California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 2, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Tom Scanlon
executiveThank you, Mandy. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to California Water Service Group's call covering 2022 annual and fourth quarter results. Joining me is Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our President and CEO; Tom Smegal, our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; and Greg Milleman, our Vice President of Rates and Regulatory Affairs. Details on the replay dial-in can be located in the year-end earnings release put out earlier today. That replay will remain accessible through May 1, 2023. One thing to note before we get started: for this quarter's earnings call, the company has a slide deck to go along with it. That deck was furnished with an 8-K yesterday afternoon, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwater.com. Before we dive into this year's results, we'd like to spend a few minutes addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since such statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages all current shareholders and interested parties alike to carefully read and understand the disclosures regarding risks and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports we file from time-to-time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Let me begin by drawing attention to Note 16 in the Form 10-K the company filed yesterday. In the fourth quarter of 2022, the company identified an immaterial error involving a regulatory liability, along with corresponding decreases to operating revenue and deferred income taxes, that had not been recorded in 2019. This relates to customer refunds. Customer billings and cash refunded to customers are unaffected by the error. Through a restatement of an opening retained earnings balance to the year ended December 31, 2020, the company corrected this error in the financial statements. Please refer to the File 10-K for further details. Now I'll hand things over to Tom Smegal.
Tom Smegal
executiveThank you, Tom Scanlon, and good morning to all of you. As is my customary practice, I'll take you through the results for our full year and for the fourth quarter. I'll begin on Page five of the slide deck, where you'll find a table showing our financial results. If we look at the bottom of that table, EPS for the year moved from $1.96 in 2021 down to $1.77 in 2022, which works out to a decrease of $0.19, while net income attributable to California Water Service Group fell by 5.1 million, or 5.1%. On capital investments, I do want to call attention to this — we'll touch on it somewhat during today's call — those rose $34.6 million, reaching a new record of 327.8 million of CapEx for the year. To try to characterize the full year financial results, moving to the next page, keep in mind that the major factor affecting the year was an $11 million negative unrealized change in the valuation of our non-qualified retirement plan assets; that was the year's big impact, and of course, it's also the third-year of the California General Rate cycle. And normally during that third year, what we observe is that rate increases fail to keep pace with the growth in operating expenses; that was definitely true here in 2022. Let me then move to the next slide and discuss the fourth quarter on Slide seven; during the fourth quarter, we did see — and I know during the first three quarters of the year we discussed our unbilled revenue — we simply see that unbilled revenue came bouncing right back up to where we had anticipated it would be, as we had talked about, and so the quarter came in much better than the fourth quarter of 2021. EPS for the quarter was $0.35 per share, versus $0.07 per share in 2021. And net income for the quarter in '22 was 19.6 million, which is an increase of 16.1 million; so as I mentioned, flipping to Slide eight, the main driver there was the reversal of the unbilled revenue, and you saw that we had an increase of 11.1. And for the year overall, we had an increase of roughly $1.7 million in unbilled revenue. It's fairly typical for us to land anywhere from positive a million, or two to negative a million or two, and that usually washes out with that factor; we did again, for the quarter <<inaudible>> higher operating expenses for a variety of reasons; and we continue to see a bit of general rate increase tied to that GRC step increase that we received at the first of the year in 2022. The bridges describe those items that I just mentioned, and I'll leave those for you to look at. Again, the big factors on the year is the mark-to-market the big factor on the quarter is the increase in the unbilled getting that back to normal. So we have a lot of regulatory matters to report on. Greg Milleman is joining us now. I'll kick things off by turning to Greg to discuss the California cost of capital case.
Greg Milleman
executiveAppreciate that, Tom. Turning to Page 11, we went over what California's cost of capital runs. Honestly, there isn't a great deal to share beyond what came out in the prior quarterly report. We haven't heard anything fresh from the Commission. Based on where things stand right now with that commission process, the soonest a final decision could land would be April of 23. With that, I'll hand things back over to you, Tom Smegal.
Tom Smegal
executiveThank you. Thank you, Greg. And owing to the holdup in putting out a ruling, our company is unable to figure out if the commission is taking into account shifts in market conditions, or some other rationale for examining the cost of capital across such an extended period. So honestly, we cannot state where these cases stand regarding timing, as Greg pointed out, or regarding the result. And as we have discussed regarding that third bullet on Slide 11. Because our financing program has succeeded, we are aware that a reduced cost of debt was included in the application, and we still do not know if the commission might apply retroactivity to whatever cost of capital decision is ultimately reached. We have observed, and we have discussed, several items that cause us to reach the conclusion that this is not probable, based on the facts and circumstances currently before us. However, should the commission decide to reach back to the start of '22, our expectation is that the decrease in cost of debt by itself would amount to an $11 million yearly unfavorable effect on the company. Yet that would be booked in whatever current period, at the time we do receive a final ruling from the Commission, should they choose retroactivity. Greg, I'll hand it back to you for the rate case update.
Greg Milleman
executiveAlright, turning to Slide 12, that's where we have the update on the California general rate case. The decision, as of right now, is running 2 months behind schedule. We don't have any fresh information about when a proposed decision might appear; that said, because it's delayed, we've set up interim rate memo accounts, which let us monitor the gap between the rates in effect now and the final rates that result from the decision, which will take effect — or which is effective — as of January 1, 2023. On top of that, we got the green light to raise rates across most of our districts by 4%. That increase kicks in beginning April 15, 2023. Now on Slide 13, focusing on the coupling. Just a reminder that as this year got underway, decoupling no longer applies to us. That means we're returning to how things were before 2008. There will be annual — since decoupling is gone, you'll get annual variability in sales and production, in the water sales revenues along with the production costs; but we saw that coming. So as a way to soften the impact in our 2021 rate case, we tackled it mainly by shifting more recovery of fixed costs into the fix service charge — moving a larger share of our revenue to the fix service charge. And then also, we went with more realistic water mix sources — water mix drawn from a range of sources — to get more realistic water production costs. And I'll hand it over to you now, Marty.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, thank you, Greg. Like we discussed during the previous earnings call, data from Q3, Governor Newsom put his signature on a brand-new statute in California on September 30, which requests that the CPUC take another look at decoupling — and that represented a major victory for the water sector across the state of California. Not long after the Governor signed that statute, the California Public Utilities Commission submitted a motion seeking dismissal of our case before the California Supreme Court. Their argument was that it had become null and void because of the newly signed statute from the Governor. We don't agree with that position. I'm delighted to share that the courts rejected the CPUC's motion to dismiss, so our case continues before the California Supreme Court here in Q1 of 2023. That case has been completely briefed. And we expect to have oral arguments in front of the State Supreme Court no later than the middle of this year. So that litigation is proceeding. I believe every signal points in a positive direction; and we're eager to have our conversation with the courts at some point in the coming quarter or so. Greg, would you like to walk through that California tracker status for 2023 regarding the delayed rate case?
Greg Milleman
executiveSure. Thank you. If you turn to Slide 14, you'll find several mechanisms—or trackers—that the Commission permits for monitoring loss revenues and expenses, and each one takes effect in January 2023. With the exception of two, none can be figured out before the 2021 rate case reaches its conclusion. Moreover, the final commission decision establishes the component parts and pieces. For the first two items, though—the incremental cost balancing account along with the conservation balancing account—we reached a settlement with Public Advocates in this case regarding their component parts, which means we can calculate them at this point. As for the remaining mechanisms, we won't be able to actually calculate them until we receive the final commission decision, though the mechanisms themselves aren't being disputed. I think it's your turn now, Marty?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveYeah, thanks. I'd like to provide a brief status report regarding the drought that everybody's been tracking, especially with those storms during Q1 of 2023. It was a wet and wild winter in California. That said, one storm doesn't amount to much in the grand scheme; we received plenty of rain in the first two weeks of the year when an atmospheric river struck the West Coast throughout the entire state, which was welcome news from a water supply standpoint, and it replenished quite a few reservoirs up in Northern California. After that, February turned out extremely dry right until this week, when we received additional snow along with blizzard-like conditions in the CRS. As I believe many of you are aware, groundwater levels respond quite gradually to seasonal shifts, and a single storm doesn't really alter the situation. The snowpack currently looks extremely healthy, sitting well above 100%. However, what truly matters as spring approaches is what becomes of that snowpack throughout April. If you recall, back in April of last year, we lost most of our snowpack, which melted rapidly as temperatures rose. And that's really — that aspect is what's genuinely caused by climate change. Another point I'd make is that water economics in California remain unchanged; you've still got 40 plus million residents. You're the biggest agricultural state in the union. Plus you've got a very robust industrial sector as the world's fourth largest economy. So folks do get quite thrilled about these storms, and we do too. We're glad to see the rainfall. But the truth is we're nowhere near done with this situation; and what really deserves attention is essentially how climate change affects the state over the longer term. That's the reason why keeping an eye on that snowpack, and how long it sticks around for — is going to become really, really crucial. Conservation efforts carry on and our customers have performed well. Some of you might have noticed we issued a press release earlier this week indicating our customers achieved nine consecutive months of conservation savings. For Q4 2022 overall, usage was 8.2% lower compared to the prior year and 70% below adopted. Once again, that reflects the efforts of the conservation team, along with our conservation messaging happening across the state. Our drought-related expenditures for the quarter came to roughly $500,000, recorded in a memorandum account. So they get expensed during the period, but we're permitted to monitor them. Our total balance in that account sits just under $2 million at this moment; so everyone's watching April to find out what happens with the snowpack. With any luck, we'll get more and more snow between now and then. But really, we need to see how long it endures. And I believe the major development that's genuinely shifted over the past year has been the increased awareness of the problems surrounding the Colorado River. Okay, so that doesn't really have a direct impact on Cal water itself. But it does impact a number of our wholesalers down in Southern California, and that's where we source some of our water. So we're going to keep watching that closely. And clearly, our drought-related work goes hand in hand with what our wholesalers are doing to ensure there's adequate supply for Southern California. So expect further updates on the drought situation as spring arrives. Now turning to Page 16, we'd like to spend a moment on capital investment — as Tom mentioned, I'd say the bright spot in what's otherwise been a tough year has been capital investment. We hit a record of $328 million in total capital deployed, which is extremely strong, honestly better than our own expectations, so credit goes to the procurement, engineering, and operations teams for getting that capital into the ground. There were a lot of supply chain obstacles throughout 2022 that we had to work around in order to keep that capital moving. Q4 capital spending was up, thanks to favorable weather through the start of the year; beyond that, we've been investing more capital into our subsidiary companies; and we view that as a really positive signal that our business development efforts keep producing results as we bring on new service connections and expand into other states. We're directing more capital into those other states and upgrading those service connections to meet our standards. We anticipate a rise in capital expenditures at non-California utilities during 2023. Again, with our subsidiary companies, we expect that pace of capital investment to keep climbing, though it won't match California in terms of total dollars — as a percentage it's increasing, and capital expenditures across the subsidiaries are expanding at a very healthy rate. I'll circle back to that shortly when we get into PD exercises. If you flip to Page 17, on the business development front, we've marked in yellow essentially what's different since our last discussion; let me walk through those changes quickly. Keahou in Hawaii, a wastewater management system, brings in 1500 equivalent units, or essentially 1500 customers, to our wastewater base in Hawaii — that represents 24% of the connection base for our Hawaii operations. Over in the Pacific Northwest in Washington, we brought in Stroh's water and Bethel Green Acres, both approved by the WUTC in January of this year, and that will contribute 3% to the customer base for our connections in Washington state. Then at the very bottom of the page, Lake section, New Mexico, we announced in January of 2023 a definitive agreement that's now been filed with the New Mexico Public Service Commission, and that will bring 5000 connections, or 58%, to our connection base in New Mexico. Thus, we've kept seeing favorable outcomes when it comes to developing business and expanding our operations beyond California; and we're eager to share news about these business development efforts as we progress through 2023. Over to you, Tom?
Tom Smegal
executiveOkay, so I’ll give a brief update on capital investment and go through the slides, specifically Slide 18. We’ve laid out the capital investment for 2022. We keep hitting CapEx at three times our depreciation rate. That makes seven years now in which we’ve delivered the best case, CapEx. And as you’ll see, remember that 2023 and 2024 hinge on the CPUC decision and the direction we receive from the CPUC in California regarding the 2021 general rate case. Slide 19 has no changes. Again, that’s our estimated regulated rate base, especially as it pertains to California. We’re waiting on a ruling, as we discussed, that would set what the regulated rate base is in 2023 as well as ’24 and ’25. So Marty, I’ll hand this back to you.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, and moving to Page 24, we're going to conclude and discuss what will take place in 2023 as we look ahead. Above all, as was mentioned during this call, there isn't much fresh information regarding the cost of capital in the general rate case. We're in a holding pattern, just like the majority of water utilities across California overseen by the PUC, which will lead to some near-term regulatory ambiguity while we await those two critical rulings. We'll keep collaborating with the Commission and do whatever is possible to secure those decisions promptly, yet in the end, the decision rests with them. In the same way, heading toward the close of the first quarter, financial reporting becomes somewhat more difficult since we are formally no longer under decoupling, yet no rate order exists that lays out all your mechanisms, as Greg pointed out. So, similar to what was done in prior year GRCs, when we had expected mechanisms and trackers we believed would be adopted in the end, we'll supply as much detail on both sides, so to speak. That way you can observe what the figures look like before and after, based on our assumptions about those trackers. So we'd ask everyone to please be patient with us until those two decisions come through; once they do, much of this will be resolved, though it will be somewhat uneven trying to interpret everything in the meantime, while we're no longer decoupled and awaiting a GRC ruling that ultimately approves trackers along with cap structure, cost of capital, and so forth. We'll remain concentrated on regulation. Obviously, we'll keep advancing in business development; the business development team has been extremely occupied. Our pipeline is quite full. We'll also stay committed to risk management and keep watching our supply chain problems, drought, and climate change matters that impact the company over the long haul. We'll be issuing our third ESG report shortly. In the coming weeks, we look forward to sharing it with all of you, along with the progress achieved in our fights against climate change and our efforts to guarantee sustainability for our customers. Finally, I want to go off on a slight tangent — some of you may be wondering, who on earth is this Tom Scanlon fellow, and whatever became of Dave Healy? Dave Healy retired from his role as our Corporate Controller. A number of you likely saw the 8-K last year; it was a retirement that had been planned. So we're fortunate to have Tom Scanlon. Tom holds an undergraduate degree in Finance from Marquette University in Wisconsin and an MBA from the University of Illinois. He is a CPA with a solid background in financial reporting and construction management. Tom has served as our Director of Financial Reporting since 2010. He's definitely been involved in our succession planning efforts here at Cal Water, and he is absolutely, absolutely well qualified. And honestly, given his solid experience in construction accounting, bringing him on board in 2010 was a significant gain for us. Construction and securing <<inaudible>> represent a major portion of our operations; so Tom, welcome. I'd also like to mention that Justin Skarb was elevated to Vice President of Community and Governmental Affairs after first joining Cal Water in 2009. He became Director in 2017 and took on the role of company officer effective January 1, alongside Tom Scanlon. Justin earned his BS in Political Science at Arizona State University, holds a Master's in Communication from Cal State Hayward, and he's presently wrapping up his Juris Doctor, which he anticipates receiving in 2024. Similarly, you might have seen a press release a couple weeks back announcing that Shawn Bunting has come aboard as our Vice President, General Counsel. Sean is stepping into the role held by Lynn McGhee, who will formally retire at the close of this month following 19 years of service to the company. Shawn spent 15 years at American Waterworks, where he held several different senior leadership positions. Shawn holds a Bachelor of Arts in political and criminal justice from Gettysburg College and a Juris Doctor from the University of Pittsburgh Law School. He's also a U.S. Marine Corps veteran. So a formal welcome to Tom, Justin and Shawn. And finally, I'd like to wrap up by simply thanking Lynn and Dave — we've been extremely fortunate at Cal Water to have a smart, thoughtful and creative leadership team. And while leadership transitions are never simple, since we all grow accustomed to working alongside one another, and this has truly been a wonderful team to have together for the last number of years without any changes. We also recognize and we support people choosing to retire and enjoy life. One of the wonderful aspects of being employed at a company like Cal Water is that we offer excellent benefits and an excellent retirement program. So even though change is difficult when we see our good friends and colleagues leave, it's a positive thing because it creates opportunities for people to advance, and succession planning is a core competency of management and the board here at Cal Water that we take very, very seriously. So to Dave and Lynn, we simply want to say thank you for everything you've contributed to us over the years, you've been a vital part of our team, you will be deeply, deeply missed, and we wish you all the best in your retirement. So with that funding, we want to open it up to questions please.
Angie Storozynski
analystThanks. I'd like to begin by noting that the decoupling mechanism has been eliminated, yet the conservation mandate remains in effect. So I'm simply attempting to figure out where the risk actually sits, correct? Since under the conservation mandate, sales volume or revisions to sales forecasts shouldn't have any effect on your earnings. Once more, I'm just trying to determine where that sensitivity lies, considering the conservation mandate is still active.
Tom Smegal
executiveCertainly, Angie. Tom Smegal speaking. And Greg, please chime in once I reach the limit of what I know. We have a filed account — one of those accounts Greg brought up, known as the DRMA, which stands for the drought lost decision lost revenue memorandum account; for non-decoupled utilities such as SJW, or the other smaller ones, that has existed at those companies for a number of years. It permits us to track and record lost sales while a drought has been declared. And a drought is currently declared. Governor Newsom declared it a couple of years ago. And as we've said, we are tracking the costs tied to that. So when you aren't decoupled, you can track lost revenue, and possibly recoup it down the road. There are a couple of points regarding that. First, it's subject to somewhat of an earnings haircut, I believe a 20 basis point reduction in ROE tied to it. And second, what remains unknown right now, since we've had such a wet winter to-date, is whether or when the Governor might declare the drought finished; as Marty noted, there are clearly major water supply challenges in California, especially in Southern California right now regarding the Colorado River supply, and we aren't sure if and when the Governor might declare the drought over. But should that occur, that account would stop tracking the lost revenue. Greg, is there anything you'd like to add?
Greg Milleman
executiveNo. You hit all the relevant points, Tom.
Angie Storozynski
analystAll right, that makes sense. So in the past, I went through the Q4 slide decks from earlier years, and you had a slide that laid out what I'd describe as a pared-down calculation of your earnings. And I get that this time around it's tough since you're still waiting on at least 2 big rulings. But could you please help us out — for instance, how big is the rate base outside California? How should we approach those other drivers, the way you normally would? Sure, I realize plenty remains uncertain, but even just something that would let us gauge this year's earnings potential would be useful.
Tom Smegal
executiveRight. My view is that we don't break things out by segment. So pulling the non-California rate base from our filed documents is somewhat hard. We've characterized the company as having somewhere in the range of 90% to 92% of revenue and operations located in California. That would likely hold roughly true for rate base too. However, I don't have those figures with me. And I'm not sure we've ever laid them out publicly. There's — someone's math that sits behind that figure on Slide 19, the rate base one. And I believe that same pattern applies there, in that roughly 90% of the rate base displayed on that slide — the projected rate base for '23, '24, '25 — is California rate base. Beyond that, I can't offer much more detail. There are many systems, and sadly, each state has its own set of regulations. Consequently, in certain instances we've got forecasted rate base, while in others we've got a litigated rate case. It becomes somewhat messy. Still, California is pretty clear-cut, since the decision will spell out the rate base there.
Angie Storozynski
analystAll right. Moving on to how you're funding things — you've clearly been busy buying up assets. What's the mechanism behind paying for those purchases? That's my first question. Second, what did the equity ratio actually stand at for the California utility when 2022 came to a close?
Tom Smegal
executiveRegarding your initial question, the majority of these purchases — take a look at slide 17 for the acquisitions — tend to be on the smaller side. The way we've covered them is by using corporate cash generated from retained earnings and the ATM equity program, plus our available lines of credit. Looking at that list, the largest deal right now is likely the lake section shown at the very bottom. That purchase was only just announced, meaning payment hasn't happened yet. So those same funding sources will be tapped for it down the road. On the topic of the equity layer at California Water Service Company — I can see Tom sitting across from me with a calculator. That figure isn't something we've made public. It will need to be computed, and we'll look for another avenue to share it. At this moment, we simply don't have it.
Angie Storozynski
analystSo, if someone were to put it at roughly 50%, would that be right?
Tom Smegal
executiveMy sense is that heading into Q3, that figure was climbing. And, as you're aware, a key point in the cost of capital matter involved whether the capital structure made sense, and it was definitely approaching 50%. When Q3 came around, I recall running the numbers, but sadly I don't have that figure for the year end.
Angie Storozynski
analystAll right. Thanks, everyone. Appreciate it.
Jonathan Reeder
analystMorning, gentlemen. Could you walk us through what drove that big 35% jump in other operating expense? I believe it came in roughly $30 million above 21. Those items aren't expected to <<inaudible>>, or can we treat that as a solid baseline for figuring how 23 grows from there?
Tom Scanlon
executiveTom Scanlon here. I'll take that one. On the rise in other operational expense: a significant chunk ties to deferral obligations under accounting rules — guidance where we project ahead and estimate what receivables we'll collect. Anything beyond 24 months, we're required to defer both the revenue and the costs. Every quarter we redo that forecast, reverse it, then book it again. Given what we expect to collect, we've reversed out revenue and cost. That's the big adjustment sitting in other operations expense. We also put our conservation expense into that same category. Since we're wrapping up our GRC, we have a subvention balancing account, and a number of programs got accelerated in the last year of our rate case. Again, keep in mind conservation expenses are recovered through a balancing account. On top of that, bad debt expense went up — that's the reserves we hold for uncollectible accounts. Partway through 2022, we got the go-ahead to start disconnecting service for non-payment; however, quite a few accounts remain under review, and it's going to take time to get out there and shut off non-payers. Those were the main things pushing other operating expense higher.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right. So it seems like much of that growth — is there a related revenue effect too, or a bump in revenue?
Tom Smegal
executiveCorrect, Jonathan. Yes.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAlright, and then — I'm not sure if this one's directed at Marty — but what was the reasoning behind the board settling on just a 4% bump to the dividend for '23? I realize it got that raise, and it's been closer to an 8% clip over the last three years, and the payout ratio on — well, at least on what ought to be a normalized EPS, since our 2023 is going to be a bit messy, but it's still fairly low, perhaps somewhere near 50%. So how come the dividend didn't really expand at the pace it has in the past?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveYes, fair question, Jonathan. Naturally, we hold our payout ratio inside a particular band. Plainly, there's just uncertainty at the moment, correct? We're nailing down the right case. We're nailing down the cap structure. And we believe one of the most crucial things we do as a business, apart from taking care of customers, is putting the capital to work, correct? That's what delivers benefits for stockholders as we bring rate base online. And so, with the uncertainty we've witnessed at the Commission, we figured it was wiser to keep this year's dividend increase smaller; and continue directing that capital back into the ground. And clearly, as circumstances shift, we'll take another look at that — we've raised the dividend annually for the past 70-some-odd years. I don't foresee us shifting course away from something like that. But we simply believed it was the moment to be somewhat conservative until we clear these two hurdles here with the California Public Utilities Commission.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right, I appreciate that. Then, for my final question, regarding that acquisition in Lake Section, New Mexico — can you share anything about what was paid? Or the related rate base figure? Also, do you anticipate completing that transaction during 2023?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveOur expectation is completion in 2023. Clearly, we have not yet submitted anything to the New Mexico Public Utilities Commission. Once that filing happens, we can discuss the purchase price in greater detail. That said, let me tell you this, Jonathan, about our approach to business development. Our mindset is that of value buyers. Acquiring assets at three, four, or five times rate base holds no appeal for us, correct? What we examine is cost per connection. We examine the extent of headroom, or available capacity, for putting money into that system, upgrading it to meet our standards, and so forth. So bear that in mind whenever we evaluate any of our business development opportunities. Our purchasing decisions carry a decidedly strong value orientation. Thus, I believe after the application goes to the Commission, we can elaborate further. Before that point, though, the purchase price genuinely cannot be stated by me. The only thing I would add is that it lacks materiality — this is a system with 5000 connections. The figures involved aren't large; it's really more of a density situation.
Davis Sunderland
analystI'd like to get some insight into what things look like right now on the supply chain front. You folks said there was perhaps a bigger hit in the prior quarter than in this one. Seems like you got past some hurdles, but I was hoping you could speak specifically to how long it takes to get lead piping, or whatever else stands out. And do you expect that to affect capital spending for this year at all? Then I've got one quick thing after that.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveAbsolutely. Well, I'd say supply chain is inked on my arm at this point — that's been a central piece of my work alongside procurement and engineering over these past 2 years. To begin with, lead pipe isn't something we purchase — let's just be clear on that — there is no lead pipe. What we have witnessed is major shifts in the lead times required for ductile iron, PVC, and so on. And it appears those may have topped out somewhere between Q3 and Q4. Take ductile iron — previously you could place an order 4 to 6 weeks ahead of time and be set at the job site. These days, in certain situations, the wait stretches to as much as a year. Part of the reason behind that — and I've sat down with most of our suppliers — is that they can't scale up output fast enough at their facilities. So they aim to align what they supply with what's demanded, avoiding excess capacity since that hurts them, and their margins are pretty thin. Still, we are watching suppliers increase output. This has been roughly 12 months in the making — they got moving on it early. So some of that added production is arriving in Q, and that should accelerate things. Another big help has been the fact that we've purchased that pipe steadily from our wholesalers. Those ties truly matter when there's a bit of a frenzy and everybody's scrambling to buy — we've ended up at the front of the line thanks to our relationships and the steadiness with which we order goods and services from particular vendors. So my sense is we've hit the peak, and it's beginning to improve. We have observed a fairly significant jump in certain costs. We've also seen our year-over-year inventory balances rise. So whenever the team spotted extra supply on hand, they'd seize it and we'd put it in storage. So, sure, it's simple to discuss on an earnings call, but the truth is procurement and engineering truly knocked it out of the park; and if you were to go back and listen to our earnings calls over the past year, we'd gently put it this way — capital had a hard year. Capital had a hard year. Capital had a hard year. And obviously, that was the case, but during Q4, we posted our best-ever fourth quarter, and that gave us a record-breaking year overall — the team has performed incredibly well. Naturally, with all the inflationary pressure out there, we're also seeing prices go up, though I believe we're handling it. And my hope is that the worst part is behind us. Based on what I've observed up to this point, conditions are beginning to improve somewhat. So assuming no further significant global disruptions occur, I think we'll find ourselves past the peak of this issue. And with any luck, things will begin to stabilize.
Davis Sunderland
analystThanks, that's useful. For my second question, I'd like to focus on the pipeline for business development projects — it's clearly exciting to hear about New Mexico — and I was wondering whether there's anything specific that, to whatever degree you're able to discuss it, you're exploring or considering when it comes to water versus wastewater, or which geographies look more appealing. Any specifics would be appreciated. Thanks so much.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveSure, that's a really good question, naturally. Let's step back; at 50,000 feet, we've completed transactions across all five states, Texas included. So the market, I'd say, remains decent. The pipeline remains full — the expectations of sellers and of buyers, that's always where the difficulty lies. We're pursuing transactions in both categories, water and wastewater. Our growth in Texas has been very strong. We've clearly been in California, and in Washington state it's been more water systems in Hawaii. Meanwhile, Texas has leaned more toward wastewater systems. So growth is happening on both sides. It simply comes down to where the market sits and where growth is occurring. As I said in response to Jonathan's question, we're quite value oriented when it comes to a system — we have no desire to acquire a system, pay too much, and then lack the capacity to put additional capital into it. That outcome is a loss for stockholders and for our company alike. So we prefer to acquire on a value basis when there's room to invest, make capital improvements, raise somebody to our operating standards, and then the entity's selling shareholder — that's their buyout — we obtain the asset at a fair price, not one that's inflated, but a fair one. After that, our stockholder gains the chance to invest capital in that system, which lets us begin producing a greater return. So I remain, in a sense, bullish on the PD side, though inflation will clearly play a role, along with whatever happens in the economy in 2023. Even so, the PD team has been on a roll, and that's been true across all five states; I don't foresee our momentum decelerating. That said, these aren't especially large deals, though they're certainly large for the subsidiary companies, since those companies are expanding exponentially through them; so I expect '23 will be another solid year for business development, assuming no global catastrophic shifts in the market.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveAppreciate it, Mandy. So clearly, with us heading into Q1, everyone is watching the California Public Utilities Commission — working through the cost of capital, securing a PD, and ideally receiving a general rate case ruling at some point during 2023. Two other items we're keeping a close eye on: the decoupling matter before the California Supreme Court. And, as I noted before, everyone is eager about snowpack — that will be essential for addressing the drought questions, specifically what happens with the snowpack in April. So, thank you for being here on this year end conference call. We're grateful for all of your support, and we're excited to bring everyone up to date at the close of the first quarter. The end of April. Thanks so much. Take care.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it, everyone. That brings today’s call to a close. Thank you for joining us. You’re free to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.