Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 11, 2022

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 49 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thanks for holding. We appreciate you being with us on this Ceconomy AG investor and analyst conference call. During the recorded portion of today's presentation, everyone will be in listen-only mode. After the presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. Should you wish to pose a question, simply press the star key and then one on your touchtone phone. For help from an operator, press the star key followed by zero. At this point, I'll hand the conference over to Hendrik Finger of the Investor Relations team. Please go ahead.

Hendrik Finger

executive
#2

Morning, everyone, and thanks for being on our Q3/9M Results Call today. Joining me are Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, and Florian Wieser, our CFO. They’ll take you through what we’re presenting today. Before we begin, a few standard items. First, this call is being recorded. Later today, a replay will be posted on our website. Second, please keep in mind that today’s presentation—and possibly some responses to your questions—may include forward-looking statements. For more details on that, please see the disclaimer. At this point, I’ll turn things over to Karsten Wildberger, our CEO.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#3

Thanks, Hendrik, and good morning to all of you. I appreciate you being here for our presentation of Q3 and the nine-month results. There's actually quite a lot I want to get through today, and I'll organize it into four thematic blocks. First, I'll offer my comments on how Q3 turned out and the market conditions we're facing. Second, I'll discuss our revised outlook and explain what stands behind that adjustment. Third, I'll shed some light on the way we're actually handling the challenges in front of us. Fourth, I'll share additional insight into our progress on implementing the omni-channel strategy. Let's go to slide four, if you would. Well, these are genuinely tough economic times. Not for decades have we seen so many negative forces at play simultaneously. Plainly put, crisis has become part of the new norm, and we're handling it as well as we possibly can. Rest assured, that is what we're doing. Our focus stays on what we control and what lies in our own hands. Following a good start to the third quarter, external conditions got worse. Fueled by persistently high inflation and rising energy costs, the consumer climate deteriorated markedly over the course of the quarter.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#4

Starting in June, demand has been softer, particularly in Germany. Even so, we raised sales 6.3% to roughly EUR 4.6 billion in Q3 and in that way outperformed competitors. Adjusted EBIT for the third quarter was -EUR 109 million, which is EUR 60 million lower than a year earlier. Keep in mind that last year's figure contained COVID-19 government support of EUR 45 million during the quarter. Q3 this year felt the effect of rising inflation, which drove up purchasing prices along with cost items like energy and logistics services. Meanwhile, we chose to put money into advertising campaigns and special offers at a time when demand is flattening and competition is heating up. Florian will walk you through our financial performance in more detail later. That said, let me take a quick look past the present situation. During Q3, we continued rolling out our omni-channel strategy. Customer satisfaction improved once more, and we picked up market share. We will reap the benefits of that going forward. Beyond that, we closed the Convergenta transaction at the start of June. With that, we have established the structural foundation for simplification and for further developing our company.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#5

Shortly, I’ll walk you through a few concrete examples showing what we’ve achieved in our main strategic areas. But first, if you’ll turn to page five, let me lay out how substantially the underlying conditions have shifted over recent months. The inflation rate across the Eurozone has climbed steeply lately, largely because energy costs and food prices have gone up considerably. In July it hit 8.9%, the highest reading since the euro was introduced in 1999. Let’s look specifically at Germany for a second, which appears in the center of the chart and the page, as well as on the right-hand side. What stands out is the price Germany pays to obtain natural gas, and that has tripled over the past 12 months. At the same time, consumer sentiment has fallen sharply since the start of the year. For August, experts actually anticipate a further decline in Germany’s consumer climate index. Nearly every sector is in fact being hit by these adverse trends, though retail is suffering the most. In inflation-adjusted terms, German retail sales dropped by nearly 9% in total during the first half of 2022 compared with a year earlier, and that is actually the steepest decrease seen in the last 30 years.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#6

Let's go to slide six, if you would. We updated our guidance for this business year not long ago in light of these developments. And since that happened, people have clearly been asking us two things: what prompted the change, and why make it at this point? So please allow me to address both. On our Q2 call, we told you that April's sales momentum looked very encouraging. But as early as May, the market turned more volatile, with substantial swings from one week to the next. Even so, we ended that month — May — with sales growth in positive territory. Then, by the middle of June at the latest, our sales trajectory dropped off steeply, and performance came in below what we had expected internally, with the effect felt most strongly in Germany. Given this clear shift in how consumers are behaving, we revised our projections for the fourth quarter. Naturally, a sizable deceleration in sales also weighs on total gross profit. On top of that, it can lower potential income from back margin conditions, a considerable share of which gets collected in September, and it introduces uncertainty around sales-related conditions. Beyond that, we found ourselves having to work harder for sales than anticipated, which brings more campaigns and pressure on selling prices. And finally, we felt inflation firsthand in certain cost lines, such as logistics and energy costs.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#7

As far as possible in the current market environment, rising purchase prices get passed through to customers, and I can assure you we are doing that as well. But from mid of June onwards, all those elements intensified, and the first weeks of July confirmed it. So we had to update our outlook for the current financial year. That said, for the fiscal year 2021 to 2022 we now expect sales at the previous year's level. Originally, we had expected sales to slightly increase. We now anticipate adjusted EBIT in the range of EUR 150 million-EUR 210 million, whereas originally we had aimed for a substantial increase on the previous year's figure of EUR 237 million. The previous outlook rested on clear assumptions, namely an improvement in consumer sentiment post-COVID and the normalization of inflation rates against the level of around 5% in our first half. The most recent developments have superseded these assumptions. Our new outlook for the full year reflects the significantly altered environment. It also rests on the assumptions that the effects of the war of aggression against Ukraine will not worsen further, and that there will be no new restrictions on brick-and-mortar retail due to potential energy supply shortage or the COVID-19 pandemic.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#8

We realize you'd also like to know how we see the current situation affecting our next fiscal year. The truth is, with this much uncertainty and so little predictability in these unprecedented times, we're not in a position to say anything about next year right now. So please be patient with us until we can offer what will hopefully be clearer guidance, and that's scheduled to come with the release of our full-year results in December. Let's move to slide seven, please. Ladies and gentlemen, this is the world we're living in, and we're adapting to conditions that may not improve anytime soon. As I mentioned at the start, we're getting ourselves ready for these negative scenarios so that we're prepared should they become reality. Since the future is uncertain, outcomes might also prove better than what's currently expected or feared. There could be, for instance, shifts in demand that benefit us in certain categories — for example, household appliances that are especially energy efficient. So how are we handling the current crisis? What does that mean in concrete terms? For a while now, we've had task forces in place to work decisively on measures across four areas so as to mitigate these adverse circumstances.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#9

To start with, cost control and protecting our margins. We're enforcing tighter cost discipline across the whole organization than we ever have before. Wherever we can, we're bringing our operating costs down. We're working hard on cutting store costs, particularly when it comes to rent and store size. On top of that, we're passing along inflation-driven costs and price increases to the extent the market allows, and especially in Germany, which is our largest business, we must do everything within our power to strengthen our margin. Our efforts there will be intensified. Second, building market momentum. Our focus is on new campaign formats, and these are being rolled out across the company. Simultaneously, we'll keep running special campaigns that support our sales and safeguard market shares. We coordinate these campaigns closely with our partners, who are in fact quite keen on us generating demand for their products. Third, working capital and stock management. We're optimizing our inventories and, most importantly, we'll keep lowering the proportion of old stock. Meanwhile, we stay in continuous contact with our suppliers so that product availability remains high. Fourth, we're getting ready for potential gas restrictions, particularly in Germany and Austria. That means, for instance, being able to move from gas-fired heating to electric heating when it's necessary and feasible.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#10

We’ll take every step we can so that our stores stay open for customers, including if a gas shortage occurs. On that front too, we are getting ready for the negative scenario. For a while now, we have been working to lower energy use in our stores, and at this point we are pursuing that with even greater intensity. Let’s turn to page eight. I want to stress that although we are fully concentrating on all the crisis management that is required, in these times it also matters that we stay true to our strategic direction. We managed to do that in the third quarter. In carrying out our omni-channel strategy, as you know, we place the customer at the center of everything we do, and overall we have made progress in the important areas. First, let’s discuss customer experience. The Net Promoter Score, NPS, the key metric we rely on to gauge customer satisfaction, has improved once more over recent quarters. During the third quarter, NPS across all sales channels came in at 53, the highest level since measurement started. A central part of our omni-channel strategy is expanding our services and solutions business. We are having growing success with our broad services, ranging from telco contracts to financing solutions and the SmartBars in our stores, where we repair or set up appliances.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#11

That applies equally to customer satisfaction and to the financial contribution. Florian will give you further specifics and figures regarding our key service and solutions business. Now let's turn to the online business. During Q3, our new webshop went live in Italy as well. The rollout was very smooth. As a result, five countries are now linked to our company-wide tech platform. Those countries account for roughly 80% of our online sales. The tech platform makes sure that additional developments, new features, and functionalities can be offered to customers directly across all the countries. At present, we are running an online in-house share of about 25%, which is over 10 percentage points above pre-COVID. Over the midterm, we are targeting a share of 30%. Let's move on to the store landscape. On one hand, we lower our store costs by renegotiating rents, cutting space, and shutting locations where necessary. We are pursuing this forcefully. At the same time, we have also achieved good progress modernizing our stores over the past months. Within this financial year alone, we converted a further 100 stores to the new core format by the end of June. Experience with the new core concept up to now is very encouraging, with profitability exceeding that of the previous classic store format.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#12

When it comes to logistics, we're likewise placing a strong emphasis on being close to the customer. With online orders, our aim is to give shoppers a dense network of pickup and drop-off locations. Within 10 minutes, 80% of our customers ought to be able to get to one. Thanks to a partnership with a logistics provider in Spain, we've in fact moved much nearer to that target. The count of contact points available to our customers has been raised to over 1,600. Another 3,000 will be added very soon. This concept is, in fact, being rolled out in other markets too. Finally, ESG and sustainability. Sustainability, as you know, is a cornerstone of how we develop strategically and, at the same time, a distinguishing proposition. Over recent months, we've broadened our repair, refurbishment, and end of life take-back services into more countries. Extended trade-in solutions are now offered to our customers in half of our countries, both in stores and through our webshops. This service covers not only smartphones but tablets and laptops as well, so the whole suite of IT products. As you can see, even in an extremely challenging environment, we aren't losing sight of the important structural necessities. We keep developing our company and we are taking action.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#13

So that's the reason we still feel good about Ceconomy's growth outlook. With that said, I'll pass things over to Florian Wieser, who is going to walk you through how our business is developing right now in greater detail. Thanks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#14

Yes. Thanks, Karsten. Good morning, everyone joining us on the line today. I'll walk you through the quarterly and nine-month numbers in greater detail, beginning on slide 10. Karsten already covered where things stand right now. Consumer sentiment has been deteriorating, particularly starting in June, and that weighed on our third-quarter results and even more so on how we see Q4 and beyond. To give you some color, let's go back to our half-year call in mid-May. At that point, we pointed to the ambiguous trend in consumer sentiment. Uncertainty stemming from the Russian war against Ukraine, along with heightened inflationary pressures, held back demand in March. During April, consumer climate brightened for a time and demand came back strongly. May proved rather volatile, and in June demand fell noticeably. So the adjusted Q3 sales growth of 6.3% blends three fairly uneven individual months and masks the underlying trend. Adjusted EBIT moved in a similar way to sales over the quarter. June accounted for most of the year-on-year decline. Although the blended sales growth looks solid at first glance, we had to spend more on marketing given a demanding competitive environment. Beyond that, inflationary pressures also weighed on our earnings. While EBIT finished EUR 60 million under last year's third quarter, after nine months we are roughly at the prior year level.

Florian Wieser

executive
#15

That said, at the outset we had aimed for an EBIT improvement compared with the prior year. That covers how our two main KPIs developed. Now let's go deeper, beginning with the online business on slide 11. Just as in earlier quarters, our online business contributed substantially to the company's performance. With COVID restrictions gradually lifted in the prior year period as the backdrop, online sales fell year-on-year, in line with expectations. Normalization of our sales channel mix was a benefit to our brick-and-mortar business, which grew beyond 20% in Q3. At group level, with an online sales ratio of around 23%, our online share stays significantly above pre-COVID levels. By rolling out our new webshop to more countries such as Italy, we make online shopping more convenient and continue working towards our ambition of a 30% online sales share. Our new webshop now covers 80% of total online sales. The pickup ratio — a crucial proof point of our omni-channel proposition — stood at 38% in Q3. We appreciate the slight trend improvement vs previous quarters and are close to our midterm ambition of 40%+. Convenient new options, such as our 30 minutes click and collect offering, help lift the ratio to the targeted level.

Florian Wieser

executive
#16

Now, on slide 12, I'll give you additional detail about the strategically important service and solutions business that Karsten also mentioned. Service and solutions stayed robust, posting 23% growth in Q3. With our brick-and-mortar business recovering, service and solution sales rose to a 6.4% share. That's the highest level we've seen since Q4 of 2018 to 19. Looking at service categories, demand climbed steadily for GSM contracts and consumer finance offerings, and attachment rates were generally elevated as well, both online and stationary. This confirms to us that our work to strengthen our service offerings — including better web functionalities like a smarter recommendation engine — is paying off sustainably. As a result, our service and solutions business contributed significantly to the positive gross margin development you see on slide 13. Gross margin rose 130 basis points, reaching 17.2% in Q3. While we're pleased with the improvement against the COVID burden of the prior year, this level falls short of our initial expectations. The usual drivers behind our gross margin in Q3 were as follows. First, the recovery of our brick-and-mortar business created a tailwind from channel shift.

Florian Wieser

executive
#17

Second, service and solutions continued to grow, as I just noted. Third, the goods margin rose slightly, which was a pleasing development and gave our gross margin a boost. On the downside, a greater proportion of older inventory placed a modest burden on gross margin. We will, of course, keep devoting all our efforts and focus to improving margin. Turning now to OpEx developments, which are on slide 14. In the past quarter, both absolute OpEx and our OpEx ratio rose. Some of that rise was anticipated, since a key driver was the lack of COVID subsidies and savings from the prior year. That factor made up roughly half of the absolute increase. Even with our sustained tight cost control, the rest mainly comes from inflationary pressures in personal expenses and energy consumption. Dealing with cost pressures is unavoidable these days, with inflation rates beyond 8%. Continuous and ongoing cost optimization efforts aimed at the cost structures in our operations and at headquarters remain key. Let's now look at segment performance on slide 15, which shows rather diverging developments across regions. The DACH region recovered by 5% compared with the prior year, which was burdened by COVID restrictions. Yet consumer sentiment declined noticeably over the course of the quarter, particularly in Germany.

Florian Wieser

executive
#18

Higher marketing spending to reach the sales levels we wanted, cost inflation, and the absence of last year's COVID-19 subsidies all hurt the segment's earnings. Demand across Western and Southern Europe was uneven and fell short of the strong sales seen a year earlier. Italy carried on its positive momentum from recent quarters, whereas the Netherlands delivered weaker business performance. Eastern Europe again posted the strongest growth rates, powered by robust demand in Turkey. Keep in mind that starting in Q3, we applied IAS 29 accounting standards to strip out technical effects of hyperinflation in Turkey. Using a more recent FX rate and the price index to consolidate the Turkish financials moved sales by roughly +EUR 66 million and had a fairly small effect on earnings. Those technical effects are left out of our guidance-relevant KPIs, adjusted sales growth, and adjusted EBIT. Moving on to reported financials through EPS on slide 16. Overall, earnings per share fell to EUR 0.02 for the first 9 months of this financial year. That stems mostly from items recorded below the adjusted EBIT line. Above all, the valuation of our strategic stake in Fnac Darty weighed on EPS.

Florian Wieser

executive
#19

Whereas reported EBIT in Q2 of last year got a boost from a partial reversal of impairment worth EUR 150 million, in Q3 of this year we booked an impairment of EUR 56 million. Second, dividends from Metro Properties and M.video propped up last year's financial result, and those did not recur this year. Because the Fnac Darty valuation is non-tax effective, our reported tax rate came in relatively low in fiscal year 2021, while this year it is comparably high. Across the first 9 months of this year, it came to 71.1%. Strip out the non-tax effective items and the underlying tax rate sat at around 48%. Tax benefits arising from the Convergenta transaction and the related tax consolidation won't show up in our financials until Q4. Moving on to free cash flow on slide 17, which stood at a seasonal low at the close of Q3. At roughly -EUR 765 million, the main factor was the usual swing in our net working capital position that arrives every summer. That net working capital change stems mostly from the seasonal decline in trade payables. This year, shorter payment terms brought about by new legal regulations in Belgium, along with our deliberate move toward direct sourcing from selected suppliers, made this effect even stronger.

Florian Wieser

executive
#20

On top of that, unsatisfactory inventory levels and the age mix of that stock put pressure on our net working capital. Where income tax is concerned, larger advance payments plus repayments scheduled for earlier years resulted in a bigger cash outflow. Beyond that, as we had anticipated, the reversal of the COVID-related German VAT deferral from last year kept weighing on free cash flow in the current year. All told, cash flow came to -EUR 1.1 billion after nine months. Partly, that mirrors the normal seasonal movement in liquidity. Partly, it mirrors inventory that is still relatively high along with weak consumer sentiment at the close of June. I want to state plainly once more that the targeted steps we took over the last month to bring overall stock levels down are delivering results, and we are carrying less inventory than we did in March and a year ago. We keep driving aligned actions on our inventory position while making sure customers have enough availability. Karsten walked through several of our initiatives earlier. Thanks to these, we believe we are on track to reach our objective of a better balanced net working capital position as we approach the end of the financial year. In the end, that should also strengthen liquidity, which normally rises in Q4 consistent with our seasonal pattern.

Florian Wieser

executive
#21

Just to remind everyone, we have undrawn credit lines of over EUR 1 billion available to us, and those are on a long-term basis. That gives us room for maneuver. That wraps up the financial section, and now I'll hand it back to Karsten for his closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#22

Thank you, Florian. Let's move to slide 19, if we may. Ladies and gentlemen, to wrap up, I'd like to lay out what you should expect from us over the next few months. Above all, we're going to do whatever it takes to soften and get past the effects of the present economic crisis. At the same time, we'll keep rolling out our omni-channel strategy exactly as planned. Both of these efforts are meant to strengthen where we stand competitively and to win market share. Within our crisis management, the key emphasis is on costs and on safeguarding our margins. Clearly, as Florian said, plenty of work is also underway on the liquidity front and around cash flow. That applies especially to our German business. We're adjusting our cost structures to fit the changed market conditions. We're likewise negotiating terms with our suppliers that establish the basis for shared long-term success. In doing so, we're relying on our strong market position and on close, long-standing partnerships. One more point matters in the present situation. Florian already touched on it. We have enough liquidity to stay on course, but let's also be clear: managing cash flow is plainly at the very center. Beyond that, we'll take the steps required to keep enhancing the customer experience and to carry out our strategy.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#23

These are the main things we'll deliver. First, a new international brand campaign arrives in October, and it will look somewhat different from what you've grown used to lately. Getting the brand re-energized matters, and having that strong brand really does create an impact in the market. Second, we're bringing a new MediaMarkt membership program to Germany. Third, we'll strengthen our online business further and launch our marketplace in Austria, following the successful start in Germany and in Spain. Beyond that, we'll keep expanding our sustainability activities and, for instance, roll out our circular economy offerings step by step across all country organizations. Naturally, we'll also keep optimizing our store portfolio over the coming months. Alongside modernizing existing stores, that includes opening new ones, with the focus on our new lighthouse format. Once we open our fourth Tech Village in Rome at the beginning of July, three more will follow during the year — on the first of September in Berlin, and later in Madrid and Vienna. Please let's turn to the next chart. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to summarize today's call. We've been facing a deteriorating customer climate since the end of Q3.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#24

Everyone is fully engaged in combating this crisis. We're bracing for additional macroeconomic headwinds, and our crisis management team is operational. We keep raising efficiency across our operations — in stores, online, and throughout our logistics networks. We're taking our omni-channel strategy further so the customer experience improves and our competitive position gets stronger. In short, we aren't merely responding to every sort of external headwind — we are acting decisively. Thank you all for listening. I'll now hand the call to the moderator for your questions. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#25

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we're going to start the question-and-answer portion now. If you'd like to pose a question, you can press the star key and then one on your touchtone phone. Should you want to drop out of the queue, press star and then two. Today, if you happen to be on speaker equipment, kindly pick up the handset before you make your selection. At this point, anybody with a question can press star followed by one. Please hold a moment while we get to the first question. Our first question comes from Volker Bosse of Baader Bank. You may proceed.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#26

Good morning, gentlemen. This is Volker Bosse from Baader Bank, and thank you for the opportunity to ask a question. I have three items I'd like to cover. Let me begin with the cost picture. It's encouraging to see that services and solutions pulled through and helped lift margins. But clearly, higher costs on other lines more than offset that. You probably have full visibility into how costs look across the entire P&L. If you could put numbers on what's hurting you the most, which P&L line would that be? Is it energy costs? Is it personnel costs? Or, to give us some granularity, what is the biggest driver behind the OpEx increase, so to speak? The second one concerns currencies. We're seeing the U.S. dollar strengthen, and my question is how that affects your sourcing in Asia, which as I understand is conducted in US dollar. How much hedging do you have in place here? Or how does this influence your gross margin going forward? What's your view on this topic? And my last question, of course, relates to trading. You mentioned that sales momentum has weakened since mid of May. How did trading perform in July and the first eight of August compared with last year? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#27

Thanks a lot, Volker, for those three questions. We'll take them in the order you asked. On the first one, about the cost situation and the currency, Florian will handle that, and I'll say something about trading. Florian?

Florian Wieser

executive
#28

Sure, glad to address that. I'll begin with the question about the U.S. dollar, which has been strengthening versus the euro. On a direct basis, the effect on us isn't that large. Our only direct exposure relates to our own brand. We have an own-brand company named Imtron, and it imports own-brand goods straight from Asia. There we do see some effect, and we're hedging that exposure as well. On the whole, that impact is fairly limited. Naturally, there's an indirect effect too, since we purchase from suppliers in euro. Over the past month, what we've observed is that the cost of merchandise — of buying merchandise — has gone up. That effect is visible, and it hits gross margin in a rather indirect way. As we also mentioned on the Q2 call, we're of course likewise attempting to pass inflationary effects on gross margin through to customers. It's a mixed picture, I'd say. As for your first question about cost increases, let me provide a bit more detail. First, I believe it matters to examine the Q3 development — to look at the figures and at the cost ratios, and to adjust those for COVID-19 subsidies.

Florian Wieser

executive
#29

When you factor out the COVID-19 subsidies, our cost ratio was adjusted last year, and it has stayed fairly level. Adjusted for those COVID-19 subsidies, we had a flat cost ratio compared with the prior year. Regarding the various components you've asked about for this year, I believe we've handled inflationary pressures on payroll quite effectively, and payroll is the biggest part of our cost structure. This year we haven't experienced anything resembling a large surge. On the whole, wage increases have remained at a moderate level. The key question, I think, will be how wage or tariff negotiations shape up in the next calendar year. On store rents, we have countermeasures in place, so we continually renegotiate our rent contracts, and we are actively working on our store portfolio. Through these efforts, we're optimistic that we can actually cut location costs further and manage cost inflation well in this area. Turning to energy, we have so far seen a low double-digit cost increase when it comes to energy. As Karsten explained on the call, we have taken active steps to lower energy consumption in stores. We began this a couple of years ago, and the overall impact, I would say, has come to a low double-digit EUR million amount, as just mentioned.

Florian Wieser

executive
#30

We've unfortunately also started to see some cost inflation in the overall cost development, and that's reflected in the Q3 figures. When you look at those very high numbers of more than 8%, I think we've handled it well. At this point I'll pass things over to Karsten for the country.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#31

Sure. Perhaps one further point on the cost picture, Volker: we've discussed, of course, the Convergenta deal and the simplification of the structure. We've clearly been at work on this. Once again, we'll speed up and redouble those efforts, since we're also examining structural cost opportunities — from a headquarter standpoint, for instance, how we organize ourselves. That's something we're accelerating, and we'll bring you up to date on progress down the road. These are, of course, fairly substantial efficiencies too, which we intend to and will achieve. Turning to trading, as I mentioned, April was in fact very encouraging. May was volatile week to week. We saw ups and downs, yet still finished May with growth. June actually fell quite noticeably and even more markedly from mid-June onward. In July, the trend has, you know, carried on. It's also worth noting that sales trends can, of course, differ greatly market by market. What I'm sharing now is much more the German picture, because Germany's situation is very special owing to the energy situation, since that is of course an enormous burden on households, as you know. We also have the gas situation in Austria, though less pronounced, and this is quite different in other markets.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#32

Now, August is obviously still ahead, and I'd say it looks similar — pretty much the same as July. Like I said, we're getting ourselves ready for, let's say, the harder scenarios when it comes to cost and so on. That said, nobody can see into the future, so things could turn out better than we expect. Right now this is obviously the only data point we have, and we have no further assumption to make about why things would change in the short run. One last point I want to make, and this is very important. In Q3, despite all these things and headwinds, we have increased market share, which is important. It's always a very important balance we have to strike between getting our fair share in market and at the same time protecting margins and campaign intensity. That's something we are obviously working on.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#33

Yeah, thanks a lot. Since you brought up the Kellerhals transaction, may I add one more question? Could you remind us what the next steps are and when — or where things stand right now on the cash components being paid out in that deal? Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#34

Let me offer a few remarks on, say, organizational matters and, clearly, the structural items we're also putting into place and addressing from a cost standpoint, plus the, say, financial consequences, cash-related items, et cetera, and tax. Florian Wieser will weigh in. As we mentioned, we're essentially removing a layer between the two companies. We operate as one. From a management view we're making this operational, yet it plainly opens up more chances for various departments to streamline and to slim down. That's work we currently have underway. Simultaneously, we're examining the structure from a headquarters angle. Are we lean enough? Do we have sufficient traction in the market? Do we concentrate on what makes the market stronger? I'd say there are opportunities we can now push through with far greater speed, and that's what we're doing. We've established a team for this. It's in the making, and we'll give you further updates on the structural changes that you should likewise see reflected in the numbers. Florian, would you like to add?

Florian Wieser

executive
#35

To be clear, there are only the two questions — the ones on technical matters. The EUR 130 million in cash has by now been transferred to Convergenta. As I said during my remarks, we are in the process of putting the structural prerequisites in place so that the tax loss carry forwards at Ceconomy level can be used. Internally, work is underway on reorganizing the organization. As Karsten noted too, this involves some organizational restructuring — trimming the organization down, eliminating a number of legal entities. That work will now be completed in the fourth quarter. After these legal restructurings are finished, we will also be able to activate the deferred tax assets tied to the Convergenta transaction. You should look for those effects in the fourth-quarter balance sheet.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#36

All right. Thanks a lot, and best of luck. Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#37

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#38

Thanks. Clement Genelot from Bryan Garnier is our next questioner. Go ahead.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#39

Good morning. There are three things I'd like to ask about. First, on EBIT: can you verify for us that the warning, together with the very low EBIT implied for Q4, stems from lower back margins — the payments coming from us suppliers? Second, on M&A in an environment this tough: is M&A still a real option for growing your size, cutting your exposure to Germany, and generating cost in marketing? Or would you regard it as rather unreasonable given the risk and the refinancing conditions? Then, on energy: in my view you're one of the rather rare European retailers that actually mentions this energy crunch in a press release, and at present it isn't included in your guidance. I assume this topic has already been discussed between the German government and yourself, but to really help us understand the potential implications — what kind of measures could be implemented in such an energy crunch in Germany? I mean, would it really be store closures, or is it some softer measures? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#40

I believe there are. We really appreciate your questions. On the EBIT question for Q4, Florian will comment. I'll comment on the M&A. The energy question, the gas question, I'll take as well. Was there a fourth one?

Clément Genelot

analyst
#41

When it comes to possible store closures.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#42

Sorry, what was that?

Clément Genelot

analyst
#43

Possible store shutdowns.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#44

All right, that's great. Florian, over to you.

Florian Wieser

executive
#45

Sure, I'm glad to talk about EBIT. Two things matter here. To start with, as we said earlier in this first Q&A session, we've observed higher costs when buying goods from suppliers because of inflation, increased logistics expenses, and possibly some currency effects too. Rising costs, above all. For the last several months we've been negotiating hard with our suppliers so that both sides get a reasonable share of these cost increases — between the retailer and the supplier. In fact, we haven't lowered our expectation on back margin for Q4. We've raised our expectation, and our contribution, on back margin for Q4. That's one factor behind the adjustment to this year's EBIT guidance. We haven't managed to lift back margin levels up to the target we set at the start of the year. There will be an increase, but it won't reach the level we were aiming at back at the beginning of the year.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#46

On your M&A question — well, as you know, we're generally reviewing our strategy and the way we execute it. There's nothing to update you on in that regard. Let me also be clear on my side. Obviously, management is about allocating resources and focus. Clearly, as I said, we're highly focused on managing the crisis — cost focus, margin focus, cash flow focus — and concentrating on the market. As you can imagine, that already absorbs a lot of capacity, and I expect this to be the case for quite some time. I think that gives you an indication. Secondly, anything on the M&A front is driven first and foremost by the attractiveness of the underlying — say, business model — that may emerge, and that's a function of that. Should that be the case in the future at any point in time and there's anything to report, obviously, we would update you on it. As I said, allocation of management resources is in the here and now, and focus on the business. That's very, very clear. The first European retailer question on managing the energy crunch. Again, this situation is a very specific, say, German situation — how the energy system works with the dependence of 40% on the gas side.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#47

As you know, this is an energy system that relies very heavily on gas, given the unique route Germany has taken with its energy transition and the fact that 40% of that gas has been supplied by Russia. Naturally, a substantial share of the gas also goes toward industrial uses. Should shortages arise, the regulator follows a defined priority order — though at present it isn't clear whether we will actually face shortages. After all, if you check storage levels, they happen to be sitting at a fairly high point right now. Still, we have to plan ahead, and that is precisely why we examine things from what you might call a worst-case angle. Let's suppose a gas shortfall of serious magnitude were to hit. Some market participants — retailers, for example — might then be barred from heating their own premises. So quite a while back, we actually set up a dedicated team to handle this matter. What does that involve? For the markets where we identify a possible issue — and that's likely 20% of the estate — we are procuring, or rather developing the option, to move away from gas-fired heating toward electric heating, and even to shrink the store footprint. We are likewise engaged in dialogue with politicians and with representatives from the retail association.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#48

Obviously, we're doing everything we can to stay open. That's something we're assuming — say, the worst case. It doesn't have to be, again, but we want to be prepared just in case. In the light of full transparency, we also want to state that, but as I said, we are working on it.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#49

Thanks. That's very clear.

Operator

operator
#50

Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, if you'd like to pose a question, kindly press the star key and then the one on your telephone keypad. Since no more questions remain at this point, I return the floor to Karsten Wildberger, CEO, for his closing remarks. Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#51

Thanks. Ladies and gentlemen, I really appreciate the time you've taken and the questions you've asked. As always, should anything else come up, don't hesitate to reach out to our investor relations team. That said, I'll bring today's results call to a close. Look after yourselves, keep well, and goodbye. Best wishes.

Operator

operator
#52

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of today's call. We appreciate your time and your questions. Should you have any follow-ups, don't hesitate to reach out to us at investor-

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.