Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 11, 2021

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 56 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for waiting. Welcome, and thank you for joining the CECONOMY AG investor and analyst conference call. <<operator_script>> I would now like to hand the conference over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and thank you for being with us on today's Q2/H1 results call. Joining me are our CEO, Bernhard Duttmann, and Florian Wieser, our new group CFO. The two of them will walk you through the presentation for today. Before we begin, allow me to quickly cover the usual formalities. First, please note that this call is being recorded. Later today, a replay will be posted on our website. Second, do bear in mind that the presentation today, and potentially some responses to your questions in the Q&A session as well, may include forward-looking statements. For more information on this point, please see the disclaimer. But now, let me turn things over to our CEO, who will begin with an overview of the second quarter. Please go ahead.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. This call is taking place in a new setup. Beside me is Florian Wieser, who, alongside his position as CFO of Media-Saturn, has now been named CFO of CECONOMY effective May 1. Florian is no newcomer. He's been with us for quite a while. He belonged to the demerger team when we split from METRO. Earlier, before gaining that experience, he built operational experience as a controller in a country. Following the demerger, he served as a Finance Manager for the Southern European region alongside Ferran Reverter and the turnaround of Italy. At the end of 2018, he took on the CFO role for our German business, and later became CFO of Media-Saturn Retail Group. In short, Florian has already played a key part in the transformation now underway. He is thoroughly familiar with all the details, along with the strengths and the weaknesses that we must overcome. I'm pleased that he is joining the Board of CECONOMY, since he will ensure that the transformation we began when we pressed the reset button in early 2019 keeps moving forward.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#4

Bringing Florian in as Group CFO is likewise an initial key move toward creating one consistent management framework across CECONOMY Group. As a result, CECONOMY now has 1 Board member under a new setup that I'm able to share with you today. The second piece: Karsten Wildberger was appointed by the CECONOMY Supervisory Board last night. Mr. Wildberger is going to step into my role in August. Simultaneously, he will also take on the CEO position at Media-Saturn Holding. Karsten Wildberger brings over 20 years of experience across marketing and sales positions, and he has driven omnichannel, retail and digital transformation efforts at large distribution companies. While at the Australian telecommunications company Telstra, he held P&L responsibility for roughly 400 branded shops and headed the whole retail and service organization. Ladies and gentlemen, by nominating Karsten Wildberger and Florian Wieser, we at last remove the dual structure. The CEO and CFO roles will be combined at CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn. With that said, let's turn to the second quarter. Ladies and gentlemen, I take pride in what we have accomplished and in how robust our business is. Let me explain why I say that. Our stationary business once more took a heavy hit from continuing temporary store closures and severe restrictions.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#5

Even so, we were able to substantially reduce the effect of COVID-19 on our operations. Both sales and adjusted EBIT ended up just a bit under the prior-year figure, and that prior-year level had been far less hit by COVID-19. On an encouraging note, demand remains strong — in stores and online alike — in countries where restrictions were lighter. Across our business, the online channel stayed very dynamic. In a single quarter, we brought in over EUR 2 billion in online sales. That impressive online expansion, together with the sales momentum we saw as stores reopened country by country, shows the strength of our market position. Operationally, we also made solid progress. The right structures are now in place to keep our transformation moving forward. Overall, the way we handled the second quarter, in spite of every difficulty and uncertainty, is evidence of how resilient our business model is. To support that point and provide context, let's examine more closely the restrictions we encountered during the second quarter. If you look at last year's figure, we had a lockdown of only roughly 2 weeks, in the latter part of March 2020. By contrast, this year the lockdowns ran considerably longer and were more severe. This year, we were essentially affected through the whole quarter.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#6

Germany, our home market, and the Netherlands took the hardest hit from temporary closures, though other nations also dealt with temporary lockdowns and restrictions. Stores in Austria were shut temporarily during January, whereas Switzerland saw impact in January and February. Then in March, Hungary was forced to close its stores. Meanwhile, countries such as Italy, Poland and Turkey dealt with severe restrictions, among them temporary weekend closures or shuttering of stores located in shopping malls. In January, just 37% of our whole store portfolio on average remained open, and that figure came to 46% in February. Come March, we were waiting with real eagerness for restrictions to ease, anticipating Germany's slow exit from lockdown. The German government, however, chose a different path. It opted for a step-by-step reopening approach in which whether stores could open depended on the infection count per 100,000 residents of a city. Where 7-day incidences sat below 50, we could reopen our stores, and where the incidence fell between 50 and 100, customers were offered the option click-and-meet, with scheduled appointments for store visits, alongside compliance with the prevailing distance, hygiene and square meter rules. Under strict restrictions, the click-and-meet concept was also used in the Netherlands and Belgium during March.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#7

As infections climbed in March, the count of stores operating at full capacity dropped sharply from one day to the next. On top of that, given the inconvenience of booking a slot before you shop at our locations, the click-and-meet feature was never especially well received by our clientele — and it still isn't. Customer visit frequencies fell by around 60% versus 2019. Across the whole of the second quarter, you can see that our physical retail operation took a heavy hit from those restrictions. And that came on top of a first quarter that had already been impacted. In fact, ladies and gentlemen, before we go any deeper into Q2, allow me to bring you back to the point when the pandemic began so I can demonstrate just how severely COVID-19 threw our sales off course. The pandemic has now been part of our lives for over a year. What you're looking at is how our sales evolved over that stretch. Back in '19/'20, we got off to a very strong start. The 2019 Black Friday period delivered yet another successful result. Through January and February, we carried the first quarter's upward trajectory forward without interruption and stood squarely where we had expected to be. Right up until the middle of March 2020, sales momentum remained encouraging. Then, as COVID-19 began spreading throughout Europe, the situation shifted entirely. COVID-19 brought most of our stationary business to a temporary halt in March and April 2020.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#8

But when restrictions were relaxed in May, we experienced significant catch-up effects. After that came sustained robust demand from customers along with heavy spending on consumer electronic products. That very favorable sales trajectory persisted right up until strict closure measures returned in a number of countries in mid-December. Through that period, our sales performance in the quarter had been a record. One key point: the sales interruptions visible across the year stem solely from how the COVID-19 pandemic affected our brick-and-mortar business. At any time our operations were not — and are not — disrupted by store closures and stringent social distancing rules, we deliver a very favorable sales result, backed by robust appetite for what we offer. That shows the potential we have. The past year has likewise demonstrated that we are well placed to gain from catch-up effects as soon as our stores open again. So I have confidence that we are well positioned across both channels once the pandemic is behind us. To close out the review of how the first 6 months of this financial year developed, let's briefly examine the headline figures. During the second quarter, because of all those restrictions, we could not reach the prior year's sales and earnings level.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#9

Even so, because we became more cost-efficient and had robust COVID-19 contingency plans in place, we managed to keep the earnings drop in check. Currency- and portfolio-adjusted sales fell only 5.7%, while adjusted EBIT was down by just EUR 15 million compared with a year earlier. Turning to the first-half figures, I'm happy to report that how sales and earnings moved shows how resilient our business model is. Even with the severe COVID-19 restrictions, we posted an overall positive trend in this period versus the prior year. Owing to a great start to the first quarter of this financial year and the mitigation steps taken in the second quarter, together with favorable trends in countries less impacted, currency- and portfolio-adjusted first-half sales increased 4.5%, and EBIT climbed by EUR 41 million to reach EUR 199 million. Ladies and gentlemen, we are likewise still on course with our transformation. Even with the enormous constraints on our stationary business and the short-time work that continues to affect a great many of our employees, 5 months have passed since we laid out our strategy update for you at the Capital Markets Day in December. As we said at the time, we will of course keep you informed about the continuous progress we are making.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#10

I'll start with how we built an efficient organization and structure. From the outset, we were explicit that this pillar is essential for speeding up the transformation. I'm happy to report that rolling out the new operating model is going well. It is actually ahead of plan and is delivering somewhat greater savings within the financial year as well. Homogeneous management structures are now in place across every country. What's more, in over 1/3 of our stores, a standardized organization has already been brought in, which is a prerequisite for a customer experience that consistently convinces. Beyond that, our hub for global business services has begun operating in a location near Barcelona with roughly 150 FTEs. This new administrative center will bring together the administrative functions of operational accounting, centralize invoice control and other services of the MediaMarktSaturn Group. It will serve all our non-German speaking countries. Through this, our stores and headquarters will be freed from administrative tasks so their capacities can focus even more strongly on value-adding services and, above all, on our customers. Taken together, our new operating model represents an important step toward future growth and rapid implementation. And the strategic layer established a unique value proposition.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#11

I want to highlight what we've done up to now regarding our passion for customers training. Even though we had limited staffing over the recent months, over 400 managers and 3,000 employees have been trained in passion for customers. Let me remind everyone that the core of this strategy is our aim to become customers' first choice. We pledged to invest even more heavily than previously in thorough employee training. Through this, we've also set a goal of contributing significantly to further building out our advisory and service competence in the stores. The training rate we've achieved demonstrates that our passion to be the first choice is something we take seriously. On the topic of service, a monthly extended warranty subscription service has been integrated into our webshop. While penetration of online services overall remains fairly low, I'm happy to report it is beginning to grow nicely. To grow our core business, we've successfully pursued local consolidation and purchased 17 Worten stores in Spain, a market where we had no local presence. This acquisition will reinforce MediaMarkt Spain's presence in regions including Catalonia and Andalusia and allow market entries in cities including Marbella.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#12

Beyond that, we expect the broader local footprint to lift online sales as well, including a possible click-and-collect option. Last, just a brief note on how our growth trajectory is speeding up. We've kept growing the MediaMarkt marketplace in Germany. By drawing on this additional revenue stream, we'll raise our relevance to customers and suppliers considerably and drive more organic traffic to our webshop. It will likewise lift our own retail and service sales and let us test new categories and products quickly and at scale. At present, roughly 230 sellers have been onboarded onto our MediaMarkt marketplace in Germany, with over 130,000 SKUs. In addition, we recently went live with the marketplace for Saturn in Germany, matching the 2022 pace, with the goal of launching the marketplace platform in the Netherlands and Spain. With that, I'll pass things to Florian, who will walk you through this quarter's financial performance.

Florian Wieser

executive
#13

Yes. Thanks, Bernhard, and thanks for the really warm welcome. Good morning, everyone on the call. Before we get into the quarterly numbers, I'd like to share a bit more background about myself. My career began as a management consultant at <<inaudible>> Company. In 2011, I moved to METRO Group, CECONOMY's former parent. While there, I held a number of senior finance roles, and then in 2017 I joined MediaMarktSaturn. At first, I was in charge of operations and finance for the south region, working closely with Ferran Reverter. I learned a great deal about the business in Spain and was part of the team that sustainably restructured <<inaudible>> Italy. After that, I moved to Germany and took on the CFO role at the German country organization. Among other things, we sharpened how the German business was steered and modernized structures and processes, managing the cost base and gaining speed. At the end of 2018, I widened my remit and became CFO of MediaMarktSaturn Retail Group. In my new role as CECONOMY's CFO, I want to simplify our governance further and keep executing our new strategy consistently. I'm also looking forward to engaging more with the capital markets. Still virtually for now, I'm excited to meet many of you over the coming weeks and months.

Florian Wieser

executive
#14

That covers me. Now I'll take you through the quarterly figures. To sum up, we're reflecting on a quarter marked by a highly difficult environment. Even so, we delivered a business performance that was both very solid and resilient. Let's begin by examining sales development more closely. Sales adjusted for currency and portfolio effects reached roughly EUR 4.3 billion, down about 6% versus a year earlier. As Bernhard said earlier, during Q2 of the prior financial year, COVID-19 restrictions had no effect on our business until mid-March. This year, store closures across a large number of countries shaped the whole of the second quarter. Germany, our home market, along with the Netherlands and Switzerland, felt the greatest impact. Every other country posted sales at least in line with, or in some cases even well above, prior-year levels. That makes clear the strong underlying consumer demand for our offerings is continuing. Online sales moved very dynamically but could not entirely offset the losses in the stationary business. Online growth even picked up further amid store closures and restrictions tied to COVID-19. Consequently, we recorded triple-digit growth rates in the online channel during January and February. The enormous expansion of our online business pleases us greatly.

Florian Wieser

executive
#15

This comes from a big rise in online visits, along with better conversion rates and larger average bonds. We also added roughly 2.2 million new online customers in Q2, which is 60% higher than the same quarter a year earlier. It's encouraging, too, that the pickup rate is back at a sustainably high level and even climbing — 38% in Q2 compared with 34% in the quarter before. To me that's an excellent outcome considering how much total online order volume grew, and it shows both the convenience for customers and the resilience of our omnichannel model. Now let's look more closely at how the online share has developed to see the trend over time. During the first quarter of the financial year, our online business more than doubled, making up 30% of total sales. In Q2, momentum in the online business picked up further as more stores closed and restrictions increased. Our online share nearly tripled, reaching about half of total sales. Given that momentum, even once our stores reopen in the future, the online sales share will probably stay elevated rather than going back to pre-COVID levels.

Florian Wieser

executive
#16

The following chart helps to further demonstrate how well our online business is doing. It essentially illustrates 2 points. First, in Germany we have continuously beaten the overall online market, and the pace of that has actually picked up. Second, our performance was particularly strong throughout the lockdown period. During the second quarter, we recorded the biggest market share gains within the online channel. All told, MediaMarktSaturn accounted for over 20% of sales across the whole German online market. That makes it very clear that our emphasis on online sales activities — stepped up when the pandemic began last year — was essential in order to mitigate the effect of COVID-19 on our business. Services & Solutions sales fell significantly during the second quarter. The reason is the drop in customer footfall together with the temporary closure of our stores. Beyond that, we noticed that stationary business has turned more transactional amid the pandemic because of social distancing <<inaudible>>. As you know, sales of Services & Solutions remain strongly tied to purchases made in stationary retail and gain from the personal advice our customers receive. Every service category was down in Q2. Even so, extended warranties, financing and our power services reversed the trend in March, with pleasing sales and income development.

Florian Wieser

executive
#17

Also, our online channel is showing a substantial rise in Services & Solutions sales. The reductions in the stationary business can't be fully offset by that lower base. Even with the online share growing, we keep working on raising our online attachment rate so we can grow our service business. Beyond the sales trends, we're even more focused on the sustainable income contribution that comes from Services & Solutions. By moving to subscription models, such as our extended warranties offerings, we've achieved a steady income contribution and we win customers for our company over the long term. The group's gross margin fell by over 2 percentage points. COVID-related headwinds are largely the cause. The big shift toward the online channel, together with product mix effects and higher delivery costs, had a negative impact on the gross margin. On top of that, closure related to write-downs on inventories had an adverse effect. Finally, the decline also stemmed from the lower Services & Solutions income, as I just described. Still, at least at their current magnitude, these effects are nonsustainable and ought to diminish once the restrictions are lifted. That should then lead to a bigger impact from the improved gross margin, which already supported the gross margin in the second quarter.

Florian Wieser

executive
#18

So overall, we expect to see that improving gross margin trend in Q3. We basically managed — we managed to offset a big chunk of the sales drop and the lower gross margin through active cost management. Those gains come from temporary cost mitigation measures such as short-time work. At the same time, we brought personnel expenses down on a sustainable basis, thanks to natural fluctuation and savings from our new operating model. Location costs were also better year-on-year, while marketing spend sits at the prior year's level to stabilize sales development. Conversely, variable cost components like payment transaction or call center costs rose along with a higher level of online sales. Altogether, we cut costs effectively by more than EUR 130 million in Q2. Our OpEx ratio came in 160 basis points better. Taking everything together, we could not match last year's earnings because of the extended lockdown. Still, thanks to intensified cost measures, we managed to limit the decline significantly. Adjusted EBIT was down by only EUR 50 million year-on-year. That was mostly driven by the decline in the DACH segment. The principal factor was Germany, along with the material impact of the country's COVID-19-related store closures and restrictions.

Florian Wieser

executive
#19

Several factors combined here: a growing portion of revenue coming from online operations, increased expenses tied to delivery, and reduced profitability in Service & Solutions. Austria, by contrast, posted higher earnings, helped among other things by encouraging sales momentum during the quarter. West and Southern Europe saw earnings edge down slightly. Segment performance took a hit from COVID-19-related strain on sales and margins in the Netherlands. Italy, however, delivered a significant earnings gain on the back of favorable sales and margin trends, while Belgium and Spain were solid, with adjusted EBIT a touch above the prior-year figure. In Eastern Europe, adjusted EBIT climbed thanks to robust sales growth, better margins, and cost savings achieved in Poland. Turkey also performed well on earnings, lifted by positive sales and margin trends, falling personnel expenses, and cost-reduction initiatives. Within the Others segment, adjusted EBIT went up owing to Sweden and reduced holding costs. All told, I want to emphasize that this outcome is extraordinary given how challenging the environment has been, and I am deeply grateful to every employee who helped make it happen and demonstrated such remarkable dedication to our company.

Florian Wieser

executive
#20

Now let's turn to Slide 20, which lays out how we get from adjusted EBIT to reported EBIT for the current financial year. During the second quarter, 2 main effects accounted for the gap between adjusted and reported EBIT. First, we saw negative earnings impacts, largely tied to permanent store closures connected with COVID-19 and to the new operating model. Those came to EUR 34 million. We continue to expect the rest of the nonrecurring expenses we've communicated to be booked in the third and fourth quarter of this financial year. Second, on the positive side, we had the partial reversal of the Fnac Darty impairment along with our profit share. By March 31, 2021, the market value of our investment in Fnac Darty had gradually recovered. We therefore carried out an impairment test, and that resulted in a partial reversal of last year's impairment. Taking everything together, reported EBIT rose by EUR 366 million, reaching minus EUR 2 million. Now let's move to the bridge from EBIT to EPS. The gain in our financial results came mainly from a dividend payment for METRO Properties that was roughly EUR 20 million above the prior year period. The tax rate for the first half year was 18.5%, reflecting the integral approach applied over the course of this fiscal year.

Florian Wieser

executive
#21

A nontax-related effective reversal of the Fnac Darty impairment gave this a boost. Keep in mind that the tax rate doesn’t yet include any benefits tied to the acquisition of the MediaMarktSaturn minority stake, because that deal still hinges on closing. Thanks to last year’s Fnac Darty impairment and this year’s reversal, our EPS rose considerably compared with a year earlier. Now let’s turn to how net working capital developed. As of March 31, 2021, net working capital stood well under the prior-year level, driven largely by a substantial drop in trade liabilities. Trade liabilities came down somewhat because purchase volume was lower. The bulk of that decrease, though, traces back to last year’s temporary extension of payment terms with certain suppliers. Put differently, last year most of those liabilities fell due in Q3. This year we made a deliberate choice not to repeat those extraordinary extensions, given our solid cash position and the fact that we had far more time than last year to prepare alternative measures against the COVID-19 effect. You can see that in both the previous year and this year, COVID-19 lockdowns affected how our net working capital developed.

Florian Wieser

executive
#22

If we set aside those nonrecurring items, I'm quite encouraged to observe that operational net working capital has been broadly steady. Free cash flow in the opening six months of this year reflected seasonality as well as effects tied to COVID-19. In particular, because no payment term extensions went past March 31, 2020, trade liabilities normalized this year. On top of that, given the currently strained conditions in worldwide supply chains, particularly in China, we intentionally built up inventory so that we would have sufficient stock available. As a result, the picture appears rather distorted, and free cash flow for the first half year should not be taken as an indicator for the full year. With the daily flow of news on the pandemic and political developments, our visibility right now is low. Estimating what further impact the corona pandemic will have on our business remains very difficult. Several factors drive this: the ongoing extension of the lockdown in Germany together with an unclear opening strategy; the high volatility of regulatory measures and temporary store closures in certain countries abroad; the unknown scale of possible catch-up effects once the stationary business reopens, especially in Germany; a potential shift in consumer behavior once tourist traveling is permitted again; and the unclear further opening and vaccination strategy, particularly in Germany.

Florian Wieser

executive
#23

Given all that, we aren’t putting out fresh specific guidance at this point. For now, what we can give you are potential future scenarios along with the assumptions behind them. When it comes to sales adjusted for portfolio and exchange rate effects, whether the full year ends in a decrease or an increase would hinge on how long the lockdown lasts in Germany and how strong catch-up effects turn out to be. Take one example: if reopening moves faster, especially in Germany, and catch-up effects are larger, sales could end up above the prior year’s level. As for adjusted EBIT excluding associates, should the lockdown in Germany run through the end of May 2021 and catch-up effects be only moderate, adjusted EBIT might decline year on year. If, on the other hand, openings come sooner, particularly in Germany, and the catch-up effect proves larger, adjusted EBIT could rise relative to the previous year’s level. So I think it’s clear that the present situation doesn’t allow for any precise outlook. With that, I’ll hand it back to Bernhard for closing remarks.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#24

Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to give a brief wrap-up of today's presentation. Here is what I'd like you to take away from this call. First, we are — we were and we remain severely affected by extended lockdowns. The most decisive factor is, and continues to be, the restrictions in the stationary business, above all the absence of a clear opening strategy and a clear perspective in Germany. Even with these restrictions, our business model has shown itself to be resilient. Second, we are ready for the reopening of our stores, to demonstrate the strength we have regained over the last 2 years. Third, succession is in place. We have at last unified the management structures, which will help us increase speed and move closer to the customers. And finally, we will carry on the transformation as planned. With Karsten Wildberger and Florian Wieser, the future management team is in place to lead the company strategically and operationally during the phase of transformation and beyond. Thank you for your attention. And I will now hand the call over to the operator for your questions.

Operator

operator
#25

<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#26

Thanks for joining, Florian. I have three questions, if I may. I understand you have no visibility into this year. But could you help us on Q3, for instance, for DACH and Western Europe? If we assume every store stays shut in Germany, which appears to be the situation, should we expect the same kind of like-for-like and EBIT loss in DACH for Q3? And on the other hand, for Western Europe, since the Netherlands has begun reopening, should we expect improved like-for-like and EBIT in Q3? That's my first question. My second question: could you tell us the marketplace GMV for the quarter? And the final point is whether you have any update on marketing services and ads. It was one of the points at the Strategy Day — that clearly enhancing your marketing services and selling ads or media online could be a solid part of boosting your profitability. Have you made progress on that topic?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#27

Yes. Morning, Fabienne. I'll take the last question first. Just as you said, we're doing work on marketing services. We're getting ready and building the groundwork for that effort. But there's nothing specific we can report on marketing services right now.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#28

Alright.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#29

Yes. And regarding the second — 2 questions, first of all about marketplace, the GMV. So marketplace remains a pilot. We're ramping it up in Germany and have made a lot of progress with it. I'm very satisfied with how it's developing; we already have more than 100,000 SKUs and more than 200 sellers on the marketplace. Now, with the rollout of the new webshop to other countries, most recently to Spain, we will extend marketplace operations to additional countries in the next fiscal year, and at that point we'll also give you some more color on the GMV development. On the outlook: I know the current situation with scenarios isn't very precise. And for us too, as I said in the call, visibility is very low. So on Germany, the picture is still quite unclear. You know that the German government passed a new law that basically links openings of the stores, and the way you can open stores, to the number of infections in certain counties. So basically, the situation changes day-to-day — whether we can do click-and-collect, whether we can do click-and-meet, or whether we can open stores fully. And even if we have openings, let's say by click-and-meet, how customers accept this offer differs very much from county to county.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#30

City frequencies remain depressed and aren’t climbing. As a result, giving a forecast or an exact estimate for how things will unfold in DACH is genuinely hard. Turning to Western Europe, we’re very happy with how Italy is progressing. Italy is coming along well. Consumer demand is entirely present. Spain’s lockdown restriction has now officially come to an end. So in Spain we’re seeing further easing. There too, our business and our offerings are progressing well. The Netherlands was hit hard. The click-and-meet offering that the government permitted was -- yes, it was extremely, extremely limited. So it wasn’t simple for customers to actually take up this offering. And now we must watch how the situation in the Netherlands evolves. If the same catch-up effects appear as we’ve observed in other countries, for instance Austria -- Austria has experienced an enormous catch-up -- then I’m likewise very optimistic about the Netherlands. But as I mentioned, we have to watch day by day and hope for the best that restrictions are coming to an end and customer frequency is rising once more.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#31

All right, let me return to Germany if I may. I fully get that, but our assumption is that stores stay shut and click-and-meet isn’t functioning, as you mentioned. So just so we can get a sense of it, should we treat the German loss — if you don’t have the loss figure because it sits within DACH as a sort of — in Q2 as a kind of worst case and as the basis for Q3, assuming stores don’t open at all before the end of June?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#32

Sure. Let me give you a bit more detail on that. If you recall, in April of last year we were still in a full lockdown. So we did see somewhat higher turnover and some easing of restrictions during April. Then in May and June of last year, we experienced a huge catch-up effect and a huge recovery. Essentially, across the stretch from May through the end of September in that fiscal year, our growth rates were very, very strong — at times even double digit — so comparisons are going to get very tough beginning in May. For April, you can be more optimistic. To answer your question exactly: if lockdowns were to persist in this drastic form through the end of Q3 in Germany, we would face very tough comps.

Operator

operator
#33

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank has the next question.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#34

Volker Bosse here from Baader Bank. Congrats on the strong online sales momentum, and welcome to Mr. Wieser — wishing you all the best in the new role. I have 3 questions. First, let me begin with the online KPIs. If I remember correctly, Karin Dohm promised a specific set of KPIs would be delivered on a rolling basis. At Q1, those KPIs were already missing. And then you said, yes, we'll report them with the H1 figures. But now in the H1 figures, I don't see the KPIs either. So how do you view this going forward? Will you provide these kinds of figures going forward? And the second question also comes back to your guidance. I know — I see the uncertainties, I'm sitting in Germany as well, of course. But on the 15th of December, you were quite concrete with guidance of EUR 320 million to EUR 370 million. Now we're mid of May, and you see the global progress of vaccination or at least in Europe, we have 7 months in the books and no guidance is possible. It's fair to work with scenarios, yes, but then you can be a bit more precise.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#35

So what you're saying is the best-case scenario means sales of XYZ produce EBIT of XYZ, and maybe under a different scenario, sales would come in like this and then EBIT would be as follows, correct? But as of December 15, concrete? Now 7 months, no concrete. I mean, on December 15 we were also in the lockdown, and there was also, I'd say, much more uncertainty than there is as of today. So I'd like to flag that, perhaps to get some granularity on it. And the third item would be rental costs. I've heard from other competitors saying that in our city locations, we see a downward trend or the potential to cut rental costs by 10% to 25%. Would you agree with that? And have you already renegotiated any rental contracts going forward on a sustainable basis, so to speak, and — yes, what potential might you see for your rental contract? Is it just Germany? Or do you see that potential for lower rental costs across Europe given the pandemic and given the digitization trend, which is a driver, I guess. But over to you.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#36

Volker, I'll take your second question, which is about the guidance. You're absolutely right. Back in December we felt sure we had solid guidance, and that we'd have a good year even with the lockdown that was already in place at that point. Unfortunately, though, we had to face the fact that politicians behave somewhat irrationally, since we know from the institutions — the health institutions — that they had demonstrated in the trade that the rate of infection — the risk of infection rate — is actually rather low. Even so, the politicians didn't follow those facts and chose a different path, imposing further lockdowns. And in Germany, as you're aware, that's 50% of our sales and over 50% of our profit. That makes it incredibly hard to put a guidance on our business when this large country is entirely beyond any means of judging when we would — or when we could reopen it. And that makes it very, very difficult to genuinely produce a guidance. You also know that a big portion of our margin gets generated in September. So for that reason, at this moment it's very difficult given the current scenario, where we don't really have open markets in some countries — the most important one being Germany, which is also our biggest market.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#37

So because of that, I’m not able to provide guidance. I think that’s something you need to understand. But for us, it’s simply not possible. As for the 2 other questions, I’d like Florian to answer them. On rental cost, he is in — he was always at the center of the universe as well, negotiating. So you can hear firsthand information from him on this.

Florian Wieser

executive
#38

Yes. Please let me begin with your first question about online growth. I think we also provided some transparency on online KPIs in the presentation and in the speech. We published the number on online growth and on how registered customers developed. And to me, the pickup rate matters very, very much. The pickup rate rose from 34% last year to 38%, and that happened alongside such tremendous online growth. In fact, the pickup ratio was even stronger — or pickup orders grew even more strongly than our online orders delivered directly to customers. That was always a critical point too: whether the omnichannel approach is convenient for customers, and we now see that even with such tremendous online order volume, the pickup rate is accepted and even demanded by customers. So there are several KPIs that we have disguised. I can also give you some more color on the underlying KPIs. The frequency, the conversion rate in the basket — all of these figures have risen against the previous year, especially the frequency. And the second question regarding the KPIs: when do we disguise the KPIs that we announced at the Capital Markets Day.

Florian Wieser

executive
#39

We'll handle that at year-end. Right now, a lot of those KPIs are plainly skewed by COVID-19, so they don't present an accurate view of the transformation or where things currently stand. That's the reason we chose to provide you the complete and accurate picture of how these KPIs developed at the close of the year. Your third question concerned rental costs. And the answer there is a clear yes. So we're seeing rental costs trend downward, and we actively negotiate that rent. So in Q2, you see a double-digit million euro improvement in location costs. That's mostly tied to occupancy costs. The stores were closed. So we used less energy. Then there's an impact, which you essentially see in the income margin, coming from corona negotiations we carried out. So each time stores were closed, we reached agreements with our landlords to temporarily reduce the rent for the period the stores were shut. And we're doing this truly day by day now. Thanks to this highly complex regulation in Germany. We conduct this negotiation truly on a day-by-day basis while the stores are closed. And the final point on these rental negotiations, yes, we've taken advantage of the current situation to renegotiate our rental -- our real estate portfolio with a lot of landlords.

Florian Wieser

executive
#40

We've completed quite a few package deals, which have brought our location costs and rental expenses down considerably with landlords. Just don't count on seeing those positive effects show up in next quarter's EBIT, because under IFRS guidelines we're required to spread those rental savings over the time, or lease term, of each individual contract. So we've made a great deal of progress. We're quite happy about it, and we took particular advantage of the current situation.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#41

So would you say there's potential for rental costs to come down across Europe? Or is that particularly the case in Germany?

Florian Wieser

executive
#42

No, this applies throughout Europe. Essentially, we’re seeing these deals in every country, and we use a range of tools. At times, we shift location costs and the rent contract to percentage-of-sales arrangements. That means location costs are paid as a percentage of sales. In other cases, we’ve achieved significant rent reductions, and we’ve lengthened the rent contracts. So we deploy various tools when carrying this out across all of Europe.

Operator

operator
#43

Clement Genelot from Bryan Garnier has the next question.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#44

I have three questions, if I may. First, regarding the inventory impairment you recorded in Q2: what was the precise amount of that impairment? And do you anticipate a further one in Q3 if lockdowns in Germany continue past June? Second, on click-and-meet in Germany — clearly this new structure went in very recently. How has it affected store sales? And did it genuinely benefit the business in Germany during Q3? Finally, my last question concerns the performance gap between Southern Europe — that is, Spain and Italy — and the rest of Europe. Do you think such a gap exists perhaps because governments in Southern Europe are providing less support to consumers, and so on? That is what Fnac Darty already pointed out.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#45

Yes, Bryan, thanks for those questions. Let me take the second one first. To be very frank, click-and-meet isn't helping us. It isn't popular. And as for the customer, we saw that the frequency on click-and-meet is really coming down. The only thing that has really helped during the quarter, which we've seen rising, is the pickup rate that Florian just mentioned. There, we really ended up -- or rather, we are getting better and better with the pickup rate. But click-and-meet isn't helping, and when you walk into the stores where you have click-and-meet, you see empty stores. This is very critical. For that reason, we need a clear opening strategy in Germany and not just this kind of fuzzy click-and-meet. On the other ones, Florian, will you comment on the impairment booked on inventories?

Florian Wieser

executive
#46

Yeah, I’m glad to address that. When you look at inventories, the impact during Q2 accounted for about 1/3 of the goods margin loss that we saw. We’re quite confident this is a temporary effect and that it will reverse over the coming quarters. Why do we believe that? First, the stock remains relatively fresh. It isn’t in the oldest aging buckets; it sits in the younger aging bands and is clearly tied only to the lockdown and to inventory remaining in the stores. Second, we have some experience from the prior year, when we saw a comparable situation. After that lockdown, stock aging deteriorated, and this effect also reversed, and we had good experience with that.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#47

Regarding your third question, I can offer a comment: we're pleased with how Spain and Italy have performed. Whenever those two countries were open, they both delivered a very, very strong performance. And as for the downturn you're seeing in this region, it stems solely from the Netherlands, since we experienced a strict lockdown there. In addition, we had a few short-term switches in Belgium. Yet in Belgium, once it opened again, we witnessed solid results. As we've also mentioned, Sweden performed well too. And with Turkey, we were likewise satisfied with its results. So we — yes, I believe that addresses the question.

Operator

operator
#48

Okay, so the final question comes from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux, and it's a follow-up.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#49

Just a couple of quick things. First, could you remind us how online orders get fulfilled, especially in Germany? Because I recall you don't have <<inaudible>> just beginning to work, so centralized fulfillment isn't in place. I'm trying to get a sense of what it costs to serve an online order in a large country such as Germany. The second question is broader. We're getting a new CEO. From where we sit, how do we gain confidence that the strategy you laid out last year will stay in place? Because most of the time, a CEO also wants to put forward their own input. And we bought into an equity story that was presented to us. Florian has been there before, but then we'll have a new CEO. So what can you tell us that would give us confidence the strategy will carry on as presented?

Florian Wieser

executive
#50

Turning to your first question about online orders, there are a number of options available to us. To begin with, we operate several dedicated online warehouses in Germany, and from those we fulfill online orders directly. The second option is the well-known ship-from-store approach. So whenever we find ourselves in a lockdown situation, or when there's specific high demand — peak season, Black November Friday. Then — Black November, Black Friday, I should say, and the Christmas business. We also rely on ship-from-store to handle that extra demand coming from the stores. So those are essentially the 2 main options we use.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#51

Most of it, though, is earmarked for the warehouses that serve online orders exclusively, correct?

Florian Wieser

executive
#52

Sorry, could you say that again?

Fabienne Caron

executive
#53

Is it fair to say that most of the volume is handled by the warehouse?

Florian Wieser

executive
#54

My take is that the situation is fairly mixed. You're also seeing pickup, so that's clearly an online order. And by now you've seen 38% fulfilled in the store through physical pickup. Then there's ship-from-store, which mostly applies to parcels — so not a great deal of handling, but for parcels — and the rest gets handled by the online warehouse. So I'd call it a fairly balanced portfolio, a fairly balanced approach.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#55

Fabienne, whether the strategy shifts under the new CEO is genuinely a fair question. Still, I can tell you that the Supervisory Board discussed our strategy just yesterday. And the strategy in its entirety was reaffirmed. The sole point we'll examine is whether the pandemic altered any of our assumptions or the market's long-term trajectory, and what, if anything, we would need to respond to. Other than that single item, we are reaffirming the strategy and will keep doing so going forward. And that, as I mentioned at the very start, is why I'm so pleased that Florian is taking on the CFO role, since he will ensure continuity in the transformation we've begun, because plenty of matters — many issues remain to be addressed, and the centralization processes are not yet fully complete. So there is still a great deal left to do, and we intend to carry on with it, as that is a prerequisite for becoming a genuinely successful player in the market.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#56

All right. And Mr. Duttmann, since you'll be leaving in August, in case we don't get a chance to talk again, I want to wish you the very best going forward.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#57

Thanks so much, Fabienne. I’m going to miss getting together with you.

Operator

operator
#58

That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer session. I'll now turn things over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations, for some closing remarks.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#59

That wraps up today's results call, everyone. We appreciate your time and your questions. If anything else comes up, as always, don't hesitate to reach out to us at Investor Relations. We're looking forward to speaking with you again. Take care, stay healthy, and goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.