Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 29, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Paul Moody
executiveHello, and thanks for joining us as we present the interim results covering the half year that ended on 31 July. During this presentation, Kris and I will offer short remarks on the full announcement that came out earlier today. Although this presentation was prerecorded, we will hold a live Q&A session afterward. These results match the expectations we had formed under COVID's influence. A 4.4% decline in stores like-for-like alongside 64% growth online are both encouraging figures. We have kept a tight grip on costs and cash. We have secured funding headroom. The search for a CEO is moving forward satisfactorily. Now let me turn to how we have performed since reopening. Trading in the most recent weeks has been very encouraging, with stores down just 6.9%, transactions trending better, and a very solid average basket value. Online is also still going strong even with every store now open. The new platform is doing well, delivering a much improved shopper experience, and the curated range keeps growing in both breadth and depth. Our partnership ambition is moving ahead, with several active discussions under way with potential partners. Obviously, over the last 6 months, COVID-19 has been everyone's focus. For us, the response has revolved around 3 elements: an RCF renewal built on 3 new covenant tests that will apply through to June 2021.
Paul Moody
executiveWe still have a chance to tap into CCFF. Over this period, we've made use of every form of government financial assistance available. And as you'd expect, there's been forceful handling of both cash and costs.
Kristian Lee
executiveAlright, so looking at the financial performance and the summary for the half year of FY '21. On the whole, revenue came in at GBP 100.5 million. That's GBP 95 million lower than the previous year, which reflects the effect of COVID, while stores' like-for-like revenue came in at minus 4.4%. Online posted plus 64.4%, which brought the group's overall like-for-like revenue to plus 1.6%. The underlying loss before tax stood at GBP 22.3 million, and net debt was GBP 143.9 million, which is GBP 26 million below where it was at the same point a year earlier. Total net debt, including lease liabilities, came to GBP 290 million, with the average lease length now reduced to 2.3 years. Moving on to like-for-like sales. As I said, 64.4% was the combined online sales growth for Card Factory online and Getting Personal, and minus 4.4% was the high street performance from our stores, giving a net positive of 1.6% across the period. If we look purely at stores, sales fell by GBP 102 million, again reflecting the COVID impact. And seasonal trading was certainly hit by store closures — particularly the Mother's Day, Father's Day, Easter and Thank You Teacher seasons. Direct costs, though, were slightly higher, mainly owing to some of the extra measures we put in place around COVID, and also because, as a share of sales, the percentage went up given the sales decline, which left us with an underlying profit before tax loss of GBP 23 million.
Kristian Lee
executiveMoving on to how we did online and across multiple channels. As mentioned, online grew 64.2%. Split across the period, that's a plus 155% for Card Factory online and a plus 32% for the Getting Personal business. While stores were closed, we saw Card Factory online pro forma LFL year-on-year above 200%, and for Getting Personal, over 60%. Another step we've taken with Getting Personal is putting more emphasis on return on investment when it comes to pay-per-click and returns. And on the online side, at Card Factory online, we're more than doubling the number of SKUs for that business. On the whole, profit before tax for the period was GBP 0.5 million into profit versus a loss the year before. Now on to partnerships. Overall, revenues came in line with our forecast, with expectations for this year. We did see a dip at The Reject Shop from the impact of COVID. But overall, as I say, we're in line with where we expect it to be. Margins are slightly lower in the period owing to some of the one-off upfront marketing costs tied to certain partnerships.
Kristian Lee
executiveAnd that allocation does include central overheads. But on the whole, for the half year, both profit and revenue came in as expected. Regarding group profitability, COVID-19 affected it during this period, and I'll now walk through the margin and cost effects. Moving to cost of goods: overall, the impact was 340 basis points, mainly because online performed more strongly than the stores on product margin. Beyond that, additional COVID-related steps were taken around the supply chain, plus some extra stock provisions stemming from disruption to certain spring seasons. Store wages as a whole fell by GBP 16.2 million, to GBP 23.7 million. That was mostly driven by job retention scheme receipts of GBP 15.6 million during the period. Store property costs likewise came in GBP 6.3 million lower, at GBP 6.9 million, largely thanks to the business rates holiday. And other direct expenses dropped GBP 1.9 million, to GBP 8.5 million, reflecting further cost control measures we've put in place as a business. In the same way, operating expenses were also cut by GBP 0.2 million. All told, this means that as a business, cost savings exceeded GBP 24 million during this period.
Kristian Lee
executiveOverall, though, the loss before tax came to GBP 22.3 million as a result of the COVID closures. Now, on the positive free cash flow during the period. Even without the effect of COVID and the closures lasting several months, the business still produced positive operating cash flow of GBP 8.4 million, along with positive free cash flow of GBP 1.1 million. Within those figures, note that deferrals of rent, VAT and credit — better creditor terms — come to GBP 26 million in terms of timing. And there were additional payment holidays of permanent benefits from rates on furlough in the period amounting to GBP 23 million. Still, to achieve positive cash flow given the level of closures we experienced, we think, is a solid outcome. Moving to CapEx now. It was kept under tight control in the period while we maintained our focus on supporting the 5-year strategy. Total CapEx spending in the period reached GBP 3.5 million. The main spend areas: roughly GBP 0.6 million on completing the new platform launched at the start of July for Card Factory online; GBP 0.7 million on supply chain, aimed at boosting efficiency through voice picking; plus the continuing reduction of operating expenses through consolidating our distribution centers; and then other recurring COVID-related costs of about GBP 900,000 for extra in-store equipment to ensure solid social distancing measures.
Kristian Lee
executiveOn FY '21 guidance, we're pointing to roughly GBP 10 million of CapEx for the year. That's below prior years, though it does cover key backing for several strategic initiatives — a new ERP system, more online capacity, and other developments in the vertical integration supply chain. On dividends and capital policy, things are largely unchanged from what we laid out at the Capital Markets Day. There was no FY '20 final dividend, and no dividends are currently expected in FY '21, since we're focused on protecting the balance sheet amid these uncertain times. Over the medium term, the overall capital policy won't shift from the 1 to 2x pre-IFRS 16 EBITDA — we're simply moving now to the more sensible PBT leverage of 1.2 to 2.6 on an equivalent basis. As Paul said earlier, liquidity is in a good place: we have the GBP 200 million revolving credit facility. And year-on-year, we're bringing down some of the overall leverage on the net debt level in the business. We can also tap the Bank of England's CCFF if needed. To reiterate, we have replacement covenants tested monthly through June, before going back to normal covenants on total net debt, monthly cash burn and last 12 months' underlying EBITDA, which gets tested from September.
Kristian Lee
executiveLooking at where we are right now with the forecast, there's ample room under those covenants. So overall, the Board feels confident that the group can access enough liquidity to navigate what lies ahead. In the near term, though, with the uncertainty around COVID-19 at its current level, providing guidance on what we expect for the year simply isn't possible at this point.
Paul Moody
executiveNow I'll give a quick update on how we're doing against the strategy we laid out at the end of July. The chart behind me shows the 3 chevrons that capture the heart of that strategy, and I'd like to spend a moment on where we stand in each one. On leadership in card choice, as you'd expect, we've been fine-tuning ranges and space so that density reaches its maximum. We also remain sharply focused on newness — not only new categories and new occasions, but also fresh design and verse within the categories we already have. A great deal of attention has gone into a new price architecture and strategy, which lets us capitalize on price elasticity and raise prices whenever we judge it appropriate. As we've said previously, test, trial and result sits at the core of that pricing approach, and we'll keep running those tests across the next year to 1.5 years. Innovation is still absolutely central to how we develop our complementary categories. We're narrowing the breadth of category components, which means concentrating on fewer and better categories that support our main push for leadership in card choice. Those calls — on card and on complementary alike — are guided more and more by what our shopper profiles tell us.
Paul Moody
executiveSo we're drawing on data and analytics right across every element of what we offer customers, making sure we get ready and deliver the strongest solution for whatever our customers are after. On the store estate side, as Kris mentioned earlier, current conditions have led us to effectively put the rollout on hold. That said, adding more distribution points through partnerships with national as well as international players remains a key focus for us, and right now we're actively chasing a number of opportunities. Turning to e-commerce and multichannel, we've already talked about the successful launch of our new platform, which substantially improves the customer experience, and the mobile app plus click and collect will arrive imminently. On vertically integrated manufacturing and supply chain, we keep building both capability and capacity. We've already noted the investment going into fulfillment for online, and that will carry on over the coming year to 2 years. Leadership engagement and capability inside the business remain a clear focus, and so does performance management, with KPIs anchored to strategic objectives and reward programs tied to those as well. Beyond that, we still hold a very clear view of our positive impact program, where our ESG program is consolidating and building on initiatives already in place across the business.
Paul Moody
executiveObviously, Christmas is a hugely important time of year for the business. And I want to give a quick rundown of how we've prepared. We've already seen some early signs of Christmas starting sooner, not necessarily right across the whole country but in large geographic areas. And because of that, we're handling the phasing very nimbly. A significant share of Christmas stock is already sitting in Card Factory distribution centers. And recruiting a large number of temporary colleagues is well advanced. We stay very confident that our preparation is solid, focused and will meet what customers expect. Turning now to a summary of what we announced this morning. The results are in line with our expectations but do reflect the impact of store estate closure during the COVID lockdown. We're pleased to see a net debt reduction thanks to successful management of our cost base, working capital and investment. The new cardfactory.co.uk platform launched successfully at the beginning of July. The refreshed strategy that we developed and presented at the end of July is progressing very well. And the planned investment to leverage and enhance our vertically integrated business carries on with great focus. As we think about the outlook, as you'll have already heard, the stores have been trading well since reopening and more recent like-for-like trends keep improving.
Paul Moody
executiveThe same applies to our online operation, where Card Factory is posting like-for-like growth of nearly 72% over the past 4 weeks. Our Christmas planning is sharp and performing very well. The partnership channel keeps trading as we expected, though we must acknowledge the near-term uncertainty, both at home and abroad, caused by the pandemic's impact, the local restrictions that follow from it, and the way those shape customer behavior. We have strong confidence that the new strategy will produce sustainable growth and shareholder value. And at the end of July, as well as today, we have shown how clear our strategy is and how we believe it will let us strengthen our position in the market. As Kris said, guidance for FY '21 has been suspended, and our next scheduled trading update comes on the 14th of January next year. So with that, I would like to wrap up the formal presentation. Kris and I are now happy to take any questions you might have. Thank you.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Right now, it looks like there aren't any questions coming in over the phone.
Executive
executiveThanks, Keith. A handful of questions came in through the webcast. <<operator_script>> Our first one is from Martin Silverman, and he's asking: given that future growth seems to lean heavily on new partnerships, how likely is it that this will hurt retail footfall and affect your long-term plans?
Paul Moody
executiveMartin, Paul here — I'll handle that one. Your point about the present hit to high street footfall is clearly on the mark. That said, with the Aldi partnership we've built, they've recently discussed growing their store count, as I understand it. They've also spoken about what share of their business they expect will stay physical, so to speak, rather than coming through a standalone online channel. Turning to Australia and The Reject Shop, that business bounced back very quickly from the COVID lockdown. Consumer and customer behaviour in that market remains strong. In the near term, it's inevitable that COVID will affect every business in every territory. Even so, we're confident the partners we pick are strong and are leaders in their sector or category. And we'd clearly expect that the success we've had with both Aldi and Reject Shop can be repeated, albeit with the unavoidable modest early drag from COVID's impact.
Executive
executiveJonathan Pritchard from Peel Hunt has our next question. He said that at your Strategy Day, you laid out a clear road map for how you intend to reach 20p-plus of EPS in the mid-20s, yet the shares sit below 40p, which suggests the market is skeptical. What pushback are investors giving you to explain that skepticism?
Kristian Lee
executiveI think since the Capital Markets Day, the response has been really favorable regarding the plans and the level of detail we provided. But then, looking internally, what we have is the entire exec board standing fully behind that plan — 100%. And we have detailed KPIs in place for how we'll deliver that 5-year strategy. On the market being skeptical, I think what matters for us as a business and for the exec board is making sure that what's in that plan gets delivered. That's where our focus sits right now, and obviously navigating through COVID. So even in this period of uncertainty, as far as the elements of the 5-year plan go, everything remains on track at this time.
Executive
executiveJonathan has a follow-up, and he’s asking about the like-for-like performance in August <<inaudible>>, and then minus 6.9% in September.
Kristian Lee
executiveWe haven't provided a 5-month like-for-like figure. What we did share, though, was the trajectory — how that position was improving. So on the whole, what we've observed is transactions recovering steadily, while our basket value has stayed fairly consistent, at around up 23%, 24% in terms of average basket value growth. So we said, in terms of <<inaudible>>, net sales on a like-for-like basis were minus 13%. And over the last 4 weeks, we've seen that fall to just under 7%. That trajectory is good. Obviously, we're watching for any potential local lockdowns. But thus far, that recovery is still continuing.
Executive
executiveKate Calvert from Investec has the next question, and she asks whether you could discuss how much the Card Factory range has grown the date, and whether we should expect another major partnership to arrive within the next 6 months.
Kristian Lee
executiveRegarding the online <<inaudible>>, as you know, we launched it at the start of July. We're continuing to broaden that range, so we're only partway through that process at this point. We're still seeing solid growth since reopening the stores — plus 72% for Card Factory online. So we do believe there's additional capacity there to improve it further. And the plan is that before Christmas, we will have doubled the number of SKUs we have online.
Executive
executiveMoving on to our next question...
Paul Moody
executiveApologies — let me address the second part of what Kate asked, regarding partnerships over the next 6 months. During the presentation I mentioned this, and I believe our position has been consistent: we're in a number of discussions with retailers, especially in the U.K. Making a prediction about when they might finalize some kind of deal would not be advisable, in my view. That said, it seems fair to note that what we achieved with Aldi, along with what we showed with TRS in Australia, has served as a genuinely strong set of almost test cases or benchmarks for other retailers, and those results have generated some productive and interesting dialogue. So no commitment can be made at this point, but this is definitely an area of work we're highly focused on.
Executive
executiveStuart Houston has a question: his local Midlands radio station runs a Moonpig ad two times each hour. So where would Card Factory advertise for its lower-cost online proposition?
Paul Moody
executivePaul here — I'll field that one. Yeah, I'm based in the Midlands too, so I'm likely seeing the very same Moonpig commercials you mentioned. Like Kris said when answering the previous question, we got the cardfactory.co.uk site off the ground successfully at the start of July. We keep expanding how deep and how wide the range goes, covering both personalized items and ones that aren't personalized. Our ability to meet online orders keeps growing. And we definitely intend to promote the dot-co-dot-uk platform in a more direct way. Doing that above-the-line — via radio or TV — before Christmas isn't likely. Still, a really robust social media marketing push for the Card Factory platform is already underway. Plus, since we've got slightly more than 1,000 shops trading, one tactic that's working well for us is flagging to our in-store shoppers the chance to purchase from Card Factory over the web — not only the range we obviously stock in shops, but a considerably wider selection available online. So I'd say we're being thoughtful about above-the-line promotion of the online proposition. Even so, it's plainly part of our plans as we head into the next calendar year.
Executive
executiveWe received a handful of questions from a private investor. First, what's your outlook for overall debt across the next 2 years? And second, how do partner profit margins stack up against shop sales?
Kristian Lee
executiveOn the debt side, clearly we've been actively managing it, which is why at the interims we came in GBP 26 million below last year's level. The plan in this environment is straightforward: we need to ensure the business isn't over the bridge. So right now our focus is on rebuilding the balance sheet while also delivering the 5-year plan. As for future dividend payments, an announcement will come at a later point. But clearly, at the minute, what we're focused on is handling the COVID situation, delivering the 5-year plan and making sure the balance sheet is secure. On margins from partnerships versus our high street stores — yes, obviously, the way those deal structures work is that we sell, say, a 99p card at a lower price point, as an example. The retailer gets a margin. So the overall product margin would be lower. However, we get an offsetting benefit that raises the margin percentage, because we haven't paid rent, rates, any of the occupational costs or staffing costs for that unit, and it's very capital-light. So partnerships remain a very important part of the strategy and of delivering the long-term 5-year profit.
Executive
executiveAnd we have a follow-up from Jonathan Pritchard at Peel Hunt. He just wants some clarification on your suggestion that the partnerships had an impact on your own store sales.
Paul Moody
executiveJonathan, Paul here. That was not what we intended. I think the proof we've accumulated over a long stretch, especially regarding Aldi, shows there's no cannibalization where an existing store estate is absent. So considering how ambitious the ad is about getting Card Factory product into additional points of distribution, the Aldi experience—even in cases where Aldi stores trade reasonably close to 1 or indeed more Card Factory stores—reveals no measurable cannibalization of our business. So it somewhat supports part of the strategy when we discussed providing customers with more opportunity in more places to access Card Factory, and that is working well for us. So no, there is no canalization with the partnering stores.
Executive
executiveWe've got a question from Daniel at <<inaudible>>, asking how pricing has trended lately — say, over the 4 weeks through September 20. Is average selling price per card about the same as in that period a year ago? Or have you raised or lowered prices?
Kristian Lee
executiveRight. So as you know, within that 5-year strategy we said there would be a set of commercial initiatives. Some pricing shifts were part of that. We talked about the move from 59p to 69p. That said, looking year on year, the quantity of price adjustments is quite small. So when it comes to like-for-like performance, no significant pricing changes versus the same period a year ago are affecting it.
Executive
executiveThat brings us to the end of the questions from the webcast. At this point, I'll turn things over to Paul, who will offer some closing remarks.
Paul Moody
executiveAlright. Thanks, everyone, for tuning in to the webcast. I know today is a heavy day for reporting, so I appreciate you giving some of your time to Card Factory. There was a time when a moment like this would have meant going through the whole presentation again. I'm not going to do that. That said, I do want to say that we have a lot of confidence in the strategy we set out at the end of July. The program to reopen stores has turned out to be a big success. As Kris mentioned, every key performance measure is trending in a positive direction. And of course, as I said in my quote in the announcement, we are now 100% focused on a flawless execution of Christmas and on developing and implementing our strategy. So thank you very much. We'll be back to speak with the market again in the middle of January. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.