-to-date conservation or water savings figure, it stands at 2%. For the quarter, it’s 5%. However, examining June alone, it exceeded 11%. That’s an encouraging signal that our drought initiatives and the messages we’re sending customers are beginning to gain traction, and I anticipate that figure will rise as we move through the drier summer period—July, August, and September. Regarding drought-related expenditures, if you recall, the entire state of California is under a stage 2 drought alert. Roughly $400,000 was spent this quarter, logged in a memorandum account, representing incremental costs incurred responding to the drought, to be recovered at a later time. The cumulative balance in that account since 2021—when the government declared the drought—now sits at approximately $1.2 million. So drought messaging is beginning to gain traction as we head into the dry summer months, and we aim to drive that figure as high as possible, getting as near to the 20% target we have statewide as we can. A few other things to keep an eye on during the latter half of the year. The first is capital spending. Per Tom’s comments, our capital spending rose 6% versus the same period last year. While we’re extremely pleased about that, I want us to be very clear: given that supply chain problems have persisted worldwide, we aren’t shielded from them. Our internal team has performed very well in reducing those risks that jeopardize our capacity to deploy capital; however, the longer such risks persist, the higher the likelihood of impact on Cal Water. Consequently, some uncertainty exists as we enter the second half regarding our ability to deploy all the capital if we encounter any supply chain disruptions. As I said, the team has done a great job mitigating those problems. But clearly, it becomes more difficult as these supply chain delays, or procured items we require to deploy capital, persist. Beyond that, concerning the rate case, we still lack regulatory approval on certain items. Thus, in the event you remember the rate case, the manner in which our rate case cycle operates, it encompasses the 2022 capital program. Therefore, as we proceed through this GRC cycle, we are making certain assumptions, and we are giving priority to the high-risk capital, which consists of items we believe we must complete as a company that rank at the very top in terms of being critical, yet we lack assurances regarding those until the commission truly approves the 2021 general rate case. Another point I wish to mention is that our reserves for bad debt stay elevated at roughly $6.7 million, mainly pushed by California at present; across the other states, we have begun the collection process as we emerge from the COVID pandemic. In California, we are only now commencing that process. It is a 90-day process to begin disconnecting people for nonpayment. Our initial notices in fact went out this week to begin the process; thus, before this week, collection activities stood at 0 while we awaited commission approval to begin the process; therefore, how customers respond will be critical. What we have observed in the other states where we operate is that once we began the collection process, customers started paying their accounts. Consequently, that will be something to monitor during the second half of the year. Moving to the next page, Slide 13, just a brief update regarding business development. The business development pipeline stays robust as we head into the second half of the year. On this page, this is the highlight of projects we have closed, projects the commissions have recently approved, and projects we have announced during 2022. Altogether, there are more than 3,600 water connections currently in process plus more than 4,000 wastewater connections. So as we head into the second half of the year, the BD team is extremely busy, and we anticipate that activity will persist as we advance into 2023. And Tom, would you like to cover capital and depreciation?
Tom Smegal
executiveOkay. Also, just to note, regarding Slides 14 and 15. These slides haven't been altered at all, and we don't anticipate altering them unless something major happens with California regulation or we bring forward a new project. So on Slide 14, the capital spending targets you see there are tied to the California general rate case request. Nothing has changed other than the year-to-date figure being updated, and the same applies to the rate base. That rate base reflects the California general rate case request along with the rate base from our other states; and Marty, I'll hand it over to you for a summary.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAlright, thank you, Tom. So, where do things stand? To put it briefly, like Tom said, the unbilled change during the quarter was a significant factor. The market swings all of us have witnessed and endured across 2021 brought down the unrealized value of some retirement plan assets within our nonqualified plans, and those will rise and fall depending on shifts and turbulence in the market. Our underlying business is still solid while we wait on regulatory decisions in California. Those of you who've been with us for quite a while know this marks year three of the rate case process for us. For Cal Water, the California entity, this is consistently the toughest stretch within the 3-year cycle, since we're waiting on regulatory sign-off for our general rate case. That means regulatory lag is at its greatest right now, and while we wait, everyone's attention is on the commission as we work to settle the cost of capital and the 2021 general rate case. Management's attention stays on the drought — a major concern in California — plus we're heading into the peak summer period, August, September, and October, for fire season, and clearly dealing with supply chain disruptions. Then there's the matter of collecting receivables now from customers who are past due because they haven't paid their water bill in some time. Along with the general rate case, that makes for a very busy second half of 2022 for the company. Finally, to wrap up, I want to note that the growth opportunities the BD team has pursued remain robust, and I anticipate that continuing as we move through the second half of the year. With that, Polly, let's take questions.
Ben Kallo
analystPerhaps regarding — Tom, returning to your opening remarks about unbilled revenue and the projections you gave. Looking at Slide 15, my initial question might be whether you folks have considered providing yearly guidance across the entire range, possibly to help all of us understand better given the complexities of operating in California?
Tom Smegal
executiveWe have talked about that among ourselves. No decisions have been reached regarding offering yearly guidance. Of course, the thing to keep in mind with Slide 15 is that our company's earnings are tied to its rate base. What we're presenting there, then, is the projected regulated rate base for the whole corporation, covering California plus the remaining states, and the chance to generate a return on investment is what propels a business such as ours. Broadly speaking, as time goes on, we would anticipate achieving the approved return on the capital invested in rebates. That is what Slide 15 generally depicts.
Ben Kallo
analystFor '22, that works out to $1.95.
Tom Smegal
executiveSorry, no — that $1.95 figure refers to rate base of $1.95 billion.
Ben Kallo
analystAll right, got it. My apologies—I misread that. Then, Marty, regarding your CapEx deployment: you mentioned the company remains on track for this year, yet clearly there are plenty of risks out there. Could you walk us through how things have shifted relative to the prior quarter? I believe I may have posed this same question back then. Has the supply chain improved, held steady, or deteriorated?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAbsolutely, Ben. In many respects, I'd tell you it has deteriorated. It comes down to the lead times we're encountering when placing orders—what I refer to as capital inputs. That includes pipes, valves, and fittings. We recently wrapped up an internal study. While assembling that report during the past 2 weeks, we saw the lead time for ductile iron stretch from 8 to 12 weeks all the way to 26 weeks. So consider how many capital projects we undertake each year, plus the timeline for design, permitting, and then procurement. With that procurement step—preordering now happening that far ahead—there's genuine potential for it to hold us back somewhat. When I say hold us back, I simply mean capital will take more time to get into the ground, correct, particularly in California, where we operate under a prospective test year. Capital gets approved through the rate case, and after that our task is putting it into the ground. So in California we aren't a historical state or a prospective state. We're simply observing those timelines stretch out when ordering materials. As for what the team has been doing, they've started placing things out somewhat sooner. They've been broadening the supplier base; we've stocked up on items available today that we might not require today, but we know we'll require them within the next 6 months to 12 months. So the team truly has done a superb job keeping us on track. Still, it's a global supply chain problem, and getting materials in simply takes longer, water main especially. Our aim is to have 0 effect, though I'd say the likelihood of that is quite low, since the supply chain is becoming more constrained right now. Does that make sense?
Ben Kallo
analystThat answers it. Circling back to what it costs to raise capital — clearly, rates have moved since the paperwork went in. Does that play into the choice at all? Or could you all take another look at that, or not?
Tom Smegal
executiveBen, from the perspective of the regulatory process, that question is somewhat intriguing, and I don't want to sound evasive, but the figures provided in the original filing were essentially 2020 figures, reaching back to the close of that year regarding what the analysts fed into the input models. There were hearings, and there were briefs, and I'm confident that — these are public records, you could read them yourself — we attempted to point the commission toward the reality that after those figures were gathered, the rate environment and the market environment had in fact shifted quite drastically; whether to acknowledge that and issue a ruling reflecting the more recent figures rests with the administrative law judge and the 5 commissioners. They don't have an absolute duty to do so. One item, though, that the parties signed off on and that has existed as a tool in California for a long stretch of years, is a water cost of capital adjustment mechanism; thus, when examining a baseline period of the Moody's AA utility bond curve, should a shift exceeding 100 basis points in either direction occur, it sets off a change in return on equity equal to 50% of that; therefore a 100 basis point movement in the Moody's AA curve would move the cost of equity by 50 basis points. That said, there's a collar on it. Reach 99 basis points, and nothing changes. So it's — that mechanism exists for extreme situations. Comparing the current figures against the baseline, Moody's AA and what the market shows today, it looks like we're near the threshold for 2023; so if the commission simply kept the figures as they are and responded only through the cost of capital adjustment mechanism. It's possible we'd receive an increase from their authorized level to an amount 50 basis points greater for return on equity; even so, it's a 12-month weighted average. Consequently, it hinges heavily on what interest rates do across that whole span. It isn't a single moment; therefore we can't say whether it would activate for 2023. It appears more probable that activation would come for 2024, since rates — the immediate rate — now sit well above the trigger level, yet you'd require all those months of elevated rates for the weighted average to trip. So, having said all that, our hope is that the commission will act appropriately, review the recent data that's emerged, and ensure companies get a fair return on equity that makes sense given today's conditions.
Ben Kallo
analystThanks. For my final question — with energy utilities raising rates, I'm not sure whether that's happening everywhere you serve, but we certainly see plenty of coverage of it. What kind of effect does that have on you, say, in the context of your rate case? Does it enter the picture at all when commissioners argue that they can't approve an increase here since there would be one over there? And beyond that, how does it shape how ratepayers push back against your rate case?
Tom Smegal
executiveLet me begin with the mechanical side of things. As a reminder, in California, going back to the 1970s, water utilities have been permitted a tracker mechanism covering power costs, purchased water costs, and pump tax costs too. As a result, when electric power rates shift, there's no material financial effect on the company. It's basically a pass-through. When it comes to how the commission thinks about it, though, I'd say we're in something of a whip-soft predicament, which is curious. I went through the ratepayer advocate's brief regarding our rate case. Originally, at the time they filed their testimony back in January and February, they described the economy as terrible and painted a picture of everyone out of work and reacting to the pandemic. What they've said more recently concerns inflation and the effect of a very hot economy on our customers and on Californians generally. So clearly there's a populism element whenever you speak with an appointed or elected official — anyone representing the public. All told, electric power cost isn't the largest thing hitting the company. Relative to purchased water, employee wages, and similar items, it's likely our fifth or sixth biggest cost. So it's definitely something we consider when the commission reviews our rate cases, though we hope the process is somewhat more mechanistic. Marty, is there anything you'd like to add?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveRight. Tom, I was looking back over my years at Cal Water alongside you. Honestly, in all that time, I've never seen a commission treat something other than as an input cost of production. Then there's your wider point — that if they're increasing rates, you can't increase yours. That argument has never come up from the commission in my experience. It has consistently been an input cost for our production. Another thing I'd mention regarding affordability broadly: on Page 4, where our corporate strategic map sits, affordability is the very first item you'll notice. That's why we work hard to remain tightly focused on affordability and on what it means for our customers, folding in everything we do, those power input costs included. So during rate case planning, when we consider where we're heading over the next 3, 6, 9, 12 years, we attempt to factor affordability into our thinking; and I believe that has genuinely served us well, since the final piece of your question concerned customers who could intervene in our rate case. And — in the rate case we're in right now, we have a few intervening parties. There are 2 cities, and they've typically been engaged, though during the past few rate cases they've stayed fairly quiet. So — not many interveners are really pressing us on that affordability front. My sense is that this stems from our having managed a solid job of balancing it against the demands of expanding the rate base, the company's capital requirements, and the need to safeguard and advance water health and conservation across the state.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, Polly. I appreciate all of you being here today. Like we said, everyone's watching what California regulators are doing during fire season, plus how the collection rollout gets started in that state, and we can't wait to share an update with all of you once Q3 wraps up. I believe that'll be Tom — the next earnings call, at the close of October, is when we'll bring everyone up to speed. So thank you for being on the line. Stay safe. Take care, and we'll be in touch before long. Thanks a lot.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.