Champion Iron Limited (CIA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
October 31, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us for the Second Quarter Results of the Financial Year 2025 Conference Call. <<operator_script>> Today is Thursday, October 31, 2024, and this call is being recorded. At this point I'll hand the conference over to Michael Marcotte, Senior Vice President, Corporate Development. Please go ahead.
Michael Marcotte
executiveThanks, operator, and thanks to all of you for being with us today as we go over the Q2 results for the 2025 financial year. Before handing things to our CEO for the formal presentation, I want to remind everyone that the deck being used for this webcast can be found on our website, championiron.com, under the Events and Presentation tab. I should also note that during this call we will be making forward-looking statements. For those forward-looking statements, along with the risks and assumptions, you can refer to our MD&A, which is also posted on our website. Here with me today are several of our executives, among them David Cataford, our CEO, who will deliver the formal presentation today as well as handle the Q&A, and also our COO, Alexandre Belleau, and our CFO, Donald Tremblay. With that, I'll pass it to David for the formal presentation.
David Cataford
executiveHey, everyone. Thanks for joining us so we can go over the second quarter highlights of fiscal year 2025. Now, turning to the highlights themselves. As you're aware, this quarter was somewhat challenging — it began with forest fires in the area that got very near Bloom Lake and very near Labrador City. I'm quite pleased with how we handled that situation, though it did have a fairly significant impact on production during the quarter. On top of that, the first quarter is when we carry out our two major shutdowns at Plant #1 and Plant #2 one right after the other, which brought its own challenges that also affected our production. Overall, though, we produced roughly 3.17 million tons in the quarter and sold a little more than 3.25 million tons in the quarter as well. I'm also glad to report there were no significant workplace incidents during the period and, once again, another quarter without major environmental issues — which means we've had no major environmental issues since Bloom Lake was re-commissioned in 2018. When it comes to local communities, we've done a great deal of work over the past quarter. As you know, one of our priorities is making sure that we don't just operate well, but that we also maintain our license to operate and keep working with local communities.
David Cataford
executiveA major highlight this quarter: we launched a new initiative in which our employees spend 2 days within a First Nations community. That's a first for Canada. It gives us a better grasp of all the challenges and realities that exist locally, and it also lets us deepen our partnership with the First Nation of Uashat mak Mani-utenam. On the operations side, looking at what took place this quarter with our stockpile, as you're aware, we had approximately 3 million tons of material stockpiled at site. We succeeded in reducing that stockpile by 200,000 tons, largely because production was lower this quarter. Yet it wasn't just production that was affected — logistics took a hit too. So absent the forest fires, we'd have taken out a substantial additional quantity of tons. I'm also pleased to say — this didn't occur last quarter, but it has happened since — we've begun receiving our rolling stock of railcars, which will give us greater flexibility to move tons all the way to the port.
David Cataford
executiveThe rail operator is expected to take delivery of its locomotives before this calendar year wraps up and to have them commissioned shortly thereafter. Looking more closely at our operations, a key standout for the quarter, I'd say, is that we succeeded in hauling slightly more than 9 million tons of waste, which gave us a strip ratio of roughly 1:1. So the fresh equipment now beginning to come online, together with the efficiency gains we've achieved at the mine, support <<inaudible>> our 1:1 strip ratio, or life of mine strip ratio. Turning to the market, you likely noticed the P65 index fell by a bit more than 9% over the quarter, driven chiefly by softer steel demand worldwide, construction-sector troubles in China, and higher output coming from Brazil and Australia. The C3 index, meanwhile, rose modestly, by roughly 3%, though we've seen it retreat since then. As a result, our freight position has come down since the close of the prior quarter. On the provisional price adjustment — as you'll recall, we had around 1.8 million tons on the water when last quarter ended, against a forecast sales price of approximately $120 per ton.
David Cataford
executiveWe ended up realizing roughly 110 because iron ore prices softened during the quarter, meaning a negative provisional price adjustment of approximately 17 million tons hit us. That took about $5 per ton off our realized selling price. Looking ahead to the next quarter, we have roughly 2.3 million tons on the water, with an expected selling price of around $120 per ton. If we turn to the actual realized selling price in Canadian dollars, we did slightly better than the P65 average this quarter, largely because some of our sales were backward looking, mostly into the Japanese market, and when you combine that with the negative provisional price adjustment and FX, we realized a price of roughly CAD107 per ton delivered in the vessel. On operating costs, they came in a bit above last quarter, driven mainly by 2 factors: first, we produced considerably fewer tons than our nameplate capacity, which pushes our operating costs up. Second, it was the first time we ran 2 major shutdowns back-to-back at site. Looking ahead, we believe this will generate some synergies and let us cut downtime while also improving our operating costs.
David Cataford
executiveHowever, this quarter marked the first occasion we’ve carried that out. We ran into certain scheduling problems, along with some difficulties when bringing the plant back online, given how complicated it was to have those shutdowns occur consecutively. So that had a somewhat adverse effect over the quarter. Yet once more, we do — we’ve identified every element requiring improvement. And like everything else we’ve undertaken previously, we will certainly focus on making that better, which lets us boost uptime and raise output, enabling us to lower our cost going forward. On financial highlights, quarterly revenues came in at roughly $350 million, EBITDA slightly under $75 million and an EPS of $0.04 per ton — $0.04 per share, pardon me. You’ve likely noticed the cash balance dip a little over the quarter, mostly because we paid out our semiannual dividend. Yet we also put about $65 million into the flotation plant we are presently constructing. We can provide a brief update on that in the upcoming slide. And we carried on with our sustaining CapEx program as well, chiefly investments in the dykes and in building the new waste dump, just as we had planned within our feasibility study.
David Cataford
executiveNow, moving on to the balance sheet. If you take a look at it, we continue to have liquid assets on hand, which lets us complete the flotation plant without any trouble. I'm also pleased to announce our seventh straight semiannual dividend of $0.10 per share. Our balance sheet remains very strong, and we keep investing in our operations so we can raise the grade of our material and take advantage of better premiums down the road, all while keeping that balance sheet very strong. Turning to our growth projects, as you're aware, there are two main ones we're working on at present: the flotation plant, which we'll give you an update on in the next slide, and the Kami Project, where we're currently putting in investment so we can permit it. So the key projects we really want to advance are, first, permitting Kami, which involves minimal investment but brings us closer to a delivery date if the market needs those tons. We do believe that in time the market will require more material of the DR-grade type, and Kami will be one of the assets capable of supplying those tons.
David Cataford
executiveAnd once the permit is in hand, it will be simpler down the road should we decide to take FID on that project, since we would then be nearer to a delivery timeline. On the flotation project, I'm glad to report that delivery remains on schedule and within budget. We have now used roughly 50% of the CapEx needed to complete the project. The majority of the high-risk elements are now behind us, including all structural construction, the geotechnical work, and procurement of the major equipment. We remain confident in our ability to deliver that project on schedule and within budget during the second half of calendar 2025. We are also devoting considerable time overseas to ensure we line up the right customers for this kind of material, and we keep working with prospective future clients. By the end of next summer, we expect to be positioned with most of our tons committed, so that we are ready to deliver those tons once the flotation project is complete. As for why we are undertaking this project, as you know, we do believe we will be able to gain from higher premiums.
David Cataford
executiveThe main reason for that is steel output has stayed relatively level over the last few years, yet DRI production has risen considerably. And if you look at the global picture, plenty of projects are either under construction or have already received sanction, which will further reinforce that expansion in the years ahead. And we want to be certain we're positioned to serve that market. When it comes to our commitment to supply the DR-grade market, that's also a rationale for supplying into the greener steel transition. And for us, it matters not just to offer a high-grade product but to hold very high standards at Bloom Lake as well. We're fully committed to achieving a 40% cut in CO2 emissions across our Scope 1 and Scope 2, and by now we've mapped out most of the projects needed to reach that level, and we also completed a fairly extensive mapping of our Scope 3 initiatives during the quarter. Looking at the projects for Scope 1 and Scope 2 reduction, although today we already rank among the lowest CO2 intensity high-grade iron ores worldwide, we do have projects in place to cut our CO2 emissions by 2030.
David Cataford
executiveThere's encouraging news for everyone who holds our stock: the majority of the projects we've looked at and are currently engaged in are ones that will let us cut back on fuel. So cutting fuel use means we lower CO2 emissions and at the same time bring down our operating costs. On the Scope 3 front, we completed a fairly extensive mapping exercise during the quarter, and several of our employees put in a great deal of effort to get it finished. There's no major revelation on our end, since we've long understood that the bulk of our Scope 3 CO2 emissions tie back to the steelmaking stage — for the customers consuming our iron ore, roughly 95% of Scope 3 emissions relate to processing our materials. That keeps underscoring how important it is for us to keep raising the grade of what we sell, which lets Scope 3 come down, helps our customers shrink their possible carbon taxes, and lets them capture the full advantage of possible green steel premiums down the road for what they produce. With all that said, I'm extremely proud of what the team managed to deliver in a quarter full of challenges.
David Cataford
executiveThanks to all of you for being on today's call. I'll now hand things over to the Q&A part of the session.
Operator
operatorYour opening question is from Orest Wowkodaw at Scotiabank. Go right ahead.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystMorning, and thanks for the additional detail. Could you give us a clearer picture of what the railroad can handle right now from a logistics standpoint? You said no more locomotives will arrive on the rail line until commissioning at the end of the year, in Q1. As I understand it, railcars are being added over the next few weeks. So what does that mean for capacity today? If I look at your annual production volume, we're talking about 3.7 million to 3.8 million tons per quarter that needs to be shipped. Is the rail line able to move that kind of volume at present? Or will it still take a couple of quarters before you reach your full production run rate from a volume shipping perspective?
David Cataford
executiveYes, and thanks for that question, Orest. So looking at the rail line right now, there have been a few improvements since last quarter. What's happening is that we're seeing some record weeks in terms of how much is being shipped. The problem is that it isn't robust enough, and there isn't enough spare capacity to account for the various elements that come up during operations. So we'll have one amazing week, and then, for some reasons on the rail line, we'll have a challenging week after that. So those other locos are going to let us keep that higher run rate, which allows us not only to get the tons down but also to weather those issues when they happen. Current capacity, if you listened to IOC's analyst visit not too long ago, is about 43 million tons. If that were true, definitely we'd be able not only to bring down our tons and bring down our stockpile, but what we're seeing is that once those locos come in, I do think we're going to have enough robustness to bring down the tons and weather those sorts of operational issues.
David Cataford
executiveStill, what stands out most, I'd say, is that there have been weeks when we managed to exceed what our existing contract allows.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystLet me try putting that another way. If Bloom Lake gets back on track operationally during the fourth calendar quarter, do you believe you could genuinely draw down additional tonnage above what you produce?
David Cataford
executiveOkay, so let's say we hit a record quarter near roughly 4 million tons — I think even then, reducing tons out of the stockpile would still be somewhat challenging. That said, I do believe that on our end as well, rolling stock has begun to arrive. The majority of the railcars should be here before this year is over. That will provide us with extra flexibility we normally lacked in the winter months. For our present production, those cars aren't strictly necessary at 100%, but as you're aware, we wanted them on hand for upcoming debottlenecking projects, so we bought them in advance to enable that flexibility. So that should certainly be beneficial potentially in the months ahead too.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystAll right. So when you're running at full capacity, I wouldn't count on much destocking, say, in the near term. Could it take a little longer?
David Cataford
executiveThat’s right.
Orest Wowkodaw
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorCraig Hutchison from TD Cowen has the next question in the queue. Please proceed.
Craig Hutchison
analystMorning, everyone. I’d like to ask about the DRPF project. You noted that you’re in active talks with prospective customers in Europe. When will we get a sense of what that pricing mechanism is? And do you expect the material to be largely locked up before commissioning begins?
David Cataford
executiveYes. Well, thank you for asking, Craig. So I would say that by the close of next summer, we ought to have a solid picture of where those tons will be committed, and likewise a decent grasp of the formulas tied to the selling price. That's because our aim is to achieve decoupling from the P65 and to ensure we gain the benefit of the DR-grade premiums. We have observed that the DR-grade premium has come in somewhat lower over the past few quarters, but we genuinely believe that with all the DRI capacity entering operation, there is a chance it could recover next year.
Craig Hutchison
analystAll right, and what's your estimate for how long the commissioning effort will run before we reach full capacity?
David Cataford
executiveYes. So this is the first flotation plant we've constructed. The technology itself is relatively straightforward, but it's still a new facility we're bringing in. At the moment, we're forecasting a few months in order to ramp up the flotation plant. Naturally, we'll do our utmost, just as we always have done previously. But realistically, I believe it will take a few months before we can achieve that production level again. What matters to note is that this shouldn't impact our production, because should there be any minor issues while commissioning, well, we can always revert to producing the 66.2% material. However, for a complete ramp-up, when we consider consistently reaching quality, what was forecasted, let's say, in the study we carried out was a full 12 months. But we'll be capable of producing material sooner than that.
Craig Hutchison
analystAll right, great. Perhaps one final question from my side. Clearly, a significant amount has been spent on other capital items at Bloom Lake this quarter. Part of that, I believe, ties to your wish to push capacity past roughly 15 million tons. In your view, when should we begin factoring in greater output from Bloom Lake, given the investments you've made so far and those still to come?
David Cataford
executiveOkay, so at the moment, a significant portion of the capital that’s been spent went into the tailings and the new waste dumps. As outlined in the feasibility study, beginning last year, we were putting money in so we could construct the new tailings facility — or rather the upgraded tailings facility — along with the new waste dump. That’s where most of the CapEx has gone. If we look at the debottlenecking projects we might pursue, we truly have to sort out the rail before we begin activating those potential projects or putting a bit more investment into them. So we’ve basically identified all the various items that must be completed in order to get there — to get to higher production. But at present, the primary focus is genuinely on bringing the rail up to the standard we want, so that we’re able to raise the tonnage.
Craig Hutchison
analystAll right, that's excellent. Appreciate it, everyone.
David Cataford
executiveAll right.
Operator
operatorAlexander Pearce from BMO has the next question in the queue. The line is yours.
Alexander Pearce
analystYou mentioned it's ticked down somewhat lately — and it seems tied to ore hardness. So I was hoping you could give us a little more detail on how you see that trending over the coming couple of quarters. Should we figure on that persisting for the next couple of periods, or might it take somewhat longer before we're back up in that 80% range?
David Cataford
executiveYes, I appreciate the question. That makes sense. If we consider recovery and the effect of that harder material we encountered, it was a limited pocket located in the <<inaudible>> area. Looking at how recovery performed in the quarter, three separate factors had an influence. First, the forest fires forced us to halt production. As you're aware, after a stop-and-go situation there are usually some minor recovery problems. It was also the quarter in which we carried out two significant shutdowns — one at Plant number 1 and another at Plant number 2. Normally, following major shutdowns, restarting the plants involves a modest ramp-up where recovery is concerned. And we additionally had that harder zone, which mainly affected our Phase 1 recovery. Phase 2 features a more robust circuit. With Phase 1, though, harder zones typically cause the material to be over-ground somewhat, meaning we lose some iron ore into the fines portion. Had hardness been the only factor, our impact would have been smaller. Still, it's one element we're addressing to ensure those fines can be recovered.
Alexander Pearce
analystThanks. Now for my second question — regarding <<inaudible>> somewhat over the quarter. I was wondering if perhaps you could describe what the market is showing for that premium you receive over the benchmark. And since iron ore prices recovered once more right at the quarter's close, has that premium widened again? Thanks.
David Cataford
executiveRight, the premium hasn't been as elevated as it was historically. What really helped us this quarter came mostly from the sales we usually make to Japan, which tend to look backward. So that largely accounts for the better realized price we achieved rather than what we got for the P65. On the high grade side — in China at the moment environmental restrictions aren't very numerous, and steel profitability is relatively weak. As a result, there aren't many incentives at present for buying greater volumes of high-grade material. That's exactly why we're keen to establish ourselves in the DR market, so we can avoid that kind of volatility between P65 and P62. Still, we haven't observed that premium rising meaningfully over the last few quarters.
Alexander Pearce
analystI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThe next person in the queue is Lucas Pipes from B. Riley, and your question is up now.
Lucas Pipes
analystThanks a lot, operator. Hello, everyone. I'd like to start with a question about costs — could you give us some sense of the outlook? You just mentioned recoveries, but also from a stripping ratio standpoint, and looking ahead over the next couple of quarters, where do you expect costs to land on a cash cost basis? Many thanks.
David Cataford
executiveYes. Thanks, Lucas. So, as you observed this quarter, we're roughly 500,000 tons—or slightly above 500,000 tons—below our nameplate capacity, largely because of the fires and the significant shutdowns we experienced. So those had a really negative effect on our costs. The stripping ratio is closer to what we'll expect going forward. So, 1:1 is our life of mine strip ratio. So, as you can imagine, we had to move those waste tons so we could access our ore. But realistically, that's pretty much the kind of strip ratio we should be able to see in the future. The main area where we'll be able to bring our cost down is really on the volume. And while I don't expect forest fires during the winter, obviously, and I think we've added protection around our site as well to try to minimize the potential impacts in the future, but realistically, the main fact or the main element was tied to the volume. The second portion is, we did draw down about 200,000 tons from the stockpile, and those stockpiles are tied to higher costs as well, because we see the cost to move the material back and forth from our production to the stockpile and then from the stockpile to the load out.
David Cataford
executiveSo that's one factor that also plays into our cost picture whenever we recover material out of the stockpiles.
Lucas Pipes
analystCould you also give us a rough reminder of the cost tied to that stockpile movement?
David Cataford
executiveProviding a precise figure is somewhat difficult. If we consider the blended rate, we're seeing approximately slightly more than CAD8 per ton in order to place it on the stockpile and then retrieve it.
Lucas Pipes
analystSo a chunk of that you'd be paying regardless, right? But part of that CAD8 could be specific to this situation where stockpiles are higher. Does that seem like a fair way to think about it?
David Cataford
executiveAll of that is entirely attributable to stockpiling. Normally, we wouldn’t encounter those costs tied to our tons.
Lucas Pipes
analystUnderstood. So that CAD8 is really something specific to right now. That helps. Thanks.
David Cataford
executiveIf you look at what we normally keep on hand, there are, say, 4 small stockpiles right next to the plant. So whenever the need arises — and it does happen that we've drawn on those piles before when there were problems with the train or something like that — we've used them. But the expense involved there is quite minor, since we usually dump directly alongside the plants using the conveyor, and a small loader puts the material back into a chute so it can return to the silos. What we now have to do is take a small loader and a small truck and haul those trucks a few kilometers from the plant to place the material on temporary stockpiles because of the rail issue. That is why we've incurred that cost of, say, $8 per ton.
Lucas Pipes
analystThat’s really useful, thanks. And I hope the rail situation gets better, as you described earlier. David, a broader question about the investment climate and appetite in iron ore — with Simandou coming online late in 2025 and plenty of headlines about China’s transition. Rio Tinto is putting money into lithium. In your view, do we need additional iron ore, or how would you put that? Thank you.
David Cataford
executiveYes. To start with the questions, we've been seeing somewhat weaker steel output, and on a year-over-year basis, growth in steel consumption is quite minimal. Whether that stays flat or turns into a decline is something we'll be watching over the coming years. Still, when you add up all the tons, it doesn't appear the world requires much additional iron ore. That said, I believe demand will rise for DR-grade material. There aren't many of those tons available globally, and my feeling is that this segment — which has expanded over the past 4 years, 5 years — will keep expanding as additional DRI facilities come online. That's precisely why we intend to focus exclusively on that market and ensure we're able to serve it. Now, if the question is whether the world needs a project like Kami, that's certainly something we'll be tracking over the next few years. The great part — well, I'm not sure it's great, but the positive part is that we currently hold 2 years of permitting.
David Cataford
executiveSo we won't be making any potential choices regarding a project such as Kami before — let's say — the end of the 2026 calendar year. By then, we'll be in a position to see how many of those DRI plants have been commissioned, what the demand environment looks like, and whether the world needs a project like Kami. But certainly, in today's environment, we wouldn't pull the trigger on the Kami project. Still, I think it holds great potential for the future. And if the world keeps up its transition toward lowering CO2 emissions, then I do believe a project like Kami is going to be necessary down the road.
Lucas Pipes
analystDavid, I really value the point of view you've shared, and to you and the team, I wish you the very best of luck.
David Cataford
executiveAppreciate it, Lucas.
Operator
operatorStefan Ioannou from Cormark Securities has the next question. Please proceed.
Stefan Ioannou
analystYes. Thank you. Perhaps I could dig a little deeper into the finer points of what Craig asked regarding CapEx. You brought up the waste dumps along with the tailings. Thinking about sustaining versus growth CapEx and the growth figure, both rose rather noticeably quarter-over-quarter. As for the growth figure, would some of the railcar purchases also be included in that number?
David Cataford
executiveYes. On the growth side, that's largely attributable to the flotation plant. That's the piece we began ramping up. Roughly $250 million is still needed — actually a touch above $250 million — to complete the project. So that's the reason you'll see the growth segment rise over the coming few quarters as we wrap up the DR grade and…
Stefan Ioannou
analystAlright, my focus is probably on the growth CapEx that falls outside the DRPF project.
David Cataford
executiveYeah. At the moment, there isn’t a great deal of growth CapEx tied to other projects. Again, our primary emphasis is on the rail — getting that back on track before we’d consider putting money into upgrading parts of the operations so that CapEx could rise above the nameplate.
Stefan Ioannou
analystAlright. Sorry — let me try putting that a different way. What I have in mind is the quarter that's already behind us, since it rose quite a bit between calendar Q2 and calendar Q3. So I'm just curious: how does that growth figure break down compared with the sustaining figure from the quarter you've just reported?
David Cataford
executiveAlright. If you look at the presentation, roughly $55 million went into the flotation plant. So that growth part is entirely — 100% — in the flotation plant. As for the other sustaining portion, it's mainly all the projects in the dykes and at the new waste dump. So if you go back to the feasibility study, a few hundred million was tied to building out the new stockpile for the tailings and also the new waste dump dykes.
Stefan Ioannou
analystAll right. Perhaps I’ll follow up with you folks once the call wraps up, and I’m still a bit confused here. There is — you’ve got one more growth item in the statements besides the DRPF. I’m just attempting to square that, that’s all.
David Cataford
executiveAll right. Sure, we could walk through the figures. There's a small amount tied to mining equipment along with a few other items. Some investment also went into the garage. That garage is finished now. That said, we can return to this afterward and review those figures item by item.
Stefan Ioannou
analystAll right, many thanks.
Operator
operatorI'll now hand things to David Cataford, who has some closing remarks for us. David, the floor is yours.
David Cataford
executiveYes, and thanks to all of you for being on the call. Once more, I'd describe this as a tough quarter, and I feel genuinely glad and proud of how the team found its way through the complicated situation caused by the forest fires early on. I believe we performed well by keeping the effect on us as small as possible. There was also some difficulty tied to the two shutdowns happening one right after the other, though I really believe that will deliver meaningful gains going forward. And again, we keep pushing ahead on the rail, which I see as the single most critical piece for our business, making sure we can ultimately move all those tons out of that stockpile and turn that material into actual sales. But once more, what I see as the bright side for us is the outlook for the DRI and for the greener steel portion, which we still expect to keep moving ahead at a fairly quick pace. And I really believe that is the market we want to operate in, and that it will generate the greatest value for our shareholders. So, once again, thank you all for being on the call today, and I look forward to talking with you on the next one.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up today’s call, everyone. We appreciate each of you taking part, and at this point you’re free to hang up.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Champion Iron Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Champion Iron Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Champion Iron Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.