California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 29, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David Healey
executiveThanks, John. I'd like to welcome all of you to the call covering California Water Service Group's results for the fourth quarter and for the 2023 year. Joining me are Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our Chairman and CEO; Jim Lynch, our Senior Vice President, Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer; and Greg Milleman, our Vice President, Rates and Regulatory Affairs Officer. Details on the dial-in number for a replay of this call appear in the quarterly results release we put out earlier today. That replay can be accessed through April 29, 2024. One quick reminder before we get started: there's a slide deck the company has prepared to go along with today's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K yesterday afternoon, and you can also find it on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we dig into the fourth quarter and 2023 year results, we want to spend a few moments addressing forward-looking statements. Throughout this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since those statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly urges all current shareholders, along with interested parties, to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures regarding risks and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Q, press releases, and other reports filed from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. With that, I'll hand things over to Marty.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveHello, everybody, and thank you for being here this morning. Our audience is somewhat larger than usual as we walk through the year-end results. Plenty of you are already aware that Dave Healey came aboard as our Interim Chief Financial Officer. Together, Dave Healey and I are closing out the year. As the Principal Financial Officer, we will be certifying the financials. In essence, Dave and I are the ones signing the company's 10-K. Following a search across the country, as hopefully all of you saw in the press release, we wound up bringing in someone from right here in our own area, Jim Lynch. Jim has come on board with us as our Senior Vice President, Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer. Many of you, I believe, are familiar with Jim from the time he spent at SJW. What a lot of you likely aren't aware of is that Jim served as the audit partner on our account for a number of years, stretching back to when I came to the company; because of that, I've been fortunate enough to work alongside Jim over the last 18 years, and I'm extremely pleased that he has come on board with us as our Senior Vice President and CFO. Jim is going to take over a portion of today's presentation, though he won't begin certifying the financials until the Q1 10-Q is filed in April. That's what today looks like. We also have Greg Milleman with us to help discuss the situation with the rates delay, and the big topic of the day is likely the ongoing delay in the 2021 general rate case. As you're going to see, we couldn't determine what was reasonable to book on the basis of APD and an APD being issued. So we'll be addressing that over the course of the program today. Let's go ahead and dive into the financials with Dave, and then we'll be going back and forth as we present different sections of the presentation, after which I'll wrap up with some closing thoughts before we open things up to Q&A. So Dave, I'm handing it back over to you.
David Healey
executiveThanks, Marty. Turning to Slide 5, our financial highlights for 2023. For the full year 2023, net income attributable to California Water Service Group came in at $51.9 million, while 2022 was $96 million — that's a drop of $44.1 million, or 45.9%. Diluted earnings per share for 2023 were $0.91, versus $1.77 for 2022, which works out to a decline of $0.86, or 48.4%. The $44 million reduction in net income stemmed mainly from the delayed final decision by the California Public Utility Commission, or CPUC, regarding California Water Service Company, or Cal Water's pending 2021 general rate case, or GRC, which would establish new revenue rates and regulatory mechanisms. The 2021 GRC had originally been slated for completion on December 31, 2022, with new rates taking effect on January 1, 2023. Then on January 24, 2024, the assigned CPUC administrative law judges released a proposed decision — the PD — on the litigated 2021 GRC, and at the same time, the assigned CPUC commissioner put out an alternate proposed decision, or APD, that opposed and modified certain determinations the administrative law judges had made. The PD from the administrative law judges hewed more closely to Cal Water's requested revenue requirement, while the APD from the assigned commissioner hewed more closely to the revenue requirement requested by the Public Advocates. On February 13, 2024, Cal Water submitted a request to change several elements in the PD and APD, including fixing possible technical issues. We could not determine which of the two proposed decisions the CPUC will adopt, or whether a second alternate proposed decision might be issued. Because of the uncertainty about what the CPUC will ultimately decide, we cannot reasonably estimate the impact on 2023 operating revenue and expenses. Once the CPUC approves it, the 2021 GRC cumulative adjustment plus interest — retroactive to January 1, 2023 — will be recorded. Net income also got a positive boost of $18.5 million from an income tax benefit, driven primarily by a reduction in pre-tax operating income caused by the delayed 2021 GRC, along with a $12.1 million increase in net other income, mostly from unrealized gains on certain non-qualified benefit plan investments thanks to favorable market conditions in 2023. Now on Slide 6, 2023 full year operating revenue excludes a revenue adjustment for the 2021 GRC because of the delay. With that in mind, 2023 full operating revenue fell $51.8 million, or 6.1%, to $794.6 million, down from 2022 full year operating revenue of $846.4 million. The drop in revenue largely came from a $66.9 million reduction in WRAM and MCBA operating revenue, since those mechanisms ended on December 31, 2022, along with a $23.1 million decline tied to 2023 customer usage caused by heavy precipitation during the winter months and ongoing conservation efforts by customers related to drought. Partly offsetting those declines were 2023 rate increases of $30.7 million, primarily from a 4% rate increase across most of our California districts effective May 5, 2023, a rise in Cal Water's authorized return on equity from 9.2% to 9.57% effective July 31, 2023, and cost offset revenue increases for water production purchase water, purchase power, and hub tax rate increases. For full year 2023, total operating expenses fell $1.3 million to $717.5 million, versus full year 2022 total operating expenses of $718.8 million. That decline was mainly attributable to an $18.5 million increase in income tax benefit, largely driven by a decrease in pre-tax operating income resulting from the delay in regulatory approval of our 2021 GRC, plus a $3.7 million decrease in other operating expenses, which were partly offset by increases of $13.4 million in labor cost, $3.2 million in water production cost, and $6.6 million in depreciation and amortization expense. Turning to Slide 7 financial results year 2023, during 2023, net interest expense rose $5.5 million, or 12.4%, to $49.8 million compared with 2022. That increase was primarily due to higher short-term borrowing rates and higher outstanding borrowings on our short-term credit facilities. And now, I'll hand it over to Jim to cover Slide 8.
Jim Lynch
executiveAppreciate that, Dave. Now, looking at Slide 8, we've laid out several key accomplishments from 2023, and the highlight among them was what we achieved on the capital investment front. Across the year, our capital investment came in at slightly below $384 million. Within that figure, $326 million went toward our Cal Water service territory. That amount also encompasses $17 million for a developer-funded CIAC project; beyond that, Dave brought up the $18.1 million tax benefit we saw. That benefit largely stemmed from lower pre-tax earnings combined with our repairs and maintenance deduction, plus amortization of the excess deferred income taxes that gave us an advantage under the TCJA Tax Act of 2017. During 2023, we likewise saw a $12.1 million rise in other non-regulated revenue and expenses, which tied back to unrealized gains on specific non-qualified benefit plan investments. Moving to Slide 9, our total capital investment spend across the period spanning 2015 through 2023, driven in significant part by how well 2023 went, has averaged roughly 3x our depreciation expense. Looking ahead to 2024, we intend to make capital investments amounting to $365 million, contingent on the delayed 2021 general rate case being finalized. That 2024 estimate of ours leaves out capital expenditures tied to PFAS or AMI/AMR meter replacement programs. Now on Slide 10, our rate base growth demonstrates how well our capital investment efforts have paid off. CWT rate base, calculated using estimated amounts from our 2021 Cal Water general rate case along with estimated rate base from our other states, reached $2.25 billion as of the close of 2023, which is a 15.4% gain versus 2022. Now Slide #11 — finishing up our 2023 annual financial results on Slide 10 or Slide 11 is our earnings per share bridge. The earnings per share illustrates the major income and expense shifts between 2023 and 2022 that Dave covered, and it bridges our 2023 earnings per share to our 2022 earnings per share. The biggest factor was losing our WRAM and MCBA revenue without any replacement mechanisms, a consequence of the 2021 general rate case delay. With that, I'll hand things back to Dave so he can go over our quarterly results.
David Healey
executiveAppreciate that, Jim. Turning to Slide 12, as we went over, operating revenue for the fourth quarter of 2023 excludes a revenue adjustment tied to the 2021 GRC because CPUC approval has been delayed. Compared with the same period a year earlier, operating revenue in Q4 2023 rose $13.6 million, reaching $214.5 million. Driving that gain were $13.6 million in rate increases, $12.3 million in higher revenue stemming from a reduction in deferred revenue, and a $3.3 million bump in revenue from customer usage — partly offset by an $18.1 million drop in WRAM and MCBA revenue, since those mechanisms wrapped up on December 31, 2022. Operating expenses for the fourth quarter of 2023 climbed $4.6 million to $179.3 million versus the same period a year earlier. That rise came mostly from water production cost growth of $6.2 million, labor cost growth of $5.3 million, and depreciation amortization expense growth of $3.2 million, partly offset by an $11.2 million increase in income tax benefit. Now on Slide 13, financial results for the fourth quarter of 2023. As we discussed, net income excludes a revenue adjustment related to the 2021 GRC given the delay. In Q4 2023, net income attributable to California Water Service Group came to $30.1 million, with diluted earnings per share of $0.52, versus net income of $19.6 million and diluted earnings per share of $0.35 in the fourth quarter of 2022. The $10.6 million improvement was mainly driven by a $12.3 million revenue increase from a decrease in deferred revenue, an $11.2 million increase in income tax benefit, and a $2.8 million increase in net other income — partly offset by expense increases of $6.2 million in water production expenses, $5.3 million in employee wages, $3.4 million in depreciation and amortization, and $1.2 million in financing costs. Net interest expense for the fourth quarter of 2023 rose $1.2 million, or 11.2%, to $29.9 million versus the same period in 2022, mainly because of higher short-term borrowing rates and larger outstanding borrowings on our short-term facilities. During the fourth quarter of 2023, Group invested $109.6 million in infrastructure improvements, a 3.7% increase over the same period a year earlier. With that, I'll hand things to Jim for Slide 14.
Jim Lynch
executiveAppreciate that, Dave. We closed out the year sitting in a solid liquidity spot. The Group kept $85 million in cash, and $45.4 million of that was tagged as restricted. On top of that, we had roughly $420 million of short-term borrowing availability, coming from the combination of our Group and Cal Water credit lines. When it comes to our aged accounts receivable, our collection efforts got better during the fourth quarter, and by year-end we had brought down past due receivables by about $2.1 million versus the same point a year earlier. We're also taking part in the California Arrearage Payment Program. Back in November, we submitted an application for money under that program to address past due accounts through December 31, 2022. We asked for $83 million, and the state accepted our application. We're eager to get those proceeds, ideally by the close of the fourth quarter of 2024, or the close of the first quarter of 2024. A dividend was declared by us. I believe many people listening in saw that we announced a $0.08 dividend for 2024; this marks our 316th consecutive quarterly dividend and represents an increase of roughly 7.7% over the previous dividend. We stay committed to our ESG objectives as well. That's a top priority for the company. We examine every dimension of ESG, from climate change to affordability to our infrastructure investment and sustainability, and we made progress in all of those areas throughout the fourth quarter, along with our cap rates from earlier in the year. Moving to Slide 15, this is our earnings bridge once more, showing how we went from prior year fourth quarter earnings per share to current year fourth quarter earnings per share. Dave already covered many of these points, and the biggest one is the drop in WRAM and MCBA revenue with no replacement mechanisms because of the rate case delay. With that, I'll hand things over to Greg so he can discuss what's likely top of mind for almost everyone here — the update on the 2021 California general rate case.
Greg Milleman
executiveOkay, thank you, Jim. I’m not going to go back over what Dave covered at the beginning of this call about that topic. Everyone here is aware those rulings — both of them — came down. What I would add is that, from where we sit, the proposed decision had substantial evidentiary backing in this proceeding, while the APD did not. And the papers we submitted in February captured precisely that position. If you go to Slide 17, it wasn’t only Cal Water taking the view that the PD rested on solid evidence and aligned more closely with the commission’s own policies — our trade group, the California Water Association, submitted comments saying the same thing, and the seven other Class A water utilities in Southern California Edison jointly drafted a letter making that point and sent it to the commission too. Now on Slide 18, we also — during last week — sat down with the Board commission offices, laid out our worries about the APD, and pushed them to cast their vote in favor of the PD. So given everything that’s been submitted by so many parties, plus the people who spoke at public participation hearings, and simply the gaps between the PD and the APD, there is a great deal of uncertainty at this point about which way the commission will go on this. Let’s go to Slide 19, where I’ll touch on a few items tied to decoupling. Some encouraging news came our way: a letter arrived from the California Supreme Court that we got back in January. The parties were informed that the court would schedule arguments within the next few months. That’s a favorable signal. There had been no activity on this for a long while. Our hope is that the court strikes down the commission’s decision, which would do away with decoupling. That result would be quite beneficial for us. Either way, though, under the new 2022 law, we’ll be seeking decoupling once more in our 2024 general rate case. On Slide 20 now — as all of you are aware, our return on equity for 2024 already stands at $10.27. Back in February of 2024, we got the green light to postpone the cost of capital proceedings that had been set for later this year. The deferral we were granted was for one year, and that’s also welcome news. So when 2025 begins, our return on equity will again be $10.27, and it could be adjusted upward or downward depending on whether the Moody’s utility bond index moves by 100 basis points or more, following the water cost of capital adjustment mechanism’s procedures. With that, Marty, I’ll turn things over to you.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveThank you, Greg. I'll spend a little time discussing where things stand with PFAS regulations, then provide an update on business development, and afterward share some closing thoughts before we take comments. Regarding PFAS, there really isn't much new to report. We continue to await final adoption of EPA's rules covering Maximum Contaminant levels for PFOA and PFAS, and the draft targets sit at 4 parts per trillion. Right now, our expectation is that this will come out in the second or third quarter, though that remains our best guess at present. The company keeps developing plans for rapid implementation to address roughly 72 wells — 7 to 2 wells that contain some trace elements of PFOA and PFAS. Something we haven't mentioned previously: during the last Rate Case Cycle, we had 7 wells included for PFAS type treatment that we were able to implement over the last few years, and those are now in production. So we've actually gained a fair amount of experience implementing this type of treatment for PFAS in some of our central valley districts. Altogether, if you take the 25 wells total that we have current treatment on and add the 72, it's about 97 wells in total, out of about 1,000 that will require this type of treatment. So as Jim mentioned, the numbers we put on the street for our capital expenditures do not include anything associated with the PFAS treatment. Nor does it include anything — any type of recovery that is anticipated with the current pending PFAS litigation, and we do think there will be some dollars that come back to the company that will be a direct offset to those costs to help keep the PFAS treatment costs making it lower for customers. Moving on to Slide 22, looking at our business development slide. In 2024 to 2023, we closed 6 deals. If you look at the last 5 years, we've closed a total of 21 deals. These are typical things that we announced. When we signed the contract, and we provide an update in our quarter — quarterly earnings deck that talks about the status of where we are filing with the commission and getting it to close. So we closed 6 deals in 2026 including one significant PPP, public-private partnership, and you see the Camino Real Utility Water Pipeline, that's a public-private partnership with the Guadalupe Basin River Authority to extend their water transmission line in the Southern Austin market, which we believe will open up water services for an additional 10,000 connections, both on the water and wastewater side. I think as many of you heard, Eversource made announcements that they're going to be selling their water utility, which is the Aquarion. Obviously, we're going to be very interested in that, and we will evaluate that as I assume they will go through a public process. It's outside the territory we serve, but a big utility — particularly a water utility — coming up for possible purchase doesn't happen all that frequently. That said, we're quite uneasy about Connecticut's regulatory climate and how things have looked across the past 2 years, which has been less helpful than it used to be historically. So we'll factor all of that in once the process gets going, and we'll run our own internal assessment. So to wrap up, I'll just — let me be completely candid here. Look, I'm obviously let down by the ongoing postponements tied to our 2021 California General Rate Case. I'm grateful for the CPUC's work to deliver a decision ahead of our year-end deadline. I don't think they meant to add confusion, yet issuing a PD and an APD simultaneously has, in effect, only deepened uncertainty, because the 2 decisions differ. As Dave and Jim noted, because of the gap between the 2, we couldn't determine which of the 2 decisions will end up being adopted, so we couldn't book anything for 2023, and that shows up plainly in our results for the year. Even though that's a disappointment, I want to remind everybody that we do have memo account treatment for the 2021 General Rate Case. And once a final decision lands, it will apply retroactively to January 1, 2023. Put another way, when we finally reach a conclusion, the carrying costs and billing tariffs are adjusted, and a surcharge goes onto the customer's bill that essentially takes those adjustments back to 1/1/'23. That also means it gets recorded in '24, and we'll try to make the disclosures very clear about what that impact is in 2024. That way the Street can grasp what the dollar amounts are. What's sad about the ongoing postponements, I think, is that it simply becomes more expensive. Customers pay more because of the ongoing postponements, since those rates — the memo account keeps accruing interest. It costs us more as well as we go through the audit, because we have to sharpen our public company disclosures and get our accountants comfortable with where we stand on these PUC matters. And on the whole, customers get no benefit from it. But again, I don't believe the commission acted with bad intent. I think they were attempting to do something good. And hopefully, once we get into March, we'll have this resolved. The CPUC's next meeting falls on March 7. At that point, they could issue a stay. They could vote in the PD, they could vote in the APD. They could put out a new APD or modify either of the 2 decisions currently on the table. So March will be watched closely, and we'll see what the commission ends up doing. Of course, our public company disclosures will be released once the 2021 General Rate Case is finalized. The General Rate Case has obviously taken center stage and generated a great deal of work for us. Still, there are several other items from the year that I think deserve mention. To begin with, we satisfied and surpassed every primary and secondary water quality standard across all the states where we supply drinking water, meaning California, Washington, Hawaii and New Mexico. As Jim noted, we achieved a new record for capital investment tied to our infrastructure improvement plan, at $384 million. That represents a 17% increase year-over-year. We earned our second J.D. Power Award for highest overall customer service and best in the west. The Los Angeles Business Journal recognized us for outstanding corporate responsibility, and Newsweek again included us among the most responsible companies and most trustworthy companies in the U.S., ranking us #1 among the water utilities, #16 among all Energy & Utilities and 298 overall. As a fourth point, we keep making solid progress on our work to improve reliability, sustainability and climate change. I would simply draw everyone's attention to what happened with the West Maui wildfires. Nobody could conclude from that event that investing in wildfire readiness fails to pay off. As many of you will remember, we were the only water pumper in West Maui that remained in service throughout and after those fires. That outcome came directly from incremental investment made by the Hawaii Water Service Company to ensure we were prepared for wildfires. So it plainly worked, and credit goes to the team for performing well under very, very hectic circumstances. And finally, I want to note, as we said earlier, that we entered 2024 with a 10.27% return on equity in California. On top of that, California has approved our extension of the cost of capital proceeding, which means we will not need to file until the spring of 2025. As a result, we will enter 2025 with 10.275% ROE, plus or minus any adjustment tied to the cost of capital adjustment mechanism, which we will announce at the close of the performance period. So as we look ahead, there are a couple of key items we are focused on. Most obviously, the CPUC meetings concerning the delayed 2021 General Rate Case. March 7 is the next meeting, as I mentioned. Following that comes March 21, and there is a meeting on April 18 and also on May 9. We look forward to collaborating with the commission to get this decision completed and to keep moving forward. Second, in March, we will report on our continued progress with our ESG program, and we will set and publicly disclose our Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas reduction targets. I believe many of you know that we have developed a very thoughtful ESG program that is very Cal Water-centric, centered on how we support our customers and how we affect climate change. The team has performed really well on Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions, scientifically based processed, and we'll be making an announcement as of March. And in May, we'll put out our third annual SASB-aligned ESG report. Also, like Greg said, we'll be following our 2024 General Rate Case in July, which includes a new decoupling mechanism that I think matters a great deal for customers and the State as we grapple with climate change, a depiction. To wrap up, although the General Rate Case has generated plenty of additional work for the team and, I think, a good deal of confusion for the public, it has not pulled us away from our core mission of taking care of our customers and running our utility. As we look forward — we look forward — pardon me, we look forward to working with the CPUC on wrapping up the 2021 General Rate Case and following the 2024 rate case, including the decoupling mechanism. Though the regulatory process can ebb and flow at different times, our service standards and commitment to service do not, and they stay steadfast and focused on executing our business plan and doing what's right for our customers. And so with that, John, we will open it up for questions.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveIf there's anyone who doubts whether putting money into wildfire readiness pays off, remember that among all the water pumpers in West Maui, ours was the sole one that kept operating throughout that entire period, both while the fires burned and afterward. That outcome came directly from the step-by-step investments Hawaii Water Service Company made so that we'd be prepared for wildfires. It obviously paid off, and I give credit to the team for performing so well under extremely chaotic conditions. One final point, which came up before: we entered 2024 with a 10.27% return on equity in California. On top of that, California approved our request to extend the cost of capital proceeding, meaning no filing is required from us until the spring of 2025; consequently, we'll enter 2025 carrying a 10.275% ROE, give or take whatever adjustment stems from the cost of capital adjustment mechanism, which we'll disclose once the performance period wraps up. So here are a few important items on our radar going forward. Obviously, there are the CPUC meetings tied to the delayed 2021 general rate case. As I noted, March 7 is when the next one happens. Following that comes March 21, then a meeting on April 18, plus another on May 9. We're eager to collaborate with the commission to secure this decision and keep things moving. Next, during March we'll share how our ESG program continues to advance, and we'll publicly establish and reveal our targets for reducing Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gases. Many of you probably know we've built a thoughtful ESG program that is deeply Cal Water centric, centered on supporting our customers and on our impact regarding climate change. The team has performed excellently on the scientifically-based process for Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions, and those announcements arrive in March; then in May, our third annual SaaS be aligned ESG report gets released. Also, as Greg noted, this July we'll submit our 2024 general rate case, which includes a new decoupling mechanism that I consider highly important for customers and the state as we confront climate change adaptation. To wrap up, even though the general ATS has generated substantial additional work for the team and considerable confusion, I believe among the public, it hasn't pulled us away from our core mission of serving our customers and operating our utilities. We anticipate collaborating with the CPUC to finish the 2021 general rate case and then pursue the 2024 rate case, decoupling mechanism included. Regulatory processes may rise and fall at various moments, yet our service standards and dedication to service remain constant. We stay resolute and focused on carrying out our business plan and doing what benefits our customers. With that, John, let's take questions.
Gregg Orrill
analystAlright, thanks. So oral arguments before the Supreme Court regarding decoupling are scheduled to take place. Were you suggesting anything beyond that?
David Healey
executiveCorrect. Every utility involved in the case got correspondence at the start of this year, during 2024, indicating that the court intends to schedule a hearing date for arguments sometime later in the year. So each of us was notified about that.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveRight. Those briefings were submitted, so the court has factored them in. Basically, we've been told to expect that oral arguments will probably be placed on the calendar at some point. Our hope is that it happens in the next few months, though the court will have the final say on timing. Still, we're quite pleased to see that conversation progressing, and I'm eager to get it wrapped up too.
Gregg Orrill
analystYeah, absolutely. So when do you actually think a GRC result might come through? I realize it's scheduled for the 7th, but your guidance suggested you were looking for a decision within the first half of the year. And perhaps the follow-up to that is, you have pretty divergent results between the PD and the APD, and still, you felt confident enough to boost the dividend the way you did. How did you arrive at that?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveSure. Let's take the first portion of what you asked. Like Greg said, we've just finished 10 days of meeting with the commission through Ex Parte Communications, discussing how the PD and the APD differ and which of the two we thought was superior. In my mind, this is inside Marty's head, so I'm not claiming this reflects reality, but our company spent millions of dollars on a general rate case, and we found ourselves in a position where litigation of that rate case was necessary since the advocates refused to settle. So we litigated it, and two assigned judges reached conclusions on that rate case, and they put out the PD. And clearly the commission, our commissioner, saw things differently from what those two judges determined based on the finding of facts and the records submitted throughout the litigation process; so my view is the PD is superior because we underwent a complete process of vetting everything in that fully litigated rate case, whereas typically in California, we have a settled rate case. This one required full litigation except for the rate design; so I think, as I mentioned before, I don't believe they meant to cause confusion. I'm not certain what their intentions were, beyond attempting to reduce some of the costs. But for those of you who have followed and studied Cal Water, we place great emphasis on affordability because we understand you need a balanced approach to your capital plan and some rate continuity rather than simply constructing infrastructure, which explains why we've devoted considerable effort across the last 10 years developing capital plans that look 10, 20, 30 years ahead. So I think the commission has to choose which decision it believes is correct based on the findings and facts. We've completed our portion at this point. We have submitted comments. It has made me quite pleased to observe that SoCal Edison, along with the remaining water utilities, has more or less entered the battle, particularly when it comes to certain mistakes and items that found their way into the APD, which might end up altering how rates get set in California — chiefly regarding reliance on contingencies whenever you're projecting projects stretching across several years, and also the practice of pulling projects approved in earlier rate cases and then declaring that no, those now must be submitted through an advice letter. That basically amounts to a more backward-looking approach to ratemaking here in California. For a very long stretch, this has been a state that sets rates prospectively; therefore, in my view, the commission is going to have to reach a conclusion on this. As for the latter portion of what you asked, Gregg, could you say it again for me, please?
Gregg Orrill
analystMy guess is that what happened with the dividend suggests there isn't much of a gap at all between the PD and the APD. Where am I getting that wrong — can you set me straight?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveHappy to. If we look at it from the dividend side, let's walk through the governance steps behind it. Each fall, the Cal Water Board handles a great deal related to officer succession planning, comp and benefits, plus capital and dividend planning too. Typically, our conversation about the dividend begins in October and November, and by January we wrap it up as a Board. Here's the thing — the company's fundamentals strike us as solid. As Jim noted, the estimated rate based growth year-over-year. California regulation's fundamentals, in our view, have stayed favorable. That's the reason we received a 10.275% ROE. So clearly there's some unease about this delayed rate case and the reasons it's been pushed back so far. I can't stand here and offer excuses on behalf of the commission. It doesn't sit well with me. And honestly, if pancakes rates on customer increases, that's not good; but I think we'll come out the other side of this. The company's fundamentals, I believe, are solid; and so our dividend has gone up annually stretching back decades. And we think the company's fundamentals are good and rate based growth is good. You saw that in the capital spending, which is good, it rose 17% year-over-year. All of that feeds into rate case and all of that, as it moves through the rate making process, helps lift revenue and cash flows. That cash flow gets used to reward investors who put money in us, and the remaining portion of the cash flow gets reinvested in infrastructure. So the fundamentals, in our view, remain good.
Gregg Orrill
analystI appreciate that response.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveI appreciate it, Gregg. Enjoy your day.
Jonathan Reeder
analystHey, you sort of addressed one of the things I was going to ask when you answered Gregg, but right now, given that the written comments have been filed and other parties have entered the fray and all that, have all the pushes from the parties already happened when it comes to these filings and ex parte meetings, so that the case is really just in the commission's hands now?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveAll of the Ex Parte Communications have been submitted. I believe a few additional comment letters are still arriving from some of the firefighters association and firefighters chiefs — fire chiefs. But once again, none of that involves us when it comes to drafting their letters or their comments. Third-parties handle all of that; so my feeling is a few more are still on the way. But yes, once those are finished, it truly rests with the commission. And the commission did hold an open meeting — Greg, do you recall the date on that?
Greg Milleman
executiveFebruary 15.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveFebruary 15. And how many people did they have speak?
Greg Milleman
executiveTwenty.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveTwenty individuals gave comments, voicing worries regarding the APD compared with the PD; every one of them expressed the view that the PD is the better option and that we should keep moving forward with adjusting to climate change, wildfire damage, and creating resilience along with sustainability across California. So Jonathan, I'd say we're nearly there. Ultimately, in my view, the commission needs to absorb all of that information and afterward determine its course of action.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAlright. You suggested the 2024 CapEx plan sat at $365 million, though it hinges on what the GRC decides. My read is that figure assumes an outcome closer to the PD plus what you asked for. Could you walk through how the capital budget would shift, I suppose, under an APD adoption?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveBoth yes and no. Conceptually, you've got it exactly right. Since the timing is late, that ruling might reshape the 2024 capital program. Yet should you be fortunate enough to get through those 600 pages of whichever decision, the APD states that capital work remains permissible — it simply must go through an advice letter; and one of our objections is that much of that capital received approval in the prior rate case. That explains, I believe, why other utilities grew so curious about this situation, since once more it involves a forecasted capital state and rules being altered retroactively. So how they'll rule, I can't say. Clearly, when Greg and I sat down with the commission, a major objection we raised was that rules functioning as a longstanding standard in California's regulatory process were being changed. So it all comes down to their direction. That said, they're essentially telling us, hey, your capital work can proceed, advice letters are available, and look, a company must, each year and continuously, perform a risk assessment identifying where capital delivers the most efficiency and fills the greatest need. So — and if we deploy capital beyond a rate case, we may either submit an advice letter or have it captured in the following rate case filing; thus nothing within the process stops a company from doing what it deems necessary to operate a solid water utility and stay on course toward achieving our goals and objectives. What it does mean is simply this: how will that get covered? Will it be pre-approved capital, where you put it in the ground and face an earnings test, which is how things have historically worked, or must you use an advice letter, meaning you make the investment, obtain plant service, then begin depreciating and request an advice letter, or do you capture it in the next general rate case? Greg, anything you'd like to add there?
Greg Milleman
executiveRight. So, yes — I’d just say this: there were a small number of projects they considered unsuitable, but the remaining ones we turned down tended to involve constructing first and pursuing cost recovery afterward, which, as you pointed out, Marty, departs from the forward-looking approach to rate making that states follow; my point, though, is that they never described those projects as poor ones — they acknowledged the need for them. The question is simply how you obtain rate recovery?
Jonathan Reeder
analystRight, so with that in mind, it seems like the greater CapEx amounts you've been putting to work — we ought to expect that continues, or if not, that it grows, what with PFAS and what I suppose are mounting spending requirements, such that if we look past 2024, should we be holding those levels closer to something like $265 million or $283 million — pardon me, the 365 and the 383 from this year?
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveYes. Jonathan, what I can tell you is, look, this company has built a genuinely strong long-term capital plan, one that lets us attempt to strike a balance between affordability and what the infrastructure requires, along with expanding resiliency and reliability and contending with climate change. So I don't expect that to ease up. What we're dealing with at the moment is likely a hiccup tied to the commission, since the rate case has run so late. But the work we need to do has to keep going, and that's the reason I wanted to call attention to West Maui. All of that was work undertaken alongside the Hawaii Commission to harden those systems. And nobody should be taken aback that, once the fires were extinguished, ours was the only water company still pumping water across the entire West side of Maui; that came about by design, by sound planning, by solid employee training, by installing backup generation, by carrying out the wildfire work, and the wildfire farming process would involve inspections to confirm properties are cleared. So being prepared for these situations carries a cost. Still, I believe we've ultimately delivered strong performance. Consider the storms from earlier this year and every storm last year; you saw no meaningful Cal Water outages. We never lost power. And then there are further marginal benefits that go uncounted when California's grid has lacked sufficient energy — when the Governor's Office phones, for instance, and says, hey, give us whatever you've got, we could pull 6 megawatt off the grid by relying on those backup systems we'd installed. So every one of these pieces has to fit together. And it matters a great deal that the commission adopt a long-term, comprehensive perspective, which is the perspective this company has applied to its capital; so I don't foresee capital slowing much. I don't foresee it slowing dramatically, because there's a great deal of work ahead of us.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAlright, that clears things up quite a bit. Best of luck with the rate case; and yeah, we'll find out whether something comes through for you on March 7, or whether it takes a bit more time.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveOkay. Appreciate it, Jonathan. Thanks for what you had to say.
Marty Kropelnicki
executiveThanks, John. And thanks to all of you for being here today. Once more, we'll make sure everybody stays up to speed on where things stand regarding the commissions — so keep an eye out for a press release and the 10-K, basically the disclosures a public company is expected to put out. In the meantime, our plan is to keep operating our utility as well as we possibly can, and honestly that means keeping our attention on the customer and doing what's right. So I appreciate you giving us your time today. Should you have any additional questions afterward, don't hesitate to get in touch with any of us. Thanks, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone for joining in; you're free to disconnect at this point. Have a wonderful day, all of you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.