Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 13, 2020

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 64 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, we appreciate you holding. Thank you for being with us, and welcome to the CECONOMY AG conference call for investors and analysts. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll hand the call over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations. You may proceed.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Q3 Results Call. Joining me today are our CEO, Bernhard Düttmann; our CFO, Karin Sonnenmoser; and Ferran Reverter, CEO of the MediaMarktSaturn Retail Group. They'll walk you through today's presentation. Before we begin, let me quickly take care of the usual formalities. First, please note that this call is being recorded. A replay will be posted on our website later today. Second, please bear in mind that today's presentation and possibly some of the answers to your questions in the Q&A session may include forward-looking statements. For more details on that, please see the disclaimer. Well, with that, let me turn things over to our CEO. Please go ahead.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the call. As our trading statement made clear, we're reflecting on a third quarter that has been exceptional in numerous respects. I'll begin today's presentation by emphasizing the way we steered through this difficult period. I'd say we managed that well. And in the end, the third quarter turned out stronger than our original expectations. Ferran will afterward provide some detail on how our strategic areas are progressing. He'll also offer perspective on yesterday's news about our new operating model, which is going to be rolled out across the whole company. Karin will, as always, take you through the quarterly financials and the outlook for the full year. Finally, we will of course close with the customary Q&A session. Ladies and gentlemen, when we last spoke in mid-May, we had only just begun reopening our stores following weeks of lockdown. At that moment, it was unclear how quickly consumers would return to our stores and what their shopping pattern would look like. I'm delighted to say that our business bounced back very quickly. Another way to put it is that we were able to hit the ground running once the lockdown was lifted.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#4

So really, we picked back up the solid momentum we’d seen during the first 5 months prior to corona. As stores started reopening from mid-May onward, activity accelerated rapidly. Thanks to thorough planning throughout the lockdown period, every measure we needed was ready so customers could shop safely. Footfall in our stores stayed below the prior year, but higher conversion and a larger checkout value made up for that. Put simply, fewer shoppers visited, yet those who did arrived with a specific purchase in mind. Meanwhile, the pronounced move toward our online sales channel persisted across every country. The encouraging part is that the robust sales momentum from June carried right on into July. In fact, it is still strong as of today. Consumers definitely have us top of mind. That said, we expect the demand-shift effect to fade gradually. We’re also staying cautious about the macro outlook in key markets throughout Europe. Even so, with every appropriate caveat, the favorable trend since lockdown ended is heartening and leaves us feeling upbeat about the business ahead. Chart 6 sums up how we see the quarter. In our view, the positives are plainly greater in number and carry more weight than the negatives.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#5

Thanks to the strength of our omnichannel business and careful preparation, we managed to move quickly and take advantage of the loosening of COVID-19 restrictions. Our proactive handling of the crisis also bore fruit. The steps we took to mitigate the crisis played a major part in producing a Q3 result that beat expectations. At the same time, we encountered some pressure on gross margin, largely from the shift toward online and from lower revenues in service and solutions, though fortunately this is easing month by month. Beyond that, we've observed a deterioration in the age structure of our inventories as a result of our stores being locked down. To close out the third quarter, let's briefly review our headline figures. On Slide 7, you can see that despite more than 6 weeks of widespread store closures — that's half of the quarter — sales adjusted for currency and portfolio effects declined by only 8.4%. Adjusted EBIT, excluding associates, was minus EUR 45 million, which is in line with prior year's level. Ladies and gentlemen, COVID-19 has brought an enormous amount of disruption to the retail industry and to all of us. I take pride in how our teams at CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn responded with determination and promptness. They devoted enormous time and energy to steering the company successfully through this unprecedented crisis.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#6

Meanwhile, our strategic initiatives stayed firmly on our radar. Tangible progress continued to be made. In a moment, Ferran will walk you through several recent accomplishments. As you might expect, given all the COVID restrictions, the primary emphasis during the last quarter was on digital growth. There, our attention went to quick wins so we could respond to the market right away, while also pursuing more strategic initiatives that will strengthen our online business going forward. For instance, our goal is to drive Services & Solutions further within our online business as well. Centralization of processes continues to be essential to our initiatives and our strategic direction. We are presently midway through the transformation. That is why we cannot delay any further in rolling out a streamlined and identical organization across all countries. We have standardized processes that are uniform throughout the entire business. That is the reason we are now introducing a new operating model. It will let us become faster and more customer oriented. During COVID, with only small agile teams working under a strict protocol, we had a good experience in gaining speed with standardized processes. We will now implement these across the entire countries and our whole business. That is all from my side — so Ferran, please go ahead, continue and talk about our details and the new model.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#7

Thanks, Bernhard, and good morning from me as well. Without question, over the past months we kept achieving visible progress across every strategic initiative. That demonstrates we remain on track and deliver on our promises, even during exceptional times. Allow me to walk you through in a bit more detail what we accomplished in the third quarter, starting with omnichannel. Above all, we delivered a strong online performance, with nearly 3 million newly registered online customers since March. That robust online growth was also fueled by our heightened emphasis on online marketing. Whereas online marketing represented 30% to 40% of our total net investment prior to COVID-19, today that figure stands at 60% to 70%, and most of this online marketing spending is performance-based, carrying very attractive returns. As a move into new business models, we launched our own marketplace in July, and we are quite happy with the early momentum and the strong interest coming from the seller community. Store traffic clearly took a hit from corona during the third quarter. Yet traffic is now recovering step-by-step, and pickup rates are already back above 40%. Inside our stores, we have achieved a significant efficiency gain thanks to our new employee app.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#8

With this new app, our employees can access all the relevant information right on their smartphone, which lets them serve customers better and faster. The time needed for a sale or for preparing a pickup drops by 1/3. That frees up considerable capacity. The rollout of this new app is complete in Germany, and we will finally roll it out across every one of our markets. And don't forget, we've begun preparing for the rebranding in Austria and Luxembourg, where our Saturn stores and the Saturn online channel will become MediaMarkt by the end of this calendar year. Given the specific situation in these 2 countries, concentrating on 1 strong brand is the right path there. In Germany, where we operate more than 150 Saturn stores, we intend to keep our 2 brand approach. In Services & Solutions, sales in June have recovered to the prior year level. Once again, our new employee app has supported this. Sales with the app carry a 25 higher attachment rate that is quite significant -- which is quite significant. Our sales have improved as well thanks to usability measures we've taken in our online channels. We've implemented the technical ability to build services as monthly subscriptions, in our online channel too, and we've launched our warranty extension Guarantee Plus as a monthly subscription service in Germany.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#9

The ability to offer monthly subscription plans is going to be extended to every channel and market we operate in, and it will serve as an important driver of future growth. We've also finished deploying our IT platform for after sales and repair in Germany. With this platform, we can deliver those services far more efficiently and in a way that's friendlier to customers. And right after the platform went live, our Net Promoter Score in aftersales improved straight away. When it comes to category and supply chain management, we've now put in place a standardized assortment and supplier framework for every country. Over time, this is going to deliver substantial benefits. On procurement, our centralization approach has moved further ahead. In Germany we're now at 90% centralized procurement, and across the group at country level we're above 95% centralized procurement. We're far more efficient today, with greater transparency and control. On top of that, we've kicked off several new category pilots — solar in Spain and health and wellness in Germany, for instance — and we expect substantial potential from these categories as we move forward. In logistics, we keep rolling out what we call our omnichannel spine, aimed at creating 1 stock across every channel and border. And our efforts to improve the customer experience are progressing steadily.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#10

Take Germany and Benelux, for instance — right now over 80% of our parcels already arrive the following day. When it comes to how we're organized and our cost structures, we keep working to make those costs more flexible. A key lever there is rental agreements, and we've managed to put turnover-based rents in place, particularly whenever new leases are signed. On that basis, our typical lease runs about 3 years. Those benefits will be captured gradually as time goes on. Finally, and this matters, we're rolling out a new operating model, which is a major step in taking our company further. It will serve as the organizational foundation for how we move ahead. I'll go into that in greater detail shortly. So we accomplished quite a bit over the past month, and we've learned a great deal too. Through corona, we showed our ability to respond quickly when conditions change fundamentally. Our agile, group-wide contingency approach turned out to be highly effective and successful. We're now prepared to take the next big step toward becoming a very efficient company that consistently puts customers first. We will now bring in a new operating model and thereby speed up our transformation process even more. We're glad that both shareholders — CECONOMY and the family Kellerhals, owner of Convergenta — back the concept and the program behind the new operating model.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#11

What our new operating model does is bring standardization and harmonization to structures and processes throughout the whole company. That covers administrative functions in our countries and also how our stores are organized. It also involves a new way of working together between our holding in Ingolstadt and the headquarters in each individual country. Across Europe, we'll harmonize management structures in our 1,000 stores and align store formats company-wide. And very importantly, administrative task will move from the stores to the headquarters of our countries. That also helps us support further standardization of key processes, such as in category management, procurement or logistics. Above all, though, we make sure our colleagues on-site can concentrate on what really matters, our customers. We'll establish group-wide unified structures with clear responsibilities for strategic guidelines, standard design and execution of activities. Every one of our countries will have the same leadership structure with the same departments, which facilitates seamless collaboration across our company. Beyond that, we will form regional clusters and bring together Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg to form the Benelux region. The Iberia region, Spain and Portugal, we had already merged beforehand. In our stores, everything will be focused on the best possible customer orientation.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#12

On top of setting up an efficient, uniform management organization, we're reinforcing our steady customer focus through additional steps. Through the Passion For Customer initiative, we're putting money into our people. We give them a dedicated training program so they can deliver outstanding customer service. Specifically, our aim is to further raise the service quality and the advising skills of our teams. The smartphones and digital tools that we equip our store colleagues with also support this effort. The employee app is a good illustration. I mentioned this subject earlier on. The guiding principle behind our operating model is straightforward: secure maximum customer orientation and a consistent customer experience, built on lean, unified structures and fast processes. Our path ahead also involves ongoing review and optimization of our store network throughout Europe. Responding to the effects of COVID-19, we intend to permanently shut 14 of our more than 1,000 stores. Over the next few months, the count of European stores could dip a bit more. To prevent any misunderstanding, these are individual cases. We mean those stores where, given COVID-19, there's no foreseeable way we'll be profitable within a reasonable timeframe.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#13

Our stores are and will stay our greatest asset. They form the heart of this company and sit at the center of our omnichannel model, even in a post-corona world. So the focus is less on closures and more on optimization. That covers rightsizing along with ongoing flexibilization of rental costs. By the way, rightsizing means more than just less space. It is about aligning the sale floor correctly with each respective store format. Above all, we will put investment into making our stores more attractive. We have set a clear goal for this. We will use our store network as the ultimate showroom, with immediate availability, and for Click and Collect fulfillment. To reach this goal, we will expand the services and experience areas for our customers. We will boost the visibility of particularly strong brands, and we will further strengthen our pickup points. On top of that, we will keep introducing new store formats. Just in the last few weeks, we opened 2 concept stores in Italy, and the next opening is scheduled for Cologne — the so-called will be inaugurated in early September. This store focuses on E-gaming. Ladies and gentlemen, to put it in a nutshell, by implementing our new operating model and optimizing our store network, we will gain speed and quality.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#14

We're going to boost competitiveness across the whole company, including our subsidiaries and our stores, in a lasting way. We'll ensure shoppers throughout Europe get an appealing and consistent omnichannel experience at MediaMarktSaturn. A lean, efficient organizational setup will additionally deliver considerable cost savings. Implementing the new operating model together with the selected store closures is expected to produce lasting savings of a bit over EUR 100 million annually. For the next financial year we anticipate only a limited earnings contribution, though savings should pick up substantially in financial year '21/'22. Come financial year '22/'23, we expect the bulk of the anticipated savings to be realized. One-time costs to execute the program come to roughly EUR 180 million. A substantial portion of those costs should still hit earnings in the current fiscal year. Rolling out the new operational model and reviewing our store network also brings job adjustments. Unfortunately, that can't be avoided. Over the next 2 to 3 years, across the company, as many as 3,500 full-time positions could be cut, mainly in our foreign European countries. Choices like these are never simple to make. As a responsible company, we'll handle these matters with decency, professionalism and in line with social standards in the best sense, just as we have done previously.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#15

I want to be very clear about this. Every decision we take rests on thorough analysis and has a very clear purpose. We came out on top, and we will turn into an even stronger company in every single respect. So this is not a matter of a straightforward cost-reduction initiative. What we are discussing is how we move ahead. The new operating model provides the organizational foundation for the coming stage of our transformation. We have a clear plan, and I would like to sketch it only briefly right now. Put simply, our company's strategic development proceeds along 3 main directions. First, we pursue growth. So we will keep reinforcing our core business. We will grow online, move into new categories such as health care and solar, and link that with the new income pools. That also means, for instance, that we will enter new business models like our own marketplace. Second, quality matters. So we will keep reinforcing our key differentiators. We are the category authority. We are relying on our omnichannel model, and we believe in our people. They are what makes the difference. Third, we want to pick up speed. Our new operating model will make efficient operations possible, and we will put technology and big data to even better use.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#16

So that means we're looking to extract more value from the data we hold ourselves — data on our segmented customer groups — and we'll pair that with stronger data analytics capability. We're going to turn into a smart retailer driven by data. Ladies and gentlemen, behind these 3 strategic dimensions sit a great many individual projects. We'll carry them out with real consistency so that we can meet our ambition of being customers' first choice. That's the path we're taking. We haven't arrived at our destination yet, though we're well on the way. That's all from me. Thank you. Karin, over to you now.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#17

I appreciate that, Ferran, and good morning everyone joining the call. As we typically do, I’ll walk you through the quarterly figures in detail. To begin, let’s examine how sales developed as shown on Chart 18. On a currency and portfolio-adjusted basis, sales fell 8.4% compared with the prior year. That decline stems entirely from COVID-19 lockdowns across most of the countries where we operate. In the DACH region, currency-adjusted sales dropped 7.3%. This came about because of lower sales in Germany, Austria and Switzerland caused by COVID-19 related store closures in April and, in part, May. Once restrictions were eased during May, sales across these countries bounced back, helped as well by catch-up effects. Momentum improved even more in June. In Western and Southern Europe, currency and portfolio-adjusted sales declined 9.9%. Spain was hit especially hard because of store closures in April and the restrictions that followed on floor space and products. Sales in Italy also fell sharply following the closure. Even so, recovery was already apparent once stores reopened in May. The Netherlands did not enter a full lockdown, so it posted a strong sales increase in the third quarter. That was driven in particular by substantial growth in the online business, which also reflects a low comparison base.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#18

For Eastern Europe, sales adjusted for currency fell 11.1%, which came from shutting stores in Poland and Turkey during April. In Turkey, locations stayed shut through the entire month of May as well. Thanks to reopening later and the strong catch-up effects that followed, Turkey posted high double-digit growth rates during June. Within the Others segment, the drop in sales stems entirely from the divestment of iBood in the prior financial year. Sweden, where no closures occurred, delivered a strong sales performance, with double-digit growth rates. That also reflects the restructuring and repositioning work we began in Sweden. Ladies and gentlemen, given that our stores were shut for at least 6 weeks during the third quarter and certain countries still face limits on space and opening hours, this counts as a very positive development under difficult circumstances. And a few countries, such as Austria and Turkey, even show positive year-to-date sales growth after 9 months. Given the unprecedented situation in Q3, we decided to give you extra transparency on how our monthly business developed. The upper diagram displays year-on-year sales development from January through June. CECONOMY stayed on its growth path until February, before COVID-19 began hitting the business, with a 28% sales decline in March and a 43% decrease in April.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#19

I want to point out that we essentially succeeded in retaining nearly 60% of what we sold in April 2019. On top of that, an average of 86% of our European stores were shut. A huge jump in online business drove this result, and it stems from the strong, nimble digital capabilities built into our powerful omnichannel model. As the diagram in the middle illustrates, total online sales climbed 58% in March and were more than three times higher in April. On the right-hand side of the page, the speed of the rebound is emphasized. Sales picked up steam quickly, rising 3% year-on-year in May and 12% in June. Reopening stores in every market helped us. Meanwhile, online growth stayed high and steady even as stores gradually reopened, including in countries where the stationary business was never closed. Since we are on the subject of the sales recovery, let me share some detail on how we are trading right now. The patterns we saw in June have carried into July and the first days of August. Even so, we continue to anticipate that sales momentum will ease during Q4, since we expect demand catch-up effects to fade out gradually.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#20

Now let's zoom in a bit on the online and Services & Solutions operations, which you can see on Slide 20 (sic) Slide 21. During Q3, our online sales climbed 145% compared with a year earlier, reaching EUR 1.4 billion. As a proportion of overall sales, that went from 13% in the same period last year up to 35%. We kept reinforcing where we stand in online, and since March we've brought in close to 3 million new online shoppers through our webshops throughout Europe. Roughly 32% of all orders placed online were collected in the stores. Part of the reason the pickup rate fell year-on-year is that the pickup option wasn't fully available at stores that were closed during April. On top of that, given the lockdown, customers made less use of the ability to collect online orders at the stores. Once stores reopened, it was encouraging to see the pickup rate bounce back during June. By then it had already returned to 43%. It won't surprise anyone that store closures and generally weaker footfall, together with restrictions inside stores after reopening, weighed on our Services & Solutions business. With no access to stores, customers couldn't take advantage of the popular in-store services at our Smartbars.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#21

When it comes to online, service attachment rates tend to be lower. That drove a 17.8% drop in the Services & Solutions business in Q3. Near the end of the quarter, though, Services & Solutions sales started to bounce back, so that by June sales had already returned to the prior year's level. Let's turn now to Slide 21 (sic) Slide 22 for a look at gross margin, OpEx and EBIT. Because of COVID-19, our adjusted gross margin fell by 260 basis points to 16.1% in the third quarter. Several effects caused this. Strong performance in our online business, and especially the shift away from the store option, pushed logistic costs higher. We also saw the product mix change during the lockdown period. Demand from customers for home office solutions and TVs, for instance, rose, while demand for higher-margin categories such as white goods declined. On top of that, lower Services & Solutions income weighed on gross margin as well. On the positive side, it's worth noting that we saw a sequential improvement in the gross margin trend from April to June, largely thanks to the recovery of store sales.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#22

We were able to offset the weaker gross margin in Q3 by moving fast on the cost side. As Bernhard touched on briefly, we quickly rolled out significant contingency actions. Those encompassed short time work compensation for our employees, along with cuts to marketing spend and location costs. Over half of those savings took effect in April by itself, when roughly 86% of our stores had to close because of the COVID-19 restrictions and more than 30,000 employees and the crew were on the short time work scheme. As stores started reopening and sales began recovering, we also brought down the count of employees on the short time work scheme, and those COVID-19 related cost savings shrank. Still, at the same time, we keep gaining from continuing savings tied to last year's reorganization and efficiency program. We cut costs by approximately EUR 185 million in effective terms, the bulk of which are personnel cost savings. Because of the cost measures just described and the sales recovery in May and June, we were able to fully offset the COVID-19 induced drop in sales and gross margin. With that, we achieved an adjusted EBIT at the prior year level. Turning to earnings development by segment, the DACH region posted a slightly positive adjusted EBIT, supported by a solid performance in Germany.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#23

Those cost savings played an obvious and essential role in delivering this result. For the remaining DACH nations, earnings matched the prior-year figure. Adjusted EBIT in Western and Southern Europe fell to minus EUR 30 million. Spain posted a substantial drop in earnings, caused by weaker sales and margins — chiefly reflecting reduced income in the Services & Solutions business. COVID-19 likewise drove a steep earnings decline in Italy. The Netherlands, by contrast, moved slightly positive, helped by robust sales performance and cost reduction. Within Eastern Europe, the downturn stems entirely from weaker earnings in Poland. Turkey delivered a stable result even with the sales disruption COVID-19 caused during the third quarter. In the Others segment, earnings rose versus the prior year, supported by gains in Sweden and reduced center cost at CECONOMY AG. We'll turn now to Slide 23 (sic) Slide 24, which sets out the bridge from adjusted to reported EBIT. Reported EBIT for the third quarter was minus EUR 64 million. Given the drop in customer frequencies at stationary business stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic, we had already made the decision to permanently shut 14 stores across Europe.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#24

Ferran has already covered this. The reported EBIT figure contains nonrecurring items of roughly negative EUR 19 million, stemming from asset impairments tied to the store closures mentioned earlier. Looking at the 9-month period, nonrecurring FX comes to a gain of EUR 9 million. As a result, training costs, restructuring expenses, and costs for the store closures already decided upon were entirely offset by the Greek transaction gain that was booked in Q1. Now let's turn to the bridge from EBIT to EPS on Slide 24 (sic) Slide 25. Bear in mind that the reported figures we see now also incorporate the IFRS 16 effects for the current period. The net financial result came in lower than a year ago, chiefly because of the interest component recognized for our operating leases under IFRS 16, along with expenses for loan and commitment fees connected to the syndicated loans. In addition, the prior-year financial result had the benefit of the sale of the 5.4 percentage METRO stake. Turning to taxes: we reported a higher tax expense in the third quarter, which stems from the integral tax approach we apply. Over the 9-month period, the tax rate was minus 54.5%. That is essentially just a technical figure.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#25

The negative tax rate basically stems from the Fnac Darty impairment. As you may remember, for this financial year, with the situation as it is and the Fnac Darty impairment, we anticipate the tax rate will be distorted. For upcoming financial years, though, our expectation remains that the underlying tax rate will move toward 35%. Overall, earnings per share fell by EUR 0.16, to minus EUR 0.29, in the third quarter. Now shifting from earnings to cash flow. Free cash flow for the first 9 months came in at EUR 27 million, which is EUR 547 million higher than the prior year period. That increase, however, is mostly tied to IFRS 16 adoption. When we look at lease-adjusted free cash flow, which deducts repayment of lease liabilities so that free cash flow is more comparable under IFRS 16, we observe a year-on-year rise of EUR 149 million. This gain is mainly driven by low cash taxes, thanks to refunds connected with prepayments made in the previous year, which produced a cash inflow. In addition, comparatively fewer tax prepayments were made. VAT payments were also deferred as a COVID-19 restriction, and that had a positive effect on other operating cash flow. We have seen a rise in cash investments as well.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#26

Let me make sure this is clear. The rise here stems from the additional cash effective investment into the joint venture during the first quarter. Spending on modernization and expansion was distinctly lower than in the same period a year earlier. Because of how the corona crisis affected the business, plant modernizations and new openings were put on hold. For the whole year, our expectation now is that CapEx will come in at roughly 1% of total sales. Now let's turn to the outlook. Based on how business developed across the first 9 months and what we know at this moment, we have chosen to narrow the outlook for this financial year further. Our outlook presumes no additional COVID-19-related restrictions in Q4 that might once more affect the business. As for fourth-quarter sales, allow me to reiterate that I'm happy to report the positive sales trend seen from June carried on seamlessly through July, thanks in particular to the VAT reduction in Germany and sustained strong demand for home office, home schooling and home entertainment products. Even so, we continue to expect sales momentum to soften as Q4 progresses, since pent-up demand from the lockdown period will likely fade out. There is, in addition, considerable uncertainty surrounding the short-term macro landscape, which we have to take into account.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#27

When it comes to margin, we anticipate some lingering corona-related headwinds in Q4. We might also see certain effects from a partial reduction of old stock, since some goods that went unsold during the lockdown have aged. And regarding costs, we clearly anticipate a considerably lower level of COVID-19 related cost savings, because, for instance, nearly all short time work schemes came to an end in Q3. Let's examine how those assumptions feed into the outlook for the current financial year. Building on the recovery seen during the third quarter, for full year 2019/'20, we now anticipate just a slight decline in ForEx adjusted sales versus the previous year. As we announced with our trading statement, adjusted EBIT is expected to land at between EUR 165 million to EUR 185 million. That figure is anticipated to include a positive effect of between EUR 5 million and EUR 15 million stemming from the introduction of IFRS 16. Given the historic crisis we have confronted and successfully managed over the past month, I think this is a solid outlook for the full year. That's all from my side, and I hand over to you, Bernhard.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#28

To close out today's call, ladies and gentlemen, let me give a brief summary. In my view, the crisis we faced was genuinely severe. In fact, for MediaMarktSaturn it was the harshest crisis imaginable, since store closures — the core pillar of our business — are something that should never occur. And we endured that for more than 6 weeks during the last quarter. Yet we proved we could act throughout the crisis. Our omnichannel business model has shown itself to be extremely robust and successful. As you saw, we took a KfW loan as insurance against a possible second wave of COVID, but we never drew on it. And we managed to repay nearly all of our own bank loans. So we are coming through this crisis in far better shape than we had expected. That is because we managed to ramp up our online business. Looking back a couple of quarters, I believe none of you would have guessed we could supply 60% of monthly sales through our online channel alone. At the same time, we showed you today that we have made further progress in our strategic areas.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#29

To speed up our transformation, we're going to put in place a leaner organization now, with standardized processes applied consistently across the whole of Europe. That forms the foundation for driving and executing the strategy. The major job ahead is figuring out how consumers will adjust to the new retail world and what we can expect when it comes to future habits. For instance, we anticipate that online shopping will stay at a higher level than it was before the pandemic. Other behaviors might fade away as things return to the new normal. Right now we're analyzing the shifting consumer landscape, and we'll factor the relevant conclusions into our strategy update. But in fact, we don't yet know how the market will evolve. Naturally, we will reschedule our Capital Markets Day as soon as circumstances permit — and by that I mean once we have some certainty about how the markets will look in the future. With that, I'd like to wrap up today's presentation. Thank you, everyone, for your attention. I'll now hand the call over to the operator for your questions.

Operator

operator
#30

<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Volker Bosse at Baader Bank.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#31

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank: I'd like to begin with the transformation process. The transformation steps you announced are welcome. But as I understand it, centralization, harmonization and process efficiency have always been on the agenda. So how should I read your announcement up to now? Are you finally starting to do what you've always talked about, so to speak? Or was COVID-19 in that regard a kind of wake-up call that now shows you the urgency of really getting this transformation process started? And connected to that, the 3,500 employees who will be cut: why is it materializing, so to speak, only in 24 to 36 months? That seems to be quite a long way off. And the 14 stores you announced would be reduced — I mean, you have 1,000 stores. That's nearly 1% of stores. To me it seems like a normalized adjustment rather than a meaningful cut that is really worth mentioning in an ad hoc announcement. So, to get more clarity on the background here. And perhaps finally, on the costs tied to the transformation process, the EUR 180 million you mention — a significant portion will be booked this year, meaning in the fourth quarter — so can we then expect an amount of EUR 60 million to EUR 100 million in one-off costs in the fourth quarter?

Volker Bosse

analyst
#32

Volker, I'll take those questions, and I'll begin with them. You raised the transformation process. Those steps have always been on the agenda. What you say is extremely correct. That's correct. So what's different? Last year we began the efficiency and reorganization project in Germany, reorganizing the entire business there. This time — and we also built tools that we need in order to centralize and to standardize — we're now taking this approach across Europe. So that's number one. Number 2 is that you asked what happens at the stores. Yes, you're right. Already last year, we removed some administrative function from the stores. But now, with purchasing more centralized, we have a completely new setup in the stores, because we can refocus the stores entirely on customer attention. And for that reason, it's a different approach. Ferran talked about the mystore app. The mystore app is crucial for bringing digital tools and new processes into the stores, so that we can run the stores much better and have more — with more productivity.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#33

And that is exactly why, only now that this tool is in place, we're able to make this type of change and adjustment in the stores — meaning, first, removing more administrative work, since there's no purchasing left in the stores. So that's a completely different situation from before. And second, leading the sales staff in the stores, backing them up with the dedicated tools they've been given, which lets us generate far more efficiency. So that's why we're taking on these processes now and have reached this point. I can also give you — I can paint a picture. In some countries, we had two management functions at the country management level, with the online and marketing people reporting to 1 person. In a second country, it wasn't online and marketing — it was supply chain and online reporting to that team, to the management function. So this was thoroughly mixed across the countries. And there we introduce complete order with a new model, so that we have an identical organization. And through that, we can harmonize the working teams much better as well, and that was an exercise we already carried out during the COVID-19 lockdown, when the online teams held daily calls about experiences, what's running nicely, what's running well, and how we improve our online business to really ramp it up in a short time with a high impact.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#34

And for that, at the time it wasn't really that hard, since a lot of others were on short labor, so you could group it. But these days we essentially organize the companies — the country organizations — according to the same blueprint we use in Ingolstadt. The second question was why it takes so long. Any time we do some kind of reorganization, we have to prepare for it. That means talking to works councils in the countries. And as you know, as of September, we're concentrating purely on the business for the Christmas season, for the year-end season. So we'll be in preparation now to get things going, but execution will only begin — basically — after the year-end season. And then we'll ramp up quickly. And — but that's the main reason why we — I'd say, we'll have savings next year, but predominantly most of the savings will come the year after. About the store closures, yes, that's right. We're talking here about 14 stores, which isn't a lot. That's true. But we said we will — as we said, clearly, we'll also review the existing stores that aren't profitable at this point in time, we'll carefully look at how customer demand will shift and whether we'll be able, with all measures we have in place, to bring them back to profitability.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#35

If we don't act, a second wave will come, and for store closures that wave might even be larger. So this is the initial step in which we make adjustments to these locations, with the understanding, clearly, that no measure we take will get these stores to profitability. That's why we made the call now in August — no, no, not in August, in the third quarter — during the third quarter, these stores have to be closed.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#36

Morning, Volker. You wanted to know how the program's expenses will be phased. As I said earlier, we anticipate incurring costs of roughly EUR 180 million. Let me add a bit more detail on that. About EUR 130 million relates to reorganizing stores and headquarters, while approximately EUR 50 million of the program comes from closing stores. The overall cost will therefore be made up of severance payments and wage costs during the notice period, along with expenses for remaining rental obligations and asset impairments on the closed stores. Turning to the phasing, we expect the bulk of that EUR 130 million for store and headquarter reorganization to show up in the current financial year 2019/'20. Some of this cost could, however, shift into the following financial year, but once again, we anticipate most of it in this financial year. The EUR 50 million tied to further optimization of our store network should be booked mainly in the financial year 2020/'21. So in fact, your assumption fits quite well, Volker.

Operator

operator
#37

Our next question is from Clement Genelot at Bryan Garnier.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#38

I have 3 questions on my end, if I may. First, about the rumors concerning the search for a new CEO: could you clarify what Dr. Düttmann's role will be going forward? My second question concerns traffic — in-store traffic in the Iberian peninsula. Are you already seeing, let's say, a new traffic impact from the recent restrictions put in place in both Spain and Portugal? And my third question is about store closures. So beyond the 14 store closures, you mentioned possible additional closures. In which countries should we expect such closures? Poland comes to mind, which is a tough country. But maybe I'm wrong. Clement, I'll take the first question, since you were asking about my office — how will it continue beyond this curve, or when will it end? Because I think you know that I'm delegated from the Supervisory Board. So my current term ends on October 16. And any decision on this measure is up to the Supervisory Board. I have signaled that I'm flexible. I can continue beyond October, if I can help the company.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#39

And I anticipate that the Supervisory Board will make its communication at the appropriate time.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#40

Alright, regarding Iberia. Of course, there are certain reasons behind the restrictions, particularly in special city centers. That said, let me note that if you look at sales, Spain continues to hold its momentum. Overall, the sales trend in that country is performing well. The team there is doing a good job. As for the network reduction, regarding the 14 stores, yes, we have 6 store closures in Poland, 4 in Italy, 3 in Germany, and 1 in Spain. And depending on how the trend develops, additional closures will follow across Europe too. But that has not been decided yet.

Operator

operator
#41

<<operator_script>> We have a follow-up question coming from Volker Bosse at Baader Bank.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#42

Thanks for letting me ask a second question. I'd be interested to hear where things stand with the rent-reduction talks you're having with your landlord. Have you managed to bring rents down on a permanent basis yet? Then my second question concerns store frequency. Just as a rough estimate, where would you put store frequency in your physical stores right now compared with precrisis levels, so to speak? And my third question is about Sweden: you mentioned double-digit growth rates there. Does that alter your divestment plans for Sweden? Or, given these results in hand, how do you view that process?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#43

Volker, I'll begin with what you asked about store traffic. In-store traffic has developed quite favorably, since we saw it come back steadily across Q3. It hasn't yet gotten back to where it stood a year earlier, though. That encouraging trend is also showing up in the current month. In June as well, the figures for in-store traffic remained significantly under the prior-year level. Still, it's really encouraging to see this favorable movement in our stores' traffic once more following the reopening. Another very encouraging point is that we're seeing larger baskets along with better conversion rates, and those are offsetting the softer in-store traffic in May and June. With that, I'll hand the next question to Ferran.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#44

Yes, thank you. Regarding rent renegotiations, our focus is clearly on lowering rents, but even more so on making our cost structure more flexible going forward. So as of today, we can say that turnover rent already applies to 1/3 of our contracts. And our average lease period — this matters a great deal — has come down to 3 years on average. Then there was your question about Sweden. I believe we've been clear from the start that whatever we undertake, we begin with the countries where we're carrying out our own turnaround. And we're fairly pleased with how Sweden has developed over the course of this fiscal year, since we've seen considerable progress. We're therefore gaining market share, and they've grown nicely. Even so, Sweden still has a long way to go. So for the time being, there's simply no change to the position we held before: we're working on a turnaround in that country, but there is still a way to go.

Operator

operator
#45

Amy Curry from Morgan Stanley has the next question.

Amy Curry

analyst
#46

My question concerns the supplier income agreements and the full year back margin. I was wondering whether the volume targets have been adjusted because of COVID-19. If you could give us any color on that, please.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#47

We’re still working to capture your question. I’m not sure we’ve yet gotten it framed correctly regarding the volume adjustment and the cost margin. I believe, Amy, I believe I have the question. I believe I have it. Because -- so what is being asked concerns our business volume. This year, the purchasing volume has come in below last year’s level. That is why we anticipate some trade-offs in the back margin. That is also why our Q4 guidance is somewhat cautious, since negotiations are still underway, and they will run through the end of September. For that reason, it’s -- we need to be -- we need to remain cautious. But one point is clear. I mean, and we have lowered the purchasing volume across the year. And that is the main reason we need to examine it.

Operator

operator
#48

Clement Genelot from Bryan Garnier has a follow-up question on the line.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#49

Only 1 question. You said purchasing centralization had already hit 90%. So do you believe the moment has come to take another look at your partnership with Fnac Darty?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#50

I believe we're now taking the first steps toward centralization. It's true that we're at 90%, but the category management project is still ongoing. So we aren't looking at that topic at the moment. We've always said that we focus on our internal transformation first. And in that respect, we're not done yet. We've seen the usual progress, but we've always said it's category management, it's logistics and it's systems — it's all 3 together. And only once we've achieved all of it are we basically done with it. And just the purchasing or 95% purchasing is not yet the key. So it's not yet finished.

Operator

operator
#51

We've reached the point where no more questions remain. Stephanie Ritschel, our Vice President of Investor Relations, will now take over for the closing remarks.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#52

That wraps up our results call for today, everyone. Thanks for being with us and for your questions. If anything else comes up afterward, don't hesitate to reach out to us at Investor Relations. We'll be glad to speak with you again. Take care, stay well, and goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.