Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 10, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 67 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Fabienne Caron

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the presentation of our results for Q3 of the 2022 to 2023 period. Joining us today are Karsten Wildberger, who is our CEO, and Kai-Ulrich Deissner, our CFO. Before we begin, please let me note that you can find the presentation slides on our website. We will be making some forward-looking statements on this call, so kindly refer to the disclaimer for further details. Please be aware that our operations in Sweden and Portugal remain part of our reported figures, yet they are left out of the guidance-relevant KPI, of currency and portfolio adjusted sales growth, and of adjusted EBIT. Lastly, please keep in mind that because of the technical effect of IAS 29, hyperinflation in Turkey, we will discuss business dynamics pre-IAS 29 during the presentation. Let me now hand things over to Karsten.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#2

Okay, thank you, Fabienne, and good morning to all of you. Welcome, everyone, to today's call, and thanks for joining us. At the start of June this year, we held our Capital Markets Day, and I want to express my appreciation as well for all the extensive feedback you gave us. That Capital Markets Day was a major moment for our company, since it was there that we unveiled our updated strategy. Interacting with so many of you and witnessing the recognition for the ambitious but achievable targets we set out has truly been encouraging. So today, together with our CFO, Kai Deissner, we'd like to bring you up to date on how we performed in Q3. We will also highlight a few areas where we've made progress in carrying out our strategy, and we'll give you a refreshed outlook. Let me start with some excellent news. We turned in a very strong Q3 performance, building on our very solid nine-month trajectory. Let me offer just a handful of general observations. Before we get into the key figures, let's examine the consumer electronics market and more broadly take a general view, because the consumer electronics market continues to be very attractive given the growing integration and the role technology plays in all our daily lives. Of course, the market does have its difficulties, and although the macroeconomic picture seems to be improving, with inflation declining and energy prices falling, consumers' purchasing power is still under pressure, and so is the CE market.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#3

Ceconomy is in excellent shape to succeed within a volatile market environment. Right at the core of our new strategy sits the customer experience, which our dedication to sustainability makes even stronger. This is no minor shift. We are going from Ceconomy being mainly a seller of consumer electronics to turning into a customer-centric service platform. Let me begin with one key point I want to emphasize: our Net Promoter Score, NPS, which reflects the customer experience, hit an all-time high of 55. What our customers tell us, along with the NPS score, demonstrates that we are on the right track — growing customer loyalty and reinforcing our standing as a leading player in the European consumer electronics market. Now let's look at how the consumer electronics market is currently developing in the countries where we operate. Including Turkey — across all the markets, including Turkey — the consumer electronics market grew by 2% in the third quarter. Excluding Turkey, the market declined by 5% over that same period. Against these market conditions, we as a group succeeded in raising our sales by 7.4% to EUR 4.5 billion in the third quarter. We picked up market share, especially in Germany, the Netherlands, and Turkey.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#4

Looking at the group overall, our market share held steady according to GfK data. Turning to earnings, we achieved additional improvement, with adjusted EBIT rising by EUR 43 million compared with a year earlier, as gross margin was stabilized and costs were managed carefully. I'd also like to stress that the steps we've taken to improve efficiency and reinforce liquidity are producing concrete results. Across the nine months of the year, free cash flow grew by nearly EUR 1 billion. Ladies and gentlemen, in light of this very strong Q3 and the nine-month performance overall this year, we are updating our outlook to a single scenario — the positive scenario one. For this fiscal year, we now anticipate a moderate rise in sales and a clear rise in adjusted EBIT. Please let's move to slide 6. During the third quarter, growth in the market came mainly from higher customer demand in brick-and-mortar business, which compensated for the online sector's decline. Other general retail sectors, such as clothing and furniture, saw a comparable situation in the third quarter. The number of customers visiting our stores rose 7% versus one year ago. The bricks and mortar business is recovering well — a very important question that, obviously, always gets asked after the pandemic.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#5

We've been able to take more market share in the DACH region thanks to our overall growth. In Western and Southern Europe, some encouraging trends are visible, and I'll also touch on Spain and Italy a bit later. Now let me move to the key aspects of how we performed in the third quarter, on slide 7. During the third quarter, as a group, we kept up the growth we delivered in the first half of this year. That performance, as highlighted, was driven by our robust brick-and-mortar business, where sales, revenues, posted a strong 8.2% year-on-year increase. With the brick-and-mortar sector continuing to recover, it offsets our weaker online sales. Taken as a whole, our online in-house share is approximately 20.4%, which is below our expectations, yet it remains significantly higher than the pre-pandemic level. I'd like to highlight that our pickup rate, a key indicator of our omnichannel approach — meaning someone orders online but picks up the product in the store — rose by 300 basis points, now standing at 41%. In the third quarter, we made notable operational improvements across several key countries. In Germany, our largest market, we increased both sales and earnings, maintaining our upward trend.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#6

We saw comparable momentum in the Netherlands and Turkey. On top of that, it's a pleasure to report that the work and attention we've put into Spain and Italy are producing favorable outcomes, which show up in better profitability patterns. I'd also like to provide a brief update on our portfolio. We're happy to report that the Swedish transaction has closed successfully, and we anticipate completing the divestment of our Portugal business prior to the close of the fiscal year. Our strategic, high-earning services and solutions business is likewise marked by growth. Even though consumer financing was tougher because of elevated interest rates, we delivered solid sales growth of 5.3% year on year, and that accounts for 6.5% of our total sales. We keep making meaningful headway in our new, very promising growth areas: retail, media, and marketplace. Through our marketplace, customers get an appealing, expanded, and rapidly expanding product range online. For us, this provides an additional income stream via reseller commissions. The marketplace business carries no stock risk and no other corresponding costs; at present, the marketplace is live in Germany, Austria, and Spain, where it posted sales growth of 121% in the third quarter. A rollout in the Netherlands and Italy is planned soon.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#7

On the customer side, the marketplace selection keeps expanding as well. As of the end of July 2023, we already had over 1,000 resellers, and roughly 1.2 million products in total were listed on our platform. To wrap up, the work we've done together has laid the foundation for growth in our strategic businesses, and our dedication to customer satisfaction is what drives us, with ongoing efforts to keep enhancing what we offer. Please turn with me to slide 8. As you're aware, at our Capital Markets Day we set out quite specific commitments tied to our new strategic direction of turning into a customer-centric retail service platform. Nine KPIs have been defined for 2025 and 2026 — covering retail core, services and solutions, marketplace, private label, space-as-a-service, and retail media — and those are the ones highlighted on this slide. Now I'd like to walk through how we've progressed against these KPIs during the last few months. Moving to slide 9, I won't cover every KPI in detail, but I do want to point out that loyalty members have shown solid growth rates, and on top of that we remain well on target with store modernization, including our lighthouse openings. With marketplace and retail media as our growth drivers, we're making steady headway.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#8

We're still not happy with how our online share is developing. Let me walk through what we're doing and how we're changing that. Our focus is on generating organic online traffic. We're upgrading our online functionality and content quality, and we're also increasing penetration and usage of our MediaMarkt app. At the same time, we're improving our store portfolio, and our motto is: the right format in the right place. Large Tech Villages in metropolitan areas, medium-sized stores with plenty of service and advice, smaller stores with a selected assortment, where customers can also access our entire range and pick up goods ordered online on-site. That's our approach. I'll give a few more details on the next slide. Let me share a few examples from the past few weeks that illustrate our commitment to driving our transformation. After the successful opening of six large Tech Villages in Europe, we opened a store in the so-called Express format for the first time in Germany in June. This is just below 1,000 square meters. As part of our omnichannel strategy, this store concept combines in a different way: service, an assortment tailored to customer needs and digital in elements that enhance the shopping experience.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#9

A store like this, one that's also more local in nature, helps make our online shopping more regional. Customers can test products at the shop just around the corner or swing by to collect them quickly. The key point is that this approach will let us run more physical locations near our customers going forward, though on a smaller footprint. These smaller formats give us fresh growth opportunities by reaching appealing sites that our previous, bigger formats simply can't access today. On top of that, they boost sales productivity for each square meter. Meanwhile, we're pressing ahead with modernizing our classic core formats on an ongoing basis. Recently, for instance, we upgraded a first MediaMarkt in Italy, built on a hybrid concept of our store formats, featuring highly flexible and sustainable design elements that we intend to roll out and apply in other markets. It has a warmer look and feel, with greater appeal as well to our female customers. There are plenty of experience zones where shoppers can try products out. You'll be seeing and hearing more from us about this concept as we move forward, including concrete figures. Slide 11, please. Before I pass things over to Kai, let me share a few more updates on two topics of great importance: technology and sustainability.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#10

Our tech transformation keeps moving forward at a steady pace. We've now successfully launched our new webshop platform in Belgium, in July, which brings us to 6/11 countries on this new technology stack. That means over 80% of our online sales are now generated on this new web platform. This lets us harvest synergies, increases speed, and we share improvements across all these countries once we implement them. All these functionalities are available much faster in all these countries. We'll expand to Switzerland, Turkey, and Hungary during the next fiscal year. We're also accelerating our MediaMarkt app enhancements with new features, functionalities going live in Germany in the first quarter of the next fiscal year. That means customers can now compare products more easily. They can utilize a QR code scanner, enjoy personalized content and push messages, status updates on delivery, et cetera. All these improvements and enhancements will make us more forceful in driving also our app adoption. Our tech transformation remains a key driver in shaping our future success. On the right-hand side of this chart, in the past quarter, we reaffirmed our commitment to sustainability as a cornerstone of our strategy, reducing carbon footprint, promoting sustainable business operations.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#11

To give you an example, we're aiming to grow the count of BetterWay items. That's our sustainability label — it rests on third-party certification — and the goal is to raise the BetterWay items in our assortment to 6,000 by the close of 2025. Through this effort, customers will be able to save more energy, and it will also advance the circular economy. Turning now to our trade-in offer, which you can see here, it has seen impressive growth, with trade-in products hitting a remarkable 75,000 units in Q3 2022, 2023. The year so far has gone very well, with roughly 150,000 trade-in products in total processed year to date. We're also seeing solid demand for sustainable services elsewhere. Our pilot project for renting electric cars has been received very well, and we're now taking it further. Starting this week, customers can again rent selected electric vehicles at a very attractive price via a subscription model. Together with Like to Drive, there's a choice of several attractive electric cars. As you can see, we're well along the road to transformation. I'll now pass things to Kai, who will give you a deeper insight into our financials. Kai?

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#12

Thanks, Karsten, and good morning from me as well. I'll walk you through our quarterly and nine-month figures on the pages that follow. On slide 13, you can see that sales momentum in Q3 was very robust, growing 7.4% year-on-year. Please keep in mind that this is adjusted for currency and portfolio changes, and these figures are pre-IAS 29, so before the effects of hyperinflation accounting in Turkey. And just to reiterate, the main driver of this sales development, again, is the continued recovery of our bricks and mortar business. From a country perspective, we saw good sales development in Germany and Turkey, along with improving trends in Italy. On EBIT, group-adjusted EBIT came in at minus EUR 60 million, which is an impressive EUR 43 million above the prior year, so roughly 2/3. This was driven by the strong sales development and successful efforts to offset rising cost inflation. I'll come back to that with a deeper dive later. This EBIT improvement over the quarter now allows us to look much more positively toward the end of the fiscal year. With nine months already behind us, we feel comfortable upgrading our outlook and focusing exclusively on what we used to call scenario one, so the more positive scenario.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#13

When we look at how we performed across the nine months, yes — even with macroeconomic conditions that remain uncertain and cost inflation that continues — we do feel comfortable delivering the first scenario in our guidance for fiscal 2022, 2023. That scenario is a moderate sales increase. Keep in mind that earlier we had talked about a slight sales increase and a clear rise in EBIT. If you examine the nine months performance, our adjusted EBIT has already gone up by an impressive EUR 35 million. That is almost a third. Now, on regions, turning to how we performed operationally. As you can see, Eastern Europe and DACH were again the main drivers this quarter. We are also pleased to see the trend improving in Western and Southern Europe. Start with DACH. Sales rose by 1.6% in Q3. Here, Austria and Germany showed very positive sales development, while Switzerland and Hungary reported a sales decline, largely due to the competitive market environment. In terms of profitability, this region posted a strong EBIT improvement with EUR 18 million plus. That is driven by Germany, thanks to good sales development and lower advertising cost. We can clearly see that here our efficiency programs are starting to bear fruits. In the other countries of the region, profitability was rather stable.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#14

Over in Western and Southern Europe, our sales came in slightly lower. Sales growth was solid in the Netherlands. Spain and Italy both still saw a sales decline, though in Italy we're seeing some improvement in the sales trend as we cycled over the highest comparison base in April. Keep in mind that state subsidies for digital TV gave us a positive boost last year. We're making progress in Spain as well. The sales decline there is mainly attributable to our online business. A new team has been in place since April, and we've especially improved product availability online. We're confident now that all of these measures will bear fruit going forward. On profitability in this region, we're pleased to report that we cut our EBIT loss here by EUR 5 million this quarter. The Netherlands and Italy were the main drivers behind this profitability recovery. Yet again, the highest growth rates were achieved in Eastern Europe. That's driven by strong demand in Turkey. Adjusted EBIT here improved by EUR 22 million in the region. Turning to services and solutions in some detail. As you know, services and solutions remains a key strategic pillar for improving our profitability going forward. Now, technically, for the current fiscal year, we're still commenting on the old definition of services and solutions.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#15

Services—covering retail media, marketplace, commissions and fees, plus deliveries—are part of this. Starting next fiscal year, we'll move our reporting to the new definition we laid out at our Capital Markets Day in June. Under the old definition, sales from services and solutions rose 5.3% year-on-year. That brings the sales share to 6.5% now. Looking at the service categories driving this, retail media performed very well, and so did warranty extensions. On the other side, as Karsten already said, the higher interest rate environment is weighing on our consumer finance business. We're also being careful in how we manage our credit portfolio so we can limit any potential rise in bad debt down the road. Also on the slide: online sales share hit 20.4% at group level in Q3. That's still nearly 60% sales growth compared with pre-COVID levels, even though we're not happy with the performance. Year-on-year, online sales fell 6.6%. It's obvious that customers still prefer shopping back in stores, which is leading to declining online sales across general retail as a whole. Our omnichannel proposition still keeps resonating well, as you can see in the pickup ratio, which rose to 41% in Q3.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#16

That's a 300 basis points increase versus a year ago — impressive. Now, returning to EBIT and how it developed, on slide 17. Once again we stabilized gross margin in the quarter, at 17.6%. Two main drivers: a tailwind from lower logistics cost, and second, a stable goods margin, thanks to a more favorable channel mix. On the selling prices side, we managed to pass some input cost inflation to consumers — not all of it. At the bottom of the slide, our OpEx ratio dropped by an impressive 90 basis points this quarter, to 19.8% of group sales. In absolute terms, OpEx rose by only EUR 9 million this quarter, as our efficiency measures accelerate and bear more and more fruit. What's behind this, as already highlighted in previous quarters: we do feel cost inflation in several areas, like personnel, location, energy cost. We do continue to work diligently on these headwinds, and have mitigated the OpEx increase with very strict cost management, even better than in previous quarters. Slide 18 summarizes the familiar drivers behind our gross margin, which I already highlighted just now. In this context, let me give you an update on our efficiency programs.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#17

So overall, we still expect restructuring costs of approximately EUR 100 million, with EUR 60 million to EUR 80 million of that falling in this financial year. During Q3 we booked EUR 31 million, and the remainder should be booked in Q4. That puts us in a position to achieve a savings run rate of about EUR 130 million starting at the end of fiscal 2023, 2024. We generated a high single-digit amount of savings in Q3 and continue to expect EUR 40 million in savings overall for this fiscal year. Underpinning this, we're continuing to streamline the headquarters structure, and as you're well aware, we have reorganized our repair services in Germany and are expanding our digital platforms and solutions internationally, as Karsten pointed out. Moving on now to reported EBIT down to EPS on slide 20. On the one-offs side, we recorded EUR 63 million in one-offs for the quarter. That's EUR 15 million below Q3 of last year. Within that, EUR 31 million relates to restructuring costs, and a roughly comparable amount — mainly non-cash — stems from IAS 29 hyperinflation in Turkey along with the deconsolidation of Sweden and Portugal. This resulted in a negative reported EBIT of minus EUR 123. That's nearly EUR 60 million better than a year ago. Continuing down the line, our financial results came in at minus EUR 33 million.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#18

This comes from increased interest payments as well as higher lease interest tied to market developments. Please keep in mind that within that EUR 22 million rise, the bulk is non-cash. The key reason is this: since we renegotiate lease contracts on a regular basis, from an accounting standpoint that produces a larger interest component within the financial results. Our rental cash out, though, stays unchanged. Across the full year, we expect a net financial result of approximately minus EUR 100 million. One particular effect. Regarding taxes, we booked a minus EUR 30 million charge during the quarter, and as is plain to see, that is the single biggest factor behind our net result in Q3. Allow me to walk through it. In the prior year, we booked a sizable tax income during the quarter, driven, among other things, by the impairment of our Fnac Darty stake at that time, along with weaker business expectations then. Because we apply an integral approach to tax, this in effect skews our tax rate at the quarterly level. Practically speaking, we fix our full year tax rate at the start of the year using our full year budget, then tweak quarterly charges as we go, reflecting unforeseeable impacts such as, for instance, the impairment charges we saw last year.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#19

Think of this negative year-on-year impact in Q3 as essentially a one-timer. For the full year 2023, we anticipate a lower tax rate brought about by the Convergenta transaction, a mid-double-digit tax charge, and on a cash basis, we're assuming a limited cash outflow of roughly only minus EUR 30 million. Specifically regarding this tax impact, in Q3 we reported a net result of minus EUR 186. That is EUR 90 million below last year, and as we explained, more than EUR 100 million of the delta stems from this extraordinary tax effect in the quarter. Our key focus across everything we're doing stays on free cash flow, and we're very pleased with the strong development over the nine months, which you can see on the current slide. Our free cash flow post-lease adjustments rose by EUR 996 million year-over-year, to minus EUR 87. We recorded a positive cash inflow of EUR 55 million from working capital for the nine months. That represents a very impressive EUR 820 million improvement year-on-year. Behind this in particular, our actions to reduce stocks paid off. Our overall stock position fell by almost EUR 500 million year-on-year, and our stock turn rose to 9.4 weeks. This compares with 10.5 weeks in the last year.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#20

Interestingly, you can also see here the positive underlying tax development, even with that one-time effect — there's a EUR 40 million improvement year-over-year at the top of the chart. Other operating cash flow is returning to normal compared with last year, since last year took a hit from the cash out for deferred tax and severance payments. Slide 22 shows our net working capital improvement, with attention on stock management. Ladies and gentlemen, our free cash flow is very strong, and that gives us confidence as we execute our current strategy. As always, let me remind you that we have no major debt repayment falling due at least until 2026. We can access EUR 1.1 billion in revolving credit facilities, which remain undrawn to date and have never been drawn. That wraps up the financial section — Karsten, let me hand back to you for the closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#21

Thank you, Kai. To wrap up, I'd like to offer an outlook along with a recap of the main points we've covered today. As we've said before, both now and earlier, our strong results across the first nine months of the year have led us to revise our guidance, and we are now working with just a single scenario — the positive one. For the 2022, 2023 fiscal year overall, we anticipate a moderate rise in sales and a clear increase in adjusted EBIT. Ladies and gentlemen, before we open things up for Q&A, I'd like to close today's presentation with a summary. First, good operating momentum carried on through the third quarter. Second, despite a challenging consumer electronics market, we achieved growth in key markets while holding our overall market share. Number three, we are clearly in command, and the steps we've taken to master current challenges are producing results. Number four, our attention is on the customer experience, and we are building momentum as we carry out our strategy. Number five, cost, profitability, and liquidity stay at the center of our focus. Lastly, we are updating our outlook for the 2022, 2023 financial year, with positive scenario one serving as our only guidance. With that, thank you for your attention, and we now look forward to your questions.

Operator

operator
#22

Yes, thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now start the question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question, you can press nine, then the star key, on your telephone keypad. Should you want to take yourself out of the question queue, press nine star a second time. If you are on speaker equipment today, please lift the handset before making your selections. I will finish up here. Anyone with a question may press nine star now. Please hold a moment for the first question. The questions are coming in. Our first questioner is Mr. Volker Bosse of Baader Bank. Please go ahead, sir.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#23

Okay, good morning everyone. This is Volker Bosse from Baader Bank. Let me congratulate you on a set of results that's encouraging. I'd like to begin with your remark that consumers' purchasing power is still under pressure. How does that show up in your numbers? What's the consumer reaction — are they trading down, or what lies behind that statement? Second, on the sales split by product group: just as a rough indication, what's the highlight and what's the lowlight when it comes to product sales, so which product segments are doing better and which are doing worse? My third question concerns the same service and solutions business, which stays stable at 6.5% compared with group sales. Isn't that a bit below what you expected, given that you invested in Smart Power, SPaaS and put money into this transformation into a service company? Your comment on that would help. Finally, if I may, just a brief one on current trading in July: how do you see things developing with regard to sales in July? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#24

Thanks a lot, Volker, for those questions. To keep it brief, there were basically four or five questions. Kai will handle the last one, the current trading question, and naturally he'll chime in whenever he feels he wants to add something. Consumer purchasing power is still under pressure. How are consumers reacting? In my view, the situation looks like this: as we mentioned earlier, conditions generally remain volatile. What does that mean? It means one month we feel, okay, it's a bit softer, and then another month it's, it's, it's going better. There's a certain volatility in that, and that's what makes it hard to predict. What we still observe is that premium is going very strong. Premium is going very strong, and we see more pressure at the entry point, which, which suggests there's more pressure on, you know, purchasing spend, what customers spend money on. Now, of course, we have, everyone hopes it's the holiday season, and then when people come back, at some point, there will be another demand. But we see kind of this bifurcation, if you like, this split between entry and premium, but premium is going strong.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#25

That also sort of brings me to how the product groups break down. Let me begin with the areas we're seeing as really, really strong. Telecommunications is very strong — hardware, mobile phones. Wearables are strong as well. Computer accessories are also very strong. On the entertainment side, entertainment hardware is strong too. Software, for us, is a good growth area. Things go well in what we call white goods, which are the big, big products, such as washing machines, and in small domestic appliances. Small domestic appliances, like floor care, are going very strong. What isn't that strong is the continued pressure on the TV section. I guess this is still a bit of a hangover from the COVID period, but let's see. It's still under pressure. Computer hardware isn't that strong either. I think that also has to do. What remains kind of stable is actually the big domestic appliances. It's a mixed bag, but within that, you can see that premium, if you like, goes better.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#26

I appreciate that.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#27

Services and solutions held steady, though they came in 6.5% under what we had expected. Here's how I see it, since Kai already went into a bit more detail on this point. What's baked into that figure is that the financing side of services is under pressure because of the high interest rate, yet it's actually a major contributor within the financial numbers. That stems from interest rates and the way the market looks right now. My own view is that over time we'll hopefully get back to a more normal situation as well, and broadly speaking I'm positive about this. Once you strip that effect out, we're actually performing very strongly. What's behind that? We're seeing good footfall in our stores, and very strong attach rates across the various services we sell. That tells me that operationally, we're doing a very good job of selling services and solutions. Another thing that gives me confidence looking ahead is that we have solid new services in the pipeline set to launch, such as myMediaMarkt+, which is essentially this enriched guarantee proposition, worry-free for customers, and it will take some time to ramp up. It's a very attractive proposition. That's how I look at both of these sides.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#28

From a strictly numerical standpoint, if I simply examine the figure, you're correct. We understand the source of this. Operationally speaking, though, I'm actually feeling more optimistic. As ever, there's plainly work ahead, and we'll get it done and deliver. Regarding July's current trading, Kai, please jump in if you'd like to add anything.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#29

Thanks. Hi, Volker. It's good to talk with you once more. As you're all very much aware, at this stage we aren't able to disclose specifics. I'd point you back to the guidance we gave, and let me restate it. For the full year, we're assuming a moderate rise in sales and a clear rise in EBIT. For EBIT, that means Q4 still needs to show another clear increase — otherwise the full-year figures wouldn't reconcile. A moderate sales increase and a clear increase, specifically in Q4 as well — nothing in current trading, nothing at all in current trading makes me question that statement. Regionally, let me remind you of what we flagged. We flagged good performance in Germany and especially in Turkey, plus encouraging trends in Italy and Spain. Nor is there anything in current trading that makes me question that statement covering the first nine months. That's how I'd put it.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#30

Thanks a lot. If I could, I'd like to ask one more question about your online sales. Your online sales are still declining. I believe the COVID effect has something to do with that as well. That said, how do you view the future of your online sales channel, and when will you get back to positive online sales figures again in terms of sales growth? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#31

Yeah, that's a key question, so thanks, Volker. Generally speaking, Q3 is always a quarter when it comes to online share. There are also certain seasonal patterns that differ, but clearly this falls short of what we expected. What we're seeing overall is that, if you look at the entire market, there's quite a decline in the online market as a whole. That's something we are, of course, also exposed to.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#32

Sure.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#33

For us specifically, what’s happening is that footfall in our stores is up a very strong 7%. That means more pressure is being placed on our online business. Operationally, when I look at the work ahead and where we need to improve, we have to grow organic traffic rather than paid traffic, because from an efficiency standpoint, more. Technically, there are things we’re developing, such as Search Engine Optimization, et cetera. We’re building quite a lot of technical capabilities in the background. I’m confident that over time this will bear fruits. The functionality of the website is improving and getting better, but more work remains to be done on the content side as well. That’s where we’ll accelerate much more, because that’s an important part, to basically go native through the app. We see a refresh of our app in September, and we will push that hard. Last but not least, the marketplace, the extension of our portfolio, is an important part of our strategy. It’s now the first time that I see growth rates that are really great to watch — Over time, this will also pay the dividends, in terms of building more attractiveness for customers to search for products and to purchase with us.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#34

One final point I’d make: considering the conditions, naturally, we also strike a careful balance between promotional efforts and our regular business in order to safeguard margins—and given the mix as well, I believe we’ve managed that quite well. That, in turn, actually affects the digital share too, which tends to be more vulnerable to things like price competition. All that said, and taking everything into account, clearly there’s genuine work ahead, as I mentioned. What makes me confident is that we understand the levers and what needs doing, and hopefully before too long we’ll come back to you with numbers that, again, I’ll be happier to report.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#35

Yeah. Thanks a lot. That’s really helpful. Appreciate the statements. Perfect.

Operator

operator
#36

Thanks. Our following question comes from Adam Gilday at Bank of America. You have the floor.

Analyst

analyst
#37

Hello, and thanks very much for taking my questions. Adam Gilday here from Bank of America. I have two, please. First, regarding retail media, I was wondering whether you could provide any quantification on how much it grew during the quarter, and whether it is growing at the pace you anticipated at the CMD when you set out the new targets? Then second, on the new web shop, I was wondering if you could walk through the services and solutions attachment rate. Are you seeing an increase on the new platform? Thanks.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#38

Adam, I’ll take the first question, on retail media. At the Capital Markets Day, we made retail media one of our key pledges. To remind you of that number, the goal for 2025 and 2026 is EUR 45 million in income. We’ll give a quantitative update with our annual figures, so with the next quarter’s quarterly results. Qualitatively, what I can say — and I made this explicit — is that with the arrows you saw on the slide Karsten presented, you saw a big arrow pointing up, and that’s also the tendency we’re seeing, but we can only share numbers in the next period, after the next three months. It’s all on the right track. That’s how I’d summarize it. Karsten, for you, the second question?

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#39

Yeah. Thanks, Adam. Regarding the uplift in service and solutions attach rate on the platform — clearly, service and solution attach rates are generally much higher offline than online, given the customer interaction. What we've accomplished over time is more than doubling that attach rate in the online world, and this is sometimes painstaking work that has to happen, since it really depends on which service we're talking about. Let me give you a few examples, and then please, if, hopefully, this answers your questions, but if you have further questions, please do ask. Give you a few examples. When you, for instance, buy a washing machine or any device, then of course, we have improved the engine, also the new web platform, so that the relevant services for this particular customer are displayed and shown. We have also made the process of then, say, clicking and adding the service much, much easier. What does that mean? It could be, for instance, a guarantee extension, it could be an installation process. On those things, like installation, we see very, very high attach rates. Let's take another very important service of ours.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#40

So if you're looking to essentially get a mobile phone contract together with the handset, that's something we're actively working on right now, so that signing up for a mobile phone contract — credit checks and all of that included — becomes far, far simpler. It's a more complicated process, and there we've recorded a substantial uplift of 70% versus the past, though additional work remains, and so forth. Really, it hinges on the service and product combination, and on where we're now building out the capabilities to track the customer journey and the attach rate through that process. What's special about this new web platform is, naturally, that essentially all development takes place on this website, or on this tech stack. Once we've enhanced something for one country — perhaps the one where the demand originated — then that same functionality becomes available across all of these countries. We get strong synergy gains and strong speed advantages. Finally, we carry out the same work on the app, and we have the app in every country that sits on that tech stack in this current format.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#41

This is a major priority for us, and as time goes on, we've managed to increase the attach rate by more than 2x. There's still more work ahead. Hopefully, we'll have additional growth to share in the future.

Analyst

analyst
#42

That is quite useful. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#43

Our next question is from Clément Genelot at Bryan, Garnier & Co. You have the floor.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#44

Thanks. I’ve got a few quick questions. First, on Germany: were you able to at least hold your market share there in Q3? If I recall correctly, during your CMD you said you’d gained roughly 120 basis points in your update there. My second question, if I may, is on guidance: the current consensus for 2023 EBIT implies an EBIT decline in Q4. I’m just wondering what your exact view is on that, and what your assumptions are for Q4 regarding demand and especially gross margin. Because if I’m right, in Q4 of last year you also booked an inventory write-off. What should provide some kind of boost, obviously? My third question is on services and repair: could you give us more color on the ongoing reorganization of your repair service team? Because some recent press articles mentioned about 400 job cuts at a subsidiary called Tec-Repair. Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#45

Thanks so much, Clément, for those questions. My suggestion is that you begin, Kai, with the finance-related ones. I'll take the question about market share in Germany, and after that the one on service repair and tech repair.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#46

Clément, let me revisit Q4 and maybe clear up any confusion my earlier response might have caused. On Q4, I’d tie it back to the full-year guidance. When it comes to the full-year EBIT guidance, looking at consensus expectations, we’re quite comfortable with those consensus expectations. If you take those consensus expectations, roughly speaking, that implies Q4 EBIT will be more or less stable—±0, ± a little—in the quarter compared with the same quarter last year. That’s roughly what we expect. Now, you asked about the margin in that quarter. You’re right about certain impacts we saw last year, especially from stock on our margin. As we’ve said consistently, we’ve made some progress managing stock, steadily over the last three quarters. With that in mind, and with our ongoing efforts to stabilize and even grow margins, my expectation is that with roughly stable EBIT versus last year, on an underlying basis, we would actually see, on a margin basis, an increase versus previous quarters in that particular quarter. Those are the two items I’d give on that, Clément. I’ll hand over to Karsten for the other two questions.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#47

Yes. Your other question was about how German market share developed in Q3. Does that match what we told you at Capital Markets Day? The clear answer is yes, it matches completely, and we have picked up market share in Germany. Clearly, the stores drove most of this gain, not online — the stores. On the whole, we have won considerable market share. Let me add one more detail that I usually don't discuss, but I believe it matters too, and honestly, I feel good about it. Because in Germany we managed to gain share on the MediaMarkt brand as well as on Saturn. The reason this matters to me and to the team is that we said we would run one kind of advertising, one type of campaigning, starting at the beginning of the year, as an efficiency measure. We did say that we think, and we hope, that Saturn will benefit from this too. In fact, for a long time now, we see good market share evolution on Saturn as well, and we can also attribute this to that decision we took to streamline the portfolio for customers.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#48

With two brands beneath a single roof, our advertising is stronger, and that approach is paying off. Naturally, yesterday's market share is one thing—we need to focus on tomorrow's market share. As for your question, the answer is a clear yes; I reaffirm what we stated at the Capital Markets Day. Thank you for asking about the Tec-Repair side, the service side. Perhaps just a single sentence for everyone else who might not grasp precisely where that question originates. Within Germany, there's a subsidiary named Tec-Repair. It's a company—a distinct entity—that handles in-store repairs. The German team made the call, and this matters greatly, they made the call to reinforce the service offering we give our customers. To accomplish that, they needed to shut down this company. That may sound quite counterintuitive. Allow me to clarify the reason. It's because when you walk into a MediaMarkt or a Saturn store as a customer wanting your phone fixed, you're essentially dealing with two companies. You're inside a MediaMarkt, yet in reality you're doing business with the Tec-Repair company. Should you have any other question beyond "Repair my screen"—anything at all—they cannot respond to it, they don't handle that, since they solely perform what they're essentially hired to do.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#49

So essentially, there's a great deal of confusion among customers, and honestly a fair amount of frustration within our own ranks as well, because we're delivering service across two separate worlds—two parallel setups—that's difficult to explain to customers. The German team came back and said, "That's enough, we want a single service offering in the stores. To get there, we have to shut down Tec-Repair." Now, looking at the figures, at Tec-Repair we previously had 800 people carrying out repairs. Going forward, we'll have at minimum 1,200 people. What that means is we'll essentially grow the headcount of those capable of performing service, and to achieve that, from the 800, we'll bring over 400 out of Tec-Repair, and we'll additionally train other colleagues to handle repairs. Beyond that, we operate a central repair facility located in Erfurt, which we'll likewise scale up and expand. One last point from me: this model is, in some areas—such as the central repair setup—essentially a copy-paste of our best-in-class organization in Spain. We're really taking something we learned and proved elsewhere and replicating it. Sadly, reaching this point required us to close an organization, and naturally we're working through that with the works council and with the employee.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#50

There was a time when we handled this properly. For the people impacted, this has quite understandably generated a great deal of noise. On the underlying side — thank you, Clément — and I hope I've been able to lay out the rationale and what we're actually doing. More service, clearer, better for the customer in the end.

Operator

operator
#51

Thanks, Mr. Genelot. Right now we don't have any more questions, so I'll go over the combination again. Ladies and gentlemen, if you still have a question to stage, please press nine star on your telephone keypad. Please press nine star right now. We have one more questioner. It's Mr. Alexander Koefoed of Nordea. Please go ahead.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#52

Yes, hello, and thanks for the opportunity to ask. I actually have two questions. Regarding your suppliers and the agreements you hold with them, could you shed some light on any KPIs you maintain with those suppliers around how many days payable you'll have with them? Would that lean more toward qualitative negotiations? And could you give us some insight into whether a batch of supplier negotiations is coming up, or whether they're, well, scattered more or less across the coming year? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#53

Yes. Alexander, thanks for asking. I'll attempt to clarify further and add a little more detail regarding our dealings with suppliers and just how wide the spectrum of, let's say, engagement and other agreements tends to be. On the first point, the payment terms: to be very clear, those terms are stable — something we're very, very clear about — and that's working well. As we've said, on cash flow and so on, that is very important. There's actually a wide spectrum of KPIs with suppliers. It isn't simply that we kind of negotiate with suppliers, say, kind of once a year to reach the big agreements. In fact, it's an ongoing daily cadence of working alongside them. It's a genuine partnership. It happens at all levels, including me personally meeting suppliers regularly. Of course, we do this under a frame agreement. That can of course contain sales numbers, unit numbers, these qualitative numbers, how we drive experience, attach rates of services, and so on. Certain suppliers also ask us to use our space — Space-as-a-Service, as we call it — to present their brand. It relates to repairs, it relates to installation, explaining the product, attach rates of selling a universe.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#54

Consider telecom firms offering various products. It truly hinges on the suppliers involved, yet I can tell you that with the major suppliers we work with, there are at times multiple requests they make of us, and those naturally end up being included in the agreement too, since our role goes far beyond that of a sales partner. We also act as a service partner, helping to showcase their brands. Certain companies likewise say, "Hey, we'd like to do something really substantial with you. We're planning to introduce new products." Some firms refer to this as the moonshot agreement, which is occasionally something extra. You can picture that moonshots tend to originate more from the U.S., though other companies do this as well, and we have a robust partner network that we collaborate with. It's a wide-ranging group, but let me also be clear, payment terms, stable.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#55

Right, understood. Thanks for clarifying that. So, on the frame agreement you brought up — and I want to be clear, I'm not assuming anything is relevant on that front at the moment — but supposing changes did occur, how quickly would they usually get put into place? Just so I understand. Take the sales KPI you mentioned as an example. If a deviation shows up in a given quarter, how soon would you typically expect the payment terms to shift? Would that kick in right away for the following quarter, or does it take a bit longer before you'd actually see the payment terms change, for instance?

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#56

Our payment terms remain extremely steady. They aren't—they aren't altering anything, and we're very transparent on that point, plus it's functioning in cooperation with the suppliers. This matters critically, yet suppliers grasp it too. They do grasp it. Regarding the customer experience strategy we run on NPS, et cetera, they likewise appreciate receiving information about this, data about this. Let me—let me be clear. Take, for example, our retail media business. A lot of our partners are interested in this, and it can happen that we reach an agreement on top concerning retail media. That means they can now position themselves, for example, on our website, they advertise differently, they obtain solid customer insights, data about this. That's something we would implement, for example, inside one to three months. This can happen. We're in solid conversations where some of our partners say, "Hey, we'd like more presentation of our brand in your stores, perhaps online, do something special for us." That is something we can pull off inside a month, two months. These are things which, I think the way to think about it, is that it makes the agreement and the engagement stronger.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#57

I want to be very clear about this. Every result we’ve presented, including on the cash side, would not be achievable unless we were — we are very clear about stable payment terms, and that is going to continue.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#58

If I could just tack on half a sentence here, Alexander. To be really precise about what Karsten said: when we talk about stable payment terms, we're talking about a multi-year perspective. If you look at it on a per-supplier basis and compare payment terms from a few years back with a few fewer years back, with last year, with this year, and very, very likely with next year, it's simply a flat line. Just to put a bit of a number on what customers say.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#59

Alright. Perhaps just one last point from me. Contrary to what was expected — and I realize things are steady at the moment, so I'm really asking about how it would function in real life should circumstances shift. Again, I don't have a fixed notion that this will definitely occur, but if a change came about, in what way, and how quickly, might suppliers adjust the payment terms? Would it usually be limited to a single quarter, or would implementing modifications to days payable, for instance, require a longer stretch of time for them?

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#60

Yeah.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#61

Does that make sense to you?

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#62

I get your point, Alexander, and I can see where you're coming from, but it — forgive me for putting it this way, that's somewhat of a hypothetical question, since that situation hasn't come up for us before.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#63

All right, that’s a reasonable point.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#64

Still, let me attempt to offer you a bit of reassurance. I'm not resisting your point. I'm simply saying that we're still somewhat wrestling with an answer. Those payment terms are locked in by contract under multi-year agreements or annual ones, so no modification to them has taken place, and I find it hard to imagine how such a change could occur in the very, very near future. That's the most I can offer, but think of it as an answer with two layers. First, we haven't observed it, and no one has requested it. Second, if it were required — if, say, whatever, I don't know, if the sky fell or something like that. If it truly had to happen, then it would conflict with a contractual arrangement of ours that is essentially fixed in stone and is settled on an annual basis. Does that give you a bit of color? I'm trying to be helpful in responding to your question, while having to admit that I simply haven't seen it yet.

Alexander Koefoed

analyst
#65

No, no, that’s really useful. I appreciate it. That helps a lot. It was, I suppose, more of a household question on my part, just so I could understand some of the background mechanics in a few of these contracts. That’s very helpful. Thanks. Thanks very much for that. I don’t have any more questions. Thank you.

Kai-Ulrich Deissner

executive
#66

Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#67

Thanks, Alexander.

Operator

operator
#68

That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer portion. I'll now turn things over to Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, for some closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#69

Okay. That brings us to the close of this Q3 results call. Many thanks for being with us today. As ever, our investor relations team, headed by Fabienne Caron, is always on hand for any additional questions you might have. Kai and I are also looking forward, in the period ahead, to seeing and meeting quite a few of you, and naturally we're glad to talk in person, take questions, and discuss. With that said, I'd like to wrap up today's call. Thanks once more for your attention and for your interest. All the best to each of you. Take care and see you again soon. Thank you very much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.