Champion Iron Limited (CIA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 20, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning, everyone. I'm Joanna, and I'll be handling the conference operator duties for you today. Right now, I'd like to extend a welcome to all of you on behalf of Champion Iron Limited as we begin the Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2019 Conference Call. <<operator_script>> Mr. Michael Marcotte, the floor is yours to start your conference.
Michael Marcotte
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning to all of you, and for those calling in from Australia, good evening. I want to express my appreciation to everyone for being with us today as we go over the fourth quarter and full year results for the fiscal year that ended March 31, 2020. I'd like to point those on the call toward a presentation that management will be referencing, and it's available on our website at www.championiron.com in the Events and Presentations section. I should also remind listeners that certain matters we'll cover during this call may include forward-looking statements, and I'd point you to the disclaimer at the start of the presentation, which we'll be using today. For further details regarding forward-looking statements, risks and assumptions, please refer to our most recent MD&A, which can be found on our website. Please be aware that every dollar figure mentioned in this presentation is in Canadian dollars, unless otherwise noted. With me today from the Champion management team are David Cataford, our Chief Executive Officer; Michael O’Keeffe, our Executive Chairman; and Natacha Garoute, our Chief Financial Officer. Having said that, I'll hand the call over to our Executive Chairman, Michael O’Keeffe, who will be followed by our CEO, David Cataford.
Michael Marcotte
executiveOnce management has finished their remarks, we'll pause for a question-and-answer session at the close. Michael?
William O'Keeffe
executiveThanks, Michael, and welcome — hello, everyone, and welcome to the call. Right now I'm speaking to you from Australia, which is quite different from where all my colleagues are in North America, and particularly in Québec, given the pandemic that has swept across the world. It's really remarkable to witness how our management team has managed to keep things running and navigate through all of this. To give you one illustration of where I am: I believe we've had no cases over the past 2 weeks, and the total for this area is roughly 10. So the situation here is quite different. I've been unable to get back to Québec, though I'm in touch with David and his team every day. But look, when you consider how young our company is and how young the management is — and David became CEO just 12 months ago — it's been a truly remarkable accomplishment. I'm extremely proud of him and the team that we're here today, still operating. We've managed a process of isolating people in an area where the case numbers have been fluctuating. And we established standards that the rest of the mining community now follows, and that the government is using.
William O'Keeffe
executiveWhat I'm saying is that for a team able to function not just in routine operations but under a stressful circumstance or a social problem of this kind, that is simply outstanding. So I want to state that publicly and on the record. But when you consider where we started and where we stand now — the first year, we considered it a very good operating year; the second year, our first full year of operation — well, I'll let David walk you through all the figures. Yet here we are with $300 million in cash after a stretch in which we've managed to — we began holding a percentage of this asset. Today we hold 100% after repaying the government. We repaid what we owed Glencore. We repaid the convertible notes. We own the railcars. The list goes on and on. Even so, we still have $300 million of cash. So look, it has come from a mix of taking a risk at a moment when nobody had faith in iron ore. And to see it now, with our price for the 65 material above $110 a tonne, you don't need to dream or anything of that sort.
William O'Keeffe
executiveWe don't take pleasure in others' troubles, but Brazil is having a hard time. Even before this, they were struggling, not just with social problems but with all the operational and physical difficulties they had. That has pushed the price up. And I would say that if the pandemic had not come along and Europe and Japan were running normally, you would be seeing an enormous, enormous shortage of supply in high-grade material. That's something we're constantly forecasting. So obviously the market has helped us a great deal. But being able to operate and produce the way we have — and David can walk you through those figures — is phenomenal for a young team. Even for an experienced team that has run the bigger companies, it's a huge vote of confidence. So I won't talk too long. But if you look at the market right now, the price is — what has happened with shipping, what has happened with the exchange rate, it gives us a wonderful chance to keep generating cash. And I have to admit we weren't sitting around the other week thinking about where we stood. I thought this doesn't hurt us at all — not having to decide to go borrow money for Phase 2, because we're building up cash so quickly.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd given how we're positioned with the market terms, that simply places us in an increasingly strong position as we move forward. So all is looking good for us. I don't get too carried away — something could happen tomorrow; everyone knows mining, everyone knows we're on quite a knife edge with the social situation. So we count our lucky stars and thank God that we're in a fortunate position, that we're healthy and we are operating. With that note, I'll hand over to David, and I'm happy to answer any questions in the Q&A session that follows.
David Cataford
executiveThank you, Michael, for that introduction. So today we're reporting the results of our fourth quarter in fiscal 2020, and that also marks the completion of our first full year of commercial production. I'm proud to share the company's accomplishments, since we delivered an all-time annual production record at Bloom Lake. From the moment we made the decision to recommission Bloom Lake, our employees have shown, time and again, that they can improve operations, and that is what allowed us to deliver such robust results. Our operational capabilities and strong balance sheet put the company in a position for growth and strengthen our ability to navigate current economic uncertainties. The considerable challenges posed by the recent COVID-19 pandemic have dramatically changed the dynamic for many industries, including mining. We are thankful to our workers, partners and communities, who rapidly adapted to new measures aimed at mitigating the risks related to COVID-19. Since the pandemic began, we have put in place measures and protocols that meet or exceed government issued guidelines for the mining industry, which is currently recognized as a priority service in the province of Québec. Even though the Québec government stated that the mining industry could resume normal operations as of April 15, our focus remains on the health and safety of all of our stakeholders.
David Cataford
executiveLike we said on April 23, we've put a plan in place to bring operations back up gradually, so that we can lower the risks for both our employees and the communities around us. As of today, there are no known COVID-19 cases among our workforce, and we're still committed to adjusting our measures and how we operate as things develop. Even with a stronger focus on tackling the COVID-19 pandemic, our dedication to keeping a high standard for worksite safety measures hasn't weakened. During the first -- fourth quarter, we had no serious injuries reported. Although Québec Iron Ore's overall statistics for the year are getting close to the Canadian open pit mining benchmarks, we're still aware of the work needed to make our workplace safer. We're counting on our people to draw on our strong health and safety culture, which is well anchored in our company, to keep improving our work environment and its safety statistics. Because activity slowed down due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we used the chance to roll out new virtual training programs for many of our workers. We intend to engage our workers further in continuous training so they can adapt to their changing work environment in response to the pandemic. Moving on to the environment. There were no major environmental issues during the period.
David Cataford
executiveWe still hold the view that our firm must take part in the shift to a green economy and in combating climate change. To that end, we recently finished a thorough review of how much energy we use, and it plainly shows the gains from the various structural adjustments our company has made since Bloom Lake was recommissioned in 2018. Beyond achieving a 40% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions thanks to the major investments completed so far, roughly 65% of the energy we consume today comes from renewable sources. Given these substantial emission cuts as of 2019, our operations are no longer deemed a significant emitter under Québec's cap-and-trade regulations. Accordingly, our company has been awarded carbon credits for more than 19,000 tonnes of greenhouse gases, and those credits can be sold at auction through the Western Climate Initiatives. These achievements likewise put our company in a favorable position with customers seeking to cut emissions throughout their own supply chains. During the period, we also enhanced our already rigorous waste management process, producing a meaningful decrease in residual waste compared with the prior year. Our team additionally took part in a new initiative with neighboring communities to recover and distribute wood harvested by our operations. As Michael discussed, iron ore prices remain resilient notwithstanding difficult global economic conditions.
David Cataford
executiveStrong iron ore pricing, combined with falling freight expenses and a weaker Canadian dollar, gives our company a favorable operating backdrop. As with a number of industries, steel demand will probably take a hit from the COVID-19 pandemic. Even so, iron ore prices have held steady, since many mining operations around the world were also disrupted by the pandemic, which brought the supply and demand picture back into balance. Brazil, the largest global producer of high-grade iron ore, saw a major production hit from an unusual rainy season during the quarter. That rainy season, on top of continuing permitting problems in the country, has constrained their capacity to supply high-grade iron. As a result, the premium for the high-grade P65 iron ore index over the traditional P62 iron ore index has widened substantially of late. Relative to the prior quarter, the average premium for the P65 index over the P62 index grew from 10.8% to 16.3%. As of today, the P65 index premium stands at 17.4%. China accounts for roughly 70% of the world's seaborne iron ore supply. Thanks to economic stimulus, the Chinese economy looks to be recovering quickly. Because of this, demand for our product remains strong, with our volumes committed for the foreseeable future.
David Cataford
executiveWe likewise gain from a slowdown in worldwide economic activity, and that has had a substantial impact on fuel prices as well as freight costs. Relative to the prior period, the C3 index — the benchmark we use for pricing our freight — has fallen by more than 30%, and it now looks out of line with its historical average versus iron ore prices. Since we usually lock in freight rates a few weeks before a vessel reaches our port at Pointe-Noire, we ought to gain this quarter from the presently depressed freight rates. It is worth pointing out that the Canadian currency is depreciating quickly too, which provides an additional tailwind for the pricing of our product. While we keep working on a number of innovations aimed at better operational reliability and continue testing a new product offering, Blue Lake stayed on a favorable track toward its nameplate capacity during the period. Ore mined during the period rose by more than 10% versus the prior quarter. That gain stems chiefly from greater equipment availability after the investments we made in the mining equipment rebuild program across the last few quarters. In the quarter, we carried out a planned 3-day shutdown in order to install new inner discharge grates, which seem capable of supporting a higher throughput.
David Cataford
executiveSo because of these changes, plant performance was strong, with ore milled rising over 5% quarter over quarter. In the period, ore recovery came in at 82.3% on average, and it got a boost from the operational innovations we put in place during the first half of the fiscal year. Given that a low silica commercial production test during the quarter weighed on recovery, every recovery is tracking as expected and is already beating a number of peers in our industry. While we're constantly working to get better results, our operations showed solid stability overall, which speaks to the billions of dollars that have been invested at Bloom Lake over the years. I'm also very proud to share the results of a commercial production test that was completed last quarter. At the request of a key customer, our team made a cargo of 68% iron ore with combined silica and alumina under 2.6%. That product is thought to be eligible for DR pellet feed material, which steelmakers using electric arc furnaces can ultimately use. Demand for our existing product spec is high, and it already helps cut emissions in the steel industry, from the sintering process through to blast furnaces and basic oxygen furnaces. That said, the steel industry is thought to be at a turning point, where electric arc furnaces, which mainly use scrap material, are expected to take market share in the years ahead within emerging markets like China.
David Cataford
executiveBeyond scrap, electric arc furnaces also depend on DRI pellets to dilute contaminants that are embedded in scrap material. Demand for DR-quality concentrate is expected to rise, and on top of that, it is in limited supply around the world. Many pellet producers are vertically integrated, but several steelmakers depend on the global seaborne market to source supply, which is concentrated in a few areas — namely Brazil, Peru and Russia. We now understand that Bloom Lake is among the very few producers globally capable of adapting to a likely shift toward greater electric arc furnace usage in steelmaking over the coming years. As we seek to partner with industry players that have long-term vision, this high-quality product, together with our stable operating jurisdiction, could draw a new subset of customers to our company. With our operational momentum and favorable commodity prices, our company keeps delivering strong financial results. During the quarter, our company generated sales of $175.7 million, EBITDA of $61.1 million and net income of $18.4 million. Even more impressive are the results we set for the recently completed fiscal year, in which we delivered historical annual records for sales and EBITDA. In the period, the total free on board cash cost was $53.9 per tonne, with an all-in free on board sustaining cost of $59.8 per tonne, both showing an improvement from the prior quarter.
David Cataford
executiveThat gain came about even with the effect of the commercial production test we talked about earlier and the 3 days of planned downtime during which inner discharge grates were swapped out. Also, even though costs were greater than in the prior year, the changes recently announced at the SFPPN port operations have begun to deliver improvements. Sales and EBITDA came in above the prior quarter, but net income was a bit lower, which gave us earnings per share of $0.04. A number of items affected net income, among them an unrealized foreign exchange loss on long-term debt, reflecting the substantial depreciation of the Canadian dollar. There was also higher depreciation tied to the mining equipment rebuild program, plus a higher effective tax rate stemming from a nondeductible foreign exchange loss on the long-term debt. Turning to our fiscal 2020 costs, operations showed considerable flexibility in lifting cash flow from operations. Operating costs ran above the prior year because we rolled out an initiative designed to boost mine and plant reliability while pursuing the upside from strong iron ore prices. With that, Blue Lake output exceeded nameplate capacity and set a record production year. The extra volume from our initiatives raised sales by $41 million during the fiscal year.
David Cataford
executiveOperating expenses for the fiscal year were likewise affected by unplanned stoppages, a $30 million initiative to speed up tailings-related work, and an elevated strip ratio as we prepare for the company's Phase 2 expansion project. During the quarter, the high-grade P65 index averaged a 16% premium relative to the traditional P62 iron ore benchmark. Turning to sales, our gross realized price came in at USD 96.9, a 9% premium over the P62 index. That smaller premium to P62 mirrors the timing of our sales amid a fairly volatile pricing environment, along with the mark-to-market adjustment on 654,000 tonnes still in transit when the period closed. If you strip out the single-period effect of those adjustments, our gross realized price for the fiscal year, including mark-to-market adjustments, averaged USD 107.2, which aligns with the P65 high-grade index average of USD 106.4. As we covered earlier, the freight index on which our freight cost is based underwent a substantial correction during the period. Freight costs averaged USD 25.8 for the quarter, a level that is elevated relative to the freight index over that same period. The explanation lies in the premium we usually pay during winter months and the fact that we typically lock in our freight rates weeks before the vessels reach Pointe-Noire.
David Cataford
executiveIf freight rates stay where they are, we anticipate gaining from the weak market during this quarter. Our cost-control measures, along with the premium we command for a top-quality product, result in solid margins for the business. In the quarter, cash operating margin came to $33.3 per tonne, an improvement over the prior quarter, equivalent to an EBITDA margin of 35%. Turning to fiscal 2020 results, the company posted an EBITDA margin of 44%, versus 42% a year earlier, which confirms our company's capacity to produce healthy operating margins across time. Thanks to these strong results, our balance sheet is getting stronger. At period end, cash on hand and the face value of long-term debt were $298.7 million and $283.7 million, respectively. Counting working capital, our balance sheet strengthened by $26.3 million during the period. Although we are well placed to keep generating and building cash from operations, we think our solid balance sheet will set the company up for growth and let us take part in an economic recovery after the effects of COVID-19. Meanwhile, demand for our product stays high, and the strength of our balance sheet leaves our company in a powerful position.
David Cataford
executiveDuring the period, our cash position grew by more than $111 million. That cash increase comes from $42.2 million generated by operating cash flows, along with the favorable results of speeding up receivable collections. We also drew USD 20 million from our revolving line of credit during the period. To strengthen liquidity further, we brought in more than $15 million through option and warrant exercises, and we also gained from a foreign exchange impact. With our company's financial strength continuing to improve, we keep carefully evaluating our organic growth plans. Our Phase 2 expansion project is still moving forward, with $58 million spent so far out of the original $68 million budget. The work completed to date has substantially reduced the risk in the construction timetable, which was originally put at 21 months, and the project stays highly flexible when it comes to the ability to adjust its completion schedule. I'd like to use this opportunity to remind everyone about the economic conclusions of the feasibility study that we released last June. That feasibility study looked at the proposed Phase 2 expansion project and showed an IRR of 33% and an NPV of almost $2.4 billion. As of the close of the fourth quarter, we have now put to work roughly 10% of the capital needed to finish the Phase 2 expansion project as estimated by the feasibility study.
David Cataford
executiveIron ore prices right now are still holding up well versus what we originally assumed — they're sitting at roughly 36% above the level we used in the feasibility study. So because of that, we keep thinking that for the cash we have on hand, this expansion project is probably the strongest return on investment we can give our shareholders over time. Given that our priority is lowering the COVID-19 risk our workers face, we suspended discretionary capital expenditures, which we announced on March 24. So with that in mind, we're still collaborating closely with our partners and pushing detailed engineering forward so the project is ready to wrap up quickly once a final investment decision comes. Protecting the health and safety of our people is our commitment and our priority. To close, I want to thank our workers, our union and the communities, all of whom are pulling in the same direction to reduce the risks tied to COVID-19. Even though plenty of companies and industries are shutting down or declaring mass layoffs, everyone's collaboration keeps benefiting us as we keep moving ahead and building on the good impact we're having in the region. From the very first day we chose to recommission Bloom Lake, we understood that with the right team behind us, we could cut operating costs substantially and compete on a global scale.
David Cataford
executiveCarrying out those structural changes and keeping our costs in check demanded a committed, well-aligned team, and that has been the foundation of what we've achieved. That same commitment and alignment will help us get through the difficulties everyone is facing right now, and we're confident this base and this partnership will let our company thrive for many years ahead. With that, operator, I'd like to open up the lines for the Q&A session.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Hayden Bairstow with Macquarie.
Hayden Bairstow
analystI’ve got a couple of questions. First, on the expansion: what level would you need to feel comfortable with—is it really, as you put it, David, about limiting how many people are on site, rather than restarting, clearly being the iron ore price, given the other money you’re bringing in—funding isn’t going to be that big of an issue? I just want to hear your thoughts on that. And then, going back to the delisting from Aussie into Canada: is that going to come back onto the table at some point? I mean, where’s your head at on that?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks for that question, Hayden. So regarding the redomiciliation, we paused it because of the economic uncertainties we were facing, but it hasn't been completely put to rest. So it's something we've shelved now, and we will revisit in the future. So some of the economic benefits of the redomiciliation are still there. So it's something that we will revisit in the future. When we look at Phase 2, you're correct on the portion for the workers, but we also want to have a clearer view on how Europe recovers and how Japan recovers in the steel process. Right now, iron ore prices are supported by the supply issues in the world. We have not seen any sanctioned projects come to light in this current market. But -- so we still see Phase 2 as a very accretive project for us, but we still want to have a bit more certainty on the steel production in Europe and Japan. What we are doing is still advancing all the work that we can and structuring Phase 2 to be able to phase it a little bit more. But we'll come back to the market a little bit later this year to be able to explain where our heads at on the Phase 2 expansion.
Hayden Bairstow
analystAnd after you've made the decision to return to it, what kind of timeline would you be looking at to get it completed?
David Cataford
executiveSo at the moment, if we look at what we got done last summer — we completed all the concrete and civil work, the steel work, essentially everything that normally leads to cost delays and schedule delays, or cost overruns and schedule delays. Initially, we had a delivery time of roughly 21 months. Today we've come down to around 18 months. But again, we're taking another look at this right now, since the industry has shifted a bit. The bottlenecks around getting mining equipment delivered — we're seeing that those time lines have now come down in the present situation. So we're reassessing the time line. But as things stand right now, we're at about 18 months.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Gordon Lawson at Paradigm Capital.
Gordon Lawson
analystCongrats on the record year. Could you sum up the overall anticipated effect from COVID-19 as well as any maintenance activity on Q1 production levels?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Appreciate the question, Gordon. So when we turn to output figures for this quarter — well, authorization came to us around the middle of April allowing a move back toward normal operations. Even so, a few bottlenecks remain before we can fully ramp up. Ramping up is happening, but the practical logistics of running trains along the QNS&L line, or the Rio Tinto line, have been constrained because of the COVID-19 situation. On top of that, the number of workers we could bring onto the site during those first weeks also held production back, though we are developing a plan aimed at reaching full production over the coming weeks. If we — so production was the first question. What was the second one?
Gordon Lawson
analystWell, during that slow—
David Cataford
executiveApologies — yes, the cost.
Gordon Lawson
analystMy understanding is that some maintenance got shifted into the stretch when output was lower. Is that right?
David Cataford
executiveYes, that's right. At the moment we're in the middle of a shutdown. We run two shutdowns each year, and one is underway right now. It's more difficult given all the social distancing requirements and the fact that we've had to bring in roughly 250 contractors from the region. The great part is that every one of the communities — whether that's Wabush, Labrador, Newfoundland or Fermont — has backed us on everything we've implemented, and we've actually made our ties with those communities stronger, so they were willing to welcome these contractors arriving during this period. So the shutdown is progressing quite well. And when it wraps up, we should be in a position to get back to close to nameplate capacity.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Stefan Ioannou with Cormark Securities.
Stefan Ioannou
analystIn the past few quarters, there's been a bit of discussion, just regarding the port side, about some efficiency problems and logistical challenges that have resulted in somewhat elevated costs. Could you perhaps provide us with a bit more detail on precisely what has been happening there, so we might hopefully fix the situation sooner rather than later? Or what the timeline could be for getting to where you'd like to be on the port side of things?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks for your question, Stefan. So one of the main problems we had at the port was that they had broken down a portion of the stacker reclaimer, and that was limiting how many tonnes per hour we could move through it. And this was causing congestion, along with the fact that there's a new player delivering from the port. What they're doing right now — during our planned shutdown at the mine, they're also shutting down the port, and they're repairing the stacker reclaimer, where we should be in a position to get back to circa about 40 hours to be able to load a capesize vessel. So this will reduce our cost. And also the better management at this site now has really improved the processes, and we're already seeing the <<inaudible>> at the port. So we feel pretty comfortable that most of the issues we had are a thing of the past.
Stefan Ioannou
analystAll right, all right, good. And perhaps regarding that final question, just kind of, I suppose, maybe attempting to put some numbers around it for the present quarter — the effect of COVID and all of that on your production profile. Like clearly, operations are still ramping up. They were closed or substantially curtailed for several weeks early in the quarter. The present run rate stands at 1.8 million, 1.9 million tonnes per quarter. Could you quantify, sort of, what this quarter may look like from a production standpoint? Or is that something you're not comfortable disclosing or not ready to discuss at this point?
David Cataford
executiveWell, we usually don't provide guidance. So right now, what we're focused on is really getting back up toward our nameplate capacity. Before we shut down, we were operating at figures near roughly 90% of nameplate. So as things come back up, we're hoping to return to those kinds of levels. But there's still considerable uncertainty out there. So we just want to be sure we're being prudent with the numbers we announced. And -- but one thing you can be certain of is that the entire team, the union, the communities, everyone is aligned so that we can operate as quickly as possible toward full production.
Stefan Ioannou
analystAll right, thanks for that. Sorry — perhaps just a single final question, and it concerns Phase 2. Clearly, discretionary spending has been paused. Regarding the ways you could fund Phase 2, are those conversations still happening? Or have they also been paused at this point, until you get some visibility into improved timing?
David Cataford
executiveRight, at the moment nothing has been paused. Those conversations have therefore been carrying on. The great thing is that iron ore, when you add shipping costs into the mix as things stand, is in fact doing better than gold. So certain partners remain fairly at ease with where iron ore prices sit and with the outlook for iron ore. So — we have not put those talks on hold.
Operator
operatorOrest Wowkodaw with Scotiabank has the following question.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystCould you provide a little more detail on the iron ore price you realized during the most recent quarter? To be specific, the gross realized price of USD 97 a tonne — that represented a 6% discount to the actual benchmark 65% Fe price. What additional color can you share regarding what drove that?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks for asking, Orest. Essentially, what really set things apart was a timing problem with realized sales in this quarter. Some of the clients we serve are on pricing tied to the prior quarter, while certain of the declines we handle point toward the future. So when we examined the actual future we observed, a number of those vessels had been booked at somewhat lower prices. But since prices have now recovered, that ought to be fixed.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystRight, got it. Okay, so that USD 97 per tonne — does it effectively take in the unrealized provisional pricing on part of that 650,000 tonnes?
Natacha Garoute
executiveThat's correct. Orest, you've got it exactly. Just like David said, regarding the tonnage shipped, the pricing formula for this customer for the upcoming quarter means that under IFRS we must record our best estimates at that point. That is the reason the 600,000 tonnes were calculated using the forward pricing from Q2 calendar 2020, which explains the roughly USD 10 gap. And as David noted, with iron ore prices now higher, that provisional price adjustment ought to show up in our Q1 financials.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystAll right, that's great. Now, on the CapEx side of things. Clearly, Phase 2 is on hold at the moment. Still, could you help us understand what you expect to spend on sustaining capital alone in the coming fiscal year? Would it be roughly in line with the figure we just saw, about $50 million?
David Cataford
executiveYes. So that's roughly the figure we're aiming to spend this year. Obviously, depending on what iron ore costs, that could potentially change. But it's approximately that number, correct.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystAll right, and lastly, regarding the Labrador Trough, the problem in fiscal Q1 came from shutdowns tied to COVID. Should we take it that your unit costs likely rose substantially during April and perhaps the first half of May, given the effect of operating at considerably reduced rates? I'm just wondering how we ought to think about that. Any quantification you could offer would be useful.
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks for that question. Some costs have definitely gone up. At the same time, though, there are areas in which we've managed to make improvements. So it's simply the reality that we're only flying in the operations staff, and everyone involved in everything from planning through to engineering and the various work streams is working from home. That also brings down our fly-in, fly-out expenses. And even though we had to double the number of planes so we could maintain social distancing, since we moved from a 14 days on, 14 days off schedule to a 21 days on, 21 days off one, well, that has cut the number of flights in and out. So when you put all of that together, our cost has certainly taken a hit, but it's not as...
William O'Keeffe
executiveThat's an extraordinary result.
David Cataford
executiveBigger or more extreme than what you probably assumed at first.
Operator
operatorCraig Hutchison from TD Bank has the next question.
Craig Hutchison
analystJust a quick follow-up. Earlier, I believe around the shutdown, you said you're operating at roughly 90% of nameplate capacity. Should we expect that to be the level you're running at as you ramp up over the year, or do you think you can return to the full 100%?
David Cataford
executiveYes. We are putting all our effort into returning to that 100%. However, given the logistics constraints and our staffing situation, we need to finish training every one of the seasonal workers, because under this COVID situation certain employees are unable to come on site, whether due to preexisting conditions or their age. So it is not that we wish to discriminate by age, but we made a decision to set an age limit for employees and to avoid flying in anyone with preexisting conditions that might make the COVID situation more complicated. So we are now training seasonal employees so they can take over the workflow from these employees. So when you put these factors together with the logistics, we are working with the IOC on a plan to bring this back up to 100%, and we could expect to reach that level in the coming weeks.
Craig Hutchison
analystAll right. Turning to shipping and the freight portfolio as it stands at the moment — could you provide a rough estimate of the price you're realizing on the freight rates currently in effect?
David Cataford
executiveYes. So normally there's a gap between freight rates and the C3 index of roughly — it varies by quarter and by how fast we've secured the ships — somewhere from 4 to 10 weeks. So let's call it around 6 to 8 weeks on that. And at the moment, what the market is showing us is ships at close to about $11, $11 50 per tonne. So we could see that pricing is considerably more favorable now than it was in the prior quarter.
Craig Hutchison
analystAlright, and perhaps just a final question from my side. Are you expecting to carry out any additional DR pellet feed operations basically during this quarter or over the quarters ahead?
David Cataford
executiveWe don't anticipate doing any during the upcoming quarters. So the — at this point we've defined what the effect on our recovery would be compared with the product we make. Even though we're capable of doing it. If a customer came to us and offered the right price for the DR grate type material, we would make it. But as things stand, we remain pretty much sold out for the year with our blast furnace type material. The reason we wanted to run that test was simply to demonstrate to customers worldwide that we can do it. And it's largely aimed at our Phase 2 expansion. But should the right customer arrive with the right pricing, that's something we could achieve right now.
Operator
operatorLucas Pipes of B. Riley FBR has the next question.
Lucas Pipes
analystNice work handling the pandemic at the sites over the past year. I have a broader demand-side question. You said that for Phase 2, you wanted to see how Europe and Japan emerge from this. What are you observing in those regions right now? From where you sit, how severe has the drop been? Opinions have differed somewhat on that. I would be interested in your view.
David Cataford
executiveYes. Appreciate the question. Michael, would you like to take this one, or should I?
William O'Keeffe
executiveHonestly, when you consider Europe, it's quite a poignant situation. Naturally, they have reduced their output. Japan alone has made substantial reductions. You witnessed Nippon genuinely scaling back. Yet clearly, China has recovered and a significant portion of the tonnage is heading into China. But honestly, Brazil has truly been the balancing factor. And consider what has occurred in Brazil, starting with the dam closures. We have now seen an earthquake in Sweden, and they have closed their mine. So the supply situation going into this — as I mentioned earlier, or in the previous presentation — I was consistently quite bullish on high-grade iron ore. And demand would be present since there will be an enormous level of supply disruption for our material. Now, most of our tonnes are focused on — going into China, Japan or to Bahrain, with some tonnes into Europe, some into India and other Fortescue. But we are not the market maker. So the impact on us has been considerably smaller than for those with long-term contracts into Europe, which is primarily Brazil due to freight. And Australia does not have major effects on Europe. So what you are observing is a rebalancing there.
William O'Keeffe
executiveWell, production in Europe has been getting shut down by people because of the pandemic, and anyway Brazil hasn't been in a position to supply those tonnes. So that kind of balances out on its own. China, though, is the biggest offtaker. Their stimulus packages are getting them moving. And we get phone calls constantly asking whether we can deliver additional tonnes into China. There's also a policy we have where — given the voyage time involved, obviously it would be better for us to go to Europe, so that we can sell tonnes into Asia on the same terms as, if not better than, what we can get in Europe. So I'm talking our own book a little here. But — so if you look at how things balance out in Europe, I see Brazil as the main supplier. So that has leveled itself out. Demand is coming from China in a big way. Let's hope that keeps going. And we're in a good position. But there's also something else we do: we set a lot of tonnes down at the port, which is something — an initiative we started with Glencore a while back. And it has paid off handsomely for us, because we were able to place tonnes in a lot of the smaller mills.
William O'Keeffe
executiveDemand for our product is picking up in that region, and that has served us rather well. That said, Michael Marcotte helps out and keeps a close eye on much of the day-to-day activity in the market too. So, Michael, is there anything you're noticing that differs from what I just described?
David Cataford
executive<<inaudible>> Michael, please continue.
Michael Marcotte
executiveNo, no, I'd say that captures it well. What's really striking is just how concentrated the major global players are. And everyone should stay aware of that, since trouble in even a few of those very big hubs can ripple outward with disproportionate impact worldwide.
Lucas Pipes
analystThat's quite useful, and I appreciate the perspective. I don't know whether you attached a figure to it. You mentioned the somewhat lower fuel costs. Could we apply some sensitivity to your future costs given weaker oil prices?
David Cataford
executiveSo really, the shipping route is the main place where oil prices matter for us. If you look at our site, roughly 65% of the energy we use comes from renewables. That means fuel consumption isn't all that significant, outside of our trucks and a handful of auxiliary equipment. As a result, the effect on our operating costs isn't as large as it is for other operators.
Operator
operatorJon Scholtz of Macquarie has the next question.
Jon Scholtz
analystI just have a single question about your cash holdings. I was wondering whether all of it is in Canadian dollars, and whether the hedging program is in place over there?
David Cataford
executiveNatacha, could you please walk us through the cash position?
Michael Marcotte
executiveNatacha, over to you?
Natacha Garoute
executiveWould you mind — apologies — saying that question again for me?
Jon Scholtz
analystRight. I'm just trying to figure out whether all of it is kept in Canadian dollars, or whether you also hold some in U.S. dollars. And do you have a hedging program around your cash? I mean, I notice the debt — its face value is in U.S. dollars. So I'm just trying to reconcile those two things?
Natacha Garoute
executiveYes. So right now we hold roughly $130 million in U.S. currency on M. The remainder was held in Canadian dollars. As things stand, we currently don't have any hedging policy in place. What we do have is a minimum cash balance that management wishes to maintain, and that sits at about USD 50 million. And as you can see from our financial statement, we're more <<inaudible>>. Regarding our long-term debt, we don't have to — just to remind everyone, no capital repayment is required until June 2021. So from that standpoint, we have a solid natural hedge position.
William O'Keeffe
executiveAnd I've steered clear of hedging. For us, hedging would only create a great deal of pain. I won't stand here telling shareholders the results ought to have looked like this, except that sadly we locked in our currency at $0.76, and that requires some explaining. In my experience running mining companies, shareholders consistently tell us there's already sufficient risk in mining without management piling on additional risk through hedging. Now, there are various approaches to hedging, and various ways to view it, but the major — the 3 major variables for us are the iron ore price, shipping and currency. So if you consider anyone discussing the iron ore price, I'm sure you all grasp this, everybody was pessimistic that the forward curve always falls away, and everybody was saying we'll return to $38 a tonne, Monday. Well, that's wonderful. On the flip side, shippers are perpetually optimistic and their forward prices always rise. So you can hedge yourself into obliteration, but I've consistently found that when you sit up and talk with shareholders, they are sophisticated enough to understand what an iron ore price is, what an exchange rate is and what a shipping rate is, and they can perform the calculation.
William O'Keeffe
executiveSo they’re expecting you to turn out a certain number of tonnes. That ought to be the revenue measured against your cost. And if you fall short of that because you’ve hedged currency or done something else, it takes some explaining. So the position we’ve taken is one we’re very comfortable with, and we’ll keep taking it.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the question queue. Please go ahead.
David Cataford
executiveWell, I really appreciate all of you joining us on today's call, and I'm looking forward to speaking with each of you over the course of the quarter as well as at the close of the following quarter. Things look quite exciting on our end. So thank you so much for your backing, and to everyone, have a wonderful day.
Operator
operatorThat brings today’s conference call to an end, everyone. We appreciate your taking part, and please go ahead and disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Champion Iron Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Champion Iron Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Champion Iron Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.