Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
December 14, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Sebastian Kauffmann
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us on this Q4 12-month Results Call today. Our CEO, Karsten Wildberger, and CFO, Florian Wieser, are here alongside me. They will walk you through the presentation for today. Before we begin, a few customary items need covering. First, this call is being recorded, and a replay will be posted on our website later today. Second, please keep in mind that today's presentation and possibly some responses to your questions may include forward-looking statements. For more details on that, kindly see the disclaimer. I'll now turn things over to our CEO, Karsten Wildberger.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you, Sebastian, and good morning to all of you. I appreciate your attendance at our full year results presentation today. Let me begin by saying that, without a doubt, this has been quite a year. Financial year 2020 to 2021 served as a genuine stress test for our company, and pass this test we did. Even though the second COVID wave struck us with restrictions that were longer and more severe than those of the previous year, we succeeded in growing our top line. In fact, in countries where COVID restrictions had less of an impact, we also raised our EBIT. Our omnichannel business model demonstrated great resilience, and having our online operations closely integrated with our bricks and mortar business was a significant advantage during that period. Thanks to growth in our online business, we were actually able to overcompensate for the COVID-induced decline in our stores. Above all, our performance stands as proof of the quality of our teams, and I want to use this opportunity to thank each and every colleague for what they delivered. Finally, I would like to point out that, furthermore, the market for consumer electronics has shown itself to be attractive and keeps offering great potential. One more important point: we were also in a position to terminate the syndicated loan facility involving the KfW, which, incidentally, we had never used.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThanks to the new financing setup, we've got enough backup liquidity to see us through the years ahead, including tough stretches. Moving to slide five. So what does that look like in figures? We lifted sales 3.8% to roughly EUR 21.4 billion, even with stores shut in countries like Germany and the Netherlands. Once you adjust for currency and portfolio effects, that number also sits above the pre-pandemic mark from two years earlier, in fiscal year 2018/2019. On the bottom line, operating profit came in at EUR 237 million, which matches the prior year's level. Under these conditions, we've shown operational strength and hit the full year targets we laid out in August. Naturally, that was only possible because our customers stayed loyal to us through the pandemic, and we'll keep working hard to earn their trust day after day. Moving on to slide six. Ladies and gentlemen, I've now spent a little over the famous 100 days at CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn. Much like what I said soon after joining in August, I can tell you that the solid progress happening beneath the surface in many areas of our business frequently goes unnoticed, because the market conditions we operate in are so volatile and challenging.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThat said, our team is extremely driven and adept at running this company, including when conditions get rough. We tackle near-term difficulties while simultaneously carrying out our Omnichannel strategy. Even with today's tough market environment, I believe the consumer electronics sector overall stays highly appealing, and I have confidence that we'll keep getting better at capitalizing on our exceptionally large customer reach and demand. Slide seven offers some key facts and figures on our business to give you added perspective. The first point I want to highlight: we see 2.5 billion customer visits and contacts each year throughout all our touchpoints, both online and in our stores. That's a tremendous asset. Our customer reach ranks among the highest in Europe, and the onus is now on us to keep enhancing how we capitalize on this huge potential and to strengthen our customer relationships. In fact, we hold the number one or number two market share position in eight countries across Europe. Turning to our online business, it has more than doubled over the past two and a half years, and we've become one of Europe's biggest online retailers. We're linking our stores ever more closely with our online operations so that the customer experience becomes increasingly seamless.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveOver one-third of our online customers actually opt to collect their orders at one of our stores. To wrap up, our Omnichannel strategy is the correct route. Let's move to slide eight. Naturally, it's also evident that far more remains to be done for us to become a genuinely customer-obsessed company. It's also time to recognize how significantly we have already transformed and reinvented ourselves. This is something I want to emphasize. We've been shifting quickly from a transaction-centric business, where customers simply pick up a product, to an experience business, where advice and service have become a key part of our customer promise. We track customer satisfaction using the Net Promoter Score, NPS, at touchpoints and along processes. Last year, we raised the NPS across the company by five points to 47. That's a good number, but we aim for more. Second, MediaMarktSaturn's heritage is a highly decentralized business model, yet we have been moving toward what I call a smart central organization. Today, we leverage central capabilities in category management, logistics, or process design far better. On the decentralized side, we keep leveraging our entrepreneurial power. To date, we've implemented roughly 75% of the respective organizational changes that we laid out, and we exceed our cost targets.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveFlorian Wieser is going to cover this in more detail a little later on. As of today, we're not purely a bricks and mortar retailer anymore. Our Omnichannel journey is picking up speed, we've embraced digitization completely, and during the last financial year our online business posted 65% growth. And now we've entered a new stage in the way we develop our business. I think there was a period when we were repairing things, and at this point we're shifting toward generating new opportunities as well. A solid illustration of that is the way we launched our marketplace and are now scaling it. Plenty of other items deserve mention and are still ahead, and later on I'll come back to add more color on the marketplace. Let's move to slide number nine. Our efforts at enhancing the customer experience will be doubled down across the whole customer journey, since this extends far past selling. Both online and offline, we're already upgrading our service and expert advice. Forward logistics and reverse logistics are getting better too. A growing portion of our business is after-sale service. Take Germany, for example: last year, in our Smartbar stores, we repaired roughly 500,000 smartphones. In Spain, personalized service allowed us to lift our after-sales NPS considerably.
Karsten Wildberger
executivePlease turn to slide 10. You can see our online business progress very clearly. Keep in mind that not long ago, MediaMarktSaturn was mainly an offline retailer with a webshop bolted on. In financial year 2018 to 19, two and a half years back, the online share was under 14%, and sales were below EUR 3 billion. During the past financial year, online sales reached about EUR 7 billion, which made up one-third of our share. We've succeeded in bringing our Omnichannel capabilities together more effectively online. Nowadays, we can uphold a 29-minute click and collect customer promise. So you place your order online, and 29 minutes later you can collect it at the store. Nearly 40% of our customers take advantage of and enjoy this service. Here's another example on slide 11. Rejuvenating our bricks and mortar business through our standard store investment program is also a key part of our strategy. Each time we refurbish, relocate or launch a new store, we apply one of our four new store formats: the Core, the Lighthouse, the Smart, and the Xpress format. These formats meet all the different customer needs and give us more location-specific opportunities. That brings me to our Lighthouse store, since I believe it holds great potential and showcases so many aspects of our business.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAt our Lighthouse locations — right now those are Milan and Rotterdam — we provide genuine journeys of technology discovery. Beyond discovery alone, this is a highly commercial store, an extremely successful format delivering roughly 20%-30% uptake in traffic along with substantially higher revenues and margins. Our suppliers and partners feel enthusiastic about this format too, and they join forces and invest alongside us by operating somewhere between 20 and 30 branded boutiques within each Lighthouse store. I actually get phone calls and questions on a regular basis, since partners wish to take part in future Lighthouses as well. We'll keep rolling out the Lighthouse concept, and next year we will also open the first one in Germany. Every one of our formats pays dividends to our ambition of offering competent advice, a super attractive product range, and great service, and they are increasingly connected with our online business for the benefit of our customers. Let me now move to slide 12 and the marketplace. That's another piece of our Omnichannel strategy. We launched our German marketplace in summer 2020, and we are surpassing our internal growth plans and kept growing strongly over the last months. At present, we offer around 300,000 products from more than 400 retailers on this platform, with a special focus on categories such as gaming, IT or the whole coffee section, especially coffee machines.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveBack in October of this year, the marketplace also launched in Spain, and we intend to bring it to Austria and the Netherlands during 2022. What this demonstrates is that we've managed to put the IT infrastructure for a marketplace like this successfully in place and have already validated our concept within the first year. From here, our focus will be on scaling it up and taking the marketplace into additional countries. Before handing things over to Florian Wieser, I'd like to move to slide 13 and spend a moment on sustainability. That's a crucial topic, and today I also want to point out the progress we've made on ESG more broadly. To us, sustainability isn't merely something tacked onto our strategy — it forms part of who we are and what we stand for. That's why, over the past financial year, we've put together our comprehensive sustainability roadmap, which rests on two main pillars. The first pillar: our foremost goal is to make our own business operations more sustainable. As an example, we're aiming to have 100% of our electricity come from renewable sources by the end of 2023. We're on a solid path to getting there even sooner. Other areas of focus include cutting down on packaging materials, auditing our supply chain for compliance with labor and human rights, and cultivating a more diverse culture and workplace.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThe second pillar is our goal of being the top pick for customers when it comes to sustainable consumer electronics products and services. First, we're steadily broadening what we offer in sustainable products. Our assortment and services portfolio already include over 1,000 certified sustainable products. We'll also motivate and assist customers in purchasing sustainable items. You can see our BetterWay label there in the green box on the right-hand corner. That BetterWay label is meant to give customers proper guidance. During the last financial year, for example, we saved 11,000 tons of e-waste, and we succeeded in reselling nearly 98% of products that customers sent back to us. We sold nearly 200,000 green electricity contracts as well. Our steady emphasis on sustainability also shows up in the reorganized financing structure of our company. My dear colleague, Florian Wieser, will now explain more details on this and much more. Over to you, Florian.
Florian Wieser
executiveThank you, and good morning to everyone joining today's call. I completely share your view, Karsten. It has been a very turbulent year. What we achieved financially demonstrates that we got a lot of things right. With severe restrictions in place for nearly the whole year, we posted a resilient performance. Thanks to our integrated business model, our far-sighted and courageous actions, and the lift from our online activities, we reached the updated targets we set for the full year. Let me take you through the results in more detail now, beginning with the fourth quarter. The fourth quarter of the prior year got a boost from pent-up demand, which came after stores reopened following the first COVID wave and after VAT reductions in Germany. Against that backdrop, we delivered sales at nearly the same level in this year's quarter. On EBIT, we actually recorded an increase, as better operating efficiency more than offset a more competitive environment. For the full year, sales rose by roughly 4%, and adjusted EBIT came in at prior year's level. Karsten and I have said this a couple of times, I know. Still, this is a great operational achievement given the longer-lasting and much more severe restrictions over the course of the last fiscal year.
Florian Wieser
executiveNow let's turn to slide 16. Better processes, stronger skills, and reduced costs are key reasons behind this achievement. All of those areas benefited from our new operating model. During our Q3 results call, we noted that implementation of this model is well advanced. We surpassed our savings goals, which were set at over EUR 100 million. In addition, we completed two-thirds of the store closures we had planned during the last fiscal year. Altogether, we spent just above EUR 120 million on these actions. The remaining EUR 55 million-EUR 60 million will be recorded in the present financial year, 2021/2022. Alongside finalizing organizational target structures, these costs will arise from chosen store closures and reductions in space. Turning back to sales, customers' appetite for shopping online with MediaMarktSaturn remained unbroken. A higher average checkout value largely powered the 25% increase in online sales during Q4. The pickup ratio rose by four percentage points, getting back above 40%, which matches our targeted range. Our solid online results offset a 7% drop in brick-and-mortar sales, tied to customer frequency that has not yet recovered. Across the full year, online growth was even stronger.
Florian Wieser
executiveThat also tied back to COVID restrictions, particularly in Germany and the Netherlands. With online sales of almost EUR 7 billion and an online sales share of around 33%, we have done a huge achievement. Both of those are evidence of our successful efforts we put into our capabilities and our logistics processes. During last fiscal year, we have been facing large swings resulting from store restrictions. After the end of COVID-19 related store restrictions, the online share remained on an elevated level. The clear message for us is to further drive the underlying online growth and to work on our omnichannel processes, providing a seamless shopping experience regardless of the channel. Let's move to slide 19 and our services and solutions performance. Next to online, service and solutions performed well in the fourth quarter. The full year performance was impacted by temporary store closures and a more transactional business as less customers sought advice in our stores. In line with our omnichannel approach, we now increasingly attract customers to our services online. As a result, we could already observe strongly improving services sales online in the fourth quarter. To mention some examples, we have upgraded our recommendation engine for online customers actively proposing the most relevant services by product.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn top of that, we've expanded our lineup of ready-to-use solutions by bundling a product into a solution ahead of time. Take a console, for instance—it can be bought with games already installed, or a laptop comes with Office and antivirus software already set up. TV calibration remains very popular with customers in our stores. Now let's turn to slide 20 and gross margin. During Q4, gross margin held roughly flat versus the same quarter a year earlier. Gross margin declined by 230 basis points in the second quarter and by 20 basis points in the third. We faced headwinds from the shift toward the online channel, a less favorable sales mix, and a more competitive environment. Because of process improvements and our active inventory management—selling down stock we had secured early in the year—the negative effects were kept in check. In addition, strong results in service and solutions contributed positively to our margin. Let's proceed to our OpEx development on slide 21. As we did previously, we adjusted the cost ratios shown on this chart for any COVID-related subsidies, and those were substantially lower in this year's quarter. Largely thanks to the success and rapid rollout of our initiatives, such as the new operating model, we're seeing a substantial underlying reduction of roughly 50 basis points in a normalized OpEx ratio.
Florian Wieser
executiveCosts matter for any retailer—they’re a critical success factor—and of course we’ll keep working hard on our cost base to support the group’s profitability. Slide 22 summarizes how our four reporting segments performed in Q4. It’s clear that the blended sales decrease and the EBIT increase at group level come from mixed performance across the segments. While the DACH region lost on sales and EBIT, all remaining segments contributed to the EBIT improvement. In Western and Southern Europe, a slight sales decline was more than offset by pleasing margin development, especially in Italy and Spain. Turkey contributed to the positive sales performance in Eastern Europe in local currency. At plus EUR 10 million year-on-year, negative EBIT contributions from segment Others declined significantly. This was mainly due to a continued pleasing improvement in Sweden and lower group holding costs. Now quickly moving to reported financials and EPS with full focus on the full year. While our adjusted EBIT came in on prior year’s level, reported EBIT was far higher year-on-year. This was mainly due to the Fnac Darty impairment in the previous year and the partial reversal of that in this year. Our financial results benefited from higher dividends coming from M.Video and METRO PROPERTIES in this year.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn the income tax side, or regarding the tax rate, please remember that the Fnac Darty impairment, along with its reversal, has no tax effect. Beyond that, the tax rate doesn't yet capture any benefits tied to acquiring the MediaMarktSaturn minority stake. That will only occur once this transaction closes. Taking everything together, for the full year, earnings per share reached EUR 0.62. That represents an improvement of nearly EUR 1.30. Now let's turn to free cash flow. Consistent with earlier quarters, free cash flow was driven primarily by a negative movement in net working capital. As you may recall, our trade payables stood at a particularly high level last September. That elevated level stemmed from a higher order volume in the prior year's fourth quarter, driven by the strong pent-up demand already mentioned. In the current year, we intentionally raised our stock levels starting at the beginning of calendar year 2021. Given anticipated supply chain distortions, we accumulated extra stock, securing maximum availability throughout the year. On top of that, the prolonged lockdowns in Germany and the Netherlands added to an elevated stock level. Altogether, this produced a significant deterioration in our net working capital.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn income tax payments, we saw an outflow of approximately EUR 100 million, compared with a smaller inflow the year before. That swing stems from reversing COVID-related deferrals and reductions from prior years. Overall, free cash flow came in at -EUR 270 million, which was EUR 740 million below the prior year. Needless to say, a negative cash flow like that cannot be sustained. The year was strongly shaped by last year's peak in trade liabilities and by our COVID-19 mitigation measures. Those effects are now normalizing. In fact, our net working capital position on September 30 was only marginally under where it stood two years earlier. So neither factor is sustainable, and neither should be extrapolated. Turning to slide 25. Despite severe headwinds, we have reinforced our balance sheet, launched cash flow measures, and expanded our room to maneuver. As of September 30, we hold a cash position of EUR 1.6 billion and have improved equity by over EUR 200 million. We refinanced upcoming maturities ahead of time and now have a sound structure made up of a EUR 500 million bond, a EUR 500 million commercial paper program, and an RCF backup line exceeding EUR 1 billion.
Florian Wieser
executiveBuilding out our own logistics network and our direct supply capabilities is going to give us optimized stock levels. On top of that, we're monetizing revolving commission receivables from our telecommunication partners. Tight cost management and a high degree of operational flexibility let us react quickly to current external challenges. Moving now to slide 27 and the outlook. For financial year 2021 to 2022, we expect a slight increase in currency and portfolio-adjusted sales versus the previous year. For adjusted EBIT, excluding associates, we expect a very clear increase compared with the previous year, which came in at EUR 237 million. Let me give you some color on the rationale behind these projections. At present we see a very volatile business. We've pictured that for you in more detail on the next slide. I'll come to this in a minute. The main driver of this volatility is, of course, the ongoing COVID pandemic. COVID restrictions have been with us for quite some time now. Yet the restrictions currently being imposed are new. In Germany, for example, the so-called 2G rule applies. That means you are either vaccinated or recovered to visit one of our stores.
Florian Wieser
executiveOther illustrations include the Netherlands, where shop hours have been cut back considerably, and Austria, which has just entered yet another lockdown that was announced at short notice. Those steps come alongside reduced footfall in stores and possible strain on sales and margin. At present we do not have enough data to properly gauge how the whole year will affect our business and our financials. Second, like most players in the market, we are dealing with supply chain interruptions for some key products, for instance in the GSM category. That is the case even though we moved early to lock in products. Third, inflation has climbed of late, and how it will develop further is being debated heavily in public at the moment. The future path of the COVID pandemic is equally hard to forecast as the international supply chain picture. We can already tell that our first quarter will be challenging against last year's high comparison base. As a result, we think it makes sense to keep our guidance a bit vaguer at this point than would otherwise have been the case. Still, be assured that we will give you a more precise outlook at the earliest opportunity. We think the pandemic's effect will prove less damaging than last year. We think today's supply chain difficulties will settle down over the course of the year, as will inflation.
Florian Wieser
executiveWith that as the background, the increase we expect in EBIT will come from our services and solutions business, from gross margin recovering, and from additional cost reductions. There is one more item I'd like you to keep in mind as we go forward. This September, we gave the equity-owning store directors in Germany the option to transfer their shares on fair terms. The vast majority of those store directors took up the offer. Transferring the shares does not change anyone's responsibilities. Going forward, though, the store directors will receive a bonus payment instead of a dividend, as was the case previously. This will be recorded as personnel expenses. As a result, adjusted EBIT will fall by roughly EUR 15 million-EUR 20 million. At the same time, our minority expenses will come down as well, so the net effect on EPS will be minor. Where cash flow is concerned, nothing will change. This effect has, of course, been factored into our guidance. Let's turn to slide 28. As I said a moment ago, the graph on this slide should provide a clearer picture of what we mean by volatility. It displays sales against the baseline of fiscal years 2018 to 2019, which is the year prior to the pandemic.
Florian Wieser
executiveThe fluctuations are considerable — they go from -12% in the lockdown periods up to +11% afterwards. With volatility at this level, making an accurate forecast becomes even harder. That's why it matters so much to look not just at the quarter from last fiscal year, but at the quarter before the pandemic too. We have confidence that we'll produce a full year result that stands clearly above the prior year when it comes to EBIT. That doesn't mean each individual quarter will also come in above the previous year — which is why I made those earlier remarks about the tough Q1 comparison base. That wraps up the financial section, so back to you, Karsten.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you, Florian. Now I'd also like to share an update from where I sit regarding the present climate and how trading has gone. As we've noted on many occasions by now, overall market conditions remain tougher and less predictable than they were before COVID. That much is obvious. COVID-related restrictions are something we're contending with, and we're navigating supply chain disruptions alongside our suppliers and partners. From the moment COVID began, we've been getting our business ready for a degree of volatility. The points that follow also give us confidence. Time and again we've shown our ability to surmount difficulties, and a period will come after COVID with fewer COVID restrictions, and for that new post-COVID normal we are well-positioned. Allow me to address one more matter that generated a certain amount of speculation. You will have heard that a cyberattack hit our IT systems in early November — the 8th of November, to be exact. We managed to respond right away, launched immediate countermeasures, and made sure the malware's spread was contained. Throughout, we were able to serve and sell to customers in our stores and online, though with somewhat limited functionalities when combining online and offline.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveSpecifically, the in-store pickup option was unavailable for a few days. At the same time, both the teams from our IT partners and our internal IT staff worked tirelessly and successfully to get all systems restored after several days. Because of this outstanding effort from our people and the strong collaboration with our IT partners, we managed to return to normal operations with no restrictions within days. As of right now, no new attacks have been registered, and we have no indication that any customer or employee data has been compromised or stolen. There's often a question that comes up, and I'll just address it in one go. The question is: have you paid anything? No, we have not paid any ransom. Let's go to page 31 and give you a bit of an update on Black Friday and the peak season. The situation around supply chains and product availability has, of course, also kept us busy over the last period. We discussed it also throughout actually last year, how we were preparing for that. We began the new fiscal year well-prepared and increased our inventories early on during the last year as a precautionary measure. In individual categories, such as, and I would say especially telecommunications, the situation is volatile, and some orders could not be met in full by our suppliers.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveIt's also fair to say that when customers try to find a product, one should definitely try with us. Just last week, for example, we received a shipment of 20,000 gaming consoles, and we sold within hours, and there are more consoles actually landed already are on the way. October, November were characterized by centrally supported and successfully implemented campaigns during the Black Friday period and the run-up to Christmas. In October and November, demand, momentum, and frequency in our stores did not reach the exceptionally high level of the same period last year. Even so, our current sales performance is stronger than in the first months, 2019 to 2020, so two years ago. Let's turn to 32. Ladies and gentlemen, we have taken important steps and made tangible progress last year despite all the challenges around. We have the right strategy and execution to be successful with a strong team, the right omnichannel strategy, an attractive range of products and services, strong brands driving very good customer demand, trustful relationships with our partners and suppliers, and most importantly, our commitment to excellent customer service. One in three Europeans has shopped at MediaMarktSaturn at least once in the last period, and this is the potential to build even stronger on and build deep customer relationships.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveBasically, here's how I'd think about the business. Where do we stand right now, ahead of Christmas 2021, and what do we stand for? Consumer electronics is still an appealing market, even with near-term volatility. We act for the short term without ever losing sight of what matters over the mid-term. Second, we're Europe's biggest consumer electronics retailer, with strong brands and leading positions across eight countries — but we won't sit still. Third, we showed resilience in 2021 and sped up our transformation. We keep growing more adaptable. Fourth, we got faster, cut overhead, and made our organizational structure simpler, because we value speed and simplicity. Number five, as an omnichannel retailer, customer excellence is our defining trait. We make it personal. Lastly, sustainability sits at the heart of our strategy. We view it as a commitment to society and, at the same time, a business opportunity. With that, thanks to all of you for your attention, and I'll now hand the call to the moderator for your questions. Thank you.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion right now. Our first question comes from Volker Bosse at Baader Bank. Go right ahead — your line is live.
Volker Bosse
analystYes. Thanks, and hello, gentlemen. This is Volker Bosse from Baader Bank. It's good to hear, and congratulations on successfully handling that nasty cyber attack. Great achievement. I'd like to begin with three questions. First would be on gross margin. It declined by 100 basis points in fiscal year 2021. For fiscal year 2021/2022, you now guide for a very clear EBIT increase. Does that also include gross margin improvements in 2021/2022? That'll be the first question. The second question would be on the Q1 trading update. According to the HDE, the stationary retailers in December suffered massively from the introduction of the 2G restrictions, which you also mentioned in Germany. Can you confirm what that means for your business? It's not about concrete figures, it's more about setting safe expectations for December, right? How much does that impact in December, these new restriction rules, 2G, which we never had before. The last question, the third question would be on the EGM. At the AGM, at the February 9th, and then you have an EGM at the April 12th. I guess this has to be seen in the context of the Kellerhals issue. Could you perhaps elaborate and remind us on the schedule, when you expect to solve the Kellerhals issue and what is the background of the EGM after just some weeks after the AGM?
Volker Bosse
analystAppreciate it.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThanks, Volker, for those three questions. I'll handle the question about the quarter one trading update, and Florian will speak to the gross margin and the EGM — and he'll begin with the gross margin.
Florian Wieser
executiveAbsolutely, I'm glad to do that. As long as we've provided EBIT guidance showing a very clear increase, that really implies we're optimistic about gross margin development as well. When you look at the different factors, please remember that during the last fiscal year, 2021, the temporary closure of our stationary business put significant weight on our gross margin. On top of that, demand for our online offerings has been very strong. We don't believe we'll see an online share above 30% again. There will basically be some compensation coming from the channel shift too. And last but not least, our growing service and solutions business will contribute significantly to margin recovery, as we already saw in the fourth quarter. Yes, in line with the EBIT guidance, we're very optimistic about the gross margin as well. From my perspective, these three factors will play a part. Second question on the Kellerhals transaction. Earlier this year we already published, like, an ad hoc message communicating the way forward. As you know, there have been two ways to Rome, so to speak. We took some time to basically study both options, and we chose the most robust one.
Florian Wieser
executiveSure, what we're aiming for is to make this deal as secure and solid as we can. So that means we now have two annual general meetings coming up next year. The first is in February — the regular Annual General Meeting — and that's where we'll pay dividends. Those dividends will essentially wipe out the voting rights attached to the preferred shares. Then in April, the second meeting in 2022 will be an extraordinary one. At that extraordinary Annual General Meeting in April, we'll essentially put the transaction forward again, and we're quite optimistic that we can close the deal next year.
Volker Bosse
analystI appreciate that.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you. Thanks, Florian. Regarding the Q1 trading update question — specifically what you asked about the 2G rule, the geimpft, genesen restriction in retail, and what it means for the high street, for traffic, and for demand — let me restate one point, since I believe it matters. As I mentioned, October and November of this year were plainly below the exceptional, comparable quarter of last year, which, given how last year went, does not strike me as a total surprise. Taken together, October and November of this year came in better than two years ago. Now the genuine uncertainty arrives with this 2G measure and the restriction in December, because clearly this does produce muted traffic on the high street. This is a dynamic quantity of roughly 35%, sometimes 40%. That also means we shift online. Of course, this is uncertainty and will plainly put pressure, let's say, on retail. That is where the main uncertainty originates. Let's also be clear — and that doesn't make it any easier — last year we had to close our shops in Germany as of December 16th. Let's assume that at least 2G stays open until the end of last year. That also means that, compared with last year, starting with December 16th, we should see some kind of catch-up effect.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThis won’t, you know, fully bridge the difference—that much is obvious. You know, it will certainly be of help. If you look more closely at individual countries, again, matters get more complicated. Among the southern countries, the effect we observe is considerably smaller. We had shut things down in Austria. It is simply, let’s say, a more complicated set of circumstances. Just as we have done before, we are managing it. That is the source of the uncertainty.
Volker Bosse
analystYeah. Understood completely. Hearing your comparison, there are plenty of ups and downs. For sure. Thanks a lot for the answers — the, the answers. Really helpful. Thank you.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Clément Genelot at Bryan, Garnier & Co. Please proceed. Your line is open now.
Clément Genelot
analystThanks. Morning. There are a couple of things I’d like to ask about, if that’s all right. First, regarding promotions: in Germany, is the promotional activity across every level of the competitive landscape still intense, with certain players — Amazon notably among them — out in front? Second, on inflation, are you noticing any upward pressure on labor inflation, particularly in Germany? Thanks.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you, Clément. I'll speak about how the promotional landscape looks right now, and Florian will address the question about labor inflation. Regarding today's promotional environment, yes, it remains competitive. Certain players, naturally, even amid the shortage and with traffic muted at present, are essentially still attempting to win market share by applying promotional pressure. In some categories, price pressure is not as strong, so it varies by category as well. One key point worth noting is that you actually observe price aggression with a trick attached, a trick played on the customer. A favorable price gets offered to you, yet the product arrives in January or February. What we actually observe is that customers prioritize availability over price when it comes to, you know, having products on hand. Look, we see that demand clearly in our online stores and in our brick-and-mortar stores. As I mentioned earlier, as a customer, when you want a high chance of finding a product available, you should definitely look to us. It's a mixed bag. Naturally, you see every kind of retail pricing trick. Again, nothing we consider especially, let's say, unusual. What matters most, again, is how traffic evolves. We collaborate very hard with the suppliers on general availability, and the rest, you know, we will manage.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn the second question about labor inflation: as I said in my remarks, inflation is a problem right now for us and for everyone in the market. Logistics costs in particular are climbing, in our view. Freight rates out of China are sitting at very high levels. We're getting the first signals that labor inflation in the logistics sector is essentially spilling over into retail as well. For our own business, it's too soon to say. Naturally, we have factored some wage inflation into our personnel expenses within the budget and the guidance for this fiscal year 2021/2022. But, as I mentioned, the exact impact, which will ultimately be negotiated between the tariff partners, is too early to assess. What our guidance assumes, basically, is that these elevated inflation levels will normalize over the course of the year, consistent with what we are hearing from the central banks at present.
Clément Genelot
analystGot it, thanks. Right now, there isn't really any labor inflation in the stores, or perhaps in the warehouses either — correct?
Florian Wieser
executiveFor us, and for our own employees, no. So far there hasn't been any meaningful effect. As I mentioned, we're still early in the new fiscal year, and we need to keep watching it carefully. The second thing, yeah, the impact, as I said, is on the logistics side, so within logistics, within the supply chain. When suppliers' costs go up, they usually push those higher costs onto us, and that's where we're already seeing some effects.
Clément Genelot
analystGot it. Appreciate that.
Operator
operatorFabienne Caron from Kepler Cheuvreux has our next question. The line is yours — please proceed.
Fabienne Caron
executiveGood morning, everyone. I have three questions. First, in a normal world—so after the Convergenta transaction—and given that you've moved or bought shares from a store manager, what percentage level of minorities should we expect for the group? And could you also share the qualitative criteria, or what the store manager's bonus will be based on? That's my first question. Second, what lessons have you drawn from the cyber attack? Because as far as I know, it didn't affect every IT system that was cloud-based. So does that mean you'll speed up your move of IT to the cloud? My last question: I saw research from a company called Profitero, which ran a survey of 15,000 products over the course of 2021, comparing prices among different operators in Germany. MediaMarkt was always more expensive than Amazon? I'd like your view on that point. Thank you.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveNo problem, Fabienne. We’re just holding for the final question to be clarified a little more. Well, I would—
Fabienne Caron
executiveThat was in Germany, actually. My apologies — I didn't.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveYeah, yeah. Okay. Okay. Florian is going to handle the third one. There may also be a follow-up question. On the first one, I'd like to say a few words. Florian will add to that, and I'll take the second one about the cyberattack, and then Florian will handle the third. Look, let me emphasize the principle. Obviously, in our stores we have a scorecard built around several very important factors. One, of course, is sales, one is profitability, and another is margin. But the customer experience is also very, very important. What's also very important — and that will change over time — for me personally, are soft factors such as people leadership, how we manage teams in the stores to deliver that experience; those will see some adjustments. The trick is always having the right targets, of course, that drive performance. At the same time, it isn't just one KPI — it's several — but at the same time, not too many, because it has to support how we have to run the business as an experience business. Again, sales, profitability, bottom line, but also margin, NPS, customer experience, and of course, how we lead and manage our people in the stores. Those are critical success factors.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveI’ll turn it over to Florian. Would you like to add anything?
Florian Wieser
executivePerhaps one question concerned the remaining minority holdings we still have. Maybe I can shed some light on that. In Germany, I believe we have somewhere between 20 and 30 store managers remaining who hold minority stakes. Essentially, if you look at our portfolio of over 400 stores, the vast majority of store managers accepted. In other countries as well, the minority stake model was essentially ended over the past years. Only a few countries remain where store managers hold minority stakes. That's perhaps to give you a bit more color on the minorities as well.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveFabienne, on your second question about what we learned from the cyberattack. Let me be clear, this is obviously a very sensitive subject, since in a semi-public conversation we are, of course, on one hand speaking with you, which we very much enjoy. On the other hand, you always have the sense that you are also speaking to the other side, which engages in criminal conduct. It is always somewhat delicate. Let me put it this way. First and foremost, a major portion of our business and our focus has all along been on IT security. I believe that is absolutely right. That was, I think, also among the key reasons we found ourselves able to respond so quickly and, with the backing of our partners, to bring services back up within days. That is the first point. Clearly, during such periods of attack, we adopt extra precautionary steps regarding reaction times, monitoring, and, you know, which kinds of system changes you permit. You don't make many of those in the high season in any case, but you know, all of those precautionary steps. Second and third, clearly, we also have a continuing review of what more we can do. Incidentally, our cloudification program that is underway, we will likely speed that up as well.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveUnderstood as well. You can be sure that safeguarding IT security stays at the very top of our priorities and that we will make it as safe as it can possibly be. The reason is that this amounts to a race against criminal forces out in the wider world. I hope that offers you a degree of context for your question.
Florian Wieser
executiveAlright. I’ll also do my best to address your third question, though I should be upfront that the Profitero research isn’t something I’m familiar with, so that’s something we’ll need to look into—for the team and for me—after this call. That said, I can offer a few comments on pricing and how we approach it. Perhaps as a first point: pricing is one of the areas we’ve put substantial investment into over the last few years, and we run an AI-based pricing platform. It’s highly automated and sophisticated, and for the most relevant products—say the top 300 or whatever the number may be—we make sure our pricing is competitive relative to the relevant competition. For those items, it should be the case that… if a higher price appears anywhere, it ought to be more of an exception. That’s my second comment for now. Turning to the current situation, if this is a recent research study, what we’re seeing at the moment is that the markets are in an exceptional state. There’s product scarcity, particularly in telecom. Supply isn’t abundant. If you look at MediaMarkt, you can be confident that when we offer a product, availability is sufficient and lead times aren’t long. I’d also encourage you, when comparing the offerings at other marketplaces, to factor in lead times as well.
Florian Wieser
executiveThis, I believe, is the picture—or the analysis—that ought to be done given where things stand right now. That, I think, is the situation as it currently is, and, as I mentioned, I'll be taking a closer look into Profitero.
Fabienne Caron
executiveThanks. Just to follow up on that, Florian, when you check prices, do you also factor in the delivery cost? Because most of the time, you know, the price may be similar, but then when it comes to delivery cost, you know, if a customer is Prime, then you may be tempted to go back to Amazon just so you don't have to pay the delivery cost for MediaMarkt.
Florian Wieser
executiveYeah. And when you look at delivery costs too, it obviously hinges on the value you're spending, and on whether it's a parcel or two-man handling. But we make sure those delivery costs stay competitive as well. Now, when you bring up Amazon, you basically also have to weigh whether it's a Prime offer or a non-Prime one. So when you factor in delivery, pricing gets more complex. So it isn't comparable one by one. But like I said, we make sure we've got a competitive offer, and delivery gets factored into the overall pricing mechanism too.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveFabienne, let me add just one thing here, since this question lets me share a single observation I made when I first arrived. First, we'll examine the study and see what we can draw from it. Yes — but in fact, our pricing operates in a very sophisticated, real-time way. As Florian mentioned, it relies on machine learning, and we adjust prices — by product and by shop — multiple times each day. Naturally, we factor in every kind of input, since it's clear we don't always need the lowest price in order to maximize margin. We check comparison sites on a product-by-product basis. We track our own conversion rates. We hold data on store footfall and the feedback coming from there. Naturally, we also keep an eye on what happens online regarding competitor pricing, et cetera. We have a very solid picture of average pricing, category pricing, and shop-product pricing. It's highly sophisticated — but we will definitely take a look at this study.
Fabienne Caron
executiveOkay. Could I just ask a couple of follow-up questions on the financial side, if that's alright? Florian, regarding the EUR 55 million of cost for this year, could you remind us what portion of that will be cash and what won't be? And then the second question is, what tax rate ought we to use for this year? And would it be fair to assume that the favorable effect of the Convergenta transaction on the tax rate will land more in 2022/2023?
Florian Wieser
executiveTo start with the first question, which I believe concerns the one-off item related to the NOM program — that is, the delayed-
Fabienne Caron
executiveYes.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn the deferred piece — the deferred one-off — yes, that will come as cash. As for your second question on the tax rate: you can see the extraordinary Annual General Meeting is scheduled for April 12th. We'll need to watch whether some deferral arises from people attempting to challenge potential decisions at the AGM. It remains to be seen how long this process stretches out. Should things proceed without friction, we would still be in a position to utilize tax loss carry forwards during this fiscal year, 2021/2022. Naturally, we are already making preparations so that those tax loss carry forwards can be used. If the transaction closes on schedule and in time, we will be able to use it this year. But if delays occur because of the public disputes in Germany that we have already discussed a few times, then it would more likely be 2022/2023.
Fabienne Caron
executiveAlright. Thanks very much.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder — if you'd like to ask a question, hit zero and then one on your phone. Our next question comes from Nicolas Champ at Barclays. Go ahead, please.
Nicolas Champ
analystYes, good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. First, could you share your CapEx guidance for next year, please? Second, with inflation accelerating—not just for consumer electronics products but across the board—are you seeing any shift in how customers shop? For instance, any trading down phenomenon in some countries? Third, could you be a bit more precise about where you see your net working capital going next year? Obviously, I understand that last year has been a bit unusual. You expect things to normalize. Could you guide us maybe a little more precisely on what you expect in terms of net working capital for next year? Thank you.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you, Nicolas. Florian is going to speak about the CapEx guidance for the coming year and shed a little more light on working capital as well. When we consider inflation as a whole, this is naturally peering somewhat into the future with some uncertainty attached. We have, naturally, once more witnessed inflation increases the likes of which hadn't been seen in so many years. Drilling down into where it originates, in numerous markets it is strongly shaped by, let's say, energy prices. The question, for example, regarding this inflationary pressure is how governments will also handle it? Will that go up? I would say a contest exists among inflation, the spending that's available, and how willing consumers are to spend as well versus, let's say, the appeal of categories, which products are in fact in the pipeline, since that is a key driver of customer demand. When you observe basket shifts, and that, I think, remains the beauty of consumer electronics, we continuously have highly attractive products that then shift behavior. Once more, the question now concerns central banks' reaction to relieve the pressure. If inflation were to climb further at some point, we will, of course, likely see demand that is somewhat slower.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAt this moment, I wouldn’t put the primary impact we’re seeing today down to inflation, naturally. It could create a certain amount of pressure. What matters more to me is getting everything reopened to normal, transacting and maintaining solid frequency. That’s probably somewhat speculative. Sadly, I’m unable to offer you likely any further perspective beyond that. On CapEx guidance we’re able to be more exact, since that’s our line of work.
Florian Wieser
executiveOn CapEx guidance, yes — we anticipate a recovery for this year, fiscal year 2021/2022. The direction we're aiming for is 1.5% of sales, which means CapEx will exceed EUR 300 million. The reason, obviously, is that during COVID, with stores closed, we weren't able to run our regular maintenance program, and essentially couldn't refurbish and upgrade our stores either. So now we'll essentially get that work done — refurbishing and maintaining the stores, as I just mentioned. On net working capital, expect a normalization. We saw an extraordinary positive development thanks to pent-up demand in 2019 to 2020, and now in 2021 there's a normalization. Big net working capital swings this fiscal year — it should normalize. Over the mid-term, you should expect net working capital to decrease slightly. The reason is that we're increasingly moving toward direct supply from our suppliers. With that direct access to products, net working capital edges down a bit.
Nicolas Champ
analystAlright, thanks.
Operator
operatorThat's all the questions we have for now. Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, will return for some closing remarks.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAlright, ladies and gentlemen, we appreciate your time and the questions you've raised. As always, should anything else come to mind or if you need further clarification, don't hesitate to reach out to our investor relations team. So let me wrap up today's results call here. Wishing each of you a happy and joyful holiday season. Good health to you. Take care, stay healthy. And if you're still on the lookout for some Christmas presents, by the way, you know where to find them. All the best. Bye-bye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.