Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 30, 2024

London Stock Exchange GB Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 63 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for attending the presentation of our full-year results for FY 2024. Thank you for being with us today, either in the room at UBS or joining via the webcast. I'm Darcy Willson-Rymer, Card Factory's CEO, and with me is Matthias Seeger, our CFO. After a look at the highlights of the past year, Matthias will take you through the financial performance update for FY 2024. I'll then update you on how far we've come with our Opening Our New Future growth strategy and on the outlook for the rest of the year. Matthias and I will be glad to take any questions you have at the end. When I came into the business three years ago, we set out on a transformation journey that would fundamentally change how Card Factory operates. The positive impact of the changes we've made right across the business is clear, and our FY 2024 results bear witness to the successful delivery of our change program and to the hard work of colleagues throughout Card Factory. By putting the customer first when we make decisions, we've kept innovating and broadening our offer while staying true to our value for money credentials. As we carry on investing in our Opening Our New Future strategy, we're delivering key initiatives at pace and making sure we maximize the growth opportunities in store, across our digital channels, and through our expanding partnership program.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#2

Our strategy execution is moving along well, and that keeps us on course to hit the growth goals in the five-year plan. Since I'm aware that many colleagues are joining the call today, I'd like to use this moment to say a personal thank you to all of you for the constructive efforts you contributed during the most recent financial year. So, colleagues, thank you. I'm glad to share as well that momentum has stayed favorable throughout the company, producing double-digit revenue growth in FY 2024. Our stores are still central to how we grow, thanks to a robust showing in the latest financial year, which highlights the strategic importance of our store estate and the edge our stores give us regarding our omni-channel ambition. Meanwhile, the strategy is generating encouraging results, with advancement and execution across every building block of growth: partnerships, online, and across both cards, where we keep our leadership position, and gifts and celebration essentials, where market share continues to expand. One standout moment in FY 2024 was buying SA Greetings in South Africa, which gave us a leading presence in a key international market and opened up wholesale growth opportunities for us as well.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#3

Central to our business transformation is the cultural progress achieved across the company, and the growth we are seeing can be tied to how much better we understand what our customers need and our capacity to execute quickly, while helping colleagues connect to our purpose. We have also launched a new sustainability strategy, which will deliver a positive impact in the communities where we operate. Our disciplined financial management and performance are also contributing to the improved financial strength of the business, with the balance sheet strengthened further and net debt reduced. And lastly, after repaying CLBILS and Term Loan A, we are no longer restricted from paying dividends, so the Board has approved an updated capital allocation policy that includes a resumption of dividend, reflecting our positive commitment to balancing investment in driving growth of the business with delivering progressive cash returns to shareholders, which together are designed to drive significant shareholder value. Right, for more detail on this and on our financial performance of FY 2024, let me hand over to Matthias to take you through that. So, Matthias?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#4

Thanks, Darcy, and good morning, everyone — great to have you with us on such a bright, sunny day, whether you're here in the room or joining online. Across the next 20 minutes, I'll walk you through the results and share some perspective on Card Factory's capital allocation policy and the dividend for this period. This was a year in which positive momentum continued. Progress was balanced right across all key financial metrics, driven by growth at both the top and bottom line. The results sit at the top range of market expectations. We have delivered double-digit revenue growth. Profit before tax rose significantly, driven by revenue growth and strong margin rate enhancement while investing into future growth. Cash generation was strong, which allowed us to strengthen our balance sheet by reducing net debt and to restart dividend payments — but more about that a little bit later. First, let me talk about the progress against the key financial metrics. As you all know, the economic backdrop was challenging for businesses and consumers. Nevertheless, we achieved significant improvements across all key financial metrics compared to the same period last year on the back of a strong, resilient business performance, particularly in stores. Total group revenue increased by 10.3% to GBP 510.9 million. This includes GBP 10 million of sales from the acquisition of SA Greetings.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#5

Adjusted PBT came in at GBP 62.1 million, up 27%, with the PBT margin widening from 10.5% last year to 12.2% this year. Cash conversion stood at 96.8%. Cash generated by the business rose 10.1%, in line with trading. That let us put money into infrastructure and growth projects, and also bring net debt down by GBP 23 million to GBP 34.4 million. And we will restart dividend payments. Again, a little bit later, more about that later. We have a track record of delivering year-on-year growth. Even if you allow for the pandemic, over the past five years, we have grown sales on average by 3.9%. For each of the past two years, we have grown sales on average by 18.4%. Last year, at our Capital Markets Day, we set out our strategic building blocks of growth. Today, I am pleased to say we are delivering against these plans, are on track to deliver our FY 2027 CMD target. This will deliver additional values for our shareholders going forward. Let me now turn to our sales performance for the fiscal year. Total group revenue increased by 10.3% from GBP 463.4 million to GBP 510.9 million. Our core business, the stores in the U.K.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#6

Turning to the Republic of Ireland, those stores represent 94% of sales and posted total store-based growth of 8.7%, alongside strong like-for-like growth of 7.7%. Driving that like-for-like performance were the strength of our range, an unrelenting emphasis on value for money, and the experience we offer in-store. As a result, sales in our strategic growth categories across gift and celebration essentials improved by 9.8%. We also delivered robust greeting card sales growth of 4.8%. Targeted price increases account for one-third of the like-for-like growth. As we keep expanding our footprint and market penetration, our store network grew by 26 stores to 1,058. During the period, net new store openings added 1 percentage point to our growth. Online sales declined overall. That said, performance at cardfactory.co.uk has been encouraging, with a positive like-for-like for the year of +0.4%, following a half two like-for-like growth of 11.4%, as our investments in the platform to improve the customer experience and to develop the online range are beginning to drive results. Partnership sales, excluding SA Greetings, rose by GBP 1.6 million, which includes the effect of the Matalan contract and the first 4 Liwa franchise stores in the Middle East.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#7

The SA Greetings acquisition brought in GBP 10.4 million of revenue, and that added 2.2 percentage points to the growth. Turning to margin. Our revenue grew at a double-digit rate. And at the same time, we lifted margin rates even as we dealt with wage inflation and kept investing in future growth. The adjusted PBT margin rate came in at 12.2%, which is 1.7 percentage points better than last year. That figure leaves out the GBP 2.6 million acquisition gain tied to SA Greetings, GBP 2 million released from COVID provisions, and a GBP 1.1 million impairment charge related to Getting Personal. On a constant currency basis, product margin rose 1.2 percentage points. Pricing effects plus normalized freight costs did more than offset the hit to margin rate and mix, which came from the strong growth in gifting and celebration essentials categories. Direct store-based costs fell 0.7 points as a share of revenue. The gains we've delivered in labor productivity and operational efficiencies, along with the ongoing benefit from our energy hedge, more than outweighed the effect of national living wage increases. Stronger sales per store lifted productivity and efficiencies below the line, which added 2.2 percentage points to the margin rate improvement. That improvement came from right to use rent, lease depreciation, and finance costs.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#8

We've likewise observed that average rents for our stores come down when leases are renewed. The rise in interest rates was counterbalanced by a decrease in the gross amount of debt. Over this period, our effective currency rate came in below the level seen in the same period a year earlier. Even so, the established approach we take to currency hedging shielded us from the complete scale of market swings during the period. When we presented our strategy update last May, we laid out what we intend to do in order to invest for future growth. During the period, we put back into operating costs the equivalent of 2.2 margin points. We're glad to make these investments in our colleagues and our infrastructure, ensuring we could deliver against our future growth plans. To sum up, the improvement in our margin came from a mix of higher sales, costs that had normalized, better productivity, and cost efficiency throughout our distinctive end-to-end value chain… Now I'd like to summarize the consolidated P&L. Sales growth in the double digits contributed GBP 47.5 million in revenue. Our product margin of 69.6% rose by 1 percentage points, which mirrors the annualization of price increases along with freight costs that had normalized. Currency and sales mix effects partly offset this, since we sold a larger percentage of non-card products. Gross margins went up by 1.5 percentage points, reaching 36.2%, thanks to efficiencies that counterbalanced living wage increases.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#9

Adjusted PBT rose GBP 13.2 million year-on-year to GBP 62.1 million. That represents a 27% gain, driven by a strong top line and margin rate growth, even with headwinds and reinvestments. Adjusted EPS came in at GBP 0.135, up 11.6%. Cash performance during the period was strong. Cash from operations climbed to GBP 118.7 million, which reflects operating cash conversion of 96.8% for the full year. Working capital trends have now normalized post-pandemic. Corporation tax payments, made quarterly in advance, of course, rose along with improved profitability. Capital expenditure totaled GBP 27.8 million, GBP 9.6 million above the prior year. Key investments included phase two of our ERP implementation, the upgrade of our network infrastructure, new store openings, upgrading stores, and investing in improving the online experience. Lease payments fell by GBP 13 million, as the last of the rent deferrals associated with the pandemic was cleared in the prior year. In addition, we continued to see reduced rents on renewal due to our dynamic and flexible approach to store portfolio. Total finance costs reduced as increases in interest rates were offset by reductions in debt. As a result, free cash of GBP 27 million was GBP 10 million higher than last year.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#10

That helped pay for the purchase of SA Greetings, along with the ongoing drop in net debt and the restart of regular dividends, which I'll get into more detail on in a moment. Turning to net debt. Across the 12-month period, net debt as of the end of January fell by GBP 23 million, landing at GBP 34.4 million, reflecting our continued work to strengthen the balance sheet. Robust operating cash flow, together with lower lease rentals, has allowed us to put money into our growth strategy and bring net debt down, all while absorbing higher corporation tax payments. Costs tied to servicing debt are still broadly in line with earlier periods. The rise in interest rates was mostly offset by a mix of our hedging program and a lower level of gross debt. At the close of the period, the group held GBP 75 million of headroom across its debt facilities. In FY 2024, we made repayments on our term debts and CLBILS facilities amounting to GBP 25.1 million. Those facilities have now been fully repaid, and as a result, the restrictions on dividend payments are gone. With the business having overcome the pandemic's challenges, posted strong financial results, and being on track to deliver its growth ambition, now is the right moment to put normalized facilities in place to support our strategic plans.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#11

We're glad to be working with a solid group of four banks whose capabilities and operational reach can back our business both now and going forward. This new financing arrangement centers on a GBP 125 million revolving credit facility, alongside an accordion option worth GBP 75 million. It takes the place of the earlier revolving facility and Term Loan B, both of which have now been repaid in full. The facility carries an initial four-year term running until April 2028, and there's an option to extend it to November 2029. As our business expands, this facility serves as a long-term platform, making sure we can access funding at competitive margins. With the business having returned to growth and strong cash generation, with the right financing foundation now in place, and with the restrictions on returning cash to shareholders having been lifted, the Board has reviewed and updated our capital allocation policy. We're committed to creating value for our shareholders by delivering on our business growth strategy and plans, as set out at the Capital Markets Day last May. Our aim is to deliver our plans and financial targets in a disciplined and sustainable manner. We will deliver long-term shareholder value while offering progressive returns to our shareholders in the short term.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#12

Our capital allocation policy rests on four guiding principles. First, we'll keep a strong balance sheet within a well-defined debt leverage range. Two, we'll invest in an appropriate, disciplined, and financially sound way to deliver our growth strategy. Three, we'll provide regular, progressive returns to our shareholders through interim and final dividends. Fourth, and finally, those dividend payments will be funded through free cash flow. Additional surplus cash will be managed in a principled and transparent manner. What does this mean now? We generated free cash flow of GBP 27 million after investments into our future plans. The Board will recommend paying a dividend of GBP 0.045 with respect to the fiscal year ending January 2024. I want to point out that this is a full year dividend, which is equivalent to an interim and final dividend. Total dividends paid to shareholders are GBP 15.5 million. We restart dividend payments at a coverage ratio of 3 and anticipate a progressive dividend within our guidance range of 2 to 3. Considering the options for the use of excess cash available under the company's capital allocation policy, the Board has decided to strengthen our balance sheet by using excess cash to reduce net debt levels.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#13

To sum up, Card Factory put up a robust financial showing this year. Gains came evenly across every key measure. Revenue rose by double digits, the PBT margin rate improved, PBT climbed 27%, we invested in the future, cash generation was strong, net debt came down and, naturally, the dividend restarted. The proof points we delivered confirm we remain on course to lift revenues to GBP 650 million and the PBT margin to 14% by the end of FY 2027. Against those targets we will keep producing balanced, sustainable progress, offsetting headwinds while putting money into growth. That said, I'll pass it back to Darcy for the strategy update. Thank you.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#14

Thanks, Matthias. Thanks. So I want to give you an update now on the substantial headway we've made in delivering our Opening Our New Future strategy during FY 2024, as well as where we'll be concentrating in this financial year. Through executing that strategy, Card Factory is strongly placed to turn into the U.K.'s number one destination for every customer looking for quality, value, choice, convenience, and experience. To fulfil that ambition, we're concentrating on the growth building blocks we set out in detail at our Capital Markets update last May. Stores, where we'll, we'll keep leveraging and expanding our profitable store estate across the U.K. and the Republic of Ireland. Cards, gift, and celebration essentials, where good progress is being made in widening our reach across the GBP 13.4 billion U.K. celebration occasions market. Online and omni-channel, where we're aiming to deliver a seamless celebration experience to our customers. Partnerships, where we'll keep building on the positive headway made in the U.K. and international. When our financial year ended, we had a store estate of 1,058 stores in the U.K. and Ireland, and thanks to our agile store optimization program, we carried on maintaining an exceptional store, a record on store profitability.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#15

Our core business kept expanding, with 26 net new stores added in FY 2024, which keeps us on track to deliver 90 new stores across the five-year plan through FY 2027. From May through December, we completed the first, most significant phase of our Store Evolution program, finishing the space realignment project across 729 stores. That initiative was capital-light and should pay back in under a year. As part of the program, average card space in each store came down by 7%, and by reallocating that space we supported growth in both card and gift sales, which produced 16% more room for our gift and celebration essentials ranges. The work wrapped up ahead of the key Christmas trading period and helped us achieve our highest ever Christmas sales. We recorded strong growth in key expanded categories including gifting, soft toys, and stationery. Rolling out The Card Factory Way customer service excellence program successfully to all colleagues boosted customer interaction on the shop floor, which allowed tailored service, product recommendations, and better basket value. For FY 2025, our priorities include carrying on with the new store opening program, drawing on an updated store format and design after successful trials under the Store Evolution program.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#16

Beyond that, we're pushing ahead with more expansion in markets that aren't yet fully penetrated, and that covers Central London along with the Republic of Ireland. As part of this, a new Central London store launched at the end of March on Cheapside — quite literally just around the corner — and there we're putting into practice what the other trial stores taught us about range, layout, and location. Work on improving and widening ranges carried on across cards, gift, and celebration essentials, with fresh lines added in both own-label and stationery, plus the launch of key licensed products. Innovation and range development aimed at broadening customer appeal and price points helped deliver like-for-like growth of 4.8% in card, and we keep tailoring what we offer to suit different regions and demographics so as to grow card market authority. Wider ranges produced strong like-for-like sales in gifts, up +15.8%, and in celebration essentials, up +6.7%. We also rolled out a new card price architecture successfully, and it upheld our long-standing value for money credentials, with low entry price points, by getting the balance right between targeted price increases and rotating promotional offers. In FY 2025 we'll carry on growing card market authority via range development and curation, including ranges tailored by region and by demographics. We're also continuing to broaden our gift and celebration essential ranges, covering baby gifting and stationery, alongside more space optimization for growth ranges such as pet gifting.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#17

Our omni-channel initiative achieved a successful national launch of the new click and collect offering, and by the close of FY 2024, 7.8% of customers were choosing in-store pickup for their orders, and encouragingly, 50% of those were new customers to cardfactory.co.uk. Customer order-to-collection times have already been cut from three to five days at rollout to one to two days on average by September. Broader digital investment included completing the re-platforming of cardfactory.co.uk and gettingpersonal.co.uk, which allows us to gain the advantages of consistent systems, tools, and processes across both platforms. We'll keep investing in technology infrastructure to further build out our omni-channel capabilities, alongside ongoing range expansion, with a focus on personalized card and personalized gift ranges. On the international side, the first four franchise stores opened in the Middle East, with up to 36 stores anticipated over the next four years, and customer response in the Middle East has been really positive. As expected, gifts and celebration essential ranges have performed well, given the strong gifting culture in that market, with stationery, soft toys, balloons, and gift bags accounting for almost 50% of total sales. Our partnership program in the U.K. continued to expand with the rollout of all 223 Matalan stores by December 2023.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#18

The purchase of SA Greetings has given us a leading position in South Africa via 25 Card stores, one online store, and 6,500 partnership distribution points run by wholesale partners—and it also opens up strategic wholesale growth opportunities for us. We're continuing to make headway in positive talks with new prospective partners in the U.K. and throughout our identified international markets of interest. On top of that, we're optimizing our Middle East partnership, where we aim to grow the store count. In FY 2024, we introduced our Delivering a Sustainable Future plan, which set out an updated and expanded sustainability strategy running to the end of 2028, with clear and transparent commitments and goals. We've set a net zero by 2050 goal, supported by near-term science-based targets to help us get there. The strategy rests on five important areas for our business, both now and in the future. Those are climate, waste and circularity, protecting nature, people and equity, and governance, each aligned with the relevant UN Sustainable Development Goals. We've made good progress across every area of focus within the strategy, and we're now engaging colleagues and suppliers under this new This Moment banner, which captures the spirit of personal accountability and commitment that we've nurtured within Card Factory.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#19

A standout moment in FY 2024 was witnessing the payoff from our waste reduction work — removing non-essential single-use plastics from our own label products and packaging, boosting recyclability, and working alongside suppliers to cut waste in products and packaging. Sustainability is now being built into business planning and decision-making, so that our commitments sit at the heart of how we operate and the choices we make daily. Turning to what's ahead, I'd like to begin by recapping how we performed during the last year. The robust results delivered in that period show the power of our customer proposition and the gains from the Opening Our New Future strategy, under which we achieved progress and delivery across every building block of growth. Our store estate continues to be our biggest asset, with the Store Evolution program contributing positively and range development work helping to drive revenue performance. The celebration occasions market in which we compete continues to be resilient, and our value and quality proposition is connecting with customers who want value for money as they celebrate all of life's special moments. Consequently, positive momentum persists across the business, fueling both top-line growth and bottom-line growth.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#20

Disciplined financial management is the foundation here, and it's helping to make the business financially stronger. With robust cash generation from operations and net debt continuing to come down, our balance sheet keeps getting stronger. And after restrictions on dividend payments came to an end, we've revised our capital allocation policy so it reflects our commitment to balancing the delivery of sustainable long-term growth in shareholder value with progressive cash returns to shareholders, while we keep driving business growth. Looking forward, the Board continues to have confidence in the compelling growth opportunity for Card Factory and in our ability to hit the FY 2027 targets we set out in the CMD updates last May. Those are GBP 650 million of sales and a profit before tax margin of 14%. We expect to keep making strategic progress toward these ambitions in FY 2025. Trading since the financial year began has been in line with the Board's expectations, and we have seen good momentum carry on across our FY 2025 spring seasons. As anticipated, PBT growth in FY 2025 is expected to be weighted toward the second half of the year, because of the phasing of planned investments and inflationary recovery actions.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#21

As we go through this year, we anticipate handling the broader inflationary pressures by continuing to make gains in efficiency and productivity, along with capitalizing on what our vertically integrated structure offers. As a result, the Board's outlook for FY 2025 is still the same. So thanks again for being with us at our results presentation. Matthias and I are now glad to answer whatever questions you might have. Just a quick reminder—for those here in the room, or if this is your first time, a microphone sits at the side of your seat. So when you ask a question, if you could pick it up and hit the red button, that lets people online and the recording hear those questions. And for anyone joining online, please include your name and organization in the QA box, and we'll read your question out on your behalf. But we'll begin with questions from the room first. So very good. Hi, Kate.

Kate Calvert

analyst
#22

Morning. Kate Calvert here from Investec. I have a couple of questions. First, I’d like some insight into the Board’s thinking on why it chose to begin with a GBP 0.045 dividend instead of, perhaps, paying a lower dividend and doing a buyback. And, related to that, I suppose: you mentioned peak leverage was about 1.2x in FY 2024. What level of adjusted peak leverage do you consider optimal going forward? Then my last question concerns Getting Personal. What will you need to do to return it to growth?

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#23

Good. Thanks. Matthias, would you like to cover the dividend and leverage, and I'll handle the GP question?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#24

Sure, glad to take that question, Kate. So yes, just to restate it, we began paying dividends after more than five years in which no dividends had been paid. Our starting point was GBP 0.045, set against adjusted EPS of 13.5. That works out to a dividend coverage ratio of 3. It aligns with the target we set previously of a dividend coverage ratio between 2 and 3. What we're aiming for is regular dividends that grow progressively, so we would expect the payout to rise as profitability rises. On your question about whether we considered buybacks, or whether the Board is considering them as an option: yes, how any surplus cash gets used will be discussed by the Board and decided according to the specific circumstances. All options remain open, a cash buyback included. Right now, given the history of the business and some uncertainty in the economic environment, the prudent course was judged to be reducing cash net debt rather than paying out, or starting to pay out, a higher dividend or doing a cash buyback. On your further question about the optimal peak debt level, as you know, we carry a capital requirement in our business across the fiscal year. We finished at a 0.4 multiple at the end of January. That figure doesn't include the dividend payment, so if you actually factor that in, we would be looking at 0.5 or 0.6.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#25

At present, working capital requirements across the fiscal year sit in the GBP 60 million to GBP 70 million band, which, once again, contributes an additional roughly 0.8. As a result, we expect to stay inside our maximum peak range of 1.5 when we hit the high point during this fiscal year, and again, lowering net debt was the more prudent choice rather than stretching this into our target. Does that address your question? Thank you.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#26

Thanks, Matthias. And Kate, regarding your last question about GP, I think — first of all, our main emphasis had been on cardfactory.co.uk. We finished the re-platforming of Getting Personal, since that technology was essentially obsolete. We're now at a point where we can begin adding new ranges and, you know, drive the right kind of marketing activity to generate sales growth. But, again, our main focus is on how we turn Card Factory into an omni-channel business, concentrating on cardfactory.co.uk and the link between stores and online.

Adam Tomlinson

analyst
#27

Good morning, this is Adam Tomlinson calling from Liberum. I've got three questions, if I may. To start with, regarding that FY 2025 guidance — specifically how profits are weighted toward H2 — you brought up the planned phasing of investment. Could you expand a bit on where that spending is directed during H1, what the main buckets are, and how significant each one is? My second question concerns pricing. Once more, some detail would help on how your prices currently stack up against competitors, and you touched on broadening the pricing architecture — perhaps the efforts undertaken over the year on that front and what further opportunity remains. Last question, on partnerships: any detail you can share, since you discussed the U.K., but also beyond it, just a sense of some of the discussions you might be having there would be really useful. Thanks.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#28

All right, sounds good. So Matthias, if you're happy to handle the FY 2025 weighting, I'll cover pricing and partnerships, and I'll get us started. On pricing — and I know I risk repeating myself here — what we laid out previously is that our focus has been on getting the pricing architecture right. That means holding our GBP 0.29 price point while stepping up through the appropriate tiers: GBP 0.59, GBP 0.99, GBP 1.49. We also want to be sure we have the correct number of cards sitting at every price point, and that each card delivers the right value for money at GBP 0.29 and so on. On top of that, we've extended the exit price point, which now sits at GBP 3.99 in seasons. The idea is that whichever card you choose — even one at GBP 3.99 — when you pick it up, it gives you the best value for money available anywhere in the market. So that's the focus: doing that work, then leveraging range development to push toward those higher price points while still offering great value at the same time. As for how you should think about pricing going forward — and again, I've been consistent on this — as we look ahead and consider inflationary costs, we have three main levers available to us: productivity, efficiency, and price.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#29

We'll use those levers whenever necessary to offset inflationary pressure, and pricing is the final option we'd turn to. Then regarding partnerships — I'd say we're happy with how far we've come, and we've gained some genuinely excellent insights from Australia, from the Middle East, and also from the U.K. partnerships. There are plenty of lessons to draw from what we've done and from how the model needs to develop. Take the Middle East, for instance, where we always understood the market would be gift-driven. What we've found there — we carry a lot of what we term milestone age product in our stores, meaning 21, 30, 40, 50. Pointing out someone's age is considered quite rude in the Middle East, so we actually didn't know that when we entered. We learned it, removed that product, and swapped in something better. So that's the sort of learning involved. And over the longer term in wholesale, there's the question of how we deliver a full-service model — we have lessons from our South Africa business on that, and we're experimenting, potentially in Australia.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#30

And then, on the operational side — we have consistently stated that this will be capital light, and we have been executing that quite efficiently and effectively. But I cannot handle any additional international orders on Excel spreadsheets. So at this stage of the ERP, we are taking the necessary steps, because we now feel confident that an international business exists. What we are observing is that our offering is resonating, people are taking our calls, and when we present the product to potential partners, they like what we have to offer. Naturally, though, we must proceed in a disciplined manner. We need to ensure the right partners. We need the right skills matched with the right infrastructure. So, more to come. Should I address that as well?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#31

Oh, sorry about that. My apologies. Yes. Uh,

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#32

Thanks, Matthias.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#33

Right, good. FY 2025 is going to be one more step on the road to hitting our FY 2027 targets. We expect continued growth on both the top and bottom lines, and the first couple of months, as Darcy said earlier, show that we're on track and in line with expectations. And just as a reminder, that progress will come in a balanced way — top-line and bottom-line progress — while we invest in future growth and, of course, you know, mitigate cost price inflation. Our PBT, and it's no secret, typically leans more toward the second half. But you also know we're seeing some unique cost price inflation in the first half, like higher container rates, because of what happened in the Red Sea. That's normalizing. As Darcy pointed out just a minute ago, we're tackling all of this cost price inflation the same way we've handled it over the past several years, and we're confident we can deliver in line with our expectations. Sorry.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#34

Very good. Rus?

Russell Pointon

analyst
#35

Hello, Russell Pointon from Edison here. I have three questions, if I may. First, you've been making solid headway with Card Factory online, so I'd like to get a sense of how your thinking has shifted since last year's Capital Markets Day regarding the service level you intend to offer online. Second question. I believe there's a mention buried in the statement that transaction numbers were roughly flat compared with a year earlier. Does that surprise you at all, or was it what you'd anticipated? And third, on the dividend, are you in effect signalling a move from an initial cover of three times to two times by the end of 2027? Thanks.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#36

Would you like to cover the transaction profile and the dividend, and then I'll handle online?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#37

Okay. I'll begin with the dividend, since that's the theme we're on. What we've set out is that we'll have a progressive dividend within — going forward, it will sit in the range of 2 to 3. Each year the Board will of course evaluate, based on performance and the EPS delivered and the particular circumstances, what the right level is. So I can't stand here and say that by 2027 we'll be at a certain range, but what I can say is that the progressive dividend will be progressive going forward. On the transactions, yes, overall we've seen transactions flat in a market that's challenging for many retailers, and so we're especially pleased to see that people are still celebrating occasions and seeking us out as one of the key retailers where they get products at value for money, at low prices, to celebrate these occasions.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#38

Thanks. And then, regarding Card Factory online — we've had a couple of questions on this too. Really, what we did in FY 2024 was invest in the platform. We've set up a digital squad, so we're able to release code every two weeks. We've made substantial improvements to the customer journey. We can see that coming through not only in second-half performance but also in key metrics. So customer feedback, or customer satisfaction, is up, and the number of complaints to our contact center has been cut in half, so we can really see the traction. The focus now is on making sure we have a very clear customer proposition — being really clear about what we want to sell online versus in-store. That work is literally happening as we speak, and then what's the best way to market to customers, to recruit them in, to convert them, and retain them? So that's where the focus is for this year. Gone at the back?

Analyst

analyst
#39

Hey Matt, can you hear me okay?

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#40

Yeah, if you're... are you hitting the correct button?

Analyst

analyst
#41

Yeah.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#42

Yes.

Analyst

analyst
#43

All right, you have me now? Great. Excellent, thanks. So my first question relates to the store format that's being progressively updated. Could you remind us what share of the current store base has been reformatted, and what level of like-for-like growth you're seeing in those reformatted locations compared with the remainder of the estate? My second question concerns range expansion. How much of that 7.7 like-for-like growth you're seeing across the estate comes from mix, and how should we expect that mix benefit to develop in FY 2025 as you keep curating your range? Thank you.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#44

Thank you. So regarding the work on store formats, I think if you look at what we actually did — we put together a set of trials in which the look and feel of the stores was changed, so in effect we refurbished them. We altered the way products are displayed, and we also examined how space was allocated. Once that trial period ended, we broke it all down to try to work out what was driving the sales, and the area where we saw the greatest traction was space reallocation and being able to generate more sales in gifting and celebration essentials. In effect, that is where we spent the whole of last year, and when we looked at the space allocation, effectively, roughly just over 700 stores required their space to be aligned. The rest did not require space alignment, either because the space was already right or because the size of the store simply did not let us do it. So the space realignment, as a one-off fix, is now complete, and as a result of that, you can see. So, but the point of it was that cards will keep growing. So any SKU in cards that we removed, there was another card available for a customer to buy.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#45

We are quite disciplined on that front, which explains why card sales kept rising at 4.8%. Gifting, though, increased out of proportion at over 15%, while celebration came in at just under 7%. So I'd say that's the strategy effectively delivering. What we did after that was say, all right, store refurbishment — making the store look nicer, if you will — well, it's extremely hard to tie sales growth to a refurbishment. Going back across my career, this is probably, I don't know, the seventh occasion I've attempted to demonstrate it, and it simply can't be done. What we do know, however, is that investment is necessary. So a minimum standard has been established, and we'll spend a modest sum where required, but every new store will open in that format. The store we've just opened in Cheapside, just down the road, and the one in Westfield — all new stores open with those changes, since we can accommodate that within the CapEx of a new store. And from here on, the way to think about it is that this is now business as usual. So space range, display — we'll be evaluating those literally on a continuous, ongoing basis.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#46

There's nothing left to catch up on, you know.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#47

Should I take the second question?

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#48

Sure.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#49

Turning to mix — yes, like-for-like growth came in at 7.7. Inside that, celebration essentials and gifting were up 9.8%, while cards rose 4.8%. The split remains roughly 50/50. That aligns with what we laid out at the CMD last May and with our expectations, though our path is for non-card sales to keep outpacing cards, with the mix moving to approximately 53%, 47%, 7%. It's important to remember that our playing field is a GBP 13.2 billion celebration occasions market, not just a GBP 1.4 billion card market. Within that larger market we hold a 6% share, so we see ample room to grow in this space.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#50

Now I'll move on to a few questions that came in online. I believe we've already partly addressed this first one, and it's directed at you, Matthias. What's the reason the company chose dividends rather than buybacks? Could you walk us through the thinking there?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#51

Happy to do that. We thought it through carefully. We spoke with existing shareholders and asked them what matters to them. Obviously, given the history the business has been through and the fact that dividends have played such a large role at Card Factory and in what Card Factory represents, the feedback was unanimous — indeed overwhelming — that bringing back dividends ought to rank among the top key priorities. That therefore shaped how we reached our decision. Was there a second part?

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#52

The question was simply about the reason for choosing one over the other.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#53

Okay, so that essentially brought us to the point of deciding — or recommending to the Board — that we ought to bring the dividend back, and just to underscore this, making certain it's a regular dividend, one that's reliable and will be a progressive dividend.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#54

Okay, so it's purely by chance that the iPad happens to be in my hands and every single question is directed at you.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#55

Yes, absolutely. Without a doubt.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#56

Um.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#57

I've got the tally right here.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#58

Alright, that sounds great.

Matthias Seeger

executive
#59

And then we’ll get to the questions you have.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#60

In the second half, like-for-like revenue came in flat and EPS declined. What was it that affected the positive momentum we had before?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#61

My apologies, could you—

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#62

In the second half, like-for-like revenue came in flat, and EPS declined. What was it that hit the positive momentum you had before?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#63

Let me try putting that question a different way. I get it. During the second half of last year, we saw some truly robust like-for-like growth. A portion of that came from lapping the shift back from online to High Street. And obviously, across the second half we've moved forward overall. From an EPS perspective, as we've mentioned, we're weighing future investment and offsetting inflation against enhancing our bottom line. So EPS performance in the second half came in entirely as expected.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#64

Great, thanks. There's a question about the absence of trading statements in November and whether that's something we expect to continue going forward. So I believe since I joined, we've had just one trading statement in November. That occurred the year before last, and it happened because we needed to deliver a profit upgrade. So beyond our key set pieces, we'll inform the market as and when things are necessary. Could you please discuss CapEx a bit? Specifically, how does the GBP 27.8 million split between maintenance CapEx and growth CapEx? And within that growth CapEx context, what return on capital hurdle do you apply?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#65

Back in May, at the CMD, we laid out that going forward we'd be spending GBP 25 million on CapEx. That covers refreshing our IT infrastructure and continuing to put money into our data capability. It also covers our store estate — opening 90 net new stores. In fact, we're opening more new stores even as we streamline the portfolio and close others. It covers refitting stores in line with Darcy, with Darcy as outlined for improving the overall store layout, and it covers what we're investing in online. The GBP 27.8 million we spent last year takes in all of these components — somewhat disproportionately, probably, in new store investment, which ran higher than we'd originally anticipated in our glide path.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#66

Thanks. Regarding the profit-before-tax margin pressure, once our energy hedge wraps up in September, what portion of that headwind do you anticipate, assuming energy prices stay where they are now?

Matthias Seeger

executive
#67

Well, we have energy pricing hedged for the whole of this fiscal year. So, consistent with our hedging policy — and we do have a hedging policy that gives us certainty for planning — there is no energy risk for FY 2025.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#68

All right, that's a great question. Looking at the many initiatives within the new plan, which ones have gone well and which haven't gone as well? What have we learned from the store initiatives we've rolled out, and from the new merchandising strategy? So I'd say, when I think about the entire plan overall — and of course, once you've got a plan, it never survives first contact with the battlefield. We have a process of iterating as we go. Before I joined, there really wasn't a long-term strategy in place. It was basically opening stores every year. So we have a process in which we iterate that annually. But if I step back and ask, what did we announce at CMD? Where are we behind and where are we ahead? We're definitely ahead, and we've made really good progress across all of Store Evolution — really optimizing the breadth of range, the depth of range, getting the pricing architecture right, and also bringing on new products. Making our decisions much more data-led and customer-led. This used to be a products-led company. It's now a customer-led company, so we're making really good progress there. Culture is ahead of where I thought we could get to.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#69

I'd say colleague engagement is really strong—we were the fifth best company to work for last year. Online, I think, is taking a bit longer, so when the market after COVID kept shrinking further than I'd expected it to. Even so, the initiatives are paying off, though there's still a fair amount of work left for us. But when we laid out the growth targets—GBP 80 million from stores, GBP 30 million from online, and GBP 80 million from partnerships—we were cautious on online for exactly the reason I just gave. And on partnerships, I'm genuinely pleased that the offer is resonating, and I think the international opportunity is there. So overall, some things are up, some are down, but I'd say net-net, we're on track. I think we've covered a lot of these. There's a question about last year's Capital Markets Day. You identified attractive markets you'd like to expand into. Are you thinking about a bigger investment in any of those markets? Well, the plans we set out at the CMD, I think, are the right ones.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#70

We are, as you know, on course for those partnerships. The weighting is toward the second half, or later, in the plan's latter years. I believe that remains correct. I have always said, when I set out the plan, that plenty of British companies have lost substantial sums going abroad, and plenty of British companies have made money going abroad, and we want to be among the latter. So I prefer a disciplined, conservative approach, in a capital-light manner, in order to capture the opportunity. I think we will... We are nearly out of time, so this will be the final question. Is there any data you can share regarding the levels of internal colleague engagement and retention, which may be gaining from improvements to the proposition in formats? How are your customer satisfaction scores trending? Is Card Factory experiencing a step up in shrink and incidents, as other retailers are? So, taking each of those in turn. On colleague engagement, the primary measure we use is the annual customer satisfaction survey, a very comprehensive tool and system that we run through Best Companies. And we have watched it rise from nowhere to about 100, to about 120, and then 125 last year.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#71

Our approach involves posing questions while paying attention to what comes back. Yet it makes no sense to seek input from people if there's no intention of acting on it. We have consistently been reacting to customer requirements and developing new things for them. Take last year, for instance, when Career Pathways was introduced. For each and every colleague, no matter what your background is, no matter what education you have, whatever role you hold, a very clear and detailed route exists showing how you can move forward should you wish to, and we make training opportunities accessible to them, you know. Beyond that, the Board — you know, we have our own listening forums and channels inside the company, and we run a full communications cascade. There will be a town hall meeting involving all store managers plus all Support Centre factory and warehouse colleagues, I believe tomorrow. So we maintain this kind of regular rhythm. So we do receive it. And our colleagues speak up, right? They tend to tell us, so we're fairly pleased about that. Regarding customer satisfaction, you know, we hold very strong Net Promoter Scores. We've introduced a customer feedback mechanism, a sort of Tell Card Factory, through which customers provide us with feedback that's usually anonymous, but others too.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#72

And naturally, we keep an eye on everything that arrives, you know, via our contact center. And even so, we make errors the same as any retailer does. By and large, we likely hold some of the top Net Promoter Scores, you know, within the industry. And then that final question regarding shrink and incidents in stores. Look, like, I think just as with all retailers, we have certainly witnessed a rise in some difficult behavior you know in stores. We are taking every step that we need to take to ensure that our colleagues feel and are safe, whether that's CCTV, personal safety devices, training, conflict training, all of the things you'd expect us to do. But we're also collaborating with the rest of the industry and with government wherever we need to so that we you know we can support our colleagues. Again, I know that we've got over 150 colleagues on the call, so, once again, thank you very much for everything you do every day, colleagues. So I think that brings today's presentation to a close. Matthias and I will stick around for a little bit if anybody wants to ask anything else. And just really thank you for attending here in person, and also thank you to all of those that have attended online.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#73

Also, in case we don’t cross paths before then, we’ll catch you at the following event.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.