California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 25, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Water Utilities earnings 48 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jim Lynch

executive
#1

Thanks, Ellie. Hello, everybody, and welcome to the results call for the first quarter of 2024 at California Water Service Group. Joining me on this call are Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our Chairman and CEO, and Greg Milleman, our Vice President of Rates and Regulatory Affairs. Details for the replay dial-in can be located in the release covering our quarterly results, which came out earlier today. You'll be able to access a replay until Monday, June 24, 2024. Just a note before we get started — the company has prepared a slide deck that goes along with today's earnings call. That deck was furnished with an 8-K and can also be found on the company's website at www.calwatergroup.com. Before we review the first quarter 2024 results, I want to spend a few moments addressing forward-looking statements. At points during this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since these statements concern future events, they carry various risks and uncertainties, and actual results may differ materially from what the company currently expects. Given that, the company strongly encourages all current shareholders, along with interested parties, to carefully read and understand the company's disclosures regarding risks and uncertainties contained in our Forms 10-K, 10-Q, press releases, and other reports filed from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. And with that, I'll hand the call over to Marty.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#2

Thanks, Jim. Morning, everybody. Appreciate you being here with us to discuss what we delivered in Q1 2024. There are several items on our agenda, and we'll begin with the solid operational results we achieved, something the final decision in the 2021 general rate case makes completely clear; and honestly, once we got past the holdups that dragged through 2023, it's great to watch every indicator pointing the right way, and huge credit goes to Jim and — Jim and the team for locking everything in and having it ready as Q1 comes to a close; beyond that, we want to address what the water cost of capital adjustment mechanism means, since it puts our ROE for 2024 at 10.27%. We also managed to obtain another $83 million in COVID funds from the state of California, which will assist our customers dealing with past due balances built up during our COVID period, and after that we'll discuss our current position on PFOS along with the EPA's new rule and how we intend to comply with it. Then, to finish, we'll cover the pledge we made not long ago to cut our Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions; but before we move into those more operational subjects, I'll hand things back to Jim so he can walk through the financial results for the first quarter of 2024. Jim?

Jim Lynch

executive
#3

Thanks, Marty. Like Marty said, the first quarter results got a boost from wrapping up our 2021 general rate case. Operating revenue rose 106.5% to $270.7 million for the quarter, versus $131.1 million in the first quarter a year earlier. Two regulatory mechanisms approved in the 2021 GRC decision made a big difference to revenues: the Interim Rate Memorandum Account, or IRMA, contributed $80.7 million, while the Monterey-Style Water Revenue Mechanism, or M-WRAM, added $31.7 million. Recorded IRMA and M-WRAM revenue came to $70.2 million and $17.6 million, respectively, tied to fiscal year 2023. Greg will take us through the 2021 GRC decision later on. The revenue gain also reflected $13.9 million from recognizing Water Revenue Adjustment Mechanism, or WRAM, revenue that had been deferred in earlier reporting periods. First quarter 2024 operating expenses climbed $192.9 million, compared with total operating expenses of $148.6 million in the first quarter. That $44.3 million rise was mainly due to $9.2 million in higher water production costs tied to the company's new incremental cost balancing account, or ICBA, along with higher other operations expenses, largely from $11.4 million in deferred costs linked to the recognized deferred WRAM revenue, plus a $21.2 million increase in income taxes from higher pretax earnings. Net interest expense rose 25.5% to $15 million in the first quarter, versus $12 million in the first quarter of 2023. That increase came mostly from higher short-term borrowing rates and larger balances on our outstanding lines of credit. Reported net income for the first quarter was $69.9 million, up nearly 415% from a loss of $22.2 million in the first quarter of 2023. Now for earnings per share: first quarter 2024 diluted earnings per share was $1.21, compared with a first quarter 2023 loss of $0.40 per share. The big jump in EPS came from resolution of our 2021 general rate case, along with rate increases and the reversal of previously deferred WRAM revenue. Those gains were partly offset by higher expenses, including increased water production expenses tied to the new ICBA regulatory mechanism, higher production expenses from the reversal of WRAM related deferred production costs, and interest expense. On capital, we keep making sizable investments in our water utilities to help ensure safe, reliable water service. We put just under $110 million into capital improvements in the first quarter of 2024. That was up roughly 34% from the first quarter of 2023; for the year, we expect to make about $380 million in capital investments, including an estimated $20 million in developer funded projects. Depreciation for the first quarter of 2024 was $32.8 million, or approximately 30% of first quarter capital investment expenditures. Our rate base growth shows how well our capital investment strategy is working. Overall rate base grew to an estimated $2.2 billion by the end of 2023. Compared with 2022, that represented a 15.4% rise. Also, assuming regulatory approval comes through and taking into account the capital expenditures we currently have planned, our estimate is that the rate base will reach $2.36 billion by the close of 2024 and $2.47 billion by the close of 2025. On the dividend side, early in the year we raised the annual payout 7.7%, taking it from $1.04 to $1.12 per share — that makes 57 years in a row of annual dividend increases; and yesterday, for shareholders of record as of May 6, 2024, we declared a quarterly dividend of $0.28 per share. That comes to 317 straight quarters of dividends. Our liquidity position remains solid. On March 31, 2024, cash and cash equivalents held by the company totaled $88.3 million, with $45.4 million of that classified as restricted. On top of that, we had $320 million in extra short-term borrowing capacity available through our lines of credit. Finally, we're happy to share that after the quarter closed, we collected roughly $83 million through the state of California extended arrearage program. That program exists to give financial help to customers whose past due balances built up during the COVID-19 pandemic. Marty is going to offer more detail about the program shortly. I'll now hand things over to Greg for an update on our 2021 General Rate Case decision. Greg?

Greg Milleman

executive
#4

Absolutely. Thank you, Jim. I'll go over a few key points from the ruling on our 2021 GRC, which we got on March 7, 2024. On the whole, this outcome was quite favorable financially for the business. As Jim mentioned, for 2023 the ruling raises adopted revenues, once corrected, by roughly $41.5 million, applied retroactively to January 1, 2023. The ruling likewise approved 95% of the operating expenses we asked for. It approved a highly advantageous mix of groundwater versus water, giving the company financial protection. It gives Cal Water the green light to put $1.2 billion to work, satisfying 86% of what we sought between 2021 and 2024 for water system infrastructure projects, among them about $160 million in infrastructure projects that can be filed for cost recovery through the PUC's advice letter process. In fact, we have already submitted an advice letter covering 145 projects with $39 million capitalized, for a $5.8 million bump in yearly revenues. The ruling sets out a highly forward-looking rate design that delivers financial stability while helping low income, low water using customers. And last, and most significantly, when the commission voted the ruling through on March 7, all of them concurred that the process ran too long, so I am optimistic that the ruling in our '24 case will arrive more promptly. Over to you, Marty.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#5

Okay, thank you, Greg. I'll just add to your point about being in that hearing room alongside the commissioners — each one of them brought that up, and we view it as an encouraging signal that they understand the difficulties this created, both for our company and for the people we serve, since it leads to a compounding impact on rates. I'll be referring to Slide 10. Let me return to California's expanded arrearage management initiative. As I believe a lot of you are aware, we've taken a very proactive stance, with our government affairs group in Sacramento, searching for ways to assist customers still dealing with what amounts to a lingering effect of the pandemic. As you may remember, California initially ran an arrearage management program that addressed roughly half of the COVID period before it ended; through that initial phase, our company managed to obtain just over $20 million, which went toward reducing what our customers owed during COVID. We then collaborated with the state to redirect a portion of the unspent federal money that had been given to the states, creating what amounts to a second arrearage management program. Together with the state, we helped direct somewhere between $300 million and $400 million in unspent federal funds and reopened that application window so that utilities and water providers could seek additional money to write off overdue balances spanning June 16, 2021 through December 31, 2022. I'm pleased to say our filing was approved and we got the full amount we asked for — the $83 million Jim referenced; those funds are now in hand, and over the second quarter we'll be directing them toward those pass-through balances, again covering June 16, 2021 through December 31, 2022. This support reaches both current customers and pass-through customers, since ultimately every customer shares in the burden of uncollectible accounts. Now on Slide 11, I'd like to briefly bring everyone up to date on the status of the PFAS rules that have been issued, otherwise called forever chemicals. We feel we remain in a strong position to satisfy the EPA's new standards. Throughout our operations, we maintain a stringent, well-coordinated water quality assurance effort, with procedures established for testing and monitoring the water supplied to our customers. Many of you, I think, are aware that when you invest in investor-owned water utilities, safeguarding public health ranks among the most critical responsibilities the company has; we've gained considerable experience with PFO and PFAS in California and Washington. Our utilities have met the earlier PFAS standards set by state regulators. On April 18, the California Public Utilities Commission rejected our request seeking approval to alter a previously authorized PFAS expense balancing account in order to enhance capital investments tied to PFAS compliance. The CPUC told us that recovery of the capital portions of PFAS treatment would have to be sought through a filing at a later stage. To put it plainly, one thing off the top is that their rejection let me down; they threw it out without prejudice, yet that leaves us able to submit a standalone application or fold it into the 2024 general rate case. And Greg, my understanding is that we intend to submit it as a standalone application?

Greg Milleman

executive
#6

That is correct.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#7

On the separate rate case: even though the commission failed to grasp how urgent it is to get this PFAS treatment deployed, the company issued a press release restating our pledge to customers that we will spend that $215 million quickly to install PFAS treatment for roughly 100 wells across every state where we do business. Broadly speaking, this is a parent company project; a project director is in charge of rolling it out in each of our states within that group. On a regular basis, that group, or rather that project director, reports to the management committee. And we have already gotten moving; our plan is to spend somewhere in the range of $12 million to $20 million on PFAS treatment this year, and that figure will climb as we move further into the implementation period over the coming 2 years.

Greg Milleman

executive
#8

Marty, before you move on, you mentioned PFAS balancing account…

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#9

This is a memo account. Thanks — it's a memo account. That sits outside the rate case, and we're the ones bearing the cost. It flows through to the P&L, but we're permitted to track those costs, and we went to the commission asking for permission to adjust that memo account so it would capture the capital components, and that request was turned down. In ratemaking, our capital projects do get an AFUDC allowance — funds used during construction — approved, and that will show up all the way through the process until the plant goes into service. Turning to Slide 12, on the topic of greenhouse gas and our Scope 1 and Scope 2 reduction targets: as we spent the last 5 years developing our decarbonization strategy and our ESG strategy more broadly, we recently committed to cutting absolute Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gases by 63% by 2023, measured against our baseline of 2021. These targets are science aligned, and the team has done a great job partnering with a third-party adviser to assemble that data; we anticipate hitting these reductions via a multi-prong approach made up of fleet electrification, conserving water, putting in on-site solar in the places where it makes sense, and exploring renewable electricity procurement. Put differently, ensuring we're covered on the green side of the grid for the power we consume. A lot of you probably remember that producing and distributing water takes a great deal of energy. The more green energy we're able to use, the more it moves us toward that target, along with the other pieces of this multi-prong strategy. As a quick FYI, the group might revise its decarbonization strategy if circumstances warrant it, given shifts in the industry, our work with the regulator, our business, and other operational developments that could arise, such as SEC rules, and so forth. All in all, we remain deeply committed to delivering value for our customers and stockholders as we pursue these reduction targets; we see it as the correct long-term path as we confront climate change. Moving to Slide 13, just by way of a recap, I'm quite pleased with how 2024 has begun and with having the 2021 rate case behind us. It's good to have that finished. The numbers are going to be somewhat confusing, obviously. Once we publish the 10-Q later this week, there'll be additional detail, so you can separate out the retroactive portion from the portion that actually belongs to the quarter itself. Our focus now shifts to executing our infrastructure improvement plans. As Greg said, we have a substantial amount of capital to get into the ground, on top of the PFAS. The guidance Jim provided everyone earlier does not factor in the $215 million commitment for PFAS — for the forever chemical treatment — that we've made to our customers; that will come on top. Also, please mark this on your schedules: our appearance before the state Supreme Court is set for May 8, which concerns oral arguments regarding the commission's land decision. We're eager, ideally, to receive a ruling from the State Supreme Court roughly 3 months following oral argument, give or take. We anticipate that outcome because we firmly hold that decoupling is completely vital for California. It supports efforts related to climate change, resiliency and sustainability. Having said that, I'd like to express gratitude to everybody for tolerating the postponements in the 2021 general rate case. My thanks go to the rates and accounting teams for their dedication. Beyond finishing the year, immediately afterward we received the decision and needed to get everything posted. The team performed wonderfully, getting all of that recorded in the general ledger. And now we'll proceed to our 2024 plan, putting money into infrastructure, pursuing PFAS and getting PFAS treatment swapped out, and submitting our rate case for the State of California around July 1 — on or about July 1. Ellie, let's begin taking questions now, please.

Mike Gaugler

analyst
#10

Morning, everybody. I was hoping you might bring us up to speed regarding order supply along with what we're paying to produce water. It struck me that those came in pretty elevated this quarter. Jim did mention it briefly, and perhaps you can tell us how to frame that for the rest of the year.

Jim Lynch

executive
#11

Sure. So when it comes to water supply, Michael, things are going quite well in the state of California. For a second year in a row, I think our snowpack came in above our 20-year average; and in a very long stretch, this strikes me as the first occasion where we've exceeded that average 2 years running. I'd say conditions look favorable. There's also been a solid chance to recharge certain underground aquifers across California. My sense is that our other states sit in a similarly strong spot when it comes to actual water supply; we do run some operations in Texas. The majority of our utilities in that region are wastewater utilities; and I don't believe the present water picture in Texas has placed any strain on those operations. Turning to expenses and water expenses, here in California, with the new rate case, we have the new ICBA, which gives us a degree of protection when it comes to cost increases in our water production. So we'll rely on that new mechanism and concentrate on it as we grow more familiar with how the new mechanism works. And I'd add that we did see a rise in other production expenses. I brought it up in my — during my comments, and those were mostly tied to the recognition of the deferred WRAM revenue. I'd characterize those as something that will keep shrinking as we sort of unwind those deferral — deferred revenue costs.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#12

Yeah. One additional point: the snowpack is looking really strong. In California, our water supply is in excellent shape, I'd say. The state remains under a stage 2 drought designation. As you may recall, we were heading quickly toward stage 3, and then the governor reversed that decision. Stage 2 is still where we stand, and my expectation is that the governor keeps us there or perhaps moves us to stage 1, considering the more enduring sustainability challenges facing California. There's climate change, plus the swings in weather patterns we experience; still, taking 2024 as a whole, we believe things look solid across every one of our districts.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#13

I have a few things to ask, if that's alright. To start, what's the right way to view when the cash from the retroactive 2023 GRC revenues will come back to us?

Greg Milleman

executive
#14

Jonathan, Greg Milleman here; given when the '21 decision landed and the '24 rate case filing we've got coming on July 1, our attention has been on putting the new rate in place and getting those into effect first, working out the lost revenue, or the IRMA amount, plus the M-WRAM amount, so that we can book it; in the third quarter we'll file to recover those back monies. We have to get through May 31, which is when we expect the new rates to be fully in effect and the IRMA accounts closed out, but after that we need some time to assemble that filing and begin asking for it. The third quarter is when we'll begin asking for it; it works off a per CCF surcharge. My guess is that during the summer it will be somewhat higher. And then clearly, across the winter months it'll be lower and run somewhere 12 to 24 months.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#15

All right. So it seems like that money really won't show up during 2024. More likely, it'll land in '25 and '26?

Greg Milleman

executive
#16

Those revenues were recorded in Q1. My understanding was that you were asking about cash.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#17

No, precisely, that's right. Those cash flows won't arrive before '25 and '26. My apologies.

Greg Milleman

executive
#18

Yes. One thing I'd mention, though, regarding when the new rates take effect, at minimum we'll see the favorable cash increase tied to those new rates as we head into what's traditionally our busiest period. It made us happy that we could get the rates in place as of June 1.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#19

Got it. Now, regarding that $83 million program for past-due payments — is it possible that the money we recover could reduce how much outside equity we need in 2024?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#20

Yes. If you remember, during COVID we had decoupling in place. The State of California's decoupling mechanisms account for all revenue. What this ultimately becomes is cash flow. Essentially, for customers who still owe overdue amounts from the period I mentioned — June 16, 2021 through the end of 2022 — those payments are credited to what they owe, and a portion of those amounts will also be applied to the WRAM balance those customers had. Every bit of that ends up in cash flow, yet revenue itself stays untouched. What it does touch is the receivables sitting past due from the COVID period, so you'll notice an uptick in cash flow. That clearly gives these companies room to sidestep heading to the market and having to sell equity on short notice. As we all know, water utility shares across 2023 got hit by declines of 20% or more, so we're in no rush to go out and peddle stock to the market. And Jim isn't lobbing any documents my way for saying so. Of course, when you factor in this rate case and the way the rate structure has shifted—moving away from variable recovery toward a larger share being fixed—all of that should benefit us for the rest of the year. Still, looking at what we need to spend on capital, our investment level remains three times what we record as depreciation. And, as Greg pointed out, we received 86% of what we requested. With a $1.2 billion capital plan, our lines and so forth are sufficient. Even so, Jim and I will keep assessing that situation as the year unfolds to pin down exactly what is required. Clearly, given that interest carrying costs have risen and the stock price has fallen, we still have to deliver on our responsibilities. We'll be examining our capital structure closely, aiming to strike the right balance for the benefit of our shareholders while keeping our customers in mind too, since that feeds directly into making things more affordable.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#21

Alright, so when it comes to the absolute magnitude of yearly equity requirements, that hasn't been settled yet, correct?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#22

Yeah, I'd agree with that, Jon. What's really encouraging is that once we recognized the 2023, being able to account for the 2023 effect from the 2021 decision has returned us to the position we'd been aiming for at this stage regarding our cap structure, and that's quite near our authorized cap structure. At present, there's no necessity, I wouldn't frame it as a necessity, but steering us toward selecting which specific capital we'd go after should we ever need to raise capital. So I believe at this moment, we have substantial room available on our line of credit. We recognize that interest rates remain inverted, so we'll be evaluating short term against the long-term debt, along with other factors, as we proceed. However, it's only by recording the results of the current rate case, the 2021 rate case results, that we're now able to sort of project what we believe we could require from a capital standpoint for the rest of the year. And we're additionally gaining from the higher ROE that took effect on January 1, the 10.27 ROEs. That is also assisting us with our cash flows.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#23

Yes, absolutely. I appreciate you raising the ROE topic. It sort of sets up my next question, since considering the final GRC result along with recouping part of the CapEx or the advice letter recovery mechanism, — what earned ROEs do you anticipate for '24 and '25 compared to the permitted thresholds?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#24

That's an excellent question. '25 is definitely a bit more difficult to address. But when it comes to budgeting and running this company, right, our aim is to push toward achieving that ROE. Naturally, if a rate case gets delayed, it disrupts everything, throwing it considerably out of balance. For 2024, I believe we ought to land at or perhaps a touch above that ROE. By 2025, regulatory lag begins to creep in, and clearly, inflation is a major factor. To return to what Michael Gaugler asked regarding production costs, in Northern California for time-of-use electricity rates, the price is currently $0.40 to $0.50 per kilowatt hour, which is the steepest in the U.S. Those are things that impact operations and will also lag. And ideally, a portion will be captured in the rate case. But if inflation remains elevated, much of it gets deferred to the following rate filing; so for 2024, I'd say we're in great shape; for 2025, we'll set our budget around ROE, and that's essentially what we're tasked with. And as Jim mentioned, there's a chance with inverted interest rates in the short term versus the long term, in how we handle financing, we'll examine all of that since our responsibility is to run things as efficiently as we can while generating an ROE for shareholders and maintaining affordable rates for customers. '25 is tough to say much about. '24, we'll push aggressively toward ROE.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#25

Alright. Then for my final question, you mentioned that you've already submitted filings for $39 million worth of advice letter recovery projects. What's the total amount you anticipate filing during 2024? And how about 2025?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#26

That hasn't been determined yet, Jonathan. If somebody tuned into the rate proceeding, I found it rather interesting, since the commission seemed quite concentrated on those 335 projects that this company either failed to complete or completed only 5 out of 335. But like you're aware, figures matter, correct? So across that 3-year stretch, we likely finished 5,000 or 6,000 projects altogether; nobody brings those up, and instead the attention was solely on those 335 projects left undone. In California's rate-making system, I see 2 shortcomings. First, there's a failure to acknowledge that projects these days span 1, 2, or perhaps even 3 rate case cycles. Suppose you're putting in a well somewhere in Southern California — from acquiring the property, engineering the well, securing approval for the treatment, constructing the treatment facility, running tests, and finally placing it into service, that takes beyond 3 years. So California's rate-making framework doesn't account for the fact that these efforts are now multi-cycle endeavors. The other shortcoming the commission overlooks in the rate-making framework is that as these efforts grow more complex and stretch further out, the contingency levels for them rise. And from what I heard at the hearing, the commission rejected many of the contingencies tied to these projects. Those are the 2 areas Greg needs to address in the 2024 rate case. Sure, they're somewhat baked into how things work, into California's rate-making framework, but those are the 2 areas we'll concentrate on in 2024, since both contribute to regulatory lag. And the truth is — you've been tracking us for quite a while — we're quite reliable when it comes to achieving our capital commitment targets and deploying that capital, correct? The real issue lies on the back end: the rate-making framework and how efficiently it operates. We'll need to observe what unfolds going forward, but I believe we'll continue with our current approach, and we'll maintain investing at 3x depreciation rate, which in my view serves our stockholders well while keeping an eye on affordability.

Jonathan Reeder

analyst
#27

All right. However, regarding those 160 million projects, is your expectation that every one of them gets finished during 2024 and 2025? Or could a portion of them still land in the following rate case cycle?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#28

Yeah. At present, we have a focused push under way to take a fresh look at those projects through 2 lenses. First, to verify they continue to be necessary. And second, with respect to that initial point, to ensure these were not simply projects where we later discovered other alternatives; and second, to genuinely determine the timeframe in which we will finish the projects and place them into service, for whichever ones stay among the 160 million. As of now, I believe that effort remains ongoing, and within the next couple of weeks we will have a clearer picture regarding the timing of it.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#29

To start, you mentioned the 10-Q, and that filing should contain additional details regarding the other retroactive effects on Q1 earnings. Could you give us a rough idea, though, of what that looks like from an EPS standpoint compared with the 21 you reported?

Jim Lynch

executive
#30

We haven't provided a breakdown on an earnings-per-share basis, but on a relative basis, roughly $90 million of earnings — of revenue — tied to the decision was included in the first quarter of 2024; beyond that, there was about $8.5 million in additional expenses connected to that decision.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#31

All right. What I'm saying is — since you aren't providing guidance, having some baseline matters a great deal to us so we can build our own estimates, correct? Once more, we'd likely be grateful for that in future periods. Second, regarding the PFAS outlay, are you going to record AFUDC income tied to this CapEx? Is that going to run through the income statement?

Jim Lynch

executive
#32

Well, with AFUDC, yes, we qualify to apply the AFUDC approach as we proceed with those costs. As I understand the way you've framed it, to the degree we incur spending on those projects, we'll be in a position to lower our interest expense for the year through AFUDC.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#33

Okay. And then, more broadly when it comes to PFAS, we're beginning to observe a few losses involving investor-owned utilities tied to the reality that, generally speaking, those utilities weren't trying to take the forever chemicals out of distributed water previously. So I'm curious what you can do to shield yourself. Does California offer anything that lets you cap the litigation exposure and, even more significantly, cap any hit to earnings?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#34

Yes. From the angle of liability in California, we have part well — essentially our well decision — which states that when we operate consistent with the rules our regulator lays out, we get protection. Compared with some of what's showing up on the East Coast involving product liability tied to water and so forth, I'm not especially concerned about California. From an earnings angle, as Jim mentioned, we'll accrue AFUDC on those capital projects. The bulk of the treatment is capital. Within the group, 100 wells out of 1,170 wells pull. We'll build up AFUDC on that, and then the remaining capital costs are picked up, while the operating costs, once those vessels go into production, will bring incremental costs through the memo account, and we'll pursue recovery data at a later date. I believe we have essentially all the pieces we need in place. I was simply disappointed by the commission's decision not to recognize the capital now, because the EPS issued that new standard, and they did push out the implementation time line. I think it's roughly 5 years now rather than over 3. But you've got the — customers don't want to be told we'll implement PFAS treatment 4.5 years from now. If Jim is drinking water that's PFAS treated, he wants to know we're kicking it right away. That's why, when our press release went out, we noted we were disappointed by the commission's decision. Even so, we've reaffirmed our commitment to getting that capital on the ground as quickly as possible. So from an operating cost angle, I'm not especially concerned. For me, it's about making sure the water is safe for customers and implementing that capital as quickly as possible.

Jim Lynch

executive
#35

Also, Angie, one more thing regarding that: we're going after every grant we can find that might help address the entire PFAS problem, along with possible liability from third parties.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#36

Sure, PFAS-related lawsuits aimed at those responsible for the contamination are quite numerous, and the media coverage has been extensive. Since we're part of the suit targeting the parties who caused the pollution, I'd rather not discuss the case's specifics, but our expectation is that we will recover some money from those polluters, which would help cover both the expenses of implementing PFAS treatment and the capital costs involved.

Angie Storozynski

analyst
#37

Okay, and finally, you brought up how 1830 stocks performed poorly and when you plan to address future equity needs. I'm curious, since you increased the dividend by what I believe was 7%, somewhere around 7%. So, does that mean — do you view dividend growth as something you could potentially dial back if you need more equity, depending on how the stock does? Is it also a tool in this environment of high interest rates? And again, what exactly is behind that 7% plus figure?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#38

Sure, if you look back at — if you examined how we've raised the dividend across the past 5 years, those increases have exceeded inflation; our target payout ratio sits between 55% and 65%. We aim to stay inside those bounds. Personally, I think the compound annual growth rate for dividends ranks among the primary forces behind equity valuation in the market. Considering that CAGR figure, like Jim said, we've increased the dividend annually for 57 years now. So I see no reason to think we won't keep following that same course. Naturally, when the board reviews it, we consider what general market conditions are like, how much other utilities grew their dividends, what our capital requirements are, and we attempt to hold all of that in balance. But clearly, from my own perspective, dividend growth matters a great deal — our investors count on it, they enjoy seeing it, and they appreciate the water company's stability. For me, yes, 2023 was a bear year for water utilities. Still, I believe the 3 most important things we can do are ensure water quality remains the top priority on our operating list, keep investing at that 3x depreciation rate, and keep that dividend growing. And I suppose the fourth item is making sure our customer service remains outstanding and best-in-class. If we accomplish those things, over the long run we generate value for stockholders.

Davis Sunderland

analyst
#39

Regarding the PFAS matter, your audio is cutting in and out, but generally speaking, has the PFAS segment opened up any chance for you all to act more boldly, or show greater interest, or I suppose examine more closely any systems that might struggle to meet those standards?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#40

Davis, honestly, we caught roughly every third word — you kept fading out. Could you — one of you —

Jim Lynch

executive
#41

Let me address something I believe you raised — or at least let me put the question differently for Marty. Davis, from what I heard you say, when PFAS is present, and we examine the business opportunities currently available in the market that we might go after, how are we weighing the possible PFAS liability? And does that factor influence how eager or interested we are in some of those possible opportunities?

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#42

Wow, that came through in the question? That's amazing. Davis, was that the correct question?

Davis Sunderland

analyst
#43

<<inaudible>>

Jim Lynch

executive
#44

My take is that what he described falls into a gray area.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#45

Let me take that one. Sure, the price of capital has clearly risen quite a bit. And on the business development side, we haven't — perhaps there's been a slight deceleration in what enters our pipeline from a business development perspective. Still, our business development group remains extremely, extremely occupied. Like Jim said, what they have underway in Texas, plus other efforts in other states. Regarding PFAS, I believe smaller systems will find it hard to stay compliant. Consider our situation: 100 wells, $215 million, and we're pretty skilled at delivering that kind of treatment; we move quickly and work to hold our overhead relatively low. If a smaller system lacks capital access, or lacks the technical staff locally to determine the right treatment, that will hurt its ability to operate; and the wider operational concern, I think, applies to firms such as Cal Water, Essential, Aqua, STW, or Middlesex, and any of us that are publicly traded — you lose compliance and the regulator fines you heavily or you wind up being sued by someone, correct? We typically run to the highest standard possible in relation to that. As a municipal system, what option do you have? Consider the 60,000 systems that fall under EPA oversight — there's no way they can effectively monitor every one of those systems to confirm compliance with PFOS and PFAS. I credit the Biden Administration for attempting to move PFAS treatment forward and bring the EPA in faster. That matters a great deal, in my view. But compliance delays will occur on the municipal side, whereas I don't believe you'll see that same issue on the investor owned side.

Jim Lynch

executive
#46

Yeah. And I believe, given what Marty has pointed out about that, we really do expect that, like with any fresh rule that gets introduced, it's going to create financial pressure for certain systems, and that could create opportunities in the market. And absolutely, if we think we're able to help the customers in those markets, then we'd have interest in taking a look at those systems.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#47

Yet, Jim, even in that scenario, there's something that occurs whenever we assume control of a system: we inherit liability for AMI. So consider a few of the projects we've completed, for instance in New Mexico, or where we've acquired struggling systems — we collaborate very closely with the regulator so that the rates are paid upfront prior to our purchase, and so that we have an implementation time line, which keeps us from getting hit on the backside by those penalties and fines. Since I believe that in the water sector, it's the investor-owned utilities that regulators define as the deep pockets.

Davis Sunderland

analyst
#48

Sorry about the sound quality there. Thanks for making room in your schedules, everyone.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#49

Jim, you've got sharp hearing. Pretty impressive that you managed to make out what was said.

Martin Kropelnicki

executive
#50

Okay, Ellie, I appreciate it. So, hello everybody, and thank you for being with us. There's clearly a great deal happening right now, yet at least we can cross one item off, and that's the General Rate case for 2021. It's now behind us. There's certainly plenty of remaining effort around the tariffs and submitting the necessary paperwork to the commission so we can begin recovering the retroactive portion; we'll have more clarity to share during our Q2 earnings call; and during the period before that, we'll be focused on the 2024 general rate case as well as getting ready for the State Supreme Court oral arguments scheduled for May 8. Thanks for spending time with us today, and we're eager to speak with all of you again very, very soon. Have a great day.

Operator

operator
#51

We appreciate everyone joining this conference call today. We wish each of you a great day. At this point, you're all free to end your session.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.