Canadian National Railway Company (CNR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 19, 2020

Toronto Stock Exchange CA Industrials Ground Transportation conference_presentation 30 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#1

I think we're live here. Good morning, everyone, and I'm Brandon Oglenski, senior transportation and airline analyst here at Barclays. Just want to welcome everyone to 37th Annual Barclays Industrial Select Conference. It's been going on for quite some time. We know you have lots of choices in conferences, so I appreciate you coming to ours and definitely appreciate the support. And I'm definitely delighted to kick off the transportation sector this morning with Canadian National. Honestly, probably the first Precision Scheduled Railroad, which has become a pretty hot topic for railroad investors, and definitely, going to have a good conversation here. So joining us today is Ghislain Houle, Chief Financial Officer; Keith Reardon, Senior Vice President of Consumer Product Supply Chain. I got that right?

Keith Reardon

executive
#2

Correct.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#3

Okay.

Ghislain Houle

executive
#4

Screen had to be elongated a little bit to fit his title, but...

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#5

You're going to hear this a lot today as we go through the presentations. If anyone that's been to this conference before is going to be well aware. But if you look at that old-school Blackberry looking device, we're going to do audience response questions. It is pretty cool for the [ corporates ] too because they see time series of these. So if we can queue up the ARS question one. Do you currently own the stock in the room? Yes, overweight, market weight, underweight or no? And then we'll give a few seconds here to answer. And you'll see these in every presentation today. [Voting]

Keith Reardon

executive
#6

Do you think they will answer?

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#7

Yes, we need some up here. Question number 2, please? What is your general bias towards Canadian National right now: positive, negative or neutral? [Voting]

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#8

All right. And then last -- question number three, and then I'm going to turn it over. In your opinion, through-cycle EPS growth for Canadian National will be, above peers, in line or below peers? [Voting]

Ghislain Houle

executive
#9

Probably talk about return to...

Keith Reardon

executive
#10

Yes. That's a pretty favorable audience, actually.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#11

So just laying in, Keith, I know there's been a lot going on in Canada. You guys want to address some issues that are going on in the network right now? I know I saw an announcement that you've had some disruption in your network so...

Ghislain Houle

executive
#12

Yes, so maybe -- well, first of all, thanks for having us again, Brandon. It's always nice to leave Montreal and come to beautiful Miami. We left actually yesterday with a bit of a snowstorm. So I think we're very pleased to be here. Thanks for people being in the room and people listening on webcast. Yes, Keith and I will give a little bit of update on the context of what we're seeing now for CN. I'll be more short term, Keith will be a little bit more long term. We'll take a few minutes. And then after that, we can dig into your questions. So obviously, there is quite a bit happening. If you look at Q1 to date, there is quite a bit of happening for CN and in Canada. Typically, Q1 is always a quarter where there's more noise, obviously, due to the weather mostly. And when you look in January, I think that hit us, not unusual. We had 8 days of deep frost in Western Canada that impacted our network. But frankly, after, we were pretty lucky on the weather. The weather in Canada, across the board, has been relatively good. Unfortunately, when we think about weather in Canada, we think about the cold, but there's been some torrential rains west of Vancouver on our main line that caused some landslides and caused some washouts, 2 washouts, actually, Keith, one before tunnel and another one in the tunnel. So we had our engineering forces working very, very, very diligently, very safely to fix this. And again, this is the rain where it's a bit tough to work on, but we're glad that we fixed the network. And then came the -- some of you that are reading the Montreal news and Québec news and Canada news, the First Nation blockage that started in February 6. So we had one in Western Canada, which was east of Terrace and west of the Smithers. So that's right in the middle of the Rockies, actually blocking our mainline going to Rupert. That blockage has been lifted. So now we're back to business in moving our -- the customers' precious goods are going to Rupert. But there's another one in the Eastern Canada on our Kingston Sub, which is the subdivision between Montreal and Toronto. The blockage is actually east of Belleville, it's still going on, as we speak. The Canadian government is involved in negotiating with First Nations to peacefully get it lifted. This has nothing to do, by the way with CN. We're a bit taken hostage, we're a bit victim out of this, but we're working with the Canadian government and cooperating with them, and we're very hopeful that this blockage on our eastern network will be lifted any time soon in the next day or 2, but it's still going on, as we speak. And then there was a ministerial order that was given to both Canadian railroads on February 6, that essentially was limiting speed on what we call key trains. Key trains, just to keep it simple for people, is trains that have loaded hazmat product. That ministerial order has been amended on February 16. And that will really allow us to get our network back fluid in Western Canada. So that's going to be very helpful. When you look at 2020, again, you and I were talking before the conference, we still remain cautiously optimistic. This is what we said in our call a few weeks ago, on our Q4 call. Again, yes, there's a little bit more noise on the first quarter than what we're used to. But again, it's only 1.5 months. So there's still 10.5 months in front of us, and we feel cautiously optimistic going forward. When you look at our CapEx, at CN, we do what we said we're going to do. We said we're going to normalize our CapEx back to historical levels in terms of percentage of revenues, we are doing this. Our CapEx now or envelope came from $3.9 roughly billion in '19 to $2 billion or $3 billion. And that will obviously help free cash flow and free cash flow conversion. We do -- and we did give some visibility on cost headwinds that are specific to CN in 2020, namely pension. There's some incentive compensation. Our tax -- effective tax rate is going up from 25% to 26%. When you total these cost headwinds, it's roughly about $400 million that we have to deal with. And then, obviously, we continue on our consistent shareholder distribution and you've all heard our dividend increase and our share buyback that we've announced on January's Q4 call. For 2021 and beyond, we still remain quite bullish. We do have -- and Keith will touch upon some of those, we do have some very CN specific structural growth opportunities that are ahead of us. We're extremely as well pleased with the advancements we're doing on technology. And Keith, I'll let you cover some of those.

Keith Reardon

executive
#13

Sure. So we are very excited, and we're very confident in a lot of these mid- to long-term structural infrastructure projects that are going to be located on our lines, many of them exclusive. We'll start off maybe in Rupert and talk about the propane terminals that have been built or being built. You have AltaGas, which was established last year in May, and they're doing about 40,000 barrels a day through that facility. Second half of this year, a new terminal built by Pembina will be open, and they will be doing roughly 25,000 barrels per day. And that will -- in 2023, that will expand an additional 15,000 barrels per day. When we look towards coal, a new facility or new mine was opened up last year in May, the -- near Hinton, Alberta, Coalspur, and they start off roughly a 3 million ton per year clip, expanding into, we feel this year, they'll be upwards of 6 million tons. And they've got some plans to going to 10 million tons. And that's -- a lot of that's going through Prince Rupert. And so in Rupert, the previously Crown Corporation owned Ridley terminals, which is the coal terminal, but they're also doing -- looking to do some other products as well, that facility put in a second dumper and the tonnage throughput there has gone from 14 million tons per year to 16 million tons per year. And they also have plans to put in a second berth. It will take that to 34 million tons per year. When we stay on the coal side of the house, we're very, very pleased with the new partnerships that we've signed with Teck Coal, where in 2021, we will start moving their product to their new -- newly expanded facility at Neptune terminals, which is on the North Shore. They've gone -- they're putting in additional capacity there, going from 12 million tons to 18 million tons, they're 18.5 million tons. So the product that we move out of their mines will not only go to the Neptune to fulfill their own terminal, but will also go to Rupert as well. We stay in the west a little bit. There's some capacity improvements also at the container terminals, near and dear to my heart. In Prince Rupert, in 2021, there will be expansion there of an additional 250,000 TEUs, and in 2022, it will take that up another 200,000 TEUs, taking the terminal to 1.8 million TEUs. If you listen to my friend, Shaun Stevenson, at the Port of Prince Rupert, they also have plans for a second terminal there, and they feel that over the next 15, 20 years, they could take that anywhere between 6 million and 7 million TEUs total throughput for Prince Rupert on a container basis. Let's not leave out Vancouver, though. Deltaport, they finished their expansions of loading rail there last year, an additional 600,000 TEUs of rail loading capabilities. At Centerm, they've got a 2-year project going on right now to take that terminal to a 1.5 million TEU terminal. And this year, there will be a completion of Vanterm, taking them to a little over 1 million TEUs there. So we see a lot of capacity on the west -- on our western front to be increased, but that doesn't leave out the east. As many of you probably have heard, PSA has purchased the Halterm container terminal in Halifax from Macquarie. And they have plans this year of extending a berth there where we could get 2 post-Panamax vessels alongside at one time. They also have another post-Panamax crane coming in and being commissioned this summer. When we go back to talk a little bit more about bulk on the grain side of the house, as the farmers keep getting better and better at producing crops and the yield increases, there's been a move to increase the number of elevators in the country. And with 32 new elevators being built in Canada from 2015, not all of them are complete yet, but I can tell you that over 70% of them are on CN lines. So we have a good footprint to handle more grain. And this year, the second half of the year, there'll be the first loop track to loop track total supply chain of grain put in place in Canada on the North Shore at the new G3 terminal. Again, we service the North Shore in Vancouver. All of those things have us very, very excited. And what that means is, for us, is we want to take it to the next level of, as Brandon mentioned earlier, we were kind of the initial PSR folks. We want to take it to -- we feel we're in PSR 2.0 right now. We've been in the growth mindset for the last 10 years. And we want to take it to 3.0 and JJ has tasked all of us to take the stuff that we were looking at in the lab, a lot of its innovative technologies that will make us a safer railroad, a more efficient railroad, and one that can create even more capacity with the same network that we have today. So we have 2 really coal projects that are ongoing. One is automated or autonomous track inspection. So we have 8 boxcars that have been fitted with a very, I guess, a high level of technology. And these cars are going around the network in regular train service and their inspection, the health and the integrity of the track, the ties and the ballast, and those are going around in this regular train service, and we do not have to stop the railroad for track inspectors to go out on the railroad, which is the traditional method. And so we're working through with the regulators on that to make that part of our process is moving forward. And that's -- we have that in our game plan to build an additional 2 of those cars this year. So we're very, very excited about what we see happening there. One more last point is the -- on the railcar inspections or train inspections, we've created 7 portals, 5 in Canada, 2 in the U.S., and these portals take high-resolution, thousands-per-second pictures of the integrity of the railcar, and we have 9 of the algorithms in place that are finding these defects and reporting in a real-time basis back to headquarters, where then people are then looking and planning the next work order for those railcars to be inspected. One key proof point is, is this stuff working? Yes, it's working. We did a 45-day test in Winnipeg where we had regular railcar inspectors testing trains and then we ran the -- ran several trains through the portals. We found 3,000 more defects with the portal than we did with the naked eye of our inspectors. So our inspectors are probably better to repair the railcars then to find out what's going wrong in some of these very tough to find places inside of a railcar. So we're very excited about all of these things, and it's going to differentiate us moving forward, for sure.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#14

Well, you guys gave me so much to talk about.

Keith Reardon

executive
#15

Yes.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#16

But I've got to put it in my short-term hand on Ghislain. You're still sticking by the annual guidance right now for...

Ghislain Houle

executive
#17

Yes, I think, as I said, we're not -- it's early on. At this time, I would say, stay tuned. We are recovering right now, our western franchise. So we're working hard on that, and we have some backlog that we're moving. So -- and then if you look at March, March is typically a very big month for us. It's -- from a seasonality standpoint, the biggest 2 month is March and it's October. So at this point, we're going as she goes. We'll see, hopefully, like these blockades in Western Canada and Eastern Canada, which, again, most of our volumes, as you know, Brandon, is west and going to Chicago. This is where we have some of our capacity issues that we've resolved in the last 2 years with quite a bit of investments in CapEx. So our eastern franchise is actually underutilized. So I don't want to undermine the impact of the blockades that are on our Eastern network, and we're hoping that it's going to be resolved. But at this point, we're not panicking. There's business out there. There's opportunities to move more crude. Keith talked a little bit about long-term grain, but grain is good as well. I mean, when you look at the Rupert, where Keith and I were comparing notes yesterday, even with the blockade that we have, I think, Rupert's volumes in terms of RTM, month -- year-to-date, Keith, I think they're up like 29%?

Keith Reardon

executive
#18

Yes.

Ghislain Houle

executive
#19

So -- and DP World is continuing to expand. So listen, at this point, when you look as well because one of your questions was, how do you see trade this year? And I think that the trade is more positive this year than it was last year. I think when you look at the tone, with the U.S. and China, I think, when you look at the USMCA agreement, that's going to be ratified or close to be ratified. I think we're hopeful that trade is going to be much better, maybe not, much better is a big word, but at least the tone is much more positive than last year. And I think that's going to be good for the railroad and for CN.

Keith Reardon

executive
#20

I think the -- a lot of uncertainty is taken out of the equation, and it allows folks like us and our customers to plan a little bit more about what we're going to do moving forward. And that uncertainty, out of the equation, is helping people start to plan for some second half improvements.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#21

And I guess along that point, though, we do have some uncertainty in China, right? And what Apple said yesterday, what are your customer base telling you about activity in China and manufacturing and expectations for volumes?

Keith Reardon

executive
#22

Well, as you know, Brandon, we have boots on the ground in China. With our business development folks and our freight forwarding arm there, and talking directly with our guy that heads that up, Gabriel Lagunes, they're slow to start ramping back up the manufacturing production. And part of that is also the -- just the logistics and the -- what they need to get those products from the plants to the ports. So the trucking is slowly get cranked up. I would not be surprised if we see another 2, 3, 4 weeks of ramp up before that we start to see it get to the point where maybe we were 4 months ago or so.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#23

Okay. But this could be a significant because the way we track it, inventory levels, at least in the U.S., have been relatively elevated. Could this actually be somewhat of a blessing in disguise, such that the channel gets a little bit lighter?

Keith Reardon

executive
#24

Yes, we actually see the inventories coming down and talking to a lot of our retail customers, the inventories are being depleted. So I think depending upon when this gets resolved or when this gets to the point where they're able to start ramping back up, it could fit quite nicely with where the inventory levels are. We're hopeful for this.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#25

Okay.

Ghislain Houle

executive
#26

And remember, again, Brandon, that the growth that we see in Rupert is somewhat, yes, coming from the economy, but it's also coming from market share from LA, Long Beach. So again, the products that are coming through Rupert are also welcoming and the issues that are -- with Rupert are also the issues that are with LA, Long Beach. So -- but there is some noise. Obviously, there's always noise. And -- but at this point, I think we're -- again, as I said in my opening remarks, we're cautiously optimistic about 2020. And we're going to continue. We'll look at demand, and we'll continue to right size our resources. Look at what we did in '19, we were pretty swift and rightsizing our resources. And we're actually pretty proud of the performance we've delivered last year. I mean, if you look, our volumes were declined 3%, and we still delivered 5% EPS growth, which demonstrates the resiliency of this franchise.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#27

Okay. And by the way, if there's any audience questions, just go ahead and raise your hand, we'll get you a mic. I guess, along those lines, you guys ran into some capacity issues back in '17 and '18, had to spend a lot of CapEx to...

Ghislain Houle

executive
#28

I remember that.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#29

Yes. But now that you're back to, I don't know, what, 19% or 20% of revenue and CapEx?

Ghislain Houle

executive
#30

Yes.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#31

And I don't even know if that's the right way to look at it. But obviously, we speak that language. Is -- there's definitely a divergence because you have big carriers in the U.S. that don't necessarily have a history of growth, but say -- and we can run CapEx in the 15%, maybe even lower level. But clearly, one of your competitors as well in Canada spending a little bit more, and there's been consistent outperformance of growth in Canada.

Ghislain Houle

executive
#32

Yes.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#33

Is this just the infrastructure or the system you guys have in place?

Ghislain Houle

executive
#34

We want to grow the business. I mean, we've said many, many times that we're not enamored with the OR. We'd rather be a $20 billion, 60% OR than a $15 billion at 59% or 58%. And when you look at what we've delivered, we've grown this business since 2010, we've grown our top line by 80%. We've talked that a little bit at our call. And when you look at our OR in 2010, it was 65.4%, and we've delivered 61.7%. So we've grown the business, and we've marginally helped the OR, reduced the OR, maintained our solid foundation of PSR. And I think from a mid- to long-term standpoint, we still stand by our guidance that we've delivered at the Analyst Day a few years ago, where we feel that high 50s OR, having the right capacity, is the good level to be. So we learned from '17 and '18, obviously, to your point. We had lots of business coming at us. Some of it, we were a little bit -- we got hurt by our success, like Rupert grew much more fast -- much faster than we had planned, which is good news. What we've learned, though, is that you need -- the notion is, bring the business while invest or invest and the business will come. In key corridors, like Rupert going to Edmonton, Winnipeg, Chicago, where all of our commodities go through these corridor, it's a little bit the opposite now. We need to invest ahead of the game because otherwise, when lumpy business comes at you in the railroad business, the lead time that it takes for you to bring -- to build infrastructure could be 1.5 years to 2 years. You have to get the permits, you've got to do First Nation consultation, et cetera, et cetera, and then you get on your knees. And if you don't have the right capacity, then your operating -- and if you still accept the growth, then your operating cost will naturally go up. If you decline the growth, then you've got the risk of customers going to the regulator and asking them to help the railroad. And when the regulator helps the railroad, it's never good. So we think that we're done on the catch-up '17, '18. We think that the 20-ish percent of revenues is a good level. But again, this is our capital allocation. This is our use-of-cash strategy. As you know, that has not changed for the last 15 years. First use of cash, was always said, was towards the business. So that's what we do, and if we have good projects that deliver good return on invested capital, above our internal threshold, hey, we're there to grow and we will. And when -- again, the example of since 2010 is a proof point to us that our strategy is working. So the key now is, we see business coming at us lumpy -- like our strategic partnership with Teck is a good one, where it's coming. So we know it’s coming. So there's about $300 million that will have to invested, not just for Teck, but will have to be invested around Vancouver. We're going to invest about 1/3 of it, the Port of Vancouver about 1/3 and the federal government about 1/3. Don't be surprised that some of this will be invested this year because we know Teck is coming in 2021. We need to provide the service to the strategic partner of ours -- long-term strategic partner of ours that they deserve, and we need to have this infrastructure to do it.

Keith Reardon

executive
#35

Just one additional point is, Ghislain mentioned earlier the east and it's one of the areas on our network that it's underdeveloped from what is -- for the building of the infrastructure that went on 30 years ago. That's why the partnership with what we're doing with PSA is so important as trade. We see a lot of trade moving from the West Coast to the East Coast. The same attributes that we have for Rupert are there for Halifax and to some extent, also for Québec City. And that's another partnership that we've announced is the construction of the Québec City Terminal in 2024. So we're doing all those things to not spend so much capital, but grow the business in those big lumpy pieces again. And so we're trying to fulfill our network there in the east with these additional projects that aren't going to be taking that capital above that traditional level.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#36

I love doing fireside chat with you guys, but there's just never enough time. Can we do question number 4, please? In your opinion, so speaking of cash, what's your Canadian National do with excess cash: bolt-on M&A, larger M&A, share repurchases, dividends, debt pay down or internal investment? [Voting]

Ghislain Houle

executive
#37

Well, as I said, we're always -- the first use of cash is towards the business. We're always interested in acquisitions if they make sense. Obviously, we're not about diversification. So it needs to either feed the network. This is an example with the TransX and H&R that we did. A lot of people, including our Canadian competitor, kept on saying, we bought a trucking company, that's not true. We actually bought these companies, and they were doing long-haul trucking. And the purpose is to take that long-haul trucking in the refrigerated product, reefers and coal produced and so on and put it on the network. And I'm happy to report that Keith and the team are doing an excellent job now integrating these businesses. If there is railroads, small railroads, short lines that are contiguous to our network that offers us new markets that we don't geographically go today because, again, as a railroad, you go to where you go and you don't go to where you don't go. The Massena line that we just purchased from CSX, and Keith was highly involved on this with our friend, Jim Foote, who used to be our CMO at CN, that's -- that again, that's in front of STB. We're hopeful that this is going to be approved in the next couple of months. But then, again, that will give us access to New York State Market, which we weren't having before. So if there's others and when we monitor the environment closely, obviously, we're interested. We're interested to grow the business, and we're interested to provide value to our shareholders, and this is what we're about.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#38

Keith, your question number 5?

Keith Reardon

executive
#39

We're almost out of time here.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#40

In your opinion, what multiple of 2020 earnings should Canadian National trade: less than 10, 10 to 12, 13, 15, 16, 18, 19, 21 and then higher than 21. Teck company, right? [Voting]

Ghislain Houle

executive
#41

Yes.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#42

All right. And then question number 6. What do you see as the most significant investment issue or headwind to the stock: core growth, margin performance, capital deployment or strategy. [Voting]

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#43

And I guess, I just want to wrap it up with this, and we're almost out of time, but should we be thinking of the rail business' GDP plus in growth?

Ghislain Houle

executive
#44

Well, that's what we said in our Investor Day a few years ago that our purpose is to grow more than the economy. And we have a list of strategic growth opportunities that are very specific to CN that Keith went through, they're there. They're -- I mean, you won't possibly see the needle moving in a given quarter. But again, we've been around for 100 years. We're actually celebrating our 100th year this year. We're going to be around for another 100 years. And these specific growth opportunities are going to continue to feed the network for the next 15, 20, 25 years, 30 years. So we're comfortable that we will grow more than the economy, and we're comfortable that we continue to do with pricing above inflation.

Brandon Oglenski

analyst
#45

Well, Ghislain, Keith, thank you very much for coming. I really appreciate it.

Ghislain Houle

executive
#46

Thank you for having us.

Keith Reardon

executive
#47

Thank you.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Canadian National Railway Company transcript — plus 248,000+ transcripts from 12,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Canadian National Railway Company earnings transcripts and 248,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.