Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 12, 2021

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 59 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thank you for holding. We appreciate your participation in the CECONOMY AG Investor and Analyst Conference Call. During the recorded presentation today, everyone will be in listen-only mode. After the presentation, we will hold a question and answer session. Should you wish to ask a question, please dial zero then one on your touchtone phone. For operator assistance, press the star key and then zero. At this point, I will hand the conference over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being on our Q3 2021 results call this morning. Joining me today are Karsten Wildberger, our new CEO, and Florian Wieser, our CFO. They'll walk you through today's presentation. Before we begin, let me quickly take care of the usual formalities. First, this call is being recorded. A replay will be posted on our website later today. Second, please keep in mind that today's presentation, and possibly some responses to your questions in the Q&A session as well, may include forward-looking statements. For more details on that, please see the disclaimer. I'll now turn things over to Karsten Wildberger, our new CEO.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#3

Thank you, Stephanie, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to be here and to meet you for the first time. Before we kick off today's results call and dive into the details, I'd like to take this opportunity to briefly introduce myself. My name is Karsten Wildberger. I'm 51 years old and two weeks in the new job. I worked internationally in different sectors: consulting, telco, and energy. Functionally, I worked in sales, retail, products, IT, digital, finance, and commercial roles. Topic-wise, my focus has always been around customers, digital transformation, sales products and services. Probably two experiences that in this role stand out is, first of all, the experience at Telstra, which is an Australian telco incumbent, where I also had the chance to lead the digital transformation for the company and also develop the store of the future, which was quite special because it combines, in a very nice way, the digital experience with the bricks and mortar world. In my last role at E.ON, I think I really embraced the topics of sustainability, recycling, and climate neutrality. There, I had the chance to also turn our core energy sales business back into growth mode and establish new scalable growth businesses, which was exciting.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#4

It's great to be here, and with Florian and me now appointed, the company has at last done away with its dual management setups. At both CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn, the CEO and CFO positions are now combined. I want to be clear: irrespective of the delayed transaction involving Convergenta — which Florian will address later — we can now guide and run the business under this newly simplified structure. Allow me to share a few experiences — what I've observed and picked up since taking over at the start of August. I've already enjoyed getting to know plenty of colleagues, speaking with customers and partners, and checking out a number of stores in Germany and other countries. First, I've encountered a highly committed team that cares deeply about what we do, and I've also witnessed both the necessity and the desire to keep enhancing the customer experience. I'd also like to highlight that I've observed a firm resolve to carry out our strategy, and on that front we're progressing well. I can affirm that this company genuinely possesses strong operational muscle, which matters so much for pushing things forward. One illustration is our flagship store in Milan — truly fantastic — and taking it from concept development to opening in July 2020 required only nine months.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#5

Beyond that, I've spotted definite avenues for growth as well. Let's discuss the opportunities along with what we could improve and approach differently. Every opportunity I'm going to mention aligns with our strategy and extends what we already do. First, keeping a steady emphasis on customers and their experience matters greatly. Delivering a smoother omnichannel experience—one that lets people shop with us in an easy, effortless way—requires it. That might seem clear, yet honestly, achieving consistently easy engagement for customers with companies is difficult. This idea touches every part of our value chain: having the right products in stock, simple navigation, convenient delivery, and providing services that are relevant and appealing and that improve what customers buy. Second, we must speed up our digital push. Progress so far has been encouraging, and our robust online growth demonstrates that. For an omnichannel experience that truly excites, we need to seize what digitalization makes possible—above all the connection between online and bricks and mortar. Using data to support better business choices belongs here too. I've noticed we've advanced quite well in selling services, yet customers want plenty of additional services, and we can improve at selling phone-related services along with tech support for computers and home office products.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#6

There's also the strong service lineup we already provide — things like the SmartBars in our stores — that we can put to better use, since many customers don't even know it exists. And I think we need to reflect on how our enthusiasm for consumer electronics can help us cultivate a category leadership mindset. Strengthening collaboration with our partners is essential for that, and I've already been in touch with them. One in three Europeans has bought something at MediaMarktSaturn over the past few years. One in three. So how do we become their first choice going forward? How do we bring customer relationship management up to the next level? What I can share with you today is that over the coming months, we will also launch a new membership club offering very compelling benefits for customers. A lot of the ways to strengthen our business are already well-covered by our transformation strategy, and that is without a doubt the right approach if we want to become customers' first choice. Let me be clear about this as well: the strategy is the right one, and we will keep executing on it. With a clear company structure and an efficient organization as our base, we need to focus on delivering a clear customer value proposition, spanning from category leadership to a consistent customer experience across all channels.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#7

I also want to stress that sustainability and saving resources are going to be a growing part of what we represent. Even with the pandemic and all the uncertainty around it, we've achieved really solid progress on our transformation journey. Once again, we'll keep concentrating on carrying out our strategy. Let me quickly give you two examples of that progress to make it more concrete. I'll begin with our stores. In bricks and mortar retail, the long-standing belief was that having more space and more products brings in more customers and more sales. But what customers expect is shifting, and it keeps climbing. They're after convenience, advice, and of course excellent value for money. They only want to deal with brands they trust. So we've developed new formats for all our stores across four categories: the core, the lighthouse, the smart, and the shop-in-shop formats, which we also announced for the first time in December. The lighthouse stores are experience centers built to inspire customers through displays that change regularly. They present state-of-the-art consumer electronics and include showrooms where our partners can demonstrate products. The first lighthouse store was the MediaWorld Tech Village in Milan, which opened in July 2020. The next one is set to open in Rotterdam at the end of this year, and additional lighthouse stores will come in other countries.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#8

Our guiding principle is that we need to be present wherever our customers are. Smart-format stores act as contact points within smaller catchment areas in city centers, where shoppers can browse a carefully chosen selection of products that are in stock, and they can also reach the full product range online and pick those items up conveniently at our stores. We opened smart stores in Rome and Turin not long ago. On my visit to the Turin smart store, what struck me most was the assortment on display and the fact that it rested on a deep grasp of the local customer segment that comes into that store. The entirely digital collection process also struck me as excellent. Step by step, we will keep adapting our current store portfolio to these four formats. Rest assured, this investment is already baked into the normalized CapEx level of 1.5% of sales that we have announced. Second, let me move to another topic, logistics. Becoming customers' first choice is only possible if the right products are available in the right place at the right time. That is why we have scaled up and improved inbound logistics in the Netherlands, Italy, and Spain. Our new national distribution center in the German city of Göttingen is close to going live.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#9

Beyond better product availability, establishing these NDCs—National Distribution Centers—also provides greater flexibility for us when it comes to sourcing directly from partners. We are likewise expanding warehouse capacity ahead of the coming peak season. To sum up, those are merely two illustrations of areas where progress has been achieved. A great deal more lies ahead, and we will update you as our transformation strategy is put into action. As I close my remarks, I'd like to tell you how I see and assess CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn's performance across the first nine months of this financial year—perhaps with a bit of an outside-in perspective after roughly two weeks. CECONOMY entered the financial year strongly, with a highly successful peak season. Still, the tightening COVID-related restrictions became most evident in Germany starting mid-December 2020 and, naturally, took a heavy toll on our bricks and mortar business in Q2. Luckily, we succeeded in offsetting those negative effects through our steadily expanding online business. On top of that, in markets where restrictions were lighter, we could meet strong customer demand. The underlying sales momentum carried into Q3, with 8% sales growth year-on-year, which translates to 5% on a year to date basis.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#10

Because last year's COVID subsidies are no longer in place, combined with strain on goods margins and tight restrictions in Germany and the Netherlands, the Q3 sales gain did not carry through to positive earnings development — but it's worth putting the financial picture into perspective. Even with the COVID complication affecting our retail business, we clearly stay on a profitable track for the nine-month period, with adjusted EBIT of EUR 106 million. That is only EUR 7 million below the prior year period, which saw fewer restrictions. Let's actually look at what store closures and the pandemic meant for store openings and all the related COVID measures. COVID-related closures and restrictions have affected nearly our whole financial year. By contrast, in the previous year most of our stores across Europe were only temporarily shut from mid-March to mid-May 2020. Here you can see the impact this year had. Germany and the Netherlands were the countries hit worst by closures this year. On top of that, the local rules-based opening strategy in Germany made matters very complicated for us and confusing for our customers. The count of German stores permitted to open shifted nearly every day.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#11

Beyond that, the ambiguous regulations governing Click & Meet frequently discouraged customers. In additional markets such as Austria, Switzerland, Italy, Poland, and Turkey, we encountered further constraints as well, among them weekend shutdowns imposed temporarily and the closure of stores located in shopping malls. To sum up, drawing a comparison between last year and this year is extremely hard because the COVID-related constraints have lasted longer and hit harder across numerous markets in the current year. To sum up, notwithstanding the ongoing external difficulties, our business stayed broadly resilient at its core during Q3. Allow me to walk you through the key wins as well as the obstacles. On a brighter note, we observed encouraging sales momentum both in our stores and online. Markets where COVID rules were less strict, such as Spain, Italy, and Turkey, delivered especially strong results. All told, we gained roughly 1.5 million new webshop customers during Q3. From the onset of the pandemic, our online shops have drawn close to 11 million new customers, which I consider impressive. It shows we succeeded in shifting customer demand to the online channel while shops were shut. It further confirms that we are headed in the right direction when it comes to strengthening our omni-channel capabilities. During Q3, we additionally experienced solid growth in our service solutions business, again thanks to our rising attach rates online.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#12

Ladies and gentlemen, I’d like to turn as well to the difficulties we faced in Q3. Once more, our results for that period took a hit from COVID-19 restrictions, with Germany and the Netherlands particularly affected. Customer frequency has been recovering since restrictions eased, though only gradually. In fact, shoppers these days tend to make more deliberate decisions about when to visit stores. Fortunately, the drop in store frequency is being offset by larger checkout values and better conversion rates. That also reflects a tremendous effort from our customer-facing colleagues. On profitability, we experienced pressure on goods margins, and those are still below where they stood before the pandemic. Combined with the normalization of the cost base, owing to substantially less furlough and short-term work this year, that produced declining earnings in the third quarter. With that, I’ll hand things over to Florian Wieser, who will take a closer look at the financial performance of the past quarter.

Florian Wieser

executive
#13

Thanks a lot, Karsten, and good morning, everyone on the call. I'll now take you through the quarterly figures in detail, beginning with how our sales developed on slide 14. As Karsten said earlier, the 8% adjusted sales growth we posted in the third quarter came primarily from countries where COVID-19 restrictions were not stringent. Those countries more than offset the sales decline in the DACH region, where we struggled with the major effect of temporary store closures in Germany caused by the pandemic. Our results in Spain, Italy and Turkey deserve particular mention. We recorded high growth there, driven by continued robust demand for consumer electronics. On top of that, sales got a lift from successful campaigns, such as the one tied to the UEFA European Championship. Our group brick-and-mortar sales growth benefited from the lockdown situation a year earlier. Meanwhile, our online sales increased from an already elevated level, as the next slide shows. The trend toward shopping online with MediaMarktSaturn carried on. It was even more pronounced in countries still hit by restrictions, which shows how strong our omni-channel model is. Also, online sales as a proportion of total sales edged down slightly.

Florian Wieser

executive
#14

Absolute online sales climbed over 3%. Given how high the comparison base was, that's a remarkable outcome. Naturally, the lockdown conditions and sales restrictions in Germany and the Netherlands alike helped drive that substantial uptick in online sales. In nearly every country, both the conversion rate and the average online checkout value stood significantly above last year's level. What's more, we're especially delighted that we added 1.5 million new online customers and that our pickup ratio climbed significantly, by 10 percentage points versus prior year. That's clear proof our customers greatly value our omni-channel model. As customers grow more accustomed to shopping online with us, our web shop doesn't merely offset COVID-related restrictions — it's also a core channel for reaching our customers. In numbers, our online sales share went from 21.6% the prior year to 36.3% this year across the nine-month period. Naturally, the online sales share shifts from quarter to quarter, and there are clear differences depending on whether our stores were open or closed. Still, we believe a trend is already apparent regardless of the lockdowns. We expect the online share to stay high even once the severe COVID restrictions have eased.

Florian Wieser

executive
#15

Actually, we're interested to find out if that online portion might climb even higher now that customers are able to shop with us as things return to the new normal—particularly during the Black Friday and Christmas periods. Regardless, both our organization and our systems are ready. Our services and solutions business performed nicely in the third quarter. On a like-for-like basis, sales for services and solutions rose roughly 18%, which held the sales share steady at 5.5%. Against the second quarter's sales share figure of 4.6%, we succeeded in narrowing the distance to the pre-COVID level of approximately 6%. For one thing, as COVID restrictions ended across many countries, customers were able to come into our stores for advice. For another, better web shop offerings and features produced an encouraging rise in our online services attach rate. The present shift toward more transactional shopping behavior, especially in Germany, weighed on how services and solutions performed. With COVID restrictions expected to ease, our service and solutions offerings continuing to expand, subscription models getting stronger, and a clear emphasis on services, we intend to push our services and solutions sales higher on the way to our midterm ambition.

Florian Wieser

executive
#16

Turning to gross margin, it was broadly flat versus a year earlier. In Q2, gross margin had fallen 230 basis points year on year, so we saw a meaningful improvement in the trend. Even so, gross margin stayed near 16%, still far under the almost 19% seen before the pandemic. We had a headwind in Q2 from the channel shift, while lower online sales in Q3 versus a year ago produced a modest positive effect from that same shift. Continued margin pressure came mainly from a growing new media share and a tougher promotional climate with competitive pricing. The year-ago quarter featured a strong demand lift following the first pandemic wave, with low campaigning intensity. On a brighter note, gross margin was helped by the rebound in service and solutions and by the reversal in Q2 of a temporary negative stock-related margin effect. Overall, we expect room for margin gains as COVID-19 restrictions ease and thanks to the impact of various initiatives in areas such as logistics and pricing. Now let's turn to OpEx development. On the surface, our cost structure worsened by roughly 1 percentage point.

Florian Wieser

executive
#17

The reason for this was that the extensive COVID-related subsidies from last year were discontinued, particularly for short-term working. During the quarter a year earlier, we had the benefit of roughly EUR 180 million in COVID-related savings, versus EUR 40 million in the quarter we just reported. Normalized, our OpEx ratio got better by 2.3 percentage points, which reflects continued strict cost discipline, the advantages of our new operating model, and lower location costs. Taking everything together, the normalization of the cost base, along with a goods margin that remains under pre-COVID levels, produced lower earnings in the third quarter. Adjusted EBIT fell by EUR 48 million compared with a year earlier. That decline came entirely from the DACH segment. Germany was the primary factor, together with the substantial effect of that country's COVID-related restrictions, which brought about a lower gross margin and smaller COVID-related cost savings than in the prior year. Earnings in Western and Southern Europe were roughly at the same level as a year earlier. In Spain, robust sales growth and a better gross margin — mainly because income from service and solution recovered — more than offset the normalization of the cost base. In Italy, underlying operating earnings likewise rose, helped by higher sales and margin.

Florian Wieser

executive
#18

In the Netherlands, by contrast, severe COVID restrictions weighed on the result. On top of that, greater campaign intensity created peer pressure on margin and earnings there. In Eastern Europe, adjusted EBIT came in higher thanks to positive results in both Poland and Turkey. Within the Others segment, continued positive sales performance in Sweden offset the associated cost of the growing digital share. Conversely, holding costs at CECONOMY rose slightly, which led to a stable segment result. Let me now turn from EBIT to EPS. Reported EBIT for Q3 came in slightly below adjusted EBIT, mainly because of non-recurring effects. Those are roughly evenly divided among COVID-related store closures, the introduction of our new operating model, and expenses stemming from the Convergenta transaction, as well as the reorganization and simplification of our corporate structure. A portion of the remaining non-recurring expenses will be incurred in Q4. Beyond that, a certain amount of trading restructuring expenses will come through in the new financial year. Regardless of the phasing, however, the total amount of non-recurring expenses tied to the program remains unchanged. On savings, I am very pleased to report that we are hitting our targeted savings run rate of EUR 100 million much sooner than expected.

Florian Wieser

executive
#19

So we're tracking well against our operational cost efficiency targets. In Q3, the reported EBIT decline was more than compensated for by a better financial result and a tax effect. That improvement in our financial result came largely from yet another dividend payment out of M.Video. On top of that, we've observed some favorable movements in exchange rates. On a nine-month basis, the tax rate stands at 20% under the integral approach we apply as the fiscal year progresses. The non-tax effective reversal of the Fnac Darty impairment contributed positively here. Keep in mind that this tax rate doesn't yet capture any benefits tied to acquiring the MediaMarktSaturn minority stake, because those depend on the transaction closing. Taking everything together, EPS for the third quarter landed EUR 0.10 above the prior-year figure. Now let's turn to free cash flow. During the nine-month period, free cash flow was shaped primarily by the negative working capital change. First, our trade payables sat at a high level when the last fiscal year ended, and that's the starting point for the development you see here. As you may recall, we intentionally built up inventory at the close of the last fiscal year so that availability would be sufficient for the exceptionally strong peak season in 2020.

Florian Wieser

executive
#20

Second, given continuing supply chain problems, particularly out of Asian markets, we chose to raise inventory levels during the third quarter of this fiscal year. As for tax payments, the special COVID-19 circumstances in both the prior year and the current year are plainly evident. During the prior year, we had Corona-related tax deferrals along with reductions in advanced tax payments. Those produced a reversal effect this year. Going forward, the same two negative factors weighing on net working capital will still apply at year-end. Along with restructuring-related cash outflows, anticipated tax and lease payments, and cash investments of roughly EUR 250 million, free cash flow will most likely be negative for the full year. Clearly, this year's development is strongly shaped by non-sustainable effects and by deliberate decisions to build up inventory given supply risk from Asia. It therefore should not be viewed as an indication for future years. Operational improvements will additionally help generate positive free cash flows in future. We are looking ahead on every front. That is also well reflected in the recent completion of our post-pandemic financing structure. In May, we laid the foundation by signing new ESG-linked syndicated revolving credit facilities totaling EUR 1.1 billion.

Florian Wieser

executive
#21

Back in June, we issued our first bond — a EUR 500 million, five-year senior unsecured note — which strengthened our long-term financing structure. That step has now enabled us to end our syndicated revolving loan agreement, in which the KfW Investment and Development Bank took part. As you're aware, the EUR 1.7 billion KfW loan facility was signed in May 2020, during the first wave of the COVID pandemic, and it added to the credit facilities we already had at the time. That KfW loan acted purely as a backup line and was never drawn. Overall, this new setup supports our ongoing prudent financial policy and still lets us meet liquidity needs even in extraordinary times. That wraps up the financial section. Before turning to the outlook, I'd like to touch briefly on another matter, the Convergenta transaction. Until recently, we had anticipated that the deal would close before this financial year ended. Unfortunately, there has been a delay. Let me sum up where things currently stand. In February, we were pleased that roughly 99% of the shareholders' votes cast at our general meeting approved the transaction. To be clear, the preference shareholders voted together with the ordinary shareholders on the resolution concerning the transaction.

Florian Wieser

executive
#22

What's behind this is that the preference shareholders' vote had been revised after dividend payments were suspended for the last three financial years. Even though approval at our annual general meeting was overwhelming, the resolution was challenged and a lawsuit was filed by a few individual shareholders. On the 8th of July, in the approval proceedings, the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court set out negative preliminary legal views. Because of that, and so that the parties involved have transaction certainty, we are looking at either repeating the resolution on the transaction with the vote of shareholders in their respective classes, or resuming dividend payments. The latter would mean the preferred shareholders' voting rights would be retracted. All in all, these recent developments have inevitably delayed the closing of the transaction. Once we have analyzed and weighed up our options, we will let you know how we will proceed. Please rest assured that we remain committed to closing the transaction to the best benefit of the entire company. Despite the delay, we remain focused on strategically and operationally steering the business through this phase of transformation with a newly established uniform management structure.

Florian Wieser

executive
#23

Now let's turn to the outlook. I'll begin with a few remarks about current trading. It's encouraging that our sales momentum right now sits well above where it was before the pandemic and is only a bit under last year's figure, which had been lifted by an exceptional catch-up in demand once the first lockdown restrictions were relaxed. That shows how strong and lasting the underlying appetite for consumer electronics is. Our online business keeps expanding, and our online share is still at a high level. For Q4, we anticipate the online share coming in above last year's 16.1%. In Germany, where tough restrictions lasted through June, frequency is recovering gradually. Overall customer frequency remains under pre-pandemic levels. Shoppers are leaning toward more focused buying behavior, reflected in a larger average basket and better conversion, alongside lower frequency. We're also still seeing a positive contribution from services and solutions, particularly our SmartBar services in stores and our extended warranty offers, both of which are seeing strong demand. On costs, our efficiency initiatives keep paying off and are supporting the results. That said, do bear in mind that Q4 EBIT last year benefited from COVID-19 subsidies of roughly EUR 20 million, which we don't expect to repeat this quarter.

Florian Wieser

executive
#24

Given where trends stand right now and the business development achieved so far, our outlook for this financial year has been revised. Clearly, uncertainty about how the pandemic will evolve is still with us. So our outlook takes as a given that no new restrictions will close stores, and that COVID-19 will cause no additional impact across the rest of the period that might hit the business once more. We also assume global supply chain imbalances will not worsen. For financial year 2021, we now anticipate a slight to moderate rise in currency and portfolio adjusted sales versus the prior year. Beyond that, adjusted EBIT, excluding associates, is expected to land in the range of EUR 210 million-EUR 250 million. Considering the difficult environment and factoring in how long and how severely the restrictions lasted, this strikes me as a very solid outlook for the full year. I'll now hand back to Karsten for his closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#25

Thank you, Florian. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to close out today's call with a few brief remarks, and I'll share my main takeaways. We're reflecting on a financial year marked by a highly difficult environment. Even so, amid these extraordinary circumstances, we delivered a very solid performance, and on an underlying basis we also achieved significant improvements across many areas that will pay off down the road. As we look forward, plenty of work remains, yet we're on the right path, and we'll be very well-positioned for the period after Corona, and we will seize our opportunities across all channels. More broadly, the consumer electronics market remains, and will continue to be, an attractive growth market, and we are well-poised to benefit from the opportunities over the longer term. Our company has everything it needs to play a leading role in this market — the right strategy, the necessary expertise, and above all, the right attitude. That brings me to the end of today's presentation. Thank you everyone for your attention. I'll now hand the call over to the moderator for your questions.

Operator

operator
#26

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now start the question-and-answer portion. To ask a question, you can press zero, then one, on your touch-tone phone. Should you want to take yourself out of the queue, press zero followed by two. If speaker equipment is what you're using today, please pick up the handset before you make your selections. Anyone with a question can press zero, then one, at this point. Please hold for a moment while we get the first question. Our first question comes from Clément Genelot of Bryan Garnier. Your line is open now. Please proceed.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#27

Yes, thank you. Good morning, everyone. From my end, I have three questions, if I may. The first concerns the guidance. In the prior one, back in mid-May, were there two scenarios with EBIT rising or falling year-on-year? This updated guidance still implies EBIT, so how can it be either up or down year-on-year? Does that suggest you have no more visibility at present than you did in May? My other question also relates to the guidance. I'd just like a view on which moving parts sit behind your guidance. Is it entirely about in-store operating leverage, services sales, or more back margins from brands and suppliers? My last one concerns Germany. Do you have any insight into the financial shape of Unix Annexberg in that country? Do you believe some Unix members are genuinely in a bad shape? Why not be willing to perhaps join the market? Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#28

Thanks, Clément. Florian will handle the first two questions about the guidance, and I’ll address your third question. Florian, go ahead.

Florian Wieser

executive
#29

Sure, I'm glad to talk about the guidance. Right now our visibility is far better than it was in May, or in February when we suspended that guidance. The only reason we could give you guidance yesterday comes down to the restrictions we were up against, particularly in Germany, our core market. We talked at length about those restrictions and about how hard and complicated the situation was for us and for our customers. At this point we can plainly see frequency coming back. We've had an uplift in service and solutions, and that has now produced the new guidance, which has a clear corridor of between EUR 210 million and EUR 250 million. The scenarios we gave on the Q2 call were simply scenarios, with no expectations attached. We only said it could come in below the prior year or it could come in above the prior year. Now we have a precise, clear range. Hitting this range and this EBIT guidance will hinge on the frequency continuing to improve the way we see it now. It will hinge on consumer sentiment continuing to get better. It will hinge on the uplift in services and solutions that we can currently see plainly and that pleased us very much in the third quarter.

Florian Wieser

executive
#30

You also brought up the supplier contracts. As you're aware, a substantial portion of our supplier income is incurred at the close of our fiscal year. On that point, we remain positive. Sales development has been favorable across the first nine months, as you can see. We're clearly ahead of the prior year, and in those same first nine months our sales development also exceeds fiscal year 2018/2019, which had not yet been affected by any pandemic-related impacts. From where we stand right now, we have no concerns. Those, I believe, are the primary implications we see at present, and they drove the new guidance that was published yesterday. I hope that answers your question.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#31

Let me address the third question you raised — how the German consumer shops, and what lies ahead. Research is currently underway, and from the studies I've reviewed, in recent days in fact, a few points stand out. To begin with, COVID has sped up particular shifts in how consumers behave. In my opinion, that should keep fueling demand for consumer technology. We've likewise observed robust growth online, particularly in grocery shopping, and many consumers say — in other sectors, mind you — that they genuinely can't wait to get out and shop again, which I consider welcome news. Next, people show a growing readiness to put money into the home office. Considerable consumer spending has already occurred, along with a rising willingness to pay for quality. We're also seeing categories such as urban mobility and health and wellbeing products expand. For us, I believe this is a key category to develop further. We'll keep investing in those areas. As for the question about competitors and their financial shape: look, I clearly cannot comment on how the competition is doing financially, and I'll hold back from that.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#32

Let me give a quick overview of what we’re seeing right now in terms of market dynamics around Europe. Pressure is building in consumer electronics. In certain markets, we’ve also watched competitors leave — Italy and Spain, for example. In Spain, we recently picked up 17 stores from a local rival. What I’d say is that selective consolidation at the local level can also be useful for filling in white spots. We’ll be monitoring that closely. One final point that I find quite interesting and revealing: whenever we expand our local footprint, online sales in that catchment area go up as well — an insight I think matters a great deal. I hope that addresses the questions.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#33

Yes, of course. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#34

Thanks. Our following question comes from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux, whose line is open now. Please proceed.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#35

Morning, and thanks for joining, Karsten. I have two questions. The first concerns the Convergenta transaction. If you choose the dividend route, what dividend payback would you owe the preferred shareholders? We’d like a sense of the millions involved—how much are we talking about there? My second question is about input cost inflation. We’re seeing input cost inflation also affecting the consumer electronics market. In Germany, for instance, we think Amazon is very active. I was wondering whether you could share your view on the possibility of passing inflation on to consumers, or whether you see main competitors such as Amazon using this to put more pressure on prices, and how you see that developing going forward? My third question is specifically about Germany. In Q3, the like-for-like was not that bad at minus 2.8%, given that Germany was closed, store-wise, for the bulk of the quarter. Could you give us a bit more granularity on the like-for-like in Germany—perhaps say whether it was a mid or high single digit decline in like-for-like terms in the quarter?

Fabienne Caron

executive
#36

Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#37

Let me address the first two questions briefly, and Florian will take the third. Fabienne, on the question about dividends: no decision has been made on whether a dividend will be paid. We're currently working through the path forward in detail. What I can tell you is that we're fully committed and confident a solution will be found, and we'll update you on further progress as soon as we're in a position to discuss it and share the details. At this moment, and I'd ask for your understanding, there's nothing more we can disclose. A great deal of work is underway, I can assure you of that. On the second question, regarding input cost inflation: yes, we are experiencing growing price pressure from suppliers throughout the supply chain. Of course, this will also result in higher recommended retail prices. We're monitoring this very closely, since what's at stake is profitability. The clear expectation is that we'll succeed in passing on the higher prices. That applies across all the sectors, and we're being very careful when it comes to profitability here. With that, I'll hand over to Florian.

Florian Wieser

executive
#38

Yeah. On Germany, like-for-like sales, I completely agree, held up decently considering the very complicated circumstances we're dealing with around all this incident-based regulation. All in all, we recorded a mid-single digit decline in sales in Germany for Q3. As we said in our remarks, we're genuinely seeing some encouraging signals at this point. Sales are trending upward. Consumer sentiment looks more positive already in July and in current trading, August. That was one of the main factors behind essentially the new guidance we put out yesterday.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#39

Thanks. Let me follow up on what Karsten mentioned. Does that also mean your main competitors are raising their prices too?

Florian Wieser

executive
#40

Yeah. I think it breaks down into two parts. First, the environment is noticeably more promotional. Compared with Q3 of last year, there was hardly any campaigning, including from competitors, and that produced a more favorable gross margin level. We also noted that gross margin came under pressure in Q3. That's one part. We also had Amazon Prime Day in June. That's one market impact that is putting pressure on margins. The second question, or the second part, is whether competitors are raising prices in response to rising supplier prices. That is something we can clearly observe. We can clearly see suppliers raising prices, and we can also see that some competitors are essentially passing along part of those increases. It's also fair to say there's still no clear trend at present. It's still too early to comment on a reliable trend. You saw our approach: we deliberately raised our inventory. We have significantly more inventory than last year because we've seen supply chain restrictions and wanted to make sure we have availability. I think we need to watch the next two to three months to see what the trend is.

Florian Wieser

executive
#41

As you’re aware, we use artificial intelligence for pricing, and we watch our competitors’ responses closely, then respond in line with what we see.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#42

All right, thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#43

Thanks. We have no more questions right now, so just a reminder—if you'd like to ask something, press zero then one at this point. We have a follow-up from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux. Your line is open.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#44

Let me take this chance to circle back once more. There are a few modeling questions, mostly coming from Florian. I somewhat lost track of the non-recurring items. Could you remind me what amount we should expect in Q4, and what portion of that will be cash? My next question would be about the slide where you present the four blocks for the gross margin movement — would you be able to quantify those four blocks a bit more? Thank you.

Florian Wieser

executive
#45

Yes. I'll begin with gross margin. Essentially, I'll start with the favorable items. Service and solutions gave us a positive contribution. We cited 18% like-for-like growth in Q3, and we observed corresponding favorable margin effects from services. We also saw the unfavorable effect of goods valuation in Q2. You may recall that on the previous quarterly call, we stated this goods valuation effect would essentially reverse in Q3, and that is exactly what happened. A favorable effect from goods valuation. There was some favorable effect from other income, also from governmental subsidies. Those were the three favorable items and, as you're aware, the gross margin stayed broadly at the prior year level. The unfavorable effect was on the goods margin, and the main driver behind the unfavorable goods margin development was the far more promotional environment that we saw in Q3. I believe that covers the gross margin development. On non-recurring items, your first question, I believe you're referring to the new operating model.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#46

Right.

Florian Wieser

executive
#47

During Q3, we recorded a total of EUR 12 million, and that amount was really split across the three components. It went to the Cesar transaction, to the new operating model and the stores, and to the remainder of the year. We still have slightly more than EUR 60 million that is going to be booked. Those items remain open, and we expect certain of these parts to be booked in Q4, with the rest then booked in the new financial year. There is still no precise guidance on this, because we also basically depend on some restrictions in the countries. We cannot give you an exact figure right now as to when these costs will be precisely booked, but we still expect the full program to be booked in Q4 and then in the next financial year.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#48

Could you remind me about that EUR 60 million in Q4 — will it be cash relevant or not?

Florian Wieser

executive
#49

Are you referring to the one among those 3?

Fabienne Caron

executive
#50

Would that be in cash or close? Yes.

Florian Wieser

executive
#51

Nope.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#52

No, that one is non-cash. All right.

Florian Wieser

executive
#53

No, one more time—please don't expect that entire EUR 60 million to land in Q4. A substantial portion of it will also come in the following financial year.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#54

Alright, thanks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#55

You're going to see a bit of spillover from that.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#56

Mm-hmm. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#57

Our next question comes from Lorenzo Margiotta at Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Lorenzo Margiotta

analyst
#58

Morning, everyone. I believe during the presentation you mentioned that the attach rate for services and solutions online is going up. Could you share some detail or give us a sense of where that now stands relative to attachment rates in stores?

Florian Wieser

executive
#59

Sure, I'm glad to address that. It's a really encouraging pattern we saw in Q3. We put substantial effort into this area, since the weaker attachment rate online genuinely concerned us throughout the lockdown period. The share of service income from online nearly doubled in Q3 versus the same quarter a year earlier. What we did, first of all, was enhance the customer journey, so that services appear far more prominently in our web shop, and essentially, for a product's customer journey, we've now made services a fully integrated part of that journey. Second, previously it wasn't always feasible to choose more than 1 service within the web shop. We've now upgraded our functionalities, and today our customers can also attach multiple services to a single product purchase. Those, I'd say, are the two main substantive changes we made, and they're clearly visible. Finally, of course, as I mentioned, we need to place still greater emphasis on services. Services have always received strong emphasis, but we keep tirelessly refining what we offer and the attention we give it, and I believe that attention is now plainly reflected in an improved figure.

Lorenzo Margiotta

analyst
#60

Appreciate it. That makes sense.

Operator

operator
#61

Thanks. The next follow-up question comes from Clément Genelot at Bryan Garnier. Go ahead, please.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#62

Okay, one more question from me. Are you still running into some obstacles in Germany that are affecting traffic in stores — things like revised or negative tests in certain areas? Thanks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#63

Yes. When it comes to store traffic in Germany, that's genuinely the complicated picture Karsten described during his remarks. What we have observed there is that the regulations governing how you may enter a shop in Germany truly vary from one store to the next. Not long ago I spoke with a store manager who oversees seven locations within a single German region, and she stated plainly that seven separate sets of rules exist regarding which customers are permitted inside. Above all, we must ensure we follow those regulations, and the government inspects them fairly often. At the same time, shoppers ended up quite bewildered. Certain regions performed better, while others performed worse. Broadly speaking, the point we aim to make is that, in our view, other European governments handled the task of providing unambiguous rules more effectively. Clear rules applied across the whole country — and what made frequency so challenging in Germany, something the figures make plainly evident, is that regulation tied to incident rates genuinely produced an effect on frequency. Karsten, I believe, can offer you additional detail on that.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#64

Naturally, this is a changing picture. We also came to see that early on, high street spots took a bigger hit, since shoppers weren't heading into city centers as much. Recovery came quicker for us in places where stores sit outside the centers with parking, or in shopping-center-style sites. At this point we're also seeing city centers bounce back, and of course this remains a shifting situation. It was essentially rules-based, and we're watching a steady recovery, though somewhat slow, and I'm hopeful, also given consumer sentiment, that things will get back to, hopefully, normal.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#65

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#66

That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer session. I'll now turn things over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations, for some closing remarks.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#67

That wraps up today's results call, everyone. We appreciate your time and your questions. If anything else comes up, as always, don't hesitate to reach out to us at Investor Relations. We're looking forward to speaking with you. Take care, stay well, and goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.