Chimera Investment Corporation (CIM) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 3, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 29 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Victor Falvo

executive
#1

Thanks, Operator, and welcome, everybody, to Chimera's third quarter 2021 earnings conference call. Before we get started, I want to go over the Safe Harbor statements. On this call, we'll be making forward-looking statements, which are predictions, projections, or other statements regarding future events; these statements rest on current expectations and assumptions that carry risks and uncertainties, which are described in the Risk Factors section of our most recent annual and quarterly SEC filings. Actual events and results could differ materially from these forward-looking statements; we urge you to read the forward-looking statement disclaimer in our earnings release as well as our quarterly and annual filings. On the call today, we may also talk about non-GAAP financial measures. Please see our SEC filings and earnings supplement for a reconciliation to the most comparable GAAP measures. In addition, the content of this conference call may include time-sensitive information that is accurate only as of the date of this earnings call. We do not undertake and specifically disclaim any obligation to update or revise this information. I'll now turn the conference over to our CEO and Chief Investment Officer, Mohit Marria.

Mohit Marria

executive
#2

Thanks, Vic. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to Chimera Investment Corporation's third quarter 2021 earnings call. On the line with me today are Choudhary Yarlagadda, our President and Chief Operating Officer; Subra Viswanathan, our Chief Financial Officer; Kelly Kortman, our Chief Accounting Officer; and Vic Falvo, who heads our Capital Markets. Once I finish my comments, Subra will walk through the financial results, and after that we'll take your questions. During this quarter and across the year, we've kept strengthening our liability structure via securitization activity and enhancements to our repo facilities, on both rate and 10-year terms, and over the year we've re-securitized 13 legacy reperforming deals, representing approximately $6 billion. Securitization has let Chimera lock in long-term, non mark-to-market financing while growing our high yield risk retention assets through voluntary prepayments. The steps we've taken this year have significantly affected earnings and have lowered financing costs for our loan portfolio on non-agency RMBS by 140 basis points since year end. We anticipate that the numerous actions on our liability structure will benefit our earnings available for distribution across many quarters ahead. Interest rates rallied as the third quarter began, with the yield on 10-year treasuries first dropping by 25 basis points. That rally didn't last once market rhetoric intensified regarding worrying higher inflationary expectations. The Federal Reserve gave markets clarity on its potential ongoing quantitative easing, and despite intra-quarter volatility, the 10-year finished the quarter at a 1.49% yield, essentially the same level as in July when it started. The housing market kept moving toward higher home prices, with the Case-Shiller Index reporting national home price appreciation year-over-year of nearly 20%, the biggest gain in more than 30 years. We expect positive HPA to persist in the near term, given that mortgage rates remain low, housing inventory remains tight, and the economy keeps emerging from the global pandemic. Investor demand for spread product stayed strong during this quarter, with spreads on U.S. high grade and high yield indices sitting near all-time tights. These market conditions have produced positive benefits for Chimera's securitization business while also driving considerable price appreciation of our residential loan portfolio and an overall improvement in the company's book value. This quarter, we kept executing our call optimization strategy; in July, we called our CMLTI 2017-RP2 securitization, which had a 4% cost of debt. After that, we sponsored $450 million CIM 2021-R5 with reperforming loans, of which approximately $180 million came from the previously called deal and the remainder was provided from our loan warehouse. We sold $336 million in notes, representing a 95% advance rate, the highest adva — wait, that's not right; let me correct that: We sold 383 million senior securities, representing 85% of the capital structure with a 1.99 average cost of debt, approximately 200 basis points below the cost of the previous CMLTI financing; we retained for investment 67 million subordinate notes and interest-only securities from the deal. This securitization becomes callable by Chimera any time, beginning August 2024. Additionally, we sponsored a $435 million CIM 2021-INB1 transaction, which was our inaugural agency-eligible investor loan securitization for 2021. We put together and disposed of $408 million in securities, reflecting a 94% advance rate. This particular deal does not get consolidated onto our balance sheet; even so, Chimera put $27 million into subordinate and interest-only securities. Ratings for the investor loan deal came from Moody's and Kroll, and Chimera kept a 10% clean-up call. Although we've implemented numerous long-term enhancements to our liability structure, during this quarter we completed a substantial volume of new asset acquisitions for our investment portfolio. In this quarter, we acquired and settled $583 million of reperforming loans carrying a 3.63 weighted average coupon. Those loans average $241,000 in balance and have 15-year seasons. During early October, we securitized $354 million CIM 2021-R6 using reperforming loans sourced from our loan warehouse. Notes totaling $363 million were sold, which equates to a 95% advance rate — the greatest advance rate we've ever achieved on reperforming loans. For the R6 deal, the average cost of debt stands at 1.53%. Chimera kept an $18 million investment in subordinate notes and interest-only securities. Fitch and DBRS rated the R6 deal, which becomes callable starting September 2026. We keep growing the business purpose loan portion of our portfolio. During this quarter, we acquired $115 million in business purpose loans featuring an 8.4% gross coupon and a 6.7 coupon net of servicing and asset management. Such loans possess compelling fundamental investment characteristics and are extremely short duration assets. At present, we finance business purpose loans through our loan warehouse, generating an appealing net interest spread for the portfolio alongside quite low duration risk. The business purpose loan purchases made this quarter push our year-to-date figure beyond $318 million, and we keep pursuing further chances to acquire more business purpose loans and grow this line of business. In this quarter, we likewise committed to acquire $148 million of reperforming loans for our portfolio; such loans carry a 4.2 weighted average coupon and are 178 months seasoned. The expected average loan balance is approximately $175,000. These loans hadn't settled before the quarter closed; nonetheless, we anticipate settling them during the fourth quarter for upcoming securitizations. All told, during this quarter we committed to acquiring close to $850 million in loans, underscoring Chimera's ongoing capacity to obtain the mortgage assets we want across a wide range of economic and interest rate environments. Over the past seven years, we have built up and kept a sizable portfolio of seasoned reperforming loans. These assets keep generating elevated yields for the portfolio while showing consistent prepayment behavior through numerous economic and interest rate cycles. As we've mentioned previously, delinquency and default rates within our loan portfolio have exceeded our initial projections, and throughout the last 12 months, even with the pandemic, delinquencies have kept getting better. The homeowners behind our loans have shown resilience over time, with many gaining from the housing market's recent strength. For over 10 years now, securitizing mortgages has been a core piece of how we operate. Our main financing tool has been loan securitization, which we've used to help handle both liquidity risk and mark-to-market risk. Across the past 6 years, the majority of the deals we securitized included explicit call options, and that has let us capitalize on the favorable market conditions seen thus far in 2021. Given how strong our balance sheet stands today, we think we can keep pursuing fresh opportunities and expand our portfolio as the nation starts returning to normal and ultimately moves past the COVID pandemic. Our aim is to rank among the best asset and liability managers in the mortgage REIT sector. Our top goal is delivering shareholders a stable, sustainable dividend, all while handling our asset and liability risk as skillfully as we can so book value volatility is minimized going forward. At this point I'll hand the call to Subra so he can go over this quarter's financial results.

Subramaniam Viswanathan

executive
#3

Thanks, Mohit, and good morning, everybody. You might have noticed in the earnings release we put out this morning that starting with this period, we're dropping the non-GAAP metric core earnings and will instead disclose a new non-GAAP metric, earnings available for distribution. Even though the label is different, the way we calculate earnings available for distribution is exactly the same as how core earnings was calculated before. I'll now walk through Chimera's financial highlights for Q3 2021. GAAP book value finished the third quarter at $12.32 per share, and our economic return on book value came to 10.5%, calculated from the quarterly movement in GAAP book value plus the third quarter dividend per share. GAAP net income for Q3 was $313 million, or $1.30 per share. Measured on an earnings available for distribution basis, net income for the third quarter reached $102 million, or $0.42 per share. Income received on securities that were called accounted for $14 million, or $0.06 per share, of our earnings available for distribution. Economic net interest income for Q3 was $149 million; during the third quarter, the yield on average interest earning assets was 6.3%. Our average cost of funds came in at 2.4%, and our net interest spread was 3.9%. Total leverage for Q3 stood at 3.1 to 1, while recourse leverage finished the quarter at 1 to 1. For the quarter, our economic net interest return on equity was 16%, and our GAAP return on equity was 35%. Our expenses for Q3, excluding service fees and transaction expense, totaled $18 million, a slight increase from last quarter. That wraps up our remarks, and we'll now open the call for questions.

Mike Smith

executive
#4

Morning to you all. Mike Smith here, filling in for Bose. Nice work on such a solid quarter. To start, word has reached us that dollar pricing for RPL and NPL has been rather high, and that has dampened the appeal of securitization returns somewhat, so I wanted to ask whether you might share some insight on that, and then, in some cases, would it be wiser simply to call and sell instead of calling and securitizing?

Mohit Marria

executive
#5

Absolutely, hello Mike. Certainly, throughout Q3 2021 the pricing on loans moved, and you can see that in how well our book value did this quarter. However, what really decides whether a purchase works well is the credit selection you make along with the securitization you're able to complete. As we said before, although loan spread conditions grew tighter, we still managed to buy $850 million worth of loans during Q3. Our plan is to securitize those loans over the next few quarters, and we believe the advance rates we're able to get can still produce appealing returns on the retained portions — likely somewhere in the mid to high single digits on the back end, both on a cash basis and after adjusting for losses, and if you add a bit of leverage, reaching double digits becomes fairly straightforward. So even given where pricing now stands, we remain quite confident about securitization liabilities, along with continuing to acquire loans.

Mike Smith

executive
#6

Okay, that adds useful context. Then I’ll ask just one more thing about BPLs. A great deal of M&A has been happening, and institutional interest in this area is definitely substantial. I was simply curious whether any of that has altered anticipated returns or the way you originate loans?

Mohit Marria

executive
#7

Once more, I'd say these assets have fairly brief lives, and that's appealing given where rates are and the expectation they'll climb. As we pointed out, the gross coupon on what we've bought comes in a bit above 8%, while net it sits in the very high 6s. Once again, there are various niches inside the business purpose loan arena; we've observed no shift in the yields available on what we're able to secure, and we intend to expand that portion of our portfolio more substantially in 2022.

Mike Smith

executive
#8

Great, thanks a lot for taking the questions.

Mohit Marria

executive
#9

No problem, thanks Mike.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#10

Good morning. To start, regarding the $240 million in unrealized gains for the period, could you break down the drivers behind that? It seemed like we entered the quarter with credit spreads already quite tight. I'm just curious what some of the specific factors were that caused it.

Mohit Marria

executive
#11

Sure, Eric, I'll begin, and I'll let Subra and Kelly chime in if I leave anything out. As Mike just asked about, because of how robust loan performance has been and where pricing now stands, that's the main reason for the book value increase in Q3. Loan spreads came in by another 40 basis points from one quarter to the next, and given an implied duration of roughly four to five years, that represents a significant rise for our loans held for consolidation and investment; that was a primary factor; we're with you — since spreads were already quite tight entering Q3, most of the other spread products and securities we hold were largely flat during the quarter. Subra or Kelly, anything further you'd like to mention?

Subramaniam Viswanathan

executive
#12

No, that pretty much summarizes it well.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#13

Yeah, that helps, but can you break out each driver on its own? Are you applying a reduced severity assumption to those loans, or is it quicker prepayments? What exactly is causing that?

Mohit Marria

executive
#14

Once more, the credit's results clearly tell the story, so speeds picked up somewhat because rates are low. Solid home price gains have pushed LTVs down, which we also talked about on the Q2 call, and those lower LTVs mean lower all-in severity, so on the whole loss projections for mortgage assets have clearly declined. Beyond that, though, it comes down to secondary-market demand for these assets. As all of you know, the GSEs sell the most, along with certain banks and funds, and in that secondary market loan trading spreads tightened by 40 basis points versus the prior quarter, and that's pushing up value on our sizable residential seasoned loan portfolio, so every other metric you brought up regarding performance has gotten better too, producing some price gains; yet when you net it all out, secondary loan trading remains quite appealing compared with other mortgage products, both on an all-in yield basis and for the upside to, once again, long term performance.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#15

Understood, alright. Now regarding the financing for the loan warehouse, could you both discuss the amount of capacity available to fund any possible expansion of the portfolio?

Mohit Marria

executive
#16

Certainly. During the third quarter, we acquired $850 million, and every bit of that will be financed through the warehouse; however, as we've mentioned on many calls, our goal is to securitize those as fast as we can. A warehouse line typically holds assets for us for a period ranging from two to three months, ending with a securitization exit, so we currently possess ample capacity to increase the lines if opportunities arose from now until year end, and once again, with the securitization market remaining quite robust, we intend to keep securitizing. As we noted during our opening remarks, we completed a securitization immediately following quarter end and achieved fairly effective execution on it.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#17

Okay, and I apologize if this was covered already, but regarding that 850 you acquired, how did it split across fix and flip, prime jumbo, and RPL?

Mohit Marria

executive
#18

Out of the 850 we purchased, $115 million is fix and flip, while everything left over is seasoned reperforming. Prime jumbo makes up none of it.

Eric Hagen

analyst
#19

All right, so prime jumbo doesn't factor into this — understood. I appreciate it a lot.

Mohit Marria

executive
#20

You're welcome, thank you sir.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#21

Hi there, and thanks. Good morning, everyone. I'd like to add to what was asked earlier regarding BPLs and our efforts to expand that portfolio moving forward. Some of our competitors, we've noticed, have pursued buying lenders in this area as a means of locking in asset flow. So I'm wondering whether that's a route you've explored, or would you rather keep originating loans the same way you always have?

Mohit Marria

executive
#22

Clearly, we've observed a certain amount of activity — M&A activity — happening in this sector. That is something we're actively evaluating. However, because of the captive relationships we hold, we've managed to acquire those assets quite successfully across the past 24 months, and particularly during Q3. Take our history, even through COVID, when conditions were distressed for many — we met every obligation we had at the time to fund any loans we'd committed to. That has earned us considerably more credibility in this sector, and I believe that regardless of whether M&A activity occurs, we'll still manage to source those loans and expand the portfolio.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#23

All right, understood. And building on what was asked regarding warehouse space to keep expanding, thinking about capital, could you give us your view on how much capacity you have to continue putting more assets into the portfolio as it grows in 2022 before you might have to consider going out to raise more capital?

Mohit Marria

executive
#24

Absolutely. On our balance sheet, we hold more than $300 million in cash, and that figure has stayed fairly elevated since the pandemic. Our recourse leverage has been reduced substantially, now at one turn of recourse leverage, so with cash plus unencumbered assets combined, we have ample capital available to expand the portfolio. Our only aim is to stay disciplined about identifying the right opportunities. During the first half of the year, we concentrated on optimizing the liability side — that continues to be the main focus for Q3, yet we managed to successfully add a mortgage along with assets amounting to $850 million. Given taper expectations that could come later today from the Fed, inflation that appears not to be transitory, and a potentially high rate environment that could also mean a spread widening environment, we believe this might open up opportunities to put the excess liquidity we hold on balance sheet to work in Q4 and as we head into 2022.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#25

Okay, understood. One final item: regarding the tightening in loan spreads that you brought up, which clearly had an effect on book value for 3Q — has that trend persisted into Q4, or has it essentially leveled out? Also, any thoughts you could share on that?

Mohit Marria

executive
#26

Yes. Our thinking had been that the sharp rate movement at the beginning of Q4, combined with some modest weakening on the new issue side, would have caused loan trading to widen somewhat. In fact, a GSE loan sale took place as of yesterday — I don't have complete details yet — but those loans, again, traded very strongly in my view, so we really haven't observed any softening in loan trading the way we have on certain parts of the securities side as we move toward year end. I don't view that as a lasting trend. Given the enormous rate move and the anticipation of rates going higher, people got somewhat uneasy following a fairly strong 2021, so I think that may be, again, a temporary phenomenon; however, there is a shortage of cash sitting on the sidelines waiting to be put to work in the mortgage sector, so any widening ought to be only short term and should return to where it stood for most of 2021.

Trevor Cranston

analyst
#27

Okay, that’s helpful. Thank you.

Mohit Marria

executive
#28

Thanks Trevor.

Doug Harter

analyst
#29

Thank you. Could you explain what shifted in the marketplace — was it our willingness to buy, or did supply play the bigger role in driving the pickup in activity this quarter?

Mohit Marria

executive
#30

As we've pointed out on many calls, our desire for seasoned reperforming loans has remained quite robust; we simply weren't competing as effectively as we had during the first half of the year. A number of the counterparties we dealt with in Q3 weren't the typical, ordinary sellers, which meant we could close deals successfully with reduced, so to speak, and that's the area where we've achieved the greatest success.

Doug Harter

analyst
#31

Understood. Do you have any perspective or want to weigh in on whether that trend keeps going, or does it look like more of a competitive bidding situation over the next few quarters?

Mohit Marria

executive
#32

Once again, I'd say those quieter opportunities are relatively scarce, though we believe a number will still surface simply because loan demand remains so robust. As I just pointed out, should there be a modest widening, some participants might step back. It has been quite an active year, so we were hoping to capitalize on that, since that has essentially been our central focus and strength, and we have set ourselves apart from competitors in that area.

Doug Harter

analyst
#33

Understood. Regarding the reperforming portfolio you hold, what's your view on where the current mark-to-market LTV stands, considering how much home prices have climbed over the last year or more?

Mohit Marria

executive
#34

Absolutely. Like we said during our opening comments, Case-Shiller rose roughly 20% year over year, which is the strongest reading in more than 30 years. I believe we also brought this up on the call — with all the re-securitization work we've completed this year, many of the loans we picked up in 2016 and '17 carried LTVs in the mid to high 80s; after those LTVs were refreshed, we completed re-securitization nearer to the mid 50s, so they've dropped considerably. That, I'd say, is roughly where the whole portfolio's LTV sits — once you account for home price appreciation and amortization across the past three, four years, likely the mid to high 50s on an aggregate basis.

Doug Harter

analyst
#35

Thanks a lot.

Mohit Marria

executive
#36

Thanks, Leo, and I appreciate everyone joining us on this call. We’re looking forward to speaking with you once more in the next quarter.

Operator

operator
#37

That brings us to the end of today’s Chimera Investment Corp Q3 2021 earnings call. You’re welcome to disconnect at this point. Have a wonderful day, everybody.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chimera Investment Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Chimera Investment Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chimera Investment Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.