Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 10, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Victor Falvo
executiveThanks, Laurie. I appreciate all of you joining us for Chimera’s Q4 earnings conference call. Before we get started, I want to go over the Safe Harbor statements. On this call, we’ll be making forward-looking statements, which are predictions, projections, or other statements about future events.
Mohit Marria
executiveAppreciate that, Vic. Morning everyone, and thanks for joining Chimera Investment Corporation's fourth quarter 2020 earnings call. Joining me are Choudhary Yarlagadda, our President and Chief Operating Officer; Rob Colligan, our Chief Financial Officer; and Vic Falvo, who leads our Capital Markets. Rob will walk through the financial results after my remarks, and then we'll take your questions. Before we start, you'll recall that in November we shared news that Matt Lambiase is retiring. Matt started Chimera back in 2007 and has led the company since day one. During his tenure, Chimera expanded into a $3.8 billion mortgage REIT and returned over $5.2 billion in dividends to shareholders. Matt was a wonderful leader, friend and mentor to all of us here. We'd like to express our gratitude to him, and everyone here sends Matt our wishes for great success going forward. During this quarter, Chimera kept progressing along its trajectory of book value recovery. Over the course of the year, we put in diligent effort on the liabilities portion of our balance sheet so as to boost liquidity and reinforce our cash position. Thanks to those steps, we were able to keep our credit portfolio with its high yields and capitalize on the rise in asset prices that began in the latter half of 2020. Chimera's book value rose almost 4% during Q4 and more than 16% from mid-year; that gain in book value, together with the dividend policy, produced a 6% economic return in the fourth quarter and a 22% economic return from June 30, 2020. Housing markets around the country remain strong. The Federal Reserve has given substantial support to agency mortgage-backed securities by buying them in the open market for its own portfolio. Those purchases by the Fed have made it easier for lenders to give homeowners low mortgage rates on new home purchases and have also reduced the cost of owning a home for people who want to refinance. According to a recent report from the National Association of Realtors, existing-home contract closings rose in December to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 6.76 million units — the fastest level since late 2006. With housing supply tight, buyer demand robust, and mortgage rates sitting at historic lows, all of these point toward sustained strength in housing and residential mortgage credit.
Rob Colligan
executiveThanks, Mohit. Next I'll walk through Chimera's financial highlights for Q4 and the full year 2020. GAAP book value per share finished the fourth quarter at $12.36, and our economic return on GAAP book value came to 6%, calculated from the quarterly book value change plus the Q4 dividend paid on each common share. GAAP net income for Q4 totaled $129 million, or $0.49 per share, and for the full year it was $15 million, or $0.07; on a core basis, Q4 net income reached $72 million, or $0.29 per share, while the full year came in at $334 million, or $1.46 per share. Economic net interest income was $117 million in the fourth quarter and $513 million across the full year. During Q4, the yield on average interest earning assets stood at 5.9%. Average cost of funds came to 3.6%, producing a net interest spread of 2.3%. Total leverage was 3.6:1 in the fourth quarter, and recourse leverage closed the quarter at 1.2:1. In Q4, economic net interest return on equity was 12.5%, and GAAP return on average equity was 15.8%. Fourth-quarter expenses, excluding servicing fees and transaction expenses, totaled $18 million, a modest increase over the prior quarter. That wraps up our remarks, and we'll now take questions.
Analyst
analystHey guys, Mike here sitting in for Bose. So first off, I wanted to ask if you could maybe walk us through where you see the strongest opportunities for putting capital to work — among RPLs, jumbo investment property? On last quarter's call you brought up season RPLs — does that remain the top choice?
Mohit Marria
executiveHey Mike, Mohit here. Thanks for being with us. Yes, I mean seasonal re-performing has been the company's core strategy since 2014; it still delivers tremendous value in the loan upside from just mitigated losses, given the strong housing fundamentals combined with how strong the new securitization market is and where you're able to achieve term financing. So we think, we still think the back end pieces that you would retain offer tremendous value.
Analyst
analystUnderstood. Then I believe you said during the previous quarter that RPL cash yield remains in the high single digits; so looking at a few of the more recent RPL sales, perhaps, it seems as though all of them are priced above par. So I was simply curious whether you could perhaps take me through the calculation that arrives at that high single digit yield, assuming that is still true?
Mohit Marria
executiveYeah, what I mean is that yields on the majority of assets have tightened, as you just said and hinted at regarding the GSE sales that happened in Q4. Spreads have tightened fairly substantially, and most loan packages in the RPL space are trading at par or above it, yet simultaneously on the new issue side spreads have tightened fairly substantially too. On the rated side, you could affect a securitization at the AAA level at 60 basis points. So your back end returns, and that probably accounts for roughly 70% of the capital structure, and when you move down to the investment grade stack, which probably gets you to an advance rate of 85%, you're looking at an all-in blended execution around mid high 100s to swaps on that basis. So as I said, your back end returns won't be high single digits anymore. Probably would be mid-high single digits, as if as all other spread products have tightened, but with some leverage you can produce double digit returns on that retained piece.
Analyst
analystGreat; that helps. Now regarding the business purpose loans, could you perhaps walk through some of the economics involved and the math around asset yield and ROE? I'm just assuming that if you aren't originating those loans again, sale margins must be pretty high at the moment, right?
Mohit Marria
executiveYes. So regarding the business purpose loan fund — I mean, our portfolio, and we've been focused on growing that portfolio; it sits at $200 plus million now given the short duration nature. I mean, we see a lot of paydowns each month, but the gross coupon on originations is probably just under %, and with servicing fees and asset management fees, you're probably looking at a net coupon of a little over 6%, with price execution right around par or slightly above par.
Analyst
analystGreat. That's useful, and then just one more thing about the buyback. You raised the authorization by 250. Could you remind me what the previous authorization was?
Mohit Marria
executiveSure, we had 150 before.
Analyst
analystUnderstood; and what amount is available at present?
Mohit Marria
executiveWell, of the 228 million, 22 million was used by us in the last year.
Analyst
analystAll right, that's great. I really appreciate you taking my questions — thank you very much.
Mohit Marria
executiveThank you, Mike.
Doug Harter
analystThanks. Mohit or Rob, could you guys walk us through what your cost of financing was on the securitizations you completed during the quarter? And can you compare that with the cost of the financing that got replaced, just so we can get a sense of the change?
Mohit Marria
executiveSure. Hey Dough, this is Mohit again. So on the securitization side, we completed four securitizations; the 2020-R6 was not a re-lever. Those were simply loans we had acquired at the end of September and placed directly into a securitization in early November, and the cost of funding there on a term basis, as we mentioned, came to roughly 2.19%. The re-lever we completed was CIM 2017 to 8; through that re-lever we achieved cost savings of about 100 basis points. As I mentioned, we issued debt at approximately 2.22% with an 85% — 86% advance rate. So before the re-lever, it stood at over 3.2 or 3.25, roughly.
Doug Harter
analystUnderstood. As for those deals you mentioned that can be called now or in ‘21, if securitization markets more or less hold steady, would you anticipate a similar level of savings?
Mohit Marria
executiveLet me share a few figures with you. Out of the 16 deals that have turned callable, that comes to about $6 billion or $7 billion of UPB, with roughly $4.8 billion of current sec debt tied to it. The yield on that debt right now sits at 4.27%, and as I said before, in the new issue market at present we believe you could place non-rated securitizations at somewhere in the 2 to 2.5 range, depending on the collateral profile and the advance rates you're prepared to accept. So that figure is actually going to come in larger than what we managed on the 2017 to 8 re-lever.
Doug Harter
analystThat helps. You also said that when opportunities come up, you're able to add leverage. Could you help us size that, and explain how you — or how we — should think about that opportunity?
Mohit Marria
executiveYes. If you look at what the company is mainly focused on, the season re-performing space, the GSE paused during the pandemic last year and then sped up sales in the second half of the year; in our view they remain behind schedule, and the portfolio has expanded because of the pandemic. So on the season re-performing side, they still have more than 100 billion of loans that the GSEs will need to dispose of, probably $18 billion to $22 billion yearly. So that remains a primary source of collateral for us. There are also some funds that will likely liquidate some assets, and some banks, given where pricing has gone, as we just alluded to. Much of that space now sits at par or in some cases above par. So again there's a robust pipeline of loans that will come available for sale today or over the course of 2021, and given the strength of the new issue market and the lack of legacy assets available, we think spreads there will stay at these levels, which are almost approaching the all-time tights from an issue standpoint. So the term fancy markets are pretty strong. Yields have come in on the underlying loans, but on a structural leverage basis combined with some limited recourse leverage, you can still produce double digit returns.
Rob Colligan
executiveYeah. Hey Dough, it's Rob. Yeah, just to add on that. If you look back 12 months, much of our thesis or plan for last year involved resecuritizing to bring down funding costs, and obviously the COVID-19 pandemic and other factors put a lot of things on hold for many companies, but heading into this year we have more deals to re-lever, and the securitization market is very liquid and the cost is low. So I'd say we're fairly optimistic about 2021.
Doug Harter
analystGreat. Thank you.
Eric Hagen
analystHey, good morning. I've got a couple of questions. Could you discuss how you're hedging the CMBS portfolio at present, plus any adjustments or additions made since year end, and perhaps how you view that as a liquidity source compared with agency pass-throughs? Then, regarding the portfolio of callable securitized debt, could you outline some of the factors behind the decision to call? And perhaps more importantly, as you finish incremental deals, could you speak to your appetite for levering the retained piece? Thanks.
Mohit Marria
executiveHey Eric. I'll begin with the agency CMBS question. By the fourth quarter, that book still carried no hedges, and nothing changed on that front during Q1, even after the 10-year sold off 25 basis points in the market. When you consider the weighted average coupon for our agency CMBS portfolio, it exceeds 4%. And with the extent of the market's rally between 2019 and 2020, that coupon combined with the duration on those assets would suggest an implied price in the mid-to-high teens — roughly a $116 to $117 price. And because of the prepayment protection these assets show, with a hard prepayment penalty lasting 10 years in most cases, prices tend to be somewhat artificially capped near that 110 to 112 range, varying by the individual loan you examine. Even with the market sell-offs we saw in Q4, the value of our agency CMBS portfolio held steady, which sort of led to the spread tightening that most other spread products also experienced; I think a similar trend is sort of showing up in Q1 so far. So, yes; we currently have no hedges in place. Given the duration sensitivity of the portfolio, we're watching what happens with the 10 year, but we believe there's still some spread tightening that could happen within that product. So we don't think the cost of hedging is needed right now. Turning to the second part of your question about the re-lever strategy: as I said, we carry $4.8 billion in debt at a weighted average cost of 4.27%. Where we might issue replacement debt largely shapes the timing and cadence of calling those deals, depending on market conditions, naturally. Beyond that, that $4.8 billion of debt against the $7 billion of collateral behind it works out to an advance rate of roughly 68% on UPB. Subject to market conditions and how that collateral performs, along with lowering our cost of debt, we'll also be in a position to extract equity, since we believe we can likely achieve effective advance rates of 80% to 85% on new securitizations, which would generate additional capital to put toward new attractive investment opportunities.
Eric Hagen
analystOkay, my apologies — please continue.
Mohit Marria
executiveWhat I meant to say is that it will serve as both a reduction in term financing costs and a possible equity takeout.
Eric Hagen
analystUnderstood. I was wondering whether you might share some views or guidance on your willingness to add leverage to the retained portion as you finish those transactions during this year?
Mohit Marria
executiveWell, I think given that our leverage sits at 1.2 times on a recourse basis, together with the sizable cash position we hold and the substantial unencumbered asset position we have, we feel fairly at ease financing the back end pieces, but in contrast to the period before the pandemic, we are pursuing strategies that would provide either non-mark-to-market or limited mark-to-market treatment on those financings going forward; we had always concentrated on keeping the balance sheet on a mark to market basis, yet beyond having committed balance sheet we also aim to concentrate on ensuring we could finance these on a limited mark-to-market basis or, as I said, a non-mark-to-market basis.
Eric Hagen
analystNow that the market has tightened up and come in, do you see any willingness or capacity to pay down that line you obtained from those areas last year and basically refinance it into cheaper non-mark-to-market term funding for the portions you retained?
Mohit Marria
executiveYes. I mean, I think that's one more tool—like our emphasis, as it was through most of 2020, stays on the liability side, both with the securitizations we can call and the savings on their cost, together with our repo borrowings. I mean, if you look back to December of '19, financing cost on our credit portfolio stood at 3.19%, and by the end of Q4 2020 the cost of borrowing sits at 5%. Now clearly during a crisis borrowing money was pricey, but we borrowed for a short period and we have the ability to refinance that; so along with the securitizations, even our repo borrowings carry meaningful upside for potential earnings for the company in 2021.
Eric Hagen
analystUnderstood. Excellent. Many thanks for the remarks.
Mohit Marria
executiveThank you, Eric.
Trevor Cranston
analystHey, thanks. Good morning. So first question, Rob — I was hoping you might walk us through what mainly drove the $0.04 decline in core EPS between last quarter and this quarter. Then the second question: given where earnings stand and the compression we've seen on new investment spreads, could you guys share some general thinking on how you're approaching the dividend as we head into 2021? Thanks.
Rob Colligan
executiveSure, Trevor. Thanks for the question. From last quarter to this one, we've had some portfolio paydown, but one of the bigger drivers — and we may have mentioned this on last quarter's earnings call — on the CMBS side, we had a number of prepayments in that portfolio where we received penalties; those have lockouts and some yield maintenance provisions, so if they pay off early, we do get some prepayment penalties. So we had a little bit higher than normal — if you looked at the yields on CMBS in particular last quarter, they were almost abnormally high versus this quarter; it got back to a normal sledding. I don't think we had very many, if any, paydowns. So I'd say last quarter was a little bit higher in that regard versus this quarter, and then going forward, I think we're looking at it, but obviously we have opportunities to reduce some of our liability costs; on spread compression, maybe Mohit can — .
Mohit Marria
executiveAbsolutely. Regarding the second part of your question—how we’re thinking about the dividend in light of the compression and the yield experience—the positive, as we mentioned in our opening remarks, is that we hold a pool of assets through which we can optimize the financing. As I noted, we have $4.8 billion of sect debt at a current basis of 4.27%, so to support and sustain our dividend, that cost base will decline by more than 200 basis points; on $4.8 billion, saving 200 basis points going forward will enhance the company’s earnings power for 2021 and beyond. And as I just mentioned on the recourse repo side with our credit borrowings, our cost of funds stands at 5.03%, and given how flush that market is with cash, that represents another avenue for lowering our cost and boosting earnings in 2021 and beyond.
Trevor Cranston
analystAll right, that helps. And looking back, your guys' portfolio has historically paid off pretty slowly. I was curious whether you could give us some detail on how prepayment speeds have moved over the past several months and what you expect for that looking ahead? Thanks.
Mohit Marria
executiveYeah. What I'd say is the unique thing about our portfolio is this: if you look at our credit portfolio, which is our biggest position, prepayments stayed flat all through the pandemic. If you looked at January prepayments, they were roughly 9 to 10 CPR, and moving ahead to January 2021, speeds are still consistent at about that 9 to 10 CPR basis. These borrowers have been in the money, but because of the credit impairment nature of their credit standings, it simply hasn't moved, and we don't anticipate that changing in 2021 either.
Trevor Cranston
analystAll right. That's great. I appreciate the remarks. Thanks.
Mohit Marria
executiveThanks to everyone for being with us on our Q4 earnings call, and we're looking forward to talking with you on our Q1 earnings call later this May. Thank you.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it — that brings the Chimera Investment Corporation Q4 2020 Earnings Conference Call to a close. You’re free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.