California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 27, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 54 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Healey

executive
#1

Appreciate that, Regina. Hello, everybody, and welcome to the third-quarter 2022 earnings call for California Water Service Group. Joining me on this call are Martin Kropelnicki, our President and CEO; Thomas Smegal, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; Paul Townsley, Vice President of Corporate Development; and Greg Milleman, Vice President of Rates and Regulatory Affairs. Details on the dial-in number for the replay are included in our Q3 earnings release, which came out earlier today. That replay can be accessed through 26 December 2022. Just a quick note before we get started: there's a slide deck that goes along with this quarter's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K this morning, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we dive into the quarter's results, we want to spend a few moments on forward-looking statements. Over the course of this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since these statements involve future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages all current shareholders, along with interested parties, to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures regarding risk and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports filed from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'm gonna hand things over to Tom to get us started.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#2

Thanks, David, and good morning, everyone — glad to have you on the call for our third-quarter results. Just so you know, each of our speakers today is going to walk through the slide deck by page number, so you can follow along, and my understanding is that on the webcast the slides will advance right along with us. I'll begin at page 5 of the deck to give a brief recap of the Q3 financials. The figures are right there: operating revenue rose $9.6 million, which works out to 3.7%. Operating expenses climbed $15.8 million, or 8.5%. Putting those two together, net income fell $6.5 million, or 10.5%, and earnings per share dropped $0.17, moving from $1.20 down to $1.03. One thing I want to call out on this page — and we'll come back to it — is that CapEx rose during the quarter, going from $69.2 million to $77.5 million. Likewise, on slide 6, where we show year-to-date results, net income is lower by $21.2 million on a year-to-date basis, which comes to $0.50 year to date in earnings per share cents. Now over to slide 7 for some color on the quarter. All year we've been discussing our unbilled revenue and the shifts in valuation of our non-qualified plan assets. This quarter, we actually saw our unbilled revenue accrual rise — mostly because that accrual was so low in the prior quarter, which we discussed at the time. Unbilled revenue did increase this quarter. That said, we're still seeing weakness in the mark-to-market valuation of our non-qualified plan assets, and that represented a $2 million change. As I said before, operating expenses were higher, driven mostly by inflationary pressures; we saw wage increases along with higher costs for goods and services. There were two items that are probably pretty noisy, and both showed up this quarter. Our uninsured loss expense was higher in the quarter — that's when someone gets hurt or files a claim against the company, and it tends to be somewhat volatile. We also raised the reserve for bad debt, and we'll get into that a bit later on the call, but that's an increase relative to Q3 of 2021. On a year-to-date basis, the majority of the variance in earnings really comes down again to the unbilled revenue and to the change in valuation of our non-qualified plan assets. Of the $21.2 million decline in net income attributable to CWSG, you can see a $9.4 million reduction in unbilled revenue and $11.4 million tied to the plan assets. As for the unbilled revenue, like we said last quarter, we expect it to normalize by year-end, with a year-over-year change of no more than ±2 million. We'll keep evaluating that as we move forward. One thing I really wanted to call out is that, for the year to date, our financing program has been performing really well. During Q3, we issued 470,000 shares, and over the last 12 months, we issued $2.2 million shares under our ATM programs, so we're very, very pleased with how that's gone. I won't spend time on the bridges, since they basically convey the same message I just gave, only in visual form. This morning on our call, we're going to spend a fair amount of time discussing regulatory affairs, especially in California. Starting on slide 11, I'll give you an update on the California cost of capital case. We received no update from the administrative law judge during the quarter. Anyone who joined our call last quarter knows the case was submitted in June. All parties finished their testimony, along with the briefs and reply briefs — all of that wrapped up in the summer — so now everyone is simply waiting for the administrative law judge to issue a proposed decision, after which the commission will issue a decision in the case. The calendar is getting somewhat tight at this point. A final decision from the CPUC this year remains possible, but for that to happen, we would need to see a proposed decision from the judge within essentially the next 2.5 weeks, since the commission's December voting meeting schedule is quite light because of the holidays; our expectation is that if a proposed decision arrived after 15 November, we would not receive a final decision in 2022; it's looking more and more likely that a cost of capital decision will land later than year-end. Given this delay in issuing a decision, I know many analysts have obviously been focused on interest rates rising in the economy since we submitted. How the commission will evaluate those changes, we can't determine. We know the testimony made in June did include some evidence of inflation and interest rate movements that had occurred up to that point, but how that might affect things, we're not certain. Nor are we certain about the impact of the potential water cost of capital adjustment mechanism and whether it would trigger, depending on how the case ultimately turns out. Just as a reminder, as we've been saying, given our financing program, the proposed cost of debt in our application was considerably lower than the last adopted cost of debt. What that means is that when the case is eventually decided and when the commission sets a starting date, at that point we will have roughly an $11 million reduction to the debt cost, and we expect that to be passed through to customers. What the timing is on the effective date of a decision, we don't yet know. No reserve has been established by the company for that figure, nor for any other sums tied to possible results stemming from the cost of capital proceeding. Now, I'll hand things over to Greg Milleman, who will cover slide 12 and provide our general rate case update.

Greg Milleman

executive
#3

Thanks, Tom. There's plenty visible on the slide already, but yes — we settled with the public advocate's office, mainly around items unrelated to revenue, and that filing went to the commission. The matter now sits with the ALJ, who will draft the decision, though getting it back before this year closes isn't likely. Given that timing, we intend to submit a request for interim rates during the fourth quarter, with an effective date of January 2023. Refunds could apply to those rates, and they'll be reconciled once the decision's final outcome is known. Turning to slide 13, where decoupling is the focus: beginning in 2023, Cal Water faces a major shift — the RAM, the mechanism tying sales to revenue, goes away. With that in mind, our agreement with public advocates lowers how much our revenue swings and includes sensible water production cost assumptions. Also, should drought conditions continue, the Commission has a tool letting utilities lacking RAMs record revenues lost to drought in a memorandum account, which may be recovered later; we'll submit a filing to open one of those too, prior to year-end. With that, Martin, over to you.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#4

Okay, thank you, Greg. For those of you tracking the documents, I'm looking at the end of page 13. One major development we had on the final day of the quarter, which was September 30, involved Governor Newsom putting his signature on California Senate Bill 1469. That legislation moved through with almost no opposition, and we've spent the past couple of years working on it, so it represents a significant victory for the water sector in California. This bill stops short of requiring decoupling, but its language explicitly states that the legislature intends for Class A water corporations to have the ability to put revenue adjustment mechanisms in place, allowing for complete decoupling between sales and revenue as a way to encourage conservation.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#5

For the past couple of years, we put in effort on this legislation alongside the other water companies — the investor-owned ones here in California. It was great to watch the governor put his signature on it and make it law. Then, quite soon after that — actually, on the 21st of last week — the CPUC submitted a motion to the Supreme Court of California asking to throw out the lawsuit that we had brought.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#6

This is all about decoupling, and there's a subtle point involved. The lawsuit submitted to the Supreme Court of California wasn't really regarding the ultimate choice to do away with the decoupling pilot program; it was actually regarding the absence of due process — the commission failed to adhere to its own procedures in reaching that determination; that, naturally, hurt us, or we lacked the chance to place sufficient information into the record so the commission could reach a proper ruling on decoupling. There's a subtle point at this stage — I continue to think the Supreme Court of California case will proceed, given that the court did accept the foundation of our argument, which is the absence of due process. Even though the CPUC did submit a motion to dismiss, so we are replying to that — based on where things stand at present, I think the court case will keep moving forward founded on the initial filing, which is the absence of due process. A major victory in the state legislature with Senate Bill 1469. We're pressing on with the court case in the Supreme Court of California concerning the absence of due process. Turning to the following page, page 14, to discuss the drought. Let's begin by discussing the left-hand portion of the slide, where we stand with our memo account. As you may recall, during 2021, the governor proclaimed a drought emergency. That let us set up a memo account to monitor incremental costs tied to our drought response. These are efforts we're undertaking over and above what's contained in our present rate case to address the drought. During Q3, our incremental drought expenditures came to roughly $400,000. They get expensed in the period; they go into the memo account. Our cumulative total in that memo account since it began in 2021 is roughly $1.4 million — so $1.4 million of drought-related items that we've expensed during the current period that we'll pursue future recovery on at a later date. Turning to the right-hand portion of the slide, conservation is working, and this is why we believe decoupling is truly, truly important. In California, customer usage declined roughly 19% in Q3 relative to our adopted numbers; that's a decline of roughly 7% relative to 2021. Earlier this week, we submitted our numbers to the state of California, which we must file each month. Average consumption dropped roughly 10% during the month of September by itself. That's the average figure — I want to give you a sense of the variance, though, among some of the districts that achieved large savings. Westlake, in Southern California, saw consumption drop 36.6% during the month of September. Palos Verdes, which lies south of Westlake on the L.A. peninsula, saw consumption drop 25% during the month of September. Los Altos, which is just down the street from us here in Silicon Valley, saw consumption drop 26% during the month of September by itself. So once more, that's the reason we feel decoupling matters so much — that second bullet — because of the consumption drops we've experienced and because of our drought response program, the amount sitting in our decoupling account has reached $94.8 million. We'll refile at some later point to recover it. If you look at what NOAA is projecting for fall and winter, and we are now officially in fall, they're calling for La Niña conditions, and that usually brings warmer weather our way, meaning less snow and possibly less rain. Naturally, we'll take a close look at how winter goes between now and our earnings announcement at the end of February. We're hoping for a wet winter, but the maps suggest otherwise. Once again, that's the reason these decoupling mechanisms matter so much, since they let us push conservation hard for our customers and help guarantee our water supply stays resilient. As for the ongoing drought conditions as we head into 2023, our expectation is that they'll persist, and once more, with climate change in the picture, decoupling really matters, water resilience really matters — so if you go through our ESG reports, we'll stay on the course we're on to encourage conservation and ensure a resilient supply for years ahead. Moving to the next slide, 15, to discuss the capital program. In spite of many headwinds, many economic headwinds, our capital program is still mostly on track. Our capital investment program, which we also refer to as our infrastructure improvement program, grew 12% year-over-year. Year to date, our capital investment has risen 6.9%. We're pleased with the progress, though of course, as we contend with supply chain headwinds the way all of us are right now, the longer those headwinds last, the greater the chance they'll eventually begin to hit us; we keep watching the supply chains, and the procurement team here at Cal Water, along with the engineering team, has done a fantastic job pivoting and bending and turning and coming up with new approaches to stay ahead of supply chain problems. Ductile iron pipe especially. Getting ductile iron pipe now takes a 12-month lead time, and when you've got a large main replacement program, that begins to create some difficulties. We keep searching for places where we can lower risk in our supply chain, among them the possibility of stockpiling raw materials used in our capital production process and holding those for future days and future weeks and future projects ahead. As we enter Q4, just a reminder to everybody, weather can hurt construction activity, but given the La Niña conditions, I believe we'll have a pretty solid Q4 on the capital investment side. I'll pass it to Tom for an update on the customer COVID debt updates.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#7

Thanks, Martin. At the close of Q2, as you may remember, we told you we had at last received approval from the California Public Utilities Commission, along with the governor, to begin the process of disconnecting customers who hadn't paid. Keep in mind that throughout the COVID pandemic, from March of 2020 until the summer, we were prohibited from cutting anyone's service. We did receive California state aid last year that covered a number of customer bills, which brought down how many delinquent accounts there were. Even so, dealing with the remaining accounts that are 90 days delinquent is still going to take us months — perhaps many months. That process is underway right now, having started late this summer, and we did achieve some success during the quarter, bringing the balance that is 90 days past due down by $3.5 million. For us, that represents an important step and a good sign for our program. When we compare our Q3 of 2022 with the Q3 of 2021, though, in that quarter a year ago we had recorded the state aid, and as a result, customer delinquency balances fell dramatically in the Q3 of 2021 — which explains why you're seeing a higher bad debt reserve this year. We're quite encouraged by the collection program we now have running. We expect that to keep going and to speed up as we move into the Q4 and then into the Q1 of 2023, and we're looking forward to discussing next year just how successful we've been at lowering that bad debt balance. Now, I'd like to hand things over to Paul Townsley for a business development update.

Paul Townsley

executive
#8

Thanks, Tom. I've moved to the following slide, and it's an exciting one because we keep up a really fast tempo when it comes to buying utilities; right now there are 10 deals announced and moving forward. On this slide you can see that during this year we've announced five new deals. Those are the Camino Real Utility Company, the Kaupuni South Shore Community Services — also called KSSCS — located on Kauai in Hawaii, the Monterey Water Company in New Mexico, the Bethel Green Acres System in Washington, plus the Strohs Water System, which is in Washington as well. Beyond those five, three additional deals have already received approval from the state public utility commissions in their respective states, and we are now in the last stages of closing; those are HOH Utilities, in Hawaii once more, Keauhou Wastewater on the Big Island in Hawaii, and the Skylonda Water System in California. Looking at the slide, you'll notice that so far this year we have closed two deals. Those are the Animas Valley system, which is also known as Morningstar Water in New Mexico, along with the Railyard Utility in Texas. Taken all together, these represent as many as 8,600 new water connections and roughly 10,000 new wastewater connections that are in process during this year. As you're able to see, we are expanding in every state where we have utilities, and our recent arrival in the State of Texas already appears very promising when it comes to growth. Last of all, our pipeline for acquisitions stays robust, and we expect opportunities to keep coming next year. With that, Tom, I'll turn it back over to you.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#9

Appreciate that, Paul. As we always do, the slide deck for this quarter contains the forecast and the trajectory for our capital expenditures along with our rate base. To repeat, those yellow bars appearing on slides 18 and 19 show what we submitted in the California general rate case. Naturally, since that proceeding remains open and there's no settlement regarding CapEx in it, we currently lack any method to revise those figures toward whatever the commission could approve. Here I am presenting and reflecting the $222 million of CapEx on a year-to-date basis across all our systems during 2022. Martin, I'll turn things over to you so you can close us out.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#10

Alright, thank you, Tom. To wrap things up, the third quarter came in essentially where we had anticipated internally. Of course, inflation isn’t something we can avoid — all of us are feeling it — and we’re noticing inflationary pressure starting to show up in our P&L. When you combine that with the regulatory lag that typically shows up in year three of a rate case, it’s definitely having an impact on our profitability. Still, we’re delivering in line with our budget, so we’re quite pleased with where things stand for Q3. As for the market headwinds, we anticipate those will persist. Like what’s stated in the press release and like Tom said, we do hold certain plan assets tied to the non-qualified retirement plan. Even though those changes are recorded below the line, we’re still obligated to assess and value those assets each quarter, and it runs through below the line on our P&L. There’s no buying or selling of assets involved — it’s simply the fluctuation in asset value due to the volatility we’re seeing in the market. We expect that will carry on into 2023 as we navigate some of these tough economic headwinds. So as we move into Q4 and into 2023, what will we be concentrating on? Clearly, wrapping up the cost of capital and general rate case are at the top; those are two extremely important proceedings for us and they impact our largest book of business, which is our California utility. Like I said before, we expect the drought to persist into 2023, and our robust drought response along with handling supply chain challenges again — the team has done an excellent job on the supply chain front — but the longer these headwinds last, the more probable it becomes that they’ll begin to impact us at some point down the road. Additionally, as Paul said, we want to keep executing on our growth plans and our business development pipeline. Even though all of us are grappling with the economic uncertainties surrounding us daily right now, our balance sheet has stayed solid. We have ample cash; we’ve been able to sustain our growth in our capital program as well as our business development pipeline, and we stay mission-driven, serving our customers and doing what we do best, which is being a water and wastewater utility. We’re entering Q4 strong, and we’ll enter 2023 strong despite all the headwinds we’re facing as a company. I’d like to take a moment and close on something a bit different for this quarter. I just want to highlight, I hope everyone saw the press release that we appointed Ms. Terry Bayer as our lead director. Terry is an exceptional leader, a seasoned executive, and she has served on the board since 2014. She took over as chair of our capital and investment committee back in September of 2019, and we put her forward as our lead director. She is simply a remarkable individual, and we feel extremely lucky to have somebody with Terry's abilities serving on the board. Her expertise in public health is substantial, and on top of that she holds a law degree from Stanford University. I'm hopeful each of you will have an opportunity to cross paths with Terry at some point down the road, since having her as our lead director is something we are truly, truly privileged about. And finally, this marks the last conference call for David Healey, who serves as our Vice President Corporate Controller. David will retire when December comes to an end, and he joined this organization more than 13 years back in the role of Director of Financial Reporting. He moved up to Corporate Controller, and after that he eventually advanced to Vice President Corporate Controller and principal accounting officer. For Cal Water, David has performed remarkably well, not only when it comes to financial reporting but in the area of tax strategy as well. Within the accounting profession, David belongs to that small group of people who excel both at taxes and at financial reporting. His absence will be felt deeply. Our plan is to share news of who will take David's place, we hope, before this year is over. David, I simply want to express my gratitude for everything you've contributed at Cal Water, and having you as part of our team has been a privilege.

David Healey

executive
#11

You're welcome. It's been a blast.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#12

With that, Regina, we will open up the line for questions, please.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#13

Thank you. There's a lot to cover, though perhaps I should begin with taxes, since you brought them up. It looks like there's been a fairly big jump in income taxes on a year-to-date basis — I believe it's around $3 million. Is that purely a timing issue, or is some kind of true-up taking place in Q4?

David Healey

executive
#14

I'll take that one. This is David B. Healey. As you may remember, when the corporate income tax rate dropped to 21% in 2017, the way utilities deal with that is the decrease gets shifted into a long-term liability and given back to ratepayers.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#15

All right.

David Healey

executive
#16

What matters here is the schedule on which money gets returned to those who pay rates. The amounts sent back to our ratepayers for 2018 and 2019 were disbursed over the course of 2021 and 2022. During 2022, the total came in at $4 million below what had been returned across 2021, and that gap is the reason behind the $4 million drop. This feeds into how we figure our effective tax rate, and that is the source of the effect.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#17

So is that a drop? Since basically what we're looking at here is a rise in operating cost, isn't it — what exactly is it?

David Healey

executive
#18

Yes, that's correct.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#19

All right.

David Healey

executive
#20

In terms of how tax refunds get booked, you'll see them come through as a decrease in income tax expense.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#21

Understood.

David Healey

executive
#22

The cutback is larger during 2021 compared with 2022.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#23

Got it. Is it reasonable to expect that $4 million difference compared with a year earlier to continue all the way to the end of the year?

David Healey

executive
#24

That's right.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#25

And then some.

David Healey

executive
#26

That pattern is going to keep going until the year wraps up, after which it levels off across the following 3 years.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#27

All right.

David Healey

executive
#28

It was simply a small amount of making up for prior periods. That making up related to 2018 along with 2019.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#29

Yeah.

David Healey

executive
#30

That applied solely during 2021 and 2022.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#31

All right. Got it. That's great. And then second, once more, since I'm simply reviewing how the numbers compare against last year, there appears to be a fairly significant rise in costs outside the regulated category. My guess is that part of that relates to those losses without insurance coverage. Once more, it's roughly a $10 million jump for the year so far, again, versus the prior year. Could you walk through what's driving that?

David Healey

executive
#32

Yeah.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#33

For what reason?

David Healey

executive
#34

The unrealized loss tied to the investments in our non-qualified pension plan — that's what we're talking about here. Non-regulated expenses are where it gets recorded, and that is the driver behind the change.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#35

All right, got it.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#36

That is the market-to-market figure. Right. Right.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#37

Yes. All right. That works for me. I get that one. All right. Turning to the regulatory cases that haven't been resolved yet. The GRC — given the inflation you're seeing in your cost structure, how much of that has already been captured in it, in the pending GRC? And is there a mechanism to essentially true up some of those costs you're experiencing before the final ruling comes out?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#38

That's a great question. Greg, do you want to take a first crack at that, about how we incorporate new inflation into the GRC process?

Greg Milleman

executive
#39

Sure thing. Within the settlement and the items that aren't in dispute, we asked the commission that when the proposed decision comes out, it incorporate the latest inflation factors across all of our expenses. That's the method we'd use to handle the inflation increase happening at present, dating back to when we submitted the case in July 2021.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#40

Angie, since—

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#41

An update is still pending. I truly apologize that you’re going to submit an update prior to the proposed decision coming out.

Greg Milleman

executive
#42

No.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#43

At the time, I think, Go ahead, Greg. Sorry.

Greg Milleman

executive
#44

I was about to make that point.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#45

All right.

Greg Milleman

executive
#46

When we submitted the filing, we projected the inflation rate for 2023.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#47

Okay.

Greg Milleman

executive
#48

That has significantly changed.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#49

Yes.

Greg Milleman

executive
#50

Within our initial submission, we included one particular ask, and public advocates haven't challenged it, which states that at the moment the Commission issues its proposed decision, they'll revise every expense using whatever inflation figures are most up to date at that point.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#51

Okay. I understand.

Greg Milleman

executive
#52

Okay.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#53

All right.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#54

One more point worth noting there, Angie, which Greg left out: keep in mind that here in California, the GRC includes escalation increases during year two and year three, and those increases also fold in the latest inflation factors. Meanwhile, Greg is discussing how that gets built into the 2023 calculations.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#55

All right.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#56

Regarding rates, there's also 2024, and possibly 2025, should this elevated inflation persist.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#57

Got it. Alright. Let's turn to the cost of capital proceeding. I realize there's a hold-up. Sure, a hold-up exists, but is there actually a dispute over when the new cost of capital takes effect? It seemed fairly clear to me that the date is 1 January 2022, and it doesn't hinge on precisely when the final decision lands, no, essentially the review window runs 1 January 2022 through 31 December 2024, correct?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#58

That's a good question. You also need to consider what's happening with the California energy cost of capital and the case pending there, what's unfolding with the proposed decision from the administrative law judge and the alternate proposed decision of the President of the Commission. The problem we face, and the reason we aren't recording the rate liability tied to the lower cost of debt, is that the procedural steps the Commission would ordinarily take to make sure rates could be applied retroactively haven't been completed. No filing was made for interim rates. There's no memorandum account tracking interim rates. Those represent the standard procedural processes that would let the Commission reach back in time. That's where things stand in the process at the moment. We're still waiting to learn what that decision says. Clearly we'll respond to whatever that decision ultimately states, but we have no evidence either way right now. We're clearly disclosing the amount in case it does go back, and you have that in the slide deck, and it's in the 10-Q as well.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#59

All right. So I follow that $11 million tied to cheaper debt costs, but it looks like you're putting out equity fairly often. So by the close of the year, what equity layer do you anticipate at the subsidiary — the California subsidiary? And should this cost of capital case bring the permitted equity layer down to match what that year-end figure turns out to be, how much revenue would that cut?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#60

Greg — no, wait, Angie, apologies for that. I don't believe we've run the numbers on the revenue decrease that would come from accepting the ratepayer advocate's stance. From what I gather, it amounts to several million more.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#61

Yeah.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#62

That could come out of the return. On the first part of your question, if you look at the financials in the 10-Q, I think within California we're at roughly 50/50 right now in terms of our current equity capital structure. You'd probably say that's actually as high as, or even higher than, what the commission staff recommended. Obviously, there's a chance at any point for comments on the decision — whenever we get a proposed decision, that'll certainly be something we comment on: look, they said our capital structure was under 50%, and in fact it's already at 50% as of whenever that date comes out. With the ATM program, we expect that to keep rising. Obviously, we have a plan to reach 53.4% equity, and we've expressed that plan to the commission — the staff is just entirely relying on a historical evaluation, which we don't believe is appropriate right now.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#63

Great. All right, thanks. I've got lots more to ask, but I'll give other people a chance. Thank you.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#64

All right, thanks.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#65

Morning, everyone, and thanks for fielding my question. I was just curious whether you might have any sense of whether the ALJ is in the process of writing up the PD right now. Or could there be other prominent matters that are still lined up ahead of it on the docket?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#66

Honestly, Jonathan, that's a tough one to answer. At the commission, the administrative law judges operate independently. For anybody who isn't aware, I spent a good while as the head of regulatory at Cal Water and dealt with the commission even earlier than that. I can say with some comfort that I understand a bit about the way ALJs function. You would need to check which other matters this specific ALJ is handling. After that, you would need to judge whether it's the sort of thing where, as the saying goes, you'd have to be a fly on the wall to really grasp it. My understanding is that Commissioner Houck has this case. Is she tied up with other matters that are preventing her from assisting the judge in getting a decision out in this case? I don't believe any of us has the answer to those questions right now. The energy cost to capital case is clearly one data point that could shape how they see our case, in certain ways. Still, my understanding is that's a separate judge, and I'm aware that's a separate commissioner. I'm not sure that would block this case from moving ahead.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#67

All right. Yeah, no, I'm familiar with every detail and was figuring you folks might have the answer, since putting that puzzle together is definitely tougher for me.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#68

You know, I believe, circling back to what Angie asked, the business would be quite grateful if the commission would issue at minimum a proposed decision prior to when we must put out earnings in February of next year, so we'd simply have some direction regarding that matter of the effective date. I realize plenty of people simply presume that effective date goes all the way back to the beginning, and at this stage we aren't persuaded of that. You know, I think we'd prefer to have that response recorded, at least when it comes to a PD. I think that would be extremely beneficial for us.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#69

Yeah, my strong expectation is that a PD arrives by February.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#70

Yeah, that's what we're hoping for as well.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#71

All right, regarding that decoupling law that got through — does it state that the ask has to come within something like a GRC, or might it be put forward as its own separate item, whether from Cal Water alone or from every utility jointly?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#72

Yes, my understanding is the legislation says it gets addressed in the upcoming GRC submission, Jonathan.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#73

Greg might have some insight into that. Greg, you're still on the call, right?

Greg Milleman

executive
#74

Correct. In fact, it calls for a GRC filing either at our upcoming GRC or through an application between GRCs, provided the company and the Commission both agree. We do have a chance to submit something ahead of our 2024 GRC.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#75

All right. So, I suppose, have you folks put together some kind of plan around that? Is it like, you know, hold off and watch how that Supreme Court matter, you know, sort of unfolds, or, you know, could you possibly take that different path of, you know, asking for it in the meantime?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#76

Well, I mean, go ahead, Greg. I'll let you go first.

Greg Milleman

executive
#77

Oh, I was just going to mention, Jonathan, what we plan to do beginning in 2023 is assemble our justification for asking again for decoupling, which we would either submit in our 2024 GRC — that's July — or decide based on how matters develop with the Supreme Court or other businesses, if we want to attempt filing it sooner by way of an application. But actually, no decision has been reached yet on when we would file it.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#78

All right.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#79

Jonathan, what matters most in this situation, I believe, is this: go back to that ruling that eliminated the decoupling — in that instance, no chance existed for us to present any testimony of an evidentiary nature. In that case, the commission basically ran right over us. Filing something lacking solid backing regarding just how well the program works and has worked is not something we want to rush into. That's the reason a filing probably won't happen from us next week. As Greg mentioned, some time will be devoted to preparing our testimony, ensuring every fact is in order prior to releasing it.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#80

Absolutely. Our attention is very much on that state Supreme Court matter — the likelihood of them agreeing to hear it stood at 1%, yet they took it on. What they're weighing is whether due process was lacking on the merits. I believe we want to dig into that somewhat, to gauge how the state Supreme Court will approach and assess it.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#81

Yeah. So what's the rough timeline for a ruling from the Supreme Court at this point? Does a Statutory timeframe exist? And also, if they conclude that your due process rights got violated, does that simply wipe out the commission's order, meaning decoupling comes right back automatically, or what precisely are the consequences should the Supreme Court decide in your favor?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#82

Well, it's the state Supreme Court, so I doubt they're bound to a fixed schedule as such. I mean, there was an application process we had to complete that needed review, after that they had to take up the case, and then oral arguments will happen at some point, ideally during Q1. My sense is they usually act pretty fast. As for what comes afterward, that's a fair question and I don't believe we have the answer, since I don't think many water cases have come before the state Supreme Court. My sense is we're somewhat in uncharted territory. It's possible they invalidate the commission's decision and remand it to them; they might state, "This isn't binding, you need to revisit that specific case to establish evidence in the record." I think we're sort of in a new zone here. Once again, we're quite pleased the state Supreme Court accepted the case based on our argument, which was a lack of due process.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#83

Okay, fine. Yeah, best of luck.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#84

Yeah, when I look at the legislative victory plus the state picking up the case, I'd say momentum has been strong for us on this matter. Like I told the Governor and his office, it ought to strike them as somewhat odd that a publicly traded firm, or a group of publicly traded firms, would phone up and request, "Please limit how much we can earn," since that's precisely what decoupling accomplishes. Consider the specific conditions we face here in California, with the drought and climate change problems. In my own view, it's somewhat ridiculous to imagine we'd abandon decoupling while dealing with this terrible drought; it simply isn't logical for the ratepayer, it isn't logical for us, and so on. We've held our ground on decoupling, since it's the correct policy stance for us to take in order to serve California and the customers we have there.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#85

OK. Clearly, you know, the commission has seen some changes in personnel since that...

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#86

Correct.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#87

... regarding that other order that came down initially, is there any indication of how the newer commissioners view decoupling?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#88

Nothing so far. What I mean is, when we mention the new paradigm on the slide, that's essentially what we're referring to. As you know, the commission has remained mostly remote, still operating somewhat in pandemic mode. Opportunities for in-person interaction have been fairly restricted, and naturally there are rules governing that—ex parte rules preventing us from discussing an active case with a commissioner, you know. We are beginning to get somewhat more in-person interaction with a few of the commissioners, which is a positive thing. Again, as you know, we are barred from discussing the active cases currently open.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#89

Okay. All right. Well, yes, I wish you success in getting that reinstated. I mean, from many directions it really does appear as though momentum is building, so good luck with all of that.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#90

Thank you.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#91

I appreciate you taking the time to be with us today.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#92

Very well, Jonathan. I'm grateful to you.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#93

Jonathan, thank you.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#94

Thanks so much. I'm being insistent today. In any case, just a few more items. Regarding unbilled revenue, you said that you expect some catch-up to occur prior to the conclusion of the year. Should I take it that Q4 earnings will see a significant gain tied to those shifts in the unbilled revenues balance?

Thomas Smegal

executive
#95

Here's how I'd frame it. When you consider Q4 of 2021, we had that massive.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#96

Okay.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#97

There was a buildup of unbilled revenue during Q2 and Q3, which then fell back to a typical level by year-end. This year, our peak unbilled revenue is significantly lower, and that hurt us in Q2. We still anticipate — and we've said this — that unbilled revenue will return to a typical level by the end of the year. What I'm getting at is that we'd anticipate a smaller drop in unbilled revenue in Q4 of 2022 versus Q4 of 2021. I believe the response to what you asked is yes.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#98

All right. I don't want to seem overly particular, but let's revisit the P&L for a moment. My earlier question concerned non-regulated expenses, but what I actually want to ask about now is the remaining pieces of net periodic benefit credits, which have risen roughly $4 million on a year-to-date basis versus the prior year. Could you walk me through what that represents?

David Healey

executive
#99

Our defined pension plan is valued using the spot rate method, and adopting that approach has produced a bigger credit. To explain what this line is: pension plans carry a service cost along with a non-service cost. What you're seeing is the movement in the non-service cost.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#100

I should note as well that we track both the service and non-service portions of California pension expense within a balancing account in that state.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#101

Alright.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#102

Thomas Smecal here: most of what we do — and this has no impact on net income, since there's a—

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#103

Alright.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#104

Thomas Smecal here: the balancing account produces an offsetting effect on revenue.

David Healey

executive
#105

Correct.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#106

Got it.

David Healey

executive
#107

Only the smaller portion is located outside California.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#108

All right. To wrap up on the cost of capital proceeding, my understanding is that you're pulling certain takeaways from the 2022 cost of capital for electrics or for energy companies. Granted, that concerned only the cost of capital adjustment mechanism, not a cost of capital review, which for them applies solely to 2023 and later. I'm not really sure there's much of a read through here. Second, you noted there's some uncertainty regarding the step up — the ROE step up tied to the adjustment mechanism, which by every account got triggered for water utilities at the end of September. Particularly on that second point, my understanding is that you folks need to file in order for this increase to take effect. I haven't come across the filing. Tell me how that affects precisely when this 50 basis points step up would take effect.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#109

Sure. Let's walk through a few items. First off, the way I understand it — and forgive me if I've got this wrong — in the energy capital case, it isn't determinative, but it's simply a sort of illustration of what the commission's thinking looks like. Two decisions exist out there: the administrative law judge decision, and then the alternate put forward by President John Reynolds. What President John Reynolds offered as the alternative matches your description — it just prevents the mechanism from being activated. To my mind, the crucial difference between the two decisions on the table comes down to whether a complete examination of the 2022 cost of capital would be undertaken, in the sense of a full review. That is the unresolved matter I had in mind. According to President Reynolds, there is no going back — that struck me as notable. Whether it helps our case is uncertain; it could prove useful, or it might not, and the outcome for energy and for water could differ. As for triggering, the difficulty is that no proposed decision exists, which leaves us unable to submit a filing. No ruling or determination exists requiring us to submit that adjustment request. There's simply no base figure to modify, and no approved ruling instructs us to make such a submission. My expectation is that should the commission issue both a proposed and a final decision stating, "This is your cost of capital for 2022," that rate order would permit us to seek the 2023 adjustment. Clearly, that wouldn't get submitted during October or November, which is when it typically goes in, since those two months will already be behind us once the commission hands down its decision. Usually when a deadline for a triggered advice letter filing gets missed in situations like this, they permit it to be submitted afterward. So picture this kind of situation: let's say, okay, assume a cost of capital for 2022 gets set by them, and that takes place around January 15 or thereabouts — most likely the final decision will contain a clause saying the companies need to hand in the triggered cost of capital for 2023, whether as part of that same submission or at a later point. That's something we would catch. Now, bear in mind that several analysts have floated the idea that the commission could take whatever information it may have triggered and simply apply a broad modification to the cost of equity, claiming that even though both sides consented to the adjustment, they've basically waved their hands and folded that adjustment into whatever they end up deciding. That's the reason we're uncertain — we have no idea how the commission will respond to its own postponement.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#110

So the sole distinction would be that the adjustment becomes effective — at least in theory — on 1 January 2023, while the cost of capital review, meaning a modification to every element of the cost of capital, happened on 1 January 2022, correct? Yet I get the argument you're making: there's no guarantee regarding precisely when this takes effect.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#111

Correct. We can't be certain how the commission will respond to the fresh data concerning shifts, the altered economic landscape — that's the essence of it. We simply have no idea what they'll put in their decision. I don't want to talk over Greg; I'm aware Greg is an expert on this too. Greg, should you have any further thoughts on the matter, I'd be glad to hear them as well.

Greg Milleman

executive
#112

No, Tom, you've addressed all the issues.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#113

All right.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#114

Those are exactly the points I would have raised as well.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#115

Appreciate it.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#116

All right, thanks everyone. Much appreciated.

Thomas Smegal

executive
#117

All right, thank you.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#118

All right, it’s good to have you with us on what’s a pleasant autumn day. We’re eager to share our results for the end of the year with all of you at the close of February. Until then, stay safe, and we appreciate it. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#119

Everyone, that brings us to the end of today's call. Thanks to each of you for being here. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.