Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
September 28, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThanks for joining our interim results update covering FY 2022. I'm Darcy, and I serve as CEO of Card Factory; with me today is Kris Lee, our Chief Financial Officer. In a moment, Kris and I will walk you through the financial performance update for the first half of FY 2022. As we said at the prelims, we'll give you an update on the future growth strategy of the business, which has been under review during the past few months since I came on board. Turning first to how we performed financially across the first half of FY 2022, we're pleased with the business's performance. Sales came in at GBP 116.9 million, and Card Factory achieved like-for-like revenues of -3.7%. Broken down, that's stores at -72% and online at +50.2%. The result was a GBP 6.5 million loss before tax. Cash remains a strong focus for us, and net debt now sits below GBP 100 million. Store transaction levels keep beating the Springboard high street footfall data, which shows the strength of the brand and the customer proposition. On top of that, higher average basket value across multiple categories is offsetting the drop in transaction volumes. What's important to note? Unlike other retailers, if a birthday party was missed because of lockdown, that event will not be repeated.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveBut take the wedding category as an example: what we're observing there is that volumes have rebounded as restrictions eased. In the same way, for children's birthday parties, with schools going back and assuming no additional restrictions, we'd expect that category to recover much like weddings. Turning to online, that channel is doing well and will keep receiving our planned investment to fuel future growth. Online is among the growth areas identified in the strategy review, and I'll go into that in more detail later. We're in the midst of transitioning into an omni-channel retailer, so customers can shop at any time and in whatever way suits them. The strategy will demonstrate a greater emphasis on gifting and party categories that complement each other, improving the offer and substantially expanding the addressable market. Crucially, Card Factory will move from being a product-led business to one that is customer-led. Kris will now walk you through the financial performance.
Kris Lee
executiveI want to walk you through how Card Factory performed financially in the first half of FY 2022. If we look at the financial summary, total sales came in at GBP 116.9 million versus GBP 100.5 million a year earlier. In total, stores were permitted to operate for 60% of the period this year compared with 48% during the same period last year. On a two-year like-for-like basis measured against pre-pandemic levels, that figure stood at -7.2%. Online and multi-channel came in at +50.2%, while net Card Factory like-for-like revenue was -3.7%, producing a loss before tax of GBP 6.5 million — an improvement over last year's loss of GBP 22.2 million. Net debt has been kept well in check at GBP 96.5 million, down from GBP 143.9 million the year before. Once lease liabilities are included, the figure is GBP 238.9 million. Let me go into a bit more detail on the like-for-like sales picture and how Card Factory has beaten footfall trends relative to what Springboard data has shown us. I'll go directly to the graph on the right-hand side, which shows in its top line where the average basket value in our stores has stood since we reopened in April.
Kris Lee
executiveSo as you can see, the ABV was placed at over 30% higher at the beginning, and when it comes to transactions, the bottom line — that green line — was -30%. The line in the middle, the yellow one, is essentially the two-year like-for-like sales performance. As you can see from that line, there has been a steady underlying recovery in transactions, and as a result in the like-for-like performance over that period. Now if I turn to the divisional analysis for Card Factory. In total, store revenues came in at GBP 102.7 million. Again, that reflects the 10+ weeks at the start of the year when we were in lockdown. On the whole, store transaction levels remain at pre-pandemic levels. Even so, we have witnessed that strong recovery, which shows the strength of the Card Factory brand. We keep reviewing the estate of just over 1,000 stores to ensure they sit in the right locations to maximize sales, and we grew the net store estate by 3 during the period. It's fair to say that in retail parks we are seeing much stronger performance when it comes to footfall and like-for-like sales. Turning to online performance, even though online grew by 4.8% year-on-year, we should keep in mind that in fact the close down period in FY 2022, as far as the stores were concerned, was lower.
Kris Lee
executiveSo all in all, that's quite a solid result. Getting Personal declined 20.7%. That was a choice made internally inside the business to pursue sales that carry more profit. And we are definitely seeing that come through in the bottom line, where on pay-per-click transactions we're back in a position where we can see return on investment on those keywords. On partnerships, year-on-year growth has been strong at +17.8%, reaching GBP 2.3 million. Total retail locations are up too, moving from 894 to 908. Aldi has performed strongly for us. We've also secured a contract renewal with them. The Reject Shop and Matalan, however, felt the impact of COVID restrictions during the period. Let me now move to the margins for the period. Broadly, cost of goods for the year came in roughly level with the prior year on margin percentage, with a modest 0.8 percentage point improvement, which came from how we've been able to work a lot of the aged seasonal stock from earlier seasons into the new year. Store wages as well — despite rising to GBP 30 million from GBP 23.7 million — really just reflect timing, in terms of lower take-up of the CJRS scheme.
Kris Lee
executiveProperty costs for stores have fallen to GBP 4.5 million from GBP 6.9 million. Once again, the main factor here is timing when it comes to government support on business rates. Moving on to direct expenses and operating expenses, you can see that compared with a year earlier, we've kept those costs level or a touch lower. The sole additional item that bridges down to the operating loss of GBP 6.5 million is net financing expenses. That figure is a little higher at GBP 6.5 million, which mirrors the blended average of the financing currently in place of just under 5%. Another key item worth flagging on the sheet is other income — a one-off GBP 8 million gain in the P&L. That reflects government grants received, relating to government support and the closure of non-essential retail. Now moving to free cash flow. We've continued to see better cash generation in the business, driven largely by the sales improvement and the overall profit performance. There are two more items to flag on cash flow. The first is net working capital, where we've recorded GBP -4.7 million. That is entirely attributable to the deferrals we succeeded in negotiating with landlords on rents and with HMRC on VAT.
Kris Lee
executiveMoving further along the cash flow statement, lease liabilities appear at GBP -1.7 million, and this figure is again attributable simply to the timing of rent payment deferrals shifting into the current year. On the whole, free cash flow was strongly positive at GBP +14.5 million, compared with GBP 1.1 million a year earlier. There's one more key item regarding free cash flow, namely the footnote at the bottom. As you may recall, at the year-end I noted GBP 21 million of rent deferrals that had been negotiated, along with a further GBP 19 million of VAT payment deferrals. Here at the half year, rent deferrals now total GBP 26 million, reflecting additional lockdown periods and further deferrals we've agreed. VAT liability deferrals currently stand at GBP 7 million. My expectation is that by the year-end — going into FY 2023 — most of these payments will have unwound during 2022, though by 2023 somewhere between GBP 6 million and GBP 12 million of deferral payments could land in that year's cash flow. I'd now like to turn to the liquidity update. As you'll remember, in May of this year we issued an announcement concerning the securing of GBP 225 million in financing facilities for the business.
Kris Lee
executiveUp until March 2022, this involved replacement covenants. Another key point from the May agreement was the obligation either to bring in GBP 70 million of net equity by July 2022 or to repay GBP 70 million early using money from other subordinated sources. As a business, it's fair to say capital investment has been kept under tight control so as to preserve cash, while we continue putting money into our long-term strategic goals. The emphasis is on keeping a capital structure that is conservative but still efficient when it comes to delivering long-term returns for shareholders. Our group capital policy remains under review as trading conditions grow clearer and as we see transactions on the high street pick up. I'll now hand back over to Darcy, who will provide an update on the refresh strategy.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAs I mentioned earlier, I'd like to spend today giving you an update on the growth plan we're pursuing going forward. We've carried out a review of the five-year strategy that we first set out at the Capital Markets Day back in July. We had to get a handle on what COVID has done to that strategy, but beyond that, I was keen to make sure it can actually deliver the growth shareholders are looking for and that it carries sufficient ambition to grab the opportunities out there — both in the markets we already serve and in those we might exploit to generate the greatest possible value for shareholders. Moving quickly, we've stress tested the strategy and evolved it, and for the reasons I'll go into, certain areas still require further work. That said, what we now have is a strategic approach that builds on our market leading proposition in cards while putting the business in position to reach wider market opportunity. Let me begin by setting out clearly what our vision is for Card Factory — where we'll stand at the close of FY 2026, once we've delivered on our Opening Our New Future strategy. Across the coming five years, we will turn Card Factory into the first omni-channel brand in our space, helping customers celebrate each and every special occasion.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOur goal is to be the top U.K. shopping destination for every customer who wants outstanding quality, value, selection, ease, and experience. We'll extend our global reach, placing more cards and gifts with more buyers worldwide. Executing this strategy should fuel faster revenue growth and margin improvement, lifting revenues past GBP 600 million by FY 2026, with roughly 20% coming from online and omni-channel and retail partnerships, while building a company with a low cost base and a highly scalable business model. Carrying out the strategy should produce a change in product and channel mix, together with investment that moves PBT margin toward 17% over the long-term. Building on the quality and value heritage we already have, we'll lead Card Factory on a path that gives customers greater convenience through better access to our products wherever they are and wherever they'd like them. Greater choice by extending our leading card offer into complementary ranges, and an exceptional customer experience that turns Card Factory into a destination brand for more customers. To make the best use of our nationwide store estate and answer today's customer needs, we must transform the business from a retail model driven mainly by stores into a full omni-channel offer that leverages existing and invested infrastructure, becoming the first card and gifting retailer to deliver a seamless physical and online customer experience.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveSo this gives people access to every category at any time, from anywhere—whether that's our personalized products through the app or website, at home or while out and about. In our view, omni-channel lets us use our brand, our store estate, vertical integration, quality and value proposition, along with what we've invested in our online channels, to grow our share of the online market substantially. The U.K. online market for cards was estimated at GBP 550 million in 2020. That compares with GBP 177 million in 2019. So we're targeting roughly 10% of group revenues from online by FY 2026, versus 2% today. The budgeted omni-channel capital expenditure will cover near-term investment in several notable areas, including letting customers reach our brand and offer at home, on the move through our apps, and in store via web access. That lets customers access our extended range in store and will test options so we understand appetite and investment return. It also means more shipping options to home or store that fit every budget. And it means more fulfillment capacity, accuracy, and speed so we deliver on our customer service promise. And for customers who want to self-serve through the whole journey, we'll support them with an AI experience centered on recommendations, personalization, notifications, and live chat.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWe’re going to optimize the store portfolio so that Card Factory has profitable shops in high-footfall locations, with 100 new stores added to our current portfolio of 1,000 stores across the U.K. and Republic of Ireland by FY 2026. Those new openings will concentrate on under-penetrated areas, London among them, and on high-footfall areas such as retail parks. The store optimization program will carry on, with sites chosen according to profitability and returns. Our stores will stay a vital route to market — they are not just legacy assets. Store revenues will keep growing on their own, but they’ll account for a smaller share of the mix as online growth speeds up. Targeted pricing and a larger gifting range are among the initiatives expected to lift in-store sales, raise average basket value, and offset the structural trend of a minor year-on-year footfall decline. As part of our omni-channel transformation and through continued platform investment, we expect to raise our online market share from 2%-10%. Our new Business Development Director, Syed Kazmi, joined in late August, and over the coming months we will have designed and begun delivery of our new partnership strategy. That will let Card Factory reach more U.K.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveFor customers, this means a modest investment in extra convenient locations that satisfy rising demand for impulse purchases. On the international side, we'll leverage the group's expertise — things like card design and customer insight — to grow into new territories via partnerships, targeting markets with appealing traits for entry and disruption. We'll stay a card-led retailer in a stable market where 76% of adults are card givers, and we'll satisfy customer demand by offering more choice through complementary gifting and party ranges, which opens access to a large market valued at GBP 40 billion per annum in the U.K., letting us capture more customer spend and lift average basket value. We already lead in party and balloon categories, and for stores we'll look at expanding into additional categories like stationery and confectionery. Other categories are also being explored. None of this will come at the expense of cards in store. It's about making smarter, more agile choices regarding the space given to complementary categories. The card range will be broadened by bringing in more modern and contemporary choice, plus a clearer focus on the in-store proposition to help shoppers. Even so, we expect the SKU size will stay the same. Online, we'll offer far more breadth across complementary categories.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOur vertically integrated business model is going to stay a unique point of difference at all times, giving us the flexibility to react to market changes and enabling efficient, high quality production at attractive margins, supporting online growth with lower cost per unit. By providing a new omni-channel service, Card Factory will improve the customer experience and access to its offer by being the first card and gifting brand to bridge digital with its store estate. An improved customer understanding from new data capabilities will support this, including through the rollout of the group's new ERP platform in quarter four this year. That will let us understand and respond to changing customer habits and preferences, including insight on price elasticity, enabling us to evolve our pricing approach while maintaining high levels of customer satisfaction. We will keep investing in our brand based around quality and value to increase customer awareness and improve trust. Lastly, we will develop our ESG strategy to be recognized as a socially and environmentally responsible business, building on the wide range of existing initiatives that we already have in place. These include the recently introduced foil balloon recycling that is available to any customer visiting our store.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWe're also proud that recycling across our stores now accounts for 87% of all store waste. We'll be a positive contributor in the communities where we operate, and we remain proud of our partnership with Macmillan Cancer Support, for which we've raised GBP 7 million since that relationship began. To sum up, our Opening Our New Future strategy rests on leveraging our market position, customer loyalty, and vertically integrated model to create a platform for our new omni-channel strategy. That means expanding into the gifting segment, which complements the card-giving market extremely well — a market where we're leaders and which is highly resilient. Our refreshed growth strategy will deliver sustainable revenue and profit growth, and we'll invest further and develop across channels to enhance convenience, choice, and experience for customers. Now, with the Christmas season here, I'd like to give an update on our preparations. We're well-positioned, with stock intake brought forward and Card Factory's in-house printing capabilities covering 70% of the range. Recruitment has been brought forward to mid-September, supporting the challenging market we face, and system changes mean we can offer a smooth and speedy onboarding process so we retain successful Christmas candidates.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveNearly every one of our Christmas and everyday ranges is going to transition into auto-replenishment. That way we can be sure the correct stock sits in the correct stores, and it will release colleague hours so they can concentrate on serving customers. This year our product ranges were planned and built around 3 new key design trends, and that includes our character of the year, the Yeti — a fantastic character, and I'd urge every one of you to head out and purchase it. Backing this up are plenty of great value for money offers across the whole store, among them cards starting at GBP 0.29, wonderful gifting ranges spanning soft toys, monogrammed gifts and festive books, and even terrific chocolate character decorations for the tree, each one just GBP 1. Throughout our single Christmas card range, we've put in real effort to cut the quantity of glitter used significantly. On top of that, we're delighted that we've managed to take all the plastic out of our boxed card range, which saves the equivalent of 6.5 million plastic bottles. To sum up, Card Factory is now well positioned for growth, with a target of over GBP 600 million of sales by FY 2026. We will open 100 net new stores, which adds to the existing portfolio of over 1,000 stores across the U.K.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAnd by FY 2026, that includes the Republic of Ireland. By FY 2026, we expect to move toward 20% of sales coming from online and omni-channel as well as retail partnerships. Over the longer term, our PBT margin will trend toward 17%, which reflects the shift in product and channel mix, and by then our transformation into a full omni-channel offer will be complete. Thank you for your time today. We now look forward to answering any questions that you may have.
Speaker
unknownThanks so much. We've received a fair number of questions through the webcast. Just a quick reminder that if you'd like to ask something, please use the toolbar located at the bottom of your screen. Vikram is first up with a few questions. Here's the first one: in the May trading update and the Annual Report, the company said it would use best efforts to raise equity with net proceeds of GBP 70 million. In the most recent update, that language has been altered to say the company is permitted to facilitate these payments through issuing new equity or through debt. The wording was changed so that best efforts for an equity raise are excluded. What's the reason for that?
Kris Lee
executiveYeah, just so we’re clear, nothing has changed there at all. Best efforts still applies to the equity raise or to prepaying through subordinated debt. That’s only an update to the presentation. The best efforts requirement itself is unchanged.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We have another one for Kris, and it comes from Vikram once more. Vikram has a couple of questions—actually, three questions here—so I'll put all of them to you at once. The first: when are the term loan and the CLBILS debt due? Second: what prepayment amount must you make by July 2022 so that the GBP 5 million penalty isn't triggered? And his final question: which conditions have to be satisfied for the RCF loan to be extended through 2024?
Kris Lee
executiveOn that first question, the term loan CLBILS debt's due date under the agreement is effectively September 2023. What prepayment amount would we have to make by July 2022 so as to avoid the GBP 5 million penalty? How it works is that if we raise GBP 70 million of net equity by November, we pay none of that GBP 5 million penalty. Should we fail to do so after July, the full GBP 5 million penalty applies, with a ratchet in between. If we fall short of the GBP 70 million, the GBP 5 million is effectively prorated against that amount. As for the extension through to September 2024, that is basically contingent on us completing a successful equity raise of GBP 70 million or GBP 70 million of subordinated debt.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We’ll go next to Harvey Jones. How much progress have you made in growing partnership revenues, and how near is Card Factory to signing any new deals?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAppreciate the question. Partnerships, I'd say, are still a key element of what we're doing, and progress keeps being made. The main thing that's happened, I'd point to, is bringing Syed on board as our new Business Development Director — he brings a lot of experience in this area. He came aboard a few weeks back, and right now he's busy going through both the work under way and the strategy. So expect to hear more from us down the road.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Our next question comes from Richard Martin. Why aren't you milking your estate by extending hours — not just on weekdays but on Sunday too, particularly in areas where you're near other stores that open longer? On most of your shops, you could also stay open later on Sundays. That's more of a comment. Maybe Darcy can address that one.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAbsolutely. We do have a program in place for reviewing the opening hours at every store. Obviously, with the low price point and the labor costs involved, it's important to make sure things are economic. Steve, who is our retail director, runs a program through which that gets looked at on a frequent basis, and we make adjustments to the estate whenever that's needed.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Our next question comes from Peter Canlish, who asks if we could elaborate on the reasons online revenue remains so sluggish when looked at in absolute terms. Why is that growth slow? And what is going to drive Card Factory's online market share upward across the next 12 months and in the years ahead?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveYeah. As far as online goes, we arrived at it fairly late. The platform was installed roughly 12 months back, and after that we brought out the apps. On top of that, while lockdown was happening, we ran into capacity problems with fulfillment. We keep putting money into the technology and keep putting money into fulfillment so we're able to handle the peaks effectively. We're sticking with the strategy I laid out. We've carried out a deep dive into online, and we now have a solid strategy along with a program of works that will support substantial growth in that business.
Speaker
unknownThank you, that's great. We'll take the next question from Adam Tomlinson at Liberum. Adam would like us to discuss how we view the cost outlook as we head into 2022 across freight, wages, rent, utilities and so on. And if that pressure continues, which levers can we pull to help offset it? That one may be for Kris.
Kris Lee
executiveLet me address these one by one. On freight, as everyone has observed, costs have gone up. That will create a bit of a headwind during the second half of the year. As for mitigating it, one step we're pursuing is essentially trying to level out the intake, which means getting the best possible container fills. We're also doing things to automate and soften the impact. On wages, there are items such as agency staff and covering the Christmas trading period. Naturally, plenty has been said in the market about the pressures in that area. We moved fairly early on recruiting. That's progressing well. Clearly, there's still a stretch of runway before we get to Christmas. Thus far, we haven't seen any significant wage inflation there, but there's still time. Some pressure on agency staff is possible. On rents, on the whole, we've been securing good reductions. Of course, these are the ones where leases are up for renewal. Most rents agreed came with deferrals. Some carried cash savings as well. Overall, across the year, on the ones we've renegotiated, we've achieved good results.
Kris Lee
executiveIn a few cases, we've sought to capitalize on the situation and pull some rent reviews forward slightly, negotiating ahead of time while the market remains as it is. Lastly, regarding utilities—especially electricity and wholesale prices—and where those have been trending: we're effectively hedged for the coming three years on electricity, so we've taken action to reduce that expense. Yeah, I'd say the major item there is freight, and as a company, we're examining which levers we can pull to offset that expense, along with how efficiently we can get the stock in.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Adam actually has two more questions, so let’s take all of them now. His other one was this: How are you viewing your headroom to raise prices? And could you share any further information or updates on the discussions you’re having with potential new retail partners?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThanks. From a pricing standpoint, obviously we implemented some price hikes during the past year, and we haven't observed any negative impact on volumes from those. We're currently doing some analysis to better grasp pricing elasticity. My view is that we should treat pricing as one tool available to us for counterbalancing inflation, along with other initiatives related to productivity that are underway. Our focus is on preserving the value proposition we offer while simultaneously ensuring that suitable inflation gets passed through. Regarding partnerships, there's nothing more I can share beyond the fact that Syed has joined, and he is in the process of reviewing the strategy right now.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Our next question comes from Toso, who thanks you for the presentation and asks what criteria are used to choose between the capital raising mechanisms. He notes that at the current market cap, a GBP 70 million equity raise would dilute current shareholders enormously. What options are less damaging, he asks, and why isn't this path clear yet?
Kris Lee
executiveRegarding the process we've gone through, as we mentioned, the refinances were completed in May. The board is weighing every option. Clearly, on that point, we're factoring in all stakeholders, shareholders included, when it comes to a possible equity raise. Beyond that, we're also examining other debt alternatives. There's no update to share at this moment. You can be certain that the board and I are actively reviewing every option, and we aim to provide clarity on this as soon as possible.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Our next question comes from Patrick Gerrard, and he asks whether there's a forecast for when the decision will be made to increase the company's capital. Given that the lockdown has ended and the future prospect for revenue is at least equal to the pre-pandemic level, what's the probability that raising more funds through the issuance of new shares will be necessary?
Kris Lee
executiveRegarding that particular point, I would really need to point you back to what I said before. As I mentioned, we are examining every one of the various alternatives, whether that means debt options or the equity raise options, in line with what the legal bank agreement stipulates.
Speaker
unknownThank you. Great. Harvey Jones has sent in another question, which is: should Card Factory look at a marketplace approach for its website — that is, giving complementary retailers space on the site, while not handling fulfillment for them? Flowers would be one example. I'm not certain that actually counts as a question, but perhaps Darcy could respond to it.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveSure, I’ll handle that question. In line with our strategy, we’ve discussed growing into gift offerings across adjacent categories, and having third parties handle gift fulfillment is certainly one possibility that we’re evaluating.
Speaker
unknownThanks a lot. The next question comes from Ulrich, and he has two questions. His first one is, "Is there any possibility that the loans due for repayment in 2022 could be covered by operating results, without pursuing a capital increase and diluting shareholders' equity? Have you perhaps reached out to your major shareholders to see whether they can support you in arranging financing via subordinated loans?" His second question is: regarding the international partnerships, which countries are you approaching at this point? Those are his questions.
Kris Lee
executiveYeah, this is along the same lines as the earlier questions. Honestly, there isn’t anything more I can add beyond saying that, as you would expect, we’ve consulted with all stakeholders. In the end, it’ll be up to the board to decide what the options are. On the second point about international partnerships, the countries we kind of set out at Capital Markets Day, which countries those might potentially be. As Darcy said, Syed is now on board, though he’s only been with us for a short period. Clearly, one of the main things he’s evaluating is the U.K. and internationally, what the opportunities are.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We’ve got a question about the Yeti. Perhaps Darcy can handle this one. How invested is Card Factory in the Yeti?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveI have a lot of confidence in our products team, which includes both the commercial side and the design side. As for the Yeti, we're excited about it — we believe it will sell well in 2024, and we've essentially bought the right amount. Yeah, we're excited about it.
Speaker
unknownKate Calvert from Investec is up next with three questions. Her first one: is there a chance to remove cash rent as we go forward, or, given the plan to add roughly 100, would a flat profile be more suitable year on year? Question two: what are your views on pricing architecture, considering recent trials at higher price points and the possibility of stretching it? Her final question concerns the partnership model — could you say where you stand on building a pipeline, and ought we to anticipate news about further contracts within the next year?
Kris Lee
executiveI'll take the first question. On rent, I suppose I'm just reiterating that what we agreed during the lockdown periods was negotiated with landlords in terms of deferrals. There were options to perhaps get cash reductions on that deferred rent, but only on the basis that a lot of these deals were signed up to longer tenure. One of the things we've always kept in the portfolio is keeping it as flexible as we can on that top two and a half years, reducing the lease lengths, which I think makes it even more important that we review that as the 1,000 stores and locations. As I say, we are getting rents down in terms of the negotiations we're currently having as leases come up for renewal. In terms of the circa 100 stores that we're looking to add on, we still think 1,100 stores is achievable. The focus will be on making sure they hit the investment criterion and hurdle rates. That 18-month payback has always been something we've looked at, so that will still remain the focus when we're assessing adding that 100 stores. I think equally, if not more important, is more the 1,000 stores, their location, maximizing sales out of those locations.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We’ve also got another question from Kate. She’s asking whether you can provide some detail on the investment that’s needed in manufacturing to deliver your refresh strategy.
Kris Lee
executiveApologies, I believe that point went unanswered.
Speaker
unknownMoving on to sections two and three. Darcy, would you take the second part?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveRight.
Kris Lee
executiveThose elevated price tiers.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOn the other two questions about pricing architecture, I believe I've already covered a few of them. Look, I realize there's a lot of appetite for us to get very specific about how much headroom we see in prices, and that is a genuinely hard question to answer. What I will say is that historically, pricing has been an underused lever in this business, and it's one that remains available to us, and we'll apply it appropriately. It's also about keeping the balance between value and price. We recently completed a full review of competitors' pricing across the market to understand where we stand. I don't think I have anything further to add beyond that. And on the partnership model again, I believe that question has been addressed.
Speaker
unknownGreat. Yeah, to pick up on what Kate asked next, could you share some specifics about the investment that manufacturing will require in order to carry out your refresh strategy?
Kris Lee
executiveOn the manufacturing front and with vertical integration, that's clearly been a competitive edge for us, and it's something we've consistently made a point of putting money into where it matters. Previously, we've put investment into the envelopes — specifically into using foil, which is a fairly pricey material, more efficiently. That's something we keep under constant review. We don't see any area where there's a significant shortfall in investment, nor anywhere we feel a major outlay is needed. We put money into a new printing machine within roughly the last year, and it ran at twice the speed. We have a fair amount of capacity there. Honestly, the other investments we'd consider on the manufacturing side are wherever we still believe there's room to improve cost of goods, especially, clearly, around card.
Speaker
unknownThanks. Vikram has sent in another question. This one is directed at Darcy. Could you talk a bit more about how the competitive landscape looks in the gift market when you compare it with a pure online player or with other card pure online only players?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveSure, I can offer a few points. First, when we originally carried out the customer segmentation exercise, it centered on cards. We've since updated that piece of work, and now we're examining customer segmentation through the lens of gifting. We have some data in hand, and there are items in research that we plan to test around gifting. That's one area, I'd say. The second point is that both we and most of our rivals handle seasonal occasions—Christmas, Mother's Day, Father's Day—very effectively. In my view, there's a chance for us to cover everyday gifting and to lead in that space. Beyond that, the gifting sector represents a GBP 40 billion market. That figure isn't our total addressable size, but it is a substantial market, so there are opportunities we can capture. We're aware that 72% of customers—or of people across the U.K.—include gifts when sending cards. That, once again, is why a strong opportunity exists for us.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We'll go next to Siddhant. With supply chain costs rising as they have, what effect has that had on your cost of goods sold? Roughly what portion of COGS before COVID came from freight costs, and what portion year-to-date?
Kris Lee
executiveFrom the half-year margin position, I believe it's clear we've handled margin pretty effectively, even with a few of those freight problems. On margin for the product overall, I'd say we're still fairly confident about holding it over the medium to longer term. For sure, in the second half of this year, we'll likely feel a bit of pressure there—as I mentioned, from freight costs. That has roughly trebled, I think, but we're examining what options we have to mitigate it. I won't provide a forecast for profit or margin on that. Yes, for the second half, that's probably the 1 area of concern, I'd say.
Speaker
unknownThanks. We have another one coming in from Harvey. He's asking how much stores have gained where Clintons or other rivals have shut down. Has footfall and like-for-like performance at those locations improved because they picked up more share in that small catchment area?
Kris Lee
executiveSo, regarding Clintons and other competitors, I think there's always been this assumption that when a Clintons shuts, we'll capture all of those sales. The customer who walks into Clintons is a bit different, and equally, I think we've chipped away at a large portion of that customer base over the years. We do see like-for-like sales improve. On locations, we're familiar with every Clintons, Paperchase, et cetera site, the spots in town and where we'd like to be. We feel fairly comfortable — even with Clintons, if every store were to shut, and obviously they've had a shrinking portfolio and been restructuring, as has Paperchase. Our locations are already quite good. There are relatively few places where we'd want to move to that a Clintons or Paperchase store would occupy. Yeah.
Speaker
unknownRichard Martin has the next question, and it's more of a statement on his part. He's making the point that longer shopping hours don't really cost much extra, and in the locations where I see your stores, hours could be stretched out, since those stores are sometimes among the earliest to shut. What do you make of that statement, Darcy?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveYes. I think — I'm not sure, Richard; you raised this earlier, so either you felt the response wasn't complete or this is a repeat. We do examine foot traffic on an hourly basis, and we have criteria we use to decide what the store operating hours should be, so that we effectively meet customer needs while also ensuring the stores are profitable. It's something we review often. I'm glad to take a specific look at it, and please feel free to reach out if there's a particular point you'd like to discuss.
Speaker
unknownThanks. That wraps up the Q&A portion of our webcast for today. Darcy, I'll turn things back over to you for any closing remarks.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThanks a lot. We truly appreciate everyone on the call taking the time to join and engage with us today, and we look forward to connecting with you again at our next update in the future. Thank you, everyone.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.