Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 4, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 35 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Emily Mohr

executive
#1

Thanks, Laurie, and I appreciate all of you joining us for Chimera's conference call on our third quarter results. Ahead of getting started, let me go over the safe harbor statement. On this call, we'll be sharing forward-looking statements, meaning predictions, projections, or other remarks regarding events yet to come. Such statements rest on present expectations and assumptions and carry risks and uncertainties, all of which are described in the Risk Factors section along with our latest annual and quarterly SEC filings. What actually happens and what we actually report could end up substantially different from those forward-looking statements. I'd urge you to look at the forward-looking statement disclaimer included in our earnings release, as well as our quarterly and annual filings. We might also cover non-GAAP financial measures on today's call. For a reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures, please see our SEC filings and earnings supplement. Also, what's said on this conference call could include time-sensitive information that holds true only as of today's earnings call date. We neither undertake nor specifically accept any duty to update or revise this information. Now I'll hand the conference over to Matthew Lambiase, our President and Chief Executive Officer.

Matt Lambiase

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us for Chimera Investment Corporation's earnings call for the third quarter of 2020. With me this morning are Mohit Marria, our Chief Investment Officer; Rob Colligan, our Chief Financial Officer; Choudhary Yarlagadda, our COO; and Vic Falvo, who heads our Capital Market. I'll offer a few quick remarks, then Mohit will go over what has changed in the portfolio, and Rob will walk through our financial results. Following that, we'll take your questions. Chimera is still operating remotely, and I'm glad to say that everyone on the team is safe and that working from home has gone well for us. During the last 6 months, we have taken numerous actions to reinforce our balance sheet, safeguard our attractive credit assets and steady the earnings stream from our portfolio. Those actions encompassed disposing of agency mortgage-backed securities, selling agency CMBS on a selective basis, arranging new financing that is not subject to mark-to-market and bringing down the company's total recourse leverage. What we did over that stretch allowed us to take part in the market's recovery in asset prices from the depressed levels seen in March. During the quarter, Chimera's book value rose 12% to $11.91 per share. We produced $0.33 of core earnings and distributed $0.30 in common dividend, which added up to an economic return of almost 15% for the period. The recovery in residential mortgage prices during this quarter can be traced to an exceptionally strong housing market, which has gotten a lift from a generational lull in U.S. interest rates. The COVID-19 pandemic has dramatically affected housing in the United States. The single-family home market is flourishing as many families leave cities for larger quarters in suburban and rural parts of the country. Families throughout America are looking for more living space for home offices, home classrooms and safe outdoor environments. According to the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, 42% of the U.S. labor force is presently working full time from home. Demand for single-family homes is surging. The pace of existing home sales climbed in September to 6.5 million homes, the highest level since 2006. And the inventory of existing homes available for sale has fallen nearly 20% versus the prior year to 1.5 million homes. At the current sales pace, all-in inventory now on the market could be sold in under 3 months. A great deal of this housing demand stems from record-low borrowing rates brought about by the Federal Reserve. Since March, the Federal Reserve has grown its balance sheet by 75% to more than $7 trillion, which has helped deliver low interest rates and ample liquidity to the mortgage market. The average rate on 30-year mortgages was reported recently at 2.8%, the lowest rate on record, with records going back to 1971. In addition, fiscal stimulus from the federal government for COVID-19 relief has injected more than $3 trillion into the economy and has assisted many mortgage borrowers through this challenging economic period. Right now, in Washington, lawmakers from both sides are talking about further fiscal stimulus measures. If those get passed, our view is they would keep assisting borrowers who are struggling and would be a positive for housing as well as the mortgage market. A solid housing sector, combined with cheap mortgage rates and backing from the government, creates a really powerful backdrop for holding residential mortgage credit. At the close of the quarter, about 90% of Chimera's investment portfolio sat in mortgage credit. The market for mortgage securitizations has come back to roughly where it stood before the pandemic, and in certain instances it looks even better, thanks to reduced interest rates and similar advance rates. During this quarter, Chimera finished 3 securitizations and also agreed to buy $640 million in mortgage loans. Because housing fundamentals are strengthening and credit conditions have improved, demand from investors for senior mortgage securities with high ratings is extremely robust. Chimera issues these securities often, and that lets us obtain long-term financing that isn't mark-to-market for the credit assets in our portfolio. Our investment team keeps uncovering opportunities and has had success building up our portfolio for securitizations down the road. Housing is among the few encouraging areas of the U.S. economy, and rising home values can lead to stronger mortgage credit fundamentals. When investment returns are low, holding a portfolio with high yield and a good credit profile puts you in a desirable spot. In our view, Chimera's portfolio is positioned well to benefit from these favorable trends and to keep generating solid dividend income for shareholders over the coming quarters. I'll hand the call to Mohit now so he can go over the portfolio.

Mohit Marria

executive
#3

Thanks, Matt. At the close of the quarter, the 10-year treasury yield stood at 68 basis points, compared with 1.92% when 2020 began. Because rates moved by such a large amount overall, prices on 10-year treasury notes have risen by roughly 10 points since the year started. Over the past 5 years, our agency CMBS investments have consisted mainly of Ginnie Mae project loans. Government guarantees back these securities, and because prepayment lockout and penalties are explicit, the Ginnie Mae permanent loan certificates are assets with longer duration. As treasury rates declined, the price performance of these assets benefited greatly. In the third quarter, we took advantage of that strong price performance and sold $659 million of securities from our agency CMBS portfolio on a selective basis. Through that sale, we realized approximately $65 million of gain and intend to move capital into mortgage credit. The purpose of this reallocation is to optimize portfolio income over the long term for the benefit of our shareholders. We keep watching our agency CMBS holdings against their market values and their explicit call protection so that our agency CMBS portfolio stays right-sized and optimal. At quarter end, our remaining agency CMBS holdings totaled $1.8 billion, which made up 10% of Chimera's total investment portfolio. During Q3, the market for newly issued securitized products remained robust, and spreads on some parts of the capital structure have nearly returned to where they stood before COVID-19. Tighter spreads combined with low absolute interest rates create attractive openings for issuers that are frequent and well known, like Chimera, to meet investor appetite for securities. Chimera closed 3 securitized transactions in Q3, amounting to just over $1 billion in total. Investment-grade ratings applied to the senior note across all 3 deals; in July, we brought CIM 2020-R5 to market with $338 million in loans drawn from our existing loan warehouse. The loans underlying that deal had a weighted average coupon of 4.98% and a weighted average loan age of 149 months. In the R5 deal, loans came in at an average of $152,000, with an average LTV of 70%. Borrowers' average FICO score was 678. From this transaction, we sold $257 million of senior securities while keeping $81 million in subordinated notes and interest-only securities. For CIM 2020-R5, our investment-grade debt cost was 2.05%, alongside a 76% advance rate. In addition, across 2 transactions, we securitized pools of prime jumbo mortgage loans as well as a pool of agency-eligible investor mortgage loans. CIM 2020-J1 marked our first prime jumbo securitization of 2020. This deal involved $362 million in loans, carrying a weighted average coupon of 3.76% and a weighted average loan age of 6 months. Loans averaged $732,000 in size, with an average FICO score of 766 and an average LTV of 67%. Our first securitization of agency-eligible investor loans for 2020 was CIM 2020-INV1. The size of that deal came to $335 million, carrying a weighted average coupon of 4.31%. Its loans averaged $332,000 in size. Those loans came with an average FICO of 765 and an average LTV of 64%. The J1 and INV1 securitizations are held off our balance sheet — they aren't consolidated. We placed $22 million into those transactions, which sits in our non-agency RMBS portfolio. During Q3, we committed to purchasing over $400 million of seasoned reperforming loans, and once the quarter ended, those loans were securitized into CIM 2020-R6. Because investor demand for senior notes was strong, we were able to go from purchase to securitization quickly. Pricing on the deal happened October 30, with closing anticipated in early November. Details of this transaction will be shared on our fourth quarter 2020 earnings call. Residential business purpose loans remain an area where we keep investing. Often called fix and flip, these loans give our portfolio attractive, high-yielding assets of short duration. This market keeps growing, and it's well supported by a positive housing market along with repeat business purpose borrowers. Over the year, we purchased roughly $135 million of business purpose loans, finishing the quarter with about $210 million held on the balance sheet. The typical interest rate on this portfolio was 8.57%, and its weighted average loan-to-value ratio stood at 80%. As we move toward the end of the year, the position of our investment portfolio looks solid. Trends in the single-family housing market are favorable, and conditions in the securitization market remain robust. At the close of the quarter, we held $412 million in loans within our mortgage warehouse that could be securitized in the future, along with plenty of liquidity to seize opportunities and buy additional loan pools. On the liability side, we took actions during the year to lessen the impact of mark-to-market risk on our secured financing. Over the course of the year, recourse leverage has fallen substantially and currently equals 1.3x capital. We retain sufficient liquidity to pursue fresh investments. And through our call optimization strategy, we keep a close watch on outstanding securitizations to optimize our long-term debt structures. As of September 30, Chimera holds $5.8 billion of outstanding securitized debt across 16 separate deals, either callable now or callable through the end of 2021. I'll now hand the call to Rob to go over the financial results.

Rob Colligan

executive
#4

Appreciate that, Mohit, and hello everyone. I want to walk through Chimera's financial results for Q3. At the close of the third quarter, GAAP book value stood at $11.91. GAAP net income for Q3 came to $349 million, which works out to $1.32 per share. Turning to a core basis, net income for Q3 totaled $80 million, or $0.33 per share. Economic net interest income for Q3 reached $125 million. During Q3, average interest-earning assets delivered a yield of 6%. Our average cost of funds came in at 3.5%, giving us a net interest spread of 2.5%. Total leverage for Q3 was 3.7:1, and recourse leverage finished the quarter at 1.3:1. Q3 expenses, once you exclude servicing fees and transaction expenses, amounted to $17 million, consistent with the prior quarter. We remain diligent about watching liquidity, holding roughly $1 billion in cash and unencumbered assets as we seek new investments and financing options to bolster our portfolio and enhance investment returns. That wraps up our prepared comments, and now we'd like to take your questions.

Doug Harter

analyst
#5

Let's begin with something simple — could you simply predict for us how the election is going to turn out? Then, returning to Chimera, would you discuss those returns — what they look like for jumbo, for investment property, and for reperforming — and also roughly how much capital we're able to put to work for every dollar of loan purchased in each category?

Mohit Marria

executive
#6

Absolutely. Mohit here. I'll take that in reverse order. The biggest opportunity, in our view, remains in seasoned reperforming; thus far this year we've completed 5 securitizations; and we believe there's still plenty of supply headed our way from the GSEs, particularly given what has occurred this year regarding forbearances and deferments within the GSE portfolio. So our view is that plenty of supply is still coming, which will generate the biggest opportunity; and when it comes to securitization, as we said during our opening remarks, the securitization market is quite strong. You can obtain term financing — whether the securitization is rated or nonrated — covering as much as 80% of your capital stack, with yields playing in the mid-high 1s if rated and the mid-2s if nonrated. That means back-end equity returns will land in the high single digits on a cash basis; and using minimal leverage, you can push those into even double digits, 12% to 15%. Turning to jumbo, originations there are recovering too. The second quarter saw a lull tied to post COVID, and originations are somewhat reduced. Even so, returns there aren't as appealing as what seasoned reperforming offers, yet we do want participation in the new issue origination business, so we continue to view it as appealing. Returns will sit in the mid-single digits, though more leverage is on offer. Then, for agency-eligible investor loans and loans that don't always get delivered to the GSEs, our view is that a bigger opportunity exists there, along with a set of opportunities to acquire loans over the coming months. So in our view the returns there are comparable to the seasoned reperforming side. We're therefore fairly optimistic, and during Q3 we completed one securitization of each type.

Doug Harter

analyst
#7

Could you also discuss what the current depth of financing looks like for the subordinate bonds, and how comfortable you feel about your liquidity position if we encounter another patch of volatility surrounding those financing levels?

Mohit Marria

executive
#8

Absolutely. Even before COVID, that market's depth was not strong, and the number of counterparties we could choose from was narrow; we needed to confirm that those providing financing for those assets participated on both the underwriting side and the cash trading side, specifically to avoid price disruptions in the market like what we saw in Q1; that's the most important thing. Next, those financings never had a tenor based on a month-to-month arrangement. On our credit assets, the shortest financing ran roughly 3 months. And as you remember, in certain instances we had financings extending as long as 3 years. Given what happened in Q1, we are mitigating any — or as much as we can — the mark-to-market risk on those assets. For those credit-sensitive assets, we have secured a significant amount of non-mark-to-market or mark-to-market holiday financing. And regarding the last few securitizations we completed, we are currently holding the equity pieces in cash rather than placing them into recourse borrowings, simply because of some uncertainty surrounding COVID and the elections.

Bose George

analyst
#9

Really, when it comes to how much cash and liquidity you hold, what would you consider a sensible amount once you're more at ease putting more capital to work?

Mohit Marria

executive
#10

It's Mohit once more. Well, I'd say given a few of the uncertainties we just mentioned regarding how elections turn out and what unfolds with COVID, we feel fairly good about the liquidity we currently have, on both a cash and unencumbered basis. And we're also optimistic — as we always are — that greater volatility as we move toward year-end could open up chances to purchase certain assets. Since I'd say our liquidity is reasonably balanced, we do have some capacity to bring on assets at this point. And to echo the final part of what I said in my prepared remarks, we managed to pick up certain loans that went straight into a securitization quite fast; so given how robust the securitization market is for us, I'd say the overall cash requirement would be reduced.

Bose George

analyst
#11

All right. That's clear to me. Then during the prior quarter, you mentioned that should asset prices bounce back, book value might return to somewhere in the $13 to $14 band. Does that remain more or less a sensible assumption? Any fresh perspective on it.

Mohit Marria

executive
#12

Yeah. As shown by how book value came in for Q3, we remain aware that in our view the portfolio holds substantial upside; we were lucky enough to keep every credit asset we spent the last decade assembling. And our take is that what we're facing is a liquidity problem rather than a credit problem, which is evident in how our credit assets have performed overall; and more broadly across the market, worries about forbearance and deferments have dropped considerably from the peaks seen in May to the situation as it stands now.

Kenneth Lee

analyst
#13

I wanted to ask about the funding side — could you share your view on whether there's still room to push out financing maturities further?

Mohit Marria

executive
#14

Sure. I'd separate funding on the agency side from the credit side. Our agency fundings are still short. Between 1 month and 1 year, that curve is fairly flat. But if you're trying to optimize the portfolio on that side, you give up a great deal of optionality, so we'd rather keep it short for flexibility. And like I mentioned, we sold a few of our agency CMBS positions, recorded some gains, and those will be redeployed into credit-sensitive assets. When it comes to the credit portion of the financing book, yes, we'd rather have that longer. As Matt mentioned, we've put in place some long-term arrangements there, in certain cases going out as far as 5 years. And wherever that's available, we'll keep using it as needed, particularly to match off against the deals that we call and we lever.

Kenneth Lee

analyst
#15

Understood. And as a fast second question, I was hoping you might tell us your view on where funding costs are likely headed in the near term.

Mohit Marria

executive
#16

Much like what's happening with assets, where spreads have tightened considerably from the March wides, financing costs are tightening too. On the agency side, once again, I'd say they remain fairly sticky. And the Fed has shown — made clear what its plan is; and those costs sit at roughly 20 to 25 basis points across 1 month to 12 months. Over on the credit side, it depends on the credit profile; I mean those spreads have tightened, and I believe they'll keep tightening as the Street's overall use of financing has dropped; and I think there's a balance sheet opportunity there; but my expectation is that as we move into Q4 and Q1, financing costs in that area ought to tighten as well.

Steve Laws

analyst
#17

Just to build on what Bose asked. Could you perhaps provide a bit more detail — I believe it'll show up in the Q later, but could you discuss the current state of the asset marks and liability marks compared with year-end?

Rob Colligan

executive
#18

Yes. Of course, Stephen. I think if you look at the press release, one possible way to consider it, clearly, this quarter was quite strong when it comes to book value recovery. However, on a year-to-date basis, our marks haven't been fully retraced. So if you review our earnings statements covering the 9 months, we remain down roughly $172 million; the asset mix has shifted somewhat, but — that's a significant figure, and it can still be recovered and contribute to book value, moving us nearer to the book value figures that Mo mentioned earlier today.

Steve Laws

analyst
#19

Thanks. I appreciate the detail and for putting numbers behind it. Looking at the change in agency assets, it was down quarter over quarter, yet asset yield rose fairly substantially in response. Could you describe what you're observing, and also when exactly did that portfolio repositioning take place? And I believe leverage came down, so what does that mean for, say, the weighted average leverage during the quarter compared with where it stood at quarter end, when we consider the future earnings capacity of the balance sheet as of quarter end?

Mohit Marria

executive
#20

Mohit here. Regarding the agency CMBS portfolio, we devoted most of the past 6 years to buying those assets. That period wasn't what I'd call a dramatically different rate setting, but we held certain lower-yielding assets that were essentially phantom as well. We secured some NIM against the hedges we'd established. So the asset sales we executed, which we finished in Q3, produced a higher base case yield on the portion we kept. That, I believe, explains the shift. It isn't really about adding new assets; rather, it's about divesting the lower-yielding ones to improve that portfolio. I expect we'll keep watching how those assets are priced versus all protection built into these securities. So, with — as you're aware, we have no hedges in place, so it's likewise a solid method for us to control the duration of that portfolio since it's a longer-duration asset outright; thus, should rates stay where they are and price action remain quite strong with substantial demand from both the investor base and the Fed, we'd keep seizing that opportunity. On the broader leverage question and how to view it, clearly, we've brought leverage down over the course of the year, and we ended Q3 at roughly 1.3x. I believe we'll likely stay near those levels, probably until year-end. Then, once we're a year past COVID and the elections are behind us, we'll evaluate whether to raise it again and hold more assets — earning assets on the books. But given our dividend and our core earnings, we're currently out earning that, so we don't see a present need to deploy the cash.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#21

When you brought up the range of possibilities for credit investments, one category I believe you left out was non-QM loans. Therefore I wanted to ask whether you might be able to share your thoughts on what you're observing regarding the supply of freshly originated non-QM, and whether that category is something you folks are considering bringing into the portfolio.

Mohit Marria

executive
#22

Certainly. Yes, that category is one we devoted considerable time to examining across the past 18 months. Fortunately, we sidestepped a few of the stumbles that space went through in Q1 and Q2. Because of those stumbles, I believe origination volumes have declined rather sharply, with many originators essentially shutting down that aspect of what was on offer — the financing had disappeared, warehouse lines had disappeared, and the securitization market had disappeared. Once that largely reversed, many of the warehouse lines have been cleaned up. Originations are recovering as our warehouse line availability for those products. So once more, we will assess those against the other loans we concentrate on, chiefly seasoned reperforming, agency-eligible investor loans, and observe how equity piece returns stack up against the non-QM space. I mean we've held plenty of thorough conversations across 18 months with various originators and prospective partners to source that collateral. But as I mentioned, it's simply in connection with other opportunities we have available.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#23

All right. Excellent. And clearly, during the third quarter, you posted a robust figure for book value. Could you share your observations regarding credit spreads up to this point in Q4 and the way that has affected book value on a quarter-to-date basis?

Mohit Marria

executive
#24

Certainly. From my perspective, credit spreads have stayed flat between September 30 and November 1. Given the ambiguity surrounding the election, that likely held spreads from moving much. Once we receive greater clarity over the next days and weeks regarding that, my expectation is spreads will gradually tighten; in our view, the ready space has not received the same backing as the other spread products have gotten from the Fed. Consequently, I believe it continues to provide, on a relative basis, greater returns. And in the near term, that ought to keep gradually pushing spreads tighter, which benefits our assets along with book value.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#25

I have three items, honestly. First, what's the current fully diluted share count, if we assume any dilutive securities under $10, roughly? You completed quite a bit of financing during a tough stretch, but what's the share — the fully diluted share count we ought to be focusing on? That's my first question.

Rob Colligan

executive
#26

Of course. Fully diluted comes to 265 million.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#27

I couldn't catch that. Was it 265 million, or 365 million?

Rob Colligan

executive
#28

It's 265 million.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#29

Understood. Alright. Regarding that 1.3 figure for recourse leverage, I believe you touched on this a moment ago, but is that the level where you feel comfortable, and you might raise it at some point next year depending on how things play out? Or would you rather hold it right there?

Mohit Marria

executive
#30

No, I'd say we feel fine with that as we move toward year-end. And assuming things generally settle down, we'd aim to increase it in 2021.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#31

What's your take on that $1 billion in cash? What's the smallest amount of cash required to operate the business? And how much extra cash do you have available to put to work in a way that might generate some sort of spread? The thing I'm attempting to determine is whether the earnings you're currently delivering sit under normalized earnings, since some of your cash is sitting idle.

Matt Lambiase

executive
#32

Well, what I'd say is that, being a levered company, our aim is always to hold as little cash as possible. Really, the story here is underlevered assets sitting on the balance sheet; and my sense is that, in looking at the business today, we've got ample liquidity. As Mo mentioned, there's an election happening today, and my guess is it could stretch on for another 2 days or perhaps even more. That creates some uncertainty. My sense is we're being careful about year-end; and given everything we've gone through this year, it strikes me as sensible for the company to conserve a portion of its cash and maintain lower gearing as we head toward year-end; then, once things settle down, we can raise leverage. My sense is we're simply striving to be prudent in light of the volatility we've witnessed in the markets. And it strikes me as sensible, at least across roughly the next 2 months, to hold a far more conservative stance.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#33

I’m with you. That logic holds up. You brought up what the election results might look like over the coming days. Is there any leaning we have when it comes to — obviously this is subjective, but when it comes to our business? Does the outcome matter to us? To me, what stands out most from the election results so far is that the left has been rejected.

Matt Lambiase

executive
#34

Right. In my view, the single best development — well, to begin with, the housing market is incredibly strong, and I believe that benefits our portfolio as well as the credit quality of that portfolio. So that’s excellent. My sense is that won’t shift because of the election results; and no matter how the presidential election turns out, it appears the Senate will be extremely tight, possibly remaining Republican, and I’d say a divided government is likely not a negative for various markets.

Leon Cooperman

analyst
#35

If you want my honest opinion, I would proceed with real caution. What I mean is, eventually someone will wake up and ask who foots the bill once the celebration ends. Reaching $21 trillion in national debt from nothing required 244 years, and it keeps climbing at 15%, 20% annually. That cannot keep going. At some point somebody has to wake up, so I would be careful. Still, best of luck to you all.

Matt Lambiase

executive
#36

Thank you, then, for joining us on this third quarter 2020 earnings call for Chimera Investment Corp., and we are eager to talk with you again early next year.

Operator

operator
#37

We appreciate everyone joining us for this conference call today. At this point you're welcome to hang up your lines, and we hope the rest of your day is wonderful.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.