California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 26, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 47 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

David Healey

executive
#1

Thanks, Krista. I'd like to welcome all of you to the call covering California Water Service Group's results for the third quarter of 2023. Joining me are Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, along with Greg Milleman, our Vice President and Rates and Regulatory Affairs Officer. Details on how to access a replay of this call appear in the quarterly results release we put out earlier today. That replay can be heard through December 25, 2023. Just a reminder before we get going: the company has prepared a slide deck to go along with this quarter's earnings call. That deck was furnished with the Form 8-K this morning, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we get into this quarter's results, we want to spend a few moments addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since these statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results may end up differing materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages current shareholders and interested parties alike to read carefully and understand the company's disclosures regarding risk and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports we file from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll begin by directing you to slide 4, which lays out our values and priorities. Then we move to slide 5, covering Q3 financial highlights. As we discussed last quarter, results for Q3 and year-to-date mainly reflect the adverse impact from the delayed proposed decision by the California Public Utilities Commission, or CPUC, on Cal Water's pending 2021 General Rate Case, which will set new rates, rate design, and regulatory mechanisms. Once the CPUC gives its approval, the General Rate Case accumulative adjustment will apply retroactively to January 1, 2023. There is one change compared with what we discussed last quarter. The General Rate Case delay is now expected to push CPUC approval of the advice letter for the 2023 Drought Response Memorandum Account, or DRMA, operating revenue into calendar year 2024. We estimate the adverse impact of the delayed General Rate Case on Q3 2023 operating revenue to fall in the range from $14 million-$27 million, with $5 million-$5.5 million of that tied to DRMA. Our estimate relies on the current positions of the parties to the California General Rate Case filing and consumption-driven regulatory mechanisms. As noted on slide 5, Q3 2023 operating revenue decreased $11.3 million to $255 million as compared to the same period last year. The decrease was primarily from a $29.6 million decrease in WRAM and MCBA revenue, as those mechanisms concluded on December 31, 2022. The decrease was partially offset by $13.7 million of 2023 general rate increases and a $1.8 million reduction in revenue deferral. Q3 2023 operating expenses increased $10.1 million to $211.5 million as compared to the same period last year. That rise matched what we had anticipated, and as we pointed out on slide 5, it stemmed mainly from higher water production costs, bad debt expense, costs tied to a reduction in revenue deferral, employee labor costs, and depreciation and amortization expense. Let's proceed to page six. In Q3 of 2023, net income attributable to Group came to $34.4 million, with diluted earnings per share of $0.60, versus net income attributable to Group of $55.9 million and diluted earnings per share of $1.03 for the quarter ended September thirtieth, 2022. As we discussed, the delayed California General Rate Case proposed decision hurt net income attributable to Group. As the bottom of the slide indicates, I'm happy to share that Group's capital investments in Q3 of 2023 totaled $96.9 million, a 25% rise over the same period last year. I'll now hand things to Greg Milleman to cover slide seven.

Greg Milleman

executive
#2

Thanks, Dave. Over on slide seven, what you're seeing is something we've talked about during earlier quarters — three California regulatory mechanisms that haven't been recorded yet, and we're keeping an eye on all of them. Our approach is that revenue doesn't get recorded until the commission has approved and we know the 2021 GRC amounts. As Dave mentioned, every one of these mechanisms is retroactive to January 1, 2023. The biggest one is the Interim Rates Memo Account, which captures the gap between interim rates and our final rates. Then there's the Monterey-Style Revenue Adjustment Mechanism, which captures the gap between actual residential sales revenue and what residential sales revenue would be at a single quantity rate; and finally the Drought Response Memo Account, which captures the difference in reduced sales revenue resulting from conservation during a drought. That one stays open until California Governor Gavin Newsom declares the drought finished, which might be sometime in 2023, 2024, or, depending on weather conditions in our state, it could remain open even longer. Recovery on that comes through a separate filing, and per Dave, those revenues won't be recorded in 2023. They get recorded only after the commission approves that filing. Now on slide eight, this simply shows you the financial impacts from the three recorded regulatory mechanisms for the Q3. Based... Again, per Dave, based on where the parties currently stand in the 2021 GRC filing, we estimate an understatement of operating revenues for the Q3 to fall in the range of $14-$27 million, or $0.22-$0.41 earnings per share. One thing worth noting is on the right, just before the subtotal where MRAM appears, you'll notice those numbers are negative. That's exactly in line with what we'd anticipate for the memorandum account. Once you get into the summer months, customers are using water in the more extensive third and fourth tiers, while the single quantity rate aligns more with the second tier. So essentially it's beginning to annualize the numbers we'd expect for the year. Further along in the deck, we'll come to a slide showing this same table with year-to-date results, and you'll see that with almost three-quarters of the year finished, the numbers are falling in line with what we'd expect on an annualized basis; with that, I'll hand it back to you, Dave.

David Healey

executive
#3

Thanks, Greg. Turning to slide 9, here are some other Q3 2023 highlights. As the slide indicates, operating revenue for 2024 should rise by roughly $10 million because Cal Water's return on equity will go up to 10.27%, taking effect January 1, 2024. That bump came from the Water Cost of Capital Mechanism covering October 1, 2022 through September 30, 2023; we'll get into more detail on this later in the presentation. In addition, Cal Water signed an agreement with the California Department of Community Services and Development aimed at assisting low-income customers in accessing funds via the state's Low Income Household Water Assistance Program so they can pay their monthly water bills. That's yet another illustration of what we're continually doing to deliver affordable water service to our customers. On slide 10, we show our earnings per share bridge, which lays out the changes from 2022 Q3 earnings per share to 2023 Q3 earnings per share. Now to slide 11, year-to-date 2023 financial highlights. As we covered earlier, because the California general rate case was delayed, we estimate the unfavorable effect on operating revenue for the first nine months of 2023 to fall somewhere between approximately $60 million-$93 million, with $16 million-$18 million of that tied to the DRMA... Our estimate rests on the current positions of the parties to the California General Rate Case filing and consumption-driven mechanisms. As mentioned before, we anticipate CPUC approval of the advice letter for 2023 DRMA operating revenue in 2024. As the slide notes, operating revenue for the nine-month period ended September 30, 2023, fell $65.4 million to $580.1 million, versus the same period a year earlier. That decline was mainly from a $48.8 million drop in WRAM and MCBA revenue, since those revenue mechanisms ended on December 31, 2022. There was a $20 million rise in revenue deferral and a $25.3 million decline in billed metered revenue; those decreases were partly offset by general rate increases, a change in balancing accounts, and interest on the net WRAM MCBA balances. Q3 operating expenses dropped $5.9 million to $538.2 million versus the same period a year earlier. All told, Q3 2023 operating expenses came in as expected. The decline largely stemmed from a $16.4 million reduction in costs tied to revenue deferral and a $3 million reduction in water production costs, which was partly offset by rises of $7.7 million in employee labor costs and $3.2 million of amortization expense, plus $1.9 million of property and other taxes. Now to slide 12, financial results year-to-date 2023. For the nine-month period ended September 30, 2023, net income attributable to Group was $21.7 million, or $0.38 earnings per diluted common share, compared to net income attributable to Group of $76.4 million, or $1.41 earnings per diluted common share for the nine-month period ended September 30, 2022. As we've said, our year-to-date results reflect the temporary absence of 2023 California general rate relief and revenue adjustments from regulatory mechanisms. Slide 12's footnote shows that during the 9 months finishing on September 30, 2023, Group placed $274.1 million into infrastructure investments — up 23.4% versus the equivalent stretch a year earlier. Turning to slide 13, we have the California regulatory mechanism items not yet recorded for the year to date. Revenue gets split out across the various mechanisms, and Greg has largely walked through what those involve. Let me proceed to slide 14, our EPS bridge for the year to date, showing what moved between earnings per share for the year to date through September 30, 2022 and earnings per share for the year to date through September 30, 2023; at this point I'll hand things over to Marty for slide 15.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#4

Thanks, Dave. Morning, everybody. As we sort of work our way through the murk of a rate case that's been pushed back, and of course with $60-$90 million in revenue that we're unable to book, or $0.93-$1.45 a share we can't recognize, we're sitting here waiting for that rate case to get approved, and it makes everything complicated. There are definitely a few other highlights I'd like to cover for the quarter. To start, like Dave just said, our capital investment program. Year to date, we've hit a new high. Heading into the Q4, we're on track for a record capital investment year for Group for 2023; and I want to remind everybody, that really is the basis and the foundation for which we grow future earnings. That continues to be strong. It's been a pretty, pretty mild summer out on the West Coast. Together with that mild summer, fire season, believe it or not, has been pretty mild too, apart from the fires that were experienced in West Maui. But all told, we've got roughly another 4 weeks of fire season so far, knock on wood, out on the West Coast. Things have been pretty tame, and we look forward to wrapping up fire season this year and then planning for the 2024 fire season. Turning to the West Maui fires, despite the amount of acreage burned, it was 6,753 acres, which is, which is not much at all, especially in California, when we've dealt with wildfires that have been in excess of 400,000 acres burned. They were very devastating, because it was an island. In Maui, the fires that took place in early August, there were really a series of three fires that were started, and it was really the kind of the perfect storm between a drought that they were having in the Hawaiian Islands, climate change, it's just been more dry and more arid. And then, believe it or not, you had the remnants of a hurricane and hurricane winds that came in, that caused these fires to really take off. In the upcountry, you had the Kula and the Olinda Fire, and those were close to our Pukalani system; in central Maui, you had the Lahaina and the Kihei fires; they burned about 3,200 acres; on the west side, you had the Lahaina fire, which was about 2,100 to 2,200 acres. And while none of our systems were directly affected, we do own the Kaanapali, the Kapalua, and the Pukalani systems. Things are very, very chaotic, and then I'm very happy to report that our employees follow their training. We do a lot of training for wildfire readiness. Our water systems performed very, very well. We've never lost pressure in our systems during the fire. And we did our job in terms of helping our customers protect their property by keeping their systems wet and the fire flows going for the fire departments as they battled these fires. In the same way, for several days following the fire, we were the sole supplier of drinkable water on Maui's west side. I'd like to take a moment and, you know, commend the team for sticking to their training and, you know, performing incredibly well through a highly chaotic and bewildering period. I believe all of us have seen media coverage of how local government responded, which only deepened the confusion, but credit goes to the Maui team for their outstanding work. The company's liquidity continues to be solid. We held $69 million in cash, with $34 million of that restricted. Our short-term borrowing capacity stands at $485 million. That's substantial as we await the general rate case ruling. There's no liquidity squeeze at the company, and given how our capital program is progressing, we don't expect any slowdown in the near future. We sold no shares under the at-the-market, or ATM, program we currently have in place, and we don't really expect to sell shares for probably the remainder of the year, and we'll assess what's needed as we move into 2024. Cash and cash equivalents rose by $32.8 million thanks to collecting the WRAM and MCBA balances. We wanted to highlight this because certain analysts had worried about whether the WRAM would be collectible once it went away. We've kept collecting that cash, and that has clearly strengthened our cash position both year to date and through the Q3. Another notable item this quarter: looking back at Q3 of 2022, we recorded a $9.3 million unrealized loss on non-qualified benefit plan investments. For the same period this year, that figure was a positive $700,000. So, you know, you can see the market shift from what was truly awful last year, and now these assets have steadied and turned more productive, contributing $700,000 in other income and expense. Moving to slide 16. As Dave said earlier, the Cost of Capital Adjustment Mechanism worked exactly as intended. The measurement window runs from 10/1, meaning October first through September thirtieth of a given year, and it monitors the Moody's Utility Bond Index along with movements in that index. When the bond index moves by more than 100 basis points, we can request an ROE adjustment equal to 50% of that change. So basically, the shift from September — pardon me — from October first, 2022 to September thirtieth, 2023 came to 140 basis points. As a result, we've filed for a 70 basis point adjustment to our return on equity, bringing it to a 10.27, plus a rise in our rate of return to 7.46, our overall rate of return, ARR, as that variable is termed in rate making. That's a Tier Two Advice Letter filed on October thirteenth. We anticipate approval at some point in early November. That leaves us the rest of the year to get those changes programmed into the tariffs so they take effect on October 1. As Dave said, this should contribute roughly $10 million to our earnings as we head into 2024. On the topic of regulatory developments, I'll pass it to Greg Milleman for an update on the California general rate case. Greg?

Greg Milleman

executive
#5

All right, just to clear something up about that cost of capital adjustment Marty brought up. He said October, with an effective date of October 1, but the truth is it takes effect on January 1. I believe you said that by mistake. Now, continuing on to the California General Rate Case. The key thing to note, as you're aware from Q2, is that a second judge joined our case; the judges have been sending us information requests, and those clearly show they're actively engaged and moving the case along, hopefully hitting the deadline that's presently in place to wrap it up by December 31, 2023. Turning to slide 18; here are the other regulatory items we're pursuing. As you can see, we've got an application filed to boost our ability to raise capital by $1.3 billion to fund our capital program. We're also pursuing recovery of expenditures we incurred tied to the drought, through those expenditures through the end of 2022. Last, we finished, filed and completed a rate case in Washington to raise our company revenues by $2.1 million; that took effect, I believe it was July 28, 2023. Moving to slide 19, I'll hand it back to you, Marty.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#6

Yes. Thank you, Greg. When it comes to PFAS and the regulatory landscape, there's no question that Q4 saw an enormous amount of media coverage regarding the settlement talks that were, that were taking place with the polluters. And although nothing has been finalized in terms of a settlement, there's definitely been plenty of activity. On our end, there's truly no shift in our, in our PFAS-related efforts; we have a memo account on file with the commission, which lets us monitor our incremental costs tied to PFAS testing; and then we submitted an application to amend that advice letter so that we can, so that we can track capital too. What matters about that is it lets us begin the work ahead of time, make those investments, and once the regulations eventually take effect, and are approved, we're able to seek recovery. I'd also like to highlight the two hundred million that we estimate as our capital requirements to treat PFAS and the systems we operate, is on top of the capital program that we discuss. So the slides included in this deck represent part of the rate case capital, which we plan for and handle in the normal course of business. A situation like this, when a regulatory change comes along that demands additional capital, that's exactly what it is. It's added on top of the capital spending that we present in the rate case, which is why we monitor it through the advice letter process. Turn to slide 20. You'll see where we stand roughly year to date, that $274 million. Once again, that's a fresh nine-month high for the company; and we're on pace heading into the Q4 for a record year of capital investment. Once again, on the whole, we don't anticipate the capital needs easing up at any point soon, and whatever goes toward PFOA, PFAS treatment is going to be additional to the figures that you see on the slide. In the same way, this slide will be trued up once we receive the final decision from the CPUC. This slide reflects what we've requested in the rate case and also what we've actually spent over the past couple of years while the rate case process has been underway. Now looking at slide 21, that investment carries through to our rate base. This is how our forecasted rate base appears given the current assumptions. And once again, this will be trued up when we get a decision from the commission based on the 2021 general rate case. So moving to slide 22, to sum up, where do we stand? Clearly, we're quite pleased that it's been a mild fire season and, you know, we didn't suffer any damage to our systems in West Maui. The Cost of Capital Adjustment Mechanism has set our ROE beginning January 1, and Greg, I appreciate that correction, at 10.27; we haven't seen an ROE above 10.2 in at least the past couple of decades. CapEx continues to be robust, and there are endless places to deploy capital. Regarding the capital portion of our operations, performance remains solid. As I noted previously, the uncertainty caused by a postponed General Rate Case is certainly capable of testing one's patience. The gaps in revenue we're seeing stem from the interim lack of regulatory mechanisms, and once the California Public Utilities Commission issues a ruling, we expect both that revenue and those mechanisms to be recognized. Similar to Greg, it's heartening to observe progress on the rate case, yet I'm equally aware of how maddening it is to sit through administrative holdups, which injects considerable muddle into financial reporting. The commission's existing target date to wrap up our 2021 General Rate Case is December 31, 2023, so with luck, the finish line is approaching. Beyond that, as we respond to their inquiries concerning the 2021 rate case, we've simultaneously been occupied with the 2024 rate case, which will demand a major company-wide undertaking, involving countless thousands upon thousands of pages of documentation and testimony being submitted. Our team has therefore been hard at work on it, and clearly, we continue advancing our PFOA and PFAS initiatives to remediate wells within our service territory that might contain trace amounts of those substances. With that said, Krista, let's begin taking questions, please.

Davis Sunderland

analyst
#7

Hi, everyone. It's a good morning, and thanks for letting me ask.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#8

Morning, Davis.

Davis Sunderland

analyst
#9

While reviewing the slide deck, I saw that nothing was provided regarding the business development pipeline. My question is whether that's just because there's nothing new to report, or perhaps it reflects a different way you're viewing things as we head into 2024 — or do you have any other thoughts?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#10

Actually, no — that's a fair question, Davis. Our perspective on 2024 hasn't shifted at all. The pipeline for business development remains extremely robust. The sole meaningful item during Q3 was our closing of the Stroh's system, which we'd already made public. Clearly, given the extra disclosures we chose to include in this deck tied to the rate case delay overhang, we simply felt there weren't many material changes over the past 90 days, and really no fresh announcements in that same 90-day window apart from the Stroh's system closing. We preferred not to take up the space at this point. In our view, that space was better used discussing the consequences of the postponed rate case, on both the revenue and EPS lines.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#11

Understood, and that's really useful. Thanks a lot. Then the sole remaining thing I had was regarding the filing with the CPUC concerning the $1.3 billion of equity and debt. Do you have any projections for when a ruling could return, or whether it would simply remain a steady pace of deployment, or perhaps some shifts stemming from the higher rate setting, or I suppose whatever else you might add would be useful. Thanks, everyone.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#12

Yeah. Greg, Greg, do you want to handle that one?

Greg Milleman

executive
#13

I caught a portion of that, and that's when it happens. Processing an application of that kind usually requires 6 to 12 months. Typically, there's very little controversy around it, though the commission still follows a procedure it has to complete.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#14

Sure, I'll address the latter portion of what you asked, Davis. So, what you observed was the cost of capital mechanism performing exactly as intended. And honestly, in my view, that cost of capital mechanism is something quite specific to California. I don't know of any other states that operate a Cost of Capital Adjustment Mechanism. As you're aware, during a period when interest rates are rising, that mechanism has proven helpful, and this marks the second instance, correct? A second increase in our ROE occurred because of the rising interest rate environment. As for the application itself, we submit it as part of routine operations. Essentially, it's a shelf, much like the shelf we submit to the Securities and Exchange Commission. In essence, the commission grants us permission to issue additional debt and equity to meet our requirements for funding our capital program and operating the business; it's an administrative procedure involving the commission. Once they give approval, we then need to keep a shelf on file with the SEC. This doesn't signal that we plan to execute a massive stock transaction tomorrow, or unexpectedly issue a large amount of new debt. It's primarily employed to address the company's financing requirements as we keep expanding our rate base, and our rate-based needs keep rising. So, once more, I'd like to emphasize that this Cost of Capital Adjustment Mechanism is functioning as it was intended to. I consider that a genuine advantage of California regulation, because we aren't forced to wait a couple of years before requesting an ROE increase, considering the rising interest rate environment. We can modify it annually, tied to movements in that Moody's Utility Bond Index.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#15

That's really useful. I appreciate you making room for us, everyone.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#16

Thank you, Davis. Take care.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#17

Morning, Marty, and everyone on the call. How's it going?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#18

Morning, Jonathan. Doing well, thanks — and you?

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#19

Oh, not too bad. Just getting into the swing of earnings now; so, I know you made the filing to increase the, you know, the ROE under the Water Cost of Capital Mechanism. Have any interveners opined on that increase? Or, you know, by what date must interveners weigh in if they wanted to?

Greg Milleman

executive
#20

Um, Jonathan-

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#21

That would be you, I believe.

Greg Milleman

executive
#22

Right. Jonathan, as of now nobody has stepped in. The filing went in on October 13th, which gives interveners 20 days. If my calculation is correct, that lands on November 7th. Still, it's 20 days starting from October 13th. My calculation was off. It's probably closer to November 3rd or 4th.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#23

Understood. All right. Are you—

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#24

Greg, that one is a Tier Two Advice Letter, right?

Greg Milleman

executive
#25

Okay, so this comes as a Tier Two Advice Letter, and that's the instrument our water division uses to issue approval. What they do is verify that we're meeting the obligations of the Water Cost of Capital Mechanism as established in the tariffs that have been approved, and in addition, they basically check that the numbers we've calculated are right. There's also a 7.46% overall rate of return reflected here. Past that point, however, there honestly isn't a great deal else involved.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#26

Understood. Alright, could you discuss perhaps what the approach might be for the upcoming cost of capital filing? From what I understand, it would be scheduled for submission next year. Hypothetically speaking, is there any interest in attempting to prolong the existing parameters, considering that the 2022 to 2024 application only just received a final order?

Greg Milleman

executive
#27

Right now we're in conversations about that with the remaining three water companies that are likewise expected to submit on May first of 2024. As of this moment, we have not landed on an approach.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#28

Alright, that covers everything I wanted to ask for now, since we're still waiting on the PD; it does sound encouraging, at least, that the ALJs are reaching out to you folks for informational requests. And, you know, that lines up with them definitely being active on the case, though hopefully wrapping it up. So best of luck with all that.

Greg Milleman

executive
#29

Thanks.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#30

Thank you.

Greg Milleman

executive
#31

Great. Thanks, Jonathan.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#32

Thanks. So, you know, returning to that slide — slide 13 — which essentially tries to connect the results so far this year with what they'd have looked like if the commission had actually reached a decision. So may I ask about the wide spread on that first line for IRMA? 1.1 versus 0.5 — well, that's quite a range. So why does a range exist here? Could you just walk me through it, given that there's a partial settlement in this case? Just so I follow, why is there a range at all?

Greg Milleman

executive
#33

Sure. The partial settlement was really about rate design issues; none of the capital projects we put in the program were addressed by it, and the disputed expense items — the O&M expense items — that we had in the case weren't addressed either. So the high end is what we submitted in our application. That represents our position, while the low end reflects what the consumer advocates Group believed we ought to get. So that's really the main explanation for the range. Not many items got settled, and not many revenue requirement items were settled — in fact, essentially no revenue requirement items were settled.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#34

All right. All right, and what about that DRMA account item? You're saying a determination on it will come in 2024, correct? So I suppose everything hinges on which point in 2024 that happens, but should we reasonably just shift that ruling, or that income stream, out of 2023 results and into 2024? Suppose the call is made, say, in January or February — I'm not sure — would it still be booked against 2023?

Greg Milleman

executive
#35

Dave, I believe that's one for you to take.

David Healey

executive
#36

Right, so regarding how the Advice Letter filing process operates, should a Proposed Decision come through, it will be finalized by year's end, and after that we'd need to get the Advice Letter filing ready during Q1 of 2024. It's a Tier Three filing, so that would require a number of months.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#37

Alright.

David Healey

executive
#38

... in order to secure the approval. Therefore, this is going to happen near the conclusion of the latter portion of 2024. Consequently, it won't be reflected in 2023.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#39

All right. And now, apologies, I'm skipping around like this; but that filing, you know, seeking authorization to put out a combination of stock and debt — is it reasonable to think I should figure that essentially, the stock piece matches the permitted equity percentage? What I mean is, so essentially, around 53% of it would be stock?

David Healey

executive
#40

Yes, that, that's a solid assumption.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#41

All right. And then, for my final question — I realize I could probably work this out from the earnings walk — but how much of a drag, on a year-to-date basis, has come from how your non-qualified pension funds have performed, if there's any at all? Rather than the year-over-year figure, maybe give me the absolute number.

David Healey

executive
#42

I believe slide 15 lays out those details.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#43

Okay.

David Healey

executive
#44

Are you referring to?

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#45

I’m taking a look at that. All right, I’ve got it now.

David Healey

executive
#46

You’re seeing that, the spot where we’ve got the—

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#47

9.3

David Healey

executive
#48

... unrealized loss in 2022-

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#49

Yes

David Healey

executive
#50

- versus the unrealized gain in 2023?

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#51

Got it. All right, I understand. So those figures aren't year-over-year comparisons — they're the real, actual numbers. Understood.

David Healey

executive
#52

Exactly right.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#53

Great. Perhaps one more thing — once again, I realize the GRC ruling hasn't come through yet, but presumably you can now see the greater ROE; you folks lifted the payouts this year by a fairly small amount, correct? Just 4%. Am I right in assuming that this was, you know, a temporary situation; so should we anticipate that the hikes in dividends will return to the pace they've historically followed? Or are we simply in an altered rate climate that will in some way hold back dividend expansion down the road?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#54

Angie, our general approach is to keep our payout ratio somewhere in the 50% to 60% band. We've remained fairly comfortably inside that band. Clearly, as the capital program expands, there's a constant requirement to fund that program. When you distribute a dividend, it reduces what you can put toward paying for that program. Even so, I believe we understand that we're a total-return kind of stock, and this company has a lengthy record of raising its dividend annually. Two things stand out to me. First, the financials as they stand today — which is why I refer to the fog created by the postponed rate case; it's extremely foggy. It's tough to see, since, as you just noted, we have estimates, and we're handing you the goalpost for where we believe the ruling will land, yet in the end we don't know. But once we record everything and bring everything current following the postponed rate case, the fog begins to lift, and you'll see how the financial statements appear. Second, I don't anticipate this company departing from its practice of boosting the dividend annually. That will most likely keep going. The real question is by how much. And clearly, we're in a climate of rising interest rates. The risk-free rate of return is currently 4.4% or higher, depending on which duration bonds you examine and which kinds of bonds you examine. I'm also very mindful that the compound annual growth rate, or CAGR figure tied to our dividend growth, helps propel stock valuation. So it's tough to state at this moment, but look, I would expect a dividend hike next year, in line with this company's record over the last 70 years. The question becomes how much, and has the rate case wrapped up? I don't believe we're ready to comment further on that today, but I think history will repeat itself with Cal Water. It's merely a matter of what size the increase will be.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#55

Alright. I realize I said I wouldn't ask anything else, yet here's another one.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#56

So, you all— Martin Kropelnicki: Of course.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#57

So, you've made a number of acquisitions — well, a few of them. The thing I want to ask is this: in a climate where financing costs more, will that approach keep going? Or is there more of a turn back toward growing organically? That's something, again, I think we're hearing from investors all over the utility sector. And like you mentioned, PFAS could hand you that extra organic growth; but still, from a strategic standpoint, is there a move in favor of organic growth and away from M&A?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#58

Yeah, I think I'll lean on the annual report we put out for this year. Keep things steady, right? I mean, it's definitely been a rough market, I'd say over the last 18 months to 2 years. Interest rates — you know, 2 years back, we were able to borrow at sub-0.5%, and these days our borrowing rates, what are we at? 6.5% on the line.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#59

Yeah.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#60

Well, our rating is A-plus stable as an issuer, so borrowing costs are climbing, and my feeling is that will separate purchasers from sellers. That said, Angie, our approach to acquisitions has consistently centered on value, and as you're aware, transactions could ease off somewhat, yet we'll keep hunting for those utilities we can add to our platform, enhance service for, and ideally direct fresh capital toward a system that might be underfunded. Therefore I stay positive about M&A. It may decelerate somewhat. Regarding what Davis raised before, the reason that slide wasn't part of this quarter is simply that only one system closed — the Stroh System in Washington. Roughly 900 connections were involved. That doesn't indicate our pipeline has lost anything; it only means no fresh announcements have been made during the past 90 days. Our business development group is quite strong. A few of you might have noticed we moved Shilen Patel into that position, heading it as our Chief Development Officer, and it's now his full-time responsibility; I believe we'll keep pursuing strategic transactions that prove accretive. And once more, we need to get past this confusion surrounding the delayed rate case, but our balance sheet is quite solid, and occasionally when conditions become difficult, better chances emerge. So we'll keep searching and keep at it.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#61

Okay, Krista. I appreciate all of you joining us on today's call, and thank you for remaining with us while we work through this rate case that has been delayed. With any luck, we're nearing the finish line here, as Greg said, and we can get this matter resolved, because clearly, heading into 2024, there are some significant objectives we're aiming to achieve. That's all for the moment. We're eager to share our year-end results at the end of February. In the meantime, please stay safe, and we can't wait to speak with you very soon. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#62

That wraps up the call for today. We appreciate everyone joining us, and you're free to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.