Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 3, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us for the Card Factory FY 2023 preliminary results presentation. If you're watching on Zoom and would like to put a question to us today, just hit the Q&A button on your screen. For those of you here in the room, the microphones at your seats are there for you to use. I'll now pass things over to Darcy Willson-Rymer, our CEO. Darcy, the floor is yours.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThank you. Good morning everyone, and welcome to the presentation of our results for the full year of FY 2023. We appreciate you being with us today, either in person at UBS's office or online. I want to begin by apologizing. I'm truly sorry that we needed to move today's presentation from last week with little notice, but I'm very grateful that so many of you could still attend, both here and online. As you know, I'm Darcy Willson-Rymer, CEO of Card Factory, and with me today for our interim presentation is Simon Comer, our interim CFO. After an overview of our highlights from the past year, Simon will give the financial summary update for FY 2023. I'll then update you on the progress we've made on our Opening Our New Future growth strategy and on the outlook for the rest of the year. I also hope you'll be able to join us after the presentation of our results for our capital market strategy update, where Simon and I will be joined by a number of our Card Factory senior leadership team to give a more detailed update on our strategic growth plans through to FY 2027, and that'll be at 11:30 today.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveTwo years have passed since I came on board at Card Factory, and the progress we are delivering makes me proud. We hold a clear and ambitious strategy to turn Card Factory into a market-leading omni-channel retailer of cards and gifts, and during FY 2023 we hit significant milestones along that path. What we have accomplished mirrors the dedication and hard work of Card Factory colleagues, who share a real passion for pushing our business forward. I want to pause and personally thank every single colleague at Card Factory and acknowledge the outstanding contribution they made over the past year, which has made possible the growth we are now enjoying. Thank you, colleagues. I am glad to report positive momentum right across our business, which, together with customers shifting their spending back toward the high street, is fueling revenue growth. Consequently, our FY 2023 performance came in ahead of expectations, with two profit upgrades announced during the year. Our one year like-for-like revenue growth of +6.7% rested on strong results in store-based sales and our everyday card ranges, powered by initiatives focused on range curation and better availability. Our expanding gifting offer proved a sales driver all through FY 2023, as did the successful rollout of targeted price increases, which had only a minimal effect on customer switching.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveDuring the key Christmas trading period, we saw higher store transactions and a larger average basket value, helped by new ranges and a strong value-for-money proposition that truly connected with customers. However, strikes over the festive period did affect our online sales. In-store like-for-like sales came in at +7.6%, and they are now marginally ahead of pre-pandemic levels, which demonstrates the worth of a nationwide store estate that will also serve as an enabler for our omni-channel ambitions. We have kept successfully offsetting the substantial inflationary cost pressures, and we have done so through a mix of proactive action, efficient cost and working capital management, better store efficiencies, targeted price rises, plus gains from our hedging policy covering both energy and foreign exchange. We have kept reinforcing the balance sheet, with net debt significantly lower than three years ago, all backed by the successful completion of our refinancing in FY2023. Our Opening Our New Future growth strategy is now being delivered at pace, with major milestones reached in FY2023. The right foundations are now in place for us to deliver this strategy. I'll go into this in more detail later. With that, I want to pass over to Simon, who will take you through the detail of our financial performance.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveSimon, go ahead.
Simon Comer
executiveThanks, Darcy, and good morning, everyone. It's a pleasure to walk you through our financial results for the year — the first full 12 months we've had outside of the pandemic. On revenue, margin, and net debt, Card Factory came in ahead of what management had expected for the year. Sales reached GBP 463.4 million, which is GBP 99 million better than last year, and Card Factory like-for-like sales came in at +6.7%. That translated into a PBT of GBP 52.4 million, GBP 41.3 million above the prior year — an increase of 42% and ahead of the guidance we gave in the January 2023 trading update of PBT of approximately GBP 48 million. We got there even with a tough backdrop of inflationary pressure coming from material and freight costs, as well as labor. Net debt before lease liabilities also improved by another GBP 17 million, down to GBP 57.2 million, with a new facility agreement delivered in April 2022. Our operating cash flow before tax payments of GBP 107.8 million reflects the cash conversion of 96%. That's lower than the prior year, when we benefited from the unwind of trade working capital post-pandemic. Turning to sales: total store sales are now slightly ahead of pre-pandemic levels, with like-for-like sales on a three-year basis at -0.3%.
Simon Comer
executiveFor stores, 1-year like-for-like sales came in at +7.6%, and that came with gains in both transactions and average basket values. We saw this particularly in the everyday ranges, for card and for gifting, and also in wedding, life moments, and children's categories. Targeted pricing activities drove two-thirds of that total. Month-on-month, LFL performance stayed positive right through the year, with April 2022 the sole exception, which reflected the sales bounce in April 2021 after the lockdown. Trading over the first few weeks of the new financial year has been encouraging and is slightly ahead of the board's expectations. All told, our store estate grew by a net 12 stores to 1,032, and we remain focused on under-penetrated markets in particular, opening three trial stores in Central London and continuing to expand in the Republic of Ireland. We keep our store portfolio under constant review and hold a position where under 1% is loss-making. Turning to non-store sales: Partnerships posted positive sales growth of 10%. That came in a year when we began laying the foundations for the international expansion we expect over the years ahead. You'll hear more detail on this in the capital market strategy update later today.
Simon Comer
executiveRevenue from The Reject Shop in Australia rose 26%, helped by stores reopening fully after lockdowns, while Aldi fell 18% as a result of reduced space and shoppers going back to card purchasing on the high street once lockdowns ended. The Royal Mail strikes across Christmas, together with customers returning to the high street, hit both online businesses. Despite that Christmas disruption, sales at cardfactory.co.uk stood 86.4% higher than pre-pandemic levels. Extending the product range in phases to cover flowers, gift experiences, and alcohol drove an 11% increase in online gifting sales during the second half of FY 2023. That positions the online business well for growth ahead. Getting Personal finished its re-platforming in March 2023, opening up the chance for range development and additional functionality. Now let's turn to margins and cost. Group PBT came in at GBP 52.4 million, a margin of 11.3%, which is 8.1 percentage points better than a year earlier. We got there by combining targeted price increases launched in the first half of FY 2023, cost control that managed inflationary pressure through effective currency and utility hedging, labor productivity, and active supply chain management. At constant currency, cost of goods sold was 2.4 percentage points better, with currency rates achieved matching the prior year.
Simon Comer
executiveWe're also well hedged going into FY 2024, with 90% cover above $1.275. On an underlying basis, store wages stayed flat as a percentage versus the prior year once you factor in the one-off CJRS provision release, as National Living Wage increases of 2 percentage points were offset by price and productivity. The 1.4 percentage points rise in property costs stems from rate support ending in Q1 of FY 2023. Other direct expenses have gained from the energy hedging agreements we have in place, which delivered savings of between GBP 4 million-GBP 5 million for the company this year. On energy, we are fully hedged out to September 2024 at rates similar to the current year. Operating expenses have improved by 0.2 percentage points. That figure includes investment in people and infrastructure supporting our Opening Our New Future strategy, which is meant to give us a platform for future growth. Depreciation and amortization charges, impairments included, came down by GBP 5.9 million versus the prior year. That mirrors a reduction in impairments of GBP 2.2 million, which reflects better trading performance plus our future expectations about store performance and cost inflation. The remaining GBP 3.7 million largely reflects lower depreciation charges on right of use assets.
Simon Comer
executiveSince the pandemic, store rents—and the right of use assets tied to them—have kept declining. Our flexible, dynamic strategy for the store portfolio has let us keep capturing those reductions through lease renewals or relocations. FY 2023 also includes a GBP 1 million credit tied to refinancing debt facilities in April 2022. Looking forward, we remain confident in our capacity to offset future cost inflation by combining productivity initiatives with targeted price actions. Now let's turn to net debt. Net debt has improved substantially, with a reduction of GBP 86 million over three years. This year brought GBP 17 million of net debt reduction, including GBP 10.8 million of agreed rent deferrals from the pandemic period. Cash generated of GBP 59.5 million from EBITDA less rent payments was used for increased CapEx financing of GBP 18.2 million, GBP 12.5 million of debt servicing, a return to paying corporation tax of GBP 7.9 million, and working capital increases of GBP 3.9 million supporting the growth delivered this year. Note that CapEx came in GBP 12 million above the equivalent investment in the prior year.
Simon Comer
executiveCapEx during the year backed phase two of our ERP rollout, along with spending on our inventory management system, store expansion, and building out our online platforms. The group leverage calculation, on a pre-lease liability basis, kept improving too and finished the year at 0.5 times. Turning to cash flow. Operating cash flow before working capital of GBP 104.1 million rose significantly versus the prior year, reflecting better trading performance and including a return to paying corporation tax at GBP 7.9 million. The working capital movement for FY 2022 takes in the effect of supply chain disruptions, which brought lower inventory holdings, plus COVID-related government support. Inventory came back in FY 2023 to a more normalized level, GBP 11 million above the prior year. Even so, stock management has cut overall net inventories by GBP 9 million since FY 2020. Lease liabilities include deferred payments of GBP 10.8 million tied to store rents from FY 2021, and we don't expect that to repeat going forward. Net interest paid is up by GBP 0.9 million, with our interest hedging policy delivering savings of circa GBP 0.6 million against the current rise in SONIA. Bearing in mind the higher CapEx tied to the investment cycle for future growth, free cash flow for FY 2023 came in at GBP 18.5 million.
Simon Comer
executiveNow, let’s turn to liquidity. In April 2022, the company secured new facilities combining an RCF, term loans, and CLBILS. That agreement reaches full maturity by September 2025, while term loan A and the CLBILS will have been repaid entirely by January 2024. At year-end, headroom stood at GBP 75 million. Once term loan A and the CLBILS are repaid, the company can look at paying a dividend after that point. In summary, these are strong financials, with trade back at pre-pandemic levels and positive one-year like-for-likes. Margins have improved, and inflationary pressures are being handled via targeted pricing, active hedging policies, and productivity savings throughout the group. During the year, the company's banking facilities were refinanced, supported by a substantial improvement in net debt. All of this has laid a foundation for strategic growth and a pathway toward restarting dividends. Thank you for your time, and I'll now hand back to Darcy.
Speaker
unknownThanks.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThanks so much, Simon. Like I said when I kicked things off, we'll give you a fuller update on our strategic plans at the Capital Markets Day. What I'll do at this point is give you a summary of the progress we've made in FY2023. I'll spend just a few minutes on that. FY2023 marked the launch year of our business transformation, and we've hit significant milestones across every one of our areas of focus. By delivering on our strategy, Card Factory is well-positioned to become the U.K.'s number one destination for all customers seeking unrivaled quality, value, choice, convenience, and experience. We're working to transform Card Factory into the leading omni-channel brand in our space to help customers celebrate life's moments. We're achieving this by being customer-centric in our thinking and approach and placing customer data at the heart of our decision-making. This customer-centric focus also forms the basis for our refreshed brand strategy that we completed in FY 2023. By placing customers at the heart of our business, we're building our brand and developing our strategic plans from a core customer truth that life needs celebration. Something I'm sure we can all agree on and which has never been more relevant given the backdrop of all of the recent events that have happened in recent years.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveTurning to our core cards business, we've kept strengthening the strong position we hold by developing and curating a focused range, along with selective price rises, and that has produced revenue growth in FY 2023. A permanent three-for-two mechanic on general card has generated sales growth on the chosen lines covered by this offer. We've also worked on broadening the diversity of our card ranges so that every one of our customers feels included for all of life's moments of celebration. Now I'd like to move to the growth opportunity in gifts and celebration essentials. We used to refer to this under the single complementary categories heading, but we have now separated it out, partly to align with industry-recognized market analysis, and it's also simpler and gives us clear measurement internally. By targeting the gifts and celebration essentials market, we've additionally been able to recalculate the total addressable U.K. market. That opportunity stands at GBP 13.4 billion. In FY 2023, we saw total everyday like-for-like growth through our stores of 11.4%, with confectionery being the largest sales growth area at +111%. Tableware saw the largest volume increase at 124%. We've also built on the success of our extensive in-house design ranges by introducing relevant third-party brands and some licensed ranges.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOur soft toy selection has gotten wider, and we've brought in boxed items plus products aimed at pocket money budgets. Last of all, we launched five fresh categories — flowers, gift experience, alcohol, chocolate, and books — which drove an 11% uplift in online gifting sales during the second half of FY 2023. So to sum up, we're achieving meaningful progress when it comes to capturing the growth opportunity within gifts and celebration essentials. Our omni-channel ambitions started being delivered in earnest during FY 2023. We ran a successful trial of the first of those omni-channel propositions by launching Click and Collect. That trial kicked off across 87 stores. From it, we observed an average order value 16% above the online average, along with an indication of a 7% in-store basket uplift from shoppers purchasing an additional item in store. Because of that, we've just finished the UK nationwide rollout — we sped that up — and more developments to the service are planned for FY 2024. As we aim to build on the milestones reached in FY 2023 to fulfil our omni-channel ambitions, we've stayed focused. We've kept making headway on delivering phase 2 of our ERP program. Completion is due in the first half of FY 2024, and it will give us the ability to see stock across all areas of the business and allow integration with future partners, both within the UK and internationally.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOn the digital-only side, our emphasis was on enhancing how customers interact with us, and that involved introducing multi-ship capability, which lets shoppers send cards and gifts to several addresses within one order. In addition, we rolled out a significant app upgrade featuring extra functions, and we kept up our ongoing enhancement efforts to boost the online user experience. We likewise finished moving cardfactory.co.uk and Getting Personal onto a new platform. Both now sit on a shared new platform, which is essential for allowing online ranges to expand in phases along with added functionality. As I noted before, the power of our store estate throughout the U.K. and Ireland fuels growth and is critical to unlocking our omni-channel ambition. A trial of our new model store format began in 10 stores during FY2023, and another five stores opened in January, testing a further capital-light variant of that approach. Those stores were chosen so the format could be tried across a broad mix of locations, demographics, and store sizes. Now that the model store trial has wrapped up, we are deploying what we learned via our store evolution program, which consists of three parts. The first is space realignment, which we'll use across most of our stores, shifting space around so gifts get somewhat more priority than previously.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAfter figuring out which stores stand to gain, we'll roll that change out to 750 stores during this year. It's an initiative that's capital-light, and the payback happens inside the year. Second, reorganizing displays. Under this, we'll change the way cards and gifts are presented in our stores, with cards positioned around the perimeter and gifts going into the central aisles. Such a layout improves how customers navigate and makes finding products simpler for them, and it also guarantees we achieve the right product adjacencies. We intend to finish this adjustment in roughly 50 stores this year while we keep fine-tuning the costs and the returns tied to it. Last, the third element: an updated store design, which we'll deploy in new stores and in a select number of full refurbishments. Its costs align with our existing refit costs, and there is no impact on our store CapEx forecasts, so to speak. Beyond that, throughout FY2023 we kept growing our store footprint into markets that are under-penetrated. That took in opening our three trial stores in Central London along with 13 new stores in the Republic of Ireland. Assessment of the trial Central London stores continues to be ongoing.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveIn part, the train strikes caused disruption for us, though in part we're also continuing to adjust the range mix so that the offer we have is right for meeting what customers in Central London need. Once the trial has concluded, we'll settle the roadmap for Central London. Partnerships form the final building block of our future growth, and that's where we see the chance to expand both within the U.K. and internationally, and good progress is being made. I'm pleased to report that our first master franchise partnership for the Middle East has now been signed. Our exclusive franchise partner, Liwa Trading Enterprises, is a specialist retail franchisee with experience across premium and value brands throughout the region. Over the next five years, Liwa are aiming to open 36 Card Factory branded stores in the Middle East. Last week we announced the acquisition of SA Greetings, which means we now have our first presence in this market, as both a retailer and a wholesaler. By giving us access to key wholesale accounts through the company's printing, merchandising, and warehouse capacity, the acquisition of SA Greetings supports our partnership strategy. We can also learn how similar local capability might be delivered in our target international markets.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAlso, we’ve made other notable headway on partnerships during the past year, including finishing a sizable research project. That work let us pinpoint the chance in both card and gifting, and it confirmed the seven international markets we’re interested in. We’ve now scoped the foundations for our partnership model, and they’re being developed to support franchise and wholesale partnership models alike — something we’ll cover in more detail soon at the Capital Market Strategy update. Lastly, our Opening Our New Future strategy is delivered on the back of our pledge to run the business sustainably in every area. In light of the extraordinary circumstances of the past 12 months, we’ve started work to refresh our five-year ESG strategy and roadmap. This began with a refreshed materiality assessment and an assessment of our Scope three greenhouse gas emissions, which will make sure our priorities mirror the world as it changes around us and stay in line with those of our stakeholders. As I said at the beginning of today’s presentation, our commitment to the thousands of passionate colleagues who are driving the Card Factory business forward is paramount. We remain focused on building a diverse, inclusive, and socially responsible culture at Card Factory, backed by our progressive DE&I strategy.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWe are very pleased to see that commitment, and the significance given to building our workplace culture shows up in the two-star outstanding accreditation we received from Best Companies. In their Q1 league tables, we also came in at number one among big retail businesses in the UK, and third among big companies to work for in the UK. Turning to what lies ahead, I'd like to begin by recapping the highlights of how we performed during the last year. Thinking about that, our value for money offer is connecting with customers across a growing range of products and price points, which is propelling our business performance. We have shown that we can proactively handle significant inflationary headwinds, and as part of that we carried out our pricing strategy with minimal impact on customer switching. Our strategic priorities for enabling future growth are clear, and we have put investment into the systems and IT infrastructure needed to build a strong foundation for delivery. Our strategy is now being delivered, and in FY 2023 we have made positive progress with some significant milestones reached, which is now beginning to come through in our financial performance. Lastly, a strengthened balance sheet is now in place, producing a highly profitable business with strong cash generation and a significant reduction in net debt.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveLooking forward to FY 2024, we anticipate that our results will show ongoing advancement against the strategic growth initiatives we have set out. The opening weeks of the new financial year have traded encouragingly and come in slightly better than we had expected. During that period, our everyday ranges and our seasonal ranges both delivered strong performances, supported by new lines, the growing strength of our gifting proposition, and a compelling value-for-money offer. Our Valentine's Day and Mother's Day offers for FY 2024 were also well received by customers, producing a robust showing across the spring seasons. That, taken together with a clear growth strategy and the strength of our value-led proposition, gives us confidence that we will keep delivering strategic and financial progress over the coming year. After a strong start in FY 2023, the board continues to feel confident about the compelling growth opportunity before the business and about our capacity to draw on our expertise and on the flexibility built into our business model in order to drive profitability and shareholder returns over the long term. As part of the update on our capital market strategy, members of the Card Factory executive team and I will set out a pathway to revenues of around GBP 650 million, alongside PBT margins of around 14% in FY 2027.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAppreciate you all joining us again for the results presentation. Simon and I are glad to take whatever questions you've got at this point. Sound right, Simon?
Simon Comer
executiveCorrect, that's right.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAll right, good. Any questions? Let me just ask that you—so that the feed can pick it up and people can hear it online—if I could have you use the microphone, that would be great. And if you could just let us know, for the benefit of everyone, who you are and what you do. Go ahead, Kate.
Kate Calvert
analystI’d like to keep this one in. Yes, Kate Calvert from Investec. Three questions from me, please — you may end up addressing some of them later. First, where exactly has the price investment gone? Could you discuss how much room you have to raise prices further if needed — in other words, how much headroom do you believe exists? My second question concerns partnerships. How much did you invest in partnerships during the current year, or in FY 2023, that has perhaps held things back, and is part of that one-off in nature when it comes to building the infrastructure? The last question is about online. Which milestones should we focus on when considering how it gets back to profitability?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveLet me start us off. On your first question about prices—where have we invested in price, and what does that mean for our ability to price going forward? Yeah. Effectively, we've concentrated on price by examining the pricing architecture we operate and the value for money at each stage of that architecture, effectively. Card Factory has sold cards at GBP 0.29 as our opening price point for 25 years. We keep protecting that, because we believe it matters a great deal. From GBP 0.29, we then step up, and we've now stretched the exit price point out to GBP 3.99 on a very small selection of cards that are select but very high quality. Within each component, it's about making sure the value for money holds. When you pick up the card, if it's GBP 0.99, it should feel like a GBP 0.99. Well, for most customers, that GBP 0.99 card at Card Factory would be GBP 1.99 somewhere else. If people pick it up and say, "Wow, that's really good value at that price." It's essentially about making sure we have the right architecture and the right value at each price point, moving the exit price. On our ability to do pricing going forward, I think I maintain the commitments I made a couple of years ago regarding the elimination of productivity and efficiency as a—I stand by that.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWhen it comes to that.
Simon Comer
executiveWhat about partnerships?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveYeah, partnerships.
Simon Comer
executiveWhen it comes to the bulk of that spending, it's really gone toward constructing the in-house infrastructure that the partnerships ahead of us require. Last week we announced SA Greetings, our first acquisition — clearly a capital acquisition. I don't believe that's the model we intend to follow for every partnership down the road, but it served as a route into the South African market. As for new partners joining up, I'd say this is considered a capital-light model. The acquisition path is more opportunistic than planned, if that makes sense. The last question, I believe, concerned the online side — specifically what has to happen to bring it back to profitability, if I can comment on that. A lot of it, I mean, we clearly took a volume hit over the Christmas period, and obviously those volumes need to come back up to something closer to normality, I should say. We're investing heavily in our online business. When we get to the capital markets day a bit later, we'll discuss investment of about GBP 3 million per annum across the next three years.
Simon Comer
executiveWe're going to need to put money in, and for the next couple of years we'd probably expect losses before it gets back to profitability around year 3 and year 4.
Analyst
analystThank you. Tomlinson. Here we are. Appreciate it. My first question concerns the size of the market. You mentioned a market size of GBP 13 billion, I believe, and if I recall correctly, in the past you referred to GBP 5 billion. Could you give us a bit more detail on the additional categories that may be entering the picture and driving that growth in the addressable market? Second, on gifting, looking further out, given the higher price points in gifting, do you still anticipate that split of roughly 50/50 in terms of... Just one more on inventory levels, if that's alright. Regarding the level you plan to maintain there, have you perhaps mentioned the new ERP system that's coming — have you observed any benefits beginning to come through yet? That's all from me. Thanks.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThanks. On the gifting market specifically, that research is far more granular and built on another basis, and we've broadened it out — the CMD section will get into much greater depth about how we do that. Over to you.
Simon Comer
executiveYeah. If I just leave the split as it is. Right now we're still about 50/50 between cards and gifting, and that's been the case for a couple of years. Over the next four years, the expectation is that we'll drift a little bit more towards gifting. I think the numbers in the CMD a little bit later on will talk about a 3% shift towards gifting. A 47%, 53% split, if that makes sense. Apologies, your final question? It's the inventory levels. Oh, on the inventory levels. Inventory. This year, as I said, although we are significantly improved over FY2020, we're GBP 9 million improved over the same position on the pre-pandemic level. We've seen a more normalized return. Our expectation is there's still areas to target, and we still think we can get inventory reductions. I think they will come from a couple of areas. Clearly I think our buying patterns were shifted a little bit because of the pandemic. In other words, we were buying in early, and obviously there's an element of unwind within that. Secondly, obviously, we've introduced the full stock loop and obviously the new ERP system, which gives us real-time information as to the stock level within stores.
Simon Comer
executiveThat should boost productivity and, ideally, bring efficiencies in our inventory, and as a result, make our inventory terms better.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveThe one thing I’d add, Adam, is back to what we discussed earlier today regarding sales growth and partly around better availability from some of the systems work we’ve already implemented. Take, for instance, what we’ve done with store ordering. These days it’s auto-replenished rather than handled by store managers. So we now have stock distributed much more effectively in the right location. That supports sales, and it supports inventory too. Yes, we keep seeing solid benefits from some of those investments. There are a couple of questions online that I’ll go to. Martin Jenkins asks, “Are the three New London stores performing according to plan?” I’ll take that one. I’d say that, in the three stores, we haven’t yet figured out the formula that delivers the strong returns we enjoy across the rest of the estate — it would be a much longer payback. We don’t believe we’ve got everything 100% right. Train strikes have had some impact, but also we haven’t quite got the range as good as it needs to be for London customers. A lot of work is happening behind the scenes, so we’ve done a fair amount of research and we’re making some changes.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveOur outlook on London is still positive. A large number of individuals both residing and employed in London lack access to cards offering good value, and our trials keep moving forward. Let me expand on that point somewhat. Within the company, our method for learning through testing has been to run tests and run them fast. Take Click and Collect as an instance: we ran the test, it turned out to work extremely well, and we sped it up. London is taking somewhat longer — slow down a bit, ensure we get it right, rather than simply clinging to your hypothesis and charging ahead. This test-and-learn method — fail fast — but we're optimistic on London. There's another question online from Joe Devoy. I hope I said your name correctly, Joe. This one's for you, Simon. Your energy costs are hedged through the end of 2024. Do you have any sense of what the impact on energy costs will be beyond that point? Is there any ability to begin exploring re-hedging starting now?
Simon Comer
executiveYeah. We're already beginning to pass along our hedging as we head into FY2025 once the contract actually ends. We're clearly not seeing the same rates we saw a few years back. Right now, we expect this to be roughly about three times the levels we originally anticipated, of about GBP 150. From an overall cost perspective, although this is obviously only an estimate at this stage, it's estimated at between GBP 4 million-GBP 5 million of additional cost coming into the business. When we look at the CMD a little later on, that is mapped into the overall numbers.
Melvin Mehta
analystAlright.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveIf you could just grab the microphone and give it a press.
Melvin Mehta
analystBad habits are extremely tough to get rid of.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWould you mind hitting that button?
Melvin Mehta
analystImproved now? Yes, improved. This is Melvin Mehta calling from Sterling Investments. I have a couple of quick questions. Regarding the percentage of customers at present—
Operator
operatorCould you please press and hold that button?
Melvin Mehta
analystIs it better at this point?
Simon Comer
executiveYeah. Thanks.
Operator
operatorI really appreciate it.
Melvin Mehta
analystApologies — truly apologies. That’s embarrassing. Two quick questions. The first is from Melvin Mehta at Sterling Investments: what share of your customers right now purchase a gift at the same time as they purchase a card?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveRoughly speaking, my sense is that it's around 17%. Let me quickly confirm that with the team. Does that sound about right? Yes. Approximately 17% of customers.
Melvin Mehta
analystSo,
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWe understand this market well, and across it, the share is roughly 70%, which fits into our gifting opportunity.
Melvin Mehta
analystThanks. One more on the franchisee side. Is there some minimum commitment in place under which they've agreed to invest a certain amount of capital for those 30-odd outlets?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveYes, so the store-count commitments are baked into our agreements. And what those agreements say is that our franchise partner builds the stores to the standards we've laid out, and they've got all the blueprints and everything. It's more or less been signed off. Every bit of the capital investment comes from the partner.
Melvin Mehta
analystI asked whether the partner has to put in a minimum amount, whether that's in pounds or in dollars.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWe're committed to opening that quantity of locations across that timeframe, along with the CapEx tied to doing so. It doesn't say that hitting that store count requires spending exactly that sum. There is, though, a standard we're held to regarding what we have to build.
Melvin Mehta
analystMuch appreciated.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveGiven my 20 years of experience in franchising, that's fairly typical, so.
Tony Shiret
analystThanks, Darcy. This is Tony Shiret from Panmure, with a few small questions. Could you tell us your average transaction value? I’m not sure whether that appears in the pack anywhere, and how it has changed compared with last year. What’s your view on competition in the market and the dynamics at the moment? Finally, a really small point: I don’t happen to know how you clear stock, so what percentage of sales are not at full price? Thanks.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWould you like to go ahead and take the first question?
Simon Comer
executiveOn average unit pricing, we mentioned a bit earlier that stores saw roughly a 7.6% rise in LFL. About two-thirds of that comes from price. Across the year, our average unit price has risen by an amount that's really quite similar. I don't have the precise figure in front of me, but a big portion of it has consequently fed into the AUB too, so we're genuinely putting fair value into that number. I'm afraid I don't have the exact figures available, though.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveWhen it comes to competition, I'd say we look at the card market as being effectively split roughly into thirds. We hold about a third of the market. The supermarkets together account for roughly a third. Basically, everyone else makes up that final third. On gifting, really anyone who can sell a birthday gift or whatever the celebration happens to be is in the mix. It's much broader, you know. It largely depends on whether you mean direct competition, you know, direct competition. Yeah. But for us, the focus is on really understanding who Card Factory customers are, you know, why they come to us, what the need state is, what they want to buy, which occasions we need to fulfill, and then making sure that we, you know, have the products around it, you know. What was your last question?
Tony Shiret
analystApologies. I suppose what I’m trying to get at is whether, over the last few years, you’ve observed any kinds of events where somebody did something in the market that affected your sales or forced you to take some action on pricing, or whether that simply hasn’t occurred?
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveNo, no. Look, I think, I mean, since I've been here, of course, the two biggest things that happened were that we shut the retail stores and all of that business moved online and to supermarkets. What we've seen with the reopening is that business has largely come back. We've seen those two positions, you know, basically, you know, kind of unwind. We think that, you know, in the specialty market, there have been changes, so Paperchase leaving the market, for example. Given that was largely, you know, much more premium and a different customer. We haven't seen any significant impact outside of an individual, a local store when they were doing a fire sale on product. You know, we could see in the data, you know, a tiny blip for a week. you know, that kind of thing. I think largely I would say the innovations that we are doing are not because of a competitive threat, but it's because of us better running our business and better understanding the market and the customers, you know, basically that we're serving. Couple of good. Just couple of questions online. Wayne Brown, what is the right level of debt for the business, and what could the dividend policy look like?
Simon Comer
executiveWhat’s the appropriate amount of debt? I guess that depends on whom you ask. Clearly, right now, we’ve clearly been in a process of clearly bringing down our total debt position. I believe we’ve been clear about where we think our dividend policy ought to sit, which is leverage of 0.5 to 1.5 times and PBT of two, three times. By the way, I should note that this is taken by looking ahead at the net debt position across the whole business, because obviously we really are a seasonal business, and so we tend to have peaks around roughly, sort of, July, August kind of time. As for the overall levels, I mean, clearly we believe that that is the right level of dividend policy. And I think right now, that’s, I think,
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveAs for the conditions that have to be there — specifically CLBILS and term loan A — well, that comes due for repayment in January, and the board will, of course, weigh what the proper next step should be during this year.
Simon Comer
executiveYes.
Darcy Willson-Rymer
executiveNow, on franchising. My assumption is that you sell wholesale to the franchisee, but do you also get a royalty on revenue, and are there any marketing commitments in the territory? Again, we'll go into that in, you know, somewhat greater depth basically at the CMD. Essentially, the... Initially, we haven't gone with a royalty model. What we're doing is basically a cost plus model. There are no market commitment spends in market on us. Our commitment is to keep developing our brand, you know, basically in the way we're doing. I think unless there are any other questions, we'll finish there. Very good. Tea. Everybody, thank you very much for attending this section. I'm hoping you'll be able to hang around and join us for the capital market strategy update. I think that begins at 11:30, and we have tea, coffee, biscuits. We've got some of the displays, some of products outside and of course, the Card Factory management team is around as well. Hope to see you again at 11:30. Thank you all.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.