Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 2, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Karen Hubbard
executiveMorning, everyone. Thanks for being here for our FY '20 results presentation covering the year that closed on 31st of January 2020 — clearly the most extraordinary stretch any of us has seen, and we're all joining remotely. Kris and I are in Wakefield together, keeping our social distance, naturally. What we plan to do is give you a quite short 30-minute update, after which we'll open the meeting up for Q&A. So, following the agenda on Slide 1 and sticking with how we normally run things, I'll give a quick update, Kris will then walk through the financials, I'll cover where the business's strategy stands, and after that we'll take any questions. Just a reminder that a second virtual presentation on our strategic plans will take place on the 28th of July in the afternoon, when you'll hear from other Executive Board members sharing future plans. Obviously, at that point we'll also be able to update you on stores trading — our stores are still closed right now, in line with government guidance — but a reopening plan will begin if it's safe to do so from the 15th of June. To start us off, let's go to Slide 3, highlights.
Karen Hubbard
executiveTo kick off the year, we achieved resilient total sales growth, consistent with other retailers that were describing tough high street conditions. Alongside growth in total store sales, which included a net 50 new stores, we also benefited from online sales growth at cardfactory.co.uk, 3 franchise stores delivering good sales, further expansion of sales to Aldi, and the addition of Matalan as a concession format. We also saw the start of the rollout in Australia, moving from the original 9 trial stores at a pace of 70 stores per week beginning on the 13th of January. Despite persistent headwinds and certain one-off costs that we discussed at the half year, including storage and Brexit stock, we did achieve progress on our business efficiency and cost mitigation programs, though these did not fully offset the cost headwinds we faced. Over the course of the year, we refreshed the Card Factory strategy and tested its core elements, which are aimed at strengthening the U.K. proposition and completing the components of our international push. In recent weeks, obviously, our attention has been on the business through COVID-19, but above all, on the health and safety of our colleagues and customers now and in the future.
Karen Hubbard
executiveI’ll pass things over to Kris so he can walk us through the financial side of how we performed.
Kristian Lee
executiveThanks, Karen. Turning to Slide 4, we have the FY '20 financial performance for Card Factory Group, then the KPIs — headline KPIs — and highlights are on Page 5. Revenue rose to GBP 451.5 million, and underlying profit before tax came in at $67.2 million. Like-for-likes dipped slightly, landing at 0.5% down, and the leverage ratio was broadly level with the previous year. Moving on to Slide 6, which essentially sets out the financial summary: total revenue was up 3.6%, powered by 50 net new stores online and retail partnerships, while like-for-like, as I mentioned, stood at minus 0.5%. Retail partnerships are not yet fully annualized, at GBP 3.1 million. Underlying EBITDA, post-IFRS 16, is GBP 125.9 million, and pre-IFRS 16 it's GBP 81.2 million. On dividends overall, an ordinary dividend of 2.9p was paid, plus an additional special dividend of 5p during the year. CapEx came in below guidance at GBP 14.5 million, and net debt in fact reduced a little, to GBP 289 million. The leverage ratio matched the guidance set earlier, at 1.76x. Now to Slide 7, covering the like-for-like assumptions: overall, Card Factory stores posted a negative 0.7% LFL, whereas online advanced 14.8%, giving us the net minus 0.5%.
Kristian Lee
executiveBut we did offset the drop in footfall — the one driven by the macroeconomic backdrop — by growing the average basket value. And when we compare that with various U.K. footfall trackers, which showed footfall declining somewhere between minus 1.3% and minus 4.7%, we have for the most part offset that reduction in footfall. Now on to the divisional analysis on Page 8. As I mentioned, overall revenue grew by 3.3%. That came from the net 50 new stores we opened, on which we still earn a good return on capital. And during the year we have continued to see some impact on EBITDA, purely from the stock build we are seeing as part of our Brexit plan, which I will cover later on the BEP slide. Turning to Slide 9, the divisional analysis of online. Overall Card Factory online grew by 14.8%, while GettingPersonal was disappointing at minus 9.8%. That said, the cost of customer acquisition and promotion-led competitor pricing has remained an issue. There will be a further update on the longer-term plans for the business, which Karen will cover. Moving to Slide 10. The divisional analysis of retail partnerships.
Kristian Lee
executiveSo overall, during the period, we gave GBP 3.1 million of extra revenue to those channels around Aldi; The Reject Shop; Matalan trail; and the 3 franchises in Jersey, Guernsey and Gibraltar. On the whole, at product margin level these are slightly dilutive, but at both the pound and percentage EBITDA level they are actually accretive. And obviously that figure of GBP 3.1 million is not fully annualized in the year. Moving to Page 11, best-in-class margins. Overall, within the year, the impact was 250 basis points. The main areas of that: 210 basis points were around the cost of goods and store wages. On cost of goods, there was some shift in product mix because of how strongly noncard performed, and also the impact of additional stock provision on the basis that we were holding GBP 15 million more stock at the half year, which I'm pleased to say is now under the prior year at the year-end, so good work through there. And on store wages, we mitigated a large proportion of the National Living Wage, but not all of it, which is where that 90 basis points comes from. Other direct expenses. Again, the increased holding costs of stock meant there was some impact on direct expenses.
Kristian Lee
executiveAlso, on the opex side, we did invest somewhat in IT infrastructure — new ATR Systems, time and attendance, and a data warehouse — but these are all components of the strategy as we move forward. And on the whole, for the year, roughly GBP 4.4 million of costs sit in the P&L as one-off nonrecurring items, based on the stock build numbers. So all told, the EBITDA percentage came in at 27.9% post-IFRS 16 and 18% pre-IFRS 16. If I move you to Page 12, looking at free cash flow for the business: strong cash generation once again. As you can see, this is now a post-IFRS 16 cash flow, where the depreciation line shows GBP 52.8 million and lease liabilities are negative GBP 41 million. The net of those 2 is effectively depreciation and amortization, which does include the goodwill write-off. Continuing further down, working capital was negative GBP 2 million for the year. Keep in mind that we had GBP 16 million that landed in the year at the close of FY '19, which related purely to working capital timing. Corporation tax of GBP 14.6 million reflected just the timing of on-account payments, and CapEx, as mentioned earlier, was GBP 14.5 million, below the guidance provided, delivering free cash flow of GBP 47.1 million and leaving a net debt increase of GBP 1.8 million during the year.
Kristian Lee
executiveNow let's turn to CapEx, which is on Slide 13. During the year, our main strategic investments went toward vertical integration, including spending on a new foiler — that machine really lowers the cost per item when it comes to foiling cards. We also put money into the new printing press, and it has doubled both our speed and our capacity, letting us handle shorter print runs as well as high volumes. On the replatform of Card Factory, we spent GBP 2 million this year, and we also funded other commercial initiatives aimed at lifting sales densities, plus supply chain technologies such as voice picking. As for recurring Capex, it's broadly consistent with previous years when you factor in the net 50 stores opening. Regarding guidance for FY '21, as things stand right now, we still expect to make the key strategic investments, for example consolidating warehousing, which brings OpEx improvements, along with e-com and items like the data warehouse, all of which will add value to the business over the longer term. Investment in new stores has been limited to legally exchanged properties amounting to just 7, and we'll provide further updates on stores over the longer term at a later point. Moving to Slide 14, covering dividends and capital policy.
Kristian Lee
executiveLike I said before, the ordinary interim dividend paid was 2.9p, along with a special dividend of 5p. Because of COVID-19's effects, there was no final dividend in FY '20. At present, we don't anticipate any dividends in FY '21 either, as we work to safeguard the balance sheet through these uncertain times. Our overall capital policy stays the same — 1 to 2x on a pre-IFRS 16 basis, and roughly 1.3x to 2.8x post-IFRS 16. That said, in FY '21, COVID's impact means we'll briefly peak above that 2x level. Turning to Slide 15, the liquidity update. On a group basis, I'm happy to report we hold an existing GBP 200 million revolving credit facility running until October 23. In addition, we've obtained the option for access to the COVID Corporate Financing Facility via the Bank of England. And we — over the stretch from now essentially through June '21, we have replacement covenants plus a waiver of the existing ones, covering total net debt and monthly cash burn measured on the last 12 months of underlying EBITDA. Another agreed term worth flagging: equity distributions and acquisitions across this window, effectively until June, will be restricted until leverage falls below 2x, and no commercial paper remains outstanding under the CCFF.
Kristian Lee
executiveAll of those figures are on a pre-IFRS 16 basis. When it comes to conserving cash, we've taken every step you'd expect across the business to manage stock intake. We've sought to make use of the options government has provided around PAYE, National Insurance and VAT deferrals, business rates, holidays, the option to furlough employees during this period, and of course we're in the important rent negotiations with landlords, examining deferrals or discounts on rents. That said, the Board as a whole is confident the group can access enough liquidity to navigate the period ahead. On FY '21 guidance, right now we don't intend to provide guidance until we have greater certainty on trading performance as and when stores begin reopening after the 15th of June. That covers the financial update. I'll hand back to Karen for the business update on Slide 16.
Karen Hubbard
executiveThanks, Kris. So as a business update, the aim here is to give you a sense of what drove the financial results over the course of the year. If I could direct your attention to Slide 17. We concentrated on 3 things during the year. First, maximizing financial performance and delivering the operational plan for the year. Second, we kept investing in key areas of the business to underpin longer-term growth. And while doing that, third, we were developing and testing the 5-year strategy to make sure it delivers tangible and sustainable results. I'd like to walk you through how the business performed at end of year, in line with the current 4 pillar strategy. So first, on Slide 19, like-for-like sales. We put in a reasonable sales performance in what was a challenging year for the high street, growing our volume and value card market share in the mature and stable U.K. greeting card market, and using our EPOS data let us grow average basket value and partly offset the decline in high street footfall. On top of that, we had our third year of successive volume and value growth for our key seasons of Valentine's and Mother's Day in both card and complementary products.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAs we mentioned in our Christmas trading statement, festive results were lackluster, reflecting 3 factors coming together: a challenging high street amid political uncertainty; Christmas itself losing some of its seasonal strength; and we made certain mistakes in stores — notably with a few of the main captions and ranges on single cards. Moving to new store performance on Slide '20. During the year we launched a net new 50 stores, and we likewise used the chance to shut and/or relocate certain underperforming locations as part of the twice-yearly review of our estate. In ROI we added 6 new stores, taking us to 13 stores there. In that market our business is doing very well for us, and going forward we see further opportunities to reach white space for greeting cards across the Republic of Ireland. Stores give us a strong opportunity, since average lease time to lease break stands at 2.5 years, giving us considerable flexibility to react to local shifts in towns and shopping venues and to make sure we always hold the most suitable leases. In the year as well, we increased sales via our Aldi supply arrangements and began Matalan partnerships.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAnd even though these are still early-stage, we view them as solid chances to grow our market share down the road, especially when it comes to impulse shopping — for customers who simply want to grab 1 or 2 cards and wouldn't make the trip to a Card Factory location. We still aren't seeing any cannibalization from these retail locations against our own stores. Moving to Slide 21 on business efficiencies. With our business efficiencies program, we largely delivered most of the initiatives we had in what was a very ambitious year, including bringing in new printing capability, which allowed fast production with less labor. We rolled out voice picking across the warehouses and made further progress on our efficiency program in terms of how we pick and deliver stock to stores. We took out over 300,000 hours in stores by introducing efficiencies in noncustomer-facing tasks, such as auto-replenishment of cards, rather than having colleagues order them manually. We also brought in electronic store rotors and cut back on back-office processes. Our program of ongoing improvement in rent, stock and cash loss carried on through the year with good results across all areas, lowering our costs in stores. Having delivered on our improvement program, the impact of these savings overall was then affected by some one-off costs, which Kris has covered, particularly in relation to stock.
Karen Hubbard
executiveMoving to pillar four, online, which Slide 22 addresses. Throughout the year, we kept selling via our 2 websites, cardfactory.co.uk. and GettingPersonal. At Card Factory, traffic and conversion both grew nicely, with those sales coming from items sold mainly online that aren't stocked in stores, though we did alter that offer when COVID-19 arrived, and rather successfully. A solid amount of newness from redesigning products drove strong sales during the year. Our new platform, launching in the first half of FY '21, will markedly enhance what we offer customers and let us become a genuine multichannel retailer. GettingPersonal, by contrast, posted weak like-for-like sales and saw customer acquisition costs rise further. As part of the strategic review of that business, we decided to fold the brand and its operation into the new Card Factory platform. That lets us keep sales while stripping out a substantial operating cost. Integration is already underway, and it will see us draw on the investments and structure behind Card Factory online, with the transition finishing in the second half of this financial year. Let me move quickly to the greeting card market.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAnyone who's tracked us for a while knows we refresh the market data every year. The summary appears on Slide 24. Our research this year found that, for a fifth consecutive year, we're regarded as the #1 retailer for value for money. We keep delivering what matters to customers in this market by hitting the top 5 factors that shape card shopping choices, and we keep selling 1 of every 3 greeting cards in the U.K. market. Slide 25 lays out the market by value and volume. The card market's fundamentals are still intact. It's large and broadly stable. Our refreshed analysis indicates that rising average card prices more than make up for the very modest year-on-year decline in volume. We're seeing interesting growth areas that align with broader consumer trends, like growth in new and non-standard occasions, which offsets a long-term decline in Christmas card giving, along with a growing minority of shoppers who now buy cards on impulse instead of during planned shopping missions. These open up new opportunities for our business, which has lifted its volume share once again to 33% of single greeting cards despite competition that keeps getting more aggressive.
Karen Hubbard
executiveRegarding where we sit in the market, that's what Slide 26 illustrates. Beyond the market itself, Card Factory has kept strengthening its defensible position—the leading stance on value for money, quality, price, and a broad selection of cards. That's the clear blue water positioning, as we've referred to it before, and we still lead the market on those mentions of price and quality versus discounters, grocers, and specialists. As I've mentioned throughout the year, the Board has concentrated on reviewing and refreshing Card Factory's strategy. We've already announced a plan to share this extended strategy on the 28th of July. Through this strategic review, we've carried out a substantial amount of customer research, examined our EPOS sales data in detail, and assessed the various markets using customer insights both in the U.K. and internationally. We've identified 3 shifts in data and insight that present a significant opportunity. First, changed occasions—growth in every day and other seasons for card giving, alongside a slight reduction in Christmas card giving. Second, mission changes—a move of customers into impulse card buying from a planned visit.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAnd thirdly, there are channel shifts — online card shopping is growing more quickly. Our refresh strategy accounts for these developments, and so it gives the Card Factory business fresh opportunities. We see growth potential in 3 main areas: a card-led proposition that wins, getting those products to customers in more markets through whatever shopping method they prefer, and maintaining and strengthening the model we already have. If you look at Slide 28, it sets out how we build a card-led proposition that wins. For the business to succeed, it's clear to us that what we offer has to rest on a retail proposition led by cards that wins. To get there, we'll be customer-led and make use of the substantial data at our disposal covering both current and prospective customers. That data has helped us build clear customer profiles, like the one you see on screen, which lets us target the opportunity precisely. Leading in card choice will mean offering the broadest selection of cards, with those ranges continually improved and refreshed. We'll build complementary categories so that every customer visit to our stores is fully capitalized on, drawing on the success factors behind our past performance.
Karen Hubbard
executiveWe're going to roll out marketing and loyalty initiatives to tackle some of the perceptions around the brand, which should widen the pool of potential Card Factory customers and get the most out of what they spend in our stores. And then last, a distinctive and defensive pricing approach — a defensive price strategy — with ongoing review of our pricing so that shoppers get market-leading value and Card Factory earns attractive margins. Our strategy is clear, and we've already tested certain elements of it. On Slide 29, having built out the proposition, we intend to offer it in more locations, no matter how customers want to shop. A major factor underpinning Card Factory's market leadership so far has been an extensive store estate of more than 1,000 locations that keeps growing. Market research indicates we can lift market share even higher by making Card Factory products available through complementary alternative formats and initiatives. There are 5 distinct aspects to extending coverage. First, we'll keep examining in detail both the existing U.K. store estate and where we intend to open new stores, so we're positioned in the best possible locations, whether on the high street or, more and more, on retail parks. While our store rollout program stays a key element of the growth strategy, we'll weigh the pace and scale as we evaluate what COVID-19 means for store trading.
Karen Hubbard
executiveWe’re going to start testing some new formats in places where there’s local demand, and those could be either smaller in scale or different in character from the main Card Factory facia. We’ll also take advantage of the rising trend of impulse buying by partnering with retailers that are in suitable locations and that have complementary brand propositions. We’re encouraged by how this model has progressed through the current Aldi relationship and the ongoing trial with Matalan. As a reminder, as of today, 493 Aldi stores are retailing Card Factory products. We have different formats in Matalan stores, and we’re looking for other ways to help more customers access our ranges. These don’t cannibalize our existing estate, because they capture the customer who is just looking for an impulse card purchase. We’ll also be offering our ranges, retail expertise and the Card Factory brand internationally, leveraging the infrastructure we have. We’ve opened in Australia with The Reject Shop following the initial trial, and we’re now trading in 355 stores, with 170 opened at the end of FY ’20. And finally, to enable all customers to have access to Card Factory products, we’ll be looking to grow market share through online transactions.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAlthough online transactions are projected to increase, they remain fairly small, representing 8% of U.K. card volume. In half 1 FY '21, we'll introduce the new web platform, which will let us expand our online footprint considerably and make use of our store estate, greatly enhancing our capacity to operate as an omni-channel retailer. Turning to Slide 30, we set out how we will sustain and extend our competitive advantage. A key competitive advantage is Card Factory's vertically-integrated business model, which enables us to provide customers with both quality and value while generating attractive margins for the business. To sustain this important differentiator, we plan to keep investing in this business model. The focus will be on, firstly, the retail operating model transformation. Across the entire estate, we've identified a number of additional opportunities, from designing a card or gift through the manufacturing and then into the store itself, where we know we can serve our customers more efficiently. This will help us achieve the lowest cost to operate, particularly in relation to the store operating model. Technology will be important in the ongoing improvement of this and will allow us to leverage infrastructure to support all channels of trade.
Karen Hubbard
executiveSecond, our attention will go toward investments in manufacturing and the supply chain. The infrastructure needed to back new sales channels with retail partners, in the U.K. as well as internationally, is already under construction. Investments in our vertical supply chain and in manufacturing technology will be made to lift product margins and bring down the operational cost base. Beyond that, we are evaluating the chance to move production of additional handmade card ranges back into the U.K., which would give us greater flexibility in responding to customer demand. That covers the summary of our refreshed strategy work. More detail on the strategy will be shared, with the wider Executive Board presenting so that you can gain a view of the growth impacts arising from each of these strands. Delivery of that will happen on the 28th of July, and at this stage we are planning to hold it virtually, of course. I would like to provide an update on where our business stands following COVID-19. So may I draw your attention to Slide 32. Before COVID, we had made a satisfactory start to the year. As a matter of fact, for Valentine's Day we recorded our fourth successive year of growth in cards, in terms of both volume and value.
Karen Hubbard
executiveEver since we closed our stores, we've kept trading through both of our online businesses, and we've witnessed substantial increases in visitors, conversion and sales. Since the lockdown, the Card Factory website has grown 302%, meaning it's achieved 153% growth year-to-date. GettingPersonnel has posted growth of 68%, which represents a 27% growth rate year-to-date. To respond to this higher demand and make sure we had proper social distancing in our fulfillment center, we quickly set up a second unit in Wakefield, using part of one of our existing warehouses. On top of that, we've carried on supplying card ranges to both Aldi and our Australian partner, The Reject Shop. While both of these businesses have themselves been affected by COVID-19, both are seeing strong greeting card sales during this period. After government guidance led us to shut all of our stores on the 23rd of March, more than 90% of our colleagues have been furloughed under the government's Job Retention Scheme. That said, parts of the operation do remain at work, but we've made it possible for most of our colleagues to either be socially distanced or work from home. In light of the government's recent announcements, we are getting ready for the phased reopening of our stores, making sure we comply with the requirements of Covid-Secure.
Karen Hubbard
executiveWe’ve done a great deal of preparation for reopening, and right now we’re making changes to how our stores operate so that both colleagues and customers can stay very safe in our shops. In most stores, we expect to be able to support proper social distancing. Over the last several weeks, the team has worked through the specifics of social distancing, including time actually spent in shops, to make sure we have the right equipment, PPE, and everything else required to plan a phased reopening of our stores safely. Throughout this, our priority has been keeping our colleagues and customers safe on an ongoing basis. Clearly, in some shops, social distancing could affect how we are able to trade. That said, the teams are working through a plan to optimize sales and are testing new ways of trading in stores that will let customers come in less often while buying more on each visit. We plan to run trials in the first weeks so we can better understand the implications and any further changes we may need to make. Our Board and management team have responded quickly to a highly dynamic situation, and I am confident that we will come out of this crisis with an operating model and customer proposition that will make Card Factory the customer’s first choice for greeting cards everywhere and for all occasions, however they wish to shop.
Karen Hubbard
executiveNaturally, with the uncertainty involved, we can't offer specific guidance about future performance, though we'll keep watching how things go in the early days of store trading. So to sum up, on Slide 33, we turned in a reasonable sales performance during a challenging year for the high street. We've increased both our volume and value card market share within the mature and stable U.K. greeting card market. Profitability, though, took a hit from a number of recurring cost pressures plus other one-off operational costs that we couldn't fully mitigate. Over the course of the year, we also put together a refreshed long-term strategy aimed at future profitable growth. That strategy centers on strengthening both our market position and the financial performance of the U.K. business. In the second half of the year, we tested our pricing positioning elasticity, trialed new customer propositions, and built partnerships to grow our U.K. market share through concessions and supply arrangements. Thanks to these partnerships, we can serve card shoppers when they make impulse-driven purchases away from our retail stores. We've further developed our online infrastructure and capability so that we're set to deliver in what is increasingly becoming a multichannel environment. We agreed a 5-year contract with The Reject Shop in Australia, following a successful concession trial.
Karen Hubbard
executiveOur view is that we have enough opportunity to make use of the infrastructure and supply chain we already have, and to grow market share in the U.K. as well as in other card markets around the world, all under the Card Factory brand. I’m looking forward to laying out the exciting growth plans in detail on the 28th of July. That concludes the formal presentation. I’ll now open things up for Q&A.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Geoff Ruddell of Morgan Stanley.
Geoff Ruddell
analystIs this coming through okay?
Karen Hubbard
executiveGeoff, yes, we’re able to do that.
Geoff Ruddell
analystOkay, sure. I’ve got two questions that are quite different from each other. The first is really more of an administrative one, I suppose: do you still intend to release a separate Q1 trading update? If you aren’t going to, would you be able to share the group-wide like-for-like figure? Then for my second question, I’d like to get a clearer picture of how social distancing will be handled when your stores reopen on the 15th of June. Specifically, will customers be allowed to browse products, pick them up, and put them back down? Will you then need to quarantine those items? Or will you simply accept that shoppers will handle products and carry on? And could you also give some sense of whether that 10% of stores is the only set you’re likely to open during the first month or 2, or whether you expect more stores to open fairly soon after that?
Karen Hubbard
executiveThanks, Geoff. I’ll pass it over to Kris to address the question about Q1 trading, and after that I’ll handle the question on the store opening plan.
Kristian Lee
executiveYes, Geoff, regarding Q1, I think, as we mentioned in the statement, we had a reasonably satisfactory Q1, pretty flat. Obviously, there was the impact before the end of March, but it did affect Mother's Day. So we aren't planning a Q1 update. We will look to provide a trading update, but only once we have the stores reopened. So we're obviously due, like everyone else, to open on 15th of June. And then basically, we'll evaluate how sales begin to build again. And at that point, once we have confidence in the shape of that, that's when we'll give a new forecast to the market at this point.
Karen Hubbard
executiveThanks. Regarding social distancing, as you'd imagine, we've put a great deal of effort into this area. So we've established model stores spanning a variety of sizes. We've installed perspex screens. We've actually adopted the best practices from other retailers. So we've collaborated with other retailers who've been lucky enough to stay open during this period. We've altered our staffing model, so a greeter will be stationed at the shop door to guide customers. What we've heard is that afterward, once stores reopen, customers shop with purpose, and our plan is to make that as easy as possible, so removing excess spinners from our shop floors and so forth. So before opening, we've got quite a bit of work to do just on reshuffling the stores to ensure it's easy to navigate, easy to get around. And in fact, we're giving as much space as possible to customers so they can easily maneuver around the store. As you'd expect, the standard things, PPE, hand sanitizers, all will be there for customers. When it comes to browsing cards and the like, again, we've followed government guidelines on that and also talked to other retailers, such as supermarkets and the like, who've been trading during this period.
Karen Hubbard
executiveSo as I mentioned, we’ll be helping customers find precisely what they’re seeking. Naturally, we expect them to pick up some products and browse. We’ll encourage our customers to follow government guidance on sanitizing hands when they come in, then thorough hand washing and so on. So we’ll be working with shoppers on that. We have some initiatives in trail that I don’t want to fully share, but we have technological solutions we’re currently working through with store teams right now, which will let customers make sure that when they come to the store, they’re able to cut down how many visits they make. For instance, in a balloon visit they would only need to come once, and still they’ll fulfill all their purchase demand. So we’ve been working throughout the business on this—operations and technology teams together, maintenance and so forth. So we’re reasonably confident about how we’re going to be able to open our stores.
Karen Hubbard
executiveRegarding the second portion of what you asked…
Geoff Ruddell
analystAnd as for the sort of profile of reopening those stores.
Karen Hubbard
executiveYes. Sorry, Geoff. Yes. So right now the plan is to open 10% during week one, and we'll test, learn, and reassess. We have several different plans ready — some to speed things up, some to slow down if we had to. So if an issue comes up, we could go slower, but we do have a plan to get every store open and running as fast as we can, though we want to take our time in certain respects. That's why we've been using the phrase hurry slowly — to make sure we take on board the learnings and that our customers and colleagues truly feel safe, adjusting the plan as we go, and then we look to reopen the stores. We do expect — our prioritization has been based on what happened before the closure. So I think it's been fairly well reported. Localized high street did incredibly well before the closure, and we expect that to continue once we reopen. Retail parks also did well, but with large shopping centers, customers tended to drift away from them fairly early. So we've somewhat deprioritized some of those openings.
Geoff Ruddell
analystSo, I mean, is it likely that — I get that you’d rather not hand us an exact schedule. But are you confident that most of the real estate will be open by, I don’t know, let’s say around September, something along those lines?
Karen Hubbard
executiveOh gosh, yes, absolutely. Yes. I wish it's well before that. But yes, we will be guided by the customers and the colleagues.
Operator
operatorWe'll move on to the next question now, coming from Adam Tomlinson at Liberum.
Adam Tomlinson
analystIs my voice coming through?
Karen Hubbard
executiveYes, Adam. Thanks.
Kristian Lee
executiveYeah.
Adam Tomlinson
analystThanks. Yes, a few questions, if I may, please. First, regarding the store reopening, given where you are at the moment, could you just give an idea of what cash burn looks like on a sort of month-by-month basis under the current situation before those reopenings? So that's the first question around the store reopenings. On the growth strategy, I appreciate there's a lot more to come on the 28th of July. But you mentioned a couple of things. On territories, you talked about the U.K. and international as well. Is there anything you can just give at this stage on the relative size of the opportunities there, which ones we should expect? Or are those to be followed in tandem? Also, for the next question, just on the CapEx investment that has gone on this year and continues to be undertaken, any efficiencies, anything around gross margin improvement underlying that you can talk to there? And then just a final question on online, some very strong growth, they're up 300%. Is that a trend that you expect to stick once we move into a more normal trading pattern?
Adam Tomlinson
analystAnd I’d just like to give you a sense of what a springboard this could be for the online part of your business — when you consider the total market, where online penetration might potentially reach, and what opportunities that opens up?
Karen Hubbard
executiveOkay, thanks, Adam. For the first couple of questions, I’ll direct them to Kris. The first one concerns cash burn — the monthly cash burn.
Kristian Lee
executiveOn the monthly cash burn, we've laid out what the new covenants are. That isn't a figure we've made public. What I can tell you is that on the liquidity front, clearly we have a GBP 200 million RCF facility running to 2023. As of the end of May, there's still substantial headroom remaining under that existing facility. And on top of that, clearly we can tap the CCFF Bank of England should we choose to issue commercial paper. So looking at liquidity, I feel good about where the business stands, and in fact, in the financial planning around the 15th of June, we assumed reopenings would come later than that. So we aren't putting out a normative cash burn number, but from a liquidity standpoint, I'd say we're as comfortable as we can be given these circumstances.
Karen Hubbard
executiveYes. Adam, I think the only thing I'd add from a business standpoint is that we've been extremely careful when it comes to handling our cash position. So, in terms of furloughing our colleagues, the team has done a fantastic job handling landlords and similar parties, staying ahead of that, and really managing our suppliers well. We've therefore had genuinely productive conversations with our suppliers about deferring payments and similar arrangements. So we've handled our cash extremely well, as you'd expect from us as a management team. On your second question about growth strategies, all I'd say — I'll pass it to Kris to discuss how large the opportunities are, or as much as you're able to at this point — but what I'd say is that the takeaway people should have is that, absolutely, the vast majority of our business will remain focused primarily on the U.K. core estate, where we're market leaders, and we want to grow that market share even further. However, what we've learned from the first market we entered internationally is that, actually, without needing to invest significantly — because of all the investment the business has made over the last 20 years in its knowledge, its expertise, its asset base, its production capabilities, its operational capabilities, et cetera — we can genuinely leverage those in other markets.
Karen Hubbard
executiveTurning to Australia — the third biggest greeting card market by volume — we've made a very successful entry there, and we expect to capture a fairly substantial share of that market by making the most of the assets we already have. That said, the U.K. is always going to account for the overwhelming bulk of our income in the U.K. So, Kris, I'm not sure whether you'd like to offer any guidance at this point on how big those opportunities are.
Kristian Lee
executiveYeah. No, I guess that one’s tricky. Of course, we’ve already shared the real revenue figure, which came to GBP 3.1 million, spread across the Aldi, TRS, and Matalan trials plus the franchises. Right now, all I can really tell you is that this isn’t a figure for a full year. So clearly, if you annualize it, the run rate would be substantially larger, and at a percentage level it adds to EBITDA. So those are positive contributions. We aren’t seeing any cannibalization come out of it. But yeah, it — obviously we’re somewhat cautious about it, given profitability and channels, and other people reading into that, or potentially challenging us or trying to undercut us. So we’re a bit wary about how much we reveal on profitability and that, at the moment.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAdam, you raised a question regarding the CapEx-efficient investment and which efficiencies we've implemented. So once again, I'll pass it to Kris. Quickly, though, on the second part of that, about the GM improvement. All the enhancements we make at Printcraft, specifically, are mainly concerned with improving margin — so the foiling machine Kris mentioned, and so on. And you'll see in the statement our wish to move more production back to the U.K. from China. The investments we're making there are made for one reason only: to deliver significant margin investments, since we have shorter lead runs when it comes to print production, but also because we believe the technology we're about to bring in will make production of the card cheaper.
Kristian Lee
executiveAs for the other CapEx areas, we are clearly examining the 5-year strategy for the business, which we'll present at the end of July. One key thing we're doing is that we're obviously limiting some CapEx right now. But for certain ones where we know we can consolidate the distribution centers and generate significant OpEx gains from that, things like the e-commerce project, which is quite important, especially given what we've seen off the back of COVID-19, those sorts of CapEx investments are still continuing at this point.
Karen Hubbard
executiveYeah. The largest shift you’re seeing in stores — actually, in store counts, that’s likely the biggest one Kris has mentioned.
Kristian Lee
executiveYeah. Obviously, as we've mentioned, until the picture gets clearer, I think we've got 7 properties with legal exchange status, and those are the only ones we'll limit openings to in FY '21.
Karen Hubbard
executiveOn your question about online, do we think that trend will persist? It's actually quite interesting. Over the last 12 months, we have seen a modest rise in the number of people purchasing cards online. Nothing that — the market still tends to be out-of-home, so people are shopping in stores. So that uptick is already visible for us. And clearly, the investment we're putting into our platform, which will really allow us to be at the leading edge as a multichannel retailer rather than purely online or purely in stores, has us quite excited. I think in the past, card giving has always been about customers wanting to browse, to pick up the card, to really judge whether or not it's quality, whether it will stand up on the mantelpiece and so forth. So my expectation is that a vast majority of card buying, of card purchasing, will still happen in stores. But it will be interesting to see what happens once the stores begin to reopen. And so at this point, we're not really willing to hazard a guess. But I would say, again, come July, again, it won't be the full answer, but we'll certainly be able to see what the trends are looking like at that point in time.
Karen Hubbard
executiveKeep in mind that before COVID, most of what we sold online was actually stuff you couldn't get in a store. That includes some noncard items and digital printing items, but especially cards — the most popular card online is a photo upload card, which is for people like girlfriends to give each other something for a night out or whatever, or for grandchildren to give cards to grandparents with a nice photo of the grandkids. So it's a product specifically that hasn't been available in stores. So I think we'll all be watching that space, since I think many other retailers have also said they'll want to see what happens with the online trend once stores open.
Adam Tomlinson
analystThanks. Sorry — just one quick follow-up on CapEx, again regarding the growth strategy. When you consider the channels opening up for you folks, whether that's the U.K. or internationally, does that need — you mentioned leveraging your existing infrastructure. I'm just curious about how much investment is needed in the infrastructure to capture those opportunities. Does it potentially push your future CapEx run rate much higher than what we've seen historically?
Karen Hubbard
executiveNo, not at all. Take Printcraft's capacity, for instance—we've been enhancing that over the years regardless. So going forward, there could be some, depending on how quickly things come onstream, but we definitely have headroom in Printcraft capacity to produce cards internationally. And the partnerships we're embarking on, both in the U.K. and internationally, are CapEx light. So the partners have made all of the capital investment, not us.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> We'll go ahead and take the following question from Jonathan Pritchard at Peel Hunt.
Jonathan Pritchard
analystLet me just ask a couple of quick factual questions, and then one more if that's alright. First off, what does your average store size come to right now?
Karen Hubbard
executive850? That's right.
Kristian Lee
executiveYeah. Yeah, it's a bit below 1,000.
Karen Hubbard
executiveThat's right.
Jonathan Pritchard
analystWhat number of square feet per customer will you start with on June 15?
Karen Hubbard
executiveJon, that’s a very good question. I’m aware that many big retailers have relied on the square footage figure, and in fact I listened to the presentation you gave on Friday, which I found pretty interesting. On that point, we aren’t using a square footage per customer approach. What we’re using is 2-meter social distancing. So the way we’re putting in place one-way systems in our stores, and the way we’re shifting fixtures, is meant to create room for customers to stay—in line with the guidelines—2 meters apart socially. So we aren’t applying the square footage rule; we’re trying to arrange our stores and let customers browse while having 2 meters of social distancing.
Jonathan Pritchard
analystAll right, that's interesting. In the Going Concern part of today's report, you mentioned reaching 88% of budgeted volumes at Christmas. I'd really like to understand what assumptions sit behind using 88% as your base case. What are your expectations for high street traffic, conversion, and average transaction value? And does that further assume we remain at 2-meter social distancing, or that we return to 1?
Kristian Lee
executiveJonathan, the assumptions we used in the modeling have centered on 2 meters of distancing, though we've also run the model at a 1-meter distance. And the other piece we've done, obviously, is stress testing all the covenants. So we're comfortable that even with a 20% fall in overall like-for-like, as a business, we will be fine. If you look at how we've modeled the demand side and the supply side — demand being where we think high street footfall is going to be, and supply side being what we can put through the store — I think we're fairly comfortable. There is a pinch point in December. And so up until that point, I think we're comfortable. And in December, we have measures that we're taking, and Karen touched on how we can get people through the stores, plus other technology options we can use in queuing systems. So yes, we're not going to give metrics away on it. But yes, I think we're pretty comfortable. We've got our solution.
Operator
operatorKaren, the floor is yours now — please continue.
Karen Hubbard
executiveKate Calvert from Investec has a question. Kate asks what capacity Printcraft was running at last year, and whether the new printer materially added to production capacity or whether that was traction flexibility. She also asks what else can be done in distribution beyond voice picking to improve efficiency. On the first piece about Printcraft, I don't actually have that number at hand, Kate, but we can follow that up. On the new printers — we actually used a couple of new printers last year. Both are significantly faster, some by doing a single run through, doing all of the same fixtures on it but on the card, just a single run through. And the other machine actually enabled us to do some additional attachments that customers have been asking for that previously we would have only been able to get by sending cards to China. So it improved our capacity in effect to be able to do more cards here in the U.K. Both of those machines are significantly faster, have less labor associated with them and a less cost of production. But it does give us further production capacity, because one of the things we haven't done in Printcraft is gone 24/7 at the moment as well.
Karen Hubbard
executiveWe could also significantly scale up capacity if needed, through measures like bringing in more partners and expanding internationally. As for the second part of your question regarding the distribution center, there is actually a great deal we can do. One topic we'll discuss in July is the supply chain improvement program. You might have noticed — it was actually covered in the press — that we've acquired an extra distribution center in Wakefield, and the entire rationale there — for that facility — is that our distribution centers have been realigned. We've actually consolidated a number of distribution centers into that one. So it's bigger. That means we're able to pick and pack 1 order for stores out of 1 distribution center instead of having to shift stock between locations. And we've also managed to bring stock that had been kept in third-party storage into that unit as well, so — along with voice. Another thing we can actually do is pre-pick orders, which lets us handle it during the downtime. For Christmas, for instance, this year, we'll pre-pick orders for stores well ahead of Christmas and get them standing and ready, so we don't have to keep hiring resource at higher cost in order to do that fulfillment.
Karen Hubbard
executiveThere's still a considerable distance to cover, honestly, when it comes to the supply chain side of things. Like I mentioned, we'll have more to share on the 28th of July—there's a whole raft of items, for instance retail-ready packaging for certain products of ours that will be arriving, and so forth. So quite a bit more is still to come at the distribution center.
Kristian Lee
executiveThere's a question about how much flexibility you currently have in the near term around expiry rents, with high street and retail parks, and the big general stores getting better deals. Mostly, what we've been seeing on rents is that we're focused on deferrals. So the March quarter certainly — April, May and June — we're seeking to defer that and pay it across a longer period, and that could be as much as 18 months. One thing landlords are pushing for is to say, well, actually, if you extend the leases, we'll give you a discount. But my view and the Board's view is that in fact, since the impact of COVID-19 will mean rents are going to fall, and given that we have lease expiry on average, or to next breakeven, at 2.5 years, which has come down further over the last couple of years, we believe it will be a bigger opportunity to negotiate rents down a lot further at the next lease event. And some of the ones we've been negotiating at the time of lease renewals now. We are seeing, though, again, extended rent-free periods, and we're seeing some quite substantial drops in rents.
Kristian Lee
executiveWhat I wasn't prepared to do, though, was actually extend leases for a further 3 to 5 years in exchange for what I see as only a modest rent reduction. Clearly, factors such as turnover and certain other items will come into play, and we'll be pushing hard to make sure we achieve those without a base rent in some of these renewals. So we're quite far along in the negotiations, but many of them right now are on a deferral basis.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAnd finally, in the last couple of minutes, we have a question from Olivia at UBS. So here's another one for you about rent, Kris. Olivia's question is how many stores have leases up for renewal in FY '21?
Kristian Lee
executiveYeah. I mean, those do shift from one year to the next. But if you take the 2.5 years we examine ahead of the next lease event, about 1/3 of our stores are being renegotiated annually. So here's one thing we're noticing: since we're renegotiating rents all the time, a number of those large rent declines that folks in the market have been discussing — we've already achieved 2 or 3 rounds across those same periods when it comes to reductions from these landlords, though I do believe there's considerably more opportunity ahead with the lease renewals that are scheduled to come up over the next 12 months.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAnd there's another question from a private investor, asking about the new growth strategy — becoming the world's best greeting card retailer — and whether your preference is branded concessions, franchise fees, or other routes. One of the things we'll cover on the 28 is showing you how we choose the best route to market in a local market here in the U.K. We're also examining various opportunities internationally as well. So the size of the particular market, and how we'd best generate profitable sales from it, is what determines our preference. So in some cases, it could be in the U.K. market. This is — it could be our own store. It could be taking a part of the town by having a unit in Aldi, or going into a retail park, where actually, we don't see the need for a full burn Card Factory store, so we can use a concession. So my answer is that the preference is determined by the size of the market and the opportunity. But we'll share more with you on that in the strategy we present on the 28th of July.
Karen Hubbard
executiveAlright, I believe we've run out of time. I think we've addressed the majority of the questions that came in. So thank you so much for joining us, and for a productive Q&A session. Thank you very much.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.