Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
December 18, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Fabienne Caron
executiveHello everyone, and welcome to the presentation of our results for Q4 and the full year 2022, 2023. Joining us on today's call are Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, and Kai-Ulrich Deissner, our CFO. Before we begin, allow me to note that the presentation slides are available on our website. On today's call, we will make certain forward-looking statements, so please consult the disclaimer for further information. I'll now hand things over to Karsten.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you, Fabienne, and good morning, everyone. We really appreciate you being with us today. I'm genuinely thrilled to walk you through the strong results we delivered in the last fiscal year. For our company, this past year was in fact a pivotal stretch—one in which we reinvigorated the business and deliberately reset where we're headed—even though we began it facing considerable uncertainty from outside forces. We also laid out a defined strategy along with explicit growth commitments for the years ahead, and I'm pleased to report that our execution against that strategy has produced concrete results. As you can see on slide four, the past year brought plenty of external headwinds stemming from shaky economic conditions—whether that was Russia's assault on Ukraine, mounting geopolitical friction worldwide, an energy crisis, the economic slump, higher energy prices, and above all escalating inflation—and all of that shaped customer behavior. Because consumer conduct shifted, we put every resource behind satisfying what our customers need and expect, reshaping our product lineup to fit them. We delivered, for example, our advisory and services offerings, with the goal of giving customers the strongest support we possibly can. And to my mind, the most important thing is that we treated these global uncertainties not as obstacles but as catalysts to push harder on executing our strategy, refining how we operate, and making the company resilient for the future.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveMoving on to slide five. In the previous financial year, we achieved meaningful progress toward our strategic goals. A key priority involved strengthening the core of our business. Throughout the past year, our company has grown leaner and more efficient, and even though the consumer electronics market, Turkey excluded, contracted by -3% in 2022 to 2023, we demonstrated our resilience. Our market share held firm, a clear indication that our strategies are delivering results and that we are successfully navigating the economic difficulties. Our modernization work focused on enhancing both the customer experience and the product experience. We have made our stores more inviting and more environmentally friendly, as well as more flexible so they integrate better with our online operations. This change has boosted our space productivity, and we have already modernized half of our stores. We have broadened our range of store formats beyond our standard models and premier flagship stores, known as Lighthouse stores, to include the more compact Xpress stores that serve local communities. Our aim is to identify the most appropriate format for each location, enabling us to give customers the finest shopping experience. We have likewise expanded our new business areas successfully, with notable progress in the services and solutions segment. We are also achieving strong growth in the marketplace and retail media segments.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveWe've grown our technology platform and made major improvements to logistics, which means the transformation is proceeding as planned. Sustainability is something we're clearly dedicated to, and I'm happy to say we hit our Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions targets for 2031 early. That milestone underlines how devoted we are to environmentally friendly practices and to the work we keep doing to shrink our carbon footprint. Above all, our customers and employees sit at the center of everything we do. Customer satisfaction has climbed to a new peak, and we stay dedicated to putting investment into training for our people. That way, our customers get strong advice and support. Let's move to slide six, if you would. As you're aware, the market we compete in is appealing but fierce. Our industry contains plenty of competitors. So what is it that cements our number one position, and above all, how do we remain at the top? A few reasons: our edge comes from being distinctive and from our capacity to push transformation. With over 70% unaided brand awareness, MediaMarktSaturn, our brand, holds considerable recognition. We also keep strong, long-standing ties with our industry partners and are constantly developing those relationships. Through new business areas such as marketplace and retail media, we give partners both existing and new outstanding chances for even more exposure.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveSustainability sits at the heart of who we are and is woven into every aspect of how we do business. During the last year, we have achieved meaningful advances on this front, delivering distinctive services that no one else in the industry offers. Our trade-in program is a strong illustration. In the previous financial year, customers exchanged their pre-owned electronics for vouchers on 219,000 occasions. As we outlined at the Capital Markets Day, our service platform is likewise building momentum, and in a moment I will demonstrate how we have taken it further. What sets us apart from conventional online pure plays is the omni-channel model we pursue. A major advantage in this regard is our staff, who help customers navigate the intricacies of technology and make the decisive difference. Our footprint is another defining element. We are present in 11 countries and rank number one or number two in nine of them, and we aim to strengthen and expand that standing further. Let's move to the next chart, slide seven. I would like to show you now how each of these elements shows up in our financial results. To begin, we posted impressive sales growth of 4.7%, which speaks to our robust market position and our capacity to capture opportunities. In addition, our Adjusted EBIT has grown as well, now reaching EUR 243 million.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThat EUR 35 million gain versus the prior year — an impressive 17% — comes from strong results in our in-store business, efficient cost control, and steady margin management. Third, on reported EBIT, note that special effects weigh on it, and it came in at -EUR 21 million. The main driver of that negative result was the roughly 23% equity accounted investment in the French retail group Fnac Darty, along with the cleanup. That means strengthening our portfolio. Fourth, on free cash flow, we brought in EUR 257 million, which is an EUR 880 million improvement over the prior year. And that beat our expectations, largely thanks to strong stock management. Number 5, Adjusted earnings per share came to a positive EUR 0.08. Last, our Net Promoter Score has risen to 53, and that score strongly signals customer satisfaction and loyalty. It shows we are significantly, significantly improving the customer experience so we don't just meet expectations — we exceed them. Overall, these figures show we aren't merely following market trends; we're setting ourselves apart through faster, more effective improvements. Our agility, innovation, and customer-focused approach come through clearly in these results.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveI'd also like to express my sincere thanks to every one of our employees for their commitment, their hard work, and their readiness to welcome how quickly things are changing as we move forward. A lot of you are in fact acquainted with slide eight, which lays out the strategy we described at our Capital Markets Day in June. So allow me to give just a quick recap. Our strategy, which puts customers at the center, is built around the experiences we create. We're elevating consumer electronics to a new level, moving toward what we refer to as experience electronics, and four key pillars bring this to life — our so-called experience pillars: the employee experience, the shopping experience, the usage experience, and the impact experience. First, the employee experience. Our people matter enormously to us. Delivering great customer service requires that they receive training, motivation, and inspiration. We've introduced new training programs and digital tools to raise their customer service performance. A strong employee experience produces a strong customer experience. Second, the shopping experience. We're upgrading every one of our channels so that shopping with us becomes even better. Taking a mobile-first approach, we're improving our online experience. Our stores are being refreshed with more flexible formats that deliver more engaging face-to-face experiences, seamlessly connected to the online world. Then comes the usage experience.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThe whole point here is expanding our service and solutions business — those efforts don't just broaden what we offer as products, they also create customer value and loyalty while we grow profitably. And finally, the impact experience. That's our sustainability commitment. We're advancing products that are energy efficient, conserve water, and are able to be repaired and recycled. Our goal is to lead in sustainable retail and to help our customers contribute as well. To us, sustainability is not merely a commitment — it's an enormous market opportunity. Every one of these pillars shows that our transformation is moving quickly, and our strategy demonstrates that we aren't simply reacting to market shifts but are actively shaping them. The next slide highlights our shift from a traditional business model toward a platform-based approach, generating profitable growth via distinct business models, orchestrated seamlessly for customers. Once again, this slide ought to look familiar to you. We handle more than 2.2 billion customer interactions every year across a range of channels, and our business model brings together different business entities, each having its own commercial strategy, growth path, and P&L. First, the retail core, our conventional retail segment, where promising opportunities exist for us to expand into new categories such as gaming, health, and e-mobility. Second, the service and solutions business.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThis part increases value and profitability through better customer experiences. For instance, we're expanding our subscription-based services. Third is the marketplace. It provides a wide product range and adds financially through commissions. Fourth is our private labels. They deliver cost-effective products with better margins and are being revitalized to speed up growth and profitability. Beyond that, we're innovating in how retail space gets used. Our Lighthouse concept gives physical display areas to industry partners, tapping our high customer traffic for distinctive brand presentations. It also gives customers direct access to leading brands. Our retail media draws on our large digital customer base, letting other brands advertise on our digital platforms. Supported by a robust omni-channel supply chain, a modern technology stack, committed personnel, and sustainable practices, we're moving toward an omni-channel services platform, and this strategy is crucial to secure profitable growth from our platform-based business model. If you go to slide 10, you'll see the nine major commitments we set at our Capital Markets Day, together with our 2025, 2026 objectives. As promised, we'll give a yearly detailed update on each key performance indicator. Broadly, you'll notice that in 2022, 2023, we made significant progress across most of our KPIs.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAllow me to highlight a few important points. First, the share of loyal customers has gone up. The count of loyalty customers has risen. The steps we've taken to improve the customer loyalty program have worked very well. There are also places where we aim to perform better, and places where our ambitions are greater, such as online along with services and solutions. I'll go deeper into these subjects on the slides that follow and demonstrate how those bigger ambitions will be reached. Let's move to retail core on slide 11. We have expanded our loyal, loyal customer base, which now stands at 39 million — a valuable group of customers who shop more often and also spend more. Our ongoing work to build an appealing customer loyalty program is delivering results. Online, we are in fact making significant strides. One sign of this progress is our high pickup rate, which hit 38% across the whole 2022 to 2023 fiscal year. Our online sales fell as customers went back to physical stores, so our online share came in at 23%. Still, we are seeing strong growth in our marketplace, which will give solid support going forward. In addition, we're putting measures in place to further improve our online performance — a key focus for the next fiscal year — and I'll share more on our plan shortly.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveWhen it comes to our brick-and-mortar locations, we posted an impressive 6.6% increase in sales, fueled by higher foot traffic. We're staying dedicated to our investments, and by 2022, 2023 we've now reached a 50% modernization rate. Eight Lighthouse concept stores are part of our portfolio today, among them recent openings in Vienna and Berlin. As for how we manage stock, we've made progress with a remarkable 11% reduction in stock reach, which now stands at 9.1 weeks. On the chart that follows, I'd like to walk you through how we've substantially upgraded our service offerings and successfully grown our marketplace. Within services and solutions, we recorded a notable 3.9% rise in income. It's important to note that we mean operational services and solutions income specifically, and this leaves out retail media, marketplace commissions, and fees and deliveries. Especially noteworthy is the strong demand for our warranty services and mobile phone contracts. We piloted the launch of my MediaMarkt+ subscription in Germany in October, with plans for an official launch in Q2 this year. Looking ahead, alongside our online efforts, we will keep growing our services and solutions business. Our marketplace, currently live in Germany, Spain, and Austria, has grown substantially. We have more than doubled our gross merchandise value, GMV, to EUR 137 million last year, and we currently offer 1.4 million SKUs from more than 1,000 suppliers.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThat represents a 41% increase. These numbers demonstrate not just how our marketplace is expanding but also how it is becoming more central to our business model. During 2023 and 2024, we intend to bring our marketplace into the Netherlands and Italy. Turning to the next chart, I'd like to examine more closely how we approach private label within retail media. We're not happy with how our private label share has developed — it stood at 2.4% in 2022 and 2023. Even so, we've already made meaningful moves, for instance by simplifying our logistics operations, which means goods now come in faster and more efficiently. Growing what we offer under private label is our third priority for 2023 to 2024, with the goal of drawing on our four brands, which give customers an attractive combination of price and quality. Our dedication to retail media has produced striking outcomes, generating EUR 18 million in retail media income across 2022 to 2023. We've seen robust growth and have consistently gotten favorable responses from our industry partners, and this area has shown itself to be a useful means of raising our products' visibility and reinforcing our industry partnerships. Slide 14 sets out the main areas we're focused on this fiscal year. On the online side, we keep honing our product assortment and availability.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThrough our marketplace, we're able to bring in new categories. On top of that, we're putting active effort into expanding organic traffic and strengthening our search engine optimization SEO capabilities. We're also upgrading how our app works so customers get a better shopping experience overall, and these steps are already delivering results. On the logistics side, we're running trials aimed at quicker, more efficient deliveries together with Lieferando, as one example. When it comes to service and solutions, following the launch in Germany and Poland, we intend to extend the rollout of the my MediaMarkt+ repair subscription into Spain. We will also widen what our subscription products offer, setting up our own billing platform. Beyond that, we'll keep growing our trade-in business. As for our private label, we've brought in new management and restructured our category management so the range becomes more efficient and appeals better to customers. Our partnership with the acclaimed two-star chef, Tim Raue, is a prime illustration of how we're elevating the marketing of our own brands. Tim Raue is showcasing his culinary creations that use the high-quality products from our KOENIC brand. As another example, in the summer we launched the PEAQ Portable TV, a smart 32-inch television built for portability and independent use, thanks to its battery operation, right in time for the camping season.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveLet's now take a look at the customer experience journey. We're putting a range of measures in place to improve how customers move through their journey with us. Store modernization has been sped up, and we're rolling out experience zones where people can engage with our products and try them out directly. On top of that, we're pushing forward with personalized marketing aimed at loyal customers, and that has brought both encouraging feedback and financial gains. Innovation continues to be a leading priority, and artificial intelligence is now an integral part of the landscape we operate in today rather than something far off in the future. We're committed to applying this technology in a thoughtful way. Our view is that AI serves as a tool for meeting customer needs and also helps our employees with their day-to-day work. And beyond that, we're seeing substantial growth in emerging product categories like augmented and virtual reality or smart home. Ultimately, an unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction is what drives us, and we keep working to improve what we offer. So let's move to slide 15. A cornerstone of an exceptional customer experience is an exceptional employee experience, and we've made meaningful progress on that front, placing strong emphasis on our people. MediaMarktSaturn is an attractive employer, providing an excellent work environment, an inclusive culture, and plenty of career opportunities. And this year we've trained 70% of our sales staff, and our aim is for all 40,000 colleagues in our stores to be trained repeatedly by the end of the 2024 financial year.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAdvancing women inside our organization matters greatly to how we honor diversity and equal opportunity. Over the last 12 months, more than 50% of the highly qualified promotions into senior management went to women. What makes us strong is the variety of our people — teams that are international, plus the blend of seasoned professionals and younger talent working together. We genuinely hold that mixed teams produce superior outcomes and tighter cooperation. That commitment shows up among our staff in the Net Promoter People, a gauge of employee satisfaction, which has climbed to +30 across the past two years. Diversity, teamwork, equal opportunities, lifelong learning, and pay for performance as well — these are the pillars of the employee experience at MediaMarktSaturn. Slide 16. Sustainability is a core value steering all that we do, as this slide underscores. Here at Ceconomy and MediaMarktSaturn, sustainability sits deeply within our corporate strategy. We see it as both a business opportunity and a duty to act responsibly. Our aim is to deliver a climate neutral shopping experience and to build greater awareness around sustainability. We are committed to helping our customers live in a more sustainable way. During the 2022 to 2023 financial year, we advanced substantially in providing one of Europe's most sustainable assortments of consumer electronics products and in leading on the circular economy.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveWe've broadened how widely sustainable products are offered, moved into the refurbished market, and expanded repair and rental services across our stores. Working hand in hand with manufacturers, we supply products that are energy efficient and environmentally friendly. On top of that, we've strengthened our advisory services so customers can cut down on energy consumption. Compared with the prior year, we achieved a 37% reduction in Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions last year, and in 2022 to 2023, 92% of all electricity procurement already came from alternative energy sources. BetterWay products' share of total sales rose by 9% to 12%, with over 4,900 SKUs. We also recorded a remarkable 250% increase in takeback of used appliances — what we define as trade-in products. At MediaMarktSaturn and CECONOMY, we recognize that sustainability is a gradual process requiring significant dedication and effort. We are committed to proactively enacting the measures needed to foster sustainability within our company and throughout society. With that, let me now hand over to Kai Deissner for the financial section. Thank you. Kai?
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveThanks, Karsten, and good morning everyone from my side too. I'll walk you through the full year numbers, beginning on slide 18, and naturally we'll get to the Q4 figures as we go along as well. Basically, what the full year figures show us are the first truly tangible outcomes of the transformation we've been pursuing. First, as Karsten pointed out, we delivered on guidance with sales growth of 4.7% year-on-year. Bear in mind, that's adjusted for currency and portfolio changes and pre-IAS 29. Second, Adjusted EBIT rose by EUR 35 million to EUR 243 million. That's 17% versus prior year. And third, this produces an Adjusted EPS of EUR 0.08. That Adjusted EPS rests on our reported net profit, adjusted for the impact of the Sweden and Portugal disposal, as well as the impairments for Fnac, and again, the IAS 29 impact. We see this as a pretty good proxy for our underlying performance. Lastly, group free cash flow reached EUR 257 million. Frankly, that's even better than we had expected. That's EUR 880 million better year-over-year. I'll obviously return to this later today.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveAlright, let's walk through these results one by one. During Q4, group sales for us went up 2.4%. Basically, we saw a softer back to school season throughout Europe, whereas Turkey stayed very strong. That weaker pattern showed up more online than in stores. Looking at a twelve-month view, growth came in at 4.7%, and we picked up 10 basis points of market share in a consumer electronics market that was declining, as Karsten pointed out. The key factor behind how our sales developed was a steady recovery all year long in our brick-and-mortar business. By country, we had good sales development in Turkey, a stabilization in Germany and Hungary, and some improving trends in Spain over the course of the year, while Italy stayed weak. Next, group-Adjusted EBIT was stable in Q4 at EUR 94 million. But please do note that this means a margin increase of 10 basis points, which is a good performance considering the sales development in Q4. This reflects, we believe, our better gross margin push and, once again, strict cost management this quarter. For the full year, Adjusted EBIT came to EUR 243 million. As I mentioned, that's EUR 35 million, or 17%, above previous year. Basically, this is driven by our strong sales and successful initiatives to offset cost inflation, which I will come back to.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveService and solutions, as you're aware, stay a key strategic pillar for boosting not just customer service but profitability too. On slide 20, what we're addressing here is the broad definition — so that covers service and solutions, retail media included, marketplace commissions and fees included, plus deliveries. I'm stressing this since earlier today you already saw the detailed sub-segment numbers when Karsten gave the update on our key KPIs. We'll keep commenting on these details going forward, but let me spotlight service and solutions in summary today, once again. Sales rose 3.2% year-over-year. That produces a stable 6.2% share. Sales in Q4 was flat. Do note that Q4 of the prior year was restated because retail media was reclassified in that year. Where service categories are concerned, retail media performed very well both for the full year and for Q4, and the same holds for warranty extensions and telecom contracts. Conversely, higher interest rates kept weighing on our consumer finance business. At the bottom of the slide, our online sales share normalized further in Q4, hitting 20.7% at group level. Viewed over 12 months, online sales fell 6.9%, which gives a 22.6% share.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveLike we've said all year, an increasing number of customers kept coming back to our stores, and online sales fell throughout retail — not only at our company but across the sector. Even so, as Karsten pointed out, we've put focus measures in place to improve our online results in the current fiscal year. On a brighter note, sales through our third-party marketplace have risen sharply, and our GMV has more than doubled, reaching EUR 137 million in 2022/23. We do anticipate that the marketplace's strong showing will carry on and will lift our online sales share over the medium term, which ought to help us hit the 30% target by 2025, 2026 that we laid out. Yet beneath all of this, our omni-channel offer keeps resonating very well with customers. The 38% pickup ratio for the full year shows it — an impressive 130 basis points of growth year-over-year. Now, let me return to how our EBIT developed on slide 21. Our gross margin rose by an impressive 70 basis points to almost 20% in Q4. That comes from product margin, and it happened despite competitive pressure during that quarter. Even looking over a 12-month view, this produced a slight gain in gross margin.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveNow moving down the P&L to cost: in Q4, our OpEx ratio went up slightly — by 10 basis points — to 18.3% of group sales. In absolute terms, underlying OpEx actually fell by EUR 5 million during the quarter, since our efficiency efforts are speeding up and increasingly bearing fruit. Keep in mind this leaves out one-offs amounting to roughly 0.5% of sales in Q4. Most of that figure relates to a provision for dismantling costs. There, we have adopted a fairly conservative stance, consistent with our generally prudent accounting policy. As we pointed out during earlier quarters, we are indeed experiencing cost inflation across several areas: personnel, location, energy cost. In Germany, as you're aware, wages have gone up by 5% as of October 2023, which already puts us ahead of whatever may come out of negotiations with the unions. Still, we keep working hard on these headwinds and have offset the OpEx rise through rigorous cost management. Consequently, for the fiscal year, our OpEx ratio came down by 10 basis points last year. Slide 22 once more illustrates the key factors driving our substantial gross margin gain in Q4, and in particular the big improvement in product margin that I mentioned a moment ago. So let's move on to slide 23.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveAs I said I would, I'd like to bring you up to speed on the efficiency programs. Overall, 85% of the measures we're taking to cut costs are in progress, and 25% of them are already finished. The main program driving this is what we refer to as Drive, and it focuses on both efficiency and how effective our organization is. To give you one example, we keep streamlining the functions at headquarters. Second, we've moved a portion of our shared services to locations abroad and streamlined the services we provide at group level. On top of that, we reorganized how repair services operate in Germany, and we're expanding our digital platforms and solutions in international markets. For all of this, we booked EUR 66 million in restructuring costs for the fiscal year 2022 to 2023, and we still expect roughly EUR 100 million in total through the end of this fiscal year. During Q4, we recorded EUR 27 million of restructuring costs tied to those programs. Consequently, thanks to these efficiency programs we'll be able to achieve a savings run rate of approximately EUR 130 million as of the end of the current fiscal year, measured against 2021 to 2022. In Q4 alone we already produced a double-digit amount of savings, plus EUR 40 million in savings across the full fiscal year 2022/23. Now let me move to how we performed operationally for the full year, on slide 24.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveSo, as you can see, the main drivers this year were Eastern Europe and DACH. Sales in DACH held steady. Within that, Austria posted a positive sales development, whereas Germany and Hungary were flat. Switzerland saw sales fall in a very competitive market environment. On profitability, this region delivered a strong EBIT improvement of +EUR 65 million, driven by Germany, where our efficiency programs are paying off. Second, in Western and Southern Europe, we saw a slight sales decline. We posted solid growth in the Netherlands, while sales in Italy were still down. We do need to acknowledge that, contrary to our expectations, the Italian market has not recovered yet. By contrast, in Spain we saw some improvement in the sales trend, particularly in Q4. There, our new management team is delivering well, and we have gained strong momentum, particularly in online. Again, on profitability, the region still recorded EUR 36 million Adjusted EBIT, which is a EUR 78 million decline year-on-year, and that's mainly due to Italy and Spain. Finally, Eastern Europe. Turkey was the clear outperformer this year, and this was the main driver behind the impressive EUR 72 million increase in Adjusted EBIT in the region.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveSure, the market is still quite favorable, and we saw robust volume growth even with inflation running high. On top of that, we picked up considerable market share. So when we look at that result, we see it not merely as a gift from the market but as very, very solid management execution. Let me now share a few highlights regarding how we did in Q4. As we mentioned, back-to-school was weak in Europe. That produced negative like-for-like figures in both DACH and Western and Southern Europe. Even so, we can report a stable Adjusted EBIT for the quarter, supported by improved gross margins and rigorous cost control. Region by region, the primary profitability drivers were DACH, including Germany, and Eastern Europe, including Turkey. Moving on, from Adjusted EBIT down to EPS, on slide 26. Let's read this carefully, starting at the left. We booked EUR 132 million in one-off costs during the year. Let me walk through them in detail. EUR 69 million of that is restructuring costs, mostly tied to our efficiency programs. Please note that this line actually contains even a EUR 21 million positive impact from IAS 29. 69 restructuring costs. Cleaning up our portfolio through the disposal of Sweden and Portugal added another EUR 63 million in cost, largely from an impairment charge as we wrote off the business in Sweden.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveOn the cash side, just 50% of the restructuring costs tied to the efficiency programs were paid out during the year. The remaining 50% gets paid in 2023 and 2024. When it comes to the portfolio cleaning actions, the cash out landed in the mid double-digit range. Moving one step to the right. As you're aware, we hold a 23% stake in Fnac, consolidated at equity. There we posted a net profit loss of -EUR 50 million for this year, and we took an EUR 82 million impairment because our stake's valuation came down. That added up to a further EUR 132 million P&L charge in total. Taken together, these actions produced a reported EBIT of -EUR 21 million for the year, even though we see the 17% growth in Adjusted EBIT as a fairly accurate picture of the operational gains we made. One more step to the right. Our financial result came in at EUR -21 million. But once again, this needs breaking down. That minus twenty-one contained a number of one-offs stemming from deconsolidating Sweden and Portugal, among them a positive currency effect of EUR 76 million. Strip those out, along with the financial results from Sweden and Portugal, and our underlying financial result would have landed at roughly minus eighty.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveThe detailed calculation is in the appendix of the presentation. And this minus eighty would have been well within our expectations. Remember, we said around minus one hundred in our Q3 call, and it would have represented a EUR 30 million increase year-over-year. All of this due to higher interest payments and higher interests on leases, even if the main part of that increase is non-cash. Finally, on taxes, we recorded a EUR 5 million income due to the further activation of deferred tax assets. Net of EUR 2 million minority interests, this derives the EUR 3 million you can see on the chart. All in all, for the full year, we thus reported a -EUR 39 million net result, EUR 165 million below last year. As explained, roughly 50% comes from the cost of our portfolio measures and the impairment of our stake in Fnac. To judge our operational performance, should we look at our net profit, excluding the impact of our portfolio measures, excluding the impairment of Fnac, and excluding IAS 29, our Adjusted net profit would be a +EUR 37 million. And we believe that this KPI is more appropriate to measure the progress we've made in our operating business.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveSo because of that, Adjusted EPS came in at EUR 0.08 for this year. Slide 27's table simply presents, in greater detail, the same slide I just took you through, so I hope it proves useful for your own work. Moving to slide 28, the Q4 financials reflect that same trend. For Q4, we posted EUR 95 million in Adjusted EBIT, a steady result versus a year ago, as we've discussed. Non-recurring items came to -108, of which -132 stemmed from our Fnac stake, as I explained, which left us with -EUR 14 million in reported EBIT. As I outlined, the deconsolidation of Sweden gave our financial result a positive lift, contributing 76 million in that quarter. On taxes again, we booked a 29 million income thanks to further activation of deferred tax assets. Although our reported EPS of EUR 0.14 sits below the prior year, once more, on an Adjusted basis — so stripping out the effect of cleaning our portfolio, stripping out IAS 29, and stripping out the Fnac impairment — Adjusted EPS came to EUR 0.06, and that is in fact a strong year-over-year increase. Last, free cash flow. What does it come down to? Our free cash flow after lease adjustments rose by an impressive EUR 880 million versus a year ago, landing at EUR 257 million.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveAnd honestly, that came in ahead of what even we had expected. We posted a positive cash inflow of EUR 332 million from working capital. That represents an improvement of more than EUR 700 million year-over-year. We did particularly better than anticipated on stock management. Our overall stock position came down by almost EUR 260 million, and our stock turn rose to 9.1 weeks. That compares with 10.3 weeks last year. On tax, we had a EUR 109 million cash outflow. That was above our expectations, and for good reasons, since the stronger performance of Turkey drove higher tax payments. Our cash CapEx was nearly flat year-over-year, pretty much in line with what we had expected. But overall, we are very, very pleased with the free cash flow generation this year. And to reiterate, free cash flow is our key focus going forward. So to summarize what I've just presented to you: good sales growth, a strong increase in EBIT, driven by both margin and cost discipline, even while cleaning our portfolio and taking robust measures to improve free cash flow. All of these are good, tangible, hard facts that prove we have taken good steps on our journey, and these steps do strengthen our overall financial position.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveHere's slide 30, and this is where I'd like to wrap up today. As you'll recall from our Capital Markets Day, our leverage here is measured as net debt, including lease liabilities, over Adjusted EBITDA, and it strengthened considerably to 1.9 for fiscal 2022 to 23 — well under our threshold and considerably better than what we had anticipated at Capital Markets Day. Sufficient liquidity reserves underpin all of this. We face no major debt repayment, at least until 2026, and we do have access to EUR 1.1 billion revolving credit facilities, which remain undrawn and have never been drawn. So with that, let me hand things back to Karsten for the outlook and some closing remarks. Karsten?
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThank you so much, Kai. If we could move to slide 32, that one matters quite a bit. So to wrap up, ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to give you our outlook for the coming financial year, 2023 to 2024. Once more, we're expecting a modest rise in total sales on a currency and portfolio-adjusted basis, and every one of our divisions should contribute to that sales growth. Beyond that, we foresee another clear improvement in Adjusted EBIT. The DACH region along with Western and Southern Europe should be the drivers behind it. Moving to slide 33, we restate our commitments to the capital markets, and when we look at our projections for the 2023 to 2024 financial year, we feel confident about hitting the 2025 to 2026 targets we laid out for you at the Capital Markets Day. We anticipate sales growth somewhat above the market average, and we also expect to reach an Adjusted EBIT of more than EUR 500 million by 2025 to 2026. Slide 34 is another very important chart as well. Let me look a bit more closely at what we saw during Black Week. It isn't only a single Black Week — it's the Black period, Black November, whatever name you give it. I can tell you we've made a promising start to the new financial year, with campaigns for Black Friday and the pre-Christmas season that were run centrally across the whole company and very well managed...
Karsten Wildberger
executiveDemand came through strongly across smartphones, consumer electronics, gaming consoles, and small electric appliances — floor care products among them. What drove our success over the Black Weeks was very careful preparation, robust supplier partnerships, and efficient logistics processes, which kept product availability high. On top of that, our marketing campaigns were crucial in building awareness and customer demand. Taken together, across the Black Weeks period we actually succeeded in lifting sales for the entire group year-over-year. That solid beginning to the year leaves us confident about 2023 and 2024. Let me now conclude on slide 35. At MediaMarktSaturn, we delivered positive results even with the market environment being challenging. Our market share holding steady shows our efforts to tackle present challenges have worked, above all by putting the customer experience first. We stay committed to controlling costs, preserving liquidity, and boosting efficiency so that we remain competitive and financially prudent. Consequently, we expect, once again, a slight rise in sales and a clear rise in Adjusted EBIT for the current financial year. This positive outlook strengthens both our confidence in the strategic direction we have chosen and our commitment to pursuing and reaching our goals. Ladies and gentlemen, as our presentation draws to a close, I want to stress the resilience and positive momentum at MediaMarkt that we have shown over the past financial year.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveEvery one of these gains really brings out how much opportunity exists inside our business. We're moving forward at a consistent pace toward the targets we've set, and the 50,000 people on our team are putting in real effort to bring to life what we envision: a service platform centered on customers that reflects stronger profitability, greater efficiency, and sustainability. Given how firmly they're committed to innovating and to satisfying customers, I have no doubt we'll reach the ambitious goals we've set for ourselves. I'd also like to thank you for listening and for placing your confidence in this journey we're on. Kai and I are now ready to take your questions.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, we're going to start the Q&A portion at this point. Should you like to pose a question, you can dial nine and then press the star key on your touchtone phone. To take yourself out of the queue, dial nine star and then hit the star key once more. If you happen to be on speaker equipment today, kindly pick up the handset before you make those selections. Anybody with a question is welcome to press nine followed by the star key right now. Please hold for a moment while we get to the first question. Our first question is from Emmanuelle Vigneron of HSBC. You may go ahead.
Emmanuelle Vigneron
analystYes, hello, and thanks for taking my questions. There are two things I'd like to ask. The first concerns retail media: you've brought in EUR 18 million in sales there. What effect does that have on operating profits? And second, in which markets did you lose market share? Thank you.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveStarting with the retail media question. My apologies, Emmanuel — my microphone wasn’t turned on. Thanks for those questions. Now, on retail media, I’ll take the first one, from Kai. That EUR 18 million figure you mention refers to income. It isn’t sales — it’s income. I hope that answers your question.
Emmanuelle Vigneron
analystYeah, thanks.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThanks for the question, Emmanuel. Where did we lose market share? Income. It's income, not sales. Hopefully that answers what you were asking. Sorry, there's a bit of background noise on our end. Apologies for that. So let me address the market shares you asked about, where we lost market share. Overall, let me say we're very pleased that across the group, we managed to gain market share slightly. Let me begin with the ones where we actually gained market share. Germany was strong over the full year. We've seen Austria as a market leader with a strong result, and the Benelux too, especially in Netherlands, has performed really well. And Turkey has also delivered a very, very strong performance. Where market share has been under pressure was slightly in Italy, and Switzerland, as well as in Poland. Market share is below 1%, a reduction overall, so that's the picture for the full year.
Emmanuelle Vigneron
analystAlright, thanks.
Operator
operatorMarius Schmidt from ODDO has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Marius Schmidt-Ott
analystThanks for the questions. I have a few. First, could you comment on how you've done so far in Q1 2024 with regard to margin and inventories? At this point, is that better than last year or in line with it? Second, please comment on like-for-like growth in DACH and Western Southern Europe, quarter to date. Third, on IAS 29, I think you had a positive effect of only EUR 6 million for the full year. I have a bit of a disconnect there. Is it easy to explain in a sentence why you show such a high like-for-like growth figure in Eastern Europe and also material EBITDA improvement, but the hyperinflation effect shown there is so low at EUR 6 million? I can't really bring this together. Maybe you could help me on this. Thank you.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveYes, thank you so much for that question, Marius. I'll cover current trading, the margin, and inventory. Kai will address Like-for-like growth in DACH and West and South, along with IAS 29. Look, first of all, regarding Q1, there's nothing beyond what I've already said about, let's say, the black period on sales that I can share. On the ninth of February we'll hold our Q1 call, and at that point we'll lay everything out in detail. Let me just say more broadly that the work we've done on stock management, on improving stock turn, and also on raising availability by genuinely getting better as an organization and using different tools, et cetera — that work, of course, continues. And these numbers will also demonstrate to you that we entered this financial year with a much fresher stock level, which matters as well. And although I can't comment on margin at this time, you can assume, as Kai has also laid out, that our efforts will carry on, and we've committed to the capital market on margin management too, whether that's product margin or growing the other businesses such as service and solutions.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveKai?
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveMarius, I’ll address the IAS 29 question. Let me head off a detailed explanation—our IR team would be glad to walk through it with you offline. Still, I’ll lay out the core reasoning behind why the figure is so unexpectedly modest at EUR 6 million. As most of you know, IAS 29 is the standard for hyperinflation accounting, and it involves two components. The first is the development of CPI—consumer price indexing—and the second is averaging out the gap between the quarter-end exchange rate and the average exchange rate across the quarter. In Q4, CPI rose substantially, while the spread between quarter-end FX and average FX was only modest. Those two factors therefore offset each other, leaving just a small EUR 6 million. I’m glad to share the details offline, but I hope that at least gives you a high-level explanation, Marius.
Marius Schmidt-Ott
analystYeah, thank you. Appreciate it — that's all for now.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Clément Genelot at Bryan, Garnier and Co. You have the floor.
Clément Genelot
analystGood morning, and thanks. I've got maybe a couple of questions. First, on the risk of deflation: in 2024, do you see any emerging danger of that on the consumer electronics side in the markets where you operate? A lot of retail industries are showing fairly strong disinflation trends, and on top of that, the U.S. has already moved into deflation in consumer electronics. My second question concerns EBIT for next year. When it comes to the EBIT improvements you expect in Southern and Western Europe, will those come mainly from gross margin — that is, all the growing services, retail media, the marketplace, and the fix for your past problems in Spain — or will sales leverage be the driver? Thank you.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThanks a lot, Clément, for those questions. So regarding deflation, Kai is going to answer that. I'll begin with where the EBIT improvement is coming from, and I'd also like Kai to perhaps provide additional detail on it regarding the financial figures and so on, since I believe it matters to revisit what the assumptions are for this year. So where does the margin improvement originate? It originates from — and this is very important, as we set out various areas — and those will keep going. 1 is, naturally, we have work underway, and we demonstrated that in the last financial year as well, and you also saw it in Q4; we'll keep working on the product margin side, which matters to us. Then, naturally, the lion's share of the growth comes from our growth businesses. Take services and solutions — we anticipate a further strong contribution over the period ahead. Retail media is expected to grow too, along with the marketplace. Broken down by country, as I mentioned, we anticipate every region to contribute. So if you look at the strong improvement across recent financial years in Germany, naturally, with all the progress we're making, we'll keep delivering strong results in Germany, with additional improvements on the way.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAnd as Kai mentioned too, clearly we're also expecting Spain to perform better — considerably better — this year. And like Kai explained as well, we've witnessed some really positive developments in our Spanish business. Let me highlight one additional point regarding Turkey, since that frequently gets somewhat misunderstood, because I believe the management team there — if you consider market share gains and the way we run things — is genuinely a very, very strong company. A very strong business that we're happy with, and clearly we expect it to do well there going forward. However, when you ask about our assumptions, naturally we have assumptions that are more normalized, so we don't expect, you know, that everything will be super, super strong down the road. Still, let's not forget Turkey. It's a very strong business with very strong management, so the margin comes from all of those areas. But Kai, please.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveClément, I want to build on what Karsten said, and I’ll begin with your first question—sorry, your second question first. So what’s going to drive EBIT improvement this year? Mathematically, we’ve guided for a slight sales increase, but a clear EBIT increase. So yes, we expect EBIT contribution to come not only from sales leverage but also, again, from clear margin improvement, and Karsten did a beautiful job explaining the drivers behind those. But to answer very clearly: margin improvement and sales leverage—or rather the other way around, sales leverage and margin improvement. Now, you initially asked about price deflation. A couple of points on that. So yes, already in Q4, we saw inflation decrease. That’s not the same as deflation, but inflation decreases. That’s one true fact. Second, keep in mind the special situation in our sector. Consumer electronics have short product life cycles, and we do operate in a market with high competitive pressure. So what usually happens is new products come to market at a high price, which then slowly but gradually falls, which is effectively deflation. So we’re used to operating in an environment like this, and we do expect some normalization toward that direction—I would say toward that direction—in 2023 and 2024.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveAlso, bear in mind what we mentioned regarding cost—on the flip side, a drop in inflation, or possibly even deflation, would in time affect cost as well and work in our favor. In addition, our cost improvement programs really only take full effect in 2023 and 2024. I cited 130 run rate savings and noted EUR 40 million was already achieved during the last fiscal year. That means the majority remains to come through in 2023 and 2024, which ought to benefit us once more in what could be a deflationary climate. I trust that addresses your question, Clément.
Clément Genelot
analystYes, thank you.
Operator
operatorAndreas Riemann from ODDO BHF has the next question. Your line is open.
Andreas Riemann
analystYes, good morning. I have two topics to raise. So, apologies, but I want to return to the EBIT outlook for this year. I believe last year produced a clear increase, which came to a EUR 35 million rise in EBIT. So is that same magnitude what you have in mind when you guide toward a clear EBIT increase this year? I'm not certain I grasped your response regarding Eastern Europe. I think you mentioned it briefly. Do you expect that Eastern European EBIT could decline this year? That would be the first topic. And the second concerns the gross margin: the product mix drove a 70 basis point improvement in the gross margin during the fourth quarter. Is that a structural change that you are steering toward? How much of it is sustainable over the coming quarters? Those would be my two topics. Thanks.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveYeah. Thanks, Andreas. Kai is going to address the questions on margin and the EBIT outlook. So what does that mean? By a clear increase, we mean EBIT goes up by a double-digit percentage, so 10% or more. That is what a clear increase refers to. And then, naturally, you can work out the numbers yourselves. Kai.
Kai-Ulrich Deissner
executiveThen, Andreas, you raised a few detailed questions on this. So what we're guiding for that clear increase is that DACH plus Western and Southern Europe are driving it, which does suggest Eastern Europe might not contribute to the same degree. Yes, we can confirm that. Okay? So think of the clear increase as 10%, but we're not guiding any absolute figure on that. And you asked about gross margin in Q4. I'm gonna give you an on the one hand side, on the other hand side, sort of answer to that. Now, the Q4 margin is highly impacted by certain condition types that become effective at the end of our fiscal year. So the Q4 margin, you cannot expect it to reappear automatically in Q1, Q2, and Q3. It is always a bit special, the Q4 margin. Okay?
Karsten Wildberger
executiveAt the same time, structural change is what's behind it. Sure, we're pursuing better margins. We're putting in very, very serious effort to lift our margin and sharpen how we manage inventory. You can see that in the figure. As for the absolute value you mentioned, don't count on it showing up again in Q1, Q2, or Q3, and I hope that clears up your question.
Andreas Riemann
analystYes, that's right. So then I'd finish by saying that during 2024, the product margin gives EBIT a favorable lift, correct? That seems like a reasonable assumption.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveNow, to tie this back to what Clément was asking.
Andreas Riemann
analystYeah.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveThe question was about EBIT, and that's driven not only by sales but by margin as well — and margin, again, comes from product margin plus the growth areas Karsten mentioned.
Andreas Riemann
analystAlright, that’s very clear. Thanks.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveGlad to help.
Operator
operatorAlessandro Cuglietta from Kepler Cheuvreux has the final question. Go right ahead.
Alessandro Cuglietta
analystYes. Hello, everyone. Thanks for asking those questions. I have a couple of things. The first concerns services and solutions as well as private label. I'd like to revisit this, since both are major contributors toward your EBIT targets for 2025 to 26. And I simply want to know whether you remain confident about those targets, given how stable things have been this year, and then how we should think about it — should we expect an acceleration in 2024, or perhaps a similar linear progression across the next three full years? And my second question concerns the consumer spending trends you are observing. Maybe you could share some color on the differing performance between premium products and more entry-level products. Are you noticing any particular trend there?
Karsten Wildberger
executiveYes. Thanks, Alessandro. I’ll address those two questions about services and solutions. What should we expect in 2024? Is it a linear progression, and so on—how are we performing? Look, we’re confident—completely confident—in what we stated at the Capital Markets Day: that service and solutions is a major contributor. And I’d expect this to proceed in a linear way, with some acceleration near the end. Why? Because we’re not only focusing on the current portfolio and raising attach rates online, but offline as well. Consider the GSM area alone, where we’ve performed, for example, very well, while also launching new service businesses such as subscription-based services. I mentioned my MediaMarkt+. We also introduced, with great success, a content product, Let’s Go TV, in Germany, which is performing very well. Naturally, those subscription-based services require some ramp-up, but this is something we’ll pursue in every one of our countries. Let’s not forget the sustainability-related services that are also on the way. There is portfolio growth. The clear answer is yes—we are completely confident and committed to it, and I think the best assumption is to begin with a linear progression.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveLet me give you some detail on where performance differs. What we’re seeing is that premium continues to hold up well. And broadly, we’re also noticing some volume pressure across the market, which points to where consumer sentiment stands right now. But we also recognize that conditions these days are somewhat more volatile, so nobody can truly predict what lies ahead. Here’s one illustration. Demand is rising very sharply in areas such as energy-efficient products, including white goods that use less energy. That could in fact help drive some demand. So we’ve observed an increase of several hundred percent in energy-efficient devices. That said, we of course always track market share, make sure we get our fair share, and if you look at what I just reported on the Black period, Santa Claus is, or Christmas is actually happening, I think, also this year. So it’s a bit, a bit generally tricky, but I would say, premium going well. Entry, there is a demand, and we see a bit of a volume pressure.
Alessandro Cuglietta
analystAll right, thank you. That's very clear.
Operator
operatorSince nobody has any more questions right now, I'll give the floor back to Dr. Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, for some closing comments.
Karsten Wildberger
executiveWell, ladies and gentlemen, thank you so much for your time and for the questions. With that said, I'd like to wrap up today's results call. I wish each of you a very happy and joyful holiday season, however you may celebrate it with your loved ones. Take care, stay healthy, and if you still need some Christmas presents, let us help you find them. So with that, all the best, and goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.