Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 4, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Victor Falvo
executiveBernie, thanks, and I appreciate all of you joining us for Chimera's earnings call covering the second quarter. Prior to getting started, let me go over the Safe Harbor statements. On this call, we'll be offering forward-looking statements, meaning predictions, projections, or other statements regarding future events. Such statements rest on current expectations and assumptions that carry risks and uncertainties, which are described in the Risk Factors section of our latest annual and quarterly SEC filings. Actual events and results could differ materially from those forward-looking statements; we urge you to review the forward-looking statement disclaimer included in our earnings release as well as our quarterly and annual filings. Also, on today's call, we might address non-GAAP financial measures. For reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures, please consult our SEC filings and earnings supplement. In addition, what's said on this conference call may include time sensitive information that holds true only as of the date of this earnings call. We do not undertake and specifically disclaim any obligation to update or revise this information. Now I'll hand the conference over to our CEO and Chief Investment Officer, Mohit Marria.
Mohit Marria
executiveThank you, Vec. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to Chimera Investment Corporation's second quarter 2021 earnings call. With me today are Choudhary Yarlagadda, our President and Chief Operating Officer; Subra Viswanathan, our new Chief Financial Officer; Kelley Kortman, our Chief Accounting Officer; and Vic Falvo, who heads our Capital Markets. Once I finish my comments, Kelly will go over the financial results, and after that we'll open the line for your questions. During this quarter, we kept moving forward considerably in optimizing how our liabilities are structured. Across the first six months of 2021, we completed refinancings on 12 legacy securitizations, which back more than $5.6 billion in loans. These deals brought down our total cost of debt by roughly 245 basis points, and we anticipate that this reduction in expense will keep delivering value to our shareholders going forward. Housing remains among the strongest pieces of the U.S. economic rebound. The National Association of Realtors most recently put existing home sales at 5.9 million annual units, with a median sale price above $363,000, which is an increase of over 23% versus a year earlier. Appetite for single family homes is still robust, even as the supply of homes for sale stays close to historic lows. Based on June data and analytics from Black Knight, the national delinquency rate reached its lowest point since the pandemic began, and it now sits beneath the average seen before the great recession. The 30 plus day delinquency rate came in at 4.4% of outstanding loans, a decline of 42% year over year. Solid appetite for existing homes, home prices, and reduced delinquency rates give strong fundamental backing to Chimera's large portfolio of seasoned low loan balance mortgages. Yields on government bonds moved in both directions during the second quarter. Over that stretch, the 10 year treasury note yield dropped by 27 basis points, while the two year treasury yield climbed by 9 basis points. Rates on money market instruments, overnight repo included, are still close to zero. Demand from investors for higher yielding and fixed income products remained strong, and credit product spreads kept tightening. As a result, the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Corporate High Yield Index finished the quarter at 3.75%, its lowest yield on record. Narrower credit spreads, combined with low absolute interest rates, have opened up appealing market opportunities for us to refinance existing securitized debt and secured financing at much lower costs. As part of our ongoing call optimization strategy, during this quarter we called and refinanced fixed SIM legacy deals representing over 1.5 billion of loans. The new securitization optimized our liabilities successfully by extracting capital and reducing cost of debt. Our April deals CIM 2021-R3 nr 3, taken together, totaled 813 million of securitized debt backed by 977 million of loans. The combined advance rate came to 83%, which let us extract 125 million of capital by cutting our cost of debt on these loans by 200 basis points to 2.12%. Chimera kept 164 million in subordinate and IO securities as investments from those transactions. Fresh securitizations carry a call schedule. These R3 financings become callable starting in April 2024. Meanwhile, the NR 3 financings turn callable starting in April of 2022. During June, we issued 546 million of CIM 2021-R4. That transaction was made up of 464 million in securitized debt, which works out to an 85% advance rate and a 1.97% debt cost on those loans. The R4 unlocked 98 million of capital while delivering roughly 180 basis points in cost savings. Chimera held onto 82 million in subordinate and IO securities as investments. The R4 financing has a call schedule starting in June 2024. You can find more specifics on page eight of our earnings supplement, which should help as you work through this quarter's securitization analysis. For Chimera, securitizations have long served as a cost effective and efficient financing vehicle; during the first half of 2021, Chimera's three securitization transactions let us take capital, shrink the size, and bring down the cost of our outstanding credit financing. Alongside this year's three securitizations, we've also refinanced a number of our outstanding secured credit facilities. We achieved meaningful improvements in the average cost of our secured financing for residential credit assets, which came in at 3.5% in the second quarter, down from 4.9% at year end. When it comes to our long term investment decisions, we've always been extremely prudent and diligent. Our agency CMBS portfolio is built with explicit prepay protection. With interest rates having fallen and stayed near historic lows, we've been active in managing our agency CMBS to figure out the best path among long term hold, gain on sale, securitization, or reaping benefits through explicit prepay penalties. This quarter, by combining prepaid penalties received from our Ginnie Mae project loans with early payoffs of non-agency credit, we generated onetime non-recurring income of 38 million. The prepaid penalties we received this year prove the concept behind many of the positive convexity attributes we've regularly discussed over the years. Now, midway through 2021, I believe we've made a meaningful impact on our balance sheet. We have re-securitized debt backing 5.6 billion loans through seven separate securitizations, lowered our cost of securitized debt by over 245 basis points, reduced the cost of our repo credit facilities by 140 basis points since year end, retired high cost debt and warrants incurred during the pandemic, issued three jumbo prime securitizations totaling 1.2 billion, purchased more than 200 million of high yielding fixed and flip loans, and raised our quarterly dividend by 10% to $0.33. Securitizing loans locks in stable long term financing for our loan portfolio. We have successfully refinanced many of our outstanding legacy deals, and we have an additional five deals with 1 billion of unpaid principal balance that will become callable over the next six months. Looking ahead, we continue to seek opportunities to further improve our liability structure. And as usual, keep going as a long-term investor who is patient, concentrating on investments that give our shareholders steady book value along with a dividend that is both sustainable and appealing on a risk-adjusted basis. At this point I'll hand the call to Kelly so she can cover our financial results for the period.
Kelley Kortman
executiveThanks, Mohit. Now I'll walk through Chimera's financial results for Q2 2021. At the close of the second quarter, GAAP book value stood at $11.45 per common share. Our GAAP net income for that quarter came to 145 million, equal to $0.60 per share on a fully diluted basis. Core earnings during Q2 were 130 million, or $0.54 per share. Economic net interest income in the second quarter reached 173 million. For Q2, the yield on average interest earning assets came in at 7%, and our average cost of funds was 2.6%, which left us with a net interest rate spread of 4.4%. Total leverage during Q2 was 3.321, and recourse leverage closed the quarter at 1.021. Economic net interest return on equity for the quarter was 19%, while our GAAP return on average equity came in at 18%. Q2 expenses, once servicing fees and transaction expenses are excluded, totaled 15 million, a decline of roughly 3 million versus last quarter. That wraps up our remarks, and now we'll take questions on the call.
Doug Harter
analystThank you. Mohit, you brought up that $38 million figure tied to prepays. In your deck, the $21 million number comes up. Could you explain what makes up the remaining $17 million you were pointing to?
Mohit Marria
executiveOf course. That $38 million breaks down this way: $21 million comes from agency CMBS securities that got recalled, and those carry explicit prepayment penalties. Beyond that, a number of non-agency legacy deals were called — not by us, but by other holders of color call rates — and that generated another $14 million to $15 million in penalties we got, or rather, I should call it accretion rather than penalties, on the non-agency side. Then there were certain IOs we hold on Ginnie Mae project deals issued by third parties, which accounted for the remaining $2 million to $3 million we received.
Doug Harter
analystDo you happen to have available, roughly, what sort of gain that produced, and how it compared with earlier quarters?
Mohit Marria
executiveWell, it wasn't like that—during previous quarters it was considerably quieter; nothing on this scale has ever happened for us before. And as I mentioned, those transactions were acquired extremely early, back in 2009 and 2010, at an exceptionally steep markdown, so the figure was never significant. If it had been, we'd have highlighted it during earlier calls.
Doug Harter
analystGreat. Turning now to the fresh investments. Which sectors look most appealing at present, and what sort of yields are you achieving?
Mohit Marria
executiveOur attention remains fixed on business purpose loans. In our view, this is a highly appealing short duration asset yielding levered returns in the mid teens. As noted in the opening remarks, we've kept growing that year-to-date; we've managed to acquire more than 200 million. We keep widening our parties regarding where we pick that up, yet it remains a major area of concentration for us. Furthermore, the season three performance base as demonstrated by the real leverage achieved from our current deals; so a spot where one might enhance equity financial holdings to a fairly solid level of returns since the loans base has become crowded, with some newcomers entering who are quite aggressive. Yet, as I've stated on multiple calls previously, a considerable volume of loan sales still needs to happen from the GSCs and other banks, which will generate opportunities down the road. I mean, we've been incredibly active; we've completed seven legacy season prime securitizations. We've finished three jumbo securitizations and have been placing bids on loans without success. Still, once more, we're hopeful that things will come our way and we'll manage to acquire investments later on. No need for any hasty moves exists, thanks to the liquidity and the earnings generated by our present call strategy.
Doug Harter
analystThat's useful, thanks.
Eric Hagen
analystThank you, and good morning. What I'd like to hear is your view regarding how the portfolio is affected once the foreclosure moratorium lapses, plus what the general strategy would be for granting further modifications to seasoned real performing borrowers in connection with the pandemic, and also what share of the portfolio remained in a forbearance tied to COVID.
Mohit Marria
executiveBroadly speaking, the delinquency pipeline within our seasoned re-performing portfolio showed no real material shift from before the pandemic to afterward. Roughly 9% of our pipeline was 60 plus delinquent. It possibly crept up to somewhere near 10%. At this point it has gone back to approximately 9% on an aggregate basis, consistent with that earlier context. Regarding our intentions for extensions or other servicing-related strategies, since every one of these loans sits in trust, servicing is not something we control under our governing docs and the PPM for the deals we issue. The participants are required to adhere to a loss mitigation matrix. They also must apply best practices independently. Consequently, on a go forward basis we have limited control over how these deals are serviced.
Eric Hagen
analystIf nothing else changes, when the foreclosure moratorium ends, should investors view that as a modest positive for the yield limit portfolio? Or is it really more of a neutral event?
Mohit Marria
executiveTo be honest, we didn't experience much disruption to cash flow. If you consider how the portfolio is composed, our mortgage loan's average balance sits below 100,000. The typical mortgage payment is a bit more than $800 per month. So in terms of cash flow, the pandemic didn't really change things much for us; but on the whole, as noted during the opening remarks, delinquencies across the mortgage universe have declined, and the moratorium ought to be a positive for cash flow, again because of the strong housing appreciation seen year-over-year combined with mortgage rates that remain low. So anyone facing difficulties could potentially refinance or reset their rates lower, which would reduce their payments.
Eric Hagen
analystUnderstood. Then, just a quick administrative point regarding the credit portfolio. At this stage, what is the LTV within that portfolio — specifically the loans held for investment, naturally?
Mohit Marria
executiveRegarding loans held for investment, that LTV will likely land around the mid 80s. However, that figure dates back to when we originally acquired those loans. After we securitize them, the BPOs will be refreshed, and given the robust housing HPA, that figure should decline further.
Eric Hagen
analystUnderstood. Thanks a lot.
Analyst
analystHi, everybody, Mike here covering for Bose. Regarding today's funding costs, given what you shared, the 2.6% — I'm curious where you expect that to head in the near term, perhaps the second half of 21, and how that ties into what you're projecting for run rate core earnings.
Mohit Marria
executiveSure. On the securitized debt side, financing costs have dropped pretty substantially, and the same goes for our recourse borrowing, thanks to the low rate environment and dealers' willingness to fund those assets. On the recourse side, I honestly don't see a lot of additional room for improvement, considering where spreads currently sit. That said, it hinges on how much cash is floating around the system, and right now there's plenty of it. As for securitized debt, we've still got five deals that can be called before the year wraps up, adding up to $1 billion of UPV, and the supplement's final page lays out which deals are callable along with the secured debt balance still outstanding there. So I believe that could continue to push earnings in the back half of the year. And if you compare where that debt was issued versus where we've managed to close some deals, you could see a reduction north of 100 basis points in financing cost on those deals.
Analyst
analystQuestioner: Excellent. That's useful insight, and then only one additional item from my side. What is the state of book value at the close of the quarter?
Mohit Marria
executiveWell, book value since — regarding the market valid spreads, those have remained quite sticky. Therefore, I would describe it as unchanged from the point at which we finished June 30.
Analyst
analystGreat. Thanks for taking the questions.
Trevor Cranston
analystThanks, good morning. About the money you folks received from legacy bonds getting called during this quarter — I was wondering whether there's any specific reason you'd cite for why certain of those deals began being called in this quarter specifically; and whether it's something that happened broadly among counterparties, or whether perhaps a single counterparty in the market or something is calling some of their legacy deals. Thanks.
Mohit Marria
executiveHey good morning, Trevor. When it comes to who's calling the deals, I'm not really sure who owns the call rights on these transactions. The way this worked was that deals got called not just within shells but also among various issuers on the legacy side. Since the new issue market has performed so well, and given the strength in securitization markets too, now is a favorable moment to call deals and bring out new debt—particularly because, on top of conditions in the new issue market, loan pricing is likewise supportive of deals being called. Given that, it doesn't shock me that this kind of thing has been going on since 2008. In 2019 there was a notable deceleration, and then 2020 brought a real drop-off thanks to COVID and the forbearance moratorium. Once those factors disappear — as touched on in that earlier question — we anticipate a rebound. Still, in recent quarters it hasn't amounted to much, and right now we're simply pointing to how much accretion we actually captured.
Trevor Cranston
analystOkay, that's clear. Now regarding your older non-agency book — can you give us a figure for how many of those deals you'd consider callable right now? Is it basically every one of them, or something less?
Mohit Marria
executiveI don't have that figure in front of me, though off the top of my head I'd guess it's likely above 80%. When you consider the legacy holdings, those securities came out during 2006, 2007, and 2008. A majority of those deals carry cleanup calls of either 10% or 20%; and since we're 13 years past the issuance of those securities, my expectation is many of them have paid down enough that they could be called today. Still, speaking about the portfolio as a whole, if you forced me to estimate, I'd say roughly 80% of our legacy assets are likely callable.
Trevor Cranston
analystthat really helps, thanks.
Steve Laws
analysthello, and good morning to you, Mohit.
Mohit Marria
executivemorning.
Steve Laws
analystThe portfolio's gotten somewhat smaller. I realize there's plenty of competition in the market, and we just talked with Trevor and some others about the call activity that looks like it's going to happen. Could you discuss other asset classes on your radar that appear to match the investment mandate you favor from a credit perspective? Do you truly believe you'll stick with the same approach, keeping a narrow focus, and simply concentrate on the identical category of assets you've pursued in the past?
Mohit Marria
executiveWell, from an investment perspective, we examine the entire range of options out there, including commercial; we've taken part in the season re-performing space. We've completed prime jumbo deals. We've completed agency eligible investor deals, and our attention is on expanding the business purpose loan portfolio; so it spans the entire range and as I mentioned, wherever we believe the best relative value opportunities are is where we'd like to put capital to work. This space has become crowded previously. And we've remained patient and continue to pick up small pools occasionally; but beyond the season reperforming loans we've completed, we've closed three jumbo deals. And we find that market, as noted on an earlier earnings call, is one that's intriguing because sometimes, there's a strong capacity to securitize and other times it widens out in a vacuum and makes for a difficult environment in which to issue those securities. But given how we've structured the business. I believe we want to participate; we want to be recurring, as demonstrated by the deals we've closed, and I understand that moving forward, still hopeful about acquiring loans and continuing to leverage securitization to fund those vehicles.
Steve Laws
analystGreat, thanks for those details. And going back to that earlier follow-up about LTVs — if you take the older vintage loans, the reperforming ones, and look at mark-to-market LTVs based on home price appreciation, I know you've run that math, so where does that number land with home prices where they are now?
Mohit Marria
executiveWe have, and I'll speak to that, though as I said before, we've called 12 legacy deals adding up to $5.6 billion, since those got relevered into new securitizations. Once we finished the new securitizations, we were able to refresh the BPOs. The prior securitizations, issued during 2016 and 2017, contained $5.6 billion in loans with LTVs in the mid-80s. Once we refresh the BPOs, the updated LTVs—reflecting amortization over those four years plus home price appreciation—came in at low 60s. So LTVs have fallen considerably, driven by both amortization and home price gains. Applying that same pattern to the remaining assets we owe, we'd anticipate a comparable downward movement in LTVs.
Steve Laws
analystThat's useful detail, thanks for providing it along with those figures. And then, only a single small clarification. I believe somebody said that costs decreased roughly 3 million from one quarter to the next. Does that stem from typical patterns tied to certain stock vesting in Q1, or did something else drive that quarter-over-quarter reduction?
Mohit Marria
executiveEvery bit of it was compensation linked, simply a reversal of that Q1 from stock vesting, and it didn't happen again in Q2.
Steve Laws
analystGreat, that's excellent. Many thanks. All the best.
Mohit Marria
executiveYou're welcome, and I appreciate all of you being here for this discussion. We're eager to talk with you again during our third-quarter earnings call.
Operator
operatorThat brings today's session to a close. We appreciate you taking part. You're free to log off whenever you like, and we hope the rest of your day is great.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.