California Water Service Group (CWT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 31, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim Lynch
executiveThanks, Kathleen. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the call covering California Water Service Group's results for the third quarter of 2024. Joining me are Marty Kropelnicki, who serves as our Chairman and CEO, and Greg Milleman, our Vice President of Rates and Regulatory Affairs. Details on how to access a replay by dial-in are included in the earnings release for the quarter that went out earlier today. That replay can be accessed through December 30, 2024. One quick note before we get started: there's a slide deck the company put together to go along with today's call. It came with an 8-K and can also be found on the company's website, www.calwatergroup.com. Prior to reviewing our third quarter 2024 results, I want to spend a short time on forward-looking statements. At points during this call, the company might make certain forward-looking statements. Since those statements involve future events, a range of risks and uncertainties apply to them, and what actually happens could end up materially different from what the company currently expects. So the company strongly encourages every current shareholder, along with interested parties, to read carefully and grasp the company's disclosures regarding risks and uncertainties contained in our Form 10-K, Form 10-Qs, press releases, and other reports we file from time to time with the Securities and Exchange Commission. With that, I'll hand things over to Marty.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveThank you, Jim. Good morning to all of you, and a happy Halloween. We appreciate that you've taken the time to be with us. It's my pleasure to walk you through what we achieved in Q3 of 2024. Essentially, there are 5 key areas we intend to address in this session. To begin, our robust financial results for the third quarter, which keep gaining from the regulatory release in California; next, a status report on the 2024 general rate case — in that quarter we held our first pre-conference hearing, and both an administrative law judge and a commissioner have now been designated to preside over it. We also obtained the California Public Utilities Commission's sign-off on several advice letters, which lets us gather $94.2 million from specific regulatory balances extending through 2027. We'd like to discuss the unprecedented level of capital we put to work this year and how that shapes up as we approach the close of the year. And finally, we'll take a moment to highlight our ongoing environmental stewardship along with corporate recognition, mentioning a handful of awards earned in the quarter. To kick things off, though, let's follow our usual format and have Jim Lynch guide you through some financial analysis covering the quarterly results. Jim, over to you.
Jim Lynch
executiveTo start, as Marty pointed out, results in Q3 of 2024 continue to benefit from the fresh rates and the rate structure that came out of our 2021 California GRC. So operating revenue for the quarter increased 17.5%, coming in at $299.6 million, compared with $255 million of operating revenue in the same quarter last year. Net income for the quarter was $60.7 million, or $1.03 per diluted share, versus $34.4 million, or $0.60 per diluted share, in Q3 of 2023. The $44.6 million revenue increase in Q3 2024 was driven mostly by a $42.2 million bump in rates billed to customers under our regulatory filings, along with higher customer usage—across both existing and new customers—that was worth $9.6 million; those improvements were partially offset by a $9.4 million decline in our Monterrey Water Rate Adjustment Mechanism, or MWRAM. Remember that MWRAM is a rate-adjustment tool with a tiered design tied to usage. In warm, dry conditions when usage rises, MWRAM typically declines. Its balance generally climbs in cooler, wetter weather as usage drops. Operating expenses for Q3 2024 were $232.8 million, versus $211.5 million in Q3 2023. That $21 million increase was mostly due to $2.7 million of higher water production costs, driven by increased wholesale rates and greater customer usage; a $3.2 million increase in depreciation and amortization from newly placed assets; and $11.5 million more of income taxes related to higher pretax earnings. On top of that, net other income rose $3.8 million in the third quarter, largely because unrealized gains on nonqualified benefit plan investments were $5 million higher. How Q3 2024 activity shaped diluted earnings per share is shown on Slide 6. The largest growth drivers were rate increases that contributed $0.56 per diluted share and usage increases that contributed $0.13 per diluted share. Gains on nonqualified benefit plan investments also contributed $0.09 per diluted share; partially offsetting those factors were the $0.12 per diluted share change in the MWRAM balance, as well as increases in water production expenses and in depreciation and amortization expenses of $0.04 per diluted share each. Results for the first nine months of 2024 benefited from the same regulatory mechanisms as the quarterly numbers. Operating revenue year to date rose $234.5 million, reaching $814.6 million in 2024, compared with $580 million in the same period of 2023. Net income for the first nine months of 2024 was $171.1 million, or $2.93 per diluted share, versus $21 million, or $0.38 per diluted share, in the comparable period of 2023. Revenue growth was primarily due to cumulative rate increases, including 2024 IRMA of $95 million, 2023 interim rate relief from the 2021 GRC of $87.5 million, and recognition of deferred WRAM revenue of $15.6 million. In addition, the change in our 2024 MWRAM balance contributed $12.4 million, while higher usage added $8.8 million. For the year to date, operating expenses in 2024 were $621.8 million, compared with $538.2 million in the same period of 2023. The increase of $83.6 million was driven primarily by a $15.4 million jump in water production costs, stemming from higher wholesale water rates along with increased usage. Another $3.3 million in water production costs resulted from the incremental cost balancing account, known as the ICBA, which received authorization through the 2021 GRC. Beyond that, we recorded $13.1 million in deferred costs associated with recognizing deferred WRAM revenue, as well as $9.3 million in higher depreciation and amortization expense. Income tax also rose $41.1 million for the year-to-date, largely driven by increased pretax earnings. On Slide 8, you can see how year-to-date 2024 activity impacted diluted earnings per share. Among the larger earnings drivers, cumulative rate increases from 2023 interim rate relief, together with recognized deferred WRAM revenue, contributed $1.29, $1.19, and $0.21 in diluted earnings per share, respectively. The change in our 2024 MWRAM balance and increased usage added $0.17 and $0.12 in diluted earnings per share, respectively. Those gains were partly offset by higher water production expenses and recognition of RAM related deferred water expenses, at $0.25 and $0.18 in diluted earnings per share, respectively, plus $0.13 in diluted earnings per share from higher depreciation and amortization. As a reminder, the 2021 GRC was adopted in Q1 2024 and featured 2023 interim rate relief totaling $64 million. Out of that interim rate relief, $15.2 million was attributed to Q3 2023, while $50.4 million would have been attributed to the 2023 9-month period year-to-date. Now let's turn to our capital. We continue to make significant investments in our water infrastructure to help ensure safe, reliable water service delivery. Capital investments by the Company during the 9-month period ended September 30, 2024, totaled $332.2 million, which represents 86% of our $385 million 2024 capital budget. As a reminder, neither our planned 2024 capital investments nor our estimated capital investments for the period from 2025 through 2027 include $226 million of estimated PFOS projects, which will be constructed over multiple years beginning in the fourth quarter of 2024. Later in the call, Greg will discuss the planned 2025 and 2027 increases applied for in the 2024 GRC and infrastructure improvement plan. Slide #10 illustrates the positive impact our capital investment program is having on regulated rate base. By the end of 2024, our overall rate base is projected to reach $2.36 billion. That marks a 7.3% increase over 2023. If approved as requested, the 2024 California GRC and infrastructure improvement plan, combined with planned capital investments in our utilities and other states, would generate compounded annual rate base growth of 11.7%. Moving to Slide 11. We maintain a strong balance sheet, with a capital structure of 61% equity and 39% debt. During the quarter, the CPUC issued a final decision granting Cal Water Authority to issue up to $1.3 billion in new debt and equity securities to finance water system infrastructure investments from 2023 to 2027, a figure that reflects 1,639,000 in authorized financing capacity. For the quarter, we raised approximately $34.5 million from the sale of 639,000 common stock shares via our at-the-market equity program, also known as ATM. So far this year, that ATM program has brought in about $86.5 million from selling 1.6 million — that's 390,000 shares. Under this program, roughly $43.1 million remains available, which might be raised for general corporate purposes later, including planned capital investments and strategic opportunities. Turning to debt: Cal Water completed the sale and issuance of $125 million in first mortgage bonds through a private placement that closed on October 22, 2024. The interest rate on these bonds is 5.22%, and they mature on October 22, 2054. Cal Water is applying the bond proceeds to refinance certain existing borrowings on its short-term bank line of credit. Also, note that yesterday our Board of Directors declared a dividend of $0.28 per share for stockholders of record on November 11, 2024. I believe that's November 12, 2024; this represents our 319th consecutive quarterly dividend. Let's turn to Slide 12. We maintain a robust liquidity position. As of September 30, 2024, the company had cash and cash equivalents of $105.2 million, with $45.6 million of that classified as restricted. Additionally, we had extra short-term borrowing capacity of $340 million on our company and Cal Water lines of credit. With that, I'll pass the call to Greg for an update on our 2024 general rate case and other regulatory matters. Greg?
Greg Milleman
executiveThank you, Jim. Turning to Slide 13, our 2024 General Rate Case is the topic. I'm happy to share that our filing for the 2024 General Rate Case keeps moving forward. The first prehearing conference has wrapped up, and both a judge and a Commissioner are now assigned to hear our case. Commissioner Baker is the commissioner assigned to it. Given his previous efforts at the California public advocates to teach the CPUC about negative customer impacts tied to rate case delays, we're glad he has this assignment. As Jim said before, our plan is to put $1.6 billion into our districts between 2025 and 2027, which covers roughly $1.3 billion in newly proposed capital investments so we can keep delivering dependable, top-quality water service. This application features our new low-use water equity program, built to separate revenue from water sales while holding rates within reach and strengthening conservation aims. Under our proposal, rate increases would bring in an extra $140.6 million for 2026, $74.2 million for 2027 and $83.6 million for 2028. We've now spent 4 months in the PUC's standard 18-month review process and are busy answering data requests. Every district tour is finished, and we're getting ready for public participation hearings later in the year. With that, I'll hand the call back to Marty.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveGreg, I'm just curious — does the number of data requests line up with what we've seen in earlier rate cases?
Greg Milleman
executiveYes, consistent with past rate cases.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveContinuing on, I'm now at Slide 14. Let me spend a moment discussing what our cost of capital looks like for 2025. A lot of you are aware that in California, we operate under something known as a cost of capital adjustment mechanism. What this mechanism does is essentially monitor the utilities AA — the utilities bond index — starting October 1 through September 30 of the subsequent year; if a change of 100 basis points or more occurs, the company is permitted to make — to request an adjustment to its ROE, in either direction; so I'm pleased to share that when the period closed on September 30, the change came in under 100 basis points, and as a result, our ROE for 2025 gets locked in at 10.27%, which in our view is a very solid ROE. Let's proceed to the following slide. Additional regulatory mechanisms. A few developments occurred during the quarter that I believe matter. As I noted during my opening remarks, we submitted several advice letters seeking recovery that the CPUC in California has now approved. There are 3 main filings I'd like to highlight. The first is the IRMA, meaning the incremental rates memo account, the 2023 MWRAM balance, and the 2023 Incremental Cost Balance Account. Taken together, those 3 items come to roughly $94.2 million, which we'll be recovering across the coming 3 years. During 2024, we anticipate collecting roughly $11.6 million from these balances as we transition into the new year. Turning to Slide #16, I'd like to spend a moment on our environmental leadership and corporate recognition. To begin, I remain extremely proud of the recognition we've earned for our environmental stewardship and workplace excellence. The Alliance for Water Efficiency recently published a study that underscored the significant impact of our conservation programs, which have lowered customer bills by roughly 21% across the last 15 years relative to projections for customers lacking the same kind of conservation program. So we're quite pleased with the survey's findings and with what we've helped our customers accomplish across the last 15 years. Beyond that, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency honored California Water Service with the WaterSense Excellence Award for the second year in a row. This acknowledges the promotion of our water-efficient products offered through our conservation programs. The products we've rolled out so far will conserve an additional 395 million gallons across the useful life of the devices for our customers. Also, during the quarter, Newsweek named us one of the World’s Most Trustworthy Companies for its second consecutive year. That puts us among just 5 water utilities receiving recognition and honor within the energy and utility category. And finally, for the ninth year in a row, we were recognized as a great place to work, which speaks to our continued commitment to building an exceptional workplace environment and supporting our employees. As I believe many of you have likely heard me mention, yes, we're a business built around fixed assets—pipes and pumps—but the employees are what matter most, since they're the people who make everything work and who deal directly with our customers. Before I close, I'd like to briefly bring up the 8-K we submitted during the quarter, which disclosed that Ron Webb, our Vice President and Chief Human Resource Officer, will be retiring. His retirement date is April 1, 2025. In his role leading HR, Ron has performed superbly, and he's been a wonderful HR colleague and friend whose contributions at Cal Water are beyond counting. I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Ron personally and to extend my best wishes to him and his wife, Tina, as they get ready for retirement—he will be deeply, deeply missed. As I'm sure everyone understands, for a CEO, your HR executive ranks among your most trusted advisors; and Ron, working alongside you for these past 10 years has simply been fantastic, and I'll miss collaborating with you, and I wish you nothing but the best in retirement. That said, a nationwide search is now underway for someone to step into Ron's role, and I'm hopeful we'll be able to make an announcement about his successor by year-end or in early 2025. So how does that leave us for the quarter? We're very pleased with the quarter's results. They matched what we had anticipated. They can be a bit hard to follow. Jim, I thought, did a nice job walking through all the pieces in motion and how they connect, in light of the 2021 general rate case being delayed. Looking ahead, it's actually quite straightforward. Our strategy centers on deploying capital, as the press release indicates. And like Jim noted, the capital we've invested this year set a record. So we're heading into the fourth quarter in a strong position, making investments under our infrastructure improvement plan; we intend to remain focused on customer service and serving our customers, and on the 2024 General Rate Case as well. Per Greg, things are progressing and following the plan so far. We want to do everything within our power to ensure we bring that rate case to a close by the end of 2025, with new rates taking effect 1/1/26. So there's plenty happening. One more point I'd make is what Jim said regarding rate base growth. Historically, we've been at roughly the depreciation rate, the investment rate, and that's stepping up over this next cycle or 2. And considering the internal capital needs growth from existing infrastructure plus the additional $226 million, that isn't captured in the 11.7% CAGR figure for rate base growth, which will be incremental. All right, so there's a great deal going on inside the company right now, and honestly — the plan is quite simple; we'll keep doing what we've always done, which means putting capital to work on the ground and taking care of the customers. And there's one item I'd like to mention before we take comments. It concerns this year's fire season. For our service areas, it has been, surprisingly, on the lighter side. Three significant fires came near our service areas this year, and not one of them caused any damage within those areas — the Thomson Fire, the Park Fire and the Boreal fire. So nothing of consequence hit our service territory. I'm delighted to share that the Sierra is receiving its first snowfall of the season this week, a positive indicator that winter has begun and will help ease the final weeks of fire season here, which usually runs through the end of November; so with that, Kathleen, let's open the line for questions, please.
Jonathan Reeder
analystTo kick things off, I'd like to hear how you're reading the CPUC's latest move to delay the PD along with CalAm's rate case. I realize the PD's wording came down quite hard against bringing back pool decoupling. That said, do you figure there's a sufficient number of commissioners who back decoupling? Or is it more likely that certain explanatory text within that part simply gets reworked?
Greg Milleman
executiveJonathan, Greg here. The way the industry is reading things at the moment is this — holding the PD until the December meeting, roughly a month or maybe 2 months, struck us as a meaningful signal. Even so, nobody agrees on precisely what it signifies. Perhaps it means the wording is being made tighter so as to prohibit it, or perhaps it's headed the opposite direction, with language added that permits it. We simply can't say yet.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAlright, that's reasonable. I'm not able to determine it either.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveJonathan, there's something I'd like to tack onto that. I haven't gone through the complete decoupling filing for any of the other California utilities we compete with. That said, I'm aware that within our own filing, we directed sharp attention toward 2 items that I consider significant. I also believe this could represent a strategic point of difference for us. First, conservation received a great deal of emphasis from us, just as it did when we first pursued decoupling back during the early part of 2012 — I suppose that was item number one. Second, what we also emphasized in the fresh rate structure contained in our filing related to what you might call underserved communities, and to having a rate structure that assists low-income customers through something like a lifeline rate during that initial year. So within our filing, conservation wasn't the sole concern; low-income communities mattered too, along with ensuring a lifeline rate exists that brings down bills for customers situated at the lower end of the economic — or the lower portion of the economic spectrum; and in our view, that is going to prove extremely, extremely significant.
Jonathan Reeder
analystYeah, no. And I believe that if we're merely easing the wording in that BD, it sort of creates an opening, correct — for a few of those reenvisioned approaches to, I suppose, structuring the decoupling so that it genuinely centers on a few of the objectives you just referenced, Marty.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveCorrect, correct. And I believe what matters regarding this community element for folks on the lower economic scale is — that's a goal the commission has stated; it's — they've been quite open about that; they have a strong interest in it; and I credit the team here a great deal, we embraced that in how we designed the decoupling mechanism we submitted in our rate case.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right. That's good, and I'm eager to watch how it unfolds. In addition, I understand the CPUC came out with a ruling not long ago that cut the permitted ROEs for energy utilities by 42 basis points during 2025, essentially shrinking how much the 2024 cost of capital mechanism would rise. Could the CPUC take a comparable step where the water companies are concerned for 2025?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveLet me start, Greg, then you can chime in. To me, that possibility always exists. When you look back, our ROEs have typically trailed those of the energy sector. As a result, we aren't starting from especially elevated ROEs; as a matter of fact, $10.27 is roughly the same ROE we had when I came to this company in 2006, after which it declined across several years before climbing back above 10% only very recently. So yes, I consider it a possibility. Several dynamics are at work in the electric business, and it differs somewhat from water. First, as you can tell, our desire to put capital to work keeps expanding, and we must somewhat accelerate placing that capital so we can satisfy the demands currently in front of us in the pending rate case, which benefits stockholders nicely. What that means is a rising rate base and possibly greater future earnings for customers. On the electric side, I believe there's another element, which is that California carries substantial wildfire expenses recovered through electricity rates, and those have stacked multiple rounds of increases onto customers, so I suspect the commission may feel some pressure, along with broader political pressure throughout California, because of certain additional increases beyond the general rate case that showed up on electric bills. Consequently, we won't really know until we arrive at that point; even so, my sense is that we will in all likelihood need to submit a cost of capital application during 2025. It would be wonderful if we could push it off once more, yet I believe that could prove difficult, and we will try our hardest to protect the company's position regarding its ROE. Greg, is there anything else you'd like to offer on this?
Greg Milleman
executiveOne more point I'd make is this: water utilities don't have that same flexibility, but energy providers can submit a request to revise their cost of capital outside of their normal timetable. As I recall, they actually did so back in 2022 when there was an emergency situation — that being COVID. So that could be another reason the cost of capital is handled differently for the two of us — energy companies as well as water.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveOkay, so Jonathan, it's clear this is going to be a major subject in '25, and we'll be sharing news about where our cost of capital stands as we move through the proceedings with the commission during 2025.
Jonathan Reeder
analystYeah. My sense is that what we take away here, for the short run anyway, is that 2025 brings us that 10.27% — as Marty pointed out, when the recalculation happened this year on September 30, nothing got set off relative to the ROE we're seeing right now.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveAnd my impression is the commission hasn't given us any resistance regarding that 10.27%. Has it, Greg?
Greg Milleman
executiveNope, we submitted a filing to show exactly what Jim mentioned, and we still haven't gotten any response from them.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right, that's fine. So it appears that the 10.27% is locked in for 2025, and after that, well, we'll simply have to wait and find out if there's — I suppose what I'm asking is, might you consider a prolongation that perhaps carries with it an adjustment to the ROE, maybe as a trade-off, you receive some form of multiyear assurance of an extension at whatever that revised ROE turns out to be?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveSpeculating about a matter such as that in the future is not easy. What I can tell you is that I've strongly backed the cost of capital adjustment mechanism, since it genuinely moves both up and down, and it operates in 2 directions. And once more, our ROEs have trailed those of the electric industry, and our need to boost capital investment keeps growing. So I believe — clearly, if we could reach a settlement on anything, we'd be glad to, because doing so makes for a tidier process on our end. Yet speculating is truly difficult, given that we lack any facts and circumstances surrounding it; and clearly, our goal is to do what's best for Cal Water, meaning ensuring our ROE is suitable enough to let us draw in capital so we can keep up our rate base growth; so I believe we'll gain far more certainty once we get into it, but speculating is genuinely tough when we aren't in a dialogue with the commission regarding it.
Jonathan Reeder
analystSure. Then, finally, regarding the cost of capital. Slide 11 seems to show your authorized California capital structures, 60.8% equity. How does that square with the 53.4% approved under the last cost of capital <<inaudible>>?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveYes. That's our actual cap structure as of right now; so Jim, can you talk a little bit about that?
Jim Lynch
executiveRight, and once more, Jonathan, we're talking about the group level here, correct? So in the event that you — what we're trying to do is handle that structure so it aligns as nearly as we can with the authorized amounts we have at our other — at our operating utilities. As I said during the call, after the quarter closed, we completed a first mortgage bond through which we brought in $125 million of debt financing. So we've begun balancing debt against equity, and truly the aim is — to bring it more closely in line with the authorized amount at the operating utilities, so that it matches better with what exists at group. And we'll sort of move through the capital structure at the group level to choose the most optimal route toward getting that nearer to alignment, though the initial move was that $125 million we issued after the quarter ended.
Jonathan Reeder
analystAll right, that's helpful to have it spelled out. My final inquiry, then. How might the capital expenditure plan be affected by the EPA's lead and copper rule, now that it's been finalized? Does that pose a significant problem in the California region you serve?
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveNot really, honestly. One advantage of operating on the West Coast, I'd say, is that our facilities are more modern compared with the East Coast. From everything our latest testing has shown, a single district of ours has reached that action level. Yet when we conducted testing there, our wells and purchased water came back fine, and we believe it's tied more to a few customers' residences. So for us, I don't see it having much of an effect, which honestly is a good thing, since PFOS is our biggest challenge over the coming 20 — over the coming 3 years, given that it requires an extra $226 million of investment, and we aim to stay ahead of schedule there. So the lead and copper rule out West doesn't keep me up much at night.
Martin Kropelnicki
executiveKathleen, I appreciate it. I want to thank all of you for being here today. Should any questions come up, please don't hesitate to contact any one of us, and we'll do our best to provide answers. To wrap things up, we finished the third quarter in a strong position. We're heading into the fourth quarter carrying a great deal of momentum. That said, once again, what we're aiming for as we enter the fourth quarter is simply to remain focused on the company's core business plan and on carrying out our current strategy, and we're eager to share an update with all of you at the end of February, when we report our earnings results for 2024. So, happy Halloween. Stay safe, and we'll be speaking with everyone before long. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up our session for today, everyone. We appreciate each of you being here. At this point, feel free to leave the line.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete California Water Service Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to California Water Service Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in California Water Service Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.