California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 27, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, thanks Jack. Morning, everybody. Appreciate you being here today. Sorry about the tech issues. We ran into trouble with our telecom line trying to connect. So my sincere apologies for that. Joining me now are Dave Healey, who serves as our Interim Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, and Greg Milleman, Vice President, Rates and Regulatory Affairs. Before we dive into the quarter's results, I'll hand things over to Dave Healey so he can walk through our forward-looking statements disclaimer. And Dave, if you could go ahead and cover the financial results for the quarter, that would be great.
Dave Healey
executiveThanks, Marty. Details for the replay dial-in for today's call are included in the quarterly results release that went out earlier today. You'll be able to access that replay through September 25, 2023. Just a quick note before we get started — there's a slide deck the company has put together to go along with this quarter's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K yesterday afternoon, and you can also find it on the company's website, www.calwatergroup.com. Before we dive into this quarter's results, we want to spend a few moments on forward-looking statements. At points during this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since those statements involve future events, they come with various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could end up differing materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages all current shareholders, as well as anyone interested, to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures about risks and uncertainties in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports we file from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Our presentation begins on Slide 4, covering their values and priorities. Then, turning to Slide 5, I'll go over the second quarter results. So, in the second quarter of 2023, net income attributable to group came in at $9.6 million, and diluted earnings per share was $0.17, compared with net income attributable to group of $19.5 million and diluted earnings per share of $0.36 for the quarter that ended June 30, 2022. As we talked about last quarter, the second quarter results mainly reflect the temporary absence of 2023 California general rate increases and regulatory mechanisms included in our 2021 general rate case. Because of the delayed California general rate case, there was a decrease in second quarter 2023 operating revenue versus the same period last year. On top of that, operating revenue fell $13.8 million because of a 10.4% decrease in customer usage. General rate increases during the quarter were approximately $3.4 million, with most of that in California, and along with the delay to our GRC, the commission authorized a 4% general rate increase for most of our California districts effective May 5, 2023, until the final 2023 GRC general rate case increases are authorized by the commission. That added roughly $3 million to operating revenue during the second quarter. Total operating expenses came down slightly in the second quarter of 2023 compared with the same period last year. Net interest expense rose $1.7 million, mostly because of an increase in interest rates and $23 million of additional borrowings on our short-term lines of credits. We invested $95.2 million in capital improvements during the second quarter of 2023, a 25.1% increase over the same period last year. That was a second quarter record for our company. In California, the governor extended the state's arrearage program to help customers struggling to pay monthly water bills. This initiative addresses unpaid amounts owed by customers that are either 60 days overdue or were charged off between the middle of June 2021 and December 31, 2022. We intend to submit our request for that money to the State Water Resources Control Board toward the close of September. One final point. In July we submitted the California advice letter seeking a boost to yearly operating revenues of $24.6 million, aimed at covering recognized rises in California water production costs. You can find our EPS bridge on Page 10. I'll now hand things over to Greg Milleman, who will speak about the temporary absence of the 2023 California General Rate Case, along with general rate increases and regulatory mechanisms.
Greg Milleman
executiveThanks, Dave. If you turn to Page 7, this follows what we did in the first quarter. The same instruments provided by the California Public Utility Commission are being relied on to capture the interim revenue effect while the decision remains delayed. On this slide, you can see the 3 main instruments. Now on Page 8. Our present estimate is that the delayed decision's interim hit to operating revenues for the second quarter of 2023 falls somewhere between $19 million and $29 million, taking into account where parties currently stand in the 2021 GRC filings as well as consumption-driven regulatory mechanisms. And while we're on that subject, please look at Slide 13, which contains identical information, only covering year-to-date activity, where the interim revenue delay is projected at $43 million to $63 million. With that, Dave, I'll hand it back to you for Slide 9.
Dave Healey
executiveThanks, Greg. If you turn to Slide 10, you'll see our Q2 earnings bridge, and Slide 11 is where we're going next. For the six months ended June 30, 2023, net loss attributable to the group was $12.7 million, or a loss of $0.23 per diluted common share. That's against net income attributable to the group of $20.6 million, or $0.38 per diluted common share, for the six months ended June 30, 2022. During the six months ended June 30, 2023, results reflect the one-time effect of not having a 2023 general rate case, the 2023 California general rate increases, or the regulatory mechanisms from our 2021 general rate case, as Greg noted. For that period, operating revenue came in at $325.1 million, compared with $379.2 million during the same six months of 2022. The decline of $54.1 million, or 14.3%, was driven by a $21.8 million rise in revenue deferral, a $15.2 million drop in RAM and MCBA revenue, and a $22.9 million reduction tied to customer usage, partly offset by $5 million in general rate increases. For the half-year period ending June 30, 2023, our total operating expenses were $326.7 million. That compares with $342.8 million during 2022 — a reduction of $16 million, or $4.7 million. Other operations expenses for the same six months ended June 30, 2023, totaled $42.4 million, against $55.3 million in 2022, which works out to a 23.2% decline, or $12.8 million. The main driver behind that drop was the deferral of $17.8 million in costs tied to the revenue deferral. Water production costs declined $6.6 million, or 5%, landing at $125.9 million in 2023, compared with $132.4 million in 2022. Lower water production expenses came mainly from a 9.7% reduction in how much customers used; those savings were partly counterbalanced by higher administrative and general costs of $4.9 million, depreciation and amortization of $2.2 million, and property and other taxes of $1.5 million. During the first 6 months of 2023, infrastructure improvements totaled $177.2 million in investment by the company. That figure also stands as a company record. Cash rose by $112.7 million in the first 6 months of 2023 thanks to the company's ATM program. The results of our ATM program please us, and we will keep running our at the market, or ATM program, through March of 2025. On Slide 15, you can find the year-to-date EPS bridge. Greg Milliman is up next to give us the latest on the regulatory side.
Greg Milleman
executiveAppreciate that, Dave. When it comes to the cost of capital proceeding, what matters most about this ruling is that it looks ahead starting July 31, 2023. Once the water cost of capital mechanism takes effect, our ROE is going to rise from 9.2% to 9.57%, and our debt will be trued up to reflect our actual lower comps to borrow of 4.23%. Beyond that, should the bond index keep moving along its present path and follow the trends it's showing now, we anticipate the water cost of capital mechanism getting triggered once more at the end of — or at the start of October, with an increase taking effect January 2024. Slide 17 covers the California 2021 GRC update. Not long after the decision was extended on June 29 through the end of the year, December 31, 2023, a second judge was assigned by the commission to our proceeding. This judge brings a lengthy career with the commission, and he's already begun working on our general rate case, and given that we now have 2 ALJs on our case, we're hopeful a proposed decision will come before the year is out. Turning to Slide 18, I'll hand things over to Marty.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, thank you, Greg. Let me give you a brief update regarding the PFOS and PFO events taking place. As I believe was included in last quarter's deck, the EPA issued draft regulations, and that was confirmed on four separate occasions. According to those draft rules, we estimate roughly $200 million in additional investment would be required to treat about 75 wells across the 5 states where we operate — 75 million wells currently. If the draft regulation gets adopted in its current form, compliance would be required by 2026. That timeline is somewhat tight. That said, in California — which has the most stringent water quality standards among the states — we began working on this back in 2018. So we're significantly ahead of where we need to be, and we'll keep progressing carefully while we await adoption. Another thing worth noting, and this represents quite a major shift for everyone in NAWC, the National Association of Water Companies: all of us have pursued the rate — the polluters. Some of you might have noticed in The Wall Street Journal that several proposed settlements have been brought before the courts and are close to being finalized. We are directly involved in that litigation for the states where we operate. Any recovered costs will be used to offset customer expenses as we put in place the treatment required to remove PFOA and PFOS from our drinking water. Turning to the next slide, I'd like to spend a moment discussing business development. As has been the case previously, BD had another active quarter — really since our last conversation at the end of Q1, we announced that the California Public Utilities Commission granted approval for us to close on Skylonda Mutual, located in the Bay Area. That involves a modest customer count — 176 — but it's a small system situated on both sides of our system. So acquiring Skylonda lets us construct an interconnect linking 3 parts of the Bay — the 2 parts we own plus the one part that is Skylonda — and enhances reliability and resiliency in the Bay Area. Additionally, we closed on the Stroh system in Washington state, which brings 900 connections into our Washington Water service company in the Pacific Northwest. We also received approval from the Hawaii Commission to close our — pardon me, to proceed with the HOH Utility. So HOH and KSSC are both located on the Island of Hawaii. This puts us on our fourth island; it's a wastewater system that will contribute roughly 2,200 wastewater connections. That means we'll be on Maui, we'll be on the big island of Hawaii; we're on Oahu, and now we're expanding into Hawaii. All in all, it was a busy quarter for our business development team, and the pipeline remains full. The team is occupied. Again, within the water space, there aren't really, really large acquisitions. Those are fairly uncommon. That said, there are definitely enough bolt-on opportunities we're seeing that fit alongside or run parallel to what we already do, which we can buy and integrate into our system, gaining economies of scale that lower costs for customers and enhance service. Moving to the next slide, which covers capital investment and depreciation. As Dave mentioned, we had a record quarter for new capital, with $95.2 million breaking ground. Obviously, we're recovering some lost time from a long, wet winter on the West Coast. I believe the team has done well accelerating that work. Also, on a year-to-date basis, it rose 22.5%, amounting to $177.29 million. So we remain on track to hit our 2023 targets. Perhaps more significantly, stepping back a bit to explain why our rate case is likely more complicated than those of some peers in California: across 2022, 2023, and 2024, that represents over $1 billion of capital we'll have put into our system. So the rate payer timeline has slipped; it's a $1 billion rate case, making it a substantial matter to resolve. I'm thankful I'm not Greg Milliman—he has to handle all the specifics—but it's intricate as we engage with the commission and proceed; the upside is that capital investment keeps going. We remain on schedule with our investment dollars and the efforts we're making to boost resiliency and sustainability. On the next slide, this is merely a snapshot of our regulated rate base for the group, assuming the rate case gets approved as filed. This will naturally shift once a proposed decision arrives, and we'll revise this slide to reflect that. But it should give you an idea of how earnings growth will appear as the rate base keeps expanding. So, stepping back and reviewing the quarter: clearly, we're still in a waiting mode due to the delayed general rate case in California. And though that's frustrating, as I noted, it's highly complicated. I'll add that we were quite pleased with the cost of capital ruling that emerged and was approved in the second quarter, which advanced swiftly after the proposed decision was issued. As Greg noted, we're heartened by the addition of a second ALJ to our general rate case. We know this judge well. We've appeared before this judge in other cases. And I think he's extremely schedule-focused, he follows the rules closely, and I think he's very impartial, which is beneficial when bringing on a new ALJ. I don't think you could ask for more than that. And ideally, it will help move the process along. Even with the setbacks, it's clear we're still achieving a great deal on our business plan—take the record capital deployed during the quarter, or the ongoing expansion we've driven through business development. That covered California, Hawaii and the State of Washington. On top of that, we released our third annual ESG report, which covers our efforts on Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions and the work we're doing to help fight climate change for our customers while making things more sustainable and reliable. So while we're waiting, we'll keep carrying out the business plan, and like Greg mentioned, we're hopeful a rate case can come through before the year is over. When a proposed decision in that rate case arrives, we'll be able to book several mechanisms that are off the table at the moment, which is exactly why we gave those figures and why the ranges were included—to give you a feel for where the high and the low sit, depending on those mechanisms we aren't booking yet. Finally, I'd like to spend a moment on a new member of our Board of Directors. Some of you might have noticed. Charles Patton has come onto our Board. For those of you who know Charles, he brings 37 years of utility experience, with a remarkable record in operations, external and governmental affairs, and rates. He's a tremendous leader. We feel extremely fortunate to have him join our board, and yesterday he sat in on his first board meeting with us. So welcome, Charles, to the California Water Service Group Board. So Jack, that's where things stand for now. Let's go ahead and open it up for questions, please?
Angie Storozynski
analystThere are simply a lot of dynamic elements when it comes to your potential to generate earnings. So, only a few points. First, were you expecting an actual final ruling in the GRC during this year, or merely a proposed one? And my assumption is that a final ruling is required for you to record all of those revenue adjustments retroactively back to 1/1/2023. Is that right?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAngie, our expectation is to receive a proposed decision before the year is over, and such a proposed decision ought to give sufficient assurance for the accounting teams to move forward and record the different items that were deferred.
Angie Storozynski
analystAll right. And if I could — look, you've laid out every revenue adjustment that would have occurred during the first half, which clearly includes the pension gain. But is there some kind of rule of thumb we could use just to get even a rough feel for the earnings power? For instance, what does the distribution of earnings look like, roughly speaking? We can work out what first half earnings would have been using the adjustments you presented. So could I take some percentage of the 2023 total earnings as a given?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveYes. Angie, that's exactly the reason we handed you the range — it reflects what we consider the top and the bottom. You'll need to decide which spot inside that range strikes you as the right one to focus on. Still, our view was that the most useful approach is showing the 2 goal posts. And clearly, we'll land somewhere between those 2 goal post. Looking back, we've performed, particularly across the last 2 rate cases, very strongly in our rate cases. In my view, the Cal Water team has genuinely raised its level over the last 3 cycles when it comes to assembling a solid rate case and reaching a favorable outcome with the Public Utilities Commission in California. What's tougher is that we are now formally decoupled from decoupling. Under the decoupling rules we used before, we were able to show you the consumption curve, which appeared in the rate case. And clearly, our pattern tracked that consumption curve — but since we're now truly demand-driven, it will shift around somewhat, and we haven't needed to genuinely examine it or view the business that way for more than 12 years; so this year, as we move through the process of leaving decoupling behind, earnings will fluctuate depending on seasonality, depending on weather, and depending on consumption. And clearly, our first quarter was extremely, extremely wet. Our second quarter was reasonably wet and consumption fell, yet right now we're in the middle of this enormous heat wave, which is hitting the entire U.S., and my expectation is that consumption will rise substantially during the third quarter. So, I realize that isn't a terribly clear response, but those are the variables we handle on the inside while doing the accounting and working on our rate cases.
Jonathan Reeder
analystI realize it's really hard with all the shifting parts this year, so maybe just build a bit on what Angie asked. Could you talk about, I suppose, how customer usage is measuring up versus the usage amounts baked into the GRCs partial settlement agreement? Clearly, weather plays a role in the first half, or not just somewhat, weather does play a role in the first half of the year, but perhaps how do you see the full year landing relative to those usage amounts?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveJonathan, forecasting what will occur down the road is tough. Yet at this moment, absent decoupling, and I think Dave said we're around 10%, 90% of consumption projected in the rate case; and since that's the case, every mechanism — except the one mechanism tied to lost revenues from the drought, the remaining mechanisms rely on actual consumption. And the drought memoranda, the mechanism tied to lost revenues from the drought, will capture lost consumption revenues linked to the drought for some span of time, but it's unclear how long that mechanism will keep going, with the governor having removed mandatory conservation and still leaving executive orders in place tied to ongoing drought or conservation efforts for the state.
Jonathan Reeder
analystUnderstood. And at what point were those required conservation steps reviewed — was that around the beginning of April?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThat happened in April.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAlright. So that 90% figure applies to what is genuinely part of the GRC settlement — the partial one?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveExactly. That is correct.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right, understood. So I suppose, given that full decoupling is no longer in place, and considering those consumption patterns plus, I guess, the expense of providing the water — which ought to be working out much better for you — do you anticipate, I guess, that having the Monterey-Style RAM this year will act as a drag or a boost to kind of EPS? Is it still a drag because decoupling is gone? Or could those reduced supply costs potentially benefit you by a decent amount that makes its way down to the bottom line?
Dave Healey
executiveJonathan, I can address that for you. So, how much consumption there will be in the second half of the year, I don't know. But should it be — if we remain at 90%, the Monterey-Style RAM mechanism will produce a small positive value..
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right. And I assume that offsets the effect on revenue versus what's happening with supply?
Dave Healey
executiveThat's right. It simply follows one volume-based rate against the real volume rates that got filled. And there's a particular threshold. At this moment, we're sitting at 90%, not at 100%. Still, it won't amount to a large figure.
Jonathan Reeder
analystOkay, understood. Thanks for the assistance — and congratulations on the strong result regarding the cost of capital. Best of luck getting a proposed decision in the rate case before the year-end results come out.
Davis Sunderland
analystThis year. We don't dig too far into that, naturally, but if no proposed decision arrives by the time the year closes, what should we expect in terms of shifts to next year's CapEx deployment, or the possibility of pushing past the close of 2023? I also have a follow-up.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveCertainly. That's a fair question, since our capital program is obviously part of the 2021 general rate case. Management allocates funds based on risk. The investments we're making today strike us as essential upgrades required to keep the network running, and to handle items such as wildfire — <<inaudible>> — areas where we've needed to intensify our response around adapting to climate change. Should a project fail to win approval in a rate case, it will be captured — if not in the 2021 rate case, then it will be captured in the subsequent one, the 2024 rate case. Thus, whatever monetary impact arises will mainly stem from interim depreciation and the way we capture that during the following rate cycle.
Davis Sunderland
analystUnderstood, that helps. One more thing, perhaps regarding the PFOS law. You brought up pursuing legal action against certain entities that could be liable, or the ones causing pollution. Is there anything on putting a number on some of those benefits, or a schedule for it? Also, I recall you highlighted a few possible additional funding sources that might help cover part of that $200 million in CapEx. Any further specifics on what those funds could be, or when they'd come into play?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveRight. We still don't have that answer. If you look at the litigation and the coverage, these settlements reach into the billions. Clearly, there's a set of claimants involved in that settlement. We're among those claimants, so the outcome and the way it gets divided remain unclear. What I can say is our General Counsel is heavily involved and serves as the class representative in the suit. We therefore coordinate very closely with counsel — the plaintiffs' counsel for the group — to grasp how these elements will come together. So after the settlements become clearer and a judge gives approval, we'll be in a spot to collaborate with the representatives, the individuals tied to the litigation, on the distribution of those funds, and then a proposal goes to the judge, the judge must accept it, and after that they begin paying out the money. My expectation — purely my own view — is that these settlements will amount to millions and millions of dollars. Once more, the key thing here is that from an investor perspective it won't provide any benefit, since every one of those dollars will be used to offset the capital expenses tied to the treatment. The real winner is the customer, which is exactly how it ought to be. Then whatever remains that doesn't cover the invested capital for PFOA and PFOS treatment will receive rate-based treatment. Naturally, we aim to offset as much of that expense as possible, because it's additive to our capital program — that $1 billion I referenced for 2022, 2023 and 2024 — and this $200 million sits on top of it. That leaves you exposed to rate shocks. We genuinely want to reduce the impact on customers. So settlement funds, in my view, are extremely, extremely probable in 2024 or 2025. Beyond that, we're exploring ways to secure grant money and additional funding from state and federal sources, particularly for disadvantaged or lower-income communities. Installing PFOS treatment in the Bay Area for Silicon Valley is one situation; it's a completely different matter when you head out to certain rural parts of California, where the water quality requirements are identical but there are far fewer customers, far fewer connections, and the overall economic picture doesn't match that of a wealthy region like the Bay Area. So grant money along with proceeds from the litigation will be used to help cover those expenses for ratepayers.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveOkay. Hi Jack. First off, I appreciate you pronouncing my name correctly. Only around one in a hundred people manage that; and honestly, until I was roughly 12 years old, I couldn't even spell it or say it properly myself. So, thanks for saying my name the right way. Everyone, I appreciate you being here. Once again, the general rate case has all our attention — it's the main focus. That said, we aren't letting the business model out of our sight, and we intend to carry out our business plan to the fullest extent we're able. We look forward to speaking with all of you when Q3 wraps up, and our earnings call is scheduled for October 26. So, I appreciate you spending this morning with us. Sorry about the technical holdups. We ran into some problems with the technology and the lines functioning properly. So, I appreciate your patience, and we'll speak with everybody later. Thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference; we thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.