Champion Iron Limited (CIA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 29, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning, everyone. I'm Joanna, and I'll be handling the conference lines for you today. Right now, I'd like to extend a welcome to all of you on behalf of Champion Iron Limited as we begin the Third Quarter Results Conference Call. <<operator_script>> Thanks very much. Mr. Marcotte, the floor is yours.
Michael Marcotte
executiveThank you, operator, and good morning to all of you — or good evening if you're calling in from Australia. I want to express my appreciation to everyone for being with us today as we go over the results for our third quarter of the fiscal year that ends March 31, 2020. I'd like to point those of you on the call toward a presentation that management will be referencing, and it's available on our website at www.championiron.com in the Events and Presentation section. I also want to remind our listeners that certain matters we'll be talking about today on this call might include forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements cover, but are not limited to, things such as expectations about the market price of iron ore, timetables, mining operating expenses, capital expenditures, guidance and reserve estimates. The statements we discuss today may carry risks and uncertainties. A number of factors and assumptions went into preparing those statements. As a result, actual results could differ materially. So you should not place undue reliance on forward-looking statements. For more information regarding forward-looking statements, risks and assumptions, please consult our most recent MD&A and other filings made with Canadian securities regulatory authorities. Those documents are also available on our website. Champion disclaims any obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements, except as required by law.
Michael Marcotte
executiveI'm delivering this cautionary note for every Champion spokesperson who might speak to you on today's call. Be aware that unless we say otherwise, each dollar figure is in Canadian dollars. With me today from the Champion Iron management team are David Cataford, our Chief Executive Officer; Michael O'Keeffe, our Executive Chairman; and Natacha Garoute, our Chief Financial Officer. Having said that, I'll hand things over now to our Executive Chairman, Michael O'Keeffe, and after him our CEO, David Cataford. At the end we'll also keep the call open for a Q&A session. Michael?
William O'Keeffe
executiveThank you, Michael. Happy new year to everybody. For Champion, I believe 2020 will be a really thrilling year. I also believe the coming 5 years will be a really thrilling period for Champion. The basis for that comment is that I'm genuinely encouraged by the fact that, when we were out in the market very recently, and also when I got up this morning and checked Mysteel iron ore prices, the whole world is discussing the collapse in iron ore prices driven by China. This morning we saw the spread from the 62% Fe widen to $16. As an example, the 62% Fe sits at roughly $84 a tonne, whereas our 65% material remains at about $100 a tonne. There are a few factors behind that. We have consistently stated that high-grade material would be in strong demand, and that is really moving to the forefront now. China is clearly driving that market, along with the unfortunate situation there at present. But I notice the good old Australians have found the virus. My hope is that a vaccine arrives before too long. Let's set that aside, though, and discuss why I'm so bullish on the next 5 years.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd really, if you look at what Vale, BHP, and Rio are doing globally — those are the true forces at play here. When we first set out to buy the assets, those companies were the benchmark we used from day one. You may recall that at the time, everybody was predicting catastrophe with iron ore priced at $38 a tonne or lower. Our approach was simply to watch what the major players were up to, and that's exactly what we do now. Take Vale — the issues they're facing are beyond fixing. I can't even start to get into the difficulties they're dealing with, but those difficulties are moving the market, and specifically the high-grade segment. So right now we're seeing that $16 premium, which is precisely what we had always projected. Now consider what BHP and Rio are up to. Not long ago, Rio discussed how they're positioning their tonnes in China. They've managed to reach the small mills, and that's great. You can access that market. We've already been doing that for a year, and that position keeps expanding. The key distinction between us and the others, though, is that we aren't able to supply sufficient high-grade material to blend with their low-grade material.
William O'Keeffe
executiveWhen you consider BHP and Rio moving forward, and Fortescue as well, you have to conclude that aside from Fortescue, no CapEx is being allocated toward further expansion in the iron ore sector—and even more crucially, in the high grade segment. So if you begin putting dollars into the ground right now merely searching for the material or attempting to buy it, finding it will take you a couple of years, and after that another 3 years to bring it into development. That's precisely why I'm so bullish. Demand isn't going to disappear, yet supply faces considerable strain. I view that as very good for shareholders. It's a topic we'll be exploring over the next couple of days in discussions in Vancouver with our Board, since they want to determine whether we're confident enough and whether we grasp the market—something David can address regarding a recent trip they've taken. And today, I'd have to tell you that upon arriving back from Australia following the bushfires, it was pleasing to see tonnes effectively sold for this year. Typically, we kick off the year with a great many options.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd if everybody exercised their options, I believe we'll end up purchasing tonnes from some source. So we're quite optimistic about our material, and I hold a strong belief—as does management—about where high-grade material is headed. That positions us really well for the coming few years. So, as I've told David repeatedly, he needs to keep his costs in check. He's fully aware of that. Costs drifted somewhat during the prior quarter. We missed a couple of shipments. A portion of those stem directly from us pushing harder for tonnes. Certain ones are beyond our control—at the port, for instance, where we had to handle other problems caused by customers who aren't properly set up, which created delays for us and cost us some shipments. But I'll have David walk you through all of that, and afterward we can sit down and have a chat. David?
David Cataford
executiveThank you, Michael, for that introduction. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the call we scheduled to go over the third quarter results for the 2020 fiscal year. As of today, we are reporting our sixth quarter of commercial production. We remain proud of what we have achieved and of the meaningful impact we are creating in the region after the successful recommissioning of Bloom Lake. Our product is still in high demand, and our flagship asset keeps delivering in line with its nameplate capacity. We are now well positioned to look at our short-term growth initiatives, which we announced last June together with our Phase 2 feasibility study. We stay focused on health and safety at all times, not only because it protects the well-being of everyone at site, but also because protecting our most valuable asset, our employees, makes good business sense. On the whole, our company's health and safety statistics remain in line with industry standards. Consistent with our company's growth initiatives, during our third quarter we put new training programs in place and optimized our emergency response protocols. Recently, our team finished emergency training programs and on-site simulations for confined space rescue as well as first aid brigade response. We believe that continuous training of this kind improves our response time and our efficiencies should future emergencies arise.
David Cataford
executiveNow, on the environmental side. We didn't have any significant environmental problems during the quarter. As we've said before, we finished the $30 million accelerated dam raising program, and it came in on schedule and within budget. That program strengthens our tailings management infrastructure, which was already safe, and it gives our operations more flexibility as we look toward the proposed expansion at Bloom Lake. Just to remind you, this program didn't change the total budget for dam-related work — it only shifted the timing. Separately, during the quarter we began a detailed review of energy consumption at the site. That thorough analysis ought to wrap up by summer, and it will give us visibility into possible work programs aimed at cutting our carbon footprint further. We're also encouraged by recent trials with a new blasting compound, which keeps showing promising results when it comes to lowering nitrogen oxide gas emissions. As Michael mentioned, today's commodity prices remain a strong backdrop for our business. During the reporting period, iron ore prices stayed volatile — P62 and P65 both fell below USD 80 and USD 90, respectively, in October. We believe that brief correction happened alongside the intense U.S.-China trade war negotiations and China's 70th anniversary celebration, which prompted a number of steelmakers to cut capacity.
David Cataford
executiveAfter that, iron ore prices bounced back, and the Platts P65 index — the main benchmark for what we sell — is currently sitting at roughly USD 100 per tonne. Turning to the premium on our product during the quarter, the gap between the high-grade P65 index and the P62 index narrowed briefly at the start of the period. In our view, three key events disrupted the normal flow of trade with customers and drove that: first, Brazilian iron ore operations restarting production; second, a weakening steel sector in Europe that pushed some inventory into the Chinese market; third, Chinese steel mills cutting output during the October celebration of the 70th anniversary. Since those events, we have witnessed a wave of steel price rises around the world, which has helped steelmaker profitability bounce back. Stronger profitability, combined with a bigger environmental push globally, drives more demand for high-grade iron ore. Indeed, the premium of the P65 index over the P62 index has climbed sharply in recent weeks and now sits at 17%. Ahead of the holidays, our senior management finished a trip across the Middle East, India and Japan, meeting with existing and prospective customers. That trip reinforced our view of the structural shift taking place worldwide in steelmaking, which is embracing tougher emission standards and placing more emphasis on increasingly complex steel manufacturing.
David Cataford
executiveWe remain of the view as well that the tailings dam failure in Brazil during 2019 is going to have a structural effect, constraining fresh supply of high-grade material for years ahead. As a lot of you are aware, the majority of our freight is priced off the C3 index. Notwithstanding considerable chatter, the implementation of IMO 2020, aimed at cutting emissions from bulk carrier vessels, has not yet had an abnormal effect on freight rates. We keep monitoring the low-sulfur fuel market, which has the potential to affect freight rates. We are additionally assessing new shipping approaches that might assist in lowering our total freight costs. As we discussed on the previous call, we recently brought berth 30 at Pointe-Noire back into service, which gives access to baby capes and Panamax vessels and may let us work with customers on shorter travel routes. Moving on to operations. Bloom Lake turned out 1.83 million tonnes of high-grade iron ore concentrate during the quarter. This period contained a planned semiannual maintenance shutdown, which was finished as scheduled in 5 days. Beyond that planned shutdown, 2 minor events affected our operations. Those events dampened the beneficial effects of the blitz work program carried out earlier this year, which was intended to boost equipment availability.
David Cataford
executiveWe had 3 days of extra downtime after a conveyor belt broke near the AG mill. Normally, that kind of problem would have caused only limited downtime. But we faced further delays because the needed spare part wasn't available. We also had 2 days of unscheduled downtime caused by premature wear on the discharge grates. That premature wear came from the higher throughput we achieved in the first 6 months of the fiscal year. We're currently working on a better discharge grate design, aiming to keep this from happening again. Together, these events affected production by roughly 100,000 tonnes in the quarter. On mining rate, 8.3 million tonnes of material was mined in the quarter, a modest decrease from the prior period because of a temporary drop in in-pit crusher availability. That was partly offset by our standby crusher being available, which kept plant feed stable. Even with these events, our operations delivered a production rate that still compares favorably with Bloom Lake's expected nameplate capacity. In addition, our product was not affected by these factors, and we continue to meet the required specifications and have not yet been assessed any penalties for contaminants.
David Cataford
executiveLike we mentioned, a shaft adjacent to the SAG mill that recirculates coarse material had problems during November. While we aim to hold spare inventory for every piece of critical equipment, the particular part needed was inadequately recorded in our backlog. That lack of availability for this critical equipment impacted the plant for 3 days during the period. To avoid further delays, we relied on local relationships to get a piece of equipment engineered instead of waiting for an original part to be delivered. This is one more illustration of how dedicated our staff is to optimizing operations and a genuine showcase of ingenuity, which is rooted in our corporate culture. To keep this from happening again, we started a thorough review of the backlog covering all of the plant's critical spare equipment, and that review is expected to finish in February. Considering the successful action plans we put in place last year after the chute blockage issues, we are confident that this ongoing analysis of critical spare parts will further enhance the stability of our operations. Turning to our ore recovery rate, we reported a quarterly rate of 81.7%. Shutdowns typically affect our recovery rate, since we usually need some time to return to target levels.
David Cataford
executiveWith the grates and liners swapped out as we discussed, we spent a longer stretch seeing lower recovery rates before they came back up to normal target levels. After those November shutdowns, our December recovery rate came in at 84.2% on average, almost equal to our all-time best monthly figure of 84.6%. We're still confident we can hit the 83% recovery target that our feasibility study originally set when Bloom Lake was recommissioned. We keep reviewing our processes so we can further enhance the recovery circuit without hurting product quality. Apart from minor setbacks that we view as nonrecurring, our operations remain on track with Bloom Lake's nameplate capacity. These results mean strong profitability for the company. During the quarter, we posted sales of $171 million, EBITDA of almost $58 million and net profit above $30 million. That works out to earnings per share of $0.07 for the quarter. Even more striking are the fiscal year-to-date figures, with sales above $609 million and adjusted net profits of $154 million. Total cash cost for the period was $54.2 per tonne. That number reflected the downtime mentioned earlier, where the unplanned events — which we consider nonrecurring — added roughly $2 per tonne in extra costs.
David Cataford
executiveOn top of that, rising expenses at our port facilities have hurt our operating costs as well. Nonrecurring expenditures also weighed on our all-in sustaining costs, and those included the accelerated tailings work program we disclosed earlier. As I noted, that extra program gets our company ready for proposed expansion projects, and it doesn't alter the total tailings spend for the Bloom Lake — it only shifts the timing. That program is now finished for the fiscal year, and with it complete, we expect the sustaining capital devoted to tailings management to come down over the next few years. Another point worth noting: additional stripping activities carried out during the period also pushed our reported costs higher. For the life of mine, our Phase 1 plan assumed a strip ratio of 0.48. The 0.7 strip ratio we have now reflects preparations for Bloom Lake's proposed expansion. Even though we benefit from state-of-the-art port facilities with the SFPPN, port-related costs over the last year have climbed past the indexation rate. While the operating time cycle at the port has improved, we incurred an incremental cost of roughly $2 per tonne versus last year. The Board of SFPPN, where our company holds a representative seat, chose to strengthen leadership with the goal of revamping operational processes.
David Cataford
executiveWe’ve found a new CEO who brings extensive experience running railroad and port facilities. We’re confident this appointment will assist in overhauling operational processes, and we believe it can produce cost savings moving forward. Turning to this period specifically, our sea freight rate was impacted by higher demurrage costs stemming from downtime at SFPPN’s loading facilities. Because of these inefficient operations, a vessel that had been set to depart before the quarter ended instead left on January 2, 2020, which contributed to weaker revenues in the quarter. Those lower revenues also have a direct effect on our cost metrics, which are calculated from the volumes we sell each quarter. That said, we look forward to collaborating with SFPPN’s new management to enhance operations and, by doing so, lower our related costs in the near future. During the period, our gross realized price was USD 106.2 per tonne. Although the P65 index’s average premium over the P62 index for the quarter was 11%, our realized premium over the P62 index came in at nearly 20% for the period. This higher premium relative to the indices reflects strong December sales as P65 index prices had recovered. On freight costs, we generally pay a premium of 20% to 25% to the C3 index, which averaged USD 20.5 per tonne in the quarter.
David Cataford
executiveDuring this period, our average freight costs came in at USD 30.7 per tonne, which is somewhat elevated, and there are 2 reasons for that: first, the additional port-related fees we discussed earlier; second, 2 low-tonnage vessels were sent to India to prospective customers. We're aiming to optimize our sales channels and engage with the best long-term customers as we consider the proposed Phase 2 expansion project at Bloom Lake. We don't expect to ship low-tonnage vessels on a recurring basis in order to secure additional customers. As we entered the period, iron ore prices saw a correction followed by a rapid recovery. Since we began the quarter with 1 million tonnes of material subject to provisional prices, this early correction in the period created a negative adjustment, with some material being priced at the lower levels. Net of the provisional price adjustments of USD 8.1 per tonne freight and currency conversion, our net realized price was $89 per tonne. Our business continues to deliver strong operating margins. In the quarter, our cash operating margin was 30.1%, and our EBITDA margin was 34%. It's important to note that provisional pricing directly affects this reported operating margin. Excluding the impact of provisional pricing, our cash operating margin would have been 36%, which is similar to prior periods.
David Cataford
executiveEven with the extra nonrecurring expenses incurred this period that we mentioned earlier, along with swings in iron ore pricing, our operations keep showing they can produce solid operating margins. The Q3 results make clear that our balance sheet is still strong. Cash and long-term debt at period end were $187.6 million and $237.7 million, respectively. Cash fell by $23.5 million relative to the prior period. Working capital, though, rose by $24.9 million, and $50.9 million in total went into Bloom Lake as part of our Phase 2 expansion project. On top of that, because our financial position is strong, we chose to prepay $14.3 million of city tax to the City of Fermont. That prepayment eases our debt burden, since it carried a 12% interest rate. The face value of our long-term debt likewise dropped by $1.4 million during the period. Even with growth spending and the city tax prepayment, our balance sheet was $2.9 million stronger once the working capital increase is taken into account. All told, we see our balance sheet as well positioned to handle shifting market conditions, giving Champion the flexibility it requires as it weighs further investments in its proposed growth initiatives.
David Cataford
executiveEarlier this month, we announced plans to move our company's domicile from Australia to Canada. A lot of you know our history: our founder, an Australian-based company called Mamba Minerals Limited, acquired Champion Iron Mines Limited back in 2014, and the merged entity took the name Champion Iron Limited. After that, through its subsidiary Québec Iron Ore, Champion Iron Limited picked up the Bloom Lake assets in April 2016. With your backing, we've built an international company that keeps growing. This re-domiciliation will produce 3 primary outcomes: first, our company's domicile will line up with where our flagship asset sits, a place where the government support we've received has been unmatched; second, simplifying our corporate structure could deliver potential cost savings; third, our company's stock will become accessible to a broader universe of equity indices and potentially reach more investors around the world. It's important to note that the re-domiciliation won't affect our active listings on the ASX and the TSX. We invite you to read the press release issued on January 6, which is available on our website, where we gave further details about this plan. Our goal is to complete this scheme of arrangement by the start of our new fiscal year, which begins April 1, 2020.
David Cataford
executiveTurning to the Phase 2 expansion project and its $68 million budget, which received approval last June. During the past quarter we spent $28.6 million, and as of December 31, 2019, total spending stood at $47.2 million. Construction work so far is moving forward within budget, and a number of key milestones have already been achieved. In the quarter, we moved several work programs ahead, including the civil work tied to the silo near the train loading area; the new reclaimer, which is designed to enhance logistics at the train loading area; we commissioned the heating system within the plant; spirals have been manufactured and are ready to ship; and detailed engineering is continuing to advance on schedule. We keep watching market conditions as we actively assess funding alternatives to finish the project. We plan to update the market on our non-dilutive financing plan by the middle of this current calendar year. The progress of our current work program and a potential financing solution would be intended to preserve the previously disclosed time line, with operations starting in the second half of calendar 2021. The work completed to date has substantially derisked the timing of delivering the project, since most of it involved civil and concrete work, which can bring construction challenges and delays given the weather conditions in the Fermont area.
David Cataford
executiveAs of today, we've accumulated more than 158,000 hours on Phase 2. Our present work program keeps us on the schedule to deliver the project in 21 months, as the feasibility study identified. Beyond that, a number of items in this work program enhance our existing operations. For instance, we finished installing a new reclaimer, which should improve logistics at our train loading facility. Using the remaining funds from the original $68 million program that was previously budgeted and approved, we intend to push forward detailed engineering, carry on with electrical work in the plant, place orders for long lead items, and address critical path items. To close, on behalf of our management team, I'd like to echo the comment Michael made earlier. I'm proud to report, once again, strong quarterly results from our young company. Our staff's capacity to adapt and respond to operational challenges and conditions keeps showing that our strong corporate culture spreads throughout the entire organization. We've built strong and sustainable relationships with partners, both locally and internationally. I'm grateful to all our partners who have shared our vision since we acquired Bloom Lake, and I'm also excited about building mutually beneficial relationships with new partners who seek to take part in our growth initiatives.
David Cataford
executiveGiven that base, we're well placed to keep producing returns for shareholders as we concentrate on growing the business and seizing the opportunities ahead. Operator, with that said, let's open the lines now for the Q&A.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question comes from Scott Schier at Clarksons.
Scott Schier
analystCongrats on a strong quarter. If I could begin with Phase 2. Since you've now used roughly two-thirds of the originally approved budget, could you give us any further detail on what your funding priorities are for the rest of the expansion, and what time line you're expecting for an announcement about that?
David Cataford
executiveYes. As we said, we're still pushing forward on the whole funding strategy and we remain engaged with the various partners on the different pieces that need to be delivered. Given that we've placed orders for all the long lead items and completed the bulk of the construction work that was needed over the summer period, we'll keep spending on the detailed engineering. We're also glad to report that none of the detailed engineering work completed so far has turned up any surprises or new elements. So we're exactly on track with the initial budget and continuing to track well against it. So we'll return to the market in the first quarter -- in the first half, sorry, of this year regarding the next steps for Phase 2. And we're still in line with the initial timetable to deliver that project in 2021.
Scott Schier
analystAlright, that’s quite useful. Now, turning to a market comment: we’ve noticed China has been constructing numerous new pelletizing plants along its coast. Could you share a bit more market detail regarding the demand you’re observing from China for your high-grade concentrates compared with pellets, and also your expectations on that going forward?
David Cataford
executiveThere are 2 distinct components here. And one area we're actively focused on is that Bloom Lake gives us an edge: we're able not just to turn out high-grade blast furnace material, but also to make high-grade DR-type material. So we're examining various approaches so we can supply both potential markets, and in that way serve any pellet plant anywhere in the world. As you rightly pointed out, a fair number of pellet plants are under construction in China. That makes it very important for us to manufacture a high-grade pellet feed capable of reaching this newer market in China, as well as a well-established market in other places such as India, Europe, or the Middle East.
Operator
operatorGordon Lawson of Paradigm has the next question.
Gordon Lawson
analystI’ve got a simple question for you. Could you discuss how Vale’s soft shipping volumes so far in 2020 have influenced freight rates and price expectations for the current quarter? And do you anticipate that shipping rates will stay within the $25 to $30 range across the next few quarters?
David Cataford
executiveA few factors hit our shipping in an unusual way. One was routing those smaller Panamax vessels to India, and another involved interactions at the port, which have since been resolved. So that had a negative effect on our shipping cost for the quarter. Normally, we come in around 20% to 25% above the C3 index. And as you correctly pointed out, the C3 index has come down a lot. Now that we're back on track toward that 20%, 25%, well, if the C3 index holds where it is, our shipping cost will be lower in the months ahead, yes.
William O'Keeffe
executiveWith Vale shipping reduced volumes, that ought to be...
David Cataford
executiveThat's right.
William O'Keeffe
executiveTo respond to the question about Vale: right now Vale is having a hard time with its tonnages, and it looks like that will persist. So clearly that is going to create pressure on shippers and bring rates down too. And what I think matters most, which we laid out, is that we must ensure things are in order on our own side at the port, and together with the government we are taking increasing control of that so that we can cut that demurrage.
Operator
operatorCraig Hutchison with TD has the next question.
Craig Hutchison
analystI've got a question about sustaining costs for Phase 1. Now that you've brought down the costs tied to the tailings dam, what should we be modeling over the coming few quarters for sustaining costs related specifically to Phase 1?
David Cataford
executiveYes. We don’t really provide formal guidance, but if you look at what we spent over the past 2 years on the dikes, as we said, the first 2 years needed somewhat more sustaining work. We also sped up the dam raise project. That will bring down our sustaining CapEx at the tailings area quite a bit. We keep investing in our mining fleet. So some sustaining capital is needed to keep all of the mining equipment maintained and to support the higher throughput at the plant. But aside from those 2 elements, very little sustaining capital is needed, because pretty much everything else in the plant and the equipment is new.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd I think there's another point, Craig: when you consider our history, we've been operating for under 2 years. So things like the shaft, purely on our direct costs, reflect a learning curve, but we're getting on top of all of that through the recoveries. We're becoming more consistent, and we can keep improving that consistency. But when you're stopping and starting plants the way we did, that clearly has an impact on recoveries. So that has to be taken into account too. So look, with under 2 years of operating, I think we're in a great position, and it sets us up very well for Phase 2, because we've had really — you could say Phase 1 has served as a pilot plant for the last 18 months to 2 years. And that lets us fully understand what we need to do when it comes to the construction and the implementation of Phase 2, and it also gives us great diversification on our product, what we're able to do. And David was talking about DR-grade pellet material. All of those things we've been able to work on over the last couple of years while operating a plant and climbing that learning curve.
William O'Keeffe
executiveThat's the reason I made that point right at the beginning. To me, 2020 looks like an exciting year, and the coming 5 years look exciting for us too, since the people have gained the experience. We've positioned ourselves quite well to be able to capture the market. And I believe the market is going to be there for the high-grade as long as we can maintain these operating costs. And I'm confident the guys can get better.
Operator
operatorBrock Salier with Sprott has the next question.
Brock Salier
analystThis is really just a broad question about how much risk you're comfortable taking on with Phase 2. My understanding is that you said you'd be discussing with the Board what you know about the costs and the market supplies. Given the risk appetite for black swan events — and realistically, hopefully the black swan event happening in China right now won't be too bad — would you be willing to take on additional debt beyond CAD 150 million?
William O'Keeffe
executiveSpeaking for myself and the management team, that's where we stand. Over the next 2 days or so, we'll be putting the Board to the test to find out whether they see things the same way. Still, our aim will be to persuade them that this is the correct course of action.
David Cataford
executiveAnd when we run our stress test, Brock, we set the iron ore price very low so we’re confident we can make it through any type of cycle. We observed the worst sort of correction having an annual price of roughly USD 56 per tonne. You might have a view on that. Is it possible for it to go that low? I mean, most of the players have seen higher costs since then. So provided the price remains above the $60 mark, we can see that we’re in a healthy position even if we take on somewhat more debt for the Phase 2 project.
Brock Salier
analystGot it. On funding alternatives outside of equity, is debt the only avenue you're considering, or are other routes on the table too? I believe joint ventures or asset sell-downs came up at some point earlier. My guess is that right after consolidation, you'd likely prefer not to go down that road again.
William O'Keeffe
executiveNo. And then there's the value people would assign us right now. So they'd need to give us — our market cap is around $1 billion today. We think it's — and so the analysts think it's $2 billion. So if someone is ready to say there's a value of $2 billion, well, we'd consider selling a portion of Bloom Lake, but that will only be known if people are ready to step up. So debt seems to be our route at the moment.
Operator
operatorStefan Ioannou from Cormark has the next question.
Stefan Ioannou
analystA lot of what I wanted to ask has already been covered regarding Phase 2. Perhaps just to shift gears a bit — clearly, not much was spent on exploration during the quarter that just passed. Is the thinking essentially to concentrate on Phase 2, get it operational, and only after that begin to scan outward and pursue some of the regional opportunity surrounding Bloom Lake?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks for asking. We already hold more than 5 billion tonnes of high-grade resources, and those are all located near Bloom Lake. We are clearly reviewing other possibilities, but our primary focus at present is really on delivering Phase 2. And we do have quite a lot of growth opportunities within the company right now without spending significant cost on exploration. And so much sunk cost has gone into those resources to develop, to define, and to do the different mine plans, which is why you see a little bit less investing right now.
Stefan Ioannou
analystUnderstood. Understood.
William O'Keeffe
executiveYes. Stefan, if I could, let me just build on that point a little. It's interesting, as I'm sitting here and that question comes up. I'm hearing David discuss it. The reality is, we had every one of the Champion assets at Fire Lake, and those were already partly within the portfolio. We've now got a feasibility study for Phase 2, and it covers, from the resources we already have, another 20 years of operations turning out 15 million to 16 million tonnes of product. And beyond that, we picked up the Quinto assets out of -- they were a portfolio of Cliffs and, before that, Consolidated Thompson, and on Cliffs' books they're carried at $400 million. There's a reason for that, because that's what they paid for it. And so much work has been put into this thing to define the resources. So here's what we'll do: we have the luxury, over the next 20 years, of deciding which deposit we move to next. And during that stretch, we'll probably ask whether there's a Phase 3 we can carry on with. But we have the luxury of holding those massive resources that a huge amount of work has been finished on.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd when you really consider it, Stefan, where else on earth can you find that kind of established supply of high-grade material? So it's a good thing we secured it when we did.
Operator
operatorJacques Wortman from Laurentian Bank has our next question.
Jacques Wortman
analystOnly two brief items. Could you walk me through the math so I can grasp the deltas in C1 cash costs? Did I hear correctly that unscheduled downtime and the port issues each accounted for roughly $2 to $3 per tonne? Second, at what point in the quarter did the unscheduled downtime occur? Earlier on, or is that my assumption? I believed I heard September, though that would, of course, have fallen in fiscal Q2. And second, has management thought about giving production and operational updates ahead of the financial results? That's all from me.
David Cataford
executiveAppreciate the question, Jacques. So, addressing your first question, you're right about those cost differentials. The unplanned schedules occurred during October and early November, meaning they fall entirely within this quarter. That explains why December turned out to be such a strong month for us. We were able to resolve everything, achieving a very high recovery and a very high production rate, and we're tracking well. Our numbers get reported fairly quickly, within roughly 30 days. So at this point we don't see any need to report production figures ahead of time. We'll keep going, at least through this year, reporting in the same manner you've seen so far.
Operator
operatorWe'll take our next question from Lucas Pipes at B. Riley FBR.
Lucas Pipes
analystA good number of my Phase 2 questions have already been raised and addressed. Still, even with the really robust iron ore price—setting aside the past couple of weeks—the market seems fairly worried about additional supply entering the market, and I'd like to hear your view on how supply will respond in today's conditions, naturally also taking into account that you're bringing Phase 2 online.
William O'Keeffe
executiveTo begin with, I said that when you look at BHP, Rio, and Vale, no significant investment in fresh capacity is on the way. So I fail to see the source of any new supply. Growth is going to remain exactly as it is. The major worry, in my view, for steel mills is where they get high-grade iron ore. Now, the only party I've recently seen discussing this is Fortescue, which is talking about a high-grade hematite, and that's likely 3 years off. After that, we saw a Chinese consortium looking in India -- Guinea, sorry. They've just laid out $15 billion to acquire the assets, but they're likely 10 years away from producing anything. So I cannot see any new supply arriving, and I see supply facing difficulties down the road. That places us in a fairly strong position given the increased tonnage we'll be delivering. And incidentally, even if it's twice what we are today, 7.5 million tonnes, it's truly a flea on a dog. It's such a tiny amount relative to the global supply/demand picture, yet it matters a lot for us. I'm not sure whether I've addressed your question, but I don't see where that new supply is coming from.
David Cataford
executiveLooking ahead, we anticipate some disruption. As we said, India is reauctioning every one of its mining leases. During the prior quarter, you saw us send 2 vessels to prospective buyers in that country. We traveled extensively across the entire Indian market, and each steel producer and pellet producer we talked with confirmed they were worried about interruptions on the mining side over the next few years. A major benefit for a project such as Bloom Lake is that India mostly consumes high-grade iron ore. That makes us well positioned to respond to those disruptions in the years ahead.
Operator
operatorThanks. At this point we don't have any more questions. You're free to go ahead.
David Cataford
executiveThanks to all of you for being with us on today's call and for taking part at such an exciting moment for us as we share the highlights of the third quarter and look forward to talking with you in the next 3 months.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings today’s conference call to a close, everyone. We appreciate your participation, and please go ahead and disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Champion Iron Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Champion Iron Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Champion Iron Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.