Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 7, 2020

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thanks for holding. Welcome, and we appreciate your joining this CECONOMY AG conference call. <<operator_script>> At this point I'd like to hand the conference over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for joining our Q1 results call. Joining me today are CEO Bernhard Düttmann and CFO Karin Sonnenmoser, who will walk you through today's presentation. Before we begin, let me quickly take care of the usual formalities. First, please note that this call is being recorded. A replay will be posted on our website later today. Second, please bear in mind that today's presentation and possibly some responses to your questions in the Q&A session may include forward-looking statements. For more information on this, please see the disclaimer. Now let me turn things over to our CEO. The floor is all yours.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#3

Morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the call. I'd like to start today with a brief look back at our first quarter. After that, I'll hand things over to Karin, who will take you through the financials and the outlook for the year, as she always does. And as usual, we'll finish with a Q&A session, where we're glad to take your questions. Ladies and gentlemen, picking up where we left off at the end of the last call, I want to stress that execution is our top priority. During the first quarter, we focused our execution on the Black Friday period and on the Christmas trading. Once again, this year's Black Friday period went well. On the other hand, since Black Friday keeps growing in importance, we once more saw the Christmas business affected by a pull-forward effect. The upgrades we made to our online platforms over the past financial year, together with our service offerings, helped support solid growth rates in our online business and in the Services & Solutions business. Higher income from Services & Solutions, along with our cost optimization efforts, contributed to the improvement in our bottom line results. Our operations in Germany did especially well in the first quarter.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#4

Karin is going to revisit that point later on. That said, the first quarter brought us a few hurdles as well. To begin with, results from our Polish operations remain unsatisfactory. We've put together an action plan along with long-term management changes aimed at countering that negative trend. Secondly, certain countries gave us a tough macroeconomic backdrop, and competition there was fierce. We are watching the situation closely and intend to ensure we still turn in a resilient performance under these conditions. Our sales and earnings felt the impact of these developments. Let's briefly review the guidance tied to the key figures for the first quarter. Sales, adjusted for FX and portfolio effects, declined 0.5%. Excluding the iBOOD business as well — which isn't counted as a portfolio measure — underlying sales growth would have come in nearly flat. Adjusted EBIT rose by EUR 20 million compared with the same period a year earlier. That number highlights how much progress we've achieved during the past month. In summary, we succeeded in laying the groundwork for a solid financial year 2019, 2020. Now let's turn to a closer look at how we did on Black Friday. In 2018, we established a dedicated concept for the first time, designed to make the most of this key selling season.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#5

That turned out nicely. So in 2019 we took that established idea and developed it further, ending up even more ready than before. For instance, each country received a thorough, standardized playbook ahead of time so the entire period and every segment would run as a highly disciplined campaign. On that note, concentrating squarely on services and selling bundles across categories has shown itself to be the correct approach for our customers. Our freshly updated web platform ran smoothly with no outages at all — something essential during peak sales stretches such as this — and together with improved availability and a much stronger delivery performance, that has produced substantial gains in customer satisfaction. People enrolled in our loyalty programs embraced the early access option, letting them shop before everybody else. Through these measures, we once more achieved a profitable Black Friday, in stores as well as online. We thank our thousands of dedicated colleagues, who put in hard work daily to provide a great customer experience. The Black Friday period was foremost in all our thoughts, and the numbers on the following slide make that clear. Once again, Black Friday stood as our strongest single day on record.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#6

All told, versus the year before, we moved over 1 million additional units. When it comes to net sales and unit volumes alike, Samsung and Apple smartphones, plus Samsung TVs, ranked among our top 3 sellers. Floor care purchases proved highly popular too, and gamers snapped up Nintendo Switch with real enthusiasm. Roughly 15% more online shoppers came to our webshops. On top of that, across the 5-day Black Friday window we saw about 2% more customers come into our stores than a year earlier. Those numbers are impressive. Overall, throughout that Black Friday stretch we posted double-digit sales growth for our stores and our online business alike. For a bit more color, let me quickly point out that bundled offers in particular landed very well with customers. And that fits precisely with our -- with our service strategy. We've managed to tie product sales together with services and accessories successfully. Ready-to-use preinstalled smartphones and notebooks stood out as especially popular, each delivering a striking sales lift of roughly 60%. Screen protection offers tell the same story, rising by nearly 70% against the prior year.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#7

Both of those services belong to what we offer as core at SmartBars. I should remind everyone that putting greater emphasis on attaching Services & Solutions definitely helps our bottom line. When we take all of that together, we feel very satisfied with how well the Black Friday period was executed. That covers what I have for now. I'll hand things over to Karin, who will take a deep dive into the Q1 financial performance.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#8

Thank you, Bernhard, and good morning to everyone joining the call. Ladies and gentlemen, it's a pleasure to reflect on a solid first quarter of the year. Allow me to walk you through how the quarter developed in detail. Group sales reached approximately EUR 6.8 billion. That marks a modest decrease of 0.8%. Once you adjust for ForEx and portfolio effects as well as iBOOD, sales landed roughly at the prior year's level. Looking at the individual segments, the picture is mixed. In DACH, sales were more or less unchanged despite a demanding comparison base. In Germany, we saw a strong double-digit sales increase over the Black Friday period. Yet, since Black Friday keeps growing in importance, our sales pull-forward also played into this. As a result, the Christmas business during the first weeks of December came in weaker than a year earlier. The late timing of Black Friday and a deliberately less campaign intensive post Black Friday period reinforced this as well. In Western and Southern Europe, ForEx and portfolio-adjusted sales fell by 2.9%. In Spain, the lack of a strong VAT campaign in the prior year period weighed negatively on sales development. In Italy, sales declined amid a currently weaker consumer climate and intense competition.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#9

In the Netherlands, sales kept falling. Still, we did see a modest improvement in the trend as the quarter drew to a close, since the countermeasures we put in place appear to be beginning to work. Eastern Europe gave us a mixed picture, and overall sales there rose 11.3%. Turkey posted mid-double-digit sales growth, helped in particular by a favorable market backdrop. Poland, by contrast, saw its sales decline carry on, which was tied to a fiercely competitive environment. Turning to the other segment, Sweden delivered solid sales growth in local currency. The decline in that segment relates to the divestment of iBOOD. During Q1 of last year, iBOOD was still responsible for roughly EUR 15 million in sales. Now let me move on to online and Services & Solutions. During the first quarter, online sales—leaving out the Greek MediaMarkt business—grew by roughly 4% versus a year earlier. Once iBOOD is adjusted for, online sales actually rose by 6%. Bear in mind that we were up against a tough comparison base, with 28% online sales growth in the same period a year ago. Our strong Black Friday campaigns gave the online business a particularly helpful boost. A further factor behind this positive development is our pick-up option, which our customers continue to embrace warmly.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#10

During the first quarter, 47% of all online orders were collected at our stores. I'm also feeling even better about how our Services & Solutions business performed this quarter. Services & Solutions had a very favorable development, with sales rising to 10%. A strong appetite for extended warranties, reflecting our enhanced offerings, largely fueled that growth. Even though demand for our SmartBars services soared during this reporting period, we saw double-digit growth rates across all 3 core services: ready-to-use, screen protection and in-store repair. Lastly, our overall mobile contract business edged up slightly. Let's turn now to Slide 13 for a look at gross profit, OpEx and EBIT. Compared with the prior quarter, gross margin showed a slight improving trend in the first quarter. Gross margin fell just 10 basis points, to 18.3%. Still, pressure on the goods margin persists. In the first quarter, our expanding exposure to Services & Solutions partly offset that. Our gross margin was also helped by how successfully we managed the Black Friday campaign period in the first quarter. Meanwhile, thanks to our rigorous cost management, we cut operational expenses by 50 basis points.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#11

The improvement came mostly from reduced personnel costs, which our reorganization and efficiency program helped with, along with additional operating expense savings tied to a better-optimized staffing setup in our German stores. On top of that, decreased material and location costs contributed favorably. Consequently, adjusted EBIT rose by EUR 20 million, reaching EUR 289 million. That figure includes a positive IFRS 16 effect of EUR 2 million. Growth in underlying EBIT came primarily from the DACH segment. Germany recorded a substantial earnings gain, whereas performance in the other DACH countries held steady. Our proactive management of operational costs played a big part in what happened in Germany. Beyond that, our strategic initiative keeps delivering results as we execute it. This fed through to greater income from Services & Solutions. Regrettably, not every region backed up the group's earnings improvement. Results in Western and Southern Europe felt the weight of a soft consumer climate and fierce competition in Italy. In Spain, weaker sales—caused by timing differences and promotional periods—likewise weighed on the segment's result. We anticipate making up that modest earnings gap over the coming quarter. In the Netherlands, earnings kept falling, though we did observe a mild improvement in the trend as the quarter drew to a close.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#12

In Eastern Europe, the tough and highly competitive conditions in Poland kept dragging down profitability for the region. In Turkey, earnings came in slightly positive given our supportive market environment. Broadly speaking, it's fair to describe the picture as one where we're seeing the first signs of improving momentum, particularly in Germany, with still more set to show up as the year goes on. Now I'll briefly walk through the bridge from adjusted to reported EBIT. During the first quarter, we recorded a positive EBIT effect -- sorry, we booked a positive EBIT impact tied to the Greek transaction, which happened at the end of November. That effect came to EUR 33 million and stemmed mainly from deconsolidating the negative net asset book value for MediaMarkt Greece and our consolidated CECONOMY account, as well as from a positive fair value on the 25% joint venture stake. On the other side, we still carried some trailing restructuring costs linked to the reorganization and efficiency program. Those -- the positive net gain came to EUR 30 million. We still anticipate a limited amount of trailing restructuring expenses arriving over the coming quarters. So altogether, we continue to expect a smaller positive net effect of roughly EUR 10 million in this financial year.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#13

If we factor in the positive earnings impact along with the remaining adjustments tied to Greece and Fnac, reported EBIT for Q1 landed at EUR 319 million. That marks a gain of EUR 84 million versus the same period a year earlier. As you may remember, charges of EUR 34 million for top management changes and restructuring weighed on the result in that prior-year period. Now let's turn to the bridge from EBIT to EPS on Slide 15. Bear in mind that what we are showing here are the reported figures. The current period also incorporates the effects from IFRS 16. In addition to the EBIT improvement, earnings before taxes rose by EUR 92 million, reaching EUR 327 million. This was further helped by a lift in the net financial result stemming from the M.video dividend, which amounted to EUR 13 million. Higher interest expenses—driven mainly by recognizing the interest component for operating leases under IFRS 16—had an upper side effect. The tax rate got better by 5.3 percentage points, coming to 32%. That gain is largely tied to the nontaxable gain from the Greek transaction. Our underlying tax rate—meaning before any effects from associates, M.video, and other restructuring—stood at 38%.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#14

Just to remind you, the tax consolidation gains we saw over the last 2 financial years came from activating tax loss carryforwards—and mostly from one-time expense reductions within that—whereas the structural tax improvements we've implemented are sustainable. At the same time, we're currently pursuing some additional minor improvements in Germany and in other countries as well. So we still anticipate the underlying tax rate moving toward 35% in this financial year. Thanks to the lower tax rate and the EBIT improvement, earnings per share rose by EUR 0.17 to EUR 0.47. Turning to Slide 16. Free cash flow for the first 3 months came in at EUR 1.421 billion, which is EUR 27 million higher than the prior year period. That increase, though, is tied to the adoption of IFRS 16. We'll also give you a lease-adjusted free cash flow, subtracting repayment of lease liabilities, so that free cash flow comparability under IFRS 16 is better. Naturally, there's no change overall in total cash flow for the group stemming from the first-time application of IFRS 16. Lease adjusted free cash flow in the first 3 months stayed below the prior year's level.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#15

Part of this comes down to the cash outflows we anticipate tied to the reorganization and efficiency program. And please also bear in mind that the positive EBIT impact from the Greek transaction isn't cash effective, and that weighed on the other operating cash flow line. On top of that, during the prior year, other operating cash flow got a boost from lower trade tax receivables and from receivables being settled in connection with the Russia transaction. A further factor behind the drop in adjusted free cash flow is a higher cash tax payment. In the previous year, we gained from lower tax expense payments thanks to tax optimization measures in the financial year '17, '18, which became largely cash effective in the first quarter of the financial year '18, '19. For the most recent tax optimization, we expect a major share of the tax refund to come in during the current financial year, which should bring about a year-on-year decline in cash taxes over the coming quarters. Let's now move on to the outlook. The underlying assumption for the financial year '19, '20 that we presented during our full year call are still valid. With this in mind, we confirm our outlook for this financial year.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#16

On the sales side, we still anticipate a modest rise in ForEx-adjusted sales versus the prior year. For adjusted EBIT, our expectation remains EUR 445 million to EUR 475 million. That figure incorporates a positive effect from pre of just EUR 5 million to EUR 15 million, reflecting the IFRS 16 transition. Our perspective on how the segment will develop is likewise unchanged. We expect DACH to support the positive EBIT trend, and Germany especially. Meanwhile, we remain cautious about how things will unfold in the Netherlands and Poland. As a result, the segment's Western, Southern Europe and Eastern Europe should perform roughly in line with prior year's levels. This outlook has been adjusted for portfolio changes and nonrecurring effects tied to the reorganization and efficiency program. In addition, the earnings effect from associates such as Fnac is not factored in. Regarding Fnac, as you know, its share price has fallen rather sharply over recent weeks. At the present share price level, an impairment risk exists as of the next end of period, which is end of March. But let me be clear: any potential impairment of the Fnac stake would, of course, have no cash impact, would not lead to a capital increase, and would not affect our guidance.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#17

Taking everything into account, we think the market currently puts too low a price on Fnac shares, and we expect them to move toward fair value. At this point I'd like to hand things back to Bernhard so he can give his closing remarks. I'm looking forward to taking your questions later in the session.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#18

Thanks, Karin. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to give a quick recap. During Q1, we managed to establish the groundwork for a strong full year. Our attention was on Black Friday. Through that effort, we raised our online sales and drew additional shoppers into our physical stores, which form the backbone of MediaMarktSaturn. Once again, this demonstrated that stores remain a central strength within an omnichannel business model. Simultaneously, we concentrated on rolling out our key initiatives further, and we are gaining traction. All in all, Q1 represented one more significant milestone on our journey. At the close of March, we will reveal the direction we intend to take going forward. So I am pleased to invite you to our strategy update on 26th of March. I look forward to that event. There is plenty for us to present. We will walk you through our perspective on the market and a customer-centric business model. We will additionally feature deep dives on chosen operational initiatives. Furthermore, we will hand you a roadmap plus the financial impact, so you can monitor how our implementation proceeds. An invitation containing every detail will go out early next week. That brings our presentation to a close.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#19

Thanks to all of you for listening. At this point, I'll hand things over to the operator so we can take your questions.

Operator

operator
#20

<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Nicolas Langlet at Exane BNP Paribas.

Nicolas Langlet

analyst
#21

I've got 3 questions, if you don't mind. First, on gross margin: within that 10 basis point decline in Q1, was there anything exceptional in there? Or do you think this 10 basis point decline is a good indication for the next quarters? Second question, how much of the savings related to the reorganization and efficiency program were generated in Q1? And what's the outlook for the coming quarters? And finally, Fnac Darty recently said they are looking at strategic options for their business in the Netherlands. Would you be interested by that asset? And do you think it's feasible from an enterprise perspective?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#22

Nicolas, I’ll begin with the third question about Fnac and its stake in the Netherlands business. I believe we already have our own agenda of work to complete. Because of that, we are not eager to take on new assets in countries before we have finished executing on our core tasks, and we have consistently said this is a transformation of our business—handling admin, handling logistics, handling the systems, bringing them into the game and getting them ready. Anything else would be a distraction. So we are not eager for these assets.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#23

Nicolas, so there are some unusual effects on gross margin. In fact, our gross margin got a boost from how well we managed the campaign period around Black Friday, which Bernhard mentioned earlier, and on top of that, from higher income out of Services & Solutions. Even so, we continue to face pressure on the goods margin because of competition, especially in West and Southern Europe and in Eastern Europe too. So the margin trend is positive, based on what we saw in Q1. But once again, we still expect pressure on margin through the remainder of the financial year. The second point — the second question was about what effects the reorganization and efficiency program had in Q1. In fact, we won't break out program-related savings specifically on a quarterly basis. The cost savings produced in connection with the program are in line with the targets we communicated. That is also visible when you look at our cost structure in Q1. And looking at our cost structure, you can see cost savings came to EUR 44 million in Q1 before IFRS 16 effect. They were mostly driven by personnel cost savings of around EUR 26 million stemming from our reorganization and efficiency program, but also from other operating cost savings, particularly thanks to efficiency measures tied to an optimized personnel deployment in our German store.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#24

I hope that addressed what you were asking.

Nicolas Langlet

analyst
#25

Yeah, it does.

Operator

operator
#26

Our next question is from Volker Bosse at Baader Bank.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#27

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank. I have a few questions. First, regarding your adjusted EBIT: it went up 7.4% in the first quarter, and that's still under the 10% earnings growth you're targeting for the full year. So my question is, what gives you confidence that earnings momentum will pick up as the year goes on? Second, on online sales, are you happy with the plus 4% trend? It looks somewhat weak, considering the market grew by plus 10%. And what do you expect for the remainder of the year? Third, on your problem countries — let's call them that — Netherlands, Spain, Italy, Poland. You said you saw an improving trend at the end of the quarter. Did that improving trend carry on into January, and coming back to Italy: in earlier calls, you said you had achieved the turnaround here. Has the turnaround not materialized anymore? And regarding Netherlands, you described the distribution center as a kind of problem in that country. You mentioned it was solved, but it doesn't seem that solved the issues in the Netherlands. Perhaps a bit of background on your updated view of these countries.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#28

And last, since you brought up Fnac Darty, can you give us some kind of guidance? At the current share price levels, what size of potential impairment risk do you see at Fnac Darty?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#29

Volker, I'll take your questions. First, the adjusted EBIT increase. You're asking why that is. Is it really consistent with our yearly guidance, since the expected increase is higher? I think we explained clearly that the savings from between 1 program will grow throughout the year. So we expected more savings in the quarters ahead. I think that should answer that question. The second point was online — are we happy with our online sales of 4.3%? First, if you take iBOOD out with a pure online business, it would have been 6%. And we are — actually, we were satisfied with our development in our online channel because we had a lot of traffic in the online channel. We had Black Friday contributing positively to the campaigns. And we had — actually, we had tough comps against previous year where we had increased to 20 — by 28% in the first quarter. That was a tough comparison. So in general, we were quite happy. But in — what we also learned, and that is an experience we made in this first quarter, that we had a very successful Black Friday in many, many — in many of our countries, in almost all of our countries.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#30

What happened was that this success caught some competitors off guard as well. So afterward, there was a fierce reaction. Apparently, there was over -- completely overstocked. So following our campaign, the market reacted fiercely, which then also led to slower Christmas business for us because they simply tried to clear out their stock. And that is reflected right now in a market situation where there are some players -- and we have -- basically, in almost all of the countries we have some players, we are under tremendous pressure, and their react -- I would partly call it strange given this situation, but they have to get their cash flow. So they're trying to get rid of whatever they had in stock. And that results in some kind of strange market situation, and that's also why we have this intense price pressure coming up in the market. And the question is -- and this question is still open, how far will this market price pressure lead? And when -- where is it going to stop? For that reason, it's crucial that we stick to our strategy going for services because Services & Solutions is our pillar where we can be really strong with our asset base, with our customer contact where online players can't have the same.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#31

Volker, on your first question, building on what Bernhard said, we anticipate robust expansion in Services & Solutions, so we see a favorable effect coming from that. Beyond that, we look for growing savings from the reorganization and efficiency program, which will ramp up over the coming quarters and ought to hit the full run rate in Q4, once every departing employee has left the payroll. As for your Fnac question: if you bear in mind that our purchase price was EUR 70 while the share price now sits at roughly EUR 45, that would imply an impairment of approximately EUR 200 million. Do keep in mind, though, that this is not guidance relevant for us. I believe that addresses your question.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#32

No, no, no. On the country question, that's still unresolved. You were looking for some detail on the countries — where do we stand? First, I think in Spain, Karin and I were recently in Barcelona, there to review our Spanish organization. I think at last we're seeing a team that is genuinely committed to carrying out the transformation systematically, step by step — in category management, in rolling out systems, in logistics. But it's going to take time. They're doing — they had run the pilot stores. They've learned a great deal from that. They've begun cutting assortments quite substantially. You'll hear about that at the Capital Markets Day. We'll provide a lot more detail on that. And we also had a very strong Black Friday. And again, that's rather what I mentioned a moment ago regarding price pressure, the period after Black Friday, and what emerges from it. But Spain, I'd say, is on track. Italy is essentially on track as well. We've seen the same thing there as I described earlier — the good Black Friday and then this fierce response from certain competitors. Poland and the Netherlands are 2 weak countries.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#33

On the Netherlands point, you're spot on in saying we ran into trouble — the trouble came from doing three things at once: opening a new warehouse, switching logistics provider, and bringing in an IT system, a new IT system. Even so, it simply didn't come together. Things are somewhat better at this point. The logistics provider is performing far better, and cooperation is functioning. The system is likewise falling into place. So it's functioning. A great deal of training is underway right now so people can live with the change processes. And third, on the warehouse, we are step by step filling the new warehouse, essentially with the goods we — and for that, we have — that we bring into the central logistics structure in the Netherlands. Through that, we can now also offer a scheduled delivery, which mattered enormously, which we couldn't test, and we were unable to supply over the — in the last month. At present we're in a position where we can even schedule delivery for the next day, a huge improvement relative to the past. Yet it will still take some time before we have convinced the customer so that we can deliver, because we disappointed the customers last year, and now the trust of our customers has to be regained.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#34

Poland is another tricky situation as well. So we’re putting measures in place to push higher-margin products and services — and services in particular — and to align the incentive structure for our store staff accordingly. So essentially, we’re trying to get our people to really focus on these. We rolled out a pricing tool in Poland in December, because a pricing tool is extremely important right now, especially with the kind of fierce price competition we have in the market, so that we know exactly where our market stands, where the price situation is and how we should react to it. So it was introduced in December. So they have to learn how to work with it, and I think we can gradually see some benefits from their learnings. We’re also working on measures to improve stock availability and — what is it now, what else? We’re also looking to bring the web platform we have in Germany and roll it out into Poland, because we’ve seen in Germany that the web platform is a much faster process. Response time, 4x faster than it was before. So we have to solve that too, because website traffic matters for Poland as well. And then we can also do some more, work some more with a media budget in line with our online — for the online business.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#35

That covers the key countries, I believe. In each of them, we're focused on specific actions we need to carry out in order to deliver. That's our job.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#36

That's really helpful. That leaves only the final question. Did the improving trend you mentioned at the end of Q4 carry on through January so far?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#37

Please — this is only part of it — I hope you realize that right now we aren't looking at the Q or at how things develop further.

Operator

operator
#38

Our next question is from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#39

I have a couple of questions. First, Karin, from how you described gross margin movement in that geography, I get the sense between the lines that it's reasonable to assume Germany's gross margin improved. And therefore, at the group net level, it was only minus 10 basis points. I'm just wondering whether this positive trend in Germany's gross margin should carry on through the rest of the year. Then the next question is for you, Mr. Düttmann. I fully grasp what you said regarding the Netherlands and Poland, where you're taking some measures. Can you give us a sense of when you expect the situation there to stabilize from your side?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#40

That's correct — gross margin in Germany came in a bit higher. We've been seeing a favorable trend there, and ideally that favorable trend will continue through the remainder of the financial year, driven largely — or driven mostly — by how our Services & Solutions business develops and its rate of growth.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#41

Fabienne, about the Netherlands and Poland, what’s the trend? Like I mentioned earlier, once you let customers down, you’ve got to persuade them all over again that you’ve improved. That isn’t something you can do overnight. It’s a difficult thing, and we need to recognize that. That’s simply how it is, but if you put yourself in their shoes, when you’ve been disappointed by the market, it takes a while before you go back there or before you’re ready to change your mind. And I believe that’s why we can’t simply claim we disappointed people last year and now we’re essentially back to normal. No, it’s — we have to earn our way back through dedicated work to reach the former situation we were in.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#42

But that's the Netherlands we're talking about, right — not Poland?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#43

Sorry — what was your question again? Was that about the Netherlands rather than Poland?

Fabienne Caron

executive
#44

No, no. What I'm getting at is that I get it — you let a customer in the Netherlands down, and that's going to take time. In Poland, though, I'd say it was more about the company specifically, yes.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#45

You're right about that. In the Netherlands, this is going to take a while. So we'll — only step by step will we see the shift happen. As for Poland, it's up for our — that's — no, I'd rather not make a projection there, because as you noted, we've rolled out tools into Poland. We've worked on measures, but I can't say how much, how fast, how quickly the transformation will go or how quickly using these tools will help improve the business. There's no glass ball in front of me that would really let me say that. On that point, I'd just say I think it took too long. It truly took too long. Unfortunately, last year we didn't have Poland on our map, even though we could already see the slight deterioration at the beginning of the year. We didn't have it on our map for immediate measures to take on. And unfortunately, that turned out worse. And we just need — the important thing is we — Poland is still a dynamic market, and we need to grow as fast as the market. And for that reason, we have to improve on several things in Poland. And as I said already, online business is a part of it.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#46

And I mentioned the work we're doing online, but I don't want to make any commitment here, because we've begun with the initiatives and with the action plans — but please, no commitment here.

Operator

operator
#47

Tushar Jain from Goldman Sachs has the next question.

Tushar Jain

analyst
#48

I have a few questions of my own. First, regarding bundling and services, I'm just trying to get a handle on this: do you see a somewhat outsized impact around Black Friday? Order growth was more or less broadly steady across the quarter, and is that the kind of run rate we should expect? That's my first point. Second, when it comes to pricing across different regions, I mean, there are some operational inefficiencies there that clearly can be restored. But do you think you also need to put investment into pricing in some of the regions that are struggling? And last, inventory came in higher. I just wanted to understand how — I mean, are you at ease with where inventory stands? Hello?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#49

Yes, we’re still here, Tushar. Well, actually, on your question about services and online — and online growth during the Black Friday period in the first quarter. I mean, yes, in Q1, online was more or less stable, with a growth rate of 4.3%. But please keep in mind — or what you need to know is that we saw pretty good online growth during the Black Friday period, as Bernhard already described. But we also saw a pull-forward effect in December, and that led to the fact that, in summary, the growth rate ended up at 4.3% in the online business. But still, I mean, Services & Solutions growth of 10% in Q1 is a very good one in my mind. And as Bernhard also mentioned, I mean, we’ve seen a big increase in the Services & Solutions business based on the fact that we saw bundles during the Black Friday period.

Tushar Jain

analyst
#50

Just to clarify that point, then. So the bundles end up having a somewhat outsized impact around Black Friday, but for the remainder of the year the run rate might be far lower? That's really what I'm attempting to gauge.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#51

No, no, no. That’s not how I’d put it. That’s not how I’d put it, Tushar. What happened is — what we did in the prior year, and I’ve already mentioned this to you, is that we’re building the fundamentals into services. So we said we clearly have offerings at our SmartBars. We secured a new contract for insurance for guarantee plus. So we laid the basis — the foundation — already in the prior year. So in Q4, we could observe that it was rising across the board. In Q1, it was very strong. In every country, we could observe double-digit growth rates on services. So we are finally getting there. People — take it in all regions — they work on the concept of selling services to the customers. So certainly, we had a Black Friday — we had a peak. Yes, we had a peak because it was a peak day anyway. But generally, the concept is now being understood that we are really going for services and also executing it in all regions.

Tushar Jain

analyst
#52

Understood.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#53

Pardon me?

Tushar Jain

analyst
#54

Okay, that’s helpful. Turning to inventory.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#55

Right. On inventories — yes, they went up by EUR 119 million in Q1. The main drivers were demand pulled forward around Black Friday and then weaker sales in December, so that's one reason. The other is that we acquired a logistics hub in Sweden, and that hub had previously been run by an outside service provider. Those are the 2 main reasons you're seeing inventory higher. That said, we're fully aware of it, and we're putting measures in place to bring inventory down next quarter.

Tushar Jain

analyst
#56

That makes sense.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#57

On the rising price question—you asked about pricing across different regions and whether we need to put money into prices. Of course, we watch the markets and their price levels closely. Competition is intense when it comes to pricing, with very low earnings. So we've also partly wrestled with this question: these competitors—or this competitor—who is basically earning almost nothing or operating at a loss and offering the lowest prices, how long will they keep undercutting prices in the market? That's the question. To some degree, our price analytics let us see that coming, and we have to respond. That's what we'll do. For that reason, we also made it clear in our guidance right from the start that we anticipate ongoing pressure on product prices. But we intend to offset it, and that's why the service solution impact matters so much—we want to offset it increasingly through Services & Solutions.

Tushar Jain

analyst
#58

Understood. May I ask a broader question? As you look back over the quarter, with a solid Black Friday performance offset by Christmas, do you think it’s probably — I’m not sure whether it’s a better approach to be less aggressive during Black Friday and achieve proper sell-through, or during the Christmas period? Or I’m just wondering whether you have any hindsight reflections on that strategy you put in place last year?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#59

Consider it for a moment — we wouldn't take part in Black Friday. Just picture that. What would be the result?

Tushar Jain

analyst
#60

No, no. What I'm saying is that from this point on there's going to be less. I realize that's a really hard position to hold as we head into Black Friday.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#61

Our Black Friday campaign was run selectively — very selectively. We didn't apply it across the board. So it was steered in a selective way. And I think that's also a very good approach.

Operator

operator
#62

That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer session. I'll now turn things over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations, for some closing remarks.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#63

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings today's results call to a close. Thanks for spending your time with us and for your questions. As always, if anything else comes up, don't hesitate to reach out to us at Investor Relations. We look forward to speaking with you. Take care, and bye-bye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.